Differentiation of benign from malignant thyroid nodules with acoustic radiation force impulse technique

Association between diagnostic efficacy of acoustic radiation force impulse for benign and malignant thyroid nodules and the presence or absence of non-papillary thyroid cancer: A meta-analysis

Purpose

The aim of this study was to investigate the diagnostic efficacy of Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse (ARFI) for benign and malignant thyroid nodules in the presence and absence of non-papillary thyroid cancer (NPTC) and to determine the cut-off values of Shear Wave Velocity (SWV) for the highest diagnostic efficacy of Virtual Touch Quantification (VTQ) and Virtual Touch Tissue Imaging and Quantification (VTIQ).

Methods

The diagnostic accuracy of ARFI for benign and malignant thyroid nodules was assessed by pooling sensitivity, specificity and area under the curve (AUC) in each group in the presence and absence of both non-papillary thyroid glands, using histology and cytology as the gold standard. All included studies were divided into two groups according to VTQ and VTIQ, and each group was ranked according to the magnitude of the SWV cutoff value to determine the SWV cutoff interval with the highest diagnostic efficacy for VTQ and VTIQ.

Results

A total of 57 studies were collected on the evaluation of ARFI for the diagnosis of benign and malignant thyroid nodules. The results showed that the presence of non-papillary thyroid carcinoma led to differences in the specificity of VTIQ for the identification of benign and malignant thyroid nodules, and the differences were statistically significant. In addition, the diagnostic efficacy of VTQ was best when the cutoff value of SWV was in the interval of 2.48-2.55 m/s, and the diagnostic efficacy of VTIQ was best when the cutoff value of SWV was in the interval of 3.01-3.15 m/s.

Conclusion

VTQ and VTIQ have a high diagnostic value for benign and malignant thyroid nodules; however, when the malignant nodules in the study contain non-papillary thyroid carcinoma occupying the thyroid gland, the findings should be viewed in a comprehensive manner.

MALİGN VE BENİGN TIROİD NODÜLLERİNİN AYRIMINDA ARFI ELASTOGRAFİ

AMAÇ: Malign ve benign tiroid nodüllerini ayırd etmede “Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse” (ARFI) elastografinin “virtual touch tissue elastografi” modunun tanısal performansını değerlendirmek MATERYAL VE METOD: Çapı > 5 mm olan ikiyüzdört adet solid ve ağırlıklı solid nodül prospektif olarak ultrasonografi, ARFI elastografinin VTQ modu, ince iğne aspirasyon biyopsisi ve endike olduğunda doku patolojisi ile değerlendirildi. Yüzdoksanaltı nodülde üç makaslama dalgası hızı (shear wave velocity-SWV) ölçümü yapıldı. Her bir nodül için SWV oranı, nodülün SWV'sinin ortalama değerinin komşu parankimin ortalama değerine bölünmesiyle hesaplandı. SWV değeri ve SWV oranının tanısal performansı, ROC analizi ile değerlendirildi. SONUÇLAR: Benign ve malign tiroid nodüllerinde normal parankimdeki ortalama SWV değeri sırasıyla 2,13±0,44 m/s, 2,06±0,80 m/s ve 2,06±0,88 m/s idi. SWVoranları benign tiroid nodülleri için 0.97±0.37 ve malign tiroid nodülleri için 1.02±0.40 idi. Ortalama SWV değerleri (t=0,008) (P=0,994) veya SWV oranları (t=0,596; P=0,527) açısından benign ve malign nodüller arasında anlamlı fark yoktu. Maligniteyi öngörmek için herhangi bir cut-off noktası bulunmadı. Alt grup analizinde, SWV ve SWV oranı için AUC'ler, ˂10 mm ve ≥10 mm nodüller arasında önemli ölçüde farklıydı. Bunun dışında herhangi iki grup arasında anlamlı fark saptanmadı (tümü P>0.05). SWV ve SWV oranı için en iyi cut-off noktaları, <10 mm nodüller için sırasıyla SWV için 2.59 m/s ve SWV oranı için 1.0 idi. SONUÇ: ARFİ görüntülemenin VTQ modu, maligniteyi saptamak için iyi bir tanısal performansa sahip değildir ve gereksiz tiroid biyopsilerinin azaltılmasına katkıda bulunamaz.

Malign ve benign tiroid nodüllerinin ayrımında ARFI elastografi

Aim: To examine the diagnostic performance of virtual touch tissue quantification (VTQ) mode of Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse (ARFI) elastography imaging in differentiating benign and malignant thyroid nodules. Materials and Methods: Two hundred four solid and mostly solid nodules >5mm were prospectively evaluated with ultrasonography, VTQ mode of ARFI elastography, fine needle aspiration biopsy, and when indicated with tissue pathology. Three shear-wave velocities (SWV) measurements were done in 196 nodules. The SWV ratio for each nodule was calculated as the mean value of the SWV of the nodule divided by the mean value of the adjacent parenchyma. The diagnostic performance of SWV value and SWV-ratio were assessed by a receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis. Results: The mean SWV value in the normal parenchyma, in benign and malign thyroid nodules, were 2.13±0.44 m/s, 2.06±0.80 m/s, and 2.06±0.88 m/s respectively. The SWV-ratios were 0.97±0.37 for benign thyroid nodules and 1.02±0.40 for malignant thyroid nodules. There was no significant difference between benign and malign nodules in terms of mean SWV values (t=0.008) (P=0.994) or SWV-ratios (t =0.596; P=0.527). No cut-off point was found to predict malignancy. In subgroup analysis, AUCs for the SWV and SWV-ratio were significantly different between nodules ˂10 mm and those ≥10 mm, but not with any other two groups (all P>0.05) (Table-2). The cutoff points for the differential diagnosis were 2.59 m/s for SWV and 1.0 for SWV- ratio respectively for nodules

Ultrasound Real-Time Tissue Elastography Improves the Diagnostic Performance of the ACR Thyroid Imaging Reporting and Data System in Differentiating Malignant from Benign Thyroid Nodules: A Summary of 1525 Thyroid Nodules

BACKGROUND

To explore the correlation between the ultrasound elasticity score (ES) of real-time tissue elastography (RTE) and the malignant risk stratification of the Thyroid Imaging Reporting and Data System (TI-RADS) and to evaluate the added value of RTE to TI-RADS in differentiating malignant nodules from benign ones.

METHODS

A total of 1,498 patients (885 women and 613 men; mean age of 43.5 ± 12.4 years) with 1,525 confirmed thyroid nodules (D = maximum diameter, D ≤ 2.5 cm) confirmed by fine-needle aspiration (FNA) and/or surgery were included. The nodules were divided into four groups based on their sizes (D ≤ 0.5 cm, 0.5 < D ≤ 1.0 cm, 1.0 < D ≤ 2.0 cm, and 2.0 < D ≤ 2.5 cm). We assigned an ES of RTE and malignant risk stratification of the TI-RADS category to each nodule. The correlation between the ES of RTE and the malignant risk stratification of TI-RADS category was analyzed by the Spearman's rank correlation. The diagnostic performances of RTE, TI-RADS, and their combination were compared by the receiver operator characteristic (ROC) analysis.

RESULTS

The ES of RTE and the malignant risk stratification of TI-RADS showed a strong correlation in the size intervals of 0.5 < D ≤ 1.0 cm, 1.0 < D ≤ 2.0 cm, and 2.0 < D ≤ 2.5 cm (r = 0.768, 0.711, and 0.743, respectively). The diagnostic performance of their combination for each size interval was always better than RTE or TI-RADS alone (for all, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, The ES of RTE was strongly correlated with the malignant risk stratification of TI-RADS. The diagnostic performance of the combination of RTE and TI-RADS outperformed RTE or TI-RADS alone. Therefore, RTE may be an adjunctive tool to the current TI-RADS system for differentiating malignant from benign thyroid nodules.

Comparison of strain elastography, point shear wave elastography using acoustic radiation force impulse imaging and 2D-shear wave elastography for the differentiation of thyroid nodules

PURPOSE

The aim of the study was to compare three different elastography methods, namely Strain Elastography (SE), Point Shear-Wave Elastography (pSWE) using Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse (ARFI)-Imaging and 2D-Shear Wave Elastography (2D-SWE), in the same study population for the differentiation of thyroid nodules.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

All patients received a conventional ultrasound scan, SE and 2D-SWE, and all patients except for two received ARFI-Imaging. Cytology/histology of thyroid nodules was used as a reference method. SE measures the relative stiffness within the region of interest (ROI) using the surrounding tissue as reference tissue. ARFI mechanically excites the tissue at the ROI using acoustic pulses to generate localized tissue displacements. 2D-SWE measures tissue elasticity using the velocity of many shear waves as they propagate through the tissue.

RESULTS

84 nodules (73 benign and 11 malignant) in 62 patients were analyzed. Sensitivity, specificity and NPV of SE were 73%, 70% and 94%, respectively. Sensitivity, specificity and NPV of ARFI and 2D-SWE were 90%, 79%, 98% and 73%, 67%, 94% respectively, using a cut-off value of 1.98m/s for ARFI and 2.65m/s (21.07kPa) for 2D-SWE. The AUROC (Area under the Receiver Operating Characteristic) of SE, ARFI and 2D-SWE for the diagnosis of malignant thyroid nodules were 52%, 86% and 71%, respectively. A significant difference in AUROC was found between SE and ARFI (p = 0.008), while no significant difference was found between ARFI and SWE (86% vs. 71%, p = 0.31), or SWE and SE (71% vs. 52%, p = 0.26).

CONCLUSION

pSWE using ARFI and 2D-SWE showed comparable results for the differentiation of thyroid nodules. ARFI was superior to elastography using SE.

Comparative study on the diagnostic values of different ultrasound technologies for malignant thyroid nodules

The present study compared and analyzed the diagnostic values of B-mode ultrasound and elasticity imaging technology for the identification of benign and malignant thyroid nodules. Ninety-four patients who were diagnosed with thyroid nodules by ultrasound were chosen. All patients were checked with B-mode ultrasound and ultrasound elasticity imaging technology before surgeries. Further, the post-operative outcomes were compared with operation pathology. The pathological examination results were taken as the gold standard. The accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value and negative predictive values of combined ultrasound diagnosis were all obviously higher than those by the B-mode ultrasound and the ultrasound elastography method (P<0.05). In conclusion, as a new technology, ultrasound elasticity imaging technology has relatively high diagnositic value in identifying benign and malignant thyroid nodules. With its own advantages and limitations, the ultrasound elasticity imaging technology could effectively complement B-mode ultrasound, and improve the sensitivity, specificity and accuracy of ultrasound diagnosis for thyroid nodules.

The Preciseness in Diagnosing Thyroid Malignant Nodules Using Shear-Wave Elastography

Our study aimed to identify more accurate results about the diagnostic role of shear-wave elastography (SWE) for thyroid malignant nodules through a meta-analysis.

Potential articles were searched in PubMed, Embase, and the Cochrane Library databases. Overall sensitivity and specificity with 95% confidence intervals (CIs) was used to represent the diagnostic accuracy of SWE. Summary receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve was constructed to illustrate the results. In addition, χ² and I² tests were performed to assess heterogeneity. A value of p≤0.05 indicated significant heterogeneity. All the analysis was conducted in Meta-DiSc version 1.4 software.

Twenty studies were included in the analysis. There were a total of 2,907 patients and 3,397 thyroid nodules included in the meta-analysis. Overall sensitivity and specificity were 0.68 (95% CI: 0.66–0.70) and 0.85 (95% CI: 0.84–0.87), respectively. The results showed the area under curve (AUC) was 0.9041, suggesting high accuracy of SWE for differentiating benign and malignant thyroid nodules.

SWE showed high accuracy in identifying thyroid malignant nodules, suggesting it could serve as a diagnostic biomarker in thyroid nodules.

Can ARFI elastography be used to differentiate parathyroid from thyroid lesions?

OBJECTIVES

To assess if elasticity score (ES) and shear wave velocity (SWV) measurement obtained using ARFI elastography can differentiate between parathyroid lesions and thyroid nodules.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

ARFI elastography was performed on patients with primary hyperparathyroidism or solid thyroid nodules who were being considered for surgery using virtual touch quantification and virtual touch imaging (VTI) software. Only patients with surgical histopathology (47 parathyroid lesions, 38 benign thyroid nodules and 55 malignant thyroid nodules) were included for final analysis. SWV and ES of the parathyroid and thyroid nodules were compared and their ability to differentiate between parathyroid and thyroid was analyzed using receiver operating characteristic curve analysis.

RESULTS

There were 39 solitary adenomas, 2 double adenomas and 4 parathyroid hyperplasias with mean size of 19.6 ± 9.7 mm in 44 patients (21 male, 23 females) with primary hyperparathyroidism. The mean SWV of the parathyroid lesion (1.6 ± 0.78 m/s) was significantly different from benign (2.11 ± 0.8 m/s) and malignant (4.3 ± 2.71 m/s) thyroid nodules, p < 0.05; so was the ES, Chi square = 51.6, p < 0.001. The majority of parathyroid lesions (n = 37, 78.7%) had ES of 2 with speckled (n = 42, 89.3%) appearance, and none showed ES of 4. The diagnostic performance of speckled appearance on VTI, elasticity score and SWV measurements was 0.901, 0.724 and 0.797, respectively, to differentiate between parathyroid and thyroid lesions.

CONCLUSIONS

Parathyroid lesions are softer than thyroid nodules. A shear wave velocity of 1.72 m/s can differentiate between parathyroid lesions and thyroid nodules.

Evaluation of Inferior Turbinate Stroma with Ultrasound Elastography in Allergic Rhinitis Patients

Background:

Diagnosis of allergic rhinitis is primarily based on history, physical examination and allergy testing. A technique that noninvasively evaluates the soft tissue changes in the nasal mucosa of allergic rhinitis patients has not been defined.

Aims:

To assess nasal mucosal changes and measure the submucosal fibrosis in allergic rhinitis patients with sonoelastography.

Study Design:

Case control study.

Methods:

Eighty-eight turbinates of 44 patients were included in the study. There were 23 prick test positive allergic rhinitis patients. The control group constituted 21 patients. The rhinitis quality of life questionnaire and the visual analogue scale were applied to the allergic rhinitis patients. A higher visual analogue scale score indicated more severe allergic rhinitis symptoms. Sonoelastographic measurements were made from the lateral nasal wall. The propagation speed of sound waves was recorded in m/s. The presence of asthma and the type of allergic rhinitis (seasonal or perennial) was noted.

Results:

Ten patients had seasonal allergic rhinitis and thirteen patients had perennial allergic rhinitis. Six patients (26.1%) had accompanying asthma along with allergic rhinitis. The median visual analogue scale score was 7 (3-9) in allergic rhinitis patients. The median symptom duration was 7 (1-24) months. The median quality of life questionnaire score was 3.39 (1.68-5.43) points. The median sonoelastography scores of allergic rhinitis patients and healthy subjects were 2.38 m/s (0.9-4.47) and 2.42 m/s (1.62-3.50), respectively. Sonoelastographic measurements of seasonal and perennial allergic rhinitis patients did not differ significantly (p>0.05). The presence of asthma did not have a significant impact on the elastography measurements (p>0.05). However, regression analysis revealed a significant inverse correlation (coefficients: B=0.005, standard error=0.097, beta 0=0.008) between the visual analogue scale and sonoelastography scores (p<0.05).

Conclusion:

Sonoelastography was not suitable as a diagnostic tool in allergic rhinitis. Reduced sonoelastography scores were measured in more symptomatic patients. Higher visual analogue scale scores could be an indicator of disease severity.

Virtual Touch Tissue Imaging and Quantification in the Evaluation of Thyroid Nodules

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the diagnostic performance of a 2-dimensional shear wave elastographic technique (Virtual Touch tissue imaging and quantification [VTIQ]; Siemens Medical Solutions, Mountain View, CA) for predicting thyroid malignancy.

METHODS

A total of 302 thyroid nodules underwent conventional sonography and VTIQ before fine-needle aspiration examination or surgery. Compared with histopathologic or cytologic results in combination with follow-up, the diagnostic performance of various shear wave speed (SWS) indices (minimum [SWS_min ], maximum [SWS_max ], and mean [SWS_mean ]) on VTIQ as well as conventional sonographic features for predicting thyroid malignancy was evaluated in all of the nodules.

RESULTS

Sixty-five malignant and 237 benign thyroid nodules were histopathologically or cytologically confirmed. All SWS indices on VTIQ were lower in benign nodules than thyroid malignancy (all P < .001). For discrimination between malignant and benign nodules, all VTIQ SWS indices were better than conventional sonographic features, such as a solid component, a taller-than-wide shape, microcalcification, a poorly defined margin and hypoechogenicity, in predicting thyroid malignancy (all P < .05). By applying a cutoff SWS_mean value of 2.60 m/s, VTIQ achieved sensitivity and negative predictive values of 84.6% and 94.3%, respectively, for differentiating nodules. The areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve of SWS_max (0.862 versus 0.717), SWS_min (0.866 versus 0.717), and SWS_mean (0.891 versus 0.725) for nodules larger than 10 mm were higher than those for nodules of 10 mm or smaller (all P < .05). Interoperator and intraoperator reproducibility was proven to be excellent, with all interclass correlation coefficient values higher than 0.80 (range, 0.813-0.905) CONCLUSIONS: Virtual Touch tissue imaging and quantification is a useful and reproducible tool for predicting thyroid malignancy.

Quantitative Shear Wave Velocity Measurement on Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse Elastography for Differential Diagnosis between Benign and Malignant Thyroid Nodules: A Meta-analysis

The aim of this study was to evaluate the diagnostic performance of quantitative shear wave velocity (SWV) measurement on acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) elastography for differentiation between benign and malignant thyroid nodules using meta-analysis. The databases of PubMed and the Web of Science were searched. Studies published in English on assessment of the sensitivity and specificity of ARFI elastography for the differentiation of thyroid nodules were collected. The quantitative measurement of ARFI elastography was evaluated by SWV (m/s). Meta-Disc Version 1.4 software was used to describe and calculate the sensitivity, specificity, positive likelihood ratio, negative likelihood ratio, diagnostic odds ratio and summary receiver operating characteristic curves. We analyzed a total of 13 studies, which included 1,854 thyroid nodules (including 1,339 benign nodules and 515 malignant nodules) from 1,641 patients. The summary sensitivity and specificity for differential diagnosis between benign and malignant thyroid nodules by SWV were 0.81 (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.77-0.84) and 0.84 (95% CI: 0.81-0.86), respectively. The pooled positive and negative likelihood ratios were 5.21 (95% CI: 3.56-7.62) and 0.23 (95% CI: 0.17-0.32), respectively. The pooled diagnostic odds ratio was 27.53 (95% CI: 14.58-52.01), and the area under the summary receiver operating characteristic curve was 0.91 (Q* = 0.84). In conclusion, SWV measurement on ARFI elastography has high sensitivity and specificity for differential diagnosis between benign and malignant thyroid nodules and can be used in combination with conventional ultrasound.

A new insight for evaluation of the inferior turbinate with ultrasound elastography

OBJECTIVES

There are diseases that affect the stroma of the inferior turbinate and many surgical interventions that alter it. However, an objective method that can evaluate the turbinate's stromal structure in detail has not been defined yet. The primary aim of this study was to investigate the effectiveness and reliability of ultrasound elastography for objective evaluation of the inferior turbinate stroma and define the most suitable elastographic technique.

METHODS

Twenty inferior turbinates in 10 healthy participants were included. Five of the participants (50%) were male, and 5 (50%) were female, with a mean age ± SD of 28.3 ± 3.2 years (range, 26-35) years. To obtain reliable and reproducible results, elastography was performed twice, 3 days apart, with and without a topical decongestant to evaluate the effects of the nasal cycle and mucosal edema. Two previously described valid elastographic outcome measures were reevaluated for the inferior turbinate. The tissue strain ratio and sound wave propagation speed were calculated for each measurement.

RESULTS

Median propagation speeds without and with the decongestant for the first and second measurements were 2.125 (interquartile range [IQR], 0.85), 2.175 (IQR, 0.53), 2.520 (IQR, 0.79), and 2.555 (IQR, 0.53) m/s, respectively. Median turbinate stroma-to-subcutaneous tissue strain ratios without and with the decongestant for the first and second measurements were 1.402 (IQR, 0.96), 0.942 (IQR, 0.24), 1.035 (IQR, 0.98), and 1.427 (IQR, 1.68).

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that elastography is a reliable and reproducible method that is not substantially affected by mucosal edema. It is a novel technique that can evaluate the inferior turbinate stroma and might be used in concordance with other objective functional techniques such as acoustic rhinometry. Therefore, it can be used in further studies regarding diagnosis of turbinate diseases and objective evaluation of previous surgical treatments.