Functional hemispheric disconnection procedures for chronic epilepsy: history, indications, techniques, complications and current practice in Europe. A consensus statement on behalf of the EANS functional neurosurgery section

Introduction

The surgical procedure for severe, drug-resistant, unilateral hemispheric epilepsy is challenging. Over the last decades the surgical landscape for hemispheric disconnection procedures changed from anatomical hemispherectomy to functional hemispherotomy with a reduction of complications and stable good seizure outcome. Here, a task force of European epilepsy surgeons prepared, on behalf of the EANS Section for Functional Neurosurgery, a consensus statement on different aspects of the hemispheric disconnection procedure.

Research question

To determine history, indication, timing, techniques, complications and current practice in Europe for hemispheric disconnection procedures in drug-resistant epilepsy.

Material and methods

Relevant literature on the topic was collected by a literature search based on the PRISMA 2020 guidelines.

Results

A comprehensive overview on the historical development of hemispheric disconnection procedures for epilepsy is presented, while discussing indications, timing, surgical techniques and complications. Current practice for this procedure in European epilepsy surgery centers is provided. At present, our knowledge of long-term seizure outcomes primarily stems from open surgical disconnection procedures. Although minimal invasive surgical techniques in epilepsy are rapidly developing and reported in case reports or small case series, long-term seizure outcome remain uncertain and needs to be reported.

Discussion and conclusion

This is the first paper presenting a European consensus statement regarding history, indications, techniques and complications of hemispheric disconnection procedures for different causes of chronic, drug-resistant epilepsy. Furthermore, it serves as the pioneering document to report a comprehensive overview of the current surgical practices regarding this type of surgery employed in renowned epilepsy surgery centers across Europe.

Vertical Hemispherotomy: Contribution of Advanced Three-Dimensional Modeling for Presurgical Planning and Training

Vertical hemispherotomy is an effective treatment for many drug-resistant encephalopathies with unilateral involvement. One of the main factors influencing positive surgical results and long-term seizure freedom is the quality of disconnection. For this reason, perfect anatomical awareness is mandatory during each step of the procedure. Although previous groups attempted to reproduce the surgical anatomy through schematic representations, cadaveric dissections, and intraoperative photographs and videos, a comprehensive understanding of the approach may still be difficult, especially for less experienced neurosurgeons. In this work, we reported the application of advanced technology for three-dimensional (3D) modeling and visualization of the main neurova-scular structures during vertical hemispherotomy procedures. In the first part of the study, we built a detailed 3D model of the main structures and landmarks involved during each disconnection phase. In the second part, we discussed the adjunctive value of augmented reality systems for the management of the most challenging etiologies, such as hemimegalencephaly and post-ischemic encephalopathy. We demonstrated the contribution of advanced 3D modeling and visualization to enhance the quality of anatomical representation and interaction between the operator and model according to a surgical perspective, optimizing the quality of presurgical planning, intraoperative orientation, and educational training.

Endoscopic Anatomy of Transcallosal Hemispherotomy: Laboratory Study with Advanced Three-Dimensional Modeling

BACKGROUND

Epilepsy surgery has an important role in the treatment of patients with medically intractable seizures. Various authors have proposed an endoscopic technique to perform disconnective procedures. A detailed description of intracerebral anatomy seen through an endoscopic transcallosal corridor has not been reported. The aim of this study was to present a cadaveric step-by-step anatomical demonstration of endoscopic transcallosal hemispherotomy using a dedicated three-dimensional model.

METHODS

Anatomical dissections were performed on 6 cadaveric heads (12 hemispheres), and the disconnective procedure was performed using an endoscopic transcallosal approach. A dedicated three-dimensional model was used to better illustrate each step. A simulation of the disconnective procedure was performed by recreating the surgical steps on a subject from the Human Connectome Project dataset, and a calculation of the fiber tracts intersected was performed.

RESULTS

Analyzing data extracted from the three-dimensional model and tractography simulation, 100% of the fibers (streamlines) of corpus callosum, corticopontine tracts, corticospinal tract, and inferior fronto-occipital fascicle were transected. Moreover, a satisfactory number of fibers (>95%) of the thalamocortical tracts, corticostriatal tracts, corona radiata, fornix, and uncinate fascicle were disconnected.

CONCLUSIONS

This anatomical study described the relevant neurovascular structures to enable prediction of feasibility and control of the surgical procedure using the endoscopic transcallosal approach. The quantitative analysis permitted estimation of the theoretical efficacy of the procedure, confirming its relevant role in disconnective surgery.

Disconnection surgery to cure or palliate medically intractable epileptic spasms: a retrospective study

OBJECTIVE

Surgery is a treatment option for medically intractable epileptic spasms (ESs). However, outcomes of ES after surgery are not well understood, especially when surgeries aimed at seizure palliation are included. The purpose of the present study was to 1) investigate the proportion of favorable postoperative ES outcomes, 2) explore the preoperative factors related to favorable postoperative ES outcomes, and 3) examine the timing of ES recurrence after disconnection surgeries, including both curative and palliative indications.

METHODS

This retrospective study included patients who underwent disconnection surgery for medically intractable ES at the authors’ institution between May 2015 and April 2021. Patients with suggested focal-onset ES based on preoperative evaluations initially underwent lobar disconnection. Patients with suggested generalized or unknown-onset ES underwent corpus callosotomy (CC). If evaluations after initial CC showed focalized or lateralized change, they were considered secondarily revealed focal-onset ES, and lobar disconnection was performed. ES outcomes were evaluated using the International League Against Epilepsy classification. ES outcomes were divided into classes 1–4 as favorable outcomes and classes 5 and 6 as unfavorable outcomes. The relationship between the favorable postoperative ES outcomes and the following preoperative factors was analyzed: sex, age at onset (< or > 1 year), duration between seizure onset and initial surgery (< or > 2 years), type of seizure at onset (ES or others), presence of other types of seizures, substrate, hypsarrhythmia, and MRI abnormalities. The period between the last surgery and ES recurrence was also analyzed.

RESULTS

A total of 41 patients were included, of whom 75.6% achieved favorable ES outcomes. A longer seizure duration between seizure onset and initial surgery, presence of hypsarrhythmia, and positive MRI findings led to poorer postoperative ES outcomes (p = 0.0028, p = 0.0041, and p = 0.0241, respectively). A total of 60.9% of patients had ES recurrence during the follow-up period, and their ES recurred within 13 months after the last surgery.

CONCLUSIONS

Disconnection surgery is an effective treatment option for medically intractable ES, even when the preoperative evaluation suggests a generalized or unknown onset.

[Lessons learnt from 101 hemispheric pediatric epilepsy surgeries part ii: pitfalls and complications]

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the spectrum of pitfalls and complications after hemisherotomy basing on a retrospective study of a large consecutive pediatric cohort of patients from a single institution.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

One hundred and one patients (med. age - 43 months) with refractory seizures underwent hemispherotomy. Developmental pathology was the anatomical substrate of disorder in 42 patients. The infantile post-stroke scarring and gliosis was the origin of epilepsy in the majority of 43 cases with acquired etiology. The progressive pathology (RE, S-W and TS) was the etiology in the rest of children (16 cases). The lateral periinsular technique was used to isolate the sick hemisphere in 55 patients; the vertical parasagittal approach was employed in 46 cases. Median perioperative blood loss constituted 10.5 ml/kg, but was markedly larger in kids with hemimegaly (52.8 ml/kg); 57 patients needed hemotransfusion during surgery. Median length of stay in ICU was 14.7 hours, and the length of stay in the hospital until discharge - 6.5 days. Eight patients underwent second-look surgery to complete sectioning of undercut commissural fibers. FU is known in 91 patients (med. length - 1.5 years).

RESULTS

Major surgical complications with serious hemorrhage and/or surgery induced life-threatening events developed in 7 patients (one of them has died on the 5^th day post-surgery for the causes of brain edema and uncontrolled hyponatremia). Various early and late infectious complications were noted in 4 cases. Ten patients experienced new not anticipated but temporary neurological deficit. Nine patients needed shunting for the causes of hydrocephalus within several first months post-hemispherotomy. Early seizure onset was associated with probability of all complications in general (p=0.02), and developmental etiology - with intraoperative bleeding and hemorrhagic complications (p=0.03).

CONCLUSION

Children with developmental etiology, particularly those with hemimegalencephaly, are most challengeable in terms of perioperative hemorrhage and serious complications. Patients with relapse or persisting seizures should be evaluated for the possibility of incomplete hemispheric isolation and have good chances to become SF by re-doing hemispherotomy.

Surgical Anatomy of Vertical Perithalamic Hemispherotomy

BACKGROUND

Vertical perithalamic hemispherotomy was introduced by Olivier Delalande in 1992 as an alternative concept of functional hemispherectomy.

OBJECTIVE

To provide a step-by-step illustration of the surgical anatomy of this procedure.

METHODS

The descriptions in this manuscript are based on an experience of 52 hemispherotomies performed with the same technique by a single surgeon.

RESULTS

Our illustrations of the surgical anatomy and the descriptions of the surgical nuances facilitate a deep understanding for the surgical concept of Delalande's vertical hemispherotomy technique. They highlight the advantages (ie, reduced risk of inadvertent damage to the contralateral hemisphere and a clear orientation by defined anatomical landmarks) over the recently suggested modifications to this original technique.

CONCLUSION

Olivier Delalande's original technique remains the most appealing concept of vertical hemispherotomy to us.

Anatomic Understanding of Subtotal Hemispherotomy Using Cadaveric Brain, 3-Dimensional Simulation Models, and Intraoperative Photographs

BACKGROUND

When the epileptogenic foci skip the motor area, the epilepsy can be cured by surgery while preserving the motor function. This surgery has been reported as subtotal hemispherectomy. The disconnective variant of this surgery, subtotal hemispherotomy, is described.

OBJECTIVE

To demonstrate each step clearly, a cadaveric brain, 3-dimensional reconstruction and simulation model, and intraoperative photographs were used.

METHODS

A formalin-fixed cadaveric brain was dissected to show each step of this surgery. For the 3-dimensional model, several brain structures were reconstructed from preoperative images, and the surgery was simulated. Intraoperative photographs and postoperative magnetic resonance images were taken from the representative cases.

RESULTS

Temporo-parieto-occipital disconnection is performed to disconnect these lobes and the insula, limbic system, and splenium of the corpus callosum. The postcentral sulcus is the anterior border of the disconnection. Next, prefrontal disconnection is performed to disconnect the frontal lobe and the insula, frontal lobe and basal ganglia, and the anterior part of the corpus callosum. The precentral sulcus is the posterior border of the disconnection. Finally, corpus callosotomy of the central part is performed. After these steps, subtotal hemispherotomy, with preservation of the pre- and postcentral gyrus, is achieved. The 3-dimensional model clearly shows the anatomic relationships between deep brain structures. In the representative cases, postoperative motor deterioration was transient or none, and seizure-free status was achieved after surgery.

CONCLUSION

Subtotal hemispherotomy is generally difficult because of the complicated anatomy and narrow and deep surgical corridors. Combined use of these methods facilitates a clearer understanding of this surgery.

Enhancing outcomes of endoscopic vertical approach hemispherotomy: understanding the role of "temporal stem" residual connections causing recurrence of seizures

Objective

The authors sought to analyze the residual connections formed by the temporal stem as a cause for seizure recurrence following endoscopic vertical interhemispheric hemispherotomy and to review and compare lateral approach (perisylvian) with vertical approach surgical techniques to highlight the anatomical factors responsible for residual connections.

METHODS

This study was a retrospective analysis of patients who underwent endoscopic hemispherotomy for drug-resistant epilepsy. Postoperative MR images were analyzed. Specific attention was given to anatomical 3D-acquired thin-section T1 images to assess the extent of disconnection, which was confirmed with a diffusion tensor imaging sequence. Cadaver brain dissection was done to analyze the anatomical factors responsible for persistent connections.

RESULTS

Of 39 patients who underwent surgery, 80% (31/39) were seizure free (follow-up of 23.61 ± 8.25 months) following the first surgery. Thirty patients underwent postoperative MRI studies, which revealed persistent connections in 14 patients (11 temporal stem only; 3 temporal stem + amygdala + splenium). Eight of these 14 patients had persistent seizures. In 4 of these 8 patients, investigations revealed good concordance with the affected hemisphere, and repeat endoscopic disconnection of the residual connection was performed. Two of the 8 patients were lost to follow-up, and 2 had bihemispheric seizure onset. The 4 patients who underwent repeat endoscopic disconnection had seizure-free outcomes following the second surgery, increasing the good outcome total among all patients to 90% (35/39). Cadaveric brain dissection analysis revealed the anatomical factors responsible for the persistence of residual connections.

CONCLUSIONS

In endoscopic vertical approach interhemispheric hemispherotomy (and also vertical approach parasagittal hemispherotomy) the temporal stem, which lies deep and parallel to the plane of disconnection, is prone to be missed, which might lead to persistent or recurrent seizures. The recognition of this limitation can lead to improved seizure outcome. The amygdala and splenium are areas less commonly prone to be missed during surgery.