Evaluation of long-term effectiveness of the use of carglumic acid in patients with propionic acidemia (PA) or methylmalonic acidemia (MMA): study protocol for a randomized controlled trial

An Early Cost-Utility Model of mRNA-Based Therapies for the Treatment of Methylmalonic and Propionic Acidemia in the United Kingdom

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Novel messenger RNA (mRNA)-based therapies, currently in development, are emerging as a promising potential treatment modality for a broad range of life-threatening and life-limiting inherited liver diseases, including methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) and propionic acidemia (PA). However, owing in part to their complexity, they are likely to come at considerable financial cost to healthcare systems. The objective of this research was to synthesize available evidence on the costs and clinical consequences associated with MMA and PA for the purpose of exploratory economic evaluation of novel mRNA-based therapies using an early cost-utility model from the United Kingdom payer perspective.

METHODS

A Markov model was constructed to simulate the costs and outcomes associated with novel mRNA therapies, compared with a combination of dietary management and organ transplantation (standard of care) among hypothetical cohorts of new-born patients with MMA and PA. Key model drivers were identified, and a price threshold analysis was performed to estimate value-based price ranges for future mRNA therapies given willingness-to-pay thresholds for orphan diseases.

RESULTS

mRNA therapy was associated with an additional 5.7 and 1.3 quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) gained per patient lifetime among patients with MMA and PA, respectively. Key drivers of cost-effectiveness were relative improvement in utility among patients who receive mRNA-based therapy and transplantation, and the cost of mRNA therapy. Assuming a willingness to pay range of £100,000-£300,000 per QALY gained, the model demonstrated mRNA therapy to be cost-effective in MMA and PA at an annual treatment cost of £70,452-£94,575 and £31,313-£36,695, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the lack of a strong evidence base in MMA and PA, this model provides a useful tool to estimate the cost-effectiveness, and inform value-based pricing, of new mRNA-based therapies. Our analyses also identified areas for research that will have the greatest value in reducing uncertainty in future health economic evaluations of such treatments.

mRNA therapies: Pioneering a new era in rare genetic disease treatment

Rare genetic diseases, often referred to as orphan diseases due to their low prevalence and limited treatment options, have long posed significant challenges to our medical system. In recent years, Messenger RNA (mRNA) therapy has emerged as a highly promising treatment approach for various diseases caused by genetic mutations. Chemically modified mRNA is introduced into cells using carriers like lipid-based nanoparticles (LNPs), producing functional proteins that compensate for genetic deficiencies. Given the advantages of precise dosing, biocompatibility, transient expression, and minimal risk of genomic integration, mRNA therapies can safely and effectively correct genetic defects in rare diseases and improve symptoms. Currently, dozens of mRNA drugs targeting rare diseases are undergoing clinical trials. This comprehensive review summarizes the progress of mRNA therapy in treating rare genetic diseases. It introduces the development, molecular design, and delivery systems of mRNA therapy, highlighting their research progress in rare genetic diseases based on protein replacement and gene editing. The review also summarizes research progress in various rare disease models and clinical trials. Additionally, it discusses the challenges and future prospects of mRNA therapy. Researchers are encouraged to join this field and collaborate to advance the clinical translation of mRNA therapy, bringing hope to patients with rare genetic diseases.

Coexistence of Two Rare Conditions Complicating the Other's Management: Propionic Acidemia and Apert Syndrome

Introduction

Propionic acidemia (PA) is an inborn error of organic acid metabolism inherited in an autosomal recessive manner. The neonatal-onset disease may present with feeding difficulties and vomiting; seizures, coma, and death may occur if untreated. In addition, catabolic processes such as infections and surgical procedures could cause metabolic decompensation, so patients with organic acidemia should be followed closely.

Case Presentation

Here, a patient diagnosed with PA and Apert syndrome in the neonatal period and the complications caused by the coexistence of the two entities are mentioned. The difficulties precipitated by the coexistence of Apert syndrome and PA make this case unique. She has had prolonged hospitalizations due to metabolic decompensations after cranioplasty and inguinal hernia repair, both triggered by nosocomial respiratory infections, complicating both the surgical treatment of Apert syndrome and the management of PA.

Conclusion

Coexistence of these two serious disorders mandates a more prudent clinical management as Apert syndrome patients undergo several surgical procedures, rendering them susceptible to catabolic decompensations.

Challenges and strategies for clinical trials in propionic and methylmalonic acidemias

Clinical trial development in rare diseases poses significant study design and methodology challenges, such as disease heterogeneity and appropriate patient selection, identification and selection of key endpoints, decisions on study duration, choice of control groups, selection of appropriate statistical analyses, and patient recruitment. Therapeutic development in organic acidemias (OAs) shares many challenges with other inborn errors of metabolism, such as incomplete understanding of natural history, heterogenous disease presentations, requirement for sensitive outcome measures and difficulties recruiting a small sample of participants. Here, we review strategies for the successful development of a clinical trial to evaluate treatment response in propionic and methylmalonic acidemias. Specifically, we discuss crucial decisions that may significantly impact success of the study, including patient selection, identification and selection of endpoints, determination of the study duration, consideration of control groups including natural history controls, and selection of appropriate statistical analyses. The significant challenges associated with designing a clinical trial in rare disease can sometimes be successfully met through strategic engagement with experts in the rare disease, seeking regulatory and biostatistical guidance, and early involvement of patients and families.

Orphan Drug Use in Patients With Rare Diseases: A Population-Based Cohort Study

Background: Orphan drugs are used for the diagnosis, prevention and treatment of rare diseases that, in the European Union, are defined as disorders affecting no more than 5 persons in 10,000. So far, a total of around 800 orphan medicinal products have been approved by the European Medicines Agency, however the utilization profile of orphan drugs has yet to be explored. This study aimed at assessing the utilization profile of orphan drugs authorized for marketing by the Italian Medicines Agency using population-based data.

Methods: A total of 21 orphan drugs used in outpatient settings, approved in the European Union before or during the 2008–2018 period and involving 15 rare diseases, were included in the study. The monitored population included patients with one of the conditions surveilled by the population-based Tuscany Registry of Rare Diseases and diagnosed between 2000–2018. A multi-database approach was applied, by linking data from the registry with information collected in drug prescriptions databases. The prevalence and intensity of use were estimated for the selected orphan drugs and other non-orphan medications, used to treat the same rare disease and for which a change in the prevalence of use was hypothesized after authorization of the orphan drug.

Results: For some diseases (acquired aplastic anemia, tuberous sclerosis complex, most metabolic diseases) a low prevalence of orphan drugs use was observed (range between 1.1–12.5%). Conversely, orphan drugs were frequently used in hemophilia B, Wilson disease and idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (maximum of 78.3, 47.6 and 41.8%, respectively). For hemophilia B and Leber’s hereditary optic neuropathy, there are currently no other medications used in clinical practice in addition to orphan drugs. Six orphan drugs were used for the treatment of pulmonary arterial hypertension, appearing the elective therapy for this disease, albeit with different utilization profiles (range of prevalence 1.7–55.6%).

Conclusion: To the best of our knowledge, this is the first study investigating the utilization profile of orphan drugs prescribed in a defined geographical area, and providing relevant information to monitor over time potential changes in the prevalence of these medications as well as in the health care decision making.

Long-term effectiveness of carglumic acid in patients with propionic acidemia (PA) and methylmalonic acidemia (MMA): a randomized clinical trial

Background

Propionic acidemia (PA) and methylmalonic acidemia (MMA) are rare, autosomal recessive inborn errors of metabolism that require life-long medical treatment. The trial aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of the administration of carglumic acid with the standard treatment compared to the standard treatment alone in the management of these organic acidemias.

Methods

The study was a prospective, multicenter, randomized, parallel-group, open-label, controlled clinical trial. Patients aged ≤ 15 years with confirmed PA and MMA were included in the study. Patients were followed up for two years. The primary outcome was the number of emergency room (ER) admissions because of hyperammonemia. Secondary outcomes included plasma ammonia levels over time, time to the first episode of hyperammonemia, biomarkers, and differences in the duration of hospital stay.

Results

Thirty-eight patients were included in the study. On the primary efficacy endpoint, a mean of 6.31 ER admissions was observed for the carglumic acid arm, compared with 12.76 for standard treatment, with a significant difference between the groups (p = 0.0095). Of the secondary outcomes, the only significant differences were in glycine and free carnitine levels.

Conclusion

Using carglumic acid in addition to standard treatment over the long term significantly reduces the number of ER admissions because of hyperammonemia in patients with PA and MMA.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13023-021-02032-8.

Guidelines for the diagnosis and management of methylmalonic acidaemia and propionic acidaemia: First revision

Isolated methylmalonic acidaemia (MMA) and propionic acidaemia (PA) are rare inherited metabolic diseases. Six years ago, a detailed evaluation of the available evidence on diagnosis and management of these disorders has been published for the first time. The article received considerable attention, illustrating the importance of an expert panel to evaluate and compile recommendations to guide rare disease patient care. Since that time, a growing body of evidence on transplant outcomes in MMA and PA patients and use of precursor free amino acid mixtures allows for updates of the guidelines. In this article, we aim to incorporate this newly published knowledge and provide a revised version of the guidelines. The analysis was performed by a panel of multidisciplinary health care experts, who followed an updated guideline development methodology (GRADE). Hence, the full body of evidence up until autumn 2019 was re-evaluated, analysed and graded. As a result, 21 updated recommendations were compiled in a more concise paper with a focus on the existing evidence to enable well-informed decisions in the context of MMA and PA patient care.

Biochemical and genetic approaches to the prenatal diagnosis of propionic acidemia in 78 pregnancies

Background

Propionic acidemia (PA) is a serious metabolic disorder, and different approaches have been applied to its prenatal diagnosis. To evaluate the reliability and validity of a biochemical strategy in the prenatal diagnosis of PA, we conducted a retrospective study of our 11-year experiences at a single center.

Methods

We accumulated data from 78 pregnancies from 58 families referred to our center and provided prenatal diagnosis by directed genetic analysis and/or metabolite measurement using tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) and gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS) of amniotic fluid (AF) samples.

Results

Sixty-five unaffected fetuses (83.33%) and 13 affected fetuses (16.67%) were confirmed in our study. The characteristic metabolites including propionylcarnitine (C3) level, C3/acetylcarnitine (C2) ratio and 2-methylcitric acid (2MCA) level in unaffected and affected groups showed significant differences (P < 0.0001), while the level of 3-hydroxypropionic acid (3HPA) showed no significant difference between the two groups (P > 0.05).Of the 78 pregnancies, 24 fetuses were found to have either one causative pathogenic variant or were without genetic information in the proband. Three of these fetuses had elevated AF levels of C3, C3/C2 ratio, and 2MCA and, thus, were determined to be affected, while the remaining fetuses were determined to be unaffected based on a normal AF metabolite profile. Our genetic and biochemical results were highly consistent with postnatal follow-up results on all unaffected fetuses.

Conclusions

We conclude that a biochemical approach can serve as a fast and convenient prenatal diagnostic method for pregnancies at an increased risk for PA, which could be used in conjunction with genetic testing for precise prenatal diagnosis of this disorder. In our analysis, the characteristic metabolites C3 level, C3/C2 ratio, and 2MCA level in AF supernatant were dependable biochemical markers for diagnosis, of which the C3/C2 ratio appears to be the most reliable biochemical marker for the prenatal diagnosis of PA.

Established and Emerging Treatments for Patients with Inborn Errors of Metabolism

Inborn errors of metabolism (IEMs) are inherited defects in a metabolic pathway resulting in clinical disease. The overall goal of therapy is to restore metabolic homeostasis while minimizing the deleterious effects of the interruption. Conventional treatments focus on decreasing substrate, providing product, and replacing deficient enzyme or cofactor. We discuss examples of established, novel, and emerging therapies to provide a framework for understanding the principles of management for patients with IEMs.