Service needs of severely disturbed children

Protecting Youth in the Mental Health Service Settings

The authors present the development of the field of psychiatry with the evolution of patient safeguards. They address the recent publicized events involving sexual harassment and abuse perpetrated by mental health service providers who have harmed youth who were under their direct psychiatric care. Recommendations are provided for primary care physicians and parents and legal guardians to further ensure patient safety.

Effectiveness of a children's home and community-based services waiver program

OBJECTIVE

Limited alternatives exist to residential treatment or hospitalization for children with the most serious emotional disturbances. Community-based interventions are intended to offer less restrictive and expensive options than traditional treatment. One such program is New York State's Home and Community-Based Services (HCBS) Waiver Program.

METHODS

From 1996 to 2002, 169 children were enrolled in the Manhattan HCBS. All spent at least one month on the wait list prior to admission to the waiver program. We used our wait list as a control group (WLC), allowing for comparison of the HCBS intervention.

RESULTS

Sample consisted of 169 children between the ages of five and eighteen. The ethnic composition was 46.8% Hispanic (N = 79), 47.9% African-American (N = 81), and 5.3% Caucasian (N = 9). Average stay was 12 months in the HCBS program and 3.5 months for the WLC. Only 30% of children in the WLC were maintained in the community, while 81% of children in the HCBS were similarly maintained (P < 0.001). Also, the rate of hospitalization for the HCBS group was significantly lower (3 versus 41%; P < 0.001). There was also a trend for the WLC group to have had substantially higher rates of removal by the Administration for Children's Services (New York City's protective service agency) (8.3 versus 1.8%) and to more frequently require residential treatment (13.0 versus 8.9%).

CONCLUSIONS

It would seem that the HCBS program appears to be a clinically and cost-effective method of maintaining children in their community.

Cultural and contextual influences in mental health help seeking: a focus on ethnic minority youth

In this article, a mental health help-seeking model is offered as a framework for understanding cultural and contextual factors that affect ethnic minority adolescents' pathways into mental health services. The effects of culture and context are profound across the entire help-seeking pathway, from problem identification to choice of treatment providers. The authors argue that an understanding of these help-seeking pathways provides insights into ethnic group differences in mental health care utilization and that further research in this area is needed.

[Therapeutic needs in psychiatric patients: a systematic review of the literature. I. General concepts and assessment measures. Needs for services]

OBJECTIVE

In Italy, mental health care is in phase of reorganisation. In this frame the measurement of users' needs may be a useful tool in planning individualised mental health service interventions and in their evaluation. Aims of the present study are (I) to highlight the basic concepts of 'needs for care' and give a brief description of the main needs assessment tools specifically developed for psychiatric patients; (II) to review studies assessing needs for mental health services in the general population; (III) to discuss the role played by the assessment of needs in planning mental health care.

METHODS

Studies published in the international literature from January 1980 to June 1999 were reviewed. The studies were located through a computerised search of the databases MEDLINE and PsycLit; in addition, the reference lists of the studies located through the computerised search and the content of main international psychiatric journals were manually scanned in order to avoid possible omissions. Studies assessing needs for services and studies assessing needs on individual level were separately reviewed. Both groups of studies, in turn, were divided in studies assessing needs for mental health care in the general population and in psychiatric patients.

RESULTS

Although most studies on needs for services used indirect methodologies and employed quite heterogeneous experimental design, they provide at large overlapping results. In the general population, about 60%-70% of patients with anxiety, depression and other neurotic disorders and 30%-40% of psychotic patients do not receive any specialist mental health care, suggesting that the majority of subjects suffering from a psychiatric disorder do not receive the mental health care they need.

CONCLUSIONS

Unmet needs for services show a higher frequency in patients with neurotic and depressive disorders, indicating a shortage in services delivery that should be taken into account both by psychiatrists and mental health planners. Moreover, the finding that a large number of patients suffering from psychotic disorders do not receive any kind of mental health care is of particular relevance for planning mental health services, since these subjects are usually the most problematic and difficult to treat.

A systems perspective on research and treatment with abused and neglected children

OBJECTIVE

To discuss two systems-level changes in the organization and financing of mental health and child welfare services that will increasingly affect abused and neglected children: the implementation of managed care processes and the incorporation of accountability mechanisms in the management of mental health and child welfare services, particularly the use of systematic outcomes assessments. A central goal of the paper is to identify critical research questions which will help us to understand the impact of these changes on maltreated children.

METHOD

These two systems-level changes are described, and ways they may affect maltreated children are addressed.

RESULTS

Both managed care and the growing focus on managing services by monitoring outcomes may positively or negatively affect maltreated children. Both of these trends are affecting the mental health and child welfare systems. It is likely that they will affect maltreated children's access to and the quality, cost, and outcomes of mental health and child welfare services.

CONCLUSIONS

Systematic research on the impact of these large-scale changes can increase the likelihood that these changes will benefit maltreated children. A number of critical areas are identified for future research.

The provision of services for rural youth with serious emotional and behavioral problems: Virginia's Comprehensive Services Act

The problems of the delivery of mental health and social services to rural children and adolescents encapsulate many of the problems in the larger health care system. Consequently, many of the principles underlying the President's Health Security Plan are applicable to the reformation of this more specialized service system. The experience of the Commonwealth of Virginia in implementing the Comprehensive Services Act (CSA) highlights the scope of vision needed to transform an existing service delivery system into a coordinated system of care on a state-wide scale.

Community service utilization by youths hospitalized in a state psychiatric facility

A majority of a cohort of 62 children and adolescents who had been hospitalized in a state psychiatric facility was found to have received less restrictive services such as outpatient mental health services prior to their index admission. Also, a number had been involved with the juvenile justice system and almost two-thirds had been placed out-of-home. Ninety percent had at least one prior psychiatric hospitalization. Just over half of the cohort received case management and individual counseling post release. About a third received family counseling, and a few received other types of services. At least a third were rehospitalized within a year of release. Although 90% of the cohort received some type of service post release, a higher proportion of non service receivers were rehospitalized than service receivers. Even those who received services had a high rate of rehospitalization. These findings raise questions as to the appropriateness of service provision during and following hospitalization.