Gene expression, polarising activity and skeletal patterning in reaggregated hind limb mesenchyme

Lewis Wolpert (1929-2021)

Lewis Wolpert was a brilliant and inspiring scientist who made hugely significant contributions which underpin and influence our understanding of developmental biology today. He spent his career interested in how the fertilised egg can give rise to the whole embryo (and ultimately the adult) with one head, two arms, two legs, all its organs and importantly how cells become different from each other and how they 'know' what to become. His ideas revolutionised the way developmental biology was perceived and also reinvigorated, in particular, the key question of how pattern formation in embryonic development is achieved. He published over 200 scientific articles and received many accolades over his career for his work and services to science in the UK. These included a CBE (Commander of the Order of the British Empire) from the Queen, being elected a Fellow of the Royal Society and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature. He was also a recipient of the Waddington Medal from the British Society for Developmental Biology and was awarded The Royal Society's top honour, the Royal Medal in 2018. Lewis was also a gifted teacher and communicator, including being the author of a textbook on developmental biology used around the world to train the next generation of developmental biologists. This contribution was recognised in 2003, by the award of the Viktor Hamburger Outstanding Educator Award from the Society of Developmental Biology in the USA. Lewis always enjoyed giving talks and lectures, having an infectious and persuasive enthusiasm coupled with a sharp sense of humour. He also published articles in popular science journals (aimed at the public) such as New Scientist, Scientific American and The Scientist. Lewis also wrote several popular science books. He was a passionate advocate for the public understanding of science and was the Chair of The Royal Society/Royal Institution/British Association for the Advancement of Science Committee for Public Understanding of Science (1994-1998). For this contribution he was awarded The Royal Society Michael Faraday Medal for "excellence in communicating science to UK audiences". He presented the prestigious Royal Institution Christmas Lectures in 1986 entitled 'Frankenstein's Quest: development of life'. These lectures, six in total, are presented by leading scientists and aimed at the general public and broadcast on national television. On a personal level, Lewis influenced all who came into contact with him, shaped his students and postdocs careers and instilled in them, and the community as whole, a life-long love of developmental biology.

Inhibition of Shh signalling in the chick wing gives insights into digit patterning and evolution

In an influential model of pattern formation, a gradient of Sonic hedgehog (Shh) signalling in the chick wing bud specifies cells with three antero-posterior positional values, which give rise to three morphologically different digits by a self-organizing mechanism with Turing-like properties. However, as four of the five digits of the mouse limb are morphologically similar in terms of phalangeal pattern, it has been suggested that self-organization alone could be sufficient. Here, we show that inhibition of Shh signalling at a specific stage of chick wing development results in a pattern of four digits, three of which can have the same number of phalanges. These patterning changes are dependent on a posterior extension of the apical ectodermal ridge, and this also allows the additional digit to arise from the Shh-producing cells of the polarizing region – an ability lost in ancestral theropod dinosaurs. Our analyses reveal that, if the specification of antero-posterior positional values is curtailed, self-organization can then produce several digits with the same number of phalanges. We present a model that may give important insights into how the number of digits and phalanges has diverged during the evolution of avian and mammalian limbs.

Highlighted Article: In the chick wing, the relative timing of the specification of antero-posterior positional values and self-organising mechanisms determines digit patterning and identity.

Sonic Hedgehog Signaling in Limb Development

The gene encoding the secreted protein Sonic hedgehog (Shh) is expressed in the polarizing region (or zone of polarizing activity), a small group of mesenchyme cells at the posterior margin of the vertebrate limb bud. Detailed analyses have revealed that Shh has the properties of the long sought after polarizing region morphogen that specifies positional values across the antero-posterior axis (e.g., thumb to little finger axis) of the limb. Shh has also been shown to control the width of the limb bud by stimulating mesenchyme cell proliferation and by regulating the antero-posterior length of the apical ectodermal ridge, the signaling region required for limb bud outgrowth and the laying down of structures along the proximo-distal axis (e.g., shoulder to digits axis) of the limb. It has been shown that Shh signaling can specify antero-posterior positional values in limb buds in both a concentration- (paracrine) and time-dependent (autocrine) fashion. Currently there are several models for how Shh specifies positional values over time in the limb buds of chick and mouse embryos and how this is integrated with growth. Extensive work has elucidated downstream transcriptional targets of Shh signaling. Nevertheless, it remains unclear how antero-posterior positional values are encoded and then interpreted to give the particular structure appropriate to that position, for example, the type of digit. A distant cis-regulatory enhancer controls limb-bud-specific expression of Shh and the discovery of increasing numbers of interacting transcription factors indicate complex spatiotemporal regulation. Altered Shh signaling is implicated in clinical conditions with congenital limb defects and in the evolution of the morphological diversity of vertebrate limbs.

Divergent differentiation of skeletal progenitors into cartilage and tendon: lessons from the embryonic limb

Repairing damaged cartilage and tendons is a major challenge of regenerative medicine. There has been great progress in the past decade toward obtaining stem cells for regenerative purposes from a variety of sources. However, the development of procedures to direct and maintain the differentiation of progenitors into cartilage or tendon is still a hurdle to overcome in regenerative medicine of the musculoskeletal system. This is because connective tissues often lack stable phenotypes and retain plasticity to return to the initial stages of differentiation or to transdifferentiate into another connective tissue cell lineage. This makes it necessary to unravel the molecular basis that is responsible for the differentiation of connective tissue cell lineages. In this review, we summarize the investigations performed in the past two decades to unravel the signals that regulate the differentiation of skeletal cell progenitors into cartilage and tendons during embryonic limb development. The data obtained in those studies demonstrate that Tgfβ, BMP, FGF, and Wnt establish a complex signaling network that directs the differentiation of skeletal cell progenitors. Remarkably, in the embryonic digit model, the divergent differentiation of progenitors depends on the temporal coordination of those signals, rather than being specified by an individual signaling pathway. Due to its potential medical relevance, we highlight the importance of the coordinate influence of the Tgfβ and BMP pathways in the differentiation of cell progenitors into tendon or cartilage.

Turing and Wolpert work together during limb development

Limb development has been widely studied in developmental biology. Two types of theories, one based on positional information and another based on spontaneous pattern formation, are utilized to understand this process. However, for historical reasons, these two concepts are regarded as mutually exclusive. By considering the interaction between these two mechanisms with quantitative morphological data, we can experimentally explore how the vertebrate limb skeletal pattern is established from a new direction.

Imparting regenerative capacity to limbs by progenitor cell transplantation

The frog Xenopus can normally regenerate its limbs at early developmental stages but loses the ability during metamorphosis. This behavior provides a potential gain-of-function model for measures that can enhance limb regeneration. Here, we show that frog limbs can be caused to form multidigit regenerates after receiving transplants of larval limb progenitor cells. It is necessary to activate Wnt/β-catenin signaling in the cells and to add Sonic hedgehog, FGF10, and thymosin β4. These factors promote survival and growth of the grafted cells and also provide pattern information. The eventual regenerates are not composed solely of donor tissue; the host cells also make a substantial contribution despite their lack of regeneration competence. Cells from adult frog legs or from regenerating tadpole tails do not promote limb regeneration, demonstrating the necessity for limb progenitor cells. These findings have obvious implications for the development of a technology to promote limb regeneration in mammals.

Computational and mathematical models of chondrogenesis in vertebrate limbs

The production of cartilage (chondrogenic patterning) in the limb is one of the best-studied examples of the emergence of form in developmental biology. At the core of the theoretical study is an effort to understand the mechanism that establishes the characteristic distribution of cartilage in the embryonic limb, which defines the future sites and shapes of bones that will be present in the mature limb. This review article gives an overview of the history and current state of a rich literature of mathematical and computational models that seek to contribute to this problem. We describe models for the mechanisms of limb growth and shaping via interaction with various chemical fields, as well as models addressing the intrinsic self-organization capabilities of the embryonic mesenchymal tissue, such as reaction-diffusion and mechanochemical models. We discuss the contributions of these models to the current understanding of chondrogenesis in vertebrate limbs, as well as their relation to the varied conceptual models that have been proposed by experimentalists.

Regulation of retinoic acid distribution is required for proximodistal patterning and outgrowth of the developing mouse limb

Exogenous retinoic acid (RA) induces marked effects on limb patterning, but the precise role of endogenous RA in this process has remained unknown. We have studied the role of RA in mouse limb development by focusing on CYP26B1, a cytochrome P450 enzyme that inactivates RA. Cyp26b1 was shown to be expressed in the distal region of the developing limb bud, and mice that lack CYP26B1 exhibited severe limb malformation (meromelia). The lack of CYP26B1 resulted in spreading of the RA signal toward the distal end of the developing limb and induced proximodistal patterning defects characterized by expansion of proximal identity and restriction of distal identity. CYP26B1 deficiency also induced pronounced apoptosis in the developing limb and delayed chondrocyte maturation. Wild-type embryos exposed to excess RA phenocopied the limb defects of Cyp26b1(-/-) mice. These observations suggest that RA acts as a morphogen to determine proximodistal identity, and that CYP26B1 prevents apoptosis and promotes chondrocyte maturation, in the developing limb.

Anteroposterior axis formation in Xenopus limb bud recombinants: a model of pattern formation during limb regeneration

We previously showed that recombinant limb buds with dissociated and reaggregated mesenchyme develop more than 30 digits in Xenopus laevis, which exhibits different capacities for limb regeneration at different developmental stages (Yokoyama et al. [1998] Dev Biol 196:1-10). Cell-cell contact among anterior- and posterior-derived mesenchymal cells is required for anteroposterior (AP) axis formation of recombinant limbs in an intercalary manner. However, whether one-way induction from posterior cells to anterior cells as proposed by the polarizing zone model or interactions between anterior and posterior cells evoke the AP axis formation in recombinant limbs remains unclear. In this study, we found, by a combination of X-ray irradiation and a recombinant limb technique, that not one-way induction but interactions between anterior and posterior cells accompanied by cell contribution are indispensable for AP axis formation in recombinant limbs. Shh was expressed in posterior-derived not anterior-derived cells. We propose that the recombinant limb is an excellent model for examining the axis formation mechanism in regenerating limbs because, as in recombinant limbs, cell-cell contact among cells derived from different positions of an amputation plane occurs in the blastema of regenerating limbs.

Time, pattern, and heterochrony: a study of hyperphalangy in the dolphin embryo flipper

The forelimb of whales and dolphins is a flipper that shows hyperphalangy (numerous finger bones). Hyperphalangy is also present in marine reptiles, including ichthyosaurs and plesiosaurs. The developmental basis of hyper-phalangy is unclear. Kükenthal suggested that phalanx anlagen split into three pieces during cetacean development, thereby multiplying the ancestral number. Alternatively, Holder suggested that apical ectodermal ridge (AER)-directed limb outgrowth might be prolonged by a timing shift (heterochrony), leading to terminal addition of extra phalanges. We prepared a series of whole mounted and serially sectioned embryonic flipper buds of the spotted dolphin Stenella attenuata. This cetacean shows marked hyperphalangy on digits II and III. We confirm previous reports that the proximodistal laying down of phalanges is prolonged in digits II and III. Histology showed that the apical ectoderm was thickened into a cap. There was a weak ridge-like structure in some embryos. The cap or ridge formed part of a bud-like mass that persisted on digits II and III at stages when it had disappeared from other digits. Thus the dolphin differs from other mammals in showing a second period of limb outgrowth during which localized hyperphalangy develops. New phalanges only formed at the tip of the digits. These findings are consistent with a model in which heterochrony leads to the terminal addition of new phalanges. Our results are more easily reconciled with the progress zone model than one in which the AER is involved in the expansion of a prepattern. We suggest that patterning mechanisms with a temporal component (i.e., the "progress zone" mechanism) are potential targets for heterochrony during limb evolution.

Mucosal addressin cell adhesion molecule 1 plays an unexpected role in the development of mouse guard hair

The first wave of coat hair development is initiated around embryonic day 14 in the mouse. Whereas ectodysplasin and ectodermal dysplasia receptor, tumor necrosis factor and tumor necrosis factor receptor family molecules, respectively, were identified to be signals triggering this process, not much was known regarding their downstream molecular targets. In this report, we show that mucosal addressin cell adhesion molecule 1 and intercellular adhesion molecule 1 are induced in the keratinocytes of the hair placode as a direct consequence of ectodermal dysplasia receptor signal, and tumor-necrosis-factor-receptor-associated factor 6 is involved in this mucosal addressin cell adhesion molecule 1 expression. Experiments using an in vitro culture of skin fragments demonstrated that ectodermal-dysplasia-receptor-induced mucosal addressin cell adhesion molecule 1 expression occurs at the initial phase of follicle development before involvement of Sonic hedgehog signal. Follicle development in this culture was also suppressed to some extent, though not completely, by addition of soluble mucosal addressin cell adhesion molecule 1/IgG-Fc chimeric protein, whereas monoclonal antibody that can inhibit mucosal addressin cell adhesion molecule 1 interaction with integrin alpha4beta7 had no effect on this process. These results demonstrated for the first time that the structural proteins, mucosal addressin cell adhesion molecule 1 and intercellular adhesion molecule 1, are induced by ectodermal dysplasia receptor signal and suggested the potential involvement of mucosal addressin cell adhesion molecule 1 in the morphogenesis of follicular keratinocytes.

A re-examination of proximodistal patterning during vertebrate limb development

The 'progress zone' model provides a framework for understanding progressive development of the vertebrate limb. This model holds that undifferentiated cells in a zone of fixed size at the distal tip of the limb bud (the progress zone) undergo a progressive change in positional information such that their specification is altered from more proximal to more distal fates. This positional change is thought to be driven by an internal clock that is kept active as long as the cells remain in the progress zone. However, owing to cell division, the most proximal of these cells are continually pushed outside the confines of the zone. As they exit, clock function ceases and cells become fixed with the positional value last attained while within the zone. In contrast to this model, our data suggest that the various limb segments are 'specified' early in limb development as distinct domains, with subsequent development involving expansion of these progenitor populations before differentiation. We also find, however, that the distal limb mesenchyme becomes progressively 'determined', that is, irreversibly fixed, to a progressively limited range of potential proximodistal fates.

Molecular model for limb development

The paper proposes a possible molecular mechanism of cell fate specification during limb development. The mechanism is based on a step-by-step activation of cell determinants, which occurs at the transcriptional level. Activation of the next determinant (or reactivation of the previous one) occurs only after the next cell division, only one determinant being activated (reactivated) in each cell cycle. This mechanism may be a basis for both proximodistal and anteroposterior specification of cell fates. As a result of this mechanism, the limb bud mesoderm proves to be divided into cell areas. Cells of the specific area would be condensed to form the specific cartilaginous element.

Pattern formation and regulation of gene expressions in chick recombinant limbs

Recombinant limbs were performed by ensembling dissociated-reaggregated wing bud mesoderm inside an ectodermal hull. The zone of polarizing activity was excluded from the mesoderm used to perform the recombinant limbs (non-polarized recombinants), and grafted when desired (polarized recombinants). Reorganization of patterning progressively occurred in the newly formed progress zone under the influence of the apical ectodermal ridge (AER), explaining the proximo-distal gradient of morphogenesis observed in developed recombinant limbs. The AER, without the influence of the polarizing region (ZPA), was sufficient to direct outgrowth and appropriate proximo-distal patterning, as observed in the expression of the Hoxa-11 and Hoxa-13 genes. The development of the recombinant limbs coursed with symmetric AER and downregulation of Bmp expression in the mesoderm supporting a negative effect of Bmp signaling upon the apical ridge. The recombinant ectoderm maintained previously established compartments of gene expressions and organized a correct dorso-ventral patterning in the recombinant progress zone. Finally, the ZPA effect was only detected on Bmp expression and pattern formation along the antero-posterior axis.

Vertebrate limb development and malformations

To understand limb abnormalities it is necessary to understand how the limb develops. The limb is the organ whose development is probably best understood. The limbs develop from small protrusions (the limb buds) that arise from the body wall of the embryo. Positioning and patterning the limb involves cellular interactions both between the ectoderm surrounding the limb bud and between the mesenchymal cells that form the core of the limb bud. As the limb grows out the cells acquire a positional value that relates to their position in the bud with respect to all three axes, proximo-distal, antero-posterior, and dorso-ventral. These positional values largely determine how the cells will develop such as what sort of cartilaginous elements they will form. The positional value of the cells is acquired in the progress zone at the tip of the growing bud. The time spent in the progress zone may determine the positional values along the proximo-distal axis, that is the formation of, for example the humerus, then the radius and ulna. Loss of the progress zone due to damage to the overlying apical ridge leads to truncations, and this progress zone model can also account for the effects of thalidomide. Position along the antero-posterior axis such as the character of the digits is by a signal from the polarizing region at the posterior margin of the limb and involves the signaling protein Sonic hedgehog. A signal from the dorsal ectoderm specifies the dorso-ventral axis. Hox genes that are transcription factors are expressed both along the body axis and in a complex pattern in the limb and may record positional value. Human mutations in these genes lead to limb abnormalities. Muscle cells have a separate origin from the cartilaginous cells and those that form connective tissue and tendons, and they migrate into the bud from the somites and are patterned by the connective tissue. Cell death separates the digits.

Modes of morphogen cooperation for limb formation in vertebrates and insects

Diffusing morphogens in cooperation can control gene expression in developing limbs. Additive cooperation corresponds to the Boolean operator OR and implies the equivalent action of the (suitably scaled) concentrations of two morphogens, either by their alternative binding to the same receptor or by another way of convergence of their effects during the signal transduction procedure. This cooperation can explain the spatial and temporal collinearities of the expression of hoxd genes in the vertebrate limb bud. A multiplicative cooperation of morphogens (corresponding to the Boolean operator AND), produced at the DPP and WG domains in the Drosophila leg imaginal disc, may account for the expression domains observed for Dll and dac. A molecular interpretation of the multiplicative morphogen cooperation is proposed. Some experiments are suggested for further testing of the model.

Expression of ptc and gli genes in talpid3 suggests bifurcation in Shh pathway

talpid3 is an embryonic-lethal chicken mutation in a molecularly un-characterised autosomal gene. The recessive, pleiotropic phenotype includes polydactylous limbs with morphologically similar digits. Previous analysis established that hox-D and bmp genes, that are normally expressed posteriorly in the limb bud in response to a localised, posterior source of Sonic Hedgehog (Shh) are expressed symmetrically across the entire anteroposterior axis in talpid3 limb buds. In contrast, Shh expression itself is unaffected. Here we examine expression of patched (ptc), which encodes a component of the Shh receptor, and is probably itself a direct target of Shh signalling, to establish whether talpid3 acts in the Shh pathway. We find that ptc expression is significantly reduced in talpid3 embryos. We also demonstrate that talpid3 function is not required for Shh signal production but is required for normal response to Shh signals, implicating talpid3 in transduction of Shh signals in responding cells. Our analysis of expression of putative components of the Shh pathway, gli1, gli3 and coupTFII shows that genes regulated by Shh are either ectopically expressed or no longer responsive to Shh signals in talpid3 limbs, suggesting possible bifurcation in the Shh pathway. We also describe genetic mapping of gli1, ptc, shh and smoothened in chickens and confirm by co-segregation analysis that none of these genes correspond to talpid3.

Molecular and cellular basis of pattern formation during vertebrate limb development

The body plan is generated by cells and tissues that become arranged precisely in the embryo. This process, termed pattern formation, involves cell interactions in which a particular group of cells produce signals that specify new cell types or patterns of differentiation in responding cells. These patterning signals emanate from very discrete centers called "organizer centers," such as the Hensen's node or Spemann organizer, the midbrain-hindbrain junction, the notochord, or in the case of the limb, the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA) or the apical ectodermal ridge (AER). The developing vertebrate limb is an ideal model system for the study of pattern formation because, in addition to surgical manipulations, molecular manipulations are now feasible. In this review we summarize early experiments that established, by means of surgical manipulations, the different organizer centers of the vertebrate limb: the ectoderm covering the limb bud, the apical ectodermal ridge, the zone of polarizing activity, and the distal mesoderm (progress zone) underlying the AER. We then describe the domains of expression of various genes present during the development of the limb and discuss some of the functional approaches (overexpression and lack of function studies) undertaken to ascertain their role in limb outgrowth. The knowledge acquired in the last few years has had an enormous impact not only on our view of how limbs develop (perhaps now one of the most approachable vertebrate model systems) but also in a more general sense of how the embryo is organized in space and time.

Shh, Bmp-2 and Hoxd-13 gene expression in chick limb bud cells in culture

The anteroposterior axis of the vertebrate limb bud is determined by signals from the zone of polarizing activity (ZPA). Sonic hedgehog (Shh) is expressed in the posterior mesoderm, which corresponds closely to ZPA activity. Moreover, Bmp-2 and HoxD genes are expressed in the broader posterior mesoderm, and it is thought that the ZPA signaling pathway consists of these gene products. Limb outgrowth and patterning, including expression of these genes, depend on the apical ectodermal ridge (AER). Fibroblast growth factors (FGF) have been identified as candidates for signal molecules from the AER. To further understand the ZPA signaling pathway and the participation of FGF, expressions of these genes were examined by reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction in chick limb bud cells cultured with FGF-4. The present results indicate that FGF-4 cannot maintain Shh expression but can maintain Hoxd-13 expression in cultured posterior cells; moreover, Bmp-2 is expressed independently of FGF-4. These results suggest that Bmp-2 and Hoxd-13 expressions do not require a continuous expression of Shh. Further, it was demonstrated that posterior cells cultured with FGF-4 recovered Shh expression when grafted to the limb bud, indicating that FGF-4 maintains not Shh expression itself but competence of Shh expression.

Multiple digit formation in Xenopus limb bud recombinants

We prepared recombinant limb buds of Xenopus tadpoles by grafting a mesenchyme mass of the hindlimb bud. The Xenopus recombinant limb buds with dissociated and reaggregated mesenchyme developed more than 30 digits with cartilage segmentation, while those with undissociated mesenchyme developed a limb with normal cartilage pattern. Before the formation of multiple digits, a patchy expression pattern of fgf-8, an AER marker, was observed in the distal region of recombinant limb buds. shh, a ZPA (zone of polarizing activity) marker, was expressed broadly in the distal region of recombinants. Recombinant limb buds with the reaggregated mesenchyme of anterior halves formed anterior digits with claws, and those with the mesenchyme of posterior halves formed posterior digits without claws. The temporal and spatial changes in the potency of multiple digit formation are discussed with reference to the regenerative capacity of Xenopus limb buds.

Somite number and vertebrate evolution

Variation in segment number is an important but neglected feature of vertebrate evolution. Some vertebrates have as few as six trunk vertebrae, while others have hundreds. We examine this phenomenon in relation to recent models of evolution and development. Surprisingly, differences in vertebral number are foreshadowed by different somite counts at the tailbud stage, thought to be a highly conserved (phylotypic) stage. Somite number therefore violates the ‘developmental hourglass’ model. We argue that this is because somitogenesis shows uncoupling or dissociation from the conserved positional field encoded by genes of the zootype. Several other systems show this kind of dissociation, including limbs and feathers. Bmp-7 expression patterns demonstrate dissociation in the chick pharyngeal arches. This makes it difficult to recognise a common stage of pharyngeal development or ‘pharyngula’ in all species. Rhombomere number is more stable during evolution than somite number, possibly because segmentation and positional specification in the hindbrain are relatively interdependent. Although developmental mechanisms are strongly conserved, dissociation allows at least some major evolutionary changes to be generated in phylotypic stages.

Hoxd-12 differentially affects preaxial and postaxial chondrogenic branches in the limb and regulates Sonic hedgehog in a positive feedback loop

Several 5′ members of the Hoxd cluster are expressed in nested posterior-distal domains of the limb bud suggesting a role in regulating anteroposterior pattern of skeletal elements. While loss-of-function mutants have demonstrated a regulatory role for these genes in the developing limb, extensive functional overlaps between various different Hox genes has hampered elucidation of the roles played by individual members. In particular, the function of Hoxd-12 in the limb remains obscure. Using a gain-of-function approach, we find that Hoxd-12 misexpression in transgenic mice produces apparent transformations of anterior digits to posterior morphology and digit duplications, while associated tibial hemimelia and other changes indicate that formation/growth of certain skeletal elements is selectively inhibited. If the digital arch represents an anterior bending of the main limb axis, then the results are all reconcilable with a model in which Hoxd-12 promotes formation of postaxial chondrogenic condensations branching from this main axis (including the anteriormost digit) and selectively antagonizes formation of ‘true’ preaxial condensations that branch from this main axis (such as the tibia). Hoxd-12 misexpression can also induce ectopic Sonic hedgehog (Shh) expression, resulting in mirror-image polydactyly in the limb. Misexpression of Hoxd-12 in other lateral plate derivatives (sternum, pelvis) likewise phenocopies several luxoid/luxate class mouse mutants that all share ectopic Shh signalling. This suggests that feedback activation of Shh expression may be a major function of Hoxd-12. Hoxd-12 can bind to and transactivate the Shh promoter in vitro. Furthermore, expression of either exogenous Hoxd-11 or Hoxd-12 in cultured limb bud cells, together with FGF, induces expression of the endogenous Shh gene. Together these results suggest that certain 5′ Hoxd genes directly amplify the posterior Shh polarizing signal in a reinforcing positive feedback loop during limb bud outgrowth.

Morphogenetic potential of the chick leg interdigital mesoderm when diverted from the cell death program

There is evidence that the interdigital mesoderm may be in an undifferentiated state. For example, under experimental manipulation in vivo it may be diverted from cell death to digit formation. In the present work we wanted to analyze the maximum morphogenetic potential of the interdigital cells. To do this we made recombinant limbs of three types, the first using dissociated-reaggregated leg interdigital mesoderm, the second using the same tissue but without dissociation and the third adding a piece of polarizing region to the dissociated interdigit. In all three the massive cell death of the interdigit failed to occur. The first type of recombinant formed a small nodule of cartilage while the other two formed a well-developed digit. Our data indicate that the maximum morphogenetic potential of the interdigital tissue appears constrained to form digits and that dissociation of the tissue decreased this ability; polarizing region restores the ability of dissociated cell recombinants to form a digit. We also analyzed in these recombinants the expression of a battery of genes implicated in interdigital cell death or in digital morphogenesis. The pattern of expression of each gene analyzed was identical in the three types of recombinant limbs. The expression of Msx1 and Msx2 genes was maintained under the ridge indicating a good interaction between the interdigital cells, both dissociated and undissociated, and the apical ridge. The expression of Hoxd-12, Hoxd-13 and Hoxa-13 genes was maintained in the recombinants, indicating that these cells carry information about their autopodial origin, and this correlates well with their distal restricted morphogenetic potential. Finally, the patterns of expression of the Bmp-2, Bmp-4 and Bmp-7 genes indicated that they are independently regulated in the recombinants and that Bmp-4 and Bmp-7 have wider expression domains than the areas of cell death that were only detected under the regressing apical ridge during day 3 of the experiment.

The ectodermal control in chick limb development: Wnt-7a, Shh, Bmp-2 and Bmp-4 expression and the effect of FGF-4 on gene expression

We have manipulated the chick limb bud by dorsoventrally inverting the ectoderm, by grafting the AER to the dorsal or ventral ectoderm and by insertion of an FGF-4 soaked heparin bead into the mesoderm. After dorso-ventral reversal of the ectoderm, Wnt-7a expression is autonomous from an early stage of limb development in the original dorsal ectoderm. Exogenous FGF-4 causes ectopic Wnt-7a expression and induces ectopic Shh. In addition, exogenous FGF-4 increases the thickness of cartilages and also shortens them, and both Bmp-2 and Bmp-4 may mediate this effect. The ectoderm outside the AER can regulate not only the dorso-ventral polarity of the underlying mesenchyme cells but also the cartilage formation, and both Bmp-2 and Bmp-4 may mediate this control.

The limb field mesoderm determines initial limb bud anteroposterior asymmetry and budding independent of sonic hedgehog or apical ectodermal gene expressions

We have analyzed the pattern of expression of several genes implicated in limb initiation and outgrowth using limbless chicken embryos. We demonstrate that the expressions of the apical ridge associated genes, Fgf-8, Fgf-4, Bmp-2 and Bmp-4, are undetectable in limbless limb bud ectoderm; however, FGF2 protein is present in the limb bud ectoderm. Shh expression is undetectable in limbless limb bud mesoderm. Nevertheless, limbless limb bud mesoderm shows polarization manifested by the asymmetric expression of Hoxd-11, −12 and −13, Wnt-5a and Bmp-4 genes. The posterior limbless limb bud mesoderm, although not actually expressing Shh, is competent to express it if supplied with exogenous FGF or transplanted to a normal apical ridge environment, providing further evidence of mesodermal asymmetry. Exogenous FGF applied to limbless limb buds permits further growth and determination of recognizable skeletal elements, without the development of an apical ridge. However, the cells competent to express Shh do so at reduced levels; nevertheless, Bmp-2 is then rapidly expressed in the posterior limbless mesoderm. limbless limb buds appear as bi-dorsal structures, as the entire limb bud ectoderm expresses Wnt-7a, a marker for dorsal limb bud ectoderm; the ectoderm fails to express En-1, a marker of ventral ectoderm. As expected, C-Lmx1, which is downstream of Wnt-7a, is expressed in the entire limbless limb bud mesoderm. We conclude that anteroposterior polarity is established in the initial limb bud prior to Shh expression, apical ridge gene expression or dorsal-ventral asymmetry. We propose that the initial pattern of gene expressions in the emergent limb bud is established by axial influences on the limb field. These permit the bud to emerge with asymmetric gene expression before Shh and the apical ridge appear. We report that expression of Fgf-8 by the limb ectoderm is not required for the initiation of the limb bud. The gene expressions in the pre-ridge limb bud mesoderm, as in the limb bud itself, are unstable without stimulation from the apical ridge and the polarizing region (Shh) after budding is initiated. We propose that the defect in limbless limb buds is the lack of a dorsal-ventral interface in the limb bud ectoderm where the apical ridge induction signal would be received and an apical ridge formed. These observations provide evidence for the hypothesis that the dorsal-ventral ectoderm interface is a precondition for apical ridge formation.

Limbs: a model for pattern formation within the vertebrate body plan

Giant strides have been made in identifying the molecular basis of limb development. The four main phases are initiation of the limb bud, specification of limb pattern, differentiation of tissues and shaping of the limb, and growth of the miniature limb to the adult size. We will focus on the exciting advances that have been made in initiation and specification of limb pattern. The limb is a model system and the same sets of molecules are used at different times and places in vertebrate embryos. There is also remarkable conservation of the molecular mechanisms of limb development in insects and vertebrates.

Activation of Fgf-4 and HoxD gene expression by BMP-2 expressing cells in the developing chick limb

Bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) has been implicated in the polarizing region signalling pathway, which specifies pattern across the antero-posterior of the developing vertebrate limb. Retinoic acid and Sonic Hedgehog (SHH) can act as polarizing signals; when applied anteriorly in the limb bud, they induce mirror-image digit duplications and ectopic Bmp-2 expression in anterior mesenchyme. In addition, the two signals can activate Fgf-4 expression in anterior ridge and HoxD expression in anterior mesenchyme. We tested the role of BMP-2 in this signalling cascade by ectopically expressing human BMP-2 (hBMP-2) at the anterior margin of the early wing bud using a replication defective retroviral vector, and found that ectopic expression of Fgf-4 was induced in the anterior part of the apical ectodermal ridge, followed later by ectopic expression of Hoxd-11 and Hoxd-13 in anterior mesenchyme. This suggests that BMP-2 is involved in regulating Fgf-4 and HoxD gene expression in the normal limb bud. Ectopically expressed hBMP-2 also induced duplication of digit 2 and bifurcation of digit 3, but could not produce the mirror-image digit duplications obtained with SHH-expressing cells. These results suggest that BMP-2 may be involved primarily in maintenance of the ridge, and in the link between patterning and outgrowth of the limb bud.