Recalibrating the significance of the decline effect in fish ocean acidification research

Ocean acidification and elevated temperatures alter the behavior of a sub-Antarctic fish

The interaction of multiple climate change stressors can affect the behavior of marine fish. While these effects have been reported in tropical and temperate species, much less is known for fish inhabiting high latitudes. We analyzed the combined effects of ocean acidification and the highest and lowest seasonal temperatures on the activity level and boldness of Eleginops maclovinus, an ecologically and commercially important notothenioid fish from the subantarctic area. Juveniles were acclimated for one month to two temperatures (T = 4 and 10 °C) and two pCO2 levels (∼500 and ∼1800 μatm) in a full factorial design. In an open field test, the time spent active was significantly affected by temperature, with fish at 10 °C 1.63 times more active than those at 4 °C, but not by pCO2 or the interaction (T × pCO2). No differences were observed in the average swimming velocity measured when active, nor in the time spent in the inner zone of the tank. A refuge emergence test indicated increased boldness under near-future pCO2 levels with fish emerging 2.06 (4 °C) and 1.23 (10 °C) times faster than those acclimated to present-day pCO2 levels. The disruptions of these fundamental behaviors by these climate-driven stressors could have consequences for foraging and predator-prey interactions, with likely detrimental effects on the interactions among sympatric subantarctic fishes under projected climate change scenarios.

Acidification affects the early development of Colombian endemic fish Prochilodus magdalenae

There is a significant knowledge gap regarding the acidification of freshwater ecosystems and its effects on biological systems. The bocachico (Prochilodus magdalenae), an endemic and migratory species vital to Colombia's inland fisheries, is currently classified as vulnerable. This study evaluated the impact of different pH levels (6.2, 7.2, and 7.6), previously recorded in the species' natural habitat, on its early development. Using an automated IKS Aquastar system, embryo incubation and larval maintenance were monitored from 0 to 5 days post-fertilization, assessing development, hatching, and survival at both organismal and transcriptional levels. Embryos exposed to pH 6.2 showed delayed development within 4 h post-fertilization, the lowest hatching rate (68.33 ± 3.13 %), and survival (23.88 ± 4.53 %), along with the highest incidence of malformations (37.80 ± 4.4 %). The pH 7.6 group also showed adverse effects, but to a lesser extent. Transcriptome analysis revealed a distinct molecular response in the pH 6.2 group, identifying 1214 differentially expressed genes related to early development, ossification, organ formation, sensory systems, and cellular processes. The findings indicate that pH fluctuations previously observed in the species' natural environment significantly affect P. magdalenae during early life stages, which raises serious concerns about the long-term viability of this endemic species and the sustainability of the artisanal fisheries that depend on it.

Commentary: Best practices for performing olfactory behavioral assays on aquatic animals: A guide for comparative physiologists

As more physiologists start to incorporate animal behavior into their experiments, especially in the olfactory behavior research field, some considerations are often overlooked, partly due to the inherited way that physiological experiments are traditionally designed and performed. Here we highlight some of these subtle but important considerations and make a case for why these might affect the results collected from behavioral assays. Our aim is to provide useful suggestions for increased standardization of methods so they can be more easily replicated among different experiments and laboratories. We have focused on areas that are less likely to be mentioned in the materials and methods section of a manuscript such as starvation, preliminary experiments, appropriate sample sizes and considerations when choosing an odorant for an assay. Additionally, we are strongly cautioning against the use of alarm cue to generate behavioral responses due to its highly unstable chemical properties/potency. Instead, we suggest using pure chemicals (made up of one known molecule) such as amino acids, bile acids, or polyamines that are commercially available and easier to make up in known concentrations. Lastly, we strongly suggest using environmentally relevant concentrations of these odorants. We believe these guidelines will help standardize these assays and improve replication of experiments within and between laboratories.

Could future ocean acidification be affecting the energy budgets of marine fish?

With the unprecedented environmental changes caused by climate change including ocean acidification, it has become crucial to understand the responses and adaptive capacity of fish to better predict directional changes in the ecological landscape of the future. We conducted a systematic literature review to examine if simulated ocean acidification (sOA) could influence growth and reproduction in fish within the dynamic energy budget theory framework. As such, we chose to examine metabolic rate, locomotion, food assimilation and growth in early life stages (i.e. larvae and juvenile) and adults. Our goal was to evaluate if acclimatization to sOA has any directional changes in these traits and to explore potential implications for energetic trade-offs in these for growth and reproduction. We found that sOA had negligible effects on energetic expenditure for maintenance and aerobic metabolism due to the robust physiological capacity regulating acid-base and ion perturbations but substantive effects on locomotion, food assimilation and growth. We demonstrated evidence that sOA significantly reduced growth performance of fish in early life stages, which may have resulted from reduced food intake and digestion efficiency. Also, our results showed that sOA may enhance reproduction with increased numbers of offspring although this may come at the cost of altered reproductive behaviours or offspring fitness. While these results indicate evidence for changes in energy budgets because of physiological acclimatization to sOA, the heterogeneity of results in the literature suggests that physiological and neural mechanisms need to be clearly elucidated in future studies. Lastly, most studies on sOA have been conducted on early life stages, which necessitates that more studies should be conducted on adults to understand reproductive success and thus better predict cohort and population dynamics under ongoing climate change.

Hidden impacts of ocean warming and acidification on biological responses of marine animals revealed through meta-analysis

Conflicting results remain on the impacts of climate change on marine organisms, hindering our capacity to predict the future state of marine ecosystems. To account for species-specific responses and for the ambiguous relation of most metrics to fitness, we develop a meta-analytical approach based on the deviation of responses from reference values (absolute change) to complement meta-analyses of directional (relative) changes in responses. Using this approach, we evaluate responses of fish and invertebrates to warming and acidification. We find that climate drivers induce directional changes in calcification, survival, and metabolism, and significant deviations in twice as many biological responses, including physiology, reproduction, behavior, and development. Widespread deviations of responses are detected even under moderate intensity levels of warming and acidification, while directional changes are mostly limited to more severe intensity levels. Because such deviations may result in ecological shifts impacting ecosystem structures and processes, our results suggest that climate change will likely have stronger impacts than those previously predicted based on directional changes alone.