Long term effect of systemic tetracycline administration on the severity of induced periodontitis in the rat

Illuminating the oral microbiome and its host interactions: animal models of disease

Periodontitis and caries are driven by complex interactions between the oral microbiome and host factors, i.e. inflammation and dietary sugars, respectively. Animal models have been instrumental in our mechanistic understanding of these oral diseases, although no single model can faithfully reproduce all aspects of a given human disease. This review discusses evidence that the utility of an animal model lies in its capacity to address a specific hypothesis and, therefore, different aspects of a disease can be investigated using distinct and complementary models. As in vitro systems cannot replicate the complexity of in vivo host-microbe interactions and human research is typically correlative, model organisms-their limitations notwithstanding-remain essential in proving causality, identifying therapeutic targets, and evaluating the safety and efficacy of novel treatments. To achieve broader and deeper insights into oral disease pathogenesis, animal model-derived findings can be synthesized with data from in vitro and clinical research. In the absence of better mechanistic alternatives, dismissal of animal models on fidelity issues would impede further progress to understand and treat oral disease.

Periodontitis induced by orthodontic wire ligature drives oral microflora dysbiosis and aggravates alveolar bone loss in an improved murine model

Aim

To assess the contribution of polymicrobial disruption of host homeostasis to periodontitis progression in orthodontic wire ligation murine model.

Methods

Orthodontic wire rings were inserted between the first and second molars of mice for 18 days for the orthodontic wire ligation mouse model, and Pg injection model and Pg-LPS injection model were used as controls. Alveolar bone loss and periodontal inflammation were analyzed by micro-CT, histological staining and qRT-PCR. Further, pyrosequencing of 16S rRNA gene amplicon was used to analyze the development of oral microorganism dysbiosis in the mice.

Results

Micro-CT, TRAP staining and qRT-PCR showed that orthodontic wire ligation model led to more severe alveolar bone loss than Pg and Pg-LPS models.

H&E staining and qRT-PCR demonstrated that stronger inflammatory response was induced by the orthodontic wire treatment compared to the other models. In addition, pyrosequencing of 16S rRNA gene amplicons revealed that the composition of oral microbiota presented a transition as the disease progressed and significant differences emerged in oral microbiota communities between orthodontic ligature mice and healthy controls. Furthermore, antibiotic treatment decreased both inflammation and alveolar bone loss in response to microbial community dysbiosis. However, no significant difference in bacterial community composition was observed in Pg and Pg-LPS models.

Conclusions

Orthodontic wire ligation drove oral microbial community transitions that mimicked polymicrobial communities characterized by polymicrobial synergy and dysbiosis. Our improved model is suitable for further study of pathogenesis of periodontitis and exploration of corresponding treatment strategies.

Experimental models of orthodontic tooth movement and their effects on periodontal tissues remodelling

OBJECTIVES

The present study aimed to compare two different models of orthodontic tooth movement (OTM) in rats by evaluating tooth movement efficiency and periodontal tissues remodelling.

DESIGN

Fifteen animals were randomly distributed into 3 groups: control group (untreated); ligature appliance (LA) as experimental OTM using a closed coil spring fixed around maxillary first molar by steel ligature; occlusal appliance (OA) as experimental OTM using a closed coil spring attached on the occlusal surface of the maxillary first molar. After 15 days, all animals were euthanized, and the maxilla of each animal was collected for qPCR, micro-computed tomography, and histological analyses.

RESULTS

Interleukin-1 beta, interleukin-6, and tumor necrosis factor-alpha gene expressions were significantly upregulated in the animals of the LA group as compared to the other groups. No significant difference was observed in tooth displacement between both methods. The LA group presented higher linear bone loss and lower values of bone volume fraction, bone mineral density, trabecular number and increased values of trabecular separation compared to the other groups. The birefringent collagen content in the tension side of the periodontal ligament contained significantly lower collagen content in the LA group than in the control group. Furthermore, on the pressure side, the collagen content was significantly lower in the LA and OA groups than in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

The OA group presented little or no deleterious effect on periodontal tissues compared to the LA group, suggesting its use may be more reliable for OTM induction in rats for 15 days.

PRMT5 inhibition modulates murine dendritic cells activation by inhibiting the metabolism switch: a new therapeutic target in periodontitis

Background

Protein arginine methyltransferase 5 (PRMT5) catalyzes the methylation of arginine residues in multiple proteins. Recent reports have highlighted the anti-inflammatory role of PRMT5. Dendritic cells (DCs) are well-known professional antigen-presenting cells that are crucial for immune response initiation. However, whether PRMT5 participates in DC immunity processes is unknown.

Methods

In an in vitro experiment, a PRMT5 inhibitor (EPZ015666) was used to inhibit PRMT5 expression, and lipopolysaccharide (LPS) stimulation was applied to mimic the inflammation context. Proinflammatory cytokine production, interferon-stimulated genes (ISGs), costimulatory molecules, major histocompatibility complex (MHC) expression and DC metabolism were measured following PRMT5 inhibition and LPS stimulation. In an in vivo study, we first tested PRMT5 mRNA and protein expression in a BALB/c mouse ligature-induced periodontitis model. Then, we evaluated changes in periodontal tissue and DC migration to cervical lymph nodes after local treatment with the PRMT5 inhibitor.

Results

The in vitro results revealed that PRMT5 inhibition attenuated DC activation and maturation by inhibiting the expression of proinflammatory cytokines, ISGs, costimulatory molecules, and MHC induced by LPS stimulation. We also found that inhibition of PRMT5 blocked the DC metabolic switch to glycolysis. In the in vivo study, we found that PRMT5 inhibition reversed the severity of the lesions and slowed the migration of DCs to cervical lymph nodes.

Conclusions

The results show a critical role of PRMT5 in the control of DC activation through inhibition of the metabolic switch and indicate that PRMT5 is a promising therapeutic target in periodontitis.

Inhibition of sphingosine-1-phosphate receptor 2 attenuated ligature-induced periodontitis in mice

Objectives

Periodontitis is an inflammatory bone loss disease initiated by oral bacterial inflammation. Herein, we determined whether inhibition of sphingosine‐1‐phosphate receptor 2 (S1PR2, a G protein‐coupled receptor) by its specific antagonist, JTE013, could alleviate ligature‐induced periodontitis in mice.

Materials and Methods

C57BL/6 mice were placed with silk ligatures at the left maxillary second molar to induce experimental periodontitis. Mice were treated with JTE013 or control vehicle (dimethyl sulfoxide, DMSO) oral topically on the ligatures once daily. After 15 days of treatment, RNA was extracted from the lingual mucosal tissues to quantify IL‐1β, IL‐6, and TNF mRNA levels in the tissues. Alveolar bone loss was determined by micro‐computed tomography. Sagittal periodontal tissue sections were cut and stained by hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) for general histology, or stained by tartrate‐resistant acid phosphatase (TRAP) for osteoclasts.

Results

Treatment with JTE013 attenuated ligature‐induced alveolar bone loss compared with DMSO treatment. Treatment with JTE013 reduced IL‐1β, IL‐6, and TNF mRNA levels in murine gingival mucosal tissues, inhibited leukocyte infiltration in the periodontal tissues, and decreased the number of osteoclasts in the periodontal tissues compared with controls.

Conclusion

Oral topical administration of JTE013 alleviated periodontal inflammatory bone loss induced by ligature placement in mice.

An experimental murine model to study periodontitis

Periodontal disease (PD) is a common dental disease associated with the interaction between dysbiotic oral microbiota and host immunity. It is a prevalent disease, resulting in loss of gingival tissue, periodontal ligament, cementum and alveolar bone. PD is a major form of tooth loss in the adult population. Experimental animal models have enabled the study of PD pathogenesis and are used to test new therapeutic approaches for treating the disease. The ligature-induced periodontitis model has several advantages as compared with other models, including rapid disease induction, predictable bone loss and the capacity to study periodontal tissue and alveolar bone regeneration because the model is established within the periodontal apparatus. Although mice are the most convenient and versatile animal models used in research, ligature-induced periodontitis has been more frequently used in large animals. This is mostly due to the technical challenges involved in consistently placing ligatures around murine teeth. To reduce the technical challenge associated with the traditional ligature model, we previously developed a simplified method to easily install a bacterially retentive ligature between two molars for inducing periodontitis. In this protocol, we provide detailed instructions for placement of the ligature and demonstrate how the model can be used to evaluate gingival tissue inflammation and alveolar bone loss over a period of 18 d after ligature placement. This model can also be used on germ-free mice to investigate the role of human oral bacteria in periodontitis in vivo. In conclusion, this protocol enables the mechanistic study of the pathogenesis of periodontitis in vivo.

The enduring importance of animal models in understanding periodontal disease

Whereas no single animal model can reproduce the complexity of periodontitis, different aspects of the disease can be addressed by distinct models. Despite their limitations, animal models are essential for testing the biological significance of in vitro findings and for establishing cause-and-effect relationships relevant to clinical observations, which are typically correlative. We provide evidence that animal-based studies have generated a durable framework for dissecting the mechanistic basis of periodontitis. These studies have solidified the etiologic role of bacteria in initiating the inflammatory response that leads to periodontal bone loss and have identified key mediators (IL-1, TNF, prostaglandins, complement, RANKL) that induce inflammatory breakdown. Moreover, animal studies suggest that dysbiosis, rather than individual bacterial species, are important in initiating periodontal bone loss and have introduced the concept that organisms previously considered commensals can play important roles as accessory pathogens or pathobionts. These studies have also provided insight as to how systemic conditions, such as diabetes or leukocyte adhesion deficiency, contribute to tissue destruction. In addition, animal studies have identified and been useful in testing therapeutic targets.

Development of an animal model for Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans biofilm-mediated oral osteolytic infection: a preliminary study

BACKGROUND

Biofilm-induced inflammatory osteolytic oral infections, such as periodontitis and peri-implantitis, have complex etiology and pathogenesis. A significant obstacle to research has been the lack of appropriate animal models where the inflammatory response to biofilms can be investigated. The aim of this study is to develop a novel animal model to study the host response to Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans (previously Actinobacillus actinomycetemcomitans)-biofilm colonizing titanium implants.

METHODS

Titanium implants were inoculated in vitro with A. actinomycetemcomitans, establishing a biofilm for 1 to 3 days. Biofilm-inoculated and control implants were transmucosally placed into rat hard palate or alveolar ridge. Analysis included documentation of clinical inflammation, polymerase chain reaction, and culture detection of A. actinomycetemcomitans and microcomputed tomography quantitation of peri-implant bone volume.

RESULTS

Viable A. actinomycetemcomitans biofilm was successfully established on titanium implants in vitro, detected by confocal laser scanning microscopy. An inflammatory response characterized by clinical inflammation, bleeding, ulceration, hyperplasia, and necrosis was observed around biofilm-inoculated implants. A. actinomycetemcomitans was detected by polymerase chain reaction and culture analysis on 100% of biofilm-inoculated implants for up to 3 weeks and 25% for up to 6 weeks. Microcomputed tomography analysis demonstrated significantly lower bone volume (P <0.05) around biofilm-inoculated implants (29.6% ± 7.6%) compared to non-inoculated implants (50.5% ± 9.6%) after 6 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

These results describe a novel animal model where A. actinomycetemcomitans biofilm was established in vitro on titanium implants before placement in rat oral cavity, leading to an inflammatory response, osteolysis, and tissue destruction. This model may have potential use for investigation of host responses to biofilm pathogens and antibiofilm therapy.

Inflammation and uncoupling as mechanisms of periodontal bone loss

Periodontal disease is characterized by both inflammation and bone loss. Advances in research in both these areas have led to a new appreciation of not only each field but also the intimate relationship between inflammation and bone loss. This relationship has resulted in a new field of science called osteoimmunology and provides a context for better understanding the pathogenesis of periodontal disease. In this review, we discuss several aspects of the immuno-inflammatory host response that ultimately results in loss of alveolar bone. A proposal is made that periodontal inflammation not only stimulates osteoclastogenesis but also interferes with the uncoupling of bone formation and bone resorption, consistent with a pathologic process. Furthermore, arguments based on experimental animal models suggest a critical role of the spatial and temporal aspects of inflammation in the periodontium. A review of these findings leads to a new paradigm to help explain more fully the impact of inflammation on alveolar bone in periodontal disease so that it includes the effects of inflammation on uncoupling of bone formation from resorption.

The use of rodent models to investigate host-bacteria interactions related to periodontal diseases

Even though animal models have limitations, they are often superior to in vitro or clinical studies in addressing mechanistic questions and serve as an essential link between hypotheses and human patients. Periodontal disease can be viewed as a process that involves four major stages: bacterial colonization, invasion, induction of a destructive host response in connective tissue and a repair process that reduces the extent of tissue breakdown. Animal studies should be evaluated in terms of their capacity to test specific hypotheses rather than their fidelity to all aspects of periodontal disease initiation and progression. Thus, each of the models described below can be adapted to test discrete components of these four major steps, but not all of them. This review describes five different animal models that are appropriate for examining components of host-bacteria interactions that can lead to breakdown of hard and soft connective tissue or conditions that limit its repair as follows: the mouse calvarial model, murine oral gavage models with or without adoptive transfer of human lymphocytes, rat ligature model and rat Aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans feeding model.

Inhibition of Experimental Periodontitis by a Topical Boron-based Antimicrobial

AN0128 is a boron-containing compound with antibacterial and anti-inflammatory properties. To test its potential effectiveness in treating periodontal disease, we induced experimental periodontitis in the rat by placing ligatures and assessed the impact of AN0128 and positive and negative controls by micro-CT and histologic measurements. The formation of an inflammatory infiltrate was measured in hematoxylin-and-eosin-stained sections. Daily application of AN0128 (1%) compared with controls reduced bone loss by 38 to 44% (P < 0.05), while vehicle alone had no effect (P > 0.05). The reduction in bone loss with AN0128 was similar to that achieved with a NSAID, ketorolac, and Total toothpaste containing triclosan. AN0128 also reduced the level of gingival inflammation 42% compared with the ligature only (P < 0.05), whereas vehicle alone had no effect (P > 0.05). The results indicate that AN0128 significantly reduces the formation of an inflammatory infiltrate and reduces bone loss, measured histologically and by micro-CT.

Diabetes enhances periodontal bone loss through enhanced resorption and diminished bone formation

Using a ligature-induced model in type-2 Zucker diabetic fatty (ZDF) rat and normoglycemic littermates, we investigated whether diabetes primarily affects periodontitis by enhancing bone loss or by limiting osseous repair. Diabetes increased the intensity and duration of the inflammatory infiltrate (P < 0.05). The formation of osteoclasts and percent eroded bone after 7 days of ligature placement was similar, while four days after removal of ligatures, the type 2 diabetic group had significantly higher osteoclast numbers and activity (P < 0.05). The amount of new bone formation following resorption was 2.4- to 2.9-fold higher in normoglycemic vs. diabetic rats (P < 0.05). Diabetes also increased apoptosis and decreased the number of bone-lining cells, osteoblasts, and periodontal ligament fibroblasts (P < 0.05). Thus, diabetes caused a more persistent inflammatory response, greater loss of attachment and more alveolar bone resorption, and impaired new bone formation. The latter may be affected by increased apoptosis of bone-lining and PDL cells.

The effect of plaque retention on cyclosporine-induced gingival overgrowth in rats

The purpose of this study was to examine the role of plaque retention on cyclosporine A (CsA)-induced gingival overgrowth. Forty-five male Sprague-Dawley rats, 15 for each of three CsA dosage conditions, were unilaterally ligated around the first mandibular molar (plaque retention). The silk ligature was left in place for 6 weeks. Contralateral first molars served as unligated controls. The daily dosage of CsA, administered by gastric feeding, was 0, 3, or 10 mg/kg body weight. Stone models from biweekly impressions of the molar sites were used to investigate development of gingival overgrowth. Rats were sacrificed at 6 weeks for histopathological and histometric examination of the molar sites. Gingival overgrowth was significantly increased in sites with higher CsA dosage, longer treatment duration, and ligation. Gingival overgrowth was enhanced in ligated sites regardless of CsA dosage. However, the odds ratio of ligated over unligated sites for gingival overgrowth increased with increasing CsA dosage. The histopathological and histometric examination revealed significantly increased gingival volume in ligated sites in CsA-treated animals. The tissue enlargement included both the epithelium and the connective tissue; however, the epithelium to connective tissue ratio remained unaltered. Within limitations of the study, we suggest that plaque retention magnifies CsA-induced gingival overgrowth; thus, dental plaque appears to be a cofactor in the development of CsA-induced gingival overgrowth.

Doxycycline prevents root resorption and alveolar bone loss in rats after periodontal surgery

The effect of systemic doxycycline administration on frequency of root resorption cavities and extent of bone loss following periodontal surgery was studied in albino rats. Thirty Wistar rats with healthy gingiva were divided into four groups. Six untreated animals (Group 1) served as controls. Gingivectomy (Group 2, six rats), mucoperiosteal flap operation (Group 3, eight rats), and mucoperiosteal flap operation with doxycycline added to the drinking water (Group 4, 10 rats) were performed on the palatal aspect of maxillary left molars. After a healing period of 3 wk, the rats were killed by an overdose of sodium pentothal, and specimens of first molars were prepared for light microscopy. Root resorption was absent in normal and gingivectomized animals (Groups 1 and 2). Resorption cavities occurred in all flap-operated animals (Group 3) and in one of 10 doxycycline-treated animals (Group 4). The distance from cementoenamel junction to alveolar bone crest remained unchanged in gingivectomized (Group 2) and doxycycline-treated animals (Group 4), as compared with control specimens. In flap-operated animals (Group 3), the crestal bone level was located more apically than in doxycycline-treated rats (Group 4). This study has shown that root resorption and bone loss were associated with flap operations involving exposure of periodontal ligament and bone. Systemic doxycycline prevented both root resorption and bone loss.

Induction of nonspecific tolerance to endotoxins reduces the alveolar bone resorption in ligature-treated rats

Previous experimental data from various laboratories indicate that endotoxin of gram-negative oral microorganisms might be one of the most important bacterial products involved in bone resorption during periodontitis. Immunologically nonspecific tolerance to endotoxins in rats was induced by repeated application of Serratia marcescens trichloroacetic acid-extracted endotoxin. Silk ligature was placed on the second maxillary molar of the endotoxin-tolerant rats as well as of control rats in which tolerance to endotoxin had not been induced. The animals were sacrificed 8 days later. The rats showed no specific immune response to the tolerance-inducing endotoxin as measured by passive hemagglutination and by the lymphoblast assays, but we found that bone resorption was significantly reduced in the endotoxin-tolerant rats as compared with ligature-treated animals in which tolerance to endotoxin had not been induced.

Effect of tetracycline on gingival inflammation and alveolar bone resorption in beagles: an individual tooth by tooth analysis

The effect of systemic tetracycline on gingival inflammation and alveolar bone resorption was studied in beagle dogs. Seventeen dogs were divided into three groups receiving either no treatment, 250 mg tetracycline HCl, or 500 mg tetracycline HCl daily. The severity of gingival inflammation and activity of alveolar bone resorption during a 6-month pretreatment period was compared to a 24-month treatment period for each individual tooth studied. In the first 12 months of treatment there was a significant decrease in the severity of gingival inflammation and the activity of alveolar bone loss in the tetracycline treated dogs. By 24 months of treatment increased gingival inflammation and rate of bone loss was evident in the treated dogs. In the untreated control dogs there was a statistically significant association between the severity of gingival inflammation and activity of alveolar bone resorption about the teeth studied. In the tetracycline treated dogs, no such association existed.

An evaluation of minocycline in patients with periodontal disease

The purpose of this study was to determine the passage into and concentration of Minocycline HCl (Minocin) in gingival crevicular fluid (GCF) and the relationship between its concentration of saliva. GCF, serum and changes in periodontal health. Over an 8 day period, 10 adults with periodontal disease received orally 200 mg/day of Minocin and 10 other received 150 mg/day. The parameter evaluated included the DMF, gingival index, plaque index, crevice depth, oral soft tissue evaluation. SMA-12, CBC, prothrombin time, and concentrations of Minocin in serum, saliva and GCF. The DMF score, crevice depth, SMA-12, CBC and prothrombin time were determined on days 1 and 8. All other parameters were evaluated on days 1, 2, 3, 5 and 8. The results of this study showed that Minocin administration resulted in no significant changes in blood chemistry, blood counts and prothrombin time, was effective against oral microorganisms as shown by reductions in plaque scores, produces an improvement in gingival health, is present in serum at therapeutically effective levels when given in doses of either 200 mg or 150 mg per day and is concentrated in gingival crevicular fluid at levels 5 times as high as serum.