Cognitive functioning in patients with classical galactosemia: a systematic review

Altered neural oscillations in classical galactosaemia during sentence production

Classical galactosaemia (CG) is a hereditary disease in galactose metabolism that despite dietary treatment is characterized by a wide range of cognitive deficits, among which is language production. CG brain functioning has been studied with several neuroimaging techniques, which revealed both structural and functional atypicalities. In the present study, for the first time, we compared the oscillatory dynamics, especially the power spectrum and time-frequency representations (TFR), in the electroencephalography (EEG) of CG patients and healthy controls while they were performing a language production task. Twenty-one CG patients and 19 healthy controls described animated scenes, either in full sentences or in words, indicating two levels of complexity in syntactic planning. Based on previous work on the P300 event related potential (ERP) and its relation with theta frequency, we hypothesized that the oscillatory activity of patients and controls would differ in theta power and TFR. With regard to behavior, reaction times showed that patients are slower, reflecting the language deficit. In the power spectrum, we observed significant higher power in patients in delta (1-3 Hz), theta (4-7 Hz), beta (15-30 Hz) and gamma (30-70 Hz) frequencies, but not in alpha (8-12 Hz), suggesting an atypical oscillatory profile. The time-frequency analysis revealed significantly weaker event-related theta synchronization (ERS) and alpha desynchronization (ERD) in patients in the sentence condition. The data support the hypothesis that CG language difficulties relate to theta-alpha brain oscillations.

Neuropsychological stability in classical galactosemia: A pilot study in 10 adult patients

Classical galactosemia (CG) is an autosomal recessive disorder of galactose metabolism. Despite early initiation of a galactose-restricted diet, patients develop long-term complications including cognitive impairment. There is an ongoing debate whether the cognitive impairment in CG is stable throughout life or progresses with age. Earlier cross-sectional and longitudinal studies regarding intelligence suggest stability, but longitudinal neuropsychological studies focusing on specific cognitive functions are limited. Therefore, the aim of this study is to assess cognitive change over time in adult CG-patients. Ten adult patients with normal to borderline intelligence (mean age 33 years, range 22-49; IQ≥70 or independent work- or living situation) were assessed twice with a mean time interval of 3 years and 9 months (range 1023-1575 days). The neuropsychological assessments covered information processing speed, executive functioning, verbal fluency, and visuospatial functioning. Results showed that there was no significant decline or improvement in test scores on all neuropsychological measures except a decline on the Trail Making Test-A (p = 0.048). However, this group-level difference was subject to "regression to the mean" and was not endorsed by significant change in test scores measuring the same cognitive domain. Moreover, no specific pattern of reliable change (RCI > -1.96) was present on specific measures or within individual patients. This explorative study performed in 10 adult CG-patients with normal to borderline intelligence revealed no cognitive change on several cognitive domains. This implies that the subset of adults with a normal to borderline IQ in their early and middle adulthood are cognitively stable.

Social cognition, emotion regulation and social competence in classical galactosemia patients without intellectual disability

OBJECTIVE

Classical galactosemia (CG) is an inborn error of galactose metabolism. Many CG patients suffer from long-term complications including poor cognitive functioning. There are indications of social dysfunction but limited evidence in the literature. Therefore, this study aims to improve our understanding of social competence in CG by investigating social cognition, neurocognition and emotion regulation.

METHODS

A comprehensive (neuro)psychological test battery, including self and proxy questionnaires, was administered to CG patients without intellectual disability. Social cognition was assessed by facial emotion recognition, Theory of Mind and self-reported empathy. Standardised results were compared to normative data of the general population.

RESULTS

Data from 23 patients (aged 8-52) were included in the study. On a group level, CG patients reported satisfaction with social roles and no social dysfunction despite the self-report of lower social skills. They showed deficits in all aspects of social cognition on both performance tests (emotion recognition and Theory of Mind) and self-report questionnaires (empathy). Adults had a lower social participation than the general population. Parents reported lower social functioning, less adaptive emotion regulation and communication difficulties in their children. Individual differences in scores were present.

CONCLUSION

This study shows that CG patients without intellectual disability are satisfied with their social competence, especially social functioning. Nevertheless, deficits in social cognition are present in a large proportion of CG patients. Due to the large variability in scores and discrepancies between self- and proxy-report, an individually tailored, comprehensive neuropsychological assessment including social cognition is advised in all CG patients. Treatment plans need to be customised to the individual patient.

The impact of diabetes in cognitive impairment: A review of current evidence and prospects for future investigations

Cognitive impairment in individuals with diabetes represents a multifaceted and increasingly prevalent health concern. This review critically examines the current evidence regarding the intricate relationship between diabetes and cognitive decline. It highlights the existing knowledge on the impact of diabetes on cognitive function, spanning from mild cognitive impairment to dementia, including vascular and Alzheimer dementia. The review underscores the need for a standardized diagnostic paradigm and explores research gaps, such as the implications of cognitive impairment in younger populations and various diabetes types. Furthermore, this review emphasizes the relevance of diabetes-related comorbidities, including hypertension and dyslipidemia, in influencing cognitive decline. It advocates for a comprehensive, interdisciplinary approach, integrating insights from neuroscience, endocrinology, and immunology to elucidate the mechanistic underpinnings of diabetes-related cognitive impairment. The second part of this review outlines prospective research directions and opportunities. It advocates for longitudinal studies to understand disease progression better and identifies critical windows of vulnerability. The search for accurate biomarkers and predictive factors is paramount, encompassing genetic and epigenetic considerations. Personalized approaches and tailored interventions are essential in addressing the substantial variability in cognitive outcomes among individuals with diabetes.

The challenges of classical galactosemia: HRQoL in pediatric and adult patients

BACKGROUND

Classical galactosemia (CG), an inborn error of galactose metabolism, results in long-term complications including cognitive impairment and movement disorders, despite early diagnosis and dietary treatment. Two decades ago, lower motor-, cognitive- and social health related quality of life (HRQoL) was demonstrated in pediatric and adult patients. Since then, the diet has been relaxed, newborn screening was implemented and new international guidelines resulted in major changes in follow-up. The aim of this study was to assess HRQoL of CG by means of online self- and/or proxy-HRQoL-questionnaires focusing on the main areas of concern of CG (i.e. anxiety, depression, cognition, fatigue, social- and upper extremity function) within the patient-reported outcomes measurement information system (PROMIS®) and generic HRQoL-questionnaires (TAPQOL, TACQOL, TAAQOL).

RESULTS

Data of 61 Dutch patients (aged 1-52 years) were collected and compared to available Dutch or US reference populations. On the PROMIS-questionnaires, children reported more fatigue (P = 0.044), lower function in upper extremities (P = 0.021), more cognitive difficulties (P = 0.055, d = 0.56) and higher anxiety (P = 0.063, d = 0.52) than reference children although the latter findings remained non-significant. Parents of CG patients reported lower quality of peer relationships of their children (P < 0.001). Both children and parents reported lower cognitive functioning (P = 0.005, P = 0.010) on the TACQOL. Adults reported on PROMIS domains lower cognitive functioning (P = 0.030), higher anxiety (P = 0.004) and more fatigue (P = 0.026). Cognitive difficulties were reported on the TAAQOL by adults (P < 0.001), as well as physical-, sleeping and social difficulties.

CONCLUSIONS

CG remains to impact the HRQoL of pediatric and adult patients negatively on several domains including cognition, anxiety, motor function and fatigue. A lower social health was mainly reported by parents, and not by patients themselves. The Covid-19 pandemic might have amplified the results on anxiety although higher levels of anxiety fit pre-pandemic findings. The reported fatigue is a new finding in CG. Because the effect of lockdown fatigue could not be eliminated and fatigue is a frequent finding in patients with chronic disorders, future studies are warranted. Clinicians and researchers should be attentive to both pediatric and adult patients, and the age-dependent difficulties they might encounter.

Optical Coherence Tomography: Retinal Imaging Contributes to the Understanding of Brain Pathology in Classical Galactosemia

It remains unresolved whether central nervous system involvement in treated classical galactosemia (CG) is a progressive neurodegenerative process. This study aimed to investigate retinal neuroaxonal degeneration in CG as a surrogate of brain pathology. Global peripapillary retinal nerve fibre layer (GpRNFL) and combined ganglion cell and inner plexiform layer (GCIPL) were analysed in 11 CG patients and 60 controls (HC) using spectral-domain optical coherence tomography. Visual acuity (VA) and low-contrast VA (LCVA) were acquired to test visual function. GpRNFL and GCIPL did not differ between CG and HC (p > 0.05). However, in CG, there was an effect of intellectual outcome on GCIPL (p = 0.036), and GpRNFL and GCIPL correlated with neurological rating scale scores (p < 0.05). A single-case follow-up analysis showed GpRNFL (0.53-0.83%) and GCIPL (0.52-0.85%) annual decrease beyond the normal aging effect. VA and LCVA were reduced in CG with intellectual disability (p = 0.009/0.006), likely due to impaired visual perception. These findings support that CG is not a neurodegenerative disease, but that brain damage is more likely to occur early in brain development. To clarify a minor neurodegenerative component in the brain pathology of CG, we propose multicenter cross-sectional and longitudinal studies using retinal imaging.

Pathophysiology of long-term complications in classic galactosemia: What we do and do not know

Despite many decades of research involving both human subjects and model systems, the underlying pathophysiology of long-term complications in classic galactosemia (CG) remains poorly understood. In this review, intended for those already familiar with galactosemia, we focus on the big questions relating to outcomes, mechanism, and markers, drawing on relevant literature where available, attempting to navigate inconsistencies where they appear, and acknowledging gaps in knowledge where they persist.

Qualitative interviews with adults with Classic Galactosemia and their caregivers: disease burden and challenges with daily living

BACKGROUND

Classic Galactosemia is a rare, autosomal recessive disease in which galactose is not metabolized properly due to severe deficiency/absence of the galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT) enzyme, converting to an aberrant and toxic metabolite, galactitol. Newborn screening and timely galactose-restricted diet can resolve acute symptoms and decrease fatalities. However, despite this, significant chronic, progressive morbidities remain which have a real impact upon daily life. To better understand the burden of disease, 20 in-depth qualitative interviews were undertaken with adult patients (n = 12), and their caregivers (n = 8), enrolled in the ACTION-Galactosemia trial, part of a clinical program designed to investigate the safety and efficacy of AT-007 (govorestat) in reducing toxic galactitol and long-term clinical outcomes in Classic Galactosemia.

RESULTS

Interviews revealed the substantial burden of Classic Galactosemia on patients and families. Most adults were not able to live independently, and all required support with day-to-day activities. Short- and long-term memory difficulties and tremors were identified as the most frequently experienced and challenging symptoms. Other difficulties such as fine motor skills and slow/slurred speech contribute to the significant impact on daily activities, affecting ability to communicate and interact with others. Symptoms were first noticed in early childhood and worsened with age. Classic Galactosemia impacted all areas of daily functioning and quality of life, leading to social isolation, anxiety, anger/frustration and depression. This demonstrates the significant burden of disease and challenges associated with Classic Galactosemia.

CONCLUSIONS

The impact on both patients and caregivers underscores the severity of the unmet medical need and the importance of pharmacological intervention to halt or prevent disease progression. Any treatment that could reduce symptoms or slow functional decline would ease the burden of this condition on patients and caregivers.

Transient developmental delays in infants with Duarte-2 variant galactosemia

Duarte galactosemia is not classic galactosemia, but rather an example of biochemical variant galactosemia that results in approximately 25% residual activity of galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT) enzyme. In contrast, classic galactosemia is associated with complete or near complete absence of GALT activity. While infants with classic galactosemia are placed on galactose-restricted diets to prevent the acute and long-term manifestations of their metabolic disorder, while individuals with Duarte variant galactosemia (Duarte-2 galactosemia) do not require diet therapy. The long-term complications that are seen in classic galactosemia such as cerebellar ataxia, and hypergonadotropic hypogonadism do not occur in Duarte-2 galactosemia. While Duarte galactosemia does not appear to be a metabolic disease, it may have an impact on early neurodevelopmental outcomes. This study examined developmental outcomes and the need for special services in individuals with Duarte-2 galactosemia in comparison to individuals with classic galactosemia. We performed a medical record review of individuals with GALT deficiency who were evaluated at Boston Children's Hospital and enrolled in our study of outcomes in galactosemia. This included 95 participants, 21 with Duarte-2 galactosemia and 73 with classic galactosemia. Duarte-2 participants had developmental test scores within the average range. However, 42% of subjects with Duarte-2 galactosemia had participated in early intervention and/or special education and 32% received speech therapy. Their pattern of strengths and weaknesses in cognitive/language/motor domains was similar to that noted in participants with classic galactosemia, albeit to a milder degree. The data indicate that in children with Duarte-2 variant galactosemia, the cognitive/language and motor skills were within normal limits with their cognitive/language skills developing earlier than their motor skills during their first year of life. A history of diet treatment was not related to the use of special services. These results suggest that Duarte-2 galactosemia increases the risk for early mild developmental delays irrespective of treatment history, which resolves over time, and highlights the need to further assess neurodevelopment in early infancy, in Duarte-2 galactosemia. As Duarte-2 galactosemia is not a bona fide biochemical genetic disease, we hypothesize that elements in the genomic space that include the GALT gene are responsible for a transient delay in language-related motor skills during early infancy.

Current and Future Treatments for Classic Galactosemia

Type I (classic) galactosemia, galactose 1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT)-deficiency is a hereditary disorder of galactose metabolism. The current therapeutic standard of care, a galactose-restricted diet, is effective in treating neonatal complications but is inadequate in preventing burdensome complications. The development of several animal models of classic galactosemia that (partly) mimic the biochemical and clinical phenotypes and the resolution of the crystal structure of GALT have provided important insights; however, precise pathophysiology remains to be elucidated. Novel therapeutic approaches currently being explored focus on several of the pathogenic factors that have been described, aiming to (i) restore GALT activity, (ii) influence the cascade of events and (iii) address the clinical picture. This review attempts to provide an overview on the latest advancements in therapy approaches.

Classical galactosemia: neuropsychological and psychosocial functioning beyond intellectual abilities

Background

Despite early diagnosis and treatment, Classical Galactosemia (CG) patients frequently develop long-term complications, such as cognitive impairment. Available literature primarily reports on general intellectual abilities and shows a substantially lower Full Scale Intelligence Quotient (FSIQ) in CG patients than in the general population. Both problems in social functioning as well as internalizing problems are often reported in CG patients. The combination of intelligence, cognitive functioning, behavior and social functioning has not been studied systematically in CG patients.

Methods

To determine if CG patients demonstrate a specific neuropsychological and psychosocial profile, we investigated intelligence, functioning on multiple cognitive domains, behavior and social functioning with a comprehensive neuropsychological test battery and questionnaires (self- and proxy-reported).

Results

The data of 48 patients, aged 4–47 years are reported. FSIQ ranged from 45 to 103 (mean 77 ± 14). A negative correlation between age and FSIQ was demonstrated (p = 0.037) which resulted directly from the inclusion of four young ‘milder’ patients detected by newborn screening (NBS) with an expected better clinical outcome. Compared to normative data, patients had significantly lower but highly variable scores on all cognitive domains, especially on tests requiring mental speed. In the context of the FSIQ, 43% of the cognitive test results exceeded IQ based expectations. Overall, the patients’ scores on social functioning were in the normal range but internalizing problems were frequently reported. In our cohort, an early initiation of dietary treatment due to NBS or family screening did not result in a more favorable neuropsychological outcome.

Conclusions

In this study, we demonstrated that as a cohort, CG patients have a below average intelligence and impaired cognitive functioning without a distinctive neuropsychological profile. The effect of age on neurocognitive functioning should be assessed in longitudinal studies. Social functioning was not impaired, but patients may be at risk for internalizing problems. Considering the large variability in cognitive, behavioral and social functioning and the finding that cognitive outcomes may exceed IQ based expectations, an individual evaluation and follow-up is warranted in all CG patients to ensure timely support if needed.