Transduction of mouse hematopoietic stem cells is more efficient with 10A1 retrovirus vectors than with amphotropic vectors

Hematopoietic stem cell gene therapy

Gene therapy applications that target hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) offer great potential for the treatment of hematologic disease. Despite this promise, clinical success has been limited by poor rates of gene transfer, poor engraftment of modified cells, and poor levels of gene expression. We describe here the basic approach used for HSC gene therapy, briefly review some of the seminal clinical trials in the field, and describe several recent advances directed toward overcoming these limitations.

Highly efficient gene transfer into antigen-specific primary mouse lymphocytes with replication-deficient retrovirus expressing the 10A1 envelope protein

BACKGROUND

Introduction of recombinant genes in the genome of primary lymphocytes by virtue of a replication-deficient retrovirus can be used in immunological studies and for cell-based gene therapy.

METHODS

Packaging cells GP+E86 producing replication-deficient retrovirus incorporating the genes of enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP), C2gamma or C2xi, were generated by calcium phosphate-mediated transfection. Clones with the highest titres of retrovirus vector were isolated from them and their supernatants were used for transduction of PT67 cells. Primary mouse lymphocytes and T-cell hybridoma MD.45 were transduced by centrifugation with retroviral stock. The retroviral content of packaging cell supernatants was determined by dot blotting and hybridization with a DNA probe.

RESULTS

PT67 cells produced approximately 50 times more retrovirus vector than the original GP+E86 clones. When retroviral stocks of PT67 and GP+E86 cells were used at 1/50 dilution and undiluted, respectively (to normalize them for retroviral RNA content), the transduction efficiency of mouse T-cell hybridoma was 40% and 5%, respectively. Centrifugation of target cells with retroviral stock at 2000 g for 60 min increased the percentage of transduced cells two- to three-fold. Within a population of cells isolated from the draining lymph nodes of an immunized mouse and reactivated with an antigen, up to 60% of CD4(+) T cells and up to 80% of B cells could be transduced with a transgene in replication-deficient retrovirus packaged by PT67 cells using the optimized gene transfer protocol.

CONCLUSIONS

This protocol allows for the generation of packaging cells producing high titres of retrovirus vector. The 10A1 envelope protein is superior to the ecotropic one for the transduction of mouse lymphocytes.

Issues in the manufacture and transplantation of genetically modified hematopoietic stem cells

The advent of safe and practical means to correct, enhance or protect blood cells at the genetic level offers tantalizing therapeutic perspectives. At present, gene delivery using a replication-defective retrovirus is the most efficient method to stably transduce hematopoietic cells. The successful adaptation of retroviral infection to hematopoietic stem cells requires optimized transduction conditions that maximize gene transfer while preserving the cells' potential for engraftment and longterm hematopoiesis. The successful establishment of effective transduction protocols hinges on retrovirus biology as well as stem cell and transplantation biology. Interestingly, the genetic approach could permit novel strategies to promote host repopulation by transplanted stem cells. However, regulated and predictable expression of any transgene integrated at random chromosomal locations cannot be taken for granted. Investigation of the control of transgene expression and prevention of vector silencing will become increasingly important.

Gene Therapy 2000

This article reviews 1) the use of gene transfer methods to genetically manipulate hematopoietic stem cell targets, 2) recent advances in technology that are addressing problems that have prevented widespread successful translation of gene transfer approaches for the cure of disease, and 3) recent regulatory issues related to human gene therapy trials.

In Section I, Dr. Nienhuis describes the use of alternative viral envelopes and vector systems to improve efficiency of transduction of hematopoietic stem cells. Major limitations of stem cell transduction are related to low levels of viral receptors on the stem cells of large animal species and the low frequency of cycling stem cells in the bone marrow. Attempts to circumvent these limitations by exploiting non-oncoretroviral vectors and pseudotyping of Moloney vectors with alternative envelopes are discussed.

In Section II, Dr. Hawley addresses new strategies to improve the expression of transgenes in cells derived from long-term reconstituting hematopoietic stem cells. Transgene silencing in transduced hematopoietic stem cells remains an obstacle to gene therapy for some gene sequences. New generations of retroviral backbones designed to both improve expression and reduce silencing in primary cells are explored.

In Section III, Drs. Smith and Cornetta update regulatory issues related to human gene therapy trials. Increased scrutiny of human trials has led to changes in requirements and shifts in emphasis of existing regulations, which apply to human gene therapy trials. The current Food and Drug Administration's structure and regulations and the roles of the Recombinant DNA Advisory Committee of the NIH and other sponsors and partners in gene therapy trials are reviewed.

Gene Therapy 2000

This article reviews 1) the use of gene transfer methods to genetically manipulate hematopoietic stem cell targets, 2) recent advances in technology that are addressing problems that have prevented widespread successful translation of gene transfer approaches for the cure of disease, and 3) recent regulatory issues related to human gene therapy trials.

In Section I, Dr. Nienhuis describes the use of alternative viral envelopes and vector systems to improve efficiency of transduction of hematopoietic stem cells. Major limitations of stem cell transduction are related to low levels of viral receptors on the stem cells of large animal species and the low frequency of cycling stem cells in the bone marrow. Attempts to circumvent these limitations by exploiting non-oncoretroviral vectors and pseudotyping of Moloney vectors with alternative envelopes are discussed.

In Section II, Dr. Hawley addresses new strategies to improve the expression of transgenes in cells derived from long-term reconstituting hematopoietic stem cells. Transgene silencing in transduced hematopoietic stem cells remains an obstacle to gene therapy for some gene sequences. New generations of retroviral backbones designed to both improve expression and reduce silencing in primary cells are explored.

In Section III, Drs. Smith and Cornetta update regulatory issues related to human gene therapy trials. Increased scrutiny of human trials has led to changes in requirements and shifts in emphasis of existing regulations, which apply to human gene therapy trials. The current Food and Drug Administration's structure and regulations and the roles of the Recombinant DNA Advisory Committee of the NIH and other sponsors and partners in gene therapy trials are reviewed.