Painful Todd's: Post-ictal painful hemiparesis as an identifier of insular epilepsy

The insula can generate seizures which mimic frontal, temporal and parietal epilepsies making electroclinical localization difficult. We report the case of a twenty-one-year-old woman who presented with seizure semiology of a left-sided painful somatosensory aura, progressing to bilateral tonic posturing and complex manual automatisms. She described a painful sensation and weakness affecting her left side following the offset of a seizure, with the pain consistenly outlasting the weakness. This would last from hours to days depending on the severity and duration of the seizure. Stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) demonstrated seizure onset in the limen of the right insula. Extra-operative stimulation of the insula reproduced the clinical symptoms. She underwent radiofrequency thermocoagulation (RFTC) which has resulted in a significant reduction in seizure frequency. This case report describes a lateralized painful Todd's phenomenon as a feature of insular epilepsy confirmed by SEEG and extra-operative stimulation.

[Insular lobe epilepsy. Part 1: semiology]

The insula is often referred to as "the fifth lobe" of the brain, and its accessibility used to be very limited due to the deep location under the opercula as well as the sylvian vasculature. It was not until the availability of modern stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG) technique that the intracranial electrodes could be safely and chronically implanted within the insula, thereby enabling anatomo-electro-clinical correlations in seizures of this deep origin. Since the first report of SEEG-recorded insular seizures in late 1990s, the knowledge of insular lobe epilepsy (ILE) has rapidly expanded. Being on the frontline for the diagnosis and management of epilepsy, neurologists should have a precise understanding of ILE to differentiate it from epilepsies of other lobes or non-epileptic conditions. Owing to the multimodal nature and rich anatomo-functional connections of the insula, ILE has a wide range of clinical presentations. The following symptoms should heighten the suspicion of ILE: somatosensory symptoms involving a large/bilateral cutaneous territory or taking on thermal/painful character, and cervico-laryngeal discomfort. The latter ranges from slight dyspnea to a strong sensation of strangulation (laryngeal constriction). Other symptoms include epigastric discomfort/nausea, hypersalivation, auditory, vestibular, gustatory, and aphasic symptoms. However, most of these insulo-opercular symptoms can easily be masked by those of extra-insular seizure propagation. Indeed, sleep-related hyperkinetic (hypermotor) epilepsy (SHE) is a common clinical presentation of ILE, which shows predominant hyperkinetic and/or tonic-dystonic features that are often indistinguishable from those of fronto-mesial seizures. Subtle objective signs, such as constrictive throat noise (i.e., laryngeal constriction) or aversive behavior (e.g., facial grimacing suggesting pain), are often the sole clue in diagnosing insular SHE. Insular-origin seizures should also be considered in temporal-like seizures without frank anatomo-electro-clinical correlations. All in all, ILE is not the epilepsy of an isolated island but rather of a crucial hub involved in the multifaceted roles of the brain.

Progressive remodeling of structural networks following surgery for operculo-insular epilepsy

Introduction

Operculo-insular epilepsy (OIE) is a rare condition amenable to surgery in well-selected cases. Despite the high rate of neurological complications associated with OIE surgery, most postoperative deficits recover fully and rapidly. We provide insights into this peculiar pattern of functional recovery by investigating the longitudinal reorganization of structural networks after surgery for OIE in 10 patients.

Methods

Structural T1 and diffusion-weighted MRIs were performed before surgery (t0) and at 6 months (t1) and 12 months (t2) postoperatively. These images were processed with an original, comprehensive structural connectivity pipeline. Using our method, we performed comparisons between the t0 and t1 timepoints and between the t1 and t2 timepoints to characterize the progressive structural remodeling.

Results

We found a widespread pattern of postoperative changes primarily in the surgical hemisphere, most of which consisted of reductions in connectivity strength (CS) and regional graph theoretic measures (rGTM) that reflect local connectivity. We also observed increases in CS and rGTMs predominantly in regions located near the resection cavity and in the contralateral healthy hemisphere. Finally, most structural changes arose in the first six months following surgery (i.e., between t0 and t1).

Discussion

To our knowledge, this study provides the first description of postoperative structural connectivity changes following surgery for OIE. The ipsilateral reductions in connectivity unveiled by our analysis may result from the reversal of seizure-related structural alterations following postoperative seizure control. Moreover, the strengthening of connections in peri-resection areas and in the contralateral hemisphere may be compatible with compensatory structural plasticity, a process that could contribute to the recovery of functions seen following operculo-insular resections for focal epilepsy.

Arteries Around the Superior Limiting Sulcus: Motor Complication Avoidance in Insular and Insulo-Opercular Surgery

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Insulo-opercular surgery can cause ischemic motor complications. A source of this is the arteries around the superior limiting sulcus (SLS), which reach the corona radiata, but the detailed anatomy remains unclear. To characterize arteries around the SLS including the long insular arteries (LIAs) and long medullary arteries, we classified them and examined their distribution in relation to the SLS, which helps reduce the risk of ischemia.

METHODS

Twenty adult cadaveric hemispheres were studied. Coronal brain slices were created perpendicular to the SLS representing insular gyri (anterior short, middle short, posterior short, anterior long, and posterior long). The arteries within 10-mm proximity of the SLS that reached the corona radiata were excavated and classified by the entry point.

RESULTS

A total of 122 arteries were identified. Sixty-three (52%), 20 (16%), and 39 (32%) arteries penetrated the insula (LIAs), peak of the SLS, and operculum (long medullary arteries), respectively. 100 and six (87%) arteries penetrated within 5 mm of the peak of the SLS. The arteries were distributed in the anterior short gyrus (19%), middle short gyrus (17%), posterior short gyrus (20%), anterior long gyrus (19%), and posterior long gyrus (25%). Seven arteries (5.7%) had anastomoses after they penetrated the parenchyma.

CONCLUSION

Approximately 90% of the arteries that entered the parenchyma and reached the corona radiata were within a 5-mm radius of the SLS in both the insula and operculum side. This suggests that using the SLS as a landmark during insulo-opercular surgery can decrease the chance of ischemia.

Predictors of outcomes after surgery for medically intractable insular epilepsy: A systematic review and individual participant data meta-analysis

Insular epilepsy (IE) is an increasingly recognized cause of drug-resistant epilepsy amenable to surgery. However, concerns of suboptimal seizure control and permanent neurological morbidity hamper widespread adoption of surgery for IE. We performed a systematic review and individual participant data meta-analysis to determine the efficacy and safety profile of surgery for IE and identify predictors of outcomes. Of 2483 unique citations, 24 retrospective studies reporting on 312 participants were eligible for inclusion. The median follow-up duration was 2.58 years (range, 0-17 years), and 206 (66.7%) patients were seizure-free at last follow-up. Younger age at surgery (≤18 years; HR = 1.70, 95% CI = 1.09-2.66, P = .022) and invasive EEG monitoring (HR = 1.97, 95% CI = 1.04-3.74, P = .039) were significantly associated with shorter time to seizure recurrence. Performing MR-guided laser ablation or radiofrequency ablation instead of open resection (OR = 2.05, 95% CI = 1.08-3.89, P = .028) was independently associated with suboptimal or poor seizure outcome (Engel II-IV) at last follow-up. Postoperative neurological complications occurred in 42.5% of patients, most commonly motor deficits (29.9%). Permanent neurological complications occurred in 7.8% of surgeries, including 5% and 1.4% rate of permanent motor deficits and dysphasia, respectively. Resection of the frontal operculum was independently associated with greater odds of motor deficits (OR = 2.75, 95% CI = 1.46-5.15, P = .002). Dominant-hemisphere resections were independently associated with dysphasia (OR = 13.09, 95% CI = 2.22-77.14, P = .005) albeit none of the observed language deficits were permanent. Surgery for IE is associated with a good efficacy/safety profile. Most patients experience seizure freedom, and neurological deficits are predominantly transient. Pediatric patients and those requiring invasive monitoring or undergoing stereotactic ablation procedures experience lower rates of seizure freedom. Transgression of the frontal operculum should be avoided if it is not deemed part of the epileptogenic zone. Well-selected candidates undergoing dominant-hemisphere resection are more likely to exhibit transient language deficits; however, the risk of permanent deficit is very low.

Insula in epilepsy - "untying the gordian knot": A systematic review

PURPOSE

Despite significant advances in epileptology, there are still many uncertainties about the role of the insula in epilepsy. Until recently, most insular onset seizures were wrongly attributed to the temporal lobe. Further, there are no standardised approaches to the diagnosis and treatment of insular onset seizures. This systematic review gathers the available information about insular epilepsy and synthesizes current knowledge as a basis for future research.

METHOD

Adhering to the PRISMA guidelines, studies were meticulously extracted from the PubMed database. The empirical data pertaining to the semiology of insular seizures, insular networks in epilepsy, techniques of mapping the insula, and the surgical intricacies of non-lesional insular epilepsy were reviewed from published studies. The corpus of information available was then subjected to a process of concise summarization and astute synthesis.

RESULTS

Out of 235 studies identified for full-text review, 86 studies were included in the systematic review. The insula emerges as a brain region with a number of functional subdivisions. The semiology of insular seizures is diverse and depends on the involvement of particular subdivisions. The semiological heterogeneity of insular seizures is explained by the extensive connectivity of the insula and its subdivisions with all four lobes of the brain, deep grey matter structures, and remote brainstem areas. The mainstay of the diagnosis of seizure onset in the insula is stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG). The surgical resection of the insular epileptogenic zone (when possible) is the most effective treatment. Open surgery on the insula is challenging but magnetic resonance-guided laser interstitial thermal therapy (MRgLITT) also holds promise.

CONCLUSION

The physiological and functional roles of the insula in epilepsy have remained obfuscated. The dearth of precisely defined diagnostic and therapeutic protocols acts as an impediment to scientific advancement. This review could potentially facilitate forthcoming research endeavours by establishing a foundational framework for uniform data collection protocols, thereby enhancing the feasibility of comparing findings across future studies and promoting progress in this domain.

Outcome following surgery for insulo-opercular epilepsies

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the clinical outcome in patients with medically refractory epilepsy who had undergone resective or ablative surgery for suspected insulo-opercular epileptogenic foci.

METHODS

The prospectively maintained database of patients undergoing epilepsy surgery was reviewed, and all patients who underwent insulo-opercular surgery for medically refractory epilepsy with a minimum of 12 months of postoperative follow-up were identified, excluding those who had insulo-opercular resection in combination with temporal lobectomy. The presurgical electroclinicoradiological data, stereo-EEG (SEEG) findings, resection/ablation patterns, surgical pathology, postoperative seizure outcome, and neurological complications were analyzed.

RESULTS

Of 407 patients undergoing epilepsy surgery in a 5-year period at the Amrita Advanced Centre for Epilepsy, 24 patients (5.9%) who underwent exclusive insulo-opercular interventions were included in the study. Eleven (46%) underwent surgery on the right side, 12 (50%) on the left side, and the operation was bilateral in 1 (4%). The mean age at surgery was 24.5 ± 12.75 years. Onset of seizures occurred on average at 10.6 ± 9.7 years of life. Characteristic auras were identified in 66% and predominant seizure type was hypermotor (15.4%), automotor (15.4%), hypomotor (11.5%), or a mixed pattern. Seventy-five percent of the seizures recorded on scalp video-EEG occurred during sleep. The 3T MRI results were normal in 12 patients (50%). Direct single-stage surgery was undertaken in 5 patients, and SEEG followed by intervention in 19. Eighteen patients (75%) underwent exclusive resective surgery, 4 (16.7%) underwent exclusive volumetric radiofrequency ablation, and 2 (8.3%) underwent staged radiofrequency ablation and resective surgery. Immediate postoperative neurological deficits occurred in 10/24 (42%), which persisted beyond 12 postoperative months in 3 (12.5%). With a mean follow-up of 25.9 ± 14.6 months, 18 patients (75%) had Engel class I outcome, 3 (12.5%) had Engel class II, and 3 (12.5%) had Engel class III or IV. There was no statistically significant difference in outcomes between MRI-positive versus MRI-negative cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgery for medically refractory epilepsy in insulo-opercular foci is less common and remains a challenge to epilepsy surgery centers. Localization is aided significantly by a careful study of auras and semiology followed by EEG and imaging. The requirement for SEEG is generally high. Satisfactory rates of seizure freedom were achievable independent of the MRI lesional/nonlesional status. Morbidity is higher for insulo-opercular epilepsy surgery compared to other focal epilepsies; hence, the practice and development of minimally invasive strategies for this subgroup of patients undergoing epilepsy surgery is perhaps most important.

Drug resistant epilepsy of the insular lobe: A review and update article

Background:

Epilepsy is a chronic disease that affects millions of people around the world generating great expenses and psychosocial problems burdening the public health in different ways. A considerable number of patients are refractory to the drug treatment requiring a more detailed and specialized investigation to establish the most appropriate therapeutic option. Insular epilepsy is a rare form of focal epilepsy commonly drug resistant and has much of its investigation and treatment involved with the surgical management at some point. The insula or the insular lobe is a portion of the cerebral cortex located in the depth of the lateral sulcus of the brain; its triangular in shape and connects with the other adjacent lobes. The insular lobe is a very interesting and complex portion of the brain related with different functions. Insula in Latin means Island and was initially described in the 18^th century but its relation with epilepsy was first reported in the 1940–1950s. Insular lobe epilepsy is generally difficult to identify and confirm due to its depth and interconnections. Initial non-invasive studies generally demonstrate frustrating or incoherent information about the origin of the ictal event. Technological evolution made this pathology to be progressively better recognized and understood enabling professionals to perform the correct diagnosis and choose the ideal treatment for the affected population.

Methods:

A literature review was performed using MEDLINE/PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science databases. The terms epilepsy/epileptic seizure of the insula and surgical treatment was used in various combinations. We included studies that were published in English, French, or Portuguese; performed in humans with insular epilepsy who underwent some surgical treatment (microsurgery, laser ablation, or radiofrequency thermocoagulation).

Results:

Initial search results in 1267 articles. After removing the duplicates 710 remaining articles were analyzed for titles and abstracts applying the inclusion and exclusion criteria. 70 studies met all inclusion criteria and were selected.

Conclusion:

At present, the main interests and efforts are in the attempt to achieve and standardize the adequate management of the patient with refractory epilepsy of the insular lobe and for that purpose several forms of investigation and treatment were developed. In this paper, we will discuss the characteristics and information regarding the pathology and gather data to identify and choose the best therapeutic option for each case.

Insular Involvement in Cases of Epilepsy Surgery Failure

Background: Epilepsy surgery failure is not uncommon, with several explanations having been proposed. In this series, we detail cases of epilepsy surgery failure subsequently attributed to insular involvement. Methods: We retrospectively identified patients investigated at the epilepsy monitoring units of two Canadian tertiary care centers (2004–2020). Included patients were adults who had undergone epilepsy surgeries with recurrence of seizures post-operatively and who were subsequently determined to have an insular epileptogenic focus. Clinical, electrophysiological, neuroimaging, and surgical data were synthesized. Results: We present 14 patients who demonstrated insular epileptic activity post-surgery-failure as detected by intracranial EEG, MEG, or seizure improvement after insular resection. Seven patients had manifestations evoking possible insular involvement prior to their first surgery. Most patients (8/14) had initial surgeries targeting the temporal lobe. Seizure recurrence ranged from the immediate post-operative period to one year. The main modality used to determine insular involvement was MEG (8/14). Nine patients underwent re-operations that included insular resection; seven achieved a favorable post-operative outcome (Engel I or II). Conclusions: Our series suggests that lowering the threshold for suspecting insular epilepsy may be necessary to improve epilepsy surgery outcomes. Detecting insular epilepsy post-surgery-failure may allow for re-operations which may lead to good outcomes.

Knowledge Atlas of Insular Epilepsy: A Bibliometric Analysis

OBJECTIVE

In order to determine research hotspots and prospective directions, this work used VOSviewer and CiteSpace to assess the current state of insular epilepsy research.

METHODS

We looked for pertinent research about insular epilepsy published between the first of January 2000 and the thirtieth of April 2022 in the Web of Science Core Collection (WoSCC) database. CiteSpace and VOSviewer were used to build a knowledge atlas by analyzing authors, institutions, countries, keywords with citation bursts, keyword clustering, keyword co-occurrence, publishing journals, reference co-citation patterns, and other factors.

RESULTS

A total of 305 publications on insular epilepsy were found. Nguyen DK had the most articles published (37), whereas Mauguière F and Isnard J had the highest average number of citations/publications (39.37 and 38.09, respectively). The leading countries and institutions in this field were the United States (82 papers) and Université de Montréal (40 papers). Authors, countries, and institutions appear to be actively collaborating. Hot topics and research frontiers included surgical treatment, functional network connectivity, and the application of neuroimaging methods to study insular epilepsy.

CONCLUSION

In summary, the most influential articles, authors, journals, organizations, and countries on the subject of insular epilepsy were determined by this analysis. This study investigated the area of insular epilepsy research and forecasted upcoming trends using co-occurrence and evolution methods.

Ictal semiology of epileptic seizures with insulo-opercular genesis

Objective

Epileptic seizures with insular genesis are often difficult to distinguish from those originating in the temporal lobe due to their complex and variable semiology. Here, we analyzed differentiating characteristics in the clinical spectrum of insulo-opercular seizures.

Methods

Ictal semiology in patients with a diagnosis of insulo-opercular epilepsy (IOE) based on imaging of epileptogenic lesions or electrophysiological evidence of an insulo-opercular seizure origin was retrospectively analyzed and compared to age-matched controls with mesial temporal lobe epilepsy (MTE).

Results

Forty-six IOE and 46 matched MTE patients were included. The most prominent ictal features in IOE were focal motor phenomena in 80.4% of these patients. Somatosensory sensations, version, tonic and clonic features, when present, were more frequent contralateral to the SOZ in MTE patients, while they occurred about equally often ipsilateral and contralateral to the SOZ in IOE patients. Ipsilateral manual automatisms were significantly more frequent in MTE patients than in IOE (p = 0.010). Multivariate analysis correctly identified IOE in 78.3% and MTE in 84.8% using five semiologic features (Chi-square = 53.79 with 5 degrees of freedom, p < 0.0001). A subanalysis comparing patients with purely insular lesions with MTE patients using only the earliest ictal signs showed that somatosensory sensations are significantly more frequent in insular epilepsy (p = 0.010), while automatisms were significantly more frequent in MTE patients (p = 0.06).

Significance

Our study represents the first in-depth analysis of ictal semiology in IOE compared to MTE. Use of these differentiating characteristics can serve for a correct syndrome classification and to steer appropriate diagnostic and local therapeutic procedures.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00415-021-10911-0.

Safety of an operculoinsulectomy in the language-dominant hemisphere for refractory epilepsy

BACKGROUND

Operculoinsular cortectomy is increasingly recognized as a therapeutic avenue for perisylvian refractory epilepsy. However, most neurosurgeons are reluctant to perform this type of procedure because of feared neurological complications, especially in the language-dominant hemisphere, as the insula is involved in speech and language processes. The goal of this retrospective study is to quantify the incidence and types of speech and language deficits associated with operculoinsulectomies in the dominant hemisphere for language, and to identify factors associated with these complications.

METHODS

Clinical, imaging, and surgical data of all patients who had an operculoinsulectomy for refractory epilepsy at our center between 1998 and 2018 were reviewed. Language lateralization was determined by functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) and/or Wada test. Speech and language assessments were carried out by neurosurgeons, neurologists, neuropsychologists and/or speech language pathologists, before surgery, during the first week after surgery, and at least 6 months after surgery.

RESULTS

Amongst 44 operculoinsulectomies, 13 were performed in the language-dominant hemisphere. 46% of these patients presented with transient aphasia post-surgery. However, a few months later, the patients' performances on language assessments were not statistically different from before surgery, thus suggesting a complete recovery of speech and language functions.

CONCLUSION

Temporary aphasias after operculoinsulectomy for refractory epilepsy in the language-dominant hemisphere are frequent, but eventually subside. Potential mechanisms underlying this recovery are discussed.

Intracranial EEG and laser interstitial thermal therapy in MRI-negative insular and/or cingulate epilepsy: case series

OBJECTIVE

The goal of this study was to assess the success rate and complications of stereo-electroencephalogra-phy (sEEG) and laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT) in the treatment of nonlesional refractory epilepsy in cingulate and insular cortex.

METHODS

The authors retrospectively analyzed the treatment response in 9 successive patients who underwent insular or cingulate LITT for nonlesional refractory epilepsy at their center between 2011 and 2019. Localization of seizures was based on inpatient video-EEG monitoring, neuropsychological testing, 3-T MRI, PET scan, magnetoencephalography scan, and/or ictal SPECT scan. Eight patients underwent sEEG, and 1 patient had implantation of both sEEG electrodes and subdural grids for localization of epileptogenic zones. LITT was performed in 5 insular cases (4 left and 1 right) and 3 cingulate cases (all left-sided). One patient also underwent both insular and cingulate LITT on the left side. All of the patients who underwent insular LITT as well as 2 of the 3 who underwent cingulate LITT were right-hand dominant. The patient who underwent insular plus cingulate LITT was also right-hand dominant.

RESULTS

Following LITT, 67% of the patients were seizure free (Engel class I) at follow-up (mean 1.35 years, range 0.6-2.8 years). All patients responded favorably to treatment (Engel class I-III). Two patients developed small intracranial hemorrhages during the sEEG implantation that did not require surgical management. One patient developed a large intracranial hemorrhage during an insular LITT procedure that did require surgical management. That patient experienced aphasia, incoordination, and hemiparesis, which resolved with inpatient rehabilitation. No permanent neurological deficits were noted in any of the patients at last follow-up. Neuropsychological status was stable in this cohort before and after LITT.

CONCLUSIONS

sEEG can be safely used to localize seizures originating from insular and cingulate cortex. LITT can successfully treat seizures arising from these deep-seated structures. The insula and cingulum should be evaluated more frequently for seizure onset zones.

Insular epilepsy surgery: lessons learned from institutional review and patient-level meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Insular lobe epilepsy is a challenging condition to diagnose and treat. Due to anatomical intricacy and proximity to eloquent brain regions, resection of epileptic foci in that region can be associated with significant postoperative morbidity. The aim of this study was to review available evidence on postoperative outcomes following insular epilepsy surgery.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search (PubMed/MEDLINE, Scopus, Cochrane) was conducted for studies investigating the postoperative outcomes for seizures originating in the insula. Seizure freedom at last follow-up (at least 12 months) comprised the primary endpoint. The authors also present their institutional experience with 8 patients (4 pediatric, 4 adult).

RESULTS

A total of 19 studies with 204 cases (90 pediatric, 114 adult) were identified. The median age at surgery was 23 years, and 48% were males. The median epilepsy duration was 8 years, and 17% of patients had undergone prior epilepsy surgery. Epilepsy was lesional in 67%. The most common approach was transsylvian (60%). The most commonly resected area was the anterior insular region (n = 42, 21%), whereas radical insulectomy was performed in 13% of cases (n = 27). The most common pathology was cortical dysplasia (n = 68, 51%), followed by low-grade neoplasm (n = 16, 12%). In the literature, seizure freedom was noted in 60% of pediatric and 69% of adult patients at a median follow-up of 29 months (75% and 50%, respectively, in the current series). A neurological deficit occurred in 43% of cases (10% permanent), with extremity paresis comprising the most common deficit (n = 35, 21%), followed by facial paresis (n = 32, 19%). Language deficits were more common in left-sided approaches (24% vs 2%, p < 0.001). Univariate analysis for seizure freedom revealed a significantly higher proportion of patients with lesional epilepsy among those with at least 12 months of follow-up (77% vs 59%, p = 0.032).

CONCLUSIONS

These findings may serve as a benchmark when tailoring decision-making for insular epilepsy, and may assist surgeons in their preoperative discussions with patients. Although seizure freedom rates are quite high with insular epilepsy treatment, the associated morbidity needs to be weighed against the potential for seizure freedom.

Structural Connectivity Alterations in Operculo-Insular Epilepsy

Operculo-insular epilepsy (OIE) is an under-recognized condition that can mimic temporal and extratemporal epilepsies. Previous studies have revealed structural connectivity changes in the epileptic network of focal epilepsy. However, most reports use the debated streamline-count to quantify ‘connectivity strength’ and rely on standard tracking algorithms. We propose a sophisticated cutting-edge method that is robust to crossing fibers, optimizes cortical coverage, and assigns an accurate microstructure-reflecting quantitative conectivity marker, namely the COMMIT (Convex Optimization Modeling for Microstructure Informed Tractography)-weight. Using our pipeline, we report the connectivity alterations in OIE. COMMIT-weighted matrices were created in all participants (nine patients with OIE, eight patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), and 22 healthy controls (HC)). In the OIE group, widespread increases in ‘connectivity strength’ were observed bilaterally. In OIE patients, ‘hyperconnections’ were observed between the insula and the pregenual cingulate gyrus (OIE group vs. HC group) and between insular subregions (OIE vs. TLE). Graph theoretic analyses revealed higher connectivity within insular subregions of OIE patients (OIE vs. TLE). We reveal, for the first time, the structural connectivity distribution in OIE. The observed pattern of connectivity in OIE likely reflects a diffuse epileptic network incorporating insular-connected regions and may represent a structural signature and diagnostic biomarker.

Epileptogenic Network Formation

Epilepsy is characterized by specific alterations in network organization. The main parameters at the basis of epileptogenic network formation are alterations of cortical thickness, development of pathologic hubs, modification of hub distribution, and white matter alterations. The effect is a reinforcement of brain connectivity in both the epileptogenic zone and the propagation zone. Moreover, the epileptogenic network is characterized by some specific neurophysiologic biomarkers that evidence the tendency of the network itself to shift from an interictal state to an ictal one. The recognition of these features is crucial in planning epilepsy surgery.

Insular seizures and epilepsies: Ictal semiology and minimal invasive surgery

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The increased identification of seizures with insular ictal onset, promoted by the international development of stereo-electroencephalography (SEEG), has led to the recent description of larger cohorts of patients with insular or insulo-opercular epilepsies than those previously available. These new series have consolidated and extended our knowledge of the rich ictal semiology and diverse anatomo-clinical correlations that characterized insular seizures. In parallel, some experiences have been gained in the surgical treatment of insular epilepsies using minimal invasive procedures.

RECENT FINDINGS

The large majority of patients present with auras (mostly somatosensory and laryngeal) and motor signs (predominantly elementary and orofacial), an underlying focal cortical dysplasia, and an excellent postoperative seizure outcome. Many other subjective and objective ictal signs, known to occur in other forms of epilepsies, are also observed and clustered in five patterns, reflecting the functional anatomy of the insula and its overlying opercula, as well as preferential propagation pathways to frontal or temporal brain regions. A nocturnal predominance of seizure is frequently reported, whereas secondary generalization is infrequent. Some rare ictal signs are highly suggestive of an insular origin, including somatic pain, reflex seizures, choking spells, and vomiting. Minimal invasive surgical techniques have been applied to the treatment of insular epilepsies, including Magnetic Resonance Imaging-guided laser ablation (laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT)), radiofrequency thermocoagulation (RFTC), gamma knife radiosurgery, and responsive neurostimulation. Rates of seizure freedom (about 50%) appear lower than that reported with open-surgery (about 80%) with yet a significant proportion of transient neurological deficit for LITT and RFTC.

SUMMARY

Significant progress has been made in the identification and surgical treatment of insular and insulo-opercular epilepsies, including more precise anatomo-clinical correlations to optimally plan SEEG investigations, and experience in using minimal invasive surgery to reduce peri-operative morbidity.

Aberrant Metabolic Patterns Networks in Insular Epilepsy

Introduction: Insular epilepsy is clinically challenging. This study aimed to map cerebral metabolic networks in insular epilepsy and investigate their graph-theoretic properties, with the goal of elucidating altered metabolic network architectures that underlie interictal hypometabolism.

Aims: Fluorine-18-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (¹⁸F-FDG-PET) imaging was performed in 17 individuals with a stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) confirmed diagnosis of insula epilepsy and 14 age- and sex-matched healthy comparison individuals. Metabolic covariance networks were mapped for each group and graph theoretical analyses of these networks were undertaken. For each pair of regions comprising a whole-brain parcellation, regionally-averaged FDG uptake values were correlated across individuals to estimate connection weights.

Results: Correlation in regionally-averaged FDG uptake values in the insular epilepsy group was substantially increased for several pairs of regions compared to the healthy comparison group, particularly for the opercular cortex and subcortical structures. This effect was less prominent in brainstem structures. Metabolic covariance networks in the epilepsy group showed reduced small-worldness as well as altered nodal properties in the ipsilateral hemisphere, compared to the healthy comparison group.

Conclusions: Cerebral glucose metabolism in insular epilepsy is marked by a lack of normal regional heterogeneity in metabolic patterns, resulting in metabolic covariance networks that are more tightly coupled between regions than healthy comparison individuals. Metabolic networks in insular epilepsy exhibit altered topological properties and evidence of potentially compensatory formation of aberrant local connections. Taken together, these results demonstrate that insular epilepsy is a systemic neurological disorder with widespread disruption to cerebral metabolic networks.

Cognitive and developmental outcomes after pediatric insular epilepsy surgery for focal cortical dysplasia

OBJECTIVE

Cognitive risk associated with insular cortex resection is not well understood. The authors reviewed cognitive and developmental outcomes in pediatric patients who underwent resection of the epileptogenic zone involving the insula.

METHODS

A review was conducted of 15 patients who underwent resective epilepsy surgery involving the insular cortex for focal cortical dysplasia, with a minimum follow-up of 12 months. The median age at surgery was 5.6 years (range 0.3-13.6 years). Developmental/intelligence quotient (DQ/IQ) scores were evaluated before surgery, within 4 months after surgery, and at 12 months or more after surgery. Repeated measures multivariate ANOVA was used to evaluate the effects on outcomes of the within-subject factor (time) and between-subject factors (resection side, anterior insular resection, seizure control, and antiepileptic drug [AED] reduction).

RESULTS

The mean preoperative DQ/IQ score was 60.7 ± 22.8. Left-side resection and anterior insular resection were performed in 9 patients each. Favorable seizure control (International League Against Epilepsy class 1-3) was achieved in 8 patients. Postoperative motor deficits were observed in 9 patients (permanent in 6, transient in 3). Within-subject changes in DQ/IQ were not significantly affected by insular resection (p = 0.13). Postoperative changes in DQ/IQ were not significantly affected by surgical side, anterior insular resection, AED reduction, or seizure outcome. Only verbal function showed no significant changes before and after surgery and no significant effects of within-subject factors.

CONCLUSIONS

Resection involving the insula in children with impaired development or intelligence can be performed without significant reduction in DQ/IQ, but carries the risk of postoperative motor deficits.

Operculoinsular cortectomy for refractory epilepsy. Part 1: Is it effective?

OBJECTIVE

Patients with refractory epilepsy of operculoinsular origin are often denied potentially effective surgical treatment with operculoinsular cortectomy (also termed operculoinsulectomy) because of feared complications and the paucity of surgical series with a significant number of cases documenting seizure control outcome. The goal of this study was to document seizure control outcome after operculoinsular cortectomy in a group of patients investigated and treated by an epilepsy team with 20 years of experience with this specific technique.

METHODS

Clinical, imaging, surgical, and seizure control outcome data of all patients who underwent surgery for refractory epilepsy requiring an operculoinsular cortectomy were retrospectively reviewed. Tumors and progressive encephalitis cases were excluded. Descriptive and uni- and multivariate analyses were done to determine seizure control outcome and predictors.

RESULTS

Forty-three patients with 44 operculoinsular cortectomies were studied. Kaplan-Meier estimates of complete seizure freedom (first seizure recurrence excluding auras) for years 0.5, 1, 2, and 5 were 70.2%, 70.2%, 65.0%, and 65.0%, respectively. With patients with more than 1 year of follow-up, seizure control outcome Engel class I was achieved in 76.9% (mean follow-up duration 5.8 years; range 1.25-20 years). With multivariate analysis, unfavorable seizure outcome predictors were frontal lobe-like seizure semiology, shorter duration of epilepsy, and the use of intracranial electrodes for invasive monitoring. Suspected causes of recurrent seizures were sparing of the language cortex part of the focus, subtotal resection of cortical dysplasia/polymicrogyria, bilateral epilepsy, and residual epileptic cortex with normal preoperative MRI studies (insula, frontal lobe, posterior parieto-temporal, orbitofrontal).

CONCLUSIONS

The surgical treatment of operculoinsular refractory epilepsy is as effective as epilepsy surgeries in other brain areas. These patients should be referred to centers with appropriate experience. A frontal lobe-like seizure semiology should command more sampling with invasive monitoring. Recordings with intracranial electrodes are not always required if the noninvasive investigation is conclusive. The complete resection of the epileptic zone is crucial to achieve good seizure control outcome.

Operculoinsular cortectomy for refractory epilepsy. Part 2: Is it safe?

OBJECTIVE

Operculoinsular cortectomy (also termed operculoinsulectomy) is increasingly recognized as a therapeutic option for perisylvian refractory epilepsy. However, most neurosurgeons are reluctant to perform the technique because of previously experienced or feared neurological complications. The goal of this study was to quantify the incidence of basic neurological complications (loss of primary nonneuropsychological functions) associated with operculoinsular cortectomies for refractory epilepsy, and to identify factors predicting these complications.

METHODS

Clinical, imaging, and surgical data of all patients investigated and surgically treated by our team for refractory epilepsy requiring an operculoinsular cortectomy were retrospectively reviewed. Patients with tumors and encephalitis were excluded. Logistic regression analysis was used for uni- and multivariate statistical analyses.

RESULTS

Forty-four operculoinsular cortectomies were performed in 43 patients. Although postoperative neurological deficits were frequent (54.5% of procedures), only 3 procedures were associated with a permanent significant neurological deficit. Out of the 3 permanent deficits, only 1 (2.3%; a sensorimotor hemisyndrome) was related to the technique of operculoinsular cortectomy (injury to a middle cerebral artery branch), while the other 2 (arm hypoesthesia and hemianopia) were attributed to cortical resection beyond the operculoinsular area. With multivariate analysis, a postoperative neurological deficit was associated with preoperative insular hypometabolism on PET scan. Postoperative motor deficit (29.6% of procedures) was correlated with fewer years of neurosurgical experience and frontal operculectomies, but not with corona radiata ischemic lesions. Ischemic lesions in the posterior two-thirds of the corona radiata (40.9% of procedures) were associated with parietal operculectomies, but not with posterior insulectomies.

CONCLUSIONS

Operculoinsular cortectomy for refractory epilepsy is a relatively safe therapeutic option but temporary neurological deficits after surgery are frequent. This study highlights the role of frontal/parietal opercula resections in postoperative complications. Corona radiata ischemic lesions are not clearly related to motor deficits. There were no obvious permanent neurological consequences of losing a part of an epileptic insula, including on the dominant side for language. A low complication rate can be achieved if the following conditions are met: 1) microsurgical technique is applied to spare cortical branches of the middle cerebral artery; 2) the resection of an opercula is done only if the opercula is part of the epileptic focus; and 3) the neurosurgeon involved has proper training and experience.

Indications, Techniques, and Outcomes of Robot-Assisted Insular Stereo-Electro-Encephalography: A Review

Stereo-electro-encephalography (SEEG) is an invasive, surgical, and electrophysiological method for three-dimensional registration and mapping of seizure activity in drug-resistant epilepsy. It allows the accurate analysis of spatio-temporal seizure activity by multiple intraparenchymal depth electrodes. The technique requires rigorous non-invasive pre-SEEG evaluation (clinical, video-EEG, and neuroimaging investigations) in order to plan the insertion of the SEEG electrodes with minimal risk and maximal recording accuracy. The resulting recordings are used to precisely define the surgical limits of resection of the epileptogenic zone in relation to adjacent eloquent structures. Since the initial description of the technique by Talairach and Bancaud in the 1950's, several techniques of electrode insertion have been used with accuracy and relatively few complications. In the last decade, robot-assisted surgery has emerged as a safe, accurate, and time-saving electrode insertion technique due to its unparalleled potential for orthogonal and oblique insertion trajectories, guided by rigorous computer-assisted planning. SEEG exploration of the insular cortex remains difficult due to its anatomical location, hidden by the temporal and frontoparietal opercula. Furthermore, the close vicinity of Sylvian vessels makes surgical electrode insertion challenging. Some epilepsy surgery teams remain cautious about insular exploration due to the potential of neurovascular injury. However, several authors have published encouraging results regarding the technique's accuracy and safety in both children and adults. We will review the indications, techniques, and outcomes of insular SEEG exploration with emphasis on robot-assisted implantation.

Anatomoelectroclinical features of SEEG-confirmed pure insular-onset epilepsy

PURPOSE

In this study, we aimed to improve our knowledge of insular epilepsy by studying anatomoelectroclinical correlations in pure insular-onset epilepsy and characterizing differences between anterior and posterior insular-onset seizures.

METHODS

Patients in whom seizure-onset zone was confined to the insula and peri-insular sulcus were selected from 301 consecutive presurgical stereo-electroencephalography (EEG) recordings performed between years 2010 and 2017 in two epilepsy centers. Ictal-onset zone in stereo-EEG was delineated visually and quantitatively using epileptogenic index method. Seizure characteristics were reanalyzed, and anatomoelectroclinical correlations were assessed. Characteristics of posterior and anterior insular-onset seizures were compared.

RESULTS

Eleven insular cases were identified, five of them with an anterior insular seizure onset and six with a posterior one. Nonpainful somatosensory symptoms and autonomic symptoms were the most common symptoms (73% of patients) followed by speech-related symptoms (55%) and ipsilateral eye blinking (45%). Six patients had seizures restricted to somatosensory or viscerosensory symptoms. In all patients, seizures progressed to motor symptoms. Somatosensory symptoms did not differentiate anterior from posterior insular seizures. However, hyperkinetic signs, speech modifications, and viscerosensory symptoms were related to an anterior insular seizure-onset zone. Pain, asymmetric tonic, focal clonic, and tonic symptoms were more frequent in patients with a posterior insular seizure onset.

CONCLUSIONS

Seizure semiology is heterogeneous in pure insular-onset epilepsy. Differences between the anterior and posterior insular seizures reflect the functional organization of the insula. Particularly, the different types of motor symptoms may help to distinguish anterior from posterior insular seizure onset.

Open Resection versus Laser Interstitial Thermal Therapy for the Treatment of Pediatric Insular Epilepsy

BACKGROUND

Various studies suggest that the insular cortex may play an underappreciated role in pediatric frontotemporal/parietal epilepsy. Here, we report on the postsurgical outcomes in 26 pediatric patients with confirmed insular involvement by depth electrode monitoring.

OBJECTIVE

To describe one of the largest series of pediatric patients with medically refractory epilepsy undergoing laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT) or surgical resection of at least some portion of the insular cortex.

METHODS

Pediatric patients in whom invasive insular sampling confirmed insular involvement and who subsequently underwent a second stage surgery (LITT or open resection) were included. Complications and Engel Class outcomes at least 1 yr postsurgery were compiled as well as pathology results in the open surgical cases.

RESULTS

The average age in our cohort was 10.3 yr, 58% were male, and the average length of follow-up was 2.43 ± 0.20 (SEM) yr. A total of 14 patients underwent LITT, whereas 12 patients underwent open resection. Complications in patients undergoing either LITT or open resection were mostly minimal and generally transient. Forty-three percent of patients who underwent LITT were Engel Class I, compared to 50% of patients who underwent open insular resection.

CONCLUSION

Both surgical resection and LITT are valid management options in the treatment of medically refractory insular/opercular epilepsy in children. Although LITT may be a less invasive alternative to craniotomy, further studies are needed to determine its noninferiority in terms of complication rates and seizure freedom, especially in cases of cortical dysplasia that may involve extensive regions of the brain.

Stereo-EEG exploration in the insula/operculum in paediatric patients with refractory epilepsy

PURPOSE

Failure to recognise involvement of the insula / opercula (I/O) region is associated with poor outcome in epilepsy surgery. Recognition is challenging due to high connectivity with adjacent structures resulting in variable and misleading semiology, often subjective and therefore likely to be underreported by children. In this study we explored prevalence and characteristics of I/O involvement in paediatric patients undergoing sEEG exploration.

METHOD

We retrospectively included all consecutive patients undergoing sEEG at our centre between 11/2014 and 01/2018 with at least three contacts within I/O and excluded those with undetermined seizure onset zone (SOZ) by sEEG. We divided patients into three groups: 1) SOZ in I/O, 2) spread to I/O and 3) no I/O involvement. We compared pre-invasive characteristics, sEEG results, surgery and outcome for each group.

RESULTS

29 of all 53 consecutive patients had an identified SOZ by sEEG and at least three contacts within the I/O and were included. 41% had I/O SOZ, 38% had I/O spread and 21% had no I/O involvement. Insula associated symptoms described in adult literature were not statistically different between the three groups. Complications due to sEEG were low (2 of 53 patients). Following I/O surgery, 63% were seizure free while an additional 26% of patients achieved seizure reduction. Postoperative deficits were seen in 75% of the patients but completely resolved in all but one patient.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggest an important role of the I/O region with frequent onset or propagation to the I/O region (at least 64% of all 53 sEEG cases). Semiology appears less specific than in adults. Insula depth electrode insertion is safe with subsequent good surgical outcomes albeit common transient deficits.

Patient phenotypes and clinical outcomes in invasive monitoring for epilepsy: An individual patient data meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Invasive monitoring provides valuable clinical information in patients with drug-resistant epilepsy (DRE). However, there is no clear evidence indicating either stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) or subdural electrodes (SDE) as the optimal method. Our goal was to examine differences in postresection seizure freedom rates between SEEG- and SDE-informed resective epilepsy surgeries. Additionally, we aimed to determine potential clinical indicators for SEEG or SDE monitoring in patients with drug-resistant epilepsy.

METHODS

A systematic literature review was performed in which we searched for primary articles using keywords such as "electroencephalography", "intracranial grid", and "epilepsy." Only studies containing individual patient data (IPD) were included for analysis. A one-stage IPD meta-analysis was performed to determine differences in rates of seizure freedom (International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) guidelines and Engel classification) and resection status between SEEG and SDE patients. A Cox proportional-hazards regression was performed to determine the effect of time on seizure freedom status. Additionally, a principal component analysis was performed to investigate primary drivers of variance between these two groups.

RESULTS

This IPD meta-analysis compared differences between SEEG and SDE invasive monitoring techniques in 595 patients from 33 studies. Our results demonstrate that while there was no difference in seizure freedom rates regardless of resection (p = 0.0565), SEEG was associated with a lower rate of resection compared with SDE (82.00% SEEG, 92.74% SDE, p = 0.0002). Additionally, while SDE was associated with a higher rate of postresection seizure freedom (54.04% SEEG, 64.32% SDE, p = 0.0247), the difference between seizure freedom rates following SEEG- or SDE-informed resection decreased with long-term follow-up. A principal component analysis showed that cases resulting in SEEG were associated with lower risk of morbidity than SDE cases, which were strongly collinear with multiple subpial transections, anterior temporal lobectomy, amygdalectomy, and hippocampectomy.

SIGNIFICANCE

In this IPD meta-analysis of SEEG and SDE invasive monitoring techniques, SEEG and SDE were associated with similar rates of seizure freedom at latest follow-up. The former was associated with lower rates of resection. Furthermore, the clinical phenotypes of patients undergoing SEEG monitoring was associated with lower rates of complications. Future long-term prospective registries of IPD are promising options for clarifying the differences in these intracranial monitoring techniques as well as the unique patient phenotypes that may be associated with their indication.

A Rare Case of Insular Epilepsy: Not To Be Missed in Refractory Epilepsy Patients

Insular epilepsy often goes under-recognized and misdiagnosed due to the similarity of its features with temporal lobe epilepsy and the common exclusion of the insula during intracranial electroencephalography (iEEG). Here, we present a case of medically refractory epilepsy in a 43-year-old male with a 12-year history of tonic-clonic seizures. Insular epilepsy cases are often considered for diagnosis in the setting of abnormal insular pathology, such as a low-grade central nervous system (CNS) lesion. This is a unique case of non-lesional insular epilepsy, successfully managed by the resection of the insular cortex.

Microneuroanatomy of the Anterior Frontal Laser Trajectory to the Insula

BACKGROUND

Magnetic resonance imaging-guided laser interstitial thermal therapy (LITT) is an emerging minimally invasive procedure for the treatment of deep intracranial lesions. Insular lesions are challenging to treat because of the risk of damaging important surrounding structures. The precise knowledge of the neural structures that are at risk along the trajectory and during the ablation is essential to reduce associated complications. This study aims to describe the relevant anatomy of the anterior frontal LITT trajectory to the insular region by using sectional anatomy and fiber dissection technique.

METHODS

Three silicone-injected cadaveric heads were used to implant laser catheters bilaterally to the insular region by using a frameless stereotactic technique from a frontal approach. Sections were cut in both the oblique axial plane parallel to the trajectory and in the coronal plane. White matter fiber dissections were used to establish the tracts related to the laser trajectory from lateral to medial and medial to lateral.

RESULTS

Supraorbital regions were selected as entry points. After crossing the frontal bone, the track intersected the inferior frontal lobe. The catheter was illustrated reaching the insular region medial to the inferior fronto-occipital fasciculus and insular cortex, and superior to the uncinate fasciculus. The uncinate fasciculus, extreme capsule, claustrum, external capsule, and putamen were traversed, preserving the major vascular structures.

CONCLUSIONS

Independent of the insular area treated, an understanding of the neuroanatomy related to the anterior frontal laser trajectory is essential to improve the ability to perform LITT of this challenging region.

Electroclinical features of insulo-opercular epilepsy: an SEEG and PET study

Objective

To report clinical experience with presurgical evaluation in patients with insulo‐opercular epilepsy. Quantitative analysis on PET imaging and stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) signals was used to summarize their electroclinical features.

Methods

Twenty‐two patients with focal epilepsy arising from the insular and/or opercular cortex according to SEEG were retrospectively analyzed. Presurgical noninvasive data were analyzed in detail. Interictal PET data of patients were then statistically compared with those of healthy controls to identify the interictal hypometabolic network. The epileptogenicity index (EI) of ictal SEEG signal was computed to identify areas of spread at the beginning of seizure onset.

Results

Focal tonic seizures of the face and/or neck (16/22, 73%) were the most prevalent early objective signs. Epileptic discharges in the interictal and ictal scalp‐EEG mostly showed an ipsilateral perisylvian distribution. Statistical analysis of interictal PET showed significant hypometabolism in the insular lobe, central operculum, supplementary motor area, middle cingulate cortex, bilateral caudate nuclei, and putamen. According to the EI analysis, insulo‐opercular epilepsy could be classified as insulo‐opercular epilepsy (50%), opercular epilepsy (41%), and insular cortex epilepsy (9%).

Significance

Clinical diagnosis of insulo‐opercular epilepsy is challenging because of its complex seizure semiology and nonlocalizing discharges on scalp‐EEG. A common hypometabolic network involving the insulo‐opercular cortex, mesial frontal cortex and subcortical nuclei may be involved in the organization of the insulo‐opercular epilepsy network. Furthermore, quantified SEEG analysis suggested that pure insular epilepsy is rare, and the close connection between insular and opercular cortex necessitates SEEG implantation to define the epileptogenic zone.

The Insula and Its Epilepsies

Insular seizures are great mimickers of seizures originating elsewhere in the brain. The insula is a highly connected brain structure. Seizures may only become clinically evident after ictal activity propagates out of the insula with semiology that reflects the propagation pattern. Insular seizures with perisylvian spread, for example, manifest first as throat constriction, followed next by perioral and hemisensory symptoms, and then by unilateral motor symptoms. On the other hand, insular seizures may spread instead to the temporal and frontal lobes and present like seizures originating from these regions. Due to the location of the insula deep in the brain, interictal and ictal scalp electroencephalogram (EEG) changes can be variable and misleading. Magnetic resonance imaging, magnetic resonance spectroscopy, magnetoencephalography, positron emission tomography, and single-photon computed tomography imaging may assist in establishing a diagnosis of insular epilepsy. Intracranial EEG recordings from within the insula, using stereo-EEG or depth electrode techniques, can prove insular seizure origin. Seizure onset, most commonly seen as low-voltage, fast gamma activity, however, can be highly localized and easily missed if the insula is only sparsely sampled. Moreover, seizure spread to the contralateral insula and other brain regions may occur rapidly. Extensive sampling of the insula with multiple electrode trajectories is necessary to avoid these pitfalls. Understanding the functional organization of the insula is helpful when interpreting the semiology produced by insular seizures. Electrical stimulation mapping around the central sulcus of the insula results in paresthesias, while stimulation of the posterior insula typically produces painful sensations. Visceral sensations are the next most common result of insular stimulation. Treatment of insular epilepsy is evolving, but poses challenges. Surgical resections of the insula are effective but risk significant morbidity if not carefully planned. Neurostimulation is an emerging option for treatment, especially for seizures with onset in the posterior insula. The close association of the insula with marked autonomic changes has led to interest in the role of the insula in sudden unexpected death in epilepsy and warrants additional study with larger patient cohorts.

Stereoelectroencephalography Versus Subdural Electrodes for Localization of the Epileptogenic Zone: What Is the Evidence?

Accurate and safe localization of epileptic foci is the crux of surgical therapy for focal epilepsy. As an initial evaluation, patients with drug-resistant epilepsy often undergo evaluation by noninvasive methods to identify the epileptic focus (i.e., the epileptogenic zone (EZ)). When there is incongruence of noninvasive neuroimaging, electroencephalographic, and clinical data, direct intracranial recordings of the brain are often necessary to delineate the EZ and determine the best course of treatment. Stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) and subdural electrodes (SDEs) are the 2 most common methods for recording directly from the cortex to delineate the EZ. For the past several decades, SEEG and SDEs have been used almost exclusively in specific geographic regions (i.e., France and Italy for stereo-EEG and elsewhere for SDEs) for virtually the same indications. In the last decade, however, stereo-EEG has started to spread from select centers in Europe to many locations worldwide. Nevertheless, it is still not the preferred method for invasive localization of the EZ at many centers that continue to employ SDEs exclusively. Despite the increased dissemination of the SEEG method throughout the globe, important questions remain unanswered. Which method (SEEG or SDEs) is superior for identification of the EZ and does it depend on the etiology of epilepsy? Which technique is safer and does this hold for all patient populations? Should these 2 methods have equivalent indications or be used selectively for different focal epilepsies? In this review, we seek to address these questions using current invasive monitoring literature. Available meta-analyses of observational data suggest that SEEG is safer than SDEs, but it is less clear from available data which method is more accurate at delineating the EZ.

Stereotactic laser ablation for nonlesional cingulate epilepsy: case report

Stereotactic laser ablation (SLA) is being increasingly used to treat refractory focal epilepsy, especially mesial temporal lobe epilepsy. However, emerging evidence suggests it can be used for extratemporal lobe epilepsy as well.The authors report the case of a 17-year-old male who presented with refractory nocturnal seizures characterized by bilateral arms stiffening or rhythmic jerking lasting several seconds. Semiology suggested an epileptogenic zone close to one of the supplementary sensory motor areas. Electroencephalography showed seizures arising from the central region without consistent lateralization. Brain imaging showed no abnormality. An invasive evaluation using bilateral stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) was utilized in 2 steps, first to establish the laterality of seizures, and second to further cover the mesial cingulate region of the right hemisphere. Seizures arose from the middle portion of the right cingulate gyrus. Extraoperative electrical mapping revealed that the seizure onset zone was adjacent to eloquent motor areas. SLA targeting the right midcingulate gyrus was performed. The patient has remained seizure free since immediately after the procedure with no postoperative deficits (follow-up of 17 months).This case highlights the utility of SEEG in evaluating difficult-to-localize, focal epilepsy. It also demonstrates that the use of SLA can be extended to nonlesional, extratemporal epilepsies.

Insular Cortex Surgery for the Treatment of Refractory Epilepsy

Focal epilepsy originating from the insular cortex is rare. One reason is the small amount of cortical tissue compared with other lobes of the brain. However, the incidence of insular epilepsy might be underestimated because of diagnostic difficulties. The semiology and the surface EEG are often not meaningful or even misleading, and elaborated imaging might be necessary. The close connections of the insular cortex with other potentially epileptogenic areas, such as the temporal lobe or frontal/central cortex, is increasingly recognized as possible reason for failure of epilepsy surgery for temporal or extratemporal seizures. Therefore, some centers consider invasive EEG recording of the insular cortex not only in case of insular epilepsy but also in other focal epilepsies with nonconclusive results from the presurgical work-up. The surgical approach to and resection of insular cortex is challenging because of its deep location and proximity to highly eloquent brain structures. Over the last decades, technical adjuncts like navigation tools, electrophysiological monitoring and intraoperative imaging have improved the outcome after surgery. Nevertheless, there is still a considerable rate of postoperative transient or permanent deficits, in some cases as unavoidable and calculated deficits. In most of the recent series, seizure outcome was favorable and comparable with extratemporal epilepsy surgery or even better. Up to now, the data volume concerning long-term follow-up is limited. This review focusses on the surgical challenges of resections to treat insular epilepsy, on prognostic factors concerning seizure outcome, on postoperative deficits and complications. Moreover, less invasive surgical techniques to treat epilepsy in this highly eloquent area are summarized.

Cortical thickness analysis in operculo-insular epilepsy

Background

In temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE), advanced neuroimaging techniques reveal anomalies extending beyond the temporal lobe such as thinning of fronto-central cortices. Operculo-insular epilepsy (OIE) is an under-recognized and poorly characterized condition with the potential of mimicking TLE. In this work, we investigated insular and extra-insular cortical thickness (CT) changes in OIE.

Methods

All participants (14 patients with refractory OIE, 9 age- and sex-matched patients with refractory TLE and 26 healthy controls) underwent a T1-weighted acquisition on a 3 T MRI. Anatomical images were processed with Advanced Normalization Tools. Between-group analysis of CT was performed using a two-sided t-test (threshold of p < 0.05 after correction for multiple comparisons; cut-off threshold of 250 voxels) between (i) patients with OIE vs TLE, and (ii) patients with OIE vs healthy controls.

Results

Significant widespread thinning was observed in OIE patients as compared with healthy controls mainly in the ipsilateral insula, peri-rolandic region, orbito-frontal area, mesiotemporal structures and lateral temporal neocortex. Contralateral cortical shrinkage followed a similar albeit milder and less diffuse pattern.The CT of OIE patients was equal or reduced relative to the TLE group for every cortical region analyzed. Thinning was observed diffusely in OIE patients, predominantly inboth insulae and the ipsilateral occipito-temporal area.

Conclusion

Our results reveal structural anomalies extending beyond the operculo-insular area in OIE.

Invasive Insular Sampling in Pediatric Epilepsy: A Single-Institution Experience

BACKGROUND

It has been increasingly recognized that the insular cortex plays an important role in frontotemporal-parietal epilepsy in children. The insula, however, cannot be properly interrogated with conventional subdural grids, and its anatomy makes it difficult to implicate the insula with semiology or noninvasive modalities. Frame-based, stereotactic placement of insular depth electrodes for direct extraoperative monitoring is a relatively low-risk maneuver that allows for conclusive interrogation of this region, and, in select cases, can easily be replaced with a laser applicator for minimally invasive treatment via thermoablation.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the largest reported series of pediatric patients with refractory epilepsy undergoing insular depth electrode placement.

METHODS

We used current procedural terminology billing records to identify cases of depth electrode insertion performed at our institution. Clinical information from patients undergoing invasive insular sampling was then retrospectively collected.

RESULTS

Seventy-four insular depth electrodes were placed in 49 patients for extraoperative, inpatient monitoring. The decision to place insular depth electrodes was determined by a multidisciplinary epilepsy team. In 65.3% of cases, direct invasive sampling implicated the insula in seizure onset and prompted either thermoablation or surgical resection of some portion of the insula. There were no serious adverse effects or complications associated with the placement of insular depth electrodes.

CONCLUSION

Given the low morbidity of insular depth electrode insertion and the high proportion of patients who exhibited insular involvement, it is worth considering whether insular depth electrodes should be part of the standard presurgical evaluation in children with treatment-refractory frontotemporal-parietal epilepsy.

Magnetic resonance imaging-guided laser interstitial thermal therapy as treatment for intractable insular epilepsy in children

OBJECTIVE Seizure onset within the insula is increasingly recognized as a cause of intractable epilepsy. Surgery within the insula is difficult, with considerable risks, given the rich vascular supply and location near critical cortex. MRI-guided laser interstitial thermal therapy (LiTT) provides an attractive treatment option for insular epilepsy, allowing direct ablation of abnormal tissue while sparing nearby normal cortex. Herein, the authors describe their experience using this technique in a large cohort of children undergoing treatment of intractable localization-related epilepsy of insular onset. METHODS The combined epilepsy surgery database of Cook Children's Medical Center and Dell Children's Hospital was queried for all cases of insular onset epilepsy treated with LiTT. Patients without at least 6 months of follow-up data and cases preoperatively designated as palliative were excluded. Patient demographics, presurgical evaluation, surgical plan, and outcome were collected from patient charts and described. RESULTS Twenty patients (mean age 12.8 years, range 6.1-18.6 years) underwent a total of 24 LiTT procedures; 70% of these patients had normal findings on MRI. Patients underwent a mean follow-up of 20.4 months after their last surgery (range 7-39 months), with 10 (50%) in Engel Class I, 1 (5%) in Engel Class II, 5 (25%) in Engel Class III, and 4 (20%) in Engel Class IV at last follow-up. Patients were discharged within 24 hours of the procedure in 15 (63%) cases, in 48 hours in 6 (24%) cases, and in more than 48 hours in the remaining cases. Adverse functional effects were experienced following 7 (29%) of the procedures: mild hemiparesis after 6 procedures (all patients experienced complete resolution or had minimal residual dysfunction by 6 months), and expressive language dysfunction after 1 procedure (resolved by 3 months). CONCLUSIONS To their knowledge, the authors present the largest cohort of pediatric patients undergoing insular surgery for treatment of intractable epilepsy. The patient outcomes suggest that LiTT can successfully treat intractable seizures originating within the insula and offers an attractive alternative to open resection. This is the first description of LiTT applied to insular epilepsy and represents one of only a few series describing the use of LiTT in children. The results indicate that seizure reduction after LiTT compares favorably to that after conventional open surgical techniques.

Indications, technique, and safety profile of insular stereoelectroencephalography electrode implantation in medically intractable epilepsy

OBJECTIVE Insular epilepsy is relatively rare; however, exploring the insular cortex when preoperative workup raises the suspicion of insular epilepsy is of paramount importance for accurate localization of the epileptogenic zone and achievement of seizure freedom. The authors review their clinical experience with stereoelectroencephalography (SEEG) electrode implantation in patients with medically intractable epilepsy and suspected insular involvement. METHODS A total of 198 consecutive cases in which patients underwent SEEG implantation with a total of 1556 electrodes between June 2009 and April 2013 were reviewed. The authors identified patients with suspected insular involvement based on seizure semiology, scalp EEG data, and preoperative imaging (MRI, PET, and SPECT or magnetoencephalography [MEG]). Patients with at least 1 insular electrode based on the postoperative 3D reconstruction of CT fused with the preoperative MRI were included. RESULTS One hundred thirty-five patients with suspected insular epilepsy underwent insular implantation of a total of 303 electrodes (1-6 insular electrodes per patient) with a total of 562 contacts. Two hundred sixty-eight electrodes (88.5%) were implanted orthogonally through the frontoparietal or temporal operculum (420 contacts). Thirty-five electrodes (11.5%) were implanted by means of an oblique trajectory either through a frontal or a parietal entry point (142 contacts). Nineteen patients (14.07%) had insular electrodes placed bilaterally. Twenty-three patients (17.04% of the insular implantation group and 11.6% of the whole SEEG cohort) were confirmed by SEEG to have ictal onset zones in the insula. None of the patients experienced any intracerebral hemorrhage related to the insular electrodes. After insular resection, 5 patients (33.3%) had Engel Class I outcomes, 6 patients (40%) had Engel Class II, 3 patients (20%) had Engel Class III, and 1 patient (6.66%) had Engel Class IV. CONCLUSIONS Insula exploration with stereotactically placed depth electrodes is a safe technique. Orthogonal electrodes are implanted when the hypothesis suggests opercular involvement; however, oblique electrodes allow a higher insular sampling rate.

sEEG is a Safe Procedure for a Comprehensive Anatomic Exploration of the Insula: A Retrospective Study of 108 Procedures Representing 254 Transopercular Insular Electrodes

BACKGROUND

The exploration of the insula in pre-surgical evaluation of epilepsy is considered to be associated with a high vascular risk resulting in an incomplete exploration of the insular cortex.

OBJECTIVE

To report a retrospective observational study of insular exploration using stereoelectroencephalography (sEEG) with transopercular and parasagittal oblique intracerebral electrodes from January 2008 to January 2016. The first purpose of this study was to evaluate the surgical risks of insular cortex sEEG exploration. The second purpose was to define the ability of placing intracerebral contacts in the whole insular cortex.

METHODS

Ninety-nine patients underwent 108 magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-guided stereotactic implantations of intracerebral electrodes in the context of preoperative assessment of drug-resistant epilepsy, including at least 1 electrode placed in the insular cortex. On postoperative computed tomography images co-registered with MRI, followed by MRI segmentation and application of a transformation matrix, intracerebral contact coordinates of the insular electrodes’ contacts were anatomically localized in the Talairach space. Finally, dispersion and clustering analysis was performed.

RESULTS

There was no morbidity, in particular hemorrhagic complications, or mortality related to insular electrodes. Statistical comparison of intracerebral contact positions demonstrated that whole insula exploration is possible on the left and right sides. In addition, the clustering analysis showed the homogeneous distribution of the electrodes within the insular cortex.

CONCLUSION

In the presurgical evaluation of drug-resistant epilepsy, the insular cortex can be explored safely and comprehensively using transopercular sEEG electrodes. Parasagittal oblique trajectories may also be associated to achieve an optimal exploration.

Proton MR Spectroscopy in Patients with Nonlesional Insular Cortex Epilepsy Confirmed by Invasive EEG Recordings

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Recent studies suggest that a nonnegligible proportion of drug-resistant epilepsy surgery candidates have an epileptogenic zone that involves the insula. We aimed to examine the value of proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (¹ H-MRS) in identifying patients with insular cortex epilepsy.

METHODS

Patients with possible nonlesional drug-refractory insular epilepsy underwent a voxel-based ¹ H-MRS study prior to an intracranial electroencephalographic (EEG) study. Patients were then divided into two groups based on invasive EEG findings: the insular group with evidence of insular seizures and the noninsular group with no evidence of insular seizures. Sixteen age-matched healthy controls were also scanned for normative data.

RESULTS

Twenty-two epileptic patients were recruited, 12 with insular seizures and 10 with extra-insular seizures. Ipsilateral and contralateral insular N-acetyl-aspartate concentrations ([NAA]) and NAA/Cr ratios were found to be similar in both patient groups. No significant differences in [NAA] or NAA/Cr ratios were found between the insular group, noninsular group, and healthy controls. [NAA] and NAA/Cr asymmetry indices correctly lateralized the seizure focus in only 16.7% and 0% of patients, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Our preliminary findings suggest that ¹ H-MRS fares poorly in identifying patients with nonlesional insular epilepsy.

Stereotactic Electroencephalography Is a Safe Procedure, Including for Insular Implantations

BACKGROUND

In some cases of drug-resistant focal epilepsy, noninvasive presurgical investigation may be insufficient to identify the ictal onset zone and the eloquent cortical areas. In such situations, invasive investigations are proposed using either stereotactic electroencephalography (SEEG) or subdural grid electrodes. Meta-analysis suggests that SEEG is safer than subdural grid electrodes, but insular implantation of SEEG electrodes has been thought to carry an additional risk of intraparenchymal hemorrhagic complications. Our objectives were to determine whether an insular SEEG trajectory is a risk factor for intracranial hematoma and to report the global safety of the procedure and provide some guidelines to prevent and detect complications.

METHODS

In a retrospective analysis of a surgical series of 525 consecutive procedures between 1995 and 2015, all electrodes were classified according to their insular or extrainsular trajectory. All complications were classified as major or minor according to their potential consequences regarding patient neurologic status.

RESULTS

Four intraparenchymal hematomas, all related to extrainsular electrodes (4/4974; 0.08%) were reported; no hematoma was found along insular electrodes (0/1042; 0%). There were 8 major complications (1.52%): 7 intracranial hematomas (1.33%) and 1 case of meningitis. Two patients had long-term neurologic impairment (0.38%), and 1 death (not directly related to the procedure) occurred (0.19%). Eleven minor complications (2.09%) were encountered, including broken electrode (1.52%), acute pneumocephalus (0.38%), and local cutaneous infection (0.19%).

CONCLUSIONS

SEEG is a safe procedure. Insular trajectories cannot be considered an additional risk of intracranial bleeding.