Ethical and cross cultural questions concerning pediatric clinical trials

During a clinical trial of recombinant growth hormone in a population of short stature but otherwise healthy children the following ethical problems were confronted: What are the prospective benefits compared with the foreseeable risks associated with this therapy? Can the doctor really inform the parent and/or the child about the outcomes of the treatment? Who must make the decision about participation in the trial? From which age can the child himself decide about continuing or dropping out? Since the treatment requires frequent check-ups for years, to what extent does the child become psychologically dependent upon the medical profession? Given this possibility, is the child really free to withdraw from the treatment? Is there a conflict between the doctor's autonomy to propose the treatment and the patient's autonomy to decide about participation? Is there a clear threshold between life-threatening problems and minor, cosmetic problems? These dilemmas are discussed in a cross-cultural context.

Growth hormone secretion and effects of growth hormone therapy on growth velocity and weight gain in children with Prader-Willi syndrome

Obesity, short stature, decreased growth rate and delayed skeletal maturation are common features of children with Prader-Willi syndrome (PWS). In contrast to PWS, children with simple exogenous obesity have normal or increased growth rate and normal or advanced skeletal maturation. Decreased growth hormone (GH) secretion evaluated by pharmacological or physiological testing associated with increased plasma insulin-like growth factor (IGF-I) and GH-binding protein (GH-BP) levels are also characteristic of simple obesity. In order to understand whether the suboptimal GH secretion in PWS is an artifact of the obesity, we studied 33 obese and 11 non-obese PWS children, aged 2-16 years.GH secretion was evaluated with three pharmacological stimuli (insulin, clonidine and L-dopa) and by spontaneous 24-hour GH secretion. Skeletal maturation was delayed in 70% whereas plasma IGF-I and GH-BP were either low or normal. Forty subjects, including ten non-obese children, had GH deficiency by standard testing (failure to respond to two pharmacological stimuli), and all but one had blunted spontaneous 24-h GH secretion. No significant correlation between body mass index (wt/ht2) and spontaneous 24-h GH secretion (r = 0.145), p > 0.06) or GH-BP levels (r = 0.19, p > 0.07) was found. Thirty documented GH deficient children have completed at least two years of GH therapy. With treatment the overall mean height SD and weight SD changed from -2.2 to -0.8 and from 3.5 to 2.4 respectively (p < 0.0001). No patient has developed diabetes mellitus. In conclusion, growth velocity, skeletal maturation, GH secretion and GH dependent proteins in PWS resemble GH deficiency more than simple obesity. Our ongoing study suggests that GH deficiency in PWS is not an artifact of obesity. Although it is unlikely that GH deficiency is the only cause of decreased growth velocity and increased adiposity in PWS, it is a common feature and significant contributory factor. Long term observation will be required until achievement of adult height to determine whether GH therapy actually improves final height.

Short stature: new challenges in growth hormone therapy

Until recently, the limited supplies of pituitary derived growth hormone (GH) enabled us to treat only those patients who were classical GH deficient. With the unlimited supplies of recombinant GH available, there is no limitation to the number of patients we can treat. It becomes necessary, however, to select those patients who will most benefit from GH therapy. Our preliminary results demonstrate that the short-term growth response to growth hormone is not an all-or-none phenomenon. The lower the growth velocity and the growth hormone reserve, the better the growth response to therapy. On the other hand we do not recommend institution of GH therapy for children with a normal growth rate and a normal GH spontaneous secretion. In children with classical GH deficiency (GHD) and in children with a subnormal spontaneous secretion of GH (NSD) adult height prediction decreases when GH therapy is started at an age older than 12. We have found that GHD and NSD boys differ in their growth pattern. Pubertal maturation and bone age maturation progress more rapidly in NSD patients. Therefore special caution is needed in NSD patients older than 12 years. The older the patient and the longer the treatment period, the faster the pubertal process can advance. Further studies are needed before recommendations for therapy in non-classical GHD patients can be made. Until patients involved in clinical trials reach final height, recommendations for new indications cannot be made.