Partial versus radical cystectomy in localized colorectal cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis

PURPOSE

Locally advanced colorectal tumors frequently invade adjacent organs, particularly the urinary bladder in the sigmoid colon and upper rectum, complicating multivisceral resections. This study compared postoperative outcomes of partial cystectomy (PC) and total cystectomy (TC) in patients with locally advanced colorectal cancer.

METHODS

A systematic review was conducted in PubMed, Scopus, Central Register of Clinical Trials, and Web of Science for studies published up to November 2024. Odds ratios (ORs) and mean differences (MDs) with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were pooled using a random-effects model. Heterogeneity was assessed with I2 statistics. Statistical analyses were performed in R Software 4.4.1.

RESULTS

Nine retrospective studies including 894 patients were analyzed. Among them, 433 (48.43%) underwent PC, and 461 (51.57%) underwent TC. Compared to TC, PC was associated with significantly lower rates of surgical site infection (OR 0.33; 95% CI 0.13-0.80; p = 0.015), shorter operative time (MD - 169.7 min; 95% CI - 214.1 to - 125.3; p < 0.01), reduced blood loss (MD - 1005.9 ml; 95% CI - 1362.1 to - 649.8; p < 0.01), and shorter hospital stay (MD - 6.6 days; 95% CI - 9.4 to - 3.9; p < 0.01). No significant differences were observed between groups in local or distant recurrence, urinary and intestinal leaks, pelvic abscess, ileus, urinary tract infection, or 90-day mortality.

CONCLUSION

Partial cystectomy demonstrated superior postoperative outcomes, including fewer surgical site infections, reduced operative time, less blood loss, and shorter hospitalization. Oncological outcomes and other postoperative complications were comparable between PC and TC, supporting PC as a safe and effective option in selected patients.

Development of a CT radiomics model for detection of bladder invasion by colorectal carcinoma

To investigate the feasibility of a radiomics model for the detection of bladder invasion (BI) by colorectal cancer (CRC) on CT images. Ninety-six patients with CRC and a suspicion of BI who underwent tumor resection with partial or total cystectomy were reviewed. The 96 patients were randomly assigned to the training dataset (n = 68) or test dataset (n = 28) at a ratio of 7:3. The CT images were reviewed by two experienced radiologists, who provided a CT impression of the invasion of the bladder by CRC. A region of interest (ROI) on the CT images for each case was manually labeled by two radiologists. A radiomics model was constructed using a Categorical Boosting (CatBoost) classifier. The predicted probability by CatBoost was used to evaluate the efficacy of the radiomics model. The areas under the curve (AUCs) of the receiver operating characteristic were compared between the radiomics model and the CT impression. In the training dataset, the AUC of the radiomic model [0.864 (95% CI: 0.778, 0.951)] was significantly greater than that of CT impression [0.678 (95% CI: 0.569. 0.786), P = 0.007]. In the test dataset, the AUC of the radiomic model [0.883 (95% CI: 0.699, 1.000)] was also significantly greater than that of CT impression [0.570 (95% CI: 0.370, 0.770), P = 0.040]. It is feasible to use radiomics models for the prediction of BI by CRC, which might perform better than human radiologists.

Survival after urological resections in colorectal cancer - a Swedish nationwide study

BACKGROUND

Colorectal cancer with overgrowth into urinary organs requires en-bloc resection of involved organs to achieve negative resection margins (R0). This study investigates survival and oncological outcomes after colorectal cancer surgery with resections of urinary organs.

METHOD

Patients undergoing colorectal cancer surgery with urological resection in Sweden 2007-2018 were identified via the Swedish Colorectal Cancer Registry using the variable "resection of another organ".

RESULTS

A total of 57 907 patients underwent colorectal cancer resection, and 1093 patients had concomitant urological resections: 589 total cystectomies, 345 partial cystectomies, and 159 ureteral resections. The majority undergoing total or partial cystectomy were men (442 (75 %) and 271 (63 %), respectively). R0 was obtained in 509/589 patients (86 %), 296/345 patients (86 %), and 134/169 patients (84 %) for total cystectomy, partial cystectomy, and ureteral resection, respectively. Five-year overall survival rates were 361 patients (61 %) after total cystectomy, 201 patients (58 %) after partial cystectomy, and 85 patients (53 %) after ureteral resection (Kaplan-Meier, Log-rank test p = 0.205). Multivariable analyses adjusted for sex, age, ASA classification, tumour localisation (colon/rectum), cTNM, pTN, year of surgery, and type of surgery (emergency/elective) revealed higher local recurrence rate in the ureteral resection group (hazard ratio: 2.290, 95 % CI: 1.166-4.498), while 5-year overall survival and distant metastases rates did not differ.

CONCLUSION

Partial cystectomy may represent an option to total cystectomy in selected patients with colorectal cancer overgrowth on urinary organs while maintaining favourable survival and oncological outcomes. Still, selection bias is an inherent problem in the interpretation of results.

Partial cystectomy as a surgical option for colorectal cancer patients with pathological bladder invasion: an original retrospective study

Background

Limited research exists on colorectal cancer (CRC) patients with bladder invasion, with survival outcomes post-cystectomy underexplored and a debate between partial and total cystectomy ongoing.

Objective

The study aimed to evaluate the effect of pathological bladder invasion on the long-term tumour prognosis of patients with clinically diagnosed bladder invasion in CRC after cystectomy.

Design

Retrospective, cohort study.

Methods

Our study involving 105 CRC patients with bladder invasion who had partial or total cystectomy from 2012 to 2020 collected surgical and pathological data. Groups were divided by pathological bladder invasion presence and compared for 3-year overall survival (OS) and recurrence-free survival (RFS) rates. Multiphoton imaging assessed collagen features in some samples.

Results

Pathological bladder invasion was confirmed in 50 patients (48%). Of 94 who had partial cystectomy, 41 were in the bladder invasion (+) group. The 3-year OS and RFS rates were 62.97% and 57.35% for the bladder invasion (+) group, and 77.16% and 58.68% for the bladder invasion (-) group, with no significant differences in recurrence rates between groups (p > 0.05). There are also no significant differences in 3-year local recurrence and intravesical recurrence rates between the two groups (18.62% vs 25.83%, 7.73% vs 11.82%, p > 0.05). Distant metastasis was identified as an independent risk factor for OS and RFS by univariate and multivariate Cox regression analyses. Of the 24 samples that underwent multi-photon imaging, 142 collagen features extracted did not show statistical differences.

Conclusion

Pathological bladder invasion impacts CRC patients' post-cystectomy survival may be less than what clinical practice implies. Partial cystectomy in cases with pathological bladder invasion might offer similar survival rates to total cystectomy.

Trial registration

ChiCTR2300077861.

Robotic Laparoscopy and Endoscopy Cooperative Surgery for Primary Appendiceal Mucinous Carcinoma Masquerading as Bladder Cancer: A Case Report

Bladder invasion by appendiceal cancer resulting in a vesico-appendiceal fistula is an uncommon occurrence. Both radical tumor removal and functional preservation of the bladder are desirable in the surgical treatment of this disease, and there are few reports on detailed surgical methods. Here, we describe a case of primary appendiceal mucinous carcinoma with bladder invasion treated with robotic laparoscopy and endoscopy cooperative surgery (RECS). A woman in her 60s was initially considered to be bladder tumor and underwent transurethral resection. However, the tumor rapidly regrew, and she was rediagnosed with primary appendiceal cancer invading the bladder. RECS was performed, involving ileocecal resection with partial cystectomy. The postoperative course was favorable, with no bladder anastomotic leakage or ureteral obstruction. In the RECS procedure, the robotic operability facilitates bladder wall repair, and simultaneous cystoscopic observation allows for identification of the ureteral orifices, making the combined bladder resection radical and safe.

Surgical outcomes of a partial or total cystectomy for colorectal cancer invasion of the bladder

BACKGROUND

Although a partial or total cystectomy may be performed for colorectal cancer (CRC) with bladder invasion, the indications for either procedure have not been established. The present study reports the oncological and functional outcomes of CRC in patients who underwent combined resection of the bladder and CRC via either a partial or total cystectomy.

METHODS

This retrospective study was conducted at a single center. A total of 107 consecutive patients with CRC who underwent colorectal surgery combined with partial or total cystectomy between January 2005 and August 2022 were enrolled. The short- and long-term outcomes of the surgery, especially postoperative bladder function, were assessed.

RESULTS

Ninety patients underwent partial resection and 17 patients underwent total resection. Forty-two patients (46.7 %) in the partial cystectomy group and 16 (94.1 %) in the total cystectomy group had histologically confirmed CRC with bladder invasion. The urinary-specific morbidity rate was 18.9 % in the partial cystectomy group and 15.6 % patients in the same group required treatment for dysuria at postoperative month 3. Of the patients who underwent partial cystectomy, five (5.6 %) experienced recurrence stemming from a bladder remnant. The cumulative distant recurrence rates did not differ significantly between patients who underwent partial cystectomy and those who underwent total cystectomy (41.9 % and 57.4 %, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Partial bladder resection contributes to the preservation of bladder function and yields oncologically acceptable outcomes.

Comparison of partial and total cystectomy for colorectal cancer with histologically confirmed bladder invasion

BACKGROUND

Although organs are preserved and quality of life is improved, insufficient evidence is available for the oncologic safety of partial cystectomy in patients with colorectal cancer with suspected bladder invasion. Therefore, we aimed to compare partial and total cystectomy outcomes in patients with pathologically confirmed or clinically suspected bladder invasion.

METHODS

Patients with colorectal cancer with suspected bladder invasion who underwent R0 resection from 2000 to 2020 were evaluated. Long-term outcomes were determined in patients with histologically confirmed bladder invasion.

RESULTS

Of the 151 consecutive patients, 96 (64.6%) had histologically confirmed bladder involvement, and 105 (69.5%) underwent partial cystectomy. Operative time, estimated blood loss, and reoperation rate in ≤30 days were significantly worse in the total cystectomy group than in the partial cystectomy group. The overall recurrence rate was significantly higher in the total cystectomy group than in the partial cystectomy group (39.1% vs 21.9%; P = .046). Five-year overall survival (75.8% vs 53.2%; P = .006) rates were higher in the partial cystectomy group than in the total cystectomy group; however, disease-free survival (60.8% vs 41.6%; P = .088) rates were similar in patients with suspected bladder invasion. In patients with histologically confirmed bladder invasion, 5-year overall survival rates (78.1% vs 52.1%; P = .017) were higher in the partial cystectomy group than in the total cystectomy group; however, disease-free survival rates (53.4% vs 41.2%; P = .220) did not differ significantly.

CONCLUSION

R0 resection is associated with favorable long-term outcomes in patients with locally advanced colorectal cancer. If R0 resection is possible, partial cystectomy is considered safe.

Comparison of urological outcomes and quality of life after pelvic exenteration: partial vs radical cystectomy

OBJECTIVE

To compare perioperative morbidity, functional and quality-of-life (QoL) outcomes in patients with partial cystectomy vs radical cystectomy as part of pelvic exenteration.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Retrospective analysis of a prospectively maintained database of pelvic exenteration patients (1998-2021) was conducted in a single centre. Study outcomes included postoperative complications, quality-of-life, functional and stoma-related outcomes. The 36-item Short-Form Health Survey Physical and Mental Health Components, Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Colorectal questionnaires and Distress Thermometer were available pre- and postoperatively. QoL outcomes were compared at the various time points. Stoma embarrassment and care scores were compared between patients with a colostomy, urostomy, and both.

RESULTS

Urological complications were similar between both groups, but patients with partial cystectomy experienced less wound-related complications. Overall, 34/81 (42%) partial cystectomy patients reported one or more long-term voiding complication (i.e., incontinence [17 patients], frequency [six], retention [three], high post-voiding residuals [10], permanent suprapubic catheter/indwelling catheter [14], recurrent urinary tract infection [nine], percutaneous nephrostomy [three], progression to urostomy [three]). The QoL improved following surgery in both the partial and radical cystectomy groups, differences between cohorts were not significant. Patients with two stomas reported higher embarrassment scores than patients with one stoma, although this did not result in more difficulties in stoma care.

CONCLUSIONS

Partial cystectomy patients have fewer postoperative wound-related complications than radical cystectomy patients, but often experience long-term voiding issues. The QoL outcomes are similar for both cohorts, with significant improvement following surgery.

Risk factors that impact long-term outcomes in sigmoid colon cancer with urinary bladder involvement

PURPOSE

This study aimed to identify the risk factors impacting long-term outcomes in patients diagnosed with sigmoid colon cancer with urinary bladder involvement.

METHODS

A comprehensive analysis was conducted on a retrospective cohort of 118 patients who underwent multivisceral resection for sigmoid colon cancer with urinary bladder involvement between June 2002 and May 2017. Univariate and multivariate analyses were employed to identify risk factors associated with long-term outcomes.

RESULTS

Among the included patients, 10 (8.5%) experienced grade III-IV complications according to Clavien-Dindo classification, with 4 (3.4%) presenting anastomotic leaks. The postoperative mortality was 0.8%. R0 resection was achieved in 108 (91.6%) patients. Adjuvant chemotherapy was administrated to only 31 patient (26.3%). Local recurrence was observed in 8 (6.8%) cases. Risk factors for local recurrence-free survival and disease-free survival were CCI>3, grade III-IV postoperative complications according to Clavien-Dindo classification, positive resection margins, stage III of the disease, additional resected organs (excluding colon and bladder) and the absence of adjuvant chemotherapy. The same risk factors, with the exception of CCI, were associated with overall survival.

CONCLUSION

This study highlights that negative resection margins, a postoperative period without grade III-IV complications, and the implementation of adjuvant chemotherapy are crucial factors contributing to improve overall, disease-free and local recurrence-free survival in patients with sigmoid colon cancer with urinary bladder involvement.

Bladder preservation or complete cystectomy during pelvic exenteration of patients with locally advanced or recurrent rectal cancer, what should we do?

INTRODUCTION

In patients with locally advanced (LARC) or locally recurrent (LRRC) rectal cancer and bladder involvement, pelvic exenteration (PE) with partial (PC) or radical (RC) cystectomy can potentially offer a cure. The study aim was to compare PC and RC in PE patients in terms of oncological outcome, post-operative complications and quality-of-life (QoL).

MATERIALS & METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort analysis of a prospectively maintained surgical database. Patients who underwent PE for LARC or LRRC cancer with bladder involvement between 1998 and 2021 were included. Post-operative complications and overall survival were compared between patients with PC and RC.

RESULTS

60 PC patients and 269 RC patients were included. Overall R0 resection was 84.3%. Patients with LRRC and PC had poorest oncological outcome with 69% R0 resection; patients with LARC and PC demonstrated highest R0 rate of 96.3% (P = 0.008). Overall, 1-, 3- and 5-year OS was 90.8%, 68.1% and 58.6% after PC, and 88.7%, 62.2% and 49.5% after RC. Rates of urinary sepsis or urological leaks did not differ between groups, however, RC patients experienced significantly higher rates of perineal wound- and flap-related complications (39.8% vs 25.0%, P = 0.032).

CONCLUSION

PC as part of PE can be performed safely with good oncological outcome in patients with LARC. In patients with LRRC, PC results in poor oncological outcome and a more aggressive surgical approach with RC seems justified. The main benefit of PC is a reduction in wound related complications compared to RC, although more urological re-interventions are observed in this group.

Outcomes of Partial or Total Cystectomy in Advanced Colon Cancer with Suspected Bladder Invasion-Our 8-Year Experience and Literature Review

PURPOSE

Advanced colon cancers with bladder invasion pose a heavy burden and challenge towards patients and surgeons. Herein, we report our series with regards to operative and oncological outcomes in our 8 years of experience.

METHODS

All patients with advanced colonic tumours and suspected bladder invasion being operated from 2012 to 2020 were included. The histological findings, clinical and oncological outcomes were evaluated.

RESULTS

Twenty-two patients were included. Partial cystectomy was performed in 17 of them (77%). No neoadjuvant treatment was prescribed. All preoperative computed tomography (CT) scan showed bladder invasion or colovesical fistula. True tumour invasion to bladder (T4b disease) was confirmed in 17 patients (77%) by histopathology. The 3-year overall survival and recurrence rates were 82% and 9%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

En bloc resection of colonic tumour with adherent bladder in advanced colon cancers can achieve a good operative and oncological outcome without neoadjuvant therapy. The relatively low concordance rate between preoperative CT scan and final histopathology may limit the benefit of routine administration of neoadjuvant therapy as it may overtreat and delay subsequent oncological treatment of our patients with possible added morbidity.

Advanced colonic cancer with clinically suspected bladder invasion: Outcomes and prognosis from a multicentric study of 117 patients from the FRENCH research group

BACKGROUND

Bladder invasion by colon cancer is rare; however, its management is still controversial. Our objective was to report outcomes and identify risk factors for local recurrence in colon cancer with clinically suspected bladder invasion.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective study in 23 centers in France. All patients who underwent colon surgery with bladder resection (2010-2017) were included. Metastatic and recurrent colon cancers were excluded.

RESULTS

One hundred and seventeen patients (men = 73) were included. Partial cystectomy occurred in 108 patients (92.3%), with a total cystectomy occurring in 9 patients (7.7%). Neoadjuvant treatment was given to 31 patients (26.5%). Major morbidity was 20.5%. R0 resection rates were 87.2%. Histologically confirmed bladder invasion was present in 47%. Thirty-four patients were pN+, while 60 patients (51.3%) received adjuvant chemotherapy. Mean follow-up was 33.8 months. Three-year overall survival and disease-free survival were 82.9% and 59.5%. Rates of local recurrence and distant recurrence were 14.5% and 18.8%, respectively; the local recurrences (11/17; 65%) were in the bladder, while 4 of these patients had a bladder recurrence despite not having histologically confirmed bladder invasion at the index surgery. The rate of bladder recurrence after histologic bladder invasion was 13% (7/55), while the rate of bladder recurrence without primary bladder invasion was 7% (4/62) (P = .343). Neoadjuvant therapy, type of cystectomy, and adjuvant therapy did not influence local recurrence (P > .445 each). R1 bladder resections, when compared with a R0 bladder resections, were associated with an increased rate of local recurrence (63% vs 10%; P < .0001).

CONCLUSION

Clinically suspected bladder invasion increases local recurrence even in the absence of histologically confirmed bladder invasion. Only complete resections with R0 margins decrease local recurrence. Careful, detailed postoperative surveillance is required, even without pathologic bladder invasion.