Compartment syndromes associated with postoperative epidural analgesia. A case report

Pain Control with Regional Anesthesia in Patients at Risk of Acute Compartment Syndrome: Review of the Literature and Editorial View

Acute compartment syndrome (ACS) is a devastating complication that can happen in almost every part of the human body, most noticeably after long bone fractures. The cardinal symptom of ACS is pain in excess of what would otherwise be expected from the underlying injury and unresponsive to routine analgesia treatment. There is paucity of literature on major analgesic management strategies including opioid analgesia, epidural anesthesia, and peripheral nerve blocks with regard to their differential efficacy and safety of pain management in patients at risk of developing ACS. The lack of quality data has led to recommendations that are perhaps more conservative than they should be, particularly when it comes to peripheral nerve blocks. In this review article, we attempt to make recommendations in favor of regional anesthesia in this vulnerable group of patients and strategies that will optimize adequate pain control and improve surgical outcome without jeopardizing patient safety.

Combined Gluteal and Posterior Thigh Compartment Syndrome Without Associated Fracture: A Case Report

Compartment syndrome usually occurs after trauma, fracture, or compression injuries. To the authors' best knowledge, this is the first reported case in the medical literature of a combined gluteal and posterior thigh compartment syndrome after an accidental fall without an associated fracture. A 65-year-old man attended the emergency department of the general hospital in a remote island complaining of a swollen painful thigh. He reported that 24 h previously he had an accidental slip and fall on his overstretching right leg. Physical examination revealed right posterior thigh edema, tenderness, paraesthesia, and firmness to palpation. Any attempt to flex the knee provoked pain of intensity 10/10. In addition, there was blue discoloration over the lower half of the gluteal region, non-compressible tense swelling, and pain of intensity 10/10 elicited with passive range of motion of the hip. Compartment syndrome was considered and consequently, fasciotomy of the gluteal and posterior thigh compartments was performed under spinal anesthesia. Compartment syndrome is a surgical emergency. In a remote island, it must be considered and treated early because any delayed diagnosis may lead to loss of an extremity, kidney failure, sepsis and even death.

Regional anesthesia and acute compartment syndrome: principles for practice

Acute compartment syndrome (ACS) is a potentially reversible orthopedic surgical emergency leading to tissue ischemia and ultimately cell death. Diagnosis of ACS can be challenging, as neither clinical symptoms nor signs are sufficiently sensitive. The cardinal symptom associated with ACS is pain reported in excess of what would otherwise be expected for the underlying injury, and not reasonably managed by opioid-based analgesia. Regional anesthesia (RA) techniques are traditionally discouraged in clinical settings where the development of ACS is a concern as sensory and motor nerve blockade may mask symptoms and signs of ACS. This Education article addresses the most common trauma and elective orthopedic surgical procedures in adults with a view towards assessing their respective risk of ACS and offering suggestions regarding the suitability of RA for each type of surgery.

Compartment syndrome of the non-injured limb

Compartment syndrome is a common limb-threatening entity in trauma. However, the occurrence of the same in the non-injured limb is rare. It seems to be multifactorial in origin, with abnormal positioning being the most common cause. We present such a case of well-leg compartment syndrome which was treated by an urgent fasciotomy. We emphasise on the fact that the diagnosis of compartment syndrome is clinical and the management remains the same irrespective of whether the limb has sustained an injury or not.

Regional anesthesia or patient-controlled analgesia and compartment syndrome in orthopedic surgical procedures: a systematic review

A systematic review of the literature on the use of regional anesthesia (RA) and patient-controlled analgesia (PCA) was conducted in patients who require orthopedic extremity procedures to determine whether either analgesic technique contributes to a delayed diagnosis of compartment syndrome (CS). A total of 34 relevant articles (28 case reports and six research articles) were identified. Of all case report articles published after 2009, the majority (75%) concluded that RA does not put the patient at an increased risk of a delayed diagnosis of CS. Of these, only two relevant prospective research studies focusing on RA or PCA and their relationship to CS were identified. Neither study resulted in any cases of CS. However, both had relatively small sample sizes. Given the lack of evidence identified in this systematic review, prospective studies or large-scale retrospective data reviews are needed to more strongly advocate the use of one modality of analgesia over the other in this patient population.

Acute compartment syndrome of the thigh in a rugby player

In the absence of obvious trauma, diagnosis of acute compartment syndrome (ACS) of the thigh can easily be delayed, as disproportional pain is not always present. We present a case of ACS of the anterior right thigh compartment in a healthy, semiprofessional rugby player with normal coagulation, who sustained a seemingly innocuous blow during a rugby match. Following early surgical fasciotomy, he returned to his preinjury playing standards within 12 months. Our literature review suggests that high muscle mass, young, athletic males participating in a contact sport are mostly at risk of developing ACS of the thigh.

A case of delayed presentation of thigh compartment syndrome

BACKGROUND

Thigh compartment syndrome is a rare and devastating process. It generally occurs within hours to days of a traumatic event, although cases have been reported nearly 2 weeks after the initial event.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the literature describing the timing between inciting event and presentation of thigh compartment syndromes, with a focus on delayed presentations of this rare condition. To describe the unique properties of thigh compartments, and finally, to review the anatomy and techniques needed to measure the compartment pressures of the thigh.

CASE REPORT

A case of a 54-year-old man is presented. He sustained trauma to his thigh 17 days prior to presenting to our ED with severe, sudden-onset pain in his right thigh. Compartment pressures were measured and confirmed the diagnosis of compartment syndrome caused by two large intramuscular hematomas. No other contributing events were identified.

CONCLUSIONS

Compartment syndrome in the thigh should be considered in patients with a concerning examination and a history of recent trauma. This particular case represents the longest reported time between injury and development of a thigh compartment syndrome.

Compartment syndrome obscured by post-operative epidural analgesia

Compartment syndrome is an orthopedic emergency that require early recognition and urgent intervention to avoid catastrophic complications. High index of suspicion is required for early diagnosis based on a constellation of signs and symptoms that include pain out of proportion and worsened by passive stretching, altered sensorium and palpable tenseness. Any event thus, that masks pain, may lead to delay the diagnosis of compartment syndrome. We report here a case of polytrauma where post-operative analgesia was administered using epidural catheter, which obscured pain and lead to delay in recognition of compartment syndrome. Authors wish to share a lesson, learned at the expense of tragedy.

Does epidural analgesia delay the diagnosis of lower limb compartment syndrome in children?

One of the cardinal symptoms of compartment syndrome is pain. A literature review was undertaken in order to assess the association of epidural analgesia and compartment syndrome in children, whether epidural analgesia delays the diagnosis, and to identify patients who might be at risk. Evidence was sought to offer recommendations in the use of epidural analgesia in patients at risk of developing compartment syndrome of the lower limb. Increasing analgesic use, increasing/breakthrough pain and pain remote to the surgical site were identified as important early warning signs of impending compartment syndrome in the lower limb of a child with a working epidural. The presence of any should trigger immediate examination of the painful site, and active management of the situation (we have proposed one clinical pathway). Avoidance of dense sensory or motor block and unnecessary sensory blockade of areas remote to the surgical site allows full assessment of the child and may prevent any delay in diagnosis of compartment syndrome. Focusing on excluding the diagnosis of compartment syndrome rather than failure of analgesic modality is vital. In the pediatric cases reviewed there was no clear evidence that the presence of an epidural had delayed the diagnosis.

Tibial compartment syndrome and the cavovarus foot

Compartment syndrome of the leg is an orthopedic emergency that requires a high index of suspicion for diagnosis and a low threshold for surgical management to prevent devastating complications. Where the clinical findings are subtle, continuous monitoring of compartment pressures, with clinical correlation, is the key to diagnosis. Surgical management should include decompression of all four compartments and early rehabilitation to prevent ischemic contracture. If contracture develops, it may cause varying degrees of equinocavovarus deformity of the foot and ankle. Appropriate evaluation and careful surgical planning that considers all components of this complex deformity are essential for obtaining good clinical results.

Compartment syndrome of the thigh in an infant: a case report

Compartment syndrome of the thigh in children is rare. We report a case of compartment syndrome of the thigh in an infant with a femur fracture resulting from suspected nonaccidental trauma. The delayed presentation of this injury may have been contributory to the development of compartment syndrome. The subtle physical findings in this case underscore the need for a high index of suspicion in making the diagnosis of compartment syndrome. The complete recovery of muscle function, even in the presence of significant tissue damage, is noteworthy and suggests that infants have a greater physiologic ability to recover in comparison with adults.

Compartment syndrome and popliteal vascular injury complicating unicompartmental knee arthroplasty

Popliteal vascular injury and the compartment syndrome of the leg are rare but important complications of knee arthroplasties. Early diagnosis and treatment are of paramount importance in preventing the devastating complications of these conditions. To our knowledge, these complications have not been reported previously after unicompartmental knee arthroplasty in the literature. Low level of suspicion may delay the diagnosis, as popliteal vascular injury and compartment syndrome are not well recognized as possible complications of unicompartmental knee arthroplasty.

The use of regional anaesthesia in patients at risk of acute compartment syndrome

A delay in the diagnosis of an acute compartment syndrome can be devastating to the patient. The increasing use of regional anaesthesia in the management of orthopaedic and trauma patients raises concerns about the potential for delay in the diagnosis of acute compartment syndrome. We undertook a postal survey to assess the usage of regional anaesthesia in patients with lower limb fractures. The study showed that regional anaesthesia is being used in patients at risk of compartment syndrome and without compartment pressure monitoring equipment being available. The anaesthetists questioned had seen cases of acute compartment syndrome being masked by regional anaesthesia. We recommend that there is an urgent need to establish joint guidelines between the orthopaedic and anaesthetic communities on the usage of regional anaesthesia in patients with lower limb fractures to reduce further morbidity from delays in the diagnosis of compartment syndrome.

Clinical spectrum of acute compartment syndrome of the thigh and its relation to associated injuries

The reason for the described clinical variability of acute compartment syndrome of the thigh, with high morbidity and mortality in some patients and an uncomplicated clinical course in others, is not known. To better define the clinical spectrum and factors determining the clinical course of this rare clinical entity, we did a retrospective multicenter study of 28 patients with 29 thigh compartment syndromes. The leading cause of acute thigh compartment syndrome was blunt trauma from motor vehicle accidents (46%) or contusion (39%). Pain with passive motion was present in all patients who were conscious, followed by paresthesia (60%), and paralysis (42%). The anterior compartment was involved most frequently with mean compartment pressure of 58 +/- 3 mm Hg. Myonecrosis, sepsis, and need for skin grafting were observed more frequently in patients with ipsilateral femur fracture. Only 7% of patients with isolated thigh compartment syndromes had short-term complications compared with 57% of patients with ipsilateral femur fractures. The incidence of complications correlated with the time to fasciotomy. Mortality was limited to patients with high injury severity scores. The clinical spectrum of thigh compartment syndrome is comparable with that of other compartment syndromes and its clinical course is determined by its associated injuries.

Differences in attitudes to analgesia in post-operative limb surgery put patients at risk of compartment syndrome

Missed compartment syndrome may result in severe disability. Complete masking of pain, the cardinal symptom of compartment syndrome, may contribute to delayed or missed diagnosis. Scenarios reported in the literature as cases of delayed or missed compartment syndrome (due to analgesia) were included in a questionnaire. Each of the respondents was requested to indicate the preferred choice of post-operative analgesia for each scenario. Significant differences were found between orthopaedic surgeons and anaesthetists regarding the preferred choice of post-operative analgesia in clinical situations which have been previously shown to be associated with a high risk of compartment syndrome. Use of analgesic methods which impair the ability to detect patients with abnormal levels of pain or unusual demands for analgesia may place such patients at risk of the devastating sequelae of a missed compartment syndrome. The differences in attitudes to local and regional nerve blockade between orthopaedic surgeons and anaesthetists suggests that some anaesthetists may be exposing patients to the risk of missed compartment syndrome following extremity surgery.

Does patient controlled analgesia delay the diagnosis of compartment syndrome following intramedullary nailing of the tibia?

We report on four cases in which the diagnosis of compartment syndrome was delayed by the administration of patient controlled analgesia (PCA) following intramedullary nailing of tibial shaft fractures. We believe that this poses a diagnostic problem and can lead to lasting sequelae as decompression is delayed. We recommend extra vigilance with the use of PCA in patients with intramedullary nailing following tibial shaft fractures.

Medial compartment syndrome of the foot: an unusual complication of spine surgery

STUDY DESIGN

Descriptive case report.

OBJECTIVES

To report the case of a child with medial compartment syndrome of the foot following posterior spinal instrumentation and fusion.

SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA

No previous study has reported medial compartment syndrome of the foot following spinal surgery.

METHODS

A 15-year-old female with progressive idiopathic scoliosis was taken for posterior instrumentation and fusion. The patient had a history of severe postexertional cramping in the feet following athletics. Surgery progressed uneventfully and the patient was continuously monitored with somatosensory-evoked potentials, which showed no changes. In the recovery room, the patient complained of severe cramping in one foot that was similar to her postexertional cramping. This was lessened with massage and ketorolac. Soreness continued in the foot into postoperative day one and then increased overnight. On the morning of postoperative day 2, pressure in the medial compartment was found to be 97 mm Hg and she was taken for fasciotomy, which found necrosis of the abductor hallucis muscle, and all other compartments of the foot were normal.

RESULTS

At the 6-month follow-up, the patient is doing well with no known sequelae.

CONCLUSION

This was a very rare case of medial compartment syndrome of the foot following spine surgery. We believe that the patient had a predisposition, whether neurologic or vascular, toward cramping in the foot and that this activity was stimulated by the nerve stimulation during the evoked potential monitoring. Although the patient had thoracic epidural analgesia after surgery, it was not felt to have contributed to the development or result of the compartment syndrome. We strongly advocate for checking patients feet and legs during surgery for overactivity and stress the need for a high index of suspicion for compartment syndrome for unexplained pain after surgery.

Three-in-one femoral nerve block as analgesia for fractured neck of femur in the emergency department: a randomized, controlled trial

STUDY OBJECTIVE

We determine whether 3-in-1 femoral nerve block is effective as analgesia for fractured neck of femur when administered by emergency physicians.

METHODS

This was a prospective, randomized controlled trial with blinded assessors conducted in a district general hospital emergency department in the United Kingdom. Over a 6-month period, all patients with fractured neck of femur were considered for study. Patients were randomly assigned to receive 3-in-1 nerve block with bupivacaine plus intravenous morphine or intravenous morphine. An accreditation package for all ED medical staff was devised to ensure competence in the technique of 3-in-1 nerve block. Pain scores were recorded on arrival and at intervals up to 24 hours after admission. Morphine consumption in the first 24 hours was recorded.

RESULTS

Ninety-four patients sustained fractured neck of femur during the study period; 50 were studied. Of 44 not studied, 42 were confused, 1 did not consent, and 1 was overlooked. Patients receiving 3-in-1 nerve blocks recorded a faster time to reach the lowest pain score: 2.88 hours for patients with nerve block and 5.81 hours for control patients (mean difference -2.93 h; 95% confidence interval [CI] -5.48 to -0.38 h). Nerve block recipients required significantly less morphine per hour than control patients (mean of 0.49 mg/h versus 1.17 mg/h; mean difference -0.68 mg/h; 95% CI -1.23 to -0.12 mg/h).

CONCLUSION

Three-in-one femoral nerve block is an effective method of providing analgesia to patients with fractured neck of femur in the ED. All grades of medical staff were able to apply and consolidate this skill.

Bilateral thigh and calf compartment syndromes following elective surgery: Case report and review of the literature

Bilateral thigh and calf compartment syndromes are rare in pediatric patients, especially following elective foot surgery. Such a case in a child with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder is described in the present report. This child was taking multiple medications, including Ritalin (methylphenidate hydrochloride), Paxil (paroxetine hydrochloride) and clonidine. Other factors that potentially contribute to the multiple compartment syndromes include pneumatic tourniquet use and caudal block augmentation of general anesthesia. Behaviour associated with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder complicated the detection of the patient's compartment syndromes. The development of the compartment syndromes was delayed more than 48 h on one side. The potential for this patient's pharmacotherapy to have contributed to the development of the compartment syndromes is discussed.