Quantitative Analysis of Biological Responses to Ionizing Radiation, Including Dose, Irradiation Time, and Dose Rate

Short- and long-term effects of radiation exposure at low dose and low dose rate in normal human VH10 fibroblasts

Introduction

Experimental studies complement epidemiological data on the biological effects of low doses and dose rates of ionizing radiation and help in determining the dose and dose rate effectiveness factor.

Methods

Human VH10 skin fibroblasts exposed to 25, 50, and 100 mGy of 137Cs gamma radiation at 1.6, 8, 12 mGy/h, and at a high dose rate of 23.4 Gy/h, were analyzed for radiation-induced short- and long-term effects. Two sample cohorts, i.e., discovery (n = 30) and validation (n = 12), were subjected to RNA sequencing. The pool of the results from those six experiments with shared conditions (1.6 mGy/h; 24 h), together with an earlier time point (0 h), constituted a third cohort (n = 12).

Results

The 100 mGy-exposed cells at all abovementioned dose rates, harvested at 0/24 h and 21 days after exposure, showed no strong gene expression changes. DMXL2, involved in the regulation of the NOTCH signaling pathway, presented a consistent upregulation among both the discovery and validation cohorts, and was validated by qPCR. Gene set enrichment analysis revealed that the NOTCH pathway was upregulated in the pooled cohort (p = 0.76, normalized enrichment score (NES) = 0.86). Apart from upregulated apical junction and downregulated DNA repair, few pathways were consistently changed across exposed cohorts. Concurringly, cell viability assays, performed 1, 3, and 6 days post irradiation, and colony forming assay, seeded just after exposure, did not reveal any statistically significant early effects on cell growth or survival patterns. Tendencies of increased viability (day 6) and reduced colony size (day 21) were observed at 12 mGy/h and 23.4 Gy/min. Furthermore, no long-term changes were observed in cell growth curves generated up to 70 days after exposure.

Discussion

In conclusion, low doses of gamma radiation given at low dose rates had no strong cytotoxic effects on radioresistant VH10 cells.

WAM to SeeSaw model for cancer therapy - overcoming LQM difficulties

PURPOSE

The assessment of biological effects caused by radiation exposure has been currently carried out with the linear-quadratic (LQ) model as an extension of the linear non-threshold (LNT) model. In this study, we suggest a new mathematical model named as SeaSaw (SS) model, which describes proliferation and cell death effects by taking account of Bergonie-Tribondeau's law in terms of a differential equation in time. We show how this model overcomes the long-standing difficulties of the LQ model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We construct the SS model as an extended Wack-A-Mole (WAM) model by using a differential equation with respect to time in order to express the dynamics of the proliferation effect. A large number of accumulated data of such parameters as α and β in the LQ based models provide us with valuable pieces of information on the corresponding parameter b 1 and the maximum volume V m of the SS model. The dose rate b 1 and the notion of active cell can explain the present data without introduction of β, which is obtained by comparing the SS model with not only the cancer therapy data but also with in vitro experimental data. Numerical calculations are presented to grasp the global features of the SS model.

RESULTS

The SS model predicts the time dependence of the number of active- and inactive-cells. The SS model clarifies how the effect of radiation depends on the cancer stage at the starting time in the treatment. Further, the time dependence of the tumor volume is calculated by changing individual dose strength, which results in the change of the irradiation duration for the same effect. We can consider continuous irradiation in the SS model with interesting outcome on the time dependence of the tumor volume for various dose rates. Especially by choosing the value of the dose rate to be balanced with the total growth rate, the tumor volume is kept constant.

CONCLUSIONS

The SS model gives a simple equation to study the situation of clinical radiation therapy and risk estimation of radiation. The radiation parameter extracted from the cancer therapy is close to the value obtained from animal experiment in vitro and in vivo. We expect the SS model leads us to a unified description of radiation therapy and protection and provides a great development in cancer-therapy clinical-planning.

Dynamics of cellular responses to radiation

Understanding the consequences of exposure to low dose ionizing radiation is an important public health concern. While the risk of low dose radiation has been estimated by extrapolation from data at higher doses according to the linear non-threshold model, it has become clear that cellular responses can be very different at low compared to high radiation doses. Important phenomena in this respect include radioadaptive responses as well as low-dose hyper-radiosensitivity (HRS) and increased radioresistance (IRR). With radioadaptive responses, low dose exposure can protect against subsequent challenges, and two mechanisms have been suggested: an intracellular mechanism, inducing cellular changes as a result of the priming radiation, and induction of a protected state by inter-cellular communication. We use mathematical models to examine the effect of these mechanisms on cellular responses to low dose radiation. We find that the intracellular mechanism can account for the occurrence of radioadaptive responses. Interestingly, the same mechanism can also explain the existence of the HRS and IRR phenomena, and successfully describe experimentally observed dose-response relationships for a variety of cell types. This indicates that different, seemingly unrelated, low dose phenomena might be connected and driven by common core processes. With respect to the inter-cellular communication mechanism, we find that it can also account for the occurrence of radioadaptive responses, indicating redundancy in this respect. The model, however, also suggests that the communication mechanism can be vital for the long term survival of cell populations that are continuously exposed to relatively low levels of radiation, which cannot be achieved with the intracellular mechanism in our model. Experimental tests to address our model predictions are proposed.

The effect of low-dose radiation on cells and tissues is a public health concern, because the human population is exposed to low-dose ionizing radiation coming from a variety of sources, such as cosmic rays, soil radioactivity, environmental contaminations, and various medical procedures. At low doses of radiation, phenomena are observed that do not occur at higher doses, such as radioadaptive responses as well as low-dose hyper-radiosensitivity (HRS) and increased radioresistance (IRR), which are so far not fully understood. Each of these phenomena have been investigated separately, and specific mechanisms have been suggested to explain them. Using mathematical models that are successfully fitted to experimental data under a variety of conditions, we show that a set of basic and documented assumptions about cellular responses to low-dose radiation can explain all three low-dose phenomena, indicating that they are inter-related. According to the model, these phenomena are brought about by the multi-factorial interactions that underlie the population dynamics of the cells involved, and this provides a new framework to understand these responses, and to evaluate the risk to human health posed by exposure to low-dose radiation.

Radiation-induced carcinogenesis: mechanistically based differences between gamma-rays and neutrons, and interactions with DMBA

Different types of ionizing radiation produce different dependences of cancer risk on radiation dose/dose rate. Sparsely ionizing radiation (e.g. γ-rays) generally produces linear or upwardly curving dose responses at low doses, and the risk decreases when the dose rate is reduced (direct dose rate effect). Densely ionizing radiation (e.g. neutrons) often produces downwardly curving dose responses, where the risk initially grows with dose, but eventually stabilizes or decreases. When the dose rate is reduced, the risk increases (inverse dose rate effect). These qualitative differences suggest qualitative differences in carcinogenesis mechanisms. We hypothesize that the dominant mechanism for induction of many solid cancers by sparsely ionizing radiation is initiation of stem cells to a pre-malignant state, but for densely ionizing radiation the dominant mechanism is radiation-bystander-effect mediated promotion of already pre-malignant cell clone growth. Here we present a mathematical model based on these assumptions and test it using data on the incidence of dysplastic growths and tumors in the mammary glands of mice exposed to high or low dose rates of γ-rays and neutrons, either with or without pre-treatment with the chemical carcinogen 7,12-dimethylbenz-alpha-anthracene (DMBA). The model provides a mechanistic and quantitative explanation which is consistent with the data and may provide useful insight into human carcinogenesis.

Suppressive effects of continuous low-dose-rate γ irradiation on diabetic nephropathy in type II diabetes mellitus model mice

It has been proposed that the development of diabetic nephropathy is caused in large part by oxidative stress. We previously showed that continuous exposure of mice to low-dose-rate γ radiation enhances antioxidant activity. Here, we studied the ameliorative effect of continuous whole-body irradiation with low-dose-rate γ rays on diabetic nephropathy. Ten-week-old female db/db mice, an experimental model for type II diabetes, were irradiated with low-dose-rate γ rays from 10 weeks of age throughout their lives. Nephropathy was studied by histological observation and biochemical analysis of serum and urine. Antioxidant activities in kidneys were determined biochemically. Continuous low-dose-rate γ radiation significantly increases life span in db/db mice. Three of 24 irradiated mice were free of glucosuria after 80 weeks of irradiation. Histological studies of kidney suggest that low-dose irradiation increases the number of normal capillaries in glomeruli. Antioxidant activities of superoxide dismutase, catalase and glutathione are significantly increased in kidneys of irradiated db/db mice. Continuous low-dose-rate γ irradiation ameliorates diabetic nephropathy and increases life span in db/db mice through the activation of renal antioxidants. These findings have noteworthy implications for radiation risk estimation of non-cancer diseases as well as for the clinical application of low-dose-rate γ radiation for diabetes treatment.

A U-shaped dose-response relationship between x radiation and sex-linked recessive lethal mutation in male germ cells of Drosophila

We reported previously that low-dose X irradiation of DNA repair-proficient immature sperm of wild-type Drosophila melanogaster at a low dose rate (50 mGy/min) resulted in a mutation frequency that was lower than that in the sham-irradiated group. Therefore, a U-shaped dose-response relationship was suggested. Here we show that the dose-response curve is actually U-shaped by carrying out a large-scale sex-linked recessive lethal assay using Drosophila. No reduction of the mutation frequency was observed in a strain mutant for the nucleotide excision repair gene mei-9a (Drosophila homologue of human XPF). Introduction of a chromosome fragment containing mei-9+ into the mei-9a mutant strain restored the reduction of the mutation frequency in the low-dose-irradiated group. These results showed that DNA repair was responsible for the U-shaped dose-response relationship in Drosophila.

Reduction in mutation frequency by very low-dose gamma irradiation of Drosophila melanogaster germ cells

To determine whether the linear no-threshold (LNT) model for stochastic effects of ionizing radiation is applicable to very low-dose radiation at a low dose rate, we irradiated immature male germ cells of the fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, with several doses of (60)Co gamma rays at a dose rate of 22.4 mGy/h. Thereafter, we performed the sex-linked recessive lethal mutation assay by mating the irradiated males with nonirradiated females. The mutation frequency in the group irradiated with 500 microGy was found to be significantly lower than that in the control group (P < 0.01), whereas in the group subjected to 10 Gy irradiation, the mutation frequency was significantly higher than that in the control group (P < 0.03). A J-shaped dose-response relationship was evident. Molecular experiments using DNA microarray and quantitative reverse transcription PCR indicated that several genes known to be expressed in response to heat or chemical stress and grim, a positive regulator of apoptosis, were up-regulated immediately after irradiation with 500 microGy. The involvement of an apoptosis function in the non-linear dose-response relationship was suggested.

hTERT-immortalized cells useful for analyzing effects of low-dose-rate radiation on human cells

To establish immortal human cells, we introduced the cDNA of the human telomere reverse transcriptase (hTERT) gene into skin fibroblast cells obtained from normal and ataxia telangiectasia (AT) individuals of Japanese origin. hTERT-immortalized cells retained their original characteristics and radiosensitivity except for immortalization, suggesting that these cells might be useful for analyzing the effects of radiation on human cells.hTERT-immortalized cells from a normal individual showed a greater resistance after low-dose-rate irradiation than after high-dose-rate irradiation. In contrast, cells from AT patients irradiated at a low-dose rate showed virtually the same survival as those irradiated at a high-dose rate. In hTERT-immortalized normal cells, the genetic effects of low-dose-rate radiation were quantitatively and qualitatively less severe than those of high-dose-rate radiation. In hTERT-immortalized AT cells, some fraction of DNA damage such as DNA double-strand breaks might not be repaired, and AT cells were severely affected by low-dose-rate radiation. The activation of ataxia telangiectasia mutated (ATM) protein was confirmed during low-dose-rate radiation, and may play an important role in repair of DNA damage induced by low-dose-rate radiation. This paper reviews briefly the current research at our laboratory. The hTERT-immortalized cells may be useful in determining the effects of low-dose and low-dose-rate radiation on human cells.

Low dose X-radiation adaptive response in spleen and prostate of Atm knockout heterozygous mice

PURPOSE

To investigate the effect of being heterozygous for a knockout mutation in the ataxia telangiectasia (Atm) gene on radiation adaptive response.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

DNA recombination, as measured by pKZ1 inversion frequency, was quantified by histochemistry in Atm knockout heterozygous prostate and spleen 3 days after treatment with a priming dose of 0.01 or 10 mGy X-radiation 4 h prior to a challenge dose of 1,000 mGy.

RESULTS

In spleen and prostate, a single dose of 0.01 mGy caused an induction in inversion frequency but a dose of 10 mGy prevented the induction of a proportion of endogenous inversions. Both doses induced an adaptive response, of similar magnitude, to a subsequent high challenge dose for chromosomal inversions in both spleen and prostate. The adaptive response completely prevented the induction of inversions from a 1,000 mGy challenge dose and also a proportion of endogenous inversions. The adaptive responses and distribution of inversions across gland cross-sections observed here in Atm knockout heterozygote prostate were similar to those induced in Atm wild-type prostate in a previous study.

CONCLUSIONS

Being heterozygous for a knockout mutation in the Atm gene does not affect the endogenous pKZ1 inversion frequency, the inversion response to single low radiation doses used here, or the induction of a radiation adaptive response for inversions in pKZ1 mouse spleen or prostate.

Amelioration of type II diabetes in db/db mice by continuous low-dose-rate gamma irradiation

Low-dose-rate radiation modulates various biological responses including carcinogenesis, immunological responses and diabetes. We found that continuous irradiation with low-dose-rate gamma rays ameliorated type II diabetes in db/db mice, diabetic mice that lack leptin receptors. Whole-body exposure of db/db mice to low dose-rate gamma radiation improved glucose clearance without affecting the response to insulin. Histological studies suggested that degeneration of pancreatic islets was significantly suppressed by the radiation. Insulin secretion in response to glucose loading was increased significantly in the irradiated mice. These results suggest that low-dose-rate gamma radiation ameliorates type II diabetes by maintaining insulin secretion, which gradually decreases during the progression of diabetes due to degeneration of pancreatic islets. We also inferred that protection from oxidative damage is involved in the anti-diabetic effect of low-dose-rate gamma rays because expression and activity of pancreatic superoxide dismutase were significantly elevated by low-dose-rate gamma radiation.

DNA repair defect in AT cells and their hypersensitivity to low-dose-rate radiation

Ataxia telangiectasia (AT) and normal cells immortalized with the human telomerase gene were irradiated in non-proliferative conditions with high- (2 Gy/min) or low-dose-rate (0.3 mGy/min) radiation. While normal cells showed a higher resistance after irradiation at a low dose rate than a high dose rate, AT cells showed virtually the same survival after low- and high-dose-rate irradiation. Although the frequency of micronuclei induced by low-dose-rate radiation was greatly reduced in normal cells, it was not reduced significantly in AT cells. The number of gamma-H2AX foci increased in proportion to the dose in both AT and normal cells after high-dose-rate irradiation. Although few gamma-H2AX foci were observed after low-dose-rate irradiation in normal cells, significant and dose-dependent numbers of gamma-H2AX foci were observed in AT cells even after low-dose-rate irradiation, indicating that DNA damage was not completely repaired during low-dose-rate irradiation. Significant phosphorylation of ATM proteins was detected in normal cells after low-dose-rate irradiation, suggesting that the activation of ATM plays an important role in the repair of DNA damage during low-dose-rate irradiation. In conclusion, AT cells may not be able to repair some fraction of DNA damage and are severely affected by low-dose-rate radiation.

Dose-Rate Effect on the Induction ofHPRTMutants in Human G0Lymphocytes ExposedIn Vitroto Gamma Radiation

The influence of dose rate on expression time, cell survival and mutant frequency at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyltransferase (HPRT) locus was evaluated in human G(0) peripheral blood lymphocytes exposed in vitro to gamma rays at low (0.0014 Gy/min) and high (0.85 Gy/min) dose rates. A cloning assay performed on different days of postirradiation incubation indicated an 8-day maximum expression period for the induction of HPRT mutants at both high and low dose rates. Cell survival increased markedly with decreasing dose rate, yielding D(0) values of 3.04 Gy and 1.3 Gy at low and high dose rates, respectively. The D(0) of 3.04 Gy obtained at low dose rate could be attributed to the repair of sublethal DNA damage taking place during prolonged exposure to low-LET radiation. Regression analysis of the mutant frequency yielded slopes of 12.35 x 10(-6) and 3.66 x 10(-6) mutants per gray at high and low dose rate, respectively. A dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor of 3.4 indicated a marked dose-rate effect on the induced HPRT mutant frequency. The results indicate that information obtained from in vitro measurements of dose-rate effects in human G(0) lymphocytes may be a useful parameter for risk estimation in radiation protection.

Cytotoxic and Mutagenic Effects of Chronic Low-Dose-Rate Irradiation onTERT-Immortalized Human Cells

To analyze the genetic effects of low-dose-rate radiation on human cells, we used human telomere reverse transcriptase (TERT)-immortalized fibroblast cells obtained from normal individuals. We studied the effect of low-dose-rate (0.3 mGy/ min) and high-dose-rate (2 Gy/min) radiation on cells in a confluent state. Survival and micronucleus induction frequency showed higher resistance after irradiation at low dose rate than at high dose rate. The survival after 5 Gy of high-dose-rate radiation was 0.01 compared to 0.3 after low-dose-rate irradiation at the same dose. In accordance with this, the level of HPRT mutation induction by low-dose-rate radiation decreased to approximately one-eighth that for high-dose-rate radiation. We then characterized the mutants by multiplex PCR analysis, which showed that the fraction of deletion mutations was lower in the mutant cells induced at low dose rate than at high dose rate. Furthermore, the size of the deletions in mutant cells induced by low-dose-rate radiation appeared to be smaller than those in mutant cells irradiated at high dose rate. Only a few exons were deleted in the former mutants while all exons were deleted in most of the latter mutants. The present study indicates that the genetic effects of low-dose-rate radiation on nonproliferating normal human cells are quantitatively and qualitatively less severe than the effect of high-dose-rate radiation.