Why is there no carbonic anhydrase activity available to fish plasma?

The physiological significance of plasma-accessible carbonic anhydrase in the respiratory systems of fishes

Carbonic anhydrase (CA) activity is ubiquitously found in all vertebrate species, tissues and cellular compartments. Most species have plasma-accessible CA (paCA) isoforms at the respiratory surfaces, where the enzyme catalyzes the conversion of plasma bicarbonate to carbon dioxide (CO2) that can be excreted by diffusion. A notable exception are the teleost fishes that appear to lack paCA at their gills. The present review: (i) recapitulates the significance of CA activity and distribution in vertebrates; (ii) summarizes the current evidence for the presence or absence of paCA at the gills of fishes, from the basal cyclostomes to the derived teleosts and extremophiles such as the Antarctic icefishes; (iii) explores the contribution of paCA to organismal CO2 excretion in fishes; and (iv) the functional significance of its absence at the gills, for the specialized system of O2 transport in most teleosts; (v) outlines the multiplicity and isoform distribution of membrane-associated CAs in fishes and methodologies to determine their plasma-accessible orientation; and (vi) sketches a tentative time line for the evolutionary dynamics of branchial paCA distribution in the major groups of fishes. Finally, this review highlights current gaps in the knowledge on branchial paCA function and provides recommendations for future work.

Developing rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) lose branchial plasma accessible carbonic anhydrase expression with hatch and the transition to pH-sensitive, adult hemoglobin polymorphs

Salmonids possess a unique respiratory system comprised of three major components: highly pH-sensitive hemoglobins, red blood cell (RBC) intracellular pH (pHi) protection, and a heterogeneous distribution of plasma accessible carbonic anhydrase (paCA), specifically with absence of paCA at the gills. These characteristics are thought to have evolved to enhance oxygen unloading to the tissues while protecting uptake at the gills. Our knowledge of this system is detailed in adults, but little is known about it through development. Developing rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) express embryonic RBCs containing hemoglobins that are relatively insensitive to pH; however, availability of gill paCA and RBC pHi protection is unknown. We show that pre-hatch rainbow trout express gill paCA, which is lost in correlation with the emergence of highly pH-sensitive adult hemoglobins and RBC pHi protection. Rainbow trout therefore exhibit a switch in respiratory strategy with hatch. We conclude that gill paCA likely represents an embryonic trait in rainbow trout and is constrained in adults due to their highly pH-sensitive hemoglobins.

An investigation of gill and blood carbonic anhydrase characteristics in three basal actinopterygian species: alligator gar (Atractosteus spatula), white sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus) and Senegal bichir (Polypterus senegalus)

Many teleosts possess a unique set of respiratory characteristics allowing enhanced oxygen unloading to the tissues during stress. This system comprises three major components: highly pH sensitive haemoglobins (large Bohr and Root effects), rapid red blood cell (RBC) intracellular pH (pHi) protection, and a heterogeneous distribution of membrane-bound plasma-accessible carbonic anhydrase (paCA; absence in the gills). The first two components have received considerable research effort; however, the evolutionary loss of branchial paCA has received little attention. In the current study, we investigated the availability of branchial membrane-bound CA, along with several other CA-related characteristics in species belonging to three basal actinopterygian groups: the Lepisosteiformes, Acipenseriformes and Polypteriformes to assess the earlier hypothesis that Root effect haemoglobins constrain branchial paCA availability. We present the first evidence suggesting branchial membrane-bound CA presence in a basal actinopterygian species: the Senegal bichir (Polypterus senegalus) and show that like the teleosts, white sturgeon (Acipenser transmontanus) and alligator gar (Atractosteus spatula) do not possess branchial membrane-bound CA. We discuss the varying respiratory strategies for these species and propose that branchial paCA may have been lost much earlier than previously thought, likely in relation to the changes in haemoglobin buffer capacity associated with the increasing magnitude of the Bohr effect. The findings described here represent an important advancement in our understanding of the evolution of the unique system of enhanced oxygen unloading thought to be present in most teleosts, a group that encompasses half of all vertebrates.

A novel perspective on the evolutionary loss of plasma-accessible carbonic anhydrase at the teleost gill

The gills of most teleost fishes lack plasma-accessible carbonic anhydrase (paCA) that could participate in CO2 excretion. We tested the prevailing hypothesis that paCA would interfere with red blood cell (RBC) intracellular pH regulation by β-adrenergic sodium-proton exchangers (β-NHE) that protect pH-sensitive haemoglobin-oxygen (Hb-O2) binding during an acidosis. In an open system that mimics the gills, β-NHE activity increased Hb-O2 saturation during a respiratory acidosis in the presence or absence of paCA, whereas the effect was abolished by NHE inhibition. However, in a closed system that mimics the tissue capillaries, paCA disrupted the protective effects of β-NHE activity on Hb-O2 binding. The gills are an open system, where CO2 generated by paCA can diffuse out and is not available to acidifying the RBCs. Therefore, branchial paCA in teleosts may not interfere with RBC pH regulation by β-NHEs, and other explanations for the evolutionary loss of the enzyme must be considered.

Blood and Gill Carbonic Anhydrase in the Context of a Chondrichthyan Model of CO2 Excretion

Pacific spiny dogfish (Squalus suckleyi) have been widely used as a representative species for chondrichthyan CO₂ excretion. Pacific spiny dogfish have a slower red blood cell (RBC) carbonic anhydrase (CA) isoform than teleost fishes, extracellular CA activity, no endogenous plasma CA inhibitor, and plasma-accessible CA IV at the gills. Thus, both the RBC and plasma compartments contribute to bicarbonate ion (HCO3-) dehydration at the gills for CO₂ excretion in contrast to teleost fishes, in which HCO3- dehydration is restricted to RBCs. We compared CA activity levels, subcellular localization, and presence of plasma CA inhibitors in the blood and gills of 13 chondrichthyans to examine the hypothesis that the dogfish model of CO₂ excretion applies broadly to chondrichthyans. In general, blood samples from the 12 other chondrichthyans examined had lower RBC CA activity than teleosts, some extracellular CA activity, and no endogenous plasma CA inhibitor. While type IV-like membrane-associated CA was found in the gills in all four of the chondrichthyans examined, S. suckleyi had three times more CA activity (183±13.2 μmol CO₂ min^-1 mg protein^-1) in the microsomal (membrane) fraction of gills than the other three. In addition, unexpected variation in CA characteristics was observed between chondrichthyan species. Thus, in general, it appears that the pattern of CA distribution in fishes can be generally categorized as either chondrichthyan or teleost models. However, further studies should examine the functional significance of the within-chondrichthyan differences we observed and investigate whether CO₂ excretion patterns exist along a continuum or in discrete groups.

A unique mode of tissue oxygenation and the adaptive radiation of teleost fishes

Teleost fishes constitute 95% of extant aquatic vertebrates, and we suggest that this is related in part to their unique mode of tissue oxygenation. We propose the following sequence of events in the evolution of their oxygen delivery system. First, loss of plasma-accessible carbonic anhydrase (CA) in the gill and venous circulations slowed the Jacobs-Stewart cycle and the transfer of acid between the plasma and the red blood cells (RBCs). This ameliorated the effects of a generalised acidosis (associated with an increased capacity for burst swimming) on haemoglobin (Hb)-O2 binding. Because RBC pH was uncoupled from plasma pH, the importance of Hb as a buffer was reduced. The decrease in buffering was mediated by a reduction in the number of histidine residues on the Hb molecule and resulted in enhanced coupling of O2 and CO2 transfer through the RBCs. In the absence of plasma CA, nearly all plasma bicarbonate ultimately dehydrated to CO2 occurred via the RBCs, and chloride/bicarbonate exchange was the rate-limiting step in CO2 excretion. This pattern of CO2 excretion across the gills resulted in disequilibrium states for CO2 hydration/dehydration reactions and thus elevated arterial and venous plasma bicarbonate levels. Plasma-accessible CA embedded in arterial endothelia was retained, which eliminated the localized bicarbonate disequilibrium forming CO2 that then moved into the RBCs. Consequently, RBC pH decreased which, in conjunction with pH-sensitive Bohr/Root Hbs, elevated arterial oxygen tensions and thus enhanced tissue oxygenation. Counter-current arrangement of capillaries (retia) at the eye and later the swim bladder evolved along with the gas gland at the swim bladder. Both arrangements enhanced and magnified CO2 and acid production and, therefore, oxygen secretion to those specialised tissues. The evolution of β-adrenergically stimulated RBC Na(+)/H(+) exchange protected gill O2 uptake during stress and further augmented plasma disequilibrium states for CO2 hydration/dehydration. Finally, RBC organophosphates (e.g. NTP) could be reduced during hypoxia to further increase Hb-O2 affinity without compromising tissue O2 delivery because high-affinity Hbs could still adequately deliver O2 to the tissues via Bohr/Root shifts. We suggest that the evolution of this unique mode of tissue O2 transfer evolved in the Triassic/Jurassic Period, when O2 levels were low, ultimately giving rise to the most extensive adaptive radiation of extant vertebrates, the teleost fishes.

Validation of the i-STAT system for the analysis of blood parameters in fish

Portable clinical analysers, such as the i-STAT system, are increasingly being used for blood analysis in animal ecology and physiology because of their portability and easy operation. Although originally conceived for clinical application and to replace robust but lengthy techniques, researchers have extended the use of the i-STAT system outside of humans and even to poikilothermic fish, with only limited validation. The present study analysed a range of blood parameters [pH, haematocrit (Hct), haemoglobin (Hb), HCO3 (-), partial pressure of CO2 (PCO2), partial pressure of O2 (PO2), Hb saturation (sO2) and Na(+) concentration] in a model teleost fish (rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss) using the i-STAT system (CG8+ cartridges) and established laboratory techniques. This methodological comparison was performed at two temperatures (10 and 20°C), two haematocrits (low and high) and three PCO2 levels (0.5, 1.0 and 1.5%). Our results indicate that pH was measured accurately with the i-STAT system over a physiological pH range and using the i-STAT temperature correction. Haematocrit was consistently underestimated by the i-STAT, while the measurements of Na(+), PCO2, HCO3 (-) and PO2 were variably inaccurate over the range of values typically found in fish. The algorithm that the i-STAT uses to calculate sO2 did not yield meaningful results on rainbow trout blood. Application of conversion factors to correct i-STAT measurements is not recommended, due to significant effects of temperature, Hct and PCO2 on the measurement errors and complex interactions may exist. In conclusion, the i-STAT system can easily generate fast results from rainbow trout whole blood, but many are inaccurate values.

Carbonic anhydrase activities from the rainbow trout lens correspond to the development of acute gas bubble disease

Dissolved gas supersaturation is hazardous to fish and can result in gas bubble disease (GBD). Signs of GBD typically include bubbles in the eyes, fins, skin, lateral line, and gill filaments. Ocular abnormalities in diseased salmonids typically occur after aberrant gas production in the eyes. In this study, freshwater rainbow trout Oncorhynchus mykiss were exposed experimentally to percent total gas pressure (TGP%) levels of 104% (control) and 115%. No mortalities occurred during the 7-d experimental period. Effects of GBD were observed externally as a darkened skin, exophthalmia, localized hemorrhage in the eye, and gas bubbles on the operculum. Additional signs included increased swimming activity and, more frequently, panic episodes. Carbonic anhydrase (CA) enzyme activities from the lens and retina were determined at days 0, 1, 3, 5, and 7 of the study. Venous blood gases were also measured on day 7. Retinal pH did not differ between normal and affected fish, but blood characteristics such as the partial pressure of O2, partial pressure of CO2, carboxyhemoglobin level, and bicarbonate ion concentration were significantly elevated in affected fish relative to normal fish. Venous blood pH and oxyhemoglobin levels were not significantly different between affected and normal fish. Patterns of response to total dissolved gas levels differed between the lens and the retina. Mean CA activities in the lenses of fish exposed to a TGP% level of 115% were significantly below those of control fish. However, retinal CA activities did not significantly differ between the two groups over the course of the experiment. These findings show that dissolved gas supersaturation reduces CA activity in the rainbow trout lens.

Plasma-accessible carbonic anhydrase at the tissue of a teleost fish may greatly enhance oxygen delivery: in vitro evidence in rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss

During a generalized acidosis in rainbow trout, catecholamines are released into the blood, activating red blood cell (RBC) Na+/H+ exchange (βNHE), thus protecting RBC intracellular pH (pHi) and subsequent O2 binding at the gill. Because of the presence of a Root effect (a reduction in oxygen carrying capacity of the blood with a reduction in pH), the latter could otherwise be impaired. However, plasma-accessible carbonic anhydrase (CA) at the tissues (and absence at the gills) may result in selective short-circuiting of RBC βNHE pH regulation. This would acidify the RBCs and greatly enhance O2 delivery by exploitation of the combined Bohr-Root effect, a mechanism not previously proposed. As proof-of-principle, an in vitro closed system was developed to continuously monitor extracellular pH (pHe) and O2 tension (PO2) of rainbow trout blood. In this closed system, adding CA to acidified, adrenergically stimulated RBCs short-circuited βNHE pH regulation, resulting in an increase in PO2 by >30 mmHg, depending on the starting Hb-O2 saturation and degree of initial acidification. Interestingly, in the absence of adrenergic stimulation, addition of CA still elevated PO2, albeit to a lesser extent, a response that was absent during general NHE inhibition. If plasma-accessible CA-mediated short-circuiting is operational in vivo, the combined Bohr-Root effect system unique to teleost fishes could markedly enhance tissue O2 delivery far in excess of that in vertebrates possessing a Bohr effect alone and may lead to insights about the early evolution of the Root effect.

Blood sampling techniques and storage duration: Effects on the presence and magnitude of the red blood cell β-adrenergic response in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss)

Many teleostean fish, including rainbow trout, regulate red blood cell (RBC) pH (pH(i)) in the presence of a stress-induced acidosis such as hypoxia, hypercapnia, or exhaustive exercise. This is accomplished through activation of RBC Na+/H+ exchange (beta-NHE), ultimately minimizing impairment to oxygen transport. Presence and characterization of the RBC beta-NHE in fish is best tested in blood from cannulated, resting animals; however, several studies have used blood from stressed animals drawn from the caudal vein and stored prior to use. The effects of sampling procedures and storage on the beta-NHE response is not known and is the focus of this study. Whole blood drawn from cannulated, resting rainbow trout was compared with RBCs obtained from the caudal vein rinsed and stored at 4 degrees C for 0, 6, 24, 48, 96 or 144 h. Isoproterenol (10(-5) M), a beta-adrenergic agonist, was added to hypoxia/hypercapnia incubated RBCs in vitro. In all treatments, isoproterenol induced a large beta-NHE response, and storage duration (< or =96 h) had a minimal affect, indicating that rinsing and storing is an easy and viable means by which to obtain RBCs and investigate function. Storage for 144 h still resulted in a significant RBC beta-NHE response; however, viability of RBCs may be compromised.

Pulmonary carbonic anhydrase in vertebrate gas exchange organs

Carbonic anhydrase (CA) catalyzes the interconversion of CO(2) and HCO(3)(-). Intracellular (extravascular) and intravascular (extracellular) CA has been identified and localized in the lungs of reptiles and mammals. Less information is known, however, on the presence of intravascular CA in the lungs of amphibians and avians. In the present study, perfusion studies were used to compare the catalytic activity of pulmonary intravascular CA in reptiles and mammals. In addition, SDS-resistant CA activity was examined in microsomal fractions prepared from gill/lung tissue from representative animals in each vertebrate class. Finally, the CNO(-) sensitivity of the microsomal CA activity was compared. No SDS-resistant CA activity was found in gill microsomal fractions of several fish species. In contrast, the data suggest that SDS-resistant, intravascular pulmonary CA activity is present in air-breathing vertebrates with vastly differing lung morphologies and that the kinetics of inhibition is remarkably comparable between the vertebrate classes.

Sensing and transfer of respiratory gases at the fish gill

The gill is both a site of gas transfer and an important location of chemoreception or gas sensing in fish. While often considered separately, these two processes are clearly intricately related because the gases that are transferred between the ventilatory water and blood at the gill are simultaneously sensed by chemoreceptors on, and within, the gill. Modulation of chemoreceptor discharge in response to changes in O(2) and CO(2) levels, in turn, is believed to initiate a series of coordinated cardiorespiratory reflexes aimed at optimising branchial gas transfer. The past decade has yielded numerous advances in terms of our understanding of gas transfer and gas sensing at the fish gill, particularly concerning the transfer and sensing of carbon dioxide. In addition, recent research has moved from striving to construct a single model that covers all fish species, to recognition of the considerable inter-specific variation that exists with respect to the mechanics of gas transfer and the cardiorespiratory responses of fish to changes in O(2) and CO(2) levels. The following review attempts to integrate gas transfer and gas sensing at the fish gill by exploring recent advances in these areas.

Apparent diffusion limitations for CO(2) excretion in rainbow trout are relieved by injections of carbonic anhydrase

Experiments were performed in vivo to elucidate the underlying mechanism(s) of apparent diffusion limitations for CO(2) excretion in rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Ligation of two gill arches and the associated expected reduction in gill surface area of 30% caused pronounced respiratory acidosis as indicated by elevated arterial blood P(CO(2)) (Pa(CO(2))) and reduced arterial blood pH. Under conditions of normoxia, arterial blood P(O(2)) (Pa(O(2))) was not significantly (statistically) reduced. However, during hypoxia (water P(O(2))=70-80 mmHg), the apparent trend for reduced Pa(O(2)) values became statistically significant in fish with 15% surface area reduction. To determine whether the elevated Pa(CO(2)) in fish with reduced surface area (30%) reflected true diffusion limitations or chemical equilibrium limitations imposed by the relatively slow rate of red blood cell Cl(-)/HCO(3)(-) exchange, fish were injected with carbonic anhydrase (CA) to permit catalysis of HCO(3)(-) dehydration within the plasma. Injection of CA caused a lowering of Pa(CO(2)) by 0.87+/-0.32 mmHg within 120 min and thus essentially eliminated the increase in Pa(CO(2)) (1.04+/-0.33 mmHg) that was caused by the reduction in surface area. These results clearly demonstrate that the elevation in Pa(CO(2)) evoked by gill surface area reduction is a consequence of chemical equilibrium limitations rather than true diffusion limitations, per se.

The distribution and physiological significance of carbonic anhydrase in vertebrate gas exchange organs

The enzyme carbonic anhydrase (CA) catalyzes the reversible hydration/dehydration of CO(2) and water, maintaining a near-instantaneous equilibrium among all chemical species involved in the reaction. CA is found in association with all tissue and organ systems involved in the transport and excretion of CO(2), from the site of CO(2) production, metabolically active tissue such as muscle, to circulating red blood cells in the vasculature, to the various organs of gas exchange, the lungs and gills. The presence of the enzyme in every fluid compartment along the pathway of CO(2) transport appears necessary in order to allow the dehydration of HCO(3)(-) to keep pace with the rapid diffusion of CO(2) across biological membranes. Within the actual organ of gas exchange, CA is compartmentalized in multiple subcellular fractions, with the specific subcellular localization determining the enzyme's physiological function.

Carbonic anhydrase and red blood cell anion exchange in the neotenic aquatic salamander, Necturus maculosus

Carbonic anhydrase (CA) activity in blood and other tissues and red blood cell (rbc) anion exchange were measured in the mud puppy, Necturus maculosus, in order to gain insight into the strategy for CO2 transport used by these neotenic salamanders and to further explore evolutionary relationships between rbc CA activity and anion exchange in nonmammalian vertebrates. CA activity was detectable in all of the tissues examined, but CA activity in blood was much lower than that in most vertebrates. There was no indication, however, that additional CA had been incorporated into the membrane fraction of other tissues to compensate for this low blood CA activity. In further contrast to most other animals, low levels of CA activity were also detectable in mud puppy plasma. Preliminary characterization of the rbc CA indicated that the Type II, fast-turnover enzyme was indeed present, but that there are a very low number of active sites in mud puppy rbc's. Further experiments showed that the rbc's were highly permeable to anions and that the relative rate of anion flux could be inhibited by 4, 4-diisothiocyanostilbene-2,2-disulphonic acid. Thus, the process of CO2 transport in the blood of mud puppies probably involves components of the Jacobs-Stewart cycle, as in most other vertebrates.

Interactions between ion and gas transfer in freshwater teleost fish

Carbonic anhydrase and proton ATPase are co-distributed, being restricted to the apical regions of the gill epithelium of freshwater teleosts. Carbonic anhydrase supplies protons to the apical proton ATPase. Carbonic anhydrase is absent from the basal regions of the gill epithelium. Plasma flowing through the gills has no available carbonic anhydrase activity and plasma CO2/bicarbonate reactions are uncatalyzed. Thus, bicarbonate dehydration in plasma is negligible, and catalyzed bicarbonate dehydration occurs in erythrocytes in blood flowing through the gills. This results in tight coupling of carbon dioxide excretion to oxygen uptake and the evolution of hemoglobins with large Haldane effects but low buffering capacities, typical of many freshwater teleosts. Tight coupling of carbon dioxide and oxygen transfer in these fish also ensures that the Root shift does not impair oxygen uptake at the gills. Under these conditions, there is a selective advantage for hemoglobins with a Root shift. The presence of a Root shift augments oxygen transfer to the tissues in general and the eye and swimbladder in particular.