Teaching NeuroImages: Sonographic detection of intraneural perineurioma in therapy-refractory carpal tunnel syndrome

Benign peripheral nerve sheath tumors: an interdisciplinary diagnostic and therapeutic challenge

A benign peripheral nerve sheath tumor (bPNST) is a rare lesion associated with peripheral nerval structures. Symptoms may be heterogeneous, complicating diagnosis finding. Additionally, management concepts of bPNST may vary. In some cases, initial misdiagnosis leads to mistreatment resulting in severe functional deficits and chronic pain syndromes. Therefore, we analyzed patients treated for bPNST in our specialized institution with a primary focus on prior misdiagnosis and possible mistreatment. Patients with bPNSTs (schwannomas, neurofibromas, hybrid nerve sheath tumors, and perineuriomas) treated at the Neurosurgical Department between January 1, 2015, and July 31, 2021, were included. Assessment of demographics, tumor entity, tumor location, symptoms, the interval between the onset of symptoms and surgery, involved medical specialties, and outpatients' treatment, with particular focus on initial misdiagnosis and inappropriate medical treatment, was performed. Eighty-five patients were included in the final analysis with schwannoma being the most prevalent histopathological diagnosis (schwannoma (75.3%, n=64), neurofibroma (12.9%, n=11), hybrid nerve sheath tumor (5.9%, n=5), and perineurioma (5.9%, n=5)). An incorrect primary diagnosis was detected in 44.7% (n=38), leading to suboptimal or insufficient treatment in these cases. Of those, 28.9% (n=11/38) were treated suboptimal, while 18.5% (n=7/38) underwent unnecessary invasive diagnostics. Inappropriate surgery based on prior misdiagnosis, which led to severe neurological deficits in all these cases, was reported in 26.3% (n=10/38). For the first time, our data shows the quantity and impact of incorrect initial diagnosis in bPNST causing a delay in causative treatment or resulting in unnecessary or potentially harmful treatment.

Clinical Features, Natural History, and Outcomes of Intraneural Perineuriomas: A Systematic Review of the Literature

BACKGROUND

Intraneural perineurioma is a rare peripheral nerve sheath tumor characterized by localized proliferation of perineurial cells. The literature consists predominantly of case reports and institutional series, with inconsistent and confusing nomenclature. We present a pooled analysis of all reported cases of intraneural perineurioma in the literature.

METHODS

A systematic search of PubMed, MEDLINE, Embase, and Scopus was performed according to PRISMA guidelines to identify all reported cases of intraneural perineurioma in the literature. Individual cases were pooled and analyzed for demographics, clinical features, and outcomes.

RESULTS

A total of 172 cases were identified across 72 studies, of which 149 were found in major peripheral nerves and their branches. Median age of patients at diagnosis and onset of symptoms was 18 years (interquartile range [IQR], 12-34 years) years and 13.5 years (IQR, 8-26 years), respectively, with 54.4% (81/149) being female. The most common sites were the sciatic nerve or its branches (41.9%), median nerve (13.5%), radial nerve (12.2%), and brachial plexus (12.2%). Most patients were managed conservatively (52.9%; 72/136). Among those managed conservatively with available follow-up (n = 31), median follow-up was 11 months, and most (67.7%, n = 21) reported no change in neurologic status, although worsening was noted in 29.0% (9/31). Among surgically managed cases (n = 64), the most common intervention was resection with or without repair (62.5%; 40/64), neurolysis (25%; 16/64), or tendon transfers without resection (12.5%; 8/64). No lesion recurred after surgical resection.

CONCLUSIONS

Intraneural perineurioma represents a benign focal lesion presenting with weakness and atrophy affecting adolescents and young adults. Most cases are managed nonoperatively and surgical treatment strategies are varied.

[Informative value of ultrasound in the diagnosis of intraneural perineurioma]

OBJECTIVE

To describe clinical and sonographic features of confirmed intraneural perineurioma in 5 patients.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We report clinical and sonographic features and retrospective follow-up data in 5 patients with intraneural perineurioma verified by biopsy.

RESULTS

In all cases, symptoms were represented by a slowly progressive painless mononeuropathy with muscle atrophy and impaired tendon reflexes. Ultrasound examination revealed locally enlarged cross-sectional area of the nerve that was confirmed by intraoperative visualization.

CONCLUSION

Intraneural perineurioma should be obligatory suspected in case of fusiform thickening of the nerve with locally changed echogenicity. Pooled multiple-center studies with large samples are needed to determine sensitivity and specificity of the main ultrasound parameters including changes in cross-sectional area and echogenicity of the nerve.

Modern treatment of perineuriomas: a case-series and systematic review

Background

Perineuriomas are rare benign peripheral nerve sheath tumours of perineurial cell origin and can be classified into intraneural and extraneural perineuriomas. They most commonly present a mononeuropathy of gradual onset and slow progression, resulting in progressive neurological deficits like hypoesthesia or motor weakness. Therapy is still variable. Aim of the study was to compare our surgical treatment and our follow-up regime including high-resolution nerve sonography with the current literature to evaluate best treatment of perineuriomas.

Methods

Retrospective analysis of our dataset “peripheral nerve lesion” to identify patients suffering from perineuriomas between 01.01.2012 until 31.12.2018. Surgical treatment and the follow-up examination of three patients were described. Additionally, a systematic review including PubMed, the Cochrane Collaboration Library, Scopus and Google Scholar was performed for literature published between January 1, 1990 and October 31, 2019 independently by 2 authors.

Results

In the first case, the left ulnar nerve was affected. In the second case, the left peroneal nerve and in the third case the right median nerve was affected. High-resolution nerve sonography was performed in each case. All patients underwent interfascicular neurolysis combined with a targeted fascicular biopsy under electrophysiological monitoring. Neurological deficits improved subsidized by rehabilitation. Surgical therapy and the neurological outcome were compared with literature. Systematic review revealed 22 articles, which met the inclusion criteria. Therefore, demographics, surgical treatment and neurological outcome of 77 patients were analysed.

Conclusions

Perineuriomas are rare benign nerve sheath tumours with a slow progression, sometimes difficult to diagnose. Decompression and neurolysis may improve neurological deficits. High resolution nerve sonography might serve as a helpful additional diagnostic tool in this process.