Failure to follow up abnormal test results associated with cervical cancer in primary and ambulatory care: a systematic review

Are we ready? assessing effectiveness and implementation of cancer control strategies in primary care: a comprehensive review of systematic reviews

BACKGROUND

Cancer is a major global cause of death, and primary care is crucial for cancer prevention and early detection. However, there is conflicting information on the effectiveness, implementation, and sustainability of cancer control interventions in primary care.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to summarize the evidence for cancer control in primary care, focussing on identifying relevant factors for implementation and sustainability.

STUDY SETTING AND DESIGN

We conducted a narrative, mixed-methods review of systematic reviews, guided by the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA). Four databases were screened, and two independent reviewers selected studies reporting on cancer prevention, screening, or early detection in primary or community settings. We analysed findings using the extended Reach-Effectiveness-Adopt-Implementation-Maintenance (RE-AIM) Framework.

PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

From the 37 reviews that met the inclusion criteria, 6 focussed on primary prevention, 23 on screening, and 12 on early detection. Most reviews (78%) addressed intervention effectiveness, such as HPV vaccination, tobacco cessation, and cervical, breast, and colorectal screening. One-third of the reviews mentioned adoption and implementation factors, including barriers and facilitators to the implementation of cancer screening programs. Only one review addressed maintenance and sustainability factors, exploring continuous resources and funding strategies.

CONCLUSION

While numerous interventions are effective for cancer prevention and detection in primary care, literature on implementation and sustainability strategies is lacking. Focusing on continuous resources and funding for cancer strategies in primary care may aid sustainability. Future research should prioritize reporting on implementation and sustainability factors to enhance cancer prevention and control in primary care settings.

[How do women in Réunion Island want to perform HPV test on vaginal sampling as part of cervical cancer screening?]

BACKGROUND

Since the introduction of HPV testing as a first-line screening method for women aged 30 and over, vaginal sampling (VS) by a healthcare professional or self-sampling (SS) is now possible for women who have not responded to the organized screening program using cervical uterine sampling. The aim of this study was to understand the choices made by a sample of women from La Reunion would like to perform their VS, and the content of the instructions they would like to receive.

METHODS

We conducted a cross-sectional descriptive study using a single-answer questionnaire. Patients were either interviewed in doctors' office or offered the possibility to answer an online questionnaire. We included women aged 30 to 65 in La Reunion who were concerned by CC screening. We compared the answers of women who were up to date with their screening with those of women who were not.

RESULTS

We included 202 women. The study showed that 64.9% of patients wished to collect the VS kit from a healthcare professional, 80.8% wished to perform SS and 52.5% wished to return it to the laboratory. The preferred language of the instruction was French, with pictures and drawings for 48.5% of patients. There was no significant difference between the answers of women who were up to date with their screening and those who were not.

CONCLUSION

In a sample of women eligible for CC screening in La Reunion, the preferred methods for CC screening were to collect the PV kit from a healthcare professional, perform the SS at home and then return it to the laboratory. These responses differed from other studies. A feasibility study on a part of La Reunion's eligible population for CC screening would enable us to assess the feasibility and generalizability of a screening modality based on SS.

Systematic review of economic evaluations of triage tests for women with atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASC-US) or low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (LSIL)

OBJECTIVES

To synthesize the results of cost-effectiveness studies of different triage tests in comparison to repeat cytology for women with atypical squamous cells of undetermined significance (ASC-US) or low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (LSIL) results.

METHODS

Electronic databases (Medline/PubMed, Lilacs, Embase, The Cochrane Library, Scopus, Web of Science, Scielo, The NHS Economic Evaluation Database, Econlit, and CEA Registry) were searched for cost-effectiveness or cost-utility publications. Per the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, two independent reviewers selected eligible publications based on the selection criteria and performed data extraction. Methodological quality was assessed using the Quality of Health Economic Studies tool.

RESULTS

Five cost-effectiveness analyses were included comparing HPV testing, immediate colposcopy, and liquid-based cytology with HPV testing reflex to repeat cytology. The main outcome adopted was cervical intraepithelial neoplasia level 2 or higher (CIN2+) cases detected. In pairwise comparisons, HPV testing was more frequently observed as the most cost-effective strategy. Incremental cost-effectiveness ratios were very sensitive to costs of test kit variation and accuracy estimates with some sensitivity analysis scenarios showing immediate colposcopy more cost-effective than HPV testing depending on the tests' unitary costs and effectiveness.

CONCLUSIONS

This systematic review of economic evidence corroborates clinical evidence showing cytology is the least effective, although less costly, triage strategy. Cytology-based triage programs need to be updated to offer timely treatment to women diagnosed with ASC-US/LSIL and better resource allocation.

Evaluation of follow-up colposcopy procedures after abnormal cervical screening result across a statewide study in Mississippi

PURPOSE

Cervical screening is used to detect and treat precancers to prevent invasive cancers. However, successful prevention also requires adequate follow-up and treatment of individuals with abnormal screening results. The aim was to investigate demographics, clinical characteristics, and follow-up status for individuals needing colposcopy after an abnormal screening result.

METHODS

The STRIDES (Studying Risk to Improve DisparitiES) cohort comprises individuals undergoing cervical cancer screening and management at a Mississippi Health Department or University of Mississippi clinic. Follow-up status, demographics, and clinical data were assessed from electronic health records and, if necessary, patient navigation on individuals identified as needing a colposcopy after an abnormal screening.

RESULTS

Of the 1,458 individuals requiring colposcopy, 43.0% had the procedure within 4 months, 16.4% had a delayed procedure, and 39.5% had no documented colposcopy follow-up, with significant predictors of follow-up identified as age and cytology diagnosis. Individuals 30 + were more likely to have follow up with a colposcopy compared to individuals < 30 years (49% and 38.7%, respectively; p < .001). Individuals with cytology diagnoses of LSIL (52.9%), ASC-H (51.4%), and HSIL (62.3%) had higher percentages of adherence to follow-up guidelines (p < .001). In total, we found that 78% of individuals had some type of follow-up, including a repeat screening visit.

CONCLUSION

Despite high cervical cancer screening rates among Mississippians, a substantial proportion did not have adequate next-step intervention. However, it is encouraging that highest risk individuals were more likely to have a colposcopy. Regardless, continuing to understand the underlying causes for incomplete follow-up is crucial for timely secondary targeted interventions to reduce cervical cancer burden, promote awareness, and improve health outcomes.

Detecting the impact of diagnostic procedures in Pap-positive women on anxiety using artificial neural networks

INTRODUCTION

Women who receive a result of an abnormal Papanicolaou (Pap) smear can fail to participate in follow up procedures, and this is often due to anxiety. This study aimed to apply artificial neural networks (ANN) in prediction of anxiety in women with an abnormal Pap smear test, prior to and following diagnostic procedures.

METHODS

One hundred-seventy two women who received an abnormal Pap screening result took part in this study, completing a questionnaire about socio-demographic characteristics and Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS), right before and two to four weeks after diagnostics (i.e. colposcopy/biopsy/endocervical curettage). A feedforward back-propagation multilayer perceptron model was applied in analysis.

RESULTS

Prior to diagnostic procedures 50.0% of women experienced anxiety, while after diagnostics anxiety was present in 61.6% of women. The correlation-based feature selection showed that anxiety prior to diagnostic procedures was associated with the use of sedatives, worry score, depression score, and score for concern about health consequences. For anxiety following diagnostics, predictors included rural place of residence, depression score, history of spontaneous abortion, and score for tension and discomfort during colposcopy. The ANN models yielded highly accurate anxiety prediction both prior and after diagnostics, 76.47% and 85.30%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The presented findings can aid in identification of those women with a positive Pap screening test who could develop anxiety and thus represent the target group for psychological support, which would consequently improve adherence to follow-up diagnostics and enable timely treatment, finally reducing complications and fatal outcome.

An Artificial Neural Network Prediction Model of Depressive Symptoms among Women with Abnormal Papanicolaou Smear Results before and after Diagnostic Procedures

(1) Background: Cervical screening and additional diagnostic procedures often lead to depression. This research aimed to develop a prediction model for depression in women who received an abnormal Papanicolaou screening test, prior to and following the diagnostic procedures. (2) Methods: The study included women who had a positive Papanicolaou screening test (N = 172) and attended the Clinical Center of Kragujevac in Serbia for additional diagnostic procedures (colposcopy/biopsy/endocervical curettage). Women filled out a sociodemographic survey and the Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression questionnaire (CES-D scale) before and after diagnostic procedures. A prediction model was built with multilayer perceptron neural networks. (3) Results: A correlation-based filter method of feature selection indicated four variables that correlated with depression both prior to and following the diagnostic procedures-anxiety, depression, worry, and concern about health consequences. In addition, the use of sedatives and a history of both induced and spontaneous abortion correlated with pre-diagnostic depression. Important attributes for predicting post-diagnostic depression were scores for the domains 'Tension/discomfort' and 'Embarrassment' and depression in personal medical history. The accuracy of the pre-diagnostic procedures model was 70.6%, and the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC) was 0.668. The model for post-diagnostic depression prediction showed an accuracy of 70.6%, and an AUROC = 0.836. (4) Conclusions: This study helps provide means to predict the occurrence of depression in women with an abnormal Papanicolaou screening result prior to and following diagnostic procedures, which can aid healthcare professionals in successfully providing timely psychological support to those women who are referred to further diagnostics.

HPV Extended Genotyping to Triage Abnormal Cervical Cancer Screens-Balancing the Harms and Benefits of an Additional Triage Test before Direct Colposcopy Referral

The Netherlands' cervical cancer screening program transitioned to primary human papillomavirus (HPV) screening in 2017. After the introduction of HPV-based screening, the country saw increases in colposcopy referral rates and detections of low-grade lesions. In July 2022, genotyping was introduced, and those with borderline or mild dyskaryotic (BMD) cytologic abnormalities were only referred to colposcopy if positive for HPV type 16 or 18, and repeat screening otherwise. In this article, various strategies using extended genotyping (HPV16/18/31/33/45/52/58) as a triage test after an abnormal screen were explored using data from HPV-positive participants with normal or BMD cytology in the Population-Based Screening Study Amsterdam (POBASCAM) trial. The authors assessed positive and negative predictive values and colposcopy referral rates for each strategy using extended genotyping to triage women to either direct referral to colposcopy or repeat screening. Direct referral did not meet positive and negative predictive value thresholds for efficiency for any strategies. However, the authors note that direct referral may nonetheless be useful among those with BMD due to minimal increases in colposcopy referrals and concerns of loss to follow-up at repeat screening. These findings demonstrate the potential utility of extended genotyping as a triage test in primary HPV screening programs. The results should be considered alongside the fact that referral to repeat screening may result in loss of engagement of women who need treatment to prevent invasive cancer. See related article by Kroon et al., p. 1037.

Current status and challenges in timely detection of cervical cancer in Mexico: expert consensus

Cervical cancer is a significant public health problem in low- and middle-income countries, accounting for 85% of new cases worldwide. Due to poorly organized screening programs, cervical cancer is more likely to develop in vulnerable groups who do not initiate or rarely undergo screening. Cervical cytology and detecting high-risk human papillomavirus types are the recommended screening tools. Further, these strategies allow for accurately identifying women at a higher risk of cervical cancer and establishing screening times. New detection tools, such as novel biomarkers or automatic HPV detection in the vagina or urine, can improve screening coverage. This review aims to identify the challenges faced by detection programs and screening tools in Mexico to provide evidence-based recommendations to improve early detection programs for cervical cancer.

Evaluation of Follow-up Colposcopy Procedures After Abnormal Cervical Screening Result Across a Statewide Study in Mississippi

Purpose

Cervical screening is used to detect and treat precancers to prevent invasive cancers. However, successful prevention also requires adequate follow-up and treatment of individuals with abnormal screening results. The aim was to investigate demographics, clinical characteristics, and follow-up status for individuals needing colposcopy after an abnormal screening result.

Methods

The STRIDES (Studying Risk to Improve DisparitiES) cohort comprises individuals undergoing cervical cancer screening and management at a Mississippi Health Department or University of Mississippi clinic. Follow-up status, demographics, and clinical data were assessed from electronic health records and, if necessary, patient navigation on individuals identified as needing a colposcopy after an abnormal screening.

Results

Of the 1,458 individuals requiring colposcopy, 43.0% had the procedure within 4 months, 16.4% had a delayed procedure, and 39.5% had no documented follow-up, with significant predictors of follow-up identified as age and cytology diagnosis. Based on age, individuals 30 + were more likely to follow up with a colposcopy compared to individuals < 30 years (49% and 38.7%, respectively; p < .001). Individuals with cytology diagnoses of LSIL (52.9%), ASC-H (51.4%), and HSIL (62.3%) had higher percentages of adherence to follow-up colposcopy guidelines (p < .001).

Conclusion

Despite high cervical cancer screening rates among Mississippians, a substantial portion did not have adequate next-step intervention. However, it is encouraging that highest risk individuals were more likely to have a colposcopy. Regardless, continuing to understand the underlying causes for incomplete follow-up is crucial for timely secondary targeted interventions to reduce cervical cancer burden, promote awareness, and improve health outcomes.

The effect of colposcopy counseling with a feminist model on anxiety in Thai women with abnormal cervical cytology results: A time-series quasi-experimental study

Background

Due to the cervical cancer screening campaign, there is a gradual increase in the number of women diagnosed with abnormal cervical cytology results. Most women experience high anxiety upon learning about these results, leading to adverse psychological effects. Therefore, nurses play a vital role in counseling these women to alleviate their concerns.

Objective

This study aimed to examine the effect of colposcopy counseling with a feminist model on anxiety in Thai women with abnormal cervical cytology results.

Methods

The study employed a time-series quasi-experimental design with a comparison group. It was conducted at the colposcopy clinic of a university hospital in Bangkok, Thailand, from August 2022 to April 2023. A total of 68 women with abnormal cervical cytology results were purposively recruited based on inclusion criteria. The comparison group (n = 34) received only usual care, while the experimental group (n = 34) received colposcopy counseling and usual care. Colposcopy counseling was provided after collecting baseline data. Anxiety was assessed at baseline, immediate post-test, and 12th week post-test. Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics, Chi-square test, independent t-test, and repeated measures analysis of variance (ANOVA).

Results

There was no statistically significant difference in anxiety across the three-time points between the two groups (F1, 66 = 0.062, p = 0.804). However, anxiety in the experimental group significantly decreased over time (p <0.05). In contrast, anxiety in the comparison group at baseline was not significantly different from that at the immediate post-test (p = 0.480).

Conclusion

Colposcopy counseling was effective in reducing anxiety in Thai women with abnormal cervical cytology results, especially during the initial period after receiving the results. Nonetheless, anxiety could gradually decrease regardless of the intervention. Therefore, colposcopy counseling by nurses and healthcare providers is helpful for women in relieving anxiety during their first colposcopy attendance.