Diagnostic and predictive value of auditory evoked responses in preterm infants: I. Patient characteristics and long-term neurodevelopmental outcome

Development of MEG sleep patterns and magnetic auditory evoked responses during early infancy

OBJECTIVE

To follow the development of MEG sleep patterns and auditory evoked responses (AERs) during the first six months of life.

METHODS

The subjects were 18 neonates, born at conceptional age (CA) 36-42 weeks, following uncomplicated pregnancies. During each session, several 10-min MEG recordings were acquired in the presence of auditory stimulation. The recordings were classified into three distinct MEG patterns-low amplitude irregular; high-amplitude slow; and mixed-based largely on MEG amplitude and frequency. Averaged AERs were computed for the entire recording and for each MEG pattern within the recording. The results were based on analysis of 61 recording sessions of the 10 subjects who yielded three or more sessions of usable data.

RESULTS

Developmental changes in the MEG sleep patterns were most pronounced at the earliest ages. By CA 48 weeks the patterns had progressed to a more mature form, characterized by the prevalence of delta wave sleep, absence of discontinuity, and development of spindling and higher amplitude delta rhythms. In contrast to the MEG patterns, the AERs did not change markedly during the first 8 weeks (CA 40-48 weeks) and showed a simple morphology, consisting of a prominent deflection at 250 ms (P250m) and a more diffuse one at around 750 ms (N750m). During the period CA 48-54 weeks, however, a relatively abrupt transition occurred to a more complex morphology, characterized by a double peak with peak latencies 150ms (P150m) and 350 ms (P350m). Beyond this period the AERs continued to evolve, showing biphasic complexes and the emergence of late components arising from outside the auditory cortex.

CONCLUSIONS

Over the age range of this study the MEG sleep patterns and AER developed in succession, rather than concurrently; i.e. development of the sleep patterns was most rapid during the first 8 weeks (CA 40-48 weeks) while major development of the AERs commenced after this time.

SIGNIFICANCE

This finding suggests that the brain must achieve a certain level of overall maturity, reflected in the character of the MEG sleep patterns at CA 48 weeks, before the cortex enters a phase of significant functional development, reflected in the more rapid evolution of the AER after CA 48 weeks. The results of this study affirm the efficacy of MEG for spatiotemporal characterization of neonatal brain activity.

Ethical dilemmas in the care of the most premature infants: the waters are murkier than ever

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Summarize the literature relevant to ethical issues surrounding decisions to provide intensive care to extremely premature newborns.

RECENT FINDINGS

A Texas Supreme Court decision and a position paper are noteworthy for health professionals participating in management decisions with families at risk for extremely preterm delivery.

SUMMARY

In Miller v HCA, the Millers sued the Hospital Corporation of America for resuscitating their approximately 23-week gestation daughter against their wishes. The baby survived with severe neurodevelopmental disabilities. They were awarded $59.9 million in a jury trial. However, the judgment was reversed by the court of appeals, which ruled that parents have no right to withhold urgently needed life-sustaining medical treatment from children with non-terminal impairments, deformities, or disabilities, regardless of their severity. The Supreme Court of Texas upheld that ruling, but reasoned that parents have no right to refuse resuscitation of extremely premature infants prior to birth because they cannot be fully evaluated until birth; therefore, decisions before birth could not be fully informed. Robertson (Hasting Center Report 2004) supports precluding parental refusal of resuscitation before birth. He argues that parents have a right to withhold or withdraw medical treatment from a non-terminally ill child, but only if the child will lack capacity for symbolic interaction. Such severe limitation of quality of life concerns in decision making for extremely premature newborns is inconsistent with current published guidelines, the positions of noted bioethicists, and the practice of many neonatologists. Further, the additional information attained by initiating intensive care in the most premature infants does not justify doing so without parental consent.

Comparison of management strategies for extreme prematurity in New Jersey and the Netherlands: outcomes and resource expenditure

OBJECTIVE

To quantify differences in resource expenditure in the perinatal period and long-term outcome of extremely premature infants who received systematically different approaches to neonatal intensive care.

METHODS

Perinatal management, mortality, prevalence of disabling cerebral palsy (DCP), and resource expenditure of 2 population-based inception cohorts of extremely premature infants born in the mid-1980s were compared. Electronic fetal monitoring, tocolysis, cesarean section delivery, and assisted ventilation were used to characterize management approaches. Participants included all live births at 23 to 26 weeks' gestation in a 3-county area of central New Jersey (NJ) from 1984 to 1987 (N = 146) and throughout the Netherlands (NETH) in 1983 (N = 142). Mortality and the prevalence of DCP were the primary outcomes. Numbers of hospital days with and without assisted ventilation were the measures of resource expenditure.

RESULTS

Electronic fetal monitoring (100% vs 38%), cesarean section (28% vs 6%), and assisted ventilation (95% vs 64%) were all more commonly used in NJ than in NETH. Ten percent of NJ deaths occurred without assisted ventilation, compared with 45% of Dutch deaths. A total of 1820 ventilator days were expended per 100 live births in NJ, compared with 448 in NETH. The increase in the number of nonventilator days (3174 vs 2265 days per 100 live births) did not reach statistical significance. Survival to age 2 (46 vs 22%) and the prevalence of DCP among survivors (17.2 vs 3.4%) were significantly greater in NJ at age 2 than in NETH at age 5.

CONCLUSIONS

Near universal initiation of intensive care in NJ, compared with selective initiation of intensive care in NETH, was associated with 24.1 additional survivors per 100 live births, 7.2 additional cases of DCP per 100 live births, and a cost of 1372 additional ventilator days per 100 live births.

The outcome of extreme prematurity

Significant advances in perinatology and neonatology in the last decade have resulted in increased survival of extremely premature infants. Survival rates for infants born in tertiary perinatal and neonatal care centers in the United States in the 1990s increase with each week of gestational age from 22 through 26 weeks. Reported survival rates at 22 weeks range from 0% to 21% in the few reporting studies. Reported survival rates at 23 and 24 weeks range from 5% to 46% and from 40% to 59%, respectively. These may not be the maximum survival rates possible because at these gestational ages information is either insufficient to determine that obstetric and neonatal intensive care strategies to maximize neonatal survival were used or it is specified that such strategies were not used. Reported survival rates at 25 and 26 weeks range from 60% to 82% and from from 75% to 93%, respectively. The literature regarding the prevalence of major neurodevelopmental disabilities among extremely premature survivors in the last 25 years is heteogeneous, and the reported prevalances of major disability vary much more than do survival rates. However, the majority of extremely premature infants who survive will be free of major disability. Overall, approximately one fifth to one quarter of survivors have at least one major disability-impaired mental development, cerebral palsy, blindness, or deafness. Impaired mental development is the most prevalent disability (17%-21% [95% CI] of survivors affected), followed by cerebral palsy (12%-15% of survivors affected). Blindness and deafness are less common (5% to 8% and 3% to 5% of survivors affected, respectively). Approximately one half of disabled survivors have more than one major disability. Based on studies of infants less than 750 to 1,000 grams birth weight, it can be anticipated that approximately another half of all extremely premature survivors will have one or more subtle neurodevelopmental disabilities in the school and teenage years. There is little evidence to suggest that long-term neurodevelopmental outcome has changed from the late 1970s to the early 1990s or with increasing survival. Survival of individual extremely premature infants cannot be accurately predicted in the immediate perinatal period. Major disability cannot be accurately predicted for individual survivors during the course in the newborn intensive care unit.

Neonatal brain injury

Complacency about long-term outcomes in newborns is being eroded rapidly with new information. We have examined developments in the area from an explicitly clinical approach, focusing on etiology, diagnostic modalities, and therapies. We attempt to discuss relevance from the preterm and the term perspective. Emerging evidence implicating chorioamnionitis as a significant contributor to neonatal brain injury is discussed. Therapeutic modalities such as magnetic resonance imaging and electrophysiological monitoring offer some potentially new tools for the clinician. An exploding series of basic advances suggest several potentially new strands of therapy. We discuss two that deserve further clinical exploration, namely anti-inflammatory strategies and thread hormone supplementation. In the arena of therapy, however, the paucity of large trials from which to guide therapies is a predominant theme, leaving a large reservoir of uncertainty for the clinician.

Brain-stem auditory evoked potentials in children with perinatal encephalopathies

OBJECTIVE

We sought to describe if neurological damage, in terms of brain lesions, syndrome and syndrome severity led to abnormalities in the brain-stem auditory evoked potentials (BAEPs) in order to provide a profile of children that could be used as an indicator of subsequent neurological sequelae. We analyzed the BAEPs from a group of children having prior evidence of neurological damage and determined the presence of neurological sequelae when the subjects were 3 years old.

METHODS

Brain-stem auditory evoked potentials (BAEPs) were carried out in a group of 154 children with perinatal neurological damage. The children were classified with neurofunctional (clinical and EEG alterations) or organic and neurofunctional brain disease (clinical, EEG and image alteration) and were all followed from the first month of life and serially for 3 years. We used principal component analysis (PCA), clustered analysis and linear correlation to determine association between BAEPs, risk factors and future sequelae.

RESULTS

Latencies of BAEPs decreased significantly with age, and the time of conduction was modified by the presence of neurological damage. All statistical analyses suggested positive and significant associations between risk factors (trophism and condition at birth), and the latencies of waves I, III and V as well as with IPL III-V (interpeak latency) and I-V. PCA showed that IPL I-III was also positively associated with condition at birth, severity of the neurological syndrome and encephalopathy. In addition, we found that the presence and type of sequela reflected changes in the latencies of the waves, as well as IPLs, primarily those of IPL I-III.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results suggest that statistical methods are often needed to analyze neurological damage. The relation between BAEPs, risk factors and neurological sequelae allowed us to obtain a profile of children, which can be then used as an aid in the prognosis of children having a risk of developing neurological sequelae.

Diagnostic and predictive value of auditory evoked responses in preterm infants: II. Auditory evoked responses

In this study, the diagnostic and predictive value of brainstem, middle latency, and cortical auditory evoked responses (BMC-AERs) obtained in the neonatal period in 81 preterm infants was assessed in relation to neurodevelopmental outcome. The preterm infants were neonatally classified according to risk category and gestational age. The BMC-AERs were analyzed with respect to detectability, latencies, and amplitudes as well as derived latency and amplitude measures. At 5 y of age the neurodevelopmental outcome was assessed from neurologic and neuropsychologic evaluations. The results showed that BMC-AER differences mainly correlated with risk category (low risk/high risk) and to some extent with degree of prematurity. In view of these findings the degree of prematurity and the effect of risk category have to be taken into account, when BMC-AERs are applied in the preterm period to predict neurodevelopmental outcome. In this study the BMC-AERs for infants with abnormal neurodevelopmental outcome were scarcely distinguishable from the BMC-AERs for infants with normal neurodevelopmental outcome. Thus far, this and previous reports have indicated that BMC-AERs in preterm infants are useful in maturational studies and with infants showing symptoms related to lesions or dysfunction of the peripheral and/or central auditory system. For predicting neurodevelopmental outcome in preterm infants, BMC-AERs are of limited clinical value.