Genetic compensation for cilia defects in cep290 mutants by upregulation of cilia-associated small GTPases

Senior-Loken Syndrome: Ocular Perspectives on Genetics, Pathogenesis, and Management

Senior-Loken syndrome (SLSN) is a group of rare autosomal recessive disorders caused by dysfunction of the primary cilium, primarily affecting the kidneys (typically leading to nephronophthisis) and eyes (typically leading to retinal degeneration). Moreover, patients with SLSN may experience additional multisystemic symptoms, such as developmental delay, intellectual disability, ataxia, and nystagmus. To date, eight genes have been demonstrated to cause SLSN, all encoding for proteins involved in the structure and functions of the primary cilium. This places SLSN within an expanding category of diseases known as "ciliopathies". Due to the genetic heterogeneity and significant phenotypic overlap with other ciliopathies, establishing a definitive diagnosis during the initial consultation remains a challenge for clinicians. Furthermore, current research on SLSN-related ciliopathies predominantly focuses on renal involvement, while the ocular manifestations remain insufficiently explored and lack a comprehensive review. Therefore, with the goal of offering practical guidance for clinical practice, this review aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the clinical features, along with an ocular perspective on the molecular mechanisms, genetic underpinnings, and advances in the treatment of SLSN.

The advancements in precision medicine for Leber congenital amaurosis: Breakthroughs from genetic diagnosis to therapy

Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA) is a hereditary retinal disease, typically manifesting as severe vision impairment in infancy. With the advancement of precision medicine, genetic diagnosis and targeted therapies offer new hope for LCA patients, significantly improving both diagnostic accuracy and therapeutic efficacy. We summarize the epidemiological characteristics, clinical manifestations, and molecular genetics underlying LCA. It also highlights recent developments in precision treatment strategies, including gene replacement therapy, CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene editing, and antisense oligonucleotide therapies. In addition, we discuss the applications of induced pluripotent stem cells and retinal organoids in LCA treatment research. Furthermore, we explore preventive strategies and future treatment directions for LCA, including the development of novel gene therapy vectors, the optimization of combinatorial treatment strategies, and the formulation of personalized treatment approaches. These advancements hold significant potential to offer improved treatment options and enhance the quality of life for LCA patients.

PSKH1 kinase activity is differentially modulated via allosteric binding of Ca2+ sensor proteins

Protein Serine Kinase H1 (PSKH1) was recently identified as a crucial factor in kidney development and is overexpressed in prostate, lung, and kidney cancers. However, little is known about PSKH1 regulatory mechanisms, leading to its classification as a "dark" kinase. Here, we used biochemistry and mass spectrometry to define PSKH1's consensus substrate motif, protein interactors, and how interactors, including Ca2+ sensor proteins, promote or suppress activity. Intriguingly, despite the absence of a canonical Calmodulin binding motif, Ca2+-Calmodulin activated PSKH1 while, in contrast, the ER-resident Ca2+ sensor of the Cab45, Reticulocalbin, Erc55, Calumenin (CREC) family, Reticulocalbin-3, suppressed PSKH1 catalytic activity. In addition to antagonistic regulation of the PSKH1 kinase domain by Ca2+ sensing proteins, we identified UNC119B as a protein interactor that activates PSKH1 via direct engagement of the kinase domain. Our findings identify complementary allosteric mechanisms by which regulatory proteins tune PSKH1's catalytic activity and raise the possibility that different Ca2+ sensors may act more broadly to tune kinase activities by detecting and decoding extremes of intracellular Ca2+ concentrations.

Follistatin like-1 (Fstl1) regulates adipose tissue development in zebrafish

Obesity is a highly prevalent disorder with complex aetiology. Therefore, studying its associated cellular and molecular pathways may be aided by analysing genetic tractable diseases. In this context, the study of ciliopathies such as Bardet-Biedl syndrome has highlighted the relevance of primary cilia in obesity, both in the central nervous system and peripheral tissues. Based on our previous in vitro results supporting the role of a novel Bbs4-cilia-Fstl1 axis in adipocyte differentiation, we evaluated the in vivo relevance of the zebrafish orthologous genes fstl1a and fstl1b in primary cilia and adipose tissue development. Using a combination of knockdowns and a new fstl1a mutant line, we show that fstl1a promotes primary cilia formation in early embryos and participates in adipose tissue formation in larvae. We also show that fstl1b partially compensates for the loss of fstl1a. Moreover, in high fat diet, fstl1a depletion affects the expression of differentiation and mature adipocyte markers. These results agree with our previous in vitro data and provide further support for the role of FSTL1 as a regulator of adipose tissue formation. Dissecting the exact biological role of proteins such as FSTL1 will likely contribute to understand obesity onset and presentation.

Zebrafish as a Model Organism for Congenital Hydrocephalus: Characteristics and Insights

Hydrocephalus is a cerebrospinal fluid-related disease that usually manifests as abnormal dilation of the ventricles, with a triad of clinical findings including walking difficulty, reduced attention span, and urinary frequency or incontinence. The onset of congenital hydrocephalus is closely related to mutations in genes that regulate brain development. Currently, our understanding of the mechanisms of congenital hydrocephalus remains limited, and the prognosis of existing treatments is unsatisfactory. Additionally, there are no suitable or dedicated model organisms for congenital hydrocephalus. Therefore, it is significant to determine the mechanism and develop special animal models of congenital hydrocephalus. Recently, zebrafish have emerged as a popular model organism in many fields, including developmental biology, genetics, and toxicology. Its genome shares high similarity with that of humans, and it has fast and low-cost reproduction. These advantages make it suitable for studying the pathogenesis and therapeutic approaches for various diseases, specifically congenital diseases. This study explored the possibility of using zebrafish as a model organism for congenital hydrocephalus. This review describes the characteristics of zebrafish and discusses specific congenital hydrocephalus models. The advantages and limitations of using zebrafish for hydrocephalus research are highlighted, and insights for further model development are provided.

Knockout, Knockdown, and the Schrödinger Paradox: Genetic Immunity to Phenotypic Recapitulation in Zebrafish

Previous research has highlighted significant phenotypic discrepancies between knockout and knockdown approaches in zebrafish, raising concerns about the reliability of these methods. However, our study suggests that these differences are not as pronounced as was once believed. By carefully examining the roles of maternal and zygotic gene contributions, we demonstrate that these factors significantly influence phenotypic outcomes, often accounting for the observed discrepancies. Our findings emphasize that morpholinos, despite their potential off-target effects, can be effective tools when used with rigorous controls. We introduce the concept of graded maternal contribution, which explains how the uneven distribution of maternal mRNA and proteins during gametogenesis impacts phenotypic variability. Our research categorizes genes into three types-susceptible, immune, and "Schrödinger" (conditional)-based on their phenotypic expression and interaction with genetic compensation mechanisms. This distinction provides new insights into the paradoxical outcomes observed in genetic studies. Ultimately, our work underscores the importance of considering both maternal and zygotic contributions, alongside rigorous experimental controls, to accurately interpret gene function and the mechanisms underlying disease. This study advocates for the continued use of morpholinos in conjunction with advanced genetic tools like CRISPR/Cas9, stressing the need for a meticulous experimental design to optimize the utility of zebrafish in genetic research and therapeutic development.

Male germ cell-associated kinase is required for axoneme formation during ciliogenesis in zebrafish photoreceptors

Vertebrate photoreceptors are highly specialized retinal neurons that have cilium-derived membrane organelles called outer segments, which function as platforms for phototransduction. Male germ cell-associated kinase (MAK) is a cilium-associated serine/threonine kinase, and its genetic mutation causes photoreceptor degeneration in mice and retinitis pigmentosa in humans. However, the role of MAK in photoreceptors is not fully understood. Here, we report that zebrafish mak mutants show rapid photoreceptor degeneration during embryonic development. In mak mutants, both cone and rod photoreceptors completely lacked outer segments and underwent apoptosis. Interestingly, zebrafish mak mutants failed to generate axonemes during photoreceptor ciliogenesis, whereas basal bodies were specified. These data suggest that Mak contributes to axoneme development in zebrafish, in contrast to mouse Mak mutants, which have elongated photoreceptor axonemes. Furthermore, the kinase activity of Mak was found to be critical in ciliary axoneme development and photoreceptor survival. Thus, Mak is required for ciliogenesis and outer segment formation in zebrafish photoreceptors to ensure intracellular protein transport and photoreceptor survival.

The binding of LARP6 and DNAAF6 in biomolecular condensates influences ciliogenesis of multiciliated cells

Motile cilia on the cell surface produce fluid flows in the body and abnormalities in motile cilia cause primary ciliary dyskinesia. Dynein axonemal assembly factor 6 (DNAAF6), a causative gene of primary ciliary dyskinesia, was isolated as an interacting protein with La ribonucleoprotein 6 (LARP6) that regulates ciliogenesis in multiciliated cells (MCCs). In MCCs of Xenopus embryos, LARP6 and DNAAF6 were colocalized in biomolecular condensates termed dynein axonemal particles and synergized to control ciliogenesis. Moreover, tubulin alpha 1c-like mRNA encoding α-tubulin protein, that is a major component of ciliary axoneme, was identified as a target mRNA regulated by binding LARP6. While DNAAF6 was necessary for high α-tubulin protein expression near the apical side of Xenopus MCCs during ciliogenesis, its mutant, which abolishes binding with LARP6, was unable to restore the expression of α-tubulin protein near the apical side of MCCs in Xenopus DNAAF6 morphant. These results indicated that the binding of LARP6 and DNAAF6 in dynein axonemal particles regulates highly expressed α-tubulin protein near the apical side of Xenopus MCCs during ciliogenesis.

The challenge of dissecting gene function in model organisms: Tools to characterize genetic mutants and assess transcriptional adaptation in zebrafish

Genome editing technologies including the CRISPR/Cas9 system have greatly improved our knowledge of gene function and biological processes, however, these approaches have also brought new challenges to determining genotype-phenotype correlations. In this chapter, we briefly review gene-editing technologies used in zebrafish and discuss the differences in phenotypes that can arise when gene expression is inhibited by anti-sense or by gene editing techniques. We outline possible explanations for why knockout phenotypes are milder, tissue-restricted, or even absent, compared with severe knockdown phenotypes. One proposed explanation is transcriptional adaptation, a form of genetic robustness that is induced by deleterious mutations but not gene knockdowns. Although much is unknown about what triggers this process, its relevance in shaping genome expression has been shown in multiple animal models. We recently explored if transcriptional adaptation could explain genotype-phenotype discrepancies seen between two zebrafish models of the centrosomal protein Cep290 deficiency. We compared cilia-related phenotypes in knockdown (anti-sense) and knockout (mutation) Cep290 models and showed that only cep290 gene mutation induces the upregulation of genes encoding the cilia-associated small GTPases Arl3, Arl13b, and Unc119b. Importantly, the ectopic expression of Arl3, Arl13b, and Unc119b in cep290 morphant zebrafish embryos rescued cilia defects. Here we provide protocols and experimental approaches that can be used to explore if transcriptional adaptation may be modulating gene expression in a zebrafish ciliary mutant model.

Model organisms for functional validation in genetic renal disease

Functional validation is key for establishing new disease genes in human genetics. Over the years, model organisms have been utilized in a very effective manner to prove causality of genes or genetic variants for a wide variety of diseases. Also in hereditary renal disease, model organisms are very helpful for functional validation of candidate genes and variants identified by next-generation sequencing strategies and for obtaining insights into the pathophysiology. Due to high genetic conservation as well as high anatomical and physiological similarities with the human kidney, almost all genetic kidney diseases can be studied in the mouse. However, mouse work is time consuming and expensive, so there is a need for alternative models. In this review, we will provide an overview of model organisms used in renal research, focusing on mouse, zebrafish, frog, and fruit flies.

Variable phenotypes and penetrance between and within different zebrafish ciliary transition zone mutants

Meckel syndrome, nephronophthisis, Joubert syndrome and Bardet-Biedl syndrome are caused by mutations in proteins that localize to the ciliary transition zone (TZ). The phenotypically distinct syndromes suggest that these TZ proteins have differing functions. However, mutations in a single TZ gene can result in multiple syndromes, suggesting that the phenotype is influenced by modifier genes. We performed a comprehensive analysis of ten zebrafish TZ mutants, including mks1, tmem216, tmem67, rpgrip1l, cc2d2a, b9d2, cep290, tctn1, nphp1 and nphp4, as well as mutants in ift88 and ift172. Our data indicate that variations in phenotypes exist between different TZ mutants, supporting different tissue-specific functions of these TZ genes. Further, we observed phenotypic variations within progeny of a single TZ mutant, reminiscent of multiple disease syndromes being associated with mutations in one gene. In some mutants, the dynamics of the phenotype became complex with transitory phenotypes that are corrected over time. We also demonstrated that multiple-guide-derived CRISPR/Cas9 F0 'crispant' embryos recapitulate zygotic null phenotypes, and rapidly identified ciliary phenotypes in 11 cilia-associated gene candidates (ankfn1, ccdc65, cfap57, fhad1, nme7, pacrg, saxo2, c1orf194, ttc26, zmynd12 and cfap52).

The inner junction protein CFAP20 functions in motile and non-motile cilia and is critical for vision

Motile and non-motile cilia are associated with mutually-exclusive genetic disorders. Motile cilia propel sperm or extracellular fluids, and their dysfunction causes primary ciliary dyskinesia. Non-motile cilia serve as sensory/signalling antennae on most cell types, and their disruption causes single-organ ciliopathies such as retinopathies or multi-system syndromes. CFAP20 is a ciliopathy candidate known to modulate motile cilia in unicellular eukaryotes. We demonstrate that in zebrafish, cfap20 is required for motile cilia function, and in C. elegans, CFAP-20 maintains the structural integrity of non-motile cilia inner junctions, influencing sensory-dependent signalling and development. Human patients and zebrafish with CFAP20 mutations both exhibit retinal dystrophy. Hence, CFAP20 functions within a structural/functional hub centered on the inner junction that is shared between motile and non-motile cilia, and is distinct from other ciliopathy-associated domains or macromolecular complexes. Our findings suggest an uncharacterised pathomechanism for retinal dystrophy, and potentially for motile and non-motile ciliopathies in general.

Zebrafish and inherited photoreceptor disease: Models and insights

Photoreceptor dysfunctions and degenerative diseases are significant causes of vision loss in patients, with few effective treatments available. Targeted interventions to prevent or reverse photoreceptor-related vision loss are not possible without a thorough understanding of the underlying mechanism leading to disease, which is exceedingly difficult to accomplish in the human system. Cone diseases are particularly challenging to model, as some popular genetically modifiable model animals are nocturnal with a rod-dominant visual system and cones that have dissimilarities to human cones. As a result, cone diseases, which affect visual acuity, colour perception, and central vision in patients, are generally poorly understood in terms of pathology and mechanism. Zebrafish (Danio rerio) provide the opportunity to model photoreceptor diseases in a diurnal vertebrate with a cone-rich retina which develops many macular degeneration-like pathologies. Zebrafish undergo external development, allowing early-onset retinal diseases to be detected and studied, and many ophthalmic tools are available for zebrafish visual assessment during development and adulthood. There are numerous zebrafish models of photoreceptor disease, spanning the various types of photoreceptor disease (developmental, rod, cone, and mixed photoreceptor diseases) and genetic/molecular cause. In this review, we explore the features of zebrafish that make them uniquely poised to model cone diseases, summarize the established zebrafish models of inherited photoreceptor disease, and discuss how disease in these models compares to the human presentation, where applicable. Further, we highlight the contributions of these zebrafish models to our understanding of photoreceptor biology and disease, and discuss future directions for utilising and investigating these diverse models.

Insights Gained From Zebrafish Models for the Ciliopathy Joubert Syndrome

Cilia are quasi-ubiquitous microtubule-based sensory organelles, which play vital roles in signal transduction during development and cell homeostasis. Dysfunction of cilia leads to a group of Mendelian disorders called ciliopathies, divided into different diagnoses according to clinical phenotype constellation and genetic causes. Joubert syndrome (JBTS) is a prototypical ciliopathy defined by a diagnostic cerebellar and brain stem malformation termed the “Molar Tooth Sign” (MTS), in addition to which patients display variable combinations of typical ciliopathy phenotypes such as retinal dystrophy, fibrocystic renal disease, polydactyly or skeletal dystrophy. Like most ciliopathies, JBTS is genetically highly heterogeneous with ∼40 associated genes. Zebrafish are widely used to model ciliopathies given the high conservation of ciliary genes and the variety of specialized cilia types similar to humans. In this review, we compare different existing JBTS zebrafish models with each other and describe their contributions to our understanding of JBTS pathomechanism. We find that retinal dystrophy, which is the most investigated ciliopathy phenotype in zebrafish ciliopathy models, is caused by distinct mechanisms according to the affected gene. Beyond this, differences in phenotypes in other organs observed between different JBTS-mutant models suggest tissue-specific roles for proteins implicated in JBTS. Unfortunately, the lack of systematic assessment of ciliopathy phenotypes in the mutants described in the literature currently limits the conclusions that can be drawn from these comparisons. In the future, the numerous existing JBTS zebrafish models represent a valuable resource that can be leveraged in order to gain further insights into ciliary function, pathomechanisms underlying ciliopathy phenotypes and to develop treatment strategies using small molecules.

Generation and characterization of Ccdc28b mutant mice links the Bardet-Biedl associated gene with mild social behavioral phenotypes

CCDC28B (coiled-coil domain-containing protein 28B) was identified as a modifier in the ciliopathy Bardet-Biedl syndrome (BBS). Our previous work in cells and zebrafish showed that CCDC28B plays a role regulating cilia length in a mechanism that is not completely understood. Here we report the generation of a Ccdc28b mutant mouse using CRISPR/Cas9 (Ccdc28b mut). Depletion of CCDC28B resulted in a mild phenotype. Ccdc28b mut animals i) do not present clear structural cilia affectation, although we did observe mild defects in cilia density and cilia length in some tissues, ii) reproduce normally, and iii) do not develop retinal degeneration or obesity, two hallmark features of reported BBS murine models. In contrast, Ccdc28b mut mice did show clear social interaction defects as well as stereotypical behaviors. This finding is indeed relevant regarding CCDC28B as a modifier of BBS since behavioral phenotypes have been documented in BBS. Overall, this work reports a novel mouse model that will be key to continue evaluating genetic interactions in BBS, deciphering the contribution of CCDC28B to modulate the presentation of BBS phenotypes. In addition, our data underscores a novel link between CCDC28B and behavioral defects, providing a novel opportunity to further our understanding of the genetic, cellular, and molecular basis of these complex phenotypes.

BBS is caused by mutations in any one of 22 genes known to date. In some families, BBS can be inherited as an oligogenic trait whereby mutations in more than one BBS gene collaborate in the presentation of the syndrome. In addition, CCDC28B was originally identified as a modifier of BBS, whereby a reduction in CCDC28B levels was associated with a more severe presentation of the syndrome. Different mechanisms, all relying on functional redundancy, have been proposed to explain these genetic interactions. The characterization of BBS proteins supported this functional redundancy hypothesis: BBS proteins play a role in cilia maintenance/function and subsets of BBS proteins can even interact directly in multiprotein complexes.

We have previously shown that CCDC28B also participates in cilia biology regulating the length of the organelle: knockdown of CCDC28B in cells results in cilia shortening and targeting ccdc28b in zebrafish also results in early embryonic phenotypes characteristic of other cilia mutants. In this work, we generated a Ccdc28b mutant mouse to determine whether abrogating Ccdc28b function would be sufficient to cause a ciliopathy phenotype in mammals, and to generate a tool to continue dissecting its modifying role in the context of BBS. Overall, Ccdc28b mutant mice presented a mild phenotype, a finding fully compatible with its role as a modifier, rather than a causal BBS gene. In addition, we found that Ccdc28b mutants showed behavioral phenotypes, similar to the deficits observed in rodent autism spectrum disorder (ASD) models. Thus, our results underscore a novel causal link between CCDC28B and behavioral phenotypes in mice.

The ARF GAPs ELMOD1 and ELMOD3 act at the Golgi and cilia to regulate ciliogenesis and ciliary protein traffic

ELMODs are a family of three mammalian paralogues that display GTPase-activating protein (GAP) activity toward a uniquely broad array of ADP-ribosylation factor (ARF) family GTPases that includes ARF-like (ARL) proteins. ELMODs are ubiquitously expressed in mammalian tissues, highly conserved across eukaryotes, and ancient in origin, being present in the last eukaryotic common ancestor. We described functions of ELMOD2 in immortalized mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) in the regulation of cell division, microtubules, ciliogenesis, and mitochondrial fusion. Here, using similar strategies with the paralogues ELMOD1 and ELMOD3, we identify novel functions and locations of these cell regulators and compare them to those of ELMOD2, allowing the determination of functional redundancy among the family members. We found strong similarities in phenotypes resulting from deletion of either Elmod1 or Elmod3 and marked differences from those arising in Elmod2 deletion lines. Deletion of either Elmod1 or Elmod3 results in the decreased ability of cells to form primary cilia, loss of a subset of proteins from cilia, and accumulation of some ciliary proteins at the Golgi, predicted to result from compromised traffic from the Golgi to cilia. These phenotypes are reversed upon activating mutant expression of either ARL3 or ARL16, linking their roles to ELMOD1/3 actions.

Zebrafish models of inherited retinal dystrophies

Inherited retinal degenerations (IRDs) cause permanent vision impairment or vision loss due to the death of rod and cone photoreceptors. Animal models of IRDs have been instrumental in providing knowledge of the pathological mechanisms that cause photoreceptor death and in developing successful approaches that could slow or prevent vision loss. Zebrafish models of IRDs represent an ideal model system to study IRDs in a cone-rich retina and to test strategies that exploit the natural ability to regenerate damaged neurons. This review highlights those zebrafish mutants and transgenic lines that exhibit adult-onset retinal degeneration and serve as models of retinitis pigmentosa, cone-rod dystrophy, and ciliopathies.

First person – Magdalena Cardenas-Rodriguez

First Person is a series of interviews with the first authors of a selection of papers published in Journal of Cell Science, helping early-career researchers promote themselves alongside their papers. Magdalena Cardenas-Rodriguez is first author on ‘ Genetic compensation for cilia defects in cep290 mutants by upregulation of cilia-associated small GTPases’, published in JCS. Magdalena is a research assistant in the lab of Jose Luis Badano at Human Molecular Genetics Laboratory, Institut Pasteur de Montevideo, Montevideo, Uruguay, investigating the cellular processes that are altered in cilia-related human diseases.