T lymphocyte subpopulations in Graves' disease: relationship with clinical conditions

Autoimmune thyroid disease: immunological, pathological, and clinical aspects

Autoimmune thyroiditis, most notably Hashimoto's thyroiditis, appears to be increasing in prevalence and is now more easily detected by sensitive laboratory tests and more invasive procedures such as fine needle aspiration. During the last decade, marked progress has been made in the understanding of these diseases. There is a greater awareness of the interaction between the humoral and cell-mediated arms of the immune system in autoimmune thyroiditis. Recent studies implicate a subpopulation of suppressor T lymphocytes which have an antigen-specific defect, resulting in their suboptimal interaction with the helper T lymphocytes and subsequent autoimmune manifestations. There is some evidence that thyroid epithelial cells which inappropriately express HLA-DR may enhance presentation of thyroid antigens to the immune system, possibly significant in the initiation or enhancement of the autoimmune response. The presence of various antithyroid autoantibodies allows the use of laboratory assays to confirm the clinical diagnosis and predict the results of treatment. There appears to be predisposing genetic factors in the development of autoimmune thyroiditis, with some geographical and racial differences. Environmental factors, most notably dietary intake of iodine, have also been implicated in the pathogenesis of Hashimoto's thyroiditis. Several animal models have been developed addressing such issues. Ongoing studies in the areas of postpartum thyroiditis and childhood thyroiditis are helpful in clarifying their relationship with Hashimoto's thyroiditis. Graves' disease and postpartum thyroiditis are being investigated as possible causes of postpartum depression. The association of Hashimoto's thyroiditis and carcinoma of the thyroid gland is still controversial, but its relationship with malignant lymphoma is now well accepted. Thus, although the pathogenesis of autoimmune thyroiditis remains elusive, there has been significant refinement of the clinical diagnosis, and immunological abnormalities of specific intrathyroidal lymphocytes have been identified. Hopefully, these new areas of knowledge will assist in the treatment of these diseases and in the prevention of the development of malignant lymphomas of the thyroid gland.

Immunological features of endemic goiter

Some immune aspects of simple endemic goiter have been studied through a comparison of IgG, IgA, IgM, kappa and lambda chains, and C3 and C4 in the peripheral blood of 59 patients operated on for goiter and the peripheral blood of 49 normal controls. The median IgM was lower in the goiter blood. The incidence of thyroglobulin (Tg) and microsomal (Mi) antibodies (Abs) was 20.3% in goiter blood and that of nonthyroid autoAbs was 37%. Active and total rosetted blood lymphocytes were counted and OKT3, OKT4, OKT8, Leu 1, Leu3a, Leu2b, T DR+, and NK cell populations were classified. Helper T cells were occasionally decreased when goiter was associated with lymphocytic thyroiditis. The NK percentage was sometimes higher in goiter blood, whereas the T DR+ percentage was not significantly different in the two groups. Lymphocyte infiltration (LI) was noted in 32% of goiters (about 5% with a diffuse and nodular pattern). A prevalence of helper/inducer cells was observed among the infiltrating T cells. HLA-DR antigen (Ag) positive epithelial cells were seen, not only in LI areas. Granular deposits of IgG, IgA, IgM, and C3 on the follicular basal membrane were stained in 6.7% of goiters Patterns histologically and immunologically similar to those in Hashimoto's thyroiditis may therefore be observed in long-standing simple endemic goiter, suggesting that an autoimmune mechanism may be involved in its pathogenesis.

T cell subsets and thyroid-stimulating antibodies in patients with Graves' disease in clinical remission

Patients with active Graves' disease almost constantly show phenotypic alterations of T lymphocytes, such as an increase of "activated" cells recognized by various surface markers (e.g. la antigens). Such alterations are present in a certain number of apparently cured patients. The data herein reported refer to 25 patients with Graves' disease in clinical remission, in whom we have attempted to correlate T cell subset imbalances, the presence of thyroid-stimulating antibodies (TSAb) and the outcome of the subsequent relapse. The results obtained show a significant association between TSAb and the increase of la-positive T cells: no relationship was found between TSAb and other T lymphocyte subsets. One-year clinical follow-up of the patients enabled us to see relapses of hyperthyroidism in only two patients, who had shown in the first control both TSAb positivity and increased la-positive T cells. These results, in our opinion, suggest a role of la antigens expression on T lymphocytes in the clinical course of Graves' disease.

Optic nerve involvement in Graves' ophthalmopathy: a case report and review

Optic neuropathy in Graves' disease is an uncommon, but potentially treatable cause of disabling visual loss. Optic nerve damage is probably secondary to compression by swollen extraocular muscles at the apex of the orbit. The visual loss is usually bilateral and insidiously progressive, although accelerated visual loss, fluctuations in vision, and features mimicking orbital cellulitis may occur. Ocular congestive symptoms and proptosis have no direct relationship to the severity of visual loss. Early diagnosis is facilitated by orbital CT scanning. Oral corticosteroids and radiotherapy, alone or in combination, are the primary modalities of medical treatment. Surgical decompression of the orbit can be used where medical approaches have failed.

T-cell sensitization to autologous thyroid cells and normal non-specific suppressor T-cell function in Graves' disease

We have employed a syngeneic system utilizing thyroid cell monolayers initiated following thyroid surgery co-cultured with autologous T cells to demonstrate T cell autosensitization in patients with Graves' disease. Antigen-induced blastogenesis was monitored using 24 h [3H]thymidine uptake. Control experiments with 5 d cultured normal human thyroid cells from tissue around benign adenomata showed no evidence of syngeneic T cell autosensitization. Human thyroid cells alone were unable to incorporate [3H]thymidine in the presence of bTSH. In three of four experiments with Graves' thyroid cells there was significant induction of autologous T cell blastogenesis with a mean stimulation index of 220%. In parallel experiments we explored the non-specific helper and suppressor T cell function of these and similar patients with Graves' disease. In normal controls (n = 6) increasing numbers of T cells added to a constant number of B cells (consisting of a T cell depleted peripheral mononuclear cell preparation) showed a marked helper effect measured as increasing IgG secretion. As the ratio of T:B cells increased above 4:1 there was a suppression of IgG secretion. One of two hyperthyroid Graves' patients was observed to have deficient T cell function as demonstrated by lack of IgG suppression. The remaining five patients (all but one of whom were euthyroid at the time of testing) had results similar to the controls indicating normal suppressor T cell function in this disease. Such data showed that patients with Graves' disease possessed circulating T cells which exhibited autosensitization to syngeneic thyroid cell surface antigens, a phenomenon not demonstrable in control individuals. Furthermore, this specific T cell autosensitization did not interfere with non-specific T cell function as judged by its influence on IgG secretion.

Autoimmune thyroid disease: purification and phenotypic analysis of intrathyroid T cells

A phenotypic analysis of T cells infiltrating the thyroid of patients with autoimmune thyroid disease (both Graves' disease and Hashimoto's thyroiditis) was performed. T lymphocytes were purified from mononuclear cells extracted from surgically removed tissue. The following markers were evaluated: la antigens, MLR4 antigen (expressed on activated T cells) 5/9 antigen (expressed on a subset of lymphocytes containing the whole "helper-inducer" activity in vitro), Fc gamma-receptors, B9 antigen (expressed by cytotoxic, or precursor of cytotoxic, T cells). We observed increased percentages of 5/9-, MLR4- and la-positive T cells with respect to peripheral blood in both HT and GD: on the contrary, in specimens from nonautoimmune thyroid diseases mononuclear infiltrate was minimal, and even T cell evaluation was not possible. In addition, B9- and Fc gamma-positive T cells were increased in Hashimoto's, but not in Graves' thyroid tissue, thus suggesting a different role of cytotoxic effector mechanisms in the two diseases.

Evidence for an effect of antithyroid drugs on the natural history of Graves' disease

In the United Kingdom, about half the patients with Graves' disease who are given antithyroid drugs are still in remission one year after treatment is stopped. The most widely held view is that such remission rates are due only to the biochemical effects of the drugs, the disease either spontaneously remitting or abating when the immune system is no longer subject to the stimulatory effects of excessive thyroid hormone. We review here the accumulating evidence against both of these alternatives. In contrast, there is now a large body of work which shows that thyrotrophin receptor antibody levels, central to the aetiology of Graves' hyperthyroidism, fall during antithyroid treatment and that remission may be related to this fall in a fashion which is dependent on the dose and duration of treatment. This immunosuppressive effect is supported by experimental data and on the basis of these results we propose that antithyroid drugs may modify the natural history of Graves' disease and contribute to the remission which occurs in a proportion of treated patients.

Incidence of T cell subset imbalance in relatives of Graves' disease patients

In previous reports we demonstrated imbalances of T cell subsets in patients with autoimmune thyroid disease. In the present investigation, we studied several T cell markers with different functional meaning (Fc gamma-receptors, HLA-Ia antigens, MLR4 and 5/9 antigens) in first degree relatives of Graves' disease patients. Our data suggest that imbalances of circulating T cell subpopulations are apparent only when abnormal hormone levels and/or thyroid autoantibodies are present.

Circulating T-cell subsets in Graves' disease: differences between patients with active disease and in remission after 131I-therapy

In the present investigation some surface markers in peripheral blood T lymphocytes of patients with active Graves' disease and subjects in remission after 131I-therapy have been studied. We confirmed low TG levels in untreated patients and normal values in treated subjects. Increased percentages of DR+, MLR4+ (activated T cells), and 5/9+ (inducer-helper) T cells were detected in patients with active disease, thus indicating the presence of activated T cells and suggesting increased levels of helper T cells. High percentages of MLR4+ and 5/9+, but normal levels of DR+ were found in 131I-treated subjects. The different distribution of DR and MLR4 positivities on 5/9+ and 5+9-T cells confirm the different meaning of these two markers of the activation state. The imbalance of T-cell subsets found in 131I-treated subjects and the normal values observed in patients with hyperthyroidism due to toxic adenoma indicate that hyperthyroidism per se is not sufficient to explain the T-cell alterations. The possible meaning of these findings is discussed with respect to previous hypotheses on the pathogenesis of Graves' disease.

Circulating T cell subsets in euthyroid Graves' disease

T cell subpopulations recognized by surfaces markers of different functional meaning have been evaluated in 12 female patients with euthyroid Graves' disease and in 2 patients with ophthalmopathy and Hashimoto's thyroiditis. We have used the following markers: i) receptors for Fc fragments of IgG; ii) antigens recognized by the monoclonal antibodies MLR4, 5/9, BT 2/9 (anti-DR). In the 12 patients with euthyroid Graves' disease a marked decrease of TG cells (which proved to exert suppressor function in several in vitro systems) was observed, as previously reported in hyperthyroid Graves' disease. The 2 Hashimoto's patients with eye changes had normal or high TG. 5/9+ T cells (which contain cells with helper activity in vitro), as well as MLR4+ and BT 2/9+ cells (activated T cells) were normal in the majority of patients, but elevated in the 2 Hashimoto's thyroiditis. The observed abnormality of TG cells in euthyroid Graves' disease might be consistent with the hypothesized autoimmune pathogenesis of endocrine ophthalmopathy.