Evaluation of a forced-air system for warming hypothermic postoperative patients

Control of Shivering During Targeted Temperature Management

Targeted temperature management (TTM) is used frequently in patients with a variety of diseases, especially those who have experienced brain injury and/or cardiac arrest. Shivering is one of the main adverse effects of TTM that can often limit its implementation and efficacy. Shivering is the body's natural response to hypothermia and its deleterious effects can negate the benefits of TTM. The purpose of this article is to provide an overview of TTM strategies and shivering management.

Therapeutic hypothermia protocols

The application of targeted temperature management has become common practice in the neurocritical care setting. It is important to recognize the pathophysiologic mechanisms by which temperature control impacts acute neurologic injury, as well as the clinical limitations to its application. Nonetheless, when utilizing temperature modulation, an organized approach is required in order to avoid complications and minimize side-effects. The most common clinically relevant complications are related to the impact of cooling on hemodynamics and electrolytes. In both instances, the rate of complications is often related to the depth and rate of cooling or rewarming. Shivering is the most common side-effect of hypothermia and is best managed by adequate monitoring and stepwise administration of medications specifically targeting the shivering response. Due to the impact cooling can have upon pharmacokinetics of commonly used sedatives and analgesics, there can be significant delays in the return of the neurologic examination. As a result, early prognostication posthypothermia should be avoided.

Peri-operative warming devices: performance and clinical application

Since the adverse consequences of accidental peri-operative hypothermia have been recognised, there has been a rapid expansion in the development of new warming equipment designed to prevent it. This is a review of peri-operative warming devices and a critique of the evidence assessing their performance. Forced-air warming is a common and extensively tested warming modality that outperforms passive insulation and water mattresses, and is at least as effective as resistive heating. More recently developed devices include circulating water garments, which have shown promising results due to their ability to cover large surface areas, and negative pressure devices aimed at improving subcutaneous perfusion for warming. We also discuss the challenge of fluid warming, looking particularly at how devices' performance varies according to flow rate. Our ultimate aim is to provide a guide through the bewildering array of devices on the market so that clinicians can make informed and accurate choices for their particular hospital environment.

Hypothermia in neurocritical care

Hypothermia has long been recognized as an effective therapy for acute neurologic injury. Recent advances in bedside technology and greater understanding of thermoregulatory mechanisms have made this therapy readily available at the bedside. Critical care management of the hypothermic patient can be divided into 3 phases: induction, maintenance, and rewarming. Each phase has known complications that require careful monitoring. At present, hypothermia has only been shown to be an effective neuroprotective therapy in cardiac arrest survivors. The primary use of hypothermia in the neurocritical care unit is to treat increased intracranial pressure.

Hypothermia for acute brain injury--mechanisms and practical aspects

Hypothermia is widely accepted as the gold-standard method by which the body can protect the brain. Therapeutic cooling--or targeted temperature management (TTM)--is increasingly being used to prevent secondary brain injury in patients admitted to the emergency department and intensive care unit. Rapid cooling to 33 °C for 24 h is considered the standard of care for minimizing neurological injury after cardiac arrest, mild-to-moderate hypothermia (33-35 °C) can be used as an effective component of multimodal therapy for patients with elevated intracranial pressure, and advanced cooling technology can control fever in patients who have experienced trauma, haemorrhagic stroke, or other forms of severe brain injury. However, the practical application of therapeutic hypothermia is not trivial, and the treatment carries risks. Development of clinical management protocols that focus on detection and control of shivering and minimize the risk of other potential complications of TTM will be essential to maximize the benefits of this emerging therapeutic modality. This Review provides an overview of the potential neuroprotective mechanisms of hypothermia, practical considerations for the application of TTM, and disease-specific evidence for the use of this therapy in patients with acute brain injuries.

Prevention of shivering during therapeutic temperature modulation: the Columbia anti-shivering protocol

BACKGROUND

As the practice of aggressive temperature control has become more commonplace, new clinical problems are arising, of which shivering is the most common. Treatment for shivering while avoiding the negative consequences of many anti-shivering therapies is often difficult. We have developed a stepwise protocol that emphasizes use of the least sedating regimen to achieve adequate shiver control.

METHODS

All patients treated with temperature modulating devices in the neurological intensive care unit were prospectively entered into a database. Baseline demographic information, daily temperature goals, best daily GCS, and type and cumulative dose of anti-shivering agents were recorded.

RESULTS

We collected 213 patients who underwent 1388 patient days of temperature modulation. Eighty-nine patients underwent hypothermia and 124 patients underwent induced normothermia. In 18% of patients and 33% of the total patient days only none-sedating baseline interventions were needed. The first agent used was most commonly dexmeditomidine at 50% of the time, followed by an opiate and increased doses of propofol. Younger patients, men, and decreased BSA were factors associated with increased number of anti-shivering interventions.

CONCLUSIONS

A significant proportion of patients undergoing temperature modulation can be effectively treated for shivering without over-sedation and paralysis. Patients at higher risk for needing more interventions are younger men with decreased BSA.

Forced-air warming: technology, physical background and practical aspects

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

There is an ever-increasing number of forced-air warming devices available in the market. However, there is also a paucity of studies that have investigated the physical background of these devices, making it difficult to find the most suitable ones.

RECENT FINDINGS

Heat flow produced by power units depends on the air temperature at the nozzle and the airflow. The heat transfer from the blanket to the body surface depends on the heat exchange coefficient, the temperature gradient between the blanket and the body surface and the area that is covered. Additionally, the homogeneity of heat distribution inside the blanket is very important. The lower the temperature difference between the highest and the lowest blanket temperature, the better the performance of the blanket.

SUMMARY

The efficacy of a forced-air warming system is mainly determined by the design of the blankets. A good forced-air warming blanket can easily be detected by measuring the temperature difference between the highest blanket temperature and the lowest blanket temperature. This temperature difference should be as low as possible. Because of the limited efficacy of forced-air warming systems to prevent hypothermia, patients must be prewarmed for 30-60 min even if a forced-air warming system is used during the operation. During the operation, the largest blanket that is possible for the operation should be used.

Hyperthermia and fever control in brain injury

Fever in the neurocritical care setting is common and has a negative impact on outcome of all disease types. Meta-analyses have demonstrated that fever at onset and in the acute setting after ischemic brain injury, intracerebral hemorrhage, and cardiac arrest has a negative impact on morbidity and mortality. Data support that the impact of fever is sustained for longer durations after subarachnoid hemorrhage and traumatic brain injury. Recent advances have made eliminating fever and maintaining normothermia feasible. However, there are no prospective randomized trials demonstrating the benefit of fever control in these patient populations, and important questions regarding indications and timing remain. The purpose of this review is to analyze the data surrounding the impact of fever across a range of neurologic injuries to better understand the optimal timing and duration of fever control. Prospective randomized trials are needed to determine whether the beneficial impact of secondary injury prevention is outweighed by the potential risks of prolonged fever control.

Intraoperative forced air-warming during cesarean delivery under spinal anesthesia does not prevent maternal hypothermia

BACKGROUND

Prewarming and intraoperative warming with forced air-warming systems prevent perioperative hypothermia and shivering in patients undergoing elective cesarean delivery with epidural anesthesia. We tested the hypothesis that intraoperative lower body forced air-warming prevents hypothermia in patients undergoing elective cesarean delivery with spinal anesthesia.

METHODS

Thirty healthy patients undergoing cesarean delivery with spinal anesthesia were randomly assigned to forced air-warming or control groups (identical cover applied with forced air-warming unit switched off). A blinded investigator assessed oral temperature, shivering, and thermal comfort scores at 15-min intervals until discharge from the postanesthetic care unit. Umbilical cord blood gases and Apgar scores were also measured after delivery.

RESULTS

The maximum core temperature changes were similar in the two groups (-1.3 degrees C +/- 0.4 degrees C vs -1.3 degrees C +/- 0.3 degrees C for the forced air-warming group and control group, respectively; P = 0.8). Core hypothermia (< or =35.5 degrees C) occurred in 8 of 15 patients receiving forced air-warming and in 10 of 15 unwarmed patients (P = 0.5). The incidence and severity of shivering did not significantly differ between groups. Umbilical cord blood gases and Apgar scores were similar in both groups (P = NS).

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that intraoperative lower body forced air-warming does not prevent intraoperative hypothermia or shivering in women undergoing elective cesarean delivery with spinal anesthesia.

Assessment of the efficiency of warming devices during neonatal surgery

This study assessed the relative efficiency of different warming devices (surgical sheets covering the body and a tubegauze on the head, forced-air warming, warming mattress) commonly used to prevent body hypothermia during neonatal surgery. Dry heat losses were measured from a thermal manikin, which simulated a low-birth-weight neonate of 1,800 g. The manikin's surface temperatures (35.8 degrees C) corresponded to those of neonates nursed in closed incubators. Experiments were performed in a climatic chamber at an ambient temperature of 30 degrees C, as commonly found in operating theatres. The supine manikin was naked or covered with operative sheets with a 5x5 cm aperture over the abdomen. Its head could be covered by a tube-gauze. Additional warming was provided by conduction through a warming mattress (surface temperature, 39 degrees C) and/or by convection (Bair Hugger, forced-air temperature 38 degrees C). Covering the manikin with surgical sheets decreased the dry heat loss by 10.4 W. Additional forced-air warming was more efficient than the warming mattress to reduce the total dry heat loss (6.8 W vs 2.1 W). Heat losses were reduced by 7.9 W when combining the warming mattress and Bair Hugger. The heat loss from the head of the covered manikin was reduced from 4.5 W to 3.9 W when the head was covered with the tubegauze. Our data indicate that forced-air warming is more effective than conductive warming in preventing neonatal hypothermia during abdominal operations.

Influence of control variables on mannequin temperature in a paediatric operating theatre

BACKGROUND

Core temperature drops in all children having general anaesthesia. Convection heating may be useful, but its effectiveness in the paediatric setting is not established. Additionally, its utility in many paediatric situations is limited by blanket design.

METHODS

Using a mannequin model in a sham operation, we assessed the likely safety and effectiveness of a draping technique in association with a 'Bair Hugger' and a heat dissipation unit (HDU). In Part 1 of the study, the influence of ambient temperature was assessed. In Part 2, a simulated laparotomy was set up and a more detailed assessment of air temperatures around the mannequin was made. In addition, the effect of a change in the HDU design was assessed.

RESULTS

Part 1: the technique achieved 'near-plateau' temperature within 5-10 min. A difference of 8 degrees C in ambient temperature (between 18 and 26 degrees C) translated only to a 2-3 degrees C difference under the drapes. Part 2: the technique produced sidestream cooler zones at the head and shoulders. Air temperature at these sites was 28-34 degrees C, whereas at other points (irrespective of their distance from the heat source), it was 37-40 degrees C. Warm air reached sufficient skin sites to anticipate adequate heat transfer in the clinical situation. Air temperature at 'skin' surface stayed below 40 degrees C over the 90-min study period.

CONCLUSIONS

A customized HDU used in association with a 'Bair Hugger' unit and a careful surgical draping technique provides stable, safe and consistent air temperatures around a mannequin. Net heat gain by a child's body should occur with this arrangement. Further evaluation in a clinical study is underway.

Monitoring and thermal management

Anaesthesia alters normal thermoregulatory control of the body, usually leading to perioperative hypothermia. Hypothermia is associated with a large number of serious complications. To assess perianaesthetic hypothermia, core temperature should be monitored vigorously. Pulmonary artery, tympanic membrane, distal oesophageal or nasopharyngeal temperatures reflect core temperature reliably. Core temperatures can be often estimated with reasonable accuracy using oral, axillary and bladder temperatures, except during extreme thermal perturbations. The body site for measurements should be chosen according to the surgical procedure. Unless hypothermia is specifically indicated, efforts should be made to maintain intraoperative core temperatures above 36 degrees C. Forced air is the most effective, commonly available, non-invasive warming method. Resistive heating electrical blankets and circulating water garment systems are an equally effective alternative. Intravenous fluid warming is also helpful when large volumes are required. In some patients, induction of mild therapeutic hypothermia may become an issue for the future. Recent studies indicate that patients suffering from neurological disease may profit from rapid core cooling.

Perioperative management and monitoring in anaesthesia

In recent years, several risk factors for adverse outcome in patients undergoing anaesthesia have been identified. Besides human errors, cardiovascular and respiratory complications are associated with substantial morbidity. Assessment of complications has promoted the introduction of basic physiological monitoring in clinical practice. Whether monitoring directly affects outcome is not proven; however, circumstantial evidence suggests that basic cardiorespiratory monitoring decreases the incidence of serious accidents. Prevention of hypothermia also reduces anaesthesia-related morbidity. Measurement of body temperature is mandatory, and active warming is a simple, effective technique to avoid hypothermia. Evidence is growing that patients with known or suspected coronary artery disease should be treated with beta blockers perioperatively. Whether the type of anaesthesia-ie, general or regional-is relevant to perioperative mortality remains unclear. In subgroups of patients at high risk, neuraxial anaesthesia reduces the rate of respiratory and cardiovascular complications.

Critical care of the vascular surgery patient

Providing effective critical care to vascular surgical patients is challenging to the intensivist. These patients often have multiple significant concurrent diseases that need to be adequately managed. A selective policy for identifying patients that need ICU is recommended. Early and smooth restoration to their preoperative physiological homeostasis is crucial. Optimal pain relief, return to normothermia, and adequate intravascular volume replacement are thus key interventions. Epidurals provide excellent analgesia. Vigilant monitoring and decisive therapy of the wide range of complications that may occur in the postoperative is of paramount importance. The level of monitoring should be an extension of that done intraoperatively. Hemorrhage and thrombosis are dreaded sequelae; cardiac morbidity and mortality is significant. Respiratory complications may necessitate prolonged postoperative mechanical ventilation. Careful clinical evaluation is necessary to detect the various neurological complications that may occur. Renal and gastrointestinal complications are potentially lethal. Graft sepsis may occur later. The development of new techniques, such as endovascular repairs of aneurysms, may minimize the need for ICU.

Postanaesthetic shivering: epidemiology, pathophysiology, and approaches to prevention and management

Along with nausea and vomiting, postanaesthetic shivering is one of the leading causes of discomfort for patients recovering from general anaesthesia. The distinguishing factor during electromyogram recordings between patients with postanaesthetic shivering and shivering in fully awake patients is the existence of clonus similar to that recorded in patients with spinal cord transection. Clonus coexists with the classic waxing and waning signals associated with cutaneous vasoconstriction (thermoregulatory shivering). The primary cause of postanaesthetic shivering is peroperative hypothermia, which sets in because of anaesthetic-induced inhibition of thermoregulation. However, shivering associated with cutaneous vasodilatation (non-thermoregulatory shivering) also occurs, one of the origins of which is postoperative pain. Apart from causing discomfort and aggravation of pain, postanaesthetic shivering increases metabolic demand proportionally to the solicited muscle mass and the cardiac capacity of the patient. No link has been demonstrated between the occurrence of shivering and an increase in cardiac morbidity, but it is preferable to avoid postanaesthetic shivering because it is oxygen draining. Prevention mainly entails preventing peroperative hypothermia by actively rewarming the patient. Postoperative skin surface rewarming is a rapid way of obtaining the threshold shivering temperature while raising the skin temperature and improving the comfort of the patient. However, it is less efficient than certain drugs such as meperidine, clonidine or tramadol, which act by reducing the shivering threshold temperature.

The failure of negative pressure rewarming (Thermostat) to accelerate recovery from mild hypothermia in postoperative surgical patients

The Thermostat device (Aquarius Medical Corp., Phoenix, AZ) is used in a new technique to accelerate recovery from hypothermia by mechanically distending blood vessels in the hand, thereby increasing transfer of exogenous heat to the body core. We evaluated the use of the Thermostat device in patients with mild postoperative hypothermia (< 36 degrees C). We studied adult patients undergoing elective surgery, general anesthesia, and neuromuscular blockade. Patients with an initial postoperative tympanic membrane temperature < 36 degrees C were randomized into two groups: 1) Thermostat, which consisted of a hypothermia warming mitt/seal and thermal exchange chamber for 60 min, and 2) conventional treatment, which consisted of warm blankets and/or radiant heat. Of the 191 patients enrolled, 60 (31%) developed hypothermia and were randomized to receive the Thermostat (n = 30) or conventional methods (n = 30). Fourteen patients in the Thermostat group and 17 patients in the conventional group rewarmed to 36 degrees C before discharge from the recovery room (P is not significant). There were no differences in vital signs, rewarming time, time to discharge from the recovery room, or postoperative temperature between groups. We conclude that patients with mild postoperative hypothermia rewarmed in a similar fashion, regardless of whether the Thermostat or conventional methods were used.

IMPLICATIONS

We found that a commercially available negative pressure rewarming device (Thermostat; Aquarius Medical Corp., Phoenix, AZ) was not effective in accelerating rewarming in postoperative hypothermic surgical patients after general anesthesia.

Metabolic and hemodynamic changes during recovery and tracheal extubation in neurosurgical patients: immediate versus delayed recovery

Delayed recovery has been advocated to limit the postoperative stress linked to awakening from anesthesia, but data on this subject are lacking. In this study, we measured oxygen consumption (V(O2)) and plasma catecholamine concentrations as markers of postoperative stress. We tested the hypothesis that delayed recovery and extubation would attenuate metabolic changes after intracranial surgery. Thirty patients were included in a prospective, open study and were randomized into two groups. In Group I, the patients were tracheally extubated as soon as possible after surgery. In Group II, the patients were sedated with propofol for 2 h after surgery. V(O2), catecholamine concentration, mean arterial pressure (MAP), and heart rate (HR) were measured during anesthesia, at extubation, and 30 min after extubation. V(O2) and noradrenaline on extubation and mean V(O2) during recovery were significantly higher in Group II than in Group I (V(O2) for Group I: preextubation 215 +/- 46 mL/min, recovery 198 +/- 38 mL/min; for Group II: preextubation 320 +/- 75 mL/min, recovery 268 +/- 49 mL/min; noradrenaline on extubation for Group I: 207 +/- 76 pg/mL, for Group II: 374 +/- 236 pg/ mL). Extubation induced a significant increase in MAP. MAP, HR, and adrenaline values were not statistically different between groups. In conclusion, delayed recovery after neurosurgery cannot be recommended as a mechanism of limiting the metabolic and hemodynamic consequences from emergence from general anesthesia.

IMPLICATIONS

In this study, we tested the hypothesis that delayed recovery after neurosurgery would attenuate the consequences of recovery from general anesthesia. As markers of stress, oxygen consumption and noradrenaline blood levels were higher after delayed versus early recovery. Thus, delayed recovery cannot be recommended as a mechanism of limiting the metabolic and hemodynamic consequences from emergence after neurosurgery.

Effects of sympathetic blockade on the efficiency of forced-air warming during combined spinal-epidural anesthesia for total hip arthroplasty

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To evaluate if active cutaneous warming of the two upper limbs with reflex vasoconstriction is less effective in maintaining intraoperative normothermia than warming the vasodilated unoperated lower limb during combined spinal-epidural anesthesia (CSE).

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized study.

SETTING

Inpatient anesthesia at university departments of orthopedic surgery.

PATIENTS

48 ASA physical status I, II, and III patients, who were scheduled for elective total hip arthroplasty.

INTERVENTIONS

Patients received CSE with intrathecal injection of 15 mg of 0.5% hyperbaric bupivacaine. All procedures started 8 to 10 AM, and operating room temperature was maintained between 21 degrees and 23 degrees C, with relative humidity ranging between 40% and 45%. For warming therapy, patients received active forced-air warming of either the two upper limbs (Group Upper body, n = 24), or the unoperated lower limb (Group Lower extremity, n = 24). Core temperature was measured before CSE placement (baseline), and then every 30 minutes until completion of surgery. Time for fulfillment of clinical discharging criteria from the recovery area was evaluated by a blinded observer.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Demographic data, duration of surgery, intraoperative blood losses, crystalloid infusion, and hemodynamic variables were similar in the two groups. Core temperature slightly decreased in both groups, but at the end of surgery the mean core temperature was 36.2 degrees +/- 0.5 degree C in Group Upper body and 36.3 +/- 0.5 in Group Lower extremity (NS). At recovery room arrival, seven patients in Group Upper body (29%) and three patients in Group Lower extremity (12.5%) had a core temperature less than 36 degrees C (NS). Shivering was observed in one patient in Group Upper body and in two patients in Group Lower extremity (NS). Clinical discharging criteria were fulfilled after 37 +/- 16 minutes in Group Upper body and 30 +/- 32 minutes in Group Lower extremity (NS).

CONCLUSIONS

Forced-air cutaneous warming allows the anesthesiologist to maintain normothermia during CSE for total hip replacement even if the convective blanket is placed on a relatively small skin surface with reflex vasoconstriction. Placing the forced-air warming system on the vasodilated unoperated lower limb may be troublesome to the surgeons and does not offer clinically relevant advantages in warming efficiency.

Warming with a forced air warming blanket minimizes anesthetic-induced hypothermia in cats

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the effectiveness of a forced-air warming blanket (FAWB) in minimizing anesthetic-induced hypothermia in cats, and to examine the relationship between esophageal and other estimates of body temperature during skin surface warming.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective, randomized cross-over trial.

ANIMALS

Eight adult domestic shorthair cats (four males and four females) weighing 2.3 to 4.5 kg.

METHODS

Each cat was anesthetized with halothane in oxygen on four occasions and covered with a modified FAWB. Air delivered to the cats by the FAWB was warmed to approximately 43 degrees C. Each trial lasted 90 minutes and was divided into two consecutive 45-minute periods, during which the FAWB was activated or inactivated thus creating four treatment trials: off/off, on/off, on/on, off/on. Measurements of body temperature from the caudal esophagus, deep rectum, toe-web, and tympanic membrane were recorded at regular intervals throughout each trial and compared.

RESULTS

A steady decline in body temperature was observed throughout each trial. Mean body temperature in the cats receiving continual skin surface warming (on/on) was significantly higher than in those receiving no active warming (off/off) and those receiving delayed warming (off/on), from 45 minutes onwards. By 90 minutes, the mean body temperature of cats warmed continuously was 0.9 degrees C higher than in those with no active warming. Notable differences in body temperature were detected between all measurement sites, with the exception of esophagus versus rectum. Rectal and esophageal temperatures did not differ at any time point. Tympanic membrane temperatures measured with either device were lower than esophageal temperatures.

CONCLUSIONS

The modified FAWB was effective in minimizing the degree of hypothermia experienced in cats anesthetized with halothane for 90 minutes. Deep rectal temperature was an accurate reflection of esophageal temperature in these cats.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Forced air warming blankets may prove successful in minimizing anesthetic-induced hypothermia in cats.

Inadvertent hypothermia prevention: the anaesthetic nurses' role

Up to 90% of patients experience hypothermia perioperatively. Inadvertent hypothermia can have a profound physiological effect on the body, varying from mild vasoconstriction and feeling cold to cardiac arrest and death. Anaesthesia, general or regional, increases the risk as the normal protective reflexes such as shivering are absent, particularly when muscle relaxants are used. The very young and the elderly are particularly vulnerable. Preoperative assessment is essential. The greatest reduction in temperature occurs in the first hour of surgery, as a result of patient exposure, skin disinfection with cold fluids, inhalation of cold volatile gases and the administration of cold intravenous fluids, as well as exposure to cool theatre temperatures. If the theatre temperature drops below 21 degrees C, all patients will develop hypothermia. Patients lose heat through radiation, convention and conduction, with conduction having the greatest effect. Forced air warmers such as the Bair Hugger are the most effective means of preventing and treating heat loss. They should be used routinely although their contribution to infection also needs to be considered. Nurses should be aware of the risks of hypothermia so that modes of prevention can be employed to minimize the risks of inadvertent hypothermia.

Recovery from mild hypothermia can be accelerated by mechanically distending blood vessels in the hand

Peripheral vasoconstriction decreases thermal conductance of hypothermic individuals, making it difficult to transfer externally applied heat to the body core. We hypothesized that increasing blood flow to the skin of a hypothermic individual would enhance the transfer of exogenous heat to the body core, thereby increasing the rate of rewarming. External auditory meatus temperature (TEAM) was monitored in hypothermic subjects during recovery from general anesthesia. In 10 subjects, heat (45-46 degreesC, water-perfused blanket) was applied to a single forearm and hand that had been placed in a subatmospheric pressure environment (-30 to -40 mmHg) to distend the blood vessels. Heat alone was applied to control subjects (n = 6). The application of subatmospheric pressure resulted in a 10-fold increase in rewarming rates as determined by changes in TEAM [13.6 +/- 2.1 (SE) degreesC/h in the experimental group vs. 1.4 +/- 0.1 degreesC/h in the control group; P < 0.001]. In the experimental subjects, the rate of change of TEAM decreased sharply as TEAM neared the normothermic range.

Convective warming blankets improve peroperative heat preservation in congenital heart surgery

Peroperative heat preservation, following hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) in children, has always been a challenge to the anaesthetist. We studied the efficiency of a convective heating system on peroperative heat preservation in 50 children undergoing congenital heart surgery. Twenty-five children, rewarmed by CPB and heating mattress, were randomly selected (Group 1). Another 25 children, rewarmed by CPB, heating mattress and convective warming blankets in addition (Group 2), were selected so the two groups were comparable regarding age, weight and anaesthetic management. The central and peripheral temperatures were measured during bypass, at the end of bypass and at the end of operation. A retrospective evaluation showed that during bypass the peripheral temperature was significantly lower in Group 2 than in Group 1, with no significant difference in central temperature. At the end of bypass there was no significant difference between the two groups. At the end of operation the central and peripheral temperatures were significantly higher in Group 2. In conclusion convective warming blankets are effective in keeping or even raising the temperature following congenital heart surgery.

Forced-air warming is no more effective than conventional methods for raising postoperative core temperature after cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether postoperative forced-air warming of cardiac bypass patients in the intensive care unit (ICU) results in faster rate of warming and improved outcomes compared with more conventional ICU warming methods.

DESIGN

Prospective randomized effectiveness study.

SETTING

Three hundred fifty-bed university-affiliated hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Sixty consenting randomized patients from a consecutive series of 84 patients undergoing routine adult cardiac surgery.

INTERVENTIONS

One group of patients received usual patient care, which includes warm blankets and overhead heat lamps. Patients in the other group were placed under forced-air warming devices on arrival in the ICU. Sixty consenting patients (30 in each group) were randomly assigned to one or the other method of warming. The remaining 24 patients refused randomization and self-selected a treatment group.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Results are presented for the randomized groups. Core temperature, measured by pulmonary artery catheter thermistor, increased in both groups at the rate of 0.25 degree C per hour. No statistically or clinically significant differences were found between the group for whom the warming device was used and the standard care group in the incidence of postoperative cardiac arrhythmia, duration of time in the ICU, or any other clinical variable.

CONCLUSIONS

There is no evidence from this study to warrant use of forced-air warming devices for the care of postoperative cardiac surgical patients in the ICU.

Active warming, not passive heat retention, maintains normothermia during combined epidural-general anesthesia for hip and knee arthroplasty

STUDY OBJECTIVE

to compare passive heat retention by low-flow anesthesia, alone and with additional thermal insulation by reflective blankets, with forced-air warming preventing intraoperative hypothermia during combined epidural-general anesthesia.

DESIGN

Randomized, controlled study.

SETTING

Inpatient anesthesia at a university department of orthopedic surgery.

PATIENTS

30 ASA physical status I and II patients, who were scheduled for elective hip or knee arthroplasty and were free from systemic disease.

INTERVENTIONS

Patients received epidural block up to T10 by alkalinized lidocaine 2%, and then were administered standard general anesthesia by means of low-flow rebreathing system (fresh gas flow = 1 L/min). All procedures started between 8 and 10 AM, and operating room (OR) temperature was maintained between 21 degrees and 23 degrees C, with relative humidity ranging between 40% and 45%. For heat retention or warming therapy, patients received either low-flow anesthesia only (control, n = 10), low-flow anesthesia with additional reflective blankets (blanket, n = 10), or low-flow anesthesia with active forced-air warming (forced-air, n = 10). Tympanic temperature was measured at OR arrival (baseline); immediately following general anesthesia induction; 30, 60, 90, and 120 minutes from general anesthesia induction; and at the end of surgery.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Duration of anesthesia, invasiveness of surgery, and baseline core temperature were similar in the three groups. Core temperature decreased in all the three groups 30 minutes after general anesthesia induction compared with baseline (p < 0.01); afterwards, it progressively decreased in the control and blankets groups (p = 0.004), with a reduction from baseline values measured at the end of surgery of 2.0 degrees C and 1.6 degrees C, respectively. In the forced-air group, after the initial significant decrease (p = 0.01 vs. baseline), core temperature progressively increased to 35.8 +/- 0.6 degrees C, which was similar to preoperative values and significantly higher than either the control or blankets groups (p = 0.004).

CONCLUSIONS

During combined epidural-general anesthesia for elective hip and knee arthroplasty, passive heat retention by means of low-flow anesthesia alone and in combination with reflective blankets is ineffective in maintaining intraoperative normothermia and definitely inferior to active forced-air warning.

The effects of forced-air warming on postbypass central and skin temperatures and shivering activity

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To test the hypothesis that forced-air skin-surface warming used prophylactically after hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) would: (1) decrease the incidence and severity of postbypass shivering, (2) rapidly increase skin-surface temperatures when compared with standard warmed cotton blankets, and (3) not contribute to excessive central temperature elevation.

DESIGN

Prospective, randomized, nonblinded comparison of two rewarming techniques.

SETTING

Multidisciplinary intensive care unit at a tertiary care, private teaching hospital.

PATIENTS

Following hypothermic CPB, 47 patients underwent postoperative rewarming by using either conduction (warmed cotton blankets) or convection (forced-air cover) techniques.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Central and skin temperatures were measured at 30-minute intervals for 5.5 hours postoperatively. Four lead electromyographic recordings were used to objectively document shivering activity. Antihypertensives, opioids, sedatives, and muscle relaxants were administered per patient need and recorded. The forced-air cover markedly decreased the overall incidence, duration, and magnitude of significant shivering compared with the warmed cotton blankets. Forced-air therapy produced clinically significant increases in skin surface temperatures, but avoided excessive central temperature elevation when compared with passive rewarming with cotton blankets.

CONCLUSION

Convection warming, when compared with conductive warming with cotton blankets, limited the incidence, magnitude, and duration of shivering following hypothermic cardiac surgery. This suggests an important role of cutaneous thermal input in the mediation of the shivering response. The central tissue compartment is buffered from the effects of skin-surface warming and, thus, forced-air therapy will not lead to excessive central temperature elevation in this patient population when compared with cotton blanket rewarming.

Afterdrop after hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass: the value of tympanic membrane temperature monitoring

OBJECTIVES

After weaning from cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB), a decrease in nasopharyngeal temperature (NPT) occurs (afterdrop). The pathophysiology of the afterdrop remains unclear: It might be caused by either inadequate total body rewarming on CPB or to heterogenous distribution of heat during CPB, with subsequent redistribution of heat from the warmer core to the cooler shell tissues. The study objectives were (1) to determine whether post-CPB afterdrop is the result of a negative CPB thermal balance, and (2) to investigate which sites (if any) could best predict the afterdrop.

DESIGN

Prospective evaluation using within-patient comparisons during CPB cooling, CPB rewarming, and 45 minutes post-CPB.

SETTING

Adult patients gave informed consent before a cardiac surgical procedure in a university hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Eight patients undergoing CABG or valvular replacement with hypothermic CPB (NPT near 29 degrees C) and standardized general anesthesia.

INTERVENTIONS

Each patient was studied with temperature monitors (Mon-a-therm 7000; Mallinckrodt-Medexel, Gemenos, France) attached to disposable thermocouple probes placed as follows: urinary bladder, rectum, deltoid, esophagus, nasopharynx, tympanic membrane, and four skin sites. In addition, the temperatures from the thermistors of the pulmonary artery catheter, and the arterial and venous lines of the CPB circuit were considered. Thirteen sites for monitoring temperature were studied.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Temperatures were recorded every 5 minutes, from the beginning of CPB to the 45th minute after CPB, and thermal exchanges were calculated: change in body heat (QBH), thermal exchanges between the patient and the pump (QCPB), metabolic heat production (Qm) (equal to calculated VO2 at the pump level), and heat loss to the environment (QS) (equal to QBH-QCPB-Qm). Thermal exchanges were obtained in six patients during the plateaus of cooling and rewarming, during the whole CPB phase, and after CPB. It was found that despite a change in QBH during rewarming (1,017 +/- 88 kJ) that was slightly greater than during cooling (-1,008 +/- 104 kJ) (mean +/- SEM), a significant decrease in post-CPB "core" temperature occurred (afterdrop: -1.4 degrees C). Magnitude of the afterdrop was directly related to the magnitude of tympanic membrane cooling and was negatively correlated to the temperature difference between the warmest site (tympanic membrane) and the coolest site (cutaneous thigh temperature) observed at the end of rewarming (r = -0.667; p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

It is suggested that besides post-CPB heat loss, redistribution of heat may be involved in the mechanism of the afterdrop and that measurements of tympanic membrane and cutaneous thigh temperatures are the best monitors of adequacy of rewarming during CPB.

The effect of prophylactic clonidine on postoperative shivering. A large prospective double-blind study

The primary goal of this study was to assess the influence of clonidine administered after induction on postoperative shivering after elective peripheral surgery. The effect of clonidine on intra-operative haemodynamics (blood pressure and heart rate) during the first 30 min after induction and on the postoperative sedation of the patient was also investigated. Two hundred and eighty male ASA 1 and 2 patients, undergoing elective peripheral surgery were randomly administered either placebo or clonidine 2 micrograms.kg-1 intravenously over 10 min after induction of anaesthesia. Clonidine was found to reduce the total incidence (p = 0.024), the severity (p = 0.005) and the duration (p = 0.01) of postoperative shivering. Clonidine did not increase postoperative sedation or diminish overall consciousness. We conclude that administration of clonidine 2 micrograms.kg-1 intravenously after induction of anaesthesia is safe and reduces postoperative shivering in this group of patients.

The etiology and management of inadvertent perioperative hypothermia

Mild perioperative hypothermia is a frequent complication of anesthesia and surgery. Core temperature should be monitored during general anesthesia and during regional anesthesia for large operations. Reliable sites of core temperature monitoring include the tympanic membrane, nasopharynx, esophagus, bladder, rectum, and pulmonary artery. The skin surface is not an acceptable site for monitoring core temperature. Anesthetic-induced vasodilation initially rapidly decreases core temperature secondary to an internal redistribution of heat rather than an increased heat loss to the environment. Both general and regional anesthetics impair thermoregulation, increasing the interthreshold range; that is, the range of core temperatures over which no autonomic response to cold or warmth occurs. Preinduction skin surface warming is the only means to prevent this initial redistribution hypothermia. Forced-air warming is the most effective method of rewarming hypothermic patients intraoperatively.

External rewarming and age in mildly hypothermic patients after cardiac surgery

OBJECTIVE

To compare the effects of two external rewarming methods on body core temperature and the rate of rewarming between two age groups (less than 65 years, 65 years or more) of adult, mildly hypothermic patients who have undergone cardiac surgery, during the immediate postoperative period.

DESIGN

Stratified, randomized clinical trial.

SETTING

Five-bed cardiac surgical intensive care unit in a large teaching-research institution.

SUBJECTS

Thirty-two white patients who had undergone cardiac surgery and who had mildly hypothermic body core temperatures (33 degrees to 35 degrees C) immediately after the surgery.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Body core temperature was measured with a pulmonary artery catheter thermistor at the time of external rewarming method application and at 60, 90, and 150 minutes afterward. Rate of rewarming was measured as body core temperature change in degrees Celsius per hour (at 36.6 degrees C, minus body core temperature when external rewarming method was applied, divided by total rewarming time). Temperatures were recorded six times at intervals of 15 minutes; then every 30 minutes until a value of 36.6 degrees C was obtained, at which time the blanket was removed; then hourly for 8 hours.

INTERVENTION

Either a fluid-filled circulating blanket (active-conductive external rewarming) or a reflective blanket (passive-reflective external rewarming) was applied immediately after core temperature was measured on admission to the cardiac surgical intensive care unit after surgery.

RESULTS

External rewarming methods affected body core temperature differently at different times, and there were significant differences in body core temperature across the time periods (p < 0.05). Both active and passive external rewarming methods showed a sigmoidal rewarming pattern without a downward temperature drift. The fluid-filled circulating blanket produced a quicker and steeper body core temperature change in the early rewarming phase; the reflective blanket resulted in a more gradual temperature rise. Age did not significantly affect body core temperature, nor did age or external rewarming method significantly influence the rate of rewarming, although total rewarming time was longer for those of more advanced age. Seven subjects with passive rewarming method experienced body core temperature overshoot during the 8-hour period after blanket removal.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, conduction and reflection of radiant heat were equally effective in producing an acceptable rate of rewarming but contributed to different internal patterns in core rewarming. The average total rewarming time with the active external rewarming method was 1 hour shorter than with the passive external rewarming method.

Propofol and postanaesthetic shivering

Sixty ASA grade 1 unpremedicated patients scheduled for minor elective surgery were randomly allocated to receive general anaesthesia consisting of either propofol-nitrous oxide in oxygen or a conventional technique of thiopentone-isoflurane-nitrous oxide-oxygen. Baseline axillary temperature readings, duration of operation and intra-operative decrease in axillary temperature were similar in both groups. The patients who received propofol-nitrous oxide-oxygen anaesthesia had a significantly lower incidence of postanaesthetic shivering than the control group. A propofol-nitrous oxide-oxygen technique may be preferable when postanaesthetic shivering is deemed undesirable.

Treatment of hypothermia in trauma victims: thermodynamic considerations

The relatively high specific heat of the human body makes hypothermia very difficult to treat. Although there are many treatment methods available, most evaluations of rewarming techniques are based on clinically observed rewarming rates, and they do not take into account initial core temperature, ambient temperature, the patient's own heat production, the effects of anesthesia, paralytic agents, and other variables. A heat transfer model is proposed that simulates the flow of heat through the body of a hypothermic patient. The model uses first principles involved in heat transfer and thermodynamics to describe the effects of currently available rewarming techniques. A commercially available routine is used to solve the equations, which also include any heat exchange between the patient's body and the environment, as well as metabolic heat generation as a function of time and core temperature. This thermodynamic analysis of rewarming, based on computer modeling of heat transfer, provides a scientific basis on which to establish guidelines for appropriate selection of treatment strategies for hypothermia, and it indicates that direct blood warming or infusion of warm intravenous fluids are the most effective rewarming techniques.

Effects of a forced-air system (Bair Hugger, OR-type) on intraoperative temperature in patients with open abdominal surgery

Intraoperative hypothermia is difficult to avoid and may present a significant clinical risk during the early postoperative phase. We evaluated a forced-air system [Bair Hugger, OR-type (BH)] for warming intraoperative patients with open abdominal surgery. Twenty patients received BH warming [BH(+) group] and another 20 patients, who served as controls, did not [BH(-) group]. Patients in both groups also received circulating blanket warming. Tempertures were measured at 30-min intervals throughout the operation in the rectum and on the tip of the index finger opposite the nail bed. The average operation time was 168.8±16.2 min. Rectal and fingertip temperatures in the BH(+) group were significantly higher than those in the BH(-) group, and central-peripheral temperature gradients in the BH(+) group were significantly smaller than those in the BH(-) group during the study, except at 180 min. No shivering occurred in either group. Therefore, BH is an effective warming device during open abdominal surgery.

Anesthesia considerations for pediatric cancer

The multidisciplinary approach to the care of children with cancer demands an understanding of all aspects of its treatment. Recognition of potential anatomic and physiologic derangements which may result from specific types of malignancy allows optimal preoperative preparation. Understanding the anesthetic implications of cancer chemotherapy, irradiation and surgery, and the medical complications which result, is essential. The anesthesiologist is involved in critical perioperative issues during surgical resection in the operating room, but just as importantly plays a crucial role in a variety of procedures performed in remote locations. An awareness of special problems related to cancer and its treatment allows optimal anesthesia care while dealing with such issues as radical surgery, organ system failure, acute and chronic pain, and terminal illness.

Hypothermia: one nursing diagnosis or three?

The nursing diagnosis of hypothermia has been described by various authors as having multiple defining characteristics. A major problem identified was a lack of consistency on an exact temperature value for this nursing diagnosis. A review of the literature on hypothermia showed three distinct types of hypothermia: inadvertent, accidental, and intentional. Each of these types were distinguished by etiologies and defining characteristics and are presented using the hypothetic model case approach.

Perioperative complications of anesthesia

An overview of several perioperative complications and their management strategies is presented. Operative hypothermia, malignant hyperthermia, bronchospasm, and side effects of spinal opioid agents are discussed. Ramifications of these complications may extend well beyond the operative period and influence patient outcome. Therefore, it is necessary that the surgeon have a fundamental understanding of the pathophysiology and modalities of treatment in the context of anesthesia and surgery.