Role of the terminator hairpin in the biogenesis of functional Hfq-binding sRNAs

An internal loop region is responsible for inherent target specificity of bacterial cold-shock proteins

Cold-shock proteins (Csps), of around 70 amino acids, share a protein fold for the cold-shock domain (CSD) that contains RNA-binding motifs, RNP1 and RNP2, and constitute one family of bacterial RNA-binding proteins. Despite similar amino acid composition, Csps have been shown to individually possess inherent specific functions. Here, we identify the molecular differences in Csps that allow selective recognition of RNA targets. Using chimeras and mutants of Escherichia coli CspD and CspA, we demonstrate that Lys43-Ala44 in an internal loop of CspD, and the N-terminal portion with Lys4 of CspA, are important for determining their target specificities. Pull-down assays suggest that these distinct specificities reflect differences in the ability to act on the target RNAs rather than differences in binding to the RNA targets. A phylogenetic tree constructed from 1,573 Csps reveals that the Csps containing Lys-Ala in the loop form a monophyletic clade, and the members in this clade are shown to have target specificities similar to E. coli CspD. The phylogenetic tree also finds a small cluster of Csps containing Lys-Glu in the loop, and these exhibit a different specificity than E. coli CspD. Examination of this difference suggests a role of the loop of CspD-type proteins in recognition of specific targets. Additionally, each identified type of Csp shows a different distribution pattern among bacteria. Our findings provide a basis for subclassification of Csps based on target RNA specificity, which will be useful for understanding the functional specialization of Csps.

What goes up must come down: off switches for regulatory RNAs

Small RNAs base pair with and regulate mRNA translation and stability. For both bacterial small regulatory RNAs and eukaryotic microRNAs, association with partner proteins is critical for the stability and function of the regulatory RNAs. We review the mechanisms for degradation of these RNAs: displacement of the regulatory RNA from its protein partner (in bacteria) or destruction of the protein and its associated microRNAs (in eukaryotes). These mechanisms can allow specific destruction of a regulatory RNA via pairing with a decay trigger RNA or function as global off switches by disrupting the stability or function of the protein partner.

Novel P335-like Phage Resistance Arises from Deletion within Putative Autolysin yccB in Lactococcus lactis

Lactococcus lactis and Lactococcus cremoris are broadly utilized as starter cultures for fermented dairy products and are inherently impacted by bacteriophage (phage) attacks in the industrial environment. Consequently, the generation of bacteriophage-insensitive mutants (BIMs) is a standard approach for addressing phage susceptibility in dairy starter strains. In this study, we characterized spontaneous BIMs of L. lactis DGCC12699 that gained resistance against homologous P335-like phages. Phage resistance was found to result from mutations in the YjdB domain of yccB, a putative autolysin gene. We further observed that alteration of a fused tail-associated lysin-receptor binding protein (Tal-RBP) in the phage restored infectivity on the yccB BIMs. Additional investigation found yccB homologs to be widespread in L. lactis and L. cremoris and that different yccB homologs are highly correlated with cell wall polysaccharide (CWPS) type/subtype. CWPS are known lactococcal phage receptors, and we found that truncation of a glycosyltransferase in the cwps operon also resulted in resistance to these P335-like phages. However, characterization of the CWPS mutant identified notable differences from the yccB mutants, suggesting the two resistance mechanisms are distinct. As phage resistance correlated with yccB mutation has not been previously described in L. lactis, this study offers insight into a novel gene involved in lactococcal phage sensitivity.

Identification of Attenuators of Transcriptional Termination: Implications for RNA Regulation in Escherichia coli

The regulatory function of many bacterial small RNAs (sRNAs) requires the binding of the RNA chaperone Hfq to the 3' portion of the sRNA intrinsic terminator, and therefore sRNA signaling might be regulated by modulating its terminator. Here, using a multicopy screen developed with the terminator of sRNA SgrS, we identified an sRNA gene (cyaR) and three protein-coding genes (cspD, ygjH, and rof) that attenuate SgrS termination in Escherichia coli. Analyses of CyaR and YgjH, a putative tRNA binding protein, suggested that the CyaR activity was indirect and the effect of YgjH was moderate. Overproduction of the protein attenuators CspD and Rof resulted in more frequent readthrough at terminators of SgrS and two other sRNAs, and regulation by SgrS of target mRNAs was reduced. The effect of Rof, a known inhibitor of Rho, was mimicked by bicyclomycin or by a rho mutant, suggesting an unexpected role for Rho in sRNA termination. CspD, a member of the cold shock protein family, bound both terminated and readthrough transcripts, stabilizing them and attenuating termination. By RNA sequencing analysis of the CspD overexpression strain, we found global effects of CspD on gene expression across some termination sites. We further demonstrated effects of endogenous CspD under slow growth conditions where cspD is highly expressed. These findings provided evidence of changes in the efficiency of intrinsic termination, confirming this as an additional layer of the regulation of sRNA signaling. IMPORTANCE Growing evidence suggests that the modulation of intrinsic termination and readthrough of transcription is more widespread than previously appreciated. For small RNAs, proper termination plays a critical role in their regulatory function. Here, we present a multicopy screen approach to identify factors that attenuate small RNA termination and therefore abrogate signaling dependent on the small RNA. This study highlights a new aspect of regulation of small RNA signaling as well as the modulation of intrinsic termination.

An overview of gene regulation in bacteria by small RNAs derived from mRNA 3' ends

Over the past two decades, small noncoding RNAs (sRNAs) that regulate mRNAs by short base pairing have gone from a curiosity to a major class of post-transcriptional regulators in bacteria. They are integral to many stress responses and regulatory circuits, affecting almost all aspects of bacterial life. Following pioneering sRNA searches in the early 2000s, the field quickly focused on conserved sRNA genes in the intergenic regions of bacterial chromosomes. Yet, it soon emerged that there might be another rich source of bacterial sRNAs-processed 3' end fragments of mRNAs. Several such 3' end-derived sRNAs have now been characterized, often revealing unexpected, conserved functions in diverse cellular processes. Here, we review our current knowledge of these 3' end-derived sRNAs-their biogenesis through ribonucleases, their molecular mechanisms, their interactions with RNA-binding proteins such as Hfq or ProQ and their functional scope, which ranges from acting as specialized regulators of single metabolic genes to constituting entire noncoding arms in global stress responses. Recent global RNA interactome studies suggest that the importance of functional 3' end-derived sRNAs has been vastly underestimated and that this type of cross-regulation between genes at the mRNA level is more pervasive in bacteria than currently appreciated.

RNase III CLASH in MRSA uncovers sRNA regulatory networks coupling metabolism to toxin expression

Methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) is a bacterial pathogen responsible for significant human morbidity and mortality. Post-transcriptional regulation by small RNAs (sRNAs) has emerged as an important mechanism for controlling virulence. However, the functionality of the majority of sRNAs during infection is unknown. To address this, we performed UV cross-linking, ligation, and sequencing of hybrids (CLASH) in MRSA to identify sRNA-RNA interactions under conditions that mimic the host environment. Using a double-stranded endoribonuclease III as bait, we uncovered hundreds of novel sRNA-RNA pairs. Strikingly, our results suggest that the production of small membrane-permeabilizing toxins is under extensive sRNA-mediated regulation and that their expression is intimately connected to metabolism. Additionally, we also uncover an sRNA sponging interaction between RsaE and RsaI. Taken together, we present a comprehensive analysis of sRNA-target interactions in MRSA and provide details on how these contribute to the control of virulence in response to changes in metabolism.

Effects of individual base-pairs on in vivo target search and destruction kinetics of bacterial small RNA

Base-pairing interactions mediate many intermolecular target recognition events. Even a single base-pair mismatch can cause a substantial difference in activity but how such changes influence the target search kinetics in vivo is unknown. Here, we use high-throughput sequencing and quantitative super-resolution imaging to probe the mutants of bacterial small RNA, SgrS, and their regulation of ptsG mRNA target. Mutations that disrupt binding of a chaperone protein, Hfq, and are distal to the mRNA annealing region still decrease the rate of target association, k_on, and increase the dissociation rate, k_off, showing that Hfq directly facilitates sRNA-mRNA annealing in vivo. Single base-pair mismatches in the annealing region reduce k_on by 24-31% and increase k_off by 14-25%, extending the time it takes to find and destroy the target by about a third. The effects of disrupting contiguous base-pairing are much more modest than that expected from thermodynamics, suggesting that Hfq buffers base-pair disruptions.

Stochastic Analysis Demonstrates the Dual Role of Hfq in Chaperoning E. coli Sugar Shock Response

Small RNAs (sRNAs) play a crucial role in the regulation of bacterial gene expression by silencing the translation of target mRNAs. SgrS is an sRNA that relieves glucose-phosphate stress, or "sugar shock" in E. coli. The power of single cell measurements is their ability to obtain population level statistics that illustrate cell-to-cell variation. Here, we utilize single molecule super-resolution microscopy in single E. coli cells coupled with stochastic modeling to analyze glucose-phosphate stress regulation by SgrS. We present a kinetic model that captures the combined effects of transcriptional regulation, gene replication and chaperone mediated RNA silencing in the SgrS regulatory network. This more complete kinetic description, simulated stochastically, recapitulates experimentally observed cellular heterogeneity and characterizes the binding of SgrS to the chaperone protein Hfq as a slow process that not only stabilizes SgrS but also may be critical in restructuring the sRNA to facilitate association with its target ptsG mRNA.

Regulatory interplay between small RNAs and transcription termination factor Rho

The largest and best studied group of regulatory small RNAs (sRNAs) in bacteria act by modulating translation or turnover of messenger RNAs (mRNAs) through base-pairing interactions that typically take place near the 5' end of the mRNA. This allows the sRNA to bind the complementary target sequence while the remainder of the mRNA is still being made, creating conditions whereby the action of the sRNA can extend to transcriptional steps, most notably transcription termination. Increasing evidence corroborates the existence of a functional interplay between sRNAs and termination factor Rho. Two general mechanisms have emerged. One mechanism operates in translated regions subjected to sRNA repression. By inhibiting ribosome binding co-transcriptionally, the sRNA uncouples translation from transcription, allowing Rho to bind the nascent RNA and promote termination. In the second mechanism, which functions in 5' untranslated regions, the sRNA antagonizes termination directly by interfering with Rho binding to the RNA or the subsequent translocation along the RNA. Here, we review the above literature in the context of other mechanisms that underlie the participation of Rho-dependent transcription termination in gene regulation. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: RNA and gene control in bacteria edited by Dr. M. Guillier and F. Repoila.

Trans-Acting Small RNAs and Their Effects on Gene Expression in Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica

The last few decades have led to an explosion in our understanding of the major roles that small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs) play in regulatory circuits and the responses to stress in many bacterial species. Much of the foundational work was carried out with Escherichia coli and Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium. The studies of these organisms provided an overview of how the sRNAs function and their impact on bacterial physiology, serving as a blueprint for sRNA biology in many other prokaryotes. They also led to the development of new technologies. In this chapter, we first summarize how these sRNAs were identified, defining them in the process. We discuss how they are regulated and how they act and provide selected examples of their roles in regulatory circuits and the consequences of this regulation. Throughout, we summarize the methodologies that were developed to identify and study the regulatory RNAs, most of which are applicable to other bacteria. Newly updated databases of the known sRNAs in E. coli K-12 and S. enterica Typhimurium SL1344 serve as a reference point for much of the discussion and, hopefully, as a resource for readers and for future experiments to address open questions raised in this review.

Regulation of Transcription Termination of Small RNAs and by Small RNAs: Molecular Mechanisms and Biological Functions

Accurate and efficient transcription termination is an important step for cells to generate functional RNA transcripts. In bacteria, two mechanisms are responsible for terminating transcription: intrinsic (Rho-independent) termination and Rho-dependent termination. Growing examples suggest that neither type of transcription termination is static, but instead are highly dynamic and regulated. Regulatory small RNAs (sRNAs) are key players in bacterial stress responses, are frequently expressed under specific growth conditions, and are predominantly terminated through the intrinsic termination mechanism. Once made, sRNAs can base-pair with mRNA targets and regulate mRNA translation and stability. Recent findings suggest that alterations in the efficiency of intrinsic termination for sRNAs under various growth conditions may affect the availability of a given sRNA and the ability of the sRNA to function properly. Moreover, alterations of mRNA structure, translation, and accessibility by sRNAs have the potential to impact the access of Rho factor to mRNAs and thus termination of the mRNA. Indeed, recent studies have revealed that some sRNAs can modulate target gene expression by stimulating or inhibiting Rho-dependent termination, thus expanding the regulatory power of bacterial sRNAs. Here we review the current knowledge on intrinsic termination of sRNAs and sRNA-mediated Rho-dependent termination of protein coding genes in bacteria.

New molecular interactions broaden the functions of the RNA chaperone Hfq

The RNA chaperone Hfq is an important bacterial post-transcriptional regulator. Most studies on Hfq are focused on the role of this protein on small non-coding RNAs (sRNAs) and messenger RNAs (mRNAs). The most well-characterized function of Hfq is its role as RNA matchmaker, promoting the base-pairing between sRNAs and their mRNA targets. However, novel substrates and previous unrecognized functions of Hfq have now been identified, which expanded the regulatory spectrum of this protein. Hfq was recently found to bind rRNA and act as a new ribosome biogenesis factor, affecting rRNA processing, ribosome assembly, translational efficiency and translational fidelity. Hfq was also found to bind tRNAs, which could provide an additional mechanism for its role on the accuracy of protein synthesis. The list of substrates does not include RNA exclusively since Hfq was shown to bind DNA, playing an important role in DNA compaction. Additionally, Hfq is also capable to establish many protein-protein interactions. Overall, the functions of the RNA-binding protein Hfq have been expanded beyond its function in small RNA-mediated regulation. The identification of additional substrates and new functions provides alternative explanations for the importance of the chaperone Hfq as a global regulator.

Mechanism and physiological significance of autoregulation of the Escherichia coli hfq gene

The RNA chaperone Hfq plays a critical role in sRNA-mediated gene regulation in enteric bacteria. The major role of Hfq is to stimulate base-pairing between sRNAs and target mRNAs by binding both RNAs through three RNA-binding surfaces. To understand the post-transcriptional network exerted by Hfq and its associated sRNAs, it is important to know how the cellular concentration of Hfq is regulated. While an early study showed that hfq translation is repressed by Hfq, the detailed mechanism and biological significance of the hfq autoregulation remain to be studied. Here, we show that the synthesis of Hfq is strictly autoregulated to maintain the cellular concentration of Hfq within a limited range even when the hfq mRNA is overexpressed from a plasmid-borne hfq gene. Mutational and biochemical studies demonstrate that Hfq represses its own translation primarily by binding to the hfq mRNA through the distal face. The growth of cells harboring the hfq plasmid is markedly inhibited due to an increased Hfq level when the distal face of Hfq is mutated or the 5'-UTR of hfq is mutated. A mutation in the rim suppresses the growth inhibition caused by the distal face mutation, suggesting that the interaction of Hfq with undefined RNAs through the rim is responsible for the growth inhibition by the increased Hfq level. In addition, the data suggest that the hfq autoregulation operates not only in cells harboring a multicopy hfq gene but also in the wild-type cells.

Workflow for a Computational Analysis of an sRNA Candidate in Bacteria

Computational methods can often facilitate the functional characterization of individual sRNAs and furthermore allow high-throughput analysis on large numbers of sRNA candidates. This chapter outlines a potential workflow for computational sRNA analyses and describes in detail methods for homolog detection, target prediction, and functional characterization based on enrichment analysis. The cyanobacterial sRNA IsaR1 is used as a specific example. All methods are available as webservers and easily accessible for nonexpert users.

The binding of Class II sRNA MgrR to two different sites on matchmaker protein Hfq enables efficient competition for Hfq and annealing to regulated mRNAs

MgrR is an Hfq-dependent sRNA, whose transcription is controlled by the level of Mg²⁺ ions in Escherichia coli MgrR belongs to Class II sRNAs because its stability in the cell is affected by mutations in Hfq differently than canonical, Class I sRNAs. Here, we examined the effect of mutations in RNA binding sites of Hfq on the kinetics of the annealing of MgrR to two different target mRNAs, eptB and ygdQ, by global data fitting of the reaction kinetics monitored by gel electrophoresis of intermediates and products. The data showed that the mutation on the rim of the Hfq ring trapped MgrR on Hfq preventing the annealing of MgrR to either mRNA. The mutation in the distal face slowed the ternary complex formation and affected the release of MgrR-mRNA complexes from Hfq, while the mutation in the proximal face weakened the MgrR binding to Hfq and in this way affected the annealing. Moreover, competition assays established that MgrR bound to both faces of Hfq and competed against other sRNAs. Further studies showed that uridine-rich sequences located in less structurally stable regions served as Hfq binding sites in each mRNA. Overall, the data show that the binding of MgrR sRNA to both faces of the Hfq ring enables it to efficiently anneal to target mRNAs. It also confers on MgrR a competitive advantage over other sRNAs, which could contribute to efficient cellular response to changes in magnesium homeostasis.

SuhB, a small non-coding RNA involved in catabolite repression of tetralin degradation genes in Sphingopyxis granuli strain TFA

Global dRNA-seq analysis of transcription start sites combined with in silico annotation using Infernal software revealed the expression of 91 putative non-coding sRNA in Sphingopyxis granuli TFA cells grown on different carbon sources. Excluding housekeeping sRNAs, only one additional sRNA, which belongs to the Rfam SuhB family (RF00519), was detected by Infernal but with an incorrect size according to the experimental results. SuhB is highly conserved across the Sphingopyxis genus. Expression data revealed that SuhB is present in rapidly growing TFA cells. A suhB deletion mutant exhibited de-repression of tetralin degradation (thn) gene expression and higher amounts of their LysR-type activator, ThnR, under conditions of carbon catabolite repression (CCR). Interaction between SuhB and the 5'UTR of thnR mRNA was demonstrated in vitro. Moreover, co-immunoprecipitation experiments, combined with fluorescence measurements of gfp fusions to the 5'UTR of thnR mRNA and the phenotype of an hfq deletion mutant, suggest the involvement of Hfq in this interaction. Taken together, these data support an Hfq-mediated repressive role for SuhB, on ThnR mRNA translation that prevents thn gene induction. SuhB, which is a highly conserved sRNA in the Sphingopyxis genus, is the first identified element directly involved in CCR of thn gene expression in S. granuli strain TFA.

Regulatory RNA in Mycobacterium tuberculosis, back to basics

Since the turn of the millenium, RNA-based control of gene expression has added an extra dimension to the central dogma of molecular biology. Still, the roles of Mycobacterium tuberculosis regulatory RNAs and the proteins that facilitate their functions remain elusive, although there can be no doubt that RNA biology plays a central role in the baterium's adaptation to its many host environments. In this review, we have presented examples from model organisms and from M. tuberculosis to showcase the abundance and versatility of regulatory RNA, in order to emphasise the importance of these 'fine-tuners' of gene expression.

The Pseudomonas aeruginosa PrrF1 and PrrF2 Small Regulatory RNAs Promote 2-Alkyl-4-Quinolone Production through Redundant Regulation of the antR mRNA

Pseudomonas aeruginosa is an opportunistic Gram-negative pathogen that requires iron for growth and virulence. Under low-iron conditions, P. aeruginosa transcribes two highly identical (95%) small regulatory RNAs (sRNAs), PrrF1 and PrrF2, which are required for virulence in acute murine lung infection models. The PrrF sRNAs promote the production of 2-akyl-4(1H)-quinolone metabolites (AQs) that mediate a range of biological activities, including quorum sensing and polymicrobial interactions. Here, we show that the PrrF1 and PrrF2 sRNAs promote AQ production by redundantly inhibiting translation of antR, which encodes a transcriptional activator of the anthranilate degradation genes. A combination of genetic and biophysical analyses was used to define the sequence requirements for PrrF regulation of antR, demonstrating that the PrrF sRNAs interact with the antR 5' untranslated region (UTR) at sequences overlapping the translational start site of this mRNA. The P. aeruginosa Hfq protein interacted with UA-rich sequences in both PrrF sRNAs (K_d [dissociation constant] = 50 nM and 70 nM). Hfq bound with lower affinity to the antR mRNA (0.3 μM), and PrrF was able to bind to antR mRNA in the absence of Hfq. Nevertheless, Hfq increased the rate of PrrF annealing to the antR UTR by 10-fold. These studies provide a mechanistic description of how the PrrF1 and PrrF2 sRNAs mediate virulence traits, such as AQ production, in P. aeruginosaIMPORTANCE The iron-responsive PrrF sRNAs play a central role in regulating P. aeruginosa iron homeostasis and pathogenesis, yet the molecular mechanisms by which PrrF regulates gene expression are largely unknown. In this study, we used genetic and biophysical analyses to define the interactions of the PrrF sRNAs with Hfq, an RNA annealer, and the antR mRNA, which has downstream effects on quorum sensing and virulence factor production. These studies provide a comprehensive mechanistic analysis of how the PrrF sRNAs regulate virulence trait production through a key mRNA target in P. aeruginosa.

New aspects of RNA-based regulation by Hfq and its partner sRNAs

Hfq, an RNA chaperone, promotes the pairing of small RNAs (sRNAs) to target mRNAs, mediating post-transcriptional regulation of mRNA stability and translation. This regulation contributes to bacterial adaptation during stress and pathogenesis. Recent advances in sequencing techniques demonstrate the presence of sRNAs encoded not only in intergenic regions but also from the 3' and 5' UTRs of mRNAs, expanding sRNA regulatory networks. Additional layers of regulation by Hfq and its associated RNAs continue to be found. Newly identified RNA sponges modulate the activity of some sRNAs. A subset of sRNAs are proving to be bifunctional, able to pair with targets and also encoding small ORFs or binding other RNA binding proteins, such as CsrA. In addition, there are accumulating examples of Hfq inhibiting mRNA translation in the absence of sRNAs.