Reconstruction of the coronoid process using the tip of the ipsilateral olecranon

Surgical treatment and outcomes of trans-ulnar basal coronoid fracture-dislocations

BACKGROUND

Trans-ulnar fracture-dislocations of the elbow are complex injuries that can be difficult to classify and treat. Trans-ulnar basal coronoid injuries, in which the coronoid is not attached to either the olecranon or the metaphysis, present substantial challenges to achieve anatomic reduction and stable internal fixation. The purpose of this study was to analyze the outcome of surgical treatment of trans-ulnar basal coronoid fracture-dislocations.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between 2002 and 2019, 32 consecutive trans-ulnar basal coronoid fracture-dislocations underwent open reduction and internal fixation at our institution. Four elbows were lost to follow-up within the first 6 months after surgery and were excluded. Among the 28 elbows remaining, there were 13 females and 15 males with a mean age of 56 (range 28-78) years at the time of injury. The mean clinical and radiographic follow-up times were 37 months and 29 months, respectively. Radiographs were reviewed to determine rates of union, Hastings and Graham heterotopic ossification (HO) grade, and Broberg and Morrey arthritis grade.

RESULTS

Union occurred in 25 elbows. Union could not be determined for 1 elbow at most recent follow-up and the remaining 2 elbows developed nonunion of the coronoid. Complications occurred in 10 elbows (36%): deep infection (4), ulnar neuropathy (2), elbow contracture (2), and nonunion (2). There were reoperations in 11 elbows (39%): irrigation and débridement with hardware removal (4), hardware removal (2), ulnar nerve transposition (2), contracture release with HO removal (2), and revision with iliac crest autograft (1). At most recent follow-up, the mean flexion-extension arc was 106° (range 10°-150°), and the mean pronation-supination arc was 137° (range 0°-170°). The mean Quick Disabilities of Arm, Shoulder, and Hand score was 11 (range 0-39) points with a mean Single Assessment Numeric Evaluation-Elbow score of 81 (range 55-100) points. At final radiographic follow-up, 16 elbows (57%) had HO (8 class I and 8 class II), and 20 elbows (71%) had arthritis (8 grade 1, 6 grade 2, and 6 grade 3).

DISCUSSION

Trans-ulnar basal coronoid fracture-dislocations are severe injuries associated with high rates of reoperation, HO, and post-traumatic arthritis. However, the majority of elbows achieve union, a functional range of motion, and reasonable patient reported outcome measures. Over the study period, surgeons were more likely to utilize multiple deep approaches and separate fixation of the coronoid (either with lag screws or anteromedial plates) to ensure anatomic reduction.

The ipsilateral olecranon tip is a suitable anatomic autograft for unrepairable coronoid fractures: A comparative three-dimensional mapping analysis

Background

Perform computed tomography (CT) three-dimensional (3D) mapping analysis of the ipsilateral olecranon tip to determine its suitability as an autograft for unrepairable coronoid fractures.

Methods

CT was evaluated using Mimics 13.0 and 3-matic software (Materialise, Inc., Leuven, Belgium). Coronoid fracture fragment was measured from the medial sublime tubercle to the halfway point of the proximal radioulnar joint. Ipsilateral olecranon tip graft was measured at the equivalent height of the coronoid fragment and the angle of graft "cut" necessary to match the coronoid fragment was measured. The overall width of each graft site was measured in thirds and the congruity of surface geometry was measured by overlapping both fragments. The ipsilateral olecranon tip lateral facet which rotates to become the coronoid medial facet was also measured.

Results

The olecranon tip and coronoid fragments were similar in average maximum height and width. The average angle of graft cut needed to match the coronoid fragment was 86°. The average difference between the medial facet of the coronoid and lateral facet of the olecranon was <2 mm.

Discussion

The ipsilateral olecranon tip can be harvested through the same surgical incision and function as a local autograft during reconstruction of unrepairable coronoid fractures.

Considerable variation in current coronoid height and fracture measurement techniques: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Coronoid fractures usually occur in the presence of a significant osseoligamentous injury to the elbow. Fracture size and location correlate with degree of instability and many authors have attempted to analyze the effect of fracture variation on decision making and outcome. There remains no standardized technique for measuring coronoid height or fracture size. The aim of this study was to appraise the literature regarding techniques for coronoid height measurement in order to understand variation.

METHODS

Preferred Reporting Items of Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines were followed. A search was performed to identify studies with either a description of coronoid height, fracture size, or bone loss using the terms (Coronoid) AND (Measurement) OR (Size) OR (Height). Articles were shortlisted by screening for topic relevance based on title, abstract and, if required, full-text review. Exclusion criteria were non-English articles, those on nonhuman species or parts other than the ulna coronoid process, and studies that included patients with pre-existing elbow pathology. Shortlisted articles were grouped based on study type, imaging modality, measurement technique, and measurement parameter as well as its location along the coronoid.

RESULTS

Thirty out of the initially identified 494 articles met the inclusion criteria. Twenty-one articles were clinical studies, 8 were cadaveric studies, and 1 combined patients as well as cadavers. A variety of imaging modalities (plain radiographs, 2-dimensional computed tomography [CT], 3-dimensional CT, magnetic resonance imaging or a combination of these) were used with CT scan (either 2-dimensional images or 3-dimensional reconstructions or both) being the most common modality used by 21 studies. Measurement technique also varied from uniplanar linear measurements in 15 studies to multiplanar area and volumetric measurements in 6 studies to techniques describing various angles and indices as an indirect measure of coronoid height in 8 studies. Across the 30 shortlisted studies, 19 different measurement techniques were identified. Fifteen studies measured normal coronoid height while the other 15 measured intact coronoid and/or fracture fragment height. The location of this measurement was also variable between studies with measurements at the apex of the coronoid in 24/30 (80%) of studies. Measurement accuracy was assessed by only 1 study. A total of 12/30 (40%) studies reported on the interobserver and intraobserver reliability of their measurement technique.

CONCLUSION

The systemic review demonstrated considerable variability between studies that report coronoid height or fracture size measurements. This variability makes comparison of coronoid height or fracture measurements and recommendations based on these between studies unreliable. There is need for development of a consistent, easy to use, and reproducible technique for coronoid height and bone loss.

Finite element analysis of a customized coronoid prosthesis for traumatic coronoid deficiency

BACKGROUND

Traumatic coronoid deficiency with persistent elbow instability is a challenging condition. Autologous bone graft reconstruction is often associated with a range of additional clinical problems and the outcome is often unpredictable. The purpose of this study was to design a prosthetic device that can reconstruct coronoid deficiency of any height and to evaluate its mechanical properties using finite element analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A customized coronoid prosthesis was designed based on image registration, automatic measurement, and computer-aided design. After pilot study and sample size calculation, image data collected from 6 patients who underwent bilateral complete upper extremity CT scans were reconstructed. The test was divided into 3 groups: coronoid intact, prosthesis and autograft. Regan-Morrey type II and autologous olecranon osteotomy models were established. The prosthesis and autogenous olecranon were assembled to the coronoid base. Stress was applied axially along the proximal humeral diaphysis and implant micromotion and contact mechanics of the humeroulnar joint were measured at 30°, 45°, 60° and 90° of joint flexion respectively.

RESULTS

At all flexion angles, the maximum stress on the coronoid articular surface was significantly reduced in the prosthesis and autograft groups, with the reduction being more significant in the latter (P < .001). With increasing flexion, the maximum stress at the coronoid articular surface increased significantly after autograft reconstruction (7.2 to 68 MPa, P < .001), whereas the humeroulnar joint obtained a similar contact mechanics pattern to that of the control group after prosthetic reconstruction. As the flexion angle increased, the relative micromotion of both the prosthesis and autograft increased significantly (0.5-1.6 vs. 0.2-1.2, Pmeasure time < 0.001, Pgroups < 0.001). Contact pressure and center-of-force paths of the humeroulnar joint experience abrupt stress changes at approximately 60° of flexion.

CONCLUSION

The contact stress pattern in the humeroulnar joint is similar in prosthesis and intact coronoid groups. Autograft reconstruction increases contact stresses at the articular surface and alters the joint center-of-force path. The "stress surge phenomenon" in the humeroulnar joint surface before and after 60° of flexion may be one of the mechanisms of traumatic elbow degeneration.

Acute and chronic coronoid reconstruction using the olecranon Tip

Post-traumatic coronoid deficiency in the elbow can lead to chronic pain, instability and arthritis. A variety of osteochondral grafts have been used to reconstruct the coronoid, and restore elbow stability. The radial head and iliac crest grafts are the most common in the literature but have limitations. The olecranon tip is a promising alternative, with both cadaveric and computer models demonstrating superior congruency, without compromising elbow stability or disrupting the extensor mechanism. We present a small, case series demonstrating the technique for contralateral and ipsilateral grafts in both the acute and chronic setting.

Coronoid Fracture Reconstruction with Ipsilateral Olecranon Osteoarticular Autograft in the Acute Setting: A Case Report

CASE

An 18-year-old male polytrauma patient sustained a high-energy posterior fracture dislocation of his left elbow associated with a comminuted and irreparable O'Driscoll type 2 subtype 3 anteromedial facet coronoid fracture. He underwent early coronoid reconstruction using ipsilateral olecranon osteoarticular autograft with incorporation of the sublime tubercle attachment of the medial collateral ligament and repair of the lateral ulnar collateral ligament. A 3-year follow-up revealed a functional, painless, congruent, and stable elbow.

CONCLUSION

Early reconstruction of a highly comminuted coronoid fracture may be a useful salvage option for the polytrauma patient, thereby avoiding complications associated with late reconstruction of posttraumatic elbow instability.

Finite element analysis of coronoid prostheses with different fixation methods in the treatment of comminuted coronoid process fracture

BACKGROUND

Comminuted fractures of the coronoid process significantly compromise the stability and function of the elbow joint. Reconstruction of the coronoid process with a prosthesis has been suggested as an alternative to restore the architecture. The purpose of this study was to investigate the strength and stability of various methods for the fixation of a coronoid prosthesis by finite element analysis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A coronoid prosthesis was designed based on the morphological information from computed tomography images acquired from 64 subjects in whom the top 40% of the coronoid process height was replaced. Four methods for the fixation of the prosthesis were suggested: (1) a double 2.0-mm fixation bolt, anterior to posterior; (2) a double 2.5-mm fixation bolt, anterior to posterior; (3) a single 4.0-mm fixation bolt, posterior to anterior; (4) a single 4.5-mm fixation bolt, posterior to anterior. The integrated prosthesis-bone constructs were analyzed via the finite element analysis of 10 simulated proximal ulna models with loading applied along the axis of the humerus and with three different elbow flexion angles (30°, 90°, and 130°). The maximum principal stress and the total deformation were quantified and compared.

RESULTS

A coronoid prosthesis was developed. The maximum principal stress of the fixation bolts occurred around the neck of the fixation bolt. For a comparison of the strengths of the four fixation methods, the maximum principal stress was the lowest for fixation using a single 4.5-mm fixation bolt. The value of the maximum principal stress significantly decreased with increased elbow flexion angle for all fixation methods. The maximum deformation of the fixation bolts occurred at the head of the fixation bolt. For a comparison of the maximum deformations in the four fixation methods, the maximum deformation was the lowest for fixation using a single 4.5-mm fixation bolt. The value of the maximum deformation significantly decreased with increased elbow flexion angle for all fixation methods.

CONCLUSIONS

The present study suggested that fixation of a coronoid prosthesis with a single 4.5-mm fixation bolt from posterior to anterior is an excellent option in terms of the strength and stability. Level of Evidence Experimental study.

Greater sigmoid notch dysplasia causing elbow instability: Lateral ligament reconstruction and Stamp osteotomy

The coronoid is one of the elbow's primary static stabilisers, and the importance of reconstruction following fracture with instability has been established. In the developing elbow, instability can lead to greater sigmoid notch dysplasia that can make reconstruction challenging. A novel technique to improve osseous stability with an opening wedge 'stamp osteotomy' reconstruction of the coronoid is described combined with a lateral ligament reconstruction, in two patients with recurrent posteromedial rotatory instability. The technique improves congruity and coverage of the greater sigmoid notch with the trochlea whilst maintaining articular cartilage. Extra-articular iliac crest bone graft is used to maintain the position with buttress plate support. The surgical technique is described and the clinical and radiographic outcome reported in two patients. Level of evidence: IV.

Longitudinal study of patients' health-related quality of life using EQ-5D-3L in 11 Swedish National Quality Registers

OBJECTIVE

To compare problems reported in the five EQ-5D-3L dimensions and EQ VAS scores at baseline and at 1-year follow-up among different patient groups and specific diagnoses in 11 National Quality Registers (NQRs) and to compare these with the general population.

DESIGN

Longitudinal, descriptive study.

PARTICIPANTS

2 66 241 patients from 11 NQRs and 49 169 participants from the general population were included in the study.

PRIMARY AND SECONDARY OUTCOME MEASURES

Proportions of problems reported in the five EQ-5D-3L dimensions, EQ VAS scores of participants' own health and proportions of participants and mean/median EQ VAS score in the Paretian Classification of Health Change (PCHC) categories.

RESULTS

In most of the included registers, and the general population, problems with pain/discomfort were the most frequently reported at baseline and at 1-year follow-up. Mean EQ VAS score (SD) ranged from 45.2 (22.4) among disc hernia patients to 88.1 (15.3) in wrist and hand fracture patients at baseline. They ranged from 48.9 (20.9) in pulmonary fibrosis patients to 83.3 (17.4) in wrist and hand fracture patients at follow-up. The improved category of PCHC, improvement in at least one dimension without deterioration in any other, accounted for the highest proportion in several diagnoses, corresponding with highest improvement in mean EQ VAS score.

CONCLUSIONS

The study documented self-reported health of several different patient groups using the EQ-5D-3L in comparing with the general population. This demonstrated the important role of patient-reported outcomes in routine clinical care, to assess and follow-up health status and progress within different groups of patients. The EQ-5D-3L descriptive system and EQ VAS have an important role in providing a 'common denominator', allowing comparisons across NQRs and specific diagnoses.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT04359628).

Reconstruction of the coronoid process with the olecranon tip for chronic elbow dislocation in children: A rare case report and literature review

The coronoid process of the ulna, as a key part of the elbow joint, plays an important role in maintaining elbow joint stability. Reconstruction of the coronoid process is necessary in both acute and chronic coronoid defects to restore elbow stability and avoid early joint degeneration. The olecranon tip may be a useful autologous osteochondral graft for reconstructing the same shape of the ulna coronoid process. The purpose of this report was to verify if reconstruction of the coronoid process with the olecranon tip can restore elbow stability and kinematics. Here, we report a 13-year-old boy who had undergone Kirschner-wire fixation for a left supracondylar fracture of the left humerus 9 years previously. After that, the right elbow dislocation and varus deformity gradually appeared. Imaging revealed posterolateral dislocation of the left elbow due to the absence of the coronoid process of the ulna. We reconstructed the ulnar coronoid process by intercepting the ipsilateral olecranon tip. After 22 months of follow-up, the range of motion of the left elbow joint was normal, and the cubitus varus deformity disappeared. The results of this report suggest that olecranon tip autografts are suitable to replace transverse coronoid defects. Given the patient's satisfactory clinical results, this reconstruction technique is safe and effective for the treatment of chronic elbow instability due to coronoid process defects of the ulna.

Computed tomography analysis of the relationship between the coronoid and the radial head

BACKGROUND

The coronoid process is an important stabilizer of the elbow, and its anatomy has been extensively studied. However, data documenting the relationship of the coronoid relative to the radial head (RH) are limited. The latter is a good landmark for the surgeon when débriding or reconstructing the coronoid. This imaging-based study quantified the anatomic relationship between the coronoid and the proximal radius and ulna.

METHODS

We investigated 80 cadaveric upper extremities (18 paired elbows) by 3-dimensional digital analysis of computed tomography data. After construction of a standardized coordinate system, the relationships between the coronoid, the anterior-most point of the RH, the deepest point of the articular surface of the RH, the top of the lesser sigmoid notch, and the deepest point of the guiding ridge of the trochlear notch were analyzed.

RESULTS

The mean height of the tip of the coronoid was 36 ± 4 mm (range, 26-43 mm). The mean height of the anterior-most point of the RH was 40 ± 4 mm (range, 28-47 mm). The mean distance between the tip of the coronoid and the anterior-most point of the RH was 4.5 ± 1 mm (range, 2-10 mm). For paired elbows, the heights of the tip of the coronoid and the anterior-most point of the RH were similar between sides.

CONCLUSION

This study described the relationship between the coronoid and RH. This information should prove useful when reconstructing a coronoid from a medial approach in the case of an intact RH. The difference in radiographic height between the tip of the coronoid and anterior RH in the normal elbow averages 5 mm. However, when we account for the normal cartilage thickness of the RH and coronoid, a 3- to 6-mm difference in height would be seen at surgery depending on whether the cartilage of the coronoid process is intact or removed. The distance between the tip of the coronoid and the anterior-most point of the RH is similar to the size of shavers used when débriding osteophytes during arthroscopy.

Clinical anatomy and biomechanics of the elbow

The anatomy of the elbow joint had been studied extensively over the last 2 decades. The increased understanding of the anatomy and contribution of the anatomical structures to the elbow biomechanics had enabled surgeons to improve the results of surgical reconstruction and fracture fixation. This review articles intend to summarise the salient functional and clinical anatomical and relevant biomechanical data that had been published recently.

Reconstruction of coronoid process of the ulna: a literature review

As a pivotal part of the elbow joint structure, the coronoid process of the ulna plays a vital role in maintaining elbow joint stability. Loss of coronoid process height causes instability of the elbow joint depending on the fracture characteristics and size. The diagnosis and treatment of coronoid process fractures has gained widespread attention from orthopedic surgeons. Nevertheless, few reports have described reconstruction of coronoid process fractures and defects that affect elbow joint stability. Treatment of elbow joint instability induced by coronoid process defects is challenging because most cases are complicated by other elbow joint injuries. Moreover, the clinical efficacy remains unclear. The present narrative review was performed to examine the research progress on reconstruction of the coronoid process. The findings of this review provide evidence for clinical repair and reconstruction of coronoid process defects and contribute to the published literature on this topic.

Prediction of the Size of the Fragment in Comminuted Coronoid Fracture Using the Contralateral Side: An Analysis of Similarity of Bilateral Ulnar Coronoid Morphology

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the morphological similarity of bilateral coronoid process.

METHODS

A total of 128 sets of computed tomography images of bilateral coronoid process from patients between January 2015 and December 2016 were acquired for three-dimensional reconstruction to generate a coronoid process model. The patients were aged between 31.4 ± 9.3 years. The upper 40% of the coronoid process was trimmed as targeted fragment for morphological analysis. The height, length, width as well as the radius of the medial and lateral facet of the targeted fragment were compared in terms of laterality, age, and gender. To evaluate the similarity of the articular surface of the coronoid process, a local coordinate was created and coordinate transformation algorithm was developed to realign the bilateral coronoid process for the following matching. Then Delaunay triangulation was introduced for calculation of the area of the articular surface. After matching of articular surface of the upper 40% of bilateral coronoid process, the overlapping area of the articular surface was quantified to assess the similarity in morphology and compared in regard to age and gender.

RESULTS

In this study, the height of the target fragment was 12.40 ± 2.74 mm, which was 12.62 ± 2.06 mm for male patients and 12.13 ± 3.76 mm for female patients (t = 0.94, P = 0.35). The height of the target fragment was 12.79 ± 1.76 mm for patients >40 years and 13.23 ± 3.16 mm for patients <40 years (t = 1.11, P = 0.27). The height of the target fragment of left and right coronoid process was 12.26 ± 3.40 mm and 12.74 ± 2.79 mm (t = 1.15, P = 0.25). The length of the target fragment was 23.81 ± 2.67 mm, which was 23.86 ± 2.11 mm for male patients and 23.76 ± 2.85 mm for female patients (t = 0.23, P = 0.82). The length of the target fragment was 22.92 ± 1.96 mm for patients >40 years and 23.23 ± 2.14 mm for patients <40 years (t = 0.76, P = 0.45). The length of the target fragment of left and right coronoid process was 22.52 ± 2.89 mm and 21.66 ± 3.01 mm, respectively (t = 1.00, P = 0.32). The width of the target fragment was 23.12 ± 1.92 mm on average, which was 23.06 ± 1.54 mm for male patients and 23.19 ± 2.82 mm for female patients (t = 0.33, P = 0.74). The width of the target fragment was 24.82 ± 2.23 mm for patients >40 years and 23.46 ± 3.38 mm for patients <40 years (t = 1.56, P = 0.12). The width of target fragment of left and right coronoid process was 24.42 ± 2.22 mm and 24.47 ± 2.69 mm, respectively (t = 1.31, P = 0.19). The radius of medial facet was 6.44 ± 1.01 mm, which was 6.41 ± 1.39 mm for male patients and 6.47 ± 0.95 mm for female patients (t = 0.28, P = 0.78). The radius of medial facet was 6.82 ± 1.28 mm for patients >40 years and 6.46 ± 0.94 mm for patients <40 years (t = 1.31, P = 0.19). The radius of medial facet of left and right coronoid process was 6.43 ± 1.24 mm and 6.64 ± 1.34 mm (t = 1.60, P = 0.11). The radius of lateral facet was 11.84 ± 3.71 mm, which was 11.61 ± 4.24 mm for male patients and 12.11 ± 3.09 mm for female patients (t = 0.74, P = 0.46). The radius of medial facet was 11.82 ± 3.28 mm for patients >40 years and 12.46 ± 3.94 mm for patients <40 years (t = 1.02, P = 0.31). The radius of lateral facet of left and right coronoid process was 11.97 ± 5.31 mm and 10.29 ± 3.29 mm, respectively (t = 1.70, P = 0.09). The covering percentage of the articular surface of the upper 40% of bilateral coronoid process was 87% ± 12% with the covering percentage as 85.3% ± 14.2% for male patients and 90.0% ± 11.2% for female patients (t = 0.75, P = 0.41). The covering percentage was 88.2% ± 11.7% for patients >40 years and it was 87.4% ± 13.2% for patients <40 years (t = 0.98, P = 0.33).

CONCLUSIONS

The present study suggested that bilateral coronoid process shares high similarity in terms of 3D structure and articular surface morphology, which suggested that the osseous architecture of the coronoid process with comminuted fracture could be predicted by the morphological information of the contralateral side.

The shape match of the olecranon tip for reconstruction of the coronoid process: influence of side and osteotomy angle

BACKGROUND

The integrity of the coronoid process is critical to maintaining elbow stability. Unreconstructible fractures and chronic coronoid deficiency are challenging clinical problems with no clear solution. The purposes of this study were to investigate the shape match of the ipsilateral and contralateral olecranon tips as graft options and to determine the influence of the osteotomy angle on fitment.

METHODS

Nineteen paired cadaveric elbow joints were investigated by 3-dimensional digital analysis of computed tomography DICOM (Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine) data. After construction of an ulnar coordinate system, the ipsilateral and contralateral olecranon tips were digitally harvested at 10°, 20°, 30°, 40°, 50°, and 60° osteotomy angles. In an overlay analysis, we compared the shape match of the ipsilateral and contralateral grafts and the different angles.

RESULTS

The ipsilateral grafts showed an average mismatch of 1.8 mm (standard deviation, 1.38 mm), whereas the contralateral grafts had a significantly lower (P < .001) mean mismatch of 1.3 mm (standard deviation, 0.95 mm). The 50° osteotomy plane showed the best shape match in comparison with the native coronoid-in both the ipsilateral and contralateral grafts. Evaluation of the intraclass correlation coefficient was calculated at r = 0.944, showing high repeatability of the measurements.

CONCLUSIONS

The contralateral olecranon tip graft showed significantly better shape matching to the native coronoid than the ipsilateral olecranon graft. Specifically, the contralateral graft more closely matched the biomechanically critical anteromedial coronoid facet. Finally, both the contralateral and ipsilateral olecranon grafts had better shape matching with the native coronoid when osteotomy was performed at higher angles, specifically 50°.

Osteochondral coronoid allograft in chronic coronoid process bone loss reconstruction: an original technique with encouraging clinical and radiological outcomes at a mid-term follow-up

Objectives

Ulnar coronoid apophysis is a primary stabiliser of the elbow; a relatively small amount of bone loss, quantifiable in 40%, could be sufficient to make an elbow incongruent. If coronoid fixation is not possible, the only way of achieving a stable elbow is to reconstruct it. This case series describes the senior author’s original surgical technique in reconstructing the coronoid with a fresh-frozen osteochondral coronoid allograft, reporting a mid-term follow-up (average of 55.5 months, minimum of 26 months) of four patients (described one by one) with subjective and objective outcomes.

Methods

The senior author operated on four patients with his original surgical technique, fully explained in the text. The mean follow-up at the time is 55.5 months (up to 10 years in one case). Preoperatively and postoperatively, the patients were asked to answer three types of validated scales: Visual Analogue Scale (VAS), Quick-Disabilities of the Arm Shoulder and Hand (Quick-DASH) and Mayo Elbow Performance Index (MEPI). All patients underwent preoperative X-rays and CT scans. Afterwards, they were asked to have further X-rays and a dual- energy CT scan in the last-follow up.

Results

Three patients achieved 100 points on the MEPI scale. Three patients achieved full range of motion (ROM), while the fourth one easily achieved functional ROM. The VAS score mean improvement was 50%, and two patients were completely pain-free; the Quick-DASH average improvement score was 56.82 points.

Conclusions

This case series presents an original technique using a coronoid allograft. Three of four patients achieved full ROM, and two were pain-free at follow up. Everyone resumed previous levels at work and in sports. The good outcomes suggest that this procedure seems to be safe and does not necessarily require autologous structures. The lack of registered cases of graft reabsorption may encourage the use of an osteochondral coronoid allograft.

Level of evidence

Level IV.

Coronoid reconstruction using osteochondral grafts: a biomechanical study

HYPOTHESIS

The purposes of this study were to test the hypothesis that coronoid deficiency in the setting of posteromedial rotatory instability (PMRI) must be reconstructed to restore articular contact pressures to normal and to compare 3 different osteochondral grafts for this purpose.

METHODS

After creation of a anteromedial fracture, six cadaveric elbows were tested under gravity varus stress using a custom-made machine designed to simulate muscle loads and to passively flex the elbow. Mean articular surface contact pressure data were collected and processed using TekScan sensors and software. After testing of the intact specimen (intact condition), a PMRI injury was created (PMRI condition). Testing was repeated after reconstruction of the lateral collateral ligament (LCL) (LCL-only condition), followed by reconstruction of the coronoid with 3 different osteochondral graft techniques (reconstructed conditions).

RESULTS

Contact pressure was consistently significantly higher in the PMRI elbow compared with the intact, LCL-only, and reconstructed conditions (P < .006). The LCL-only elbow contact pressure was significantly higher than that of the intact and reconstructed conditions from 5° to 55° of flexion (P = .018). The contact pressure of the intact elbow was never significantly different from that of the reconstructed elbow, except at 5° of flexion (P ≤ .008). No significant difference was detected between each of the reconstructed techniques (P ≥ .15). However, the annular surface of the radial head was the only graft that yielded contact pressures not significantly different from normal at any flexion angle.

CONCLUSION

Isolated reconstruction of the LCL did not restore native articular surface contact pressure, and reconstruction of the coronoid using osteochondral graft was necessary. There was no difference in contact pressures among the 3 coronoid reconstruction techniques.

Role of the lateral collateral ligament in posteromedial rotatory instability of the elbow

BACKGROUND

Posteromedial rotatory instability (PMRI) of the elbow consists of an anteromedial coronoid fracture with lateral collateral ligament (LCL) and posterior bundle of the medial collateral ligament (PMCL) tears. We hypothesized that the LCL tear is required for elbow subluxation/joint incongruity and that an elbow affected by an anteromedial subtype 2 coronoid fracture and a PMCL tear exhibits contact pressures different from both an intact elbow and an elbow affected by PMRI.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Six cadaveric elbows were tested under gravity varus stress using a custom-made machine designed to simulate muscle loads and to passively flex the elbow from 0° to 90° and measure joint contact pressures. After testing of the intact specimen (INTACT-elbow), an anteromedial subtype 2 coronoid fracture with a PMCL tear (COR+PMCL-elbow) and a PMRI injury (PMRI-elbow), after adding an LCL tear, were tested. The highest values of mean contact pressure were used for the comparison among the 3 groups.

RESULTS

Neither subluxation nor joint incongruity was observed in the COR+PMCL-elbow. The addition of an LCL detachment consistently caused subluxation and joint incongruity. Mean contact pressures were higher in the COR+PMCL-elbow compared with the INTACT-elbow (P < .03) but lower than in the PMRI-elbow (P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

The LCL lesion in PMRI is necessary for elbow subluxation and causes marked elevations in contact pressures. Even without subluxation, the COR+PMCL-elbow showed higher contact pressures compared with the INTACT-elbow. Treatment of PMRI should be directed toward prevention of joint incongruity, whether by surgical or nonsurgical means, to prevent high articular contact pressures.

Complex elbow instability: surgical management of elbow fracture dislocations

There are three main patterns of complex elbow instability: posterolateral (terrible triad), varus posteromedial (anteromedial coronoid fracture with lateral collateral ligament complex disruption), and trans-olecranon fracture dislocations.Radial head fractures, in the setting of complex elbow instability, often require internal fixation or arthroplasty; the outcome of radial head replacement is dictated by adequate selection of the head diameter, correct restoration of radial length, and proper alignment and tracking.Small coronoid fractures can be ignored. Larger coronoid fractures, especially those involving the anteromedial facet, require fixation or graft reconstruction, particularly in the presence of incongruity.The lateral collateral ligament complex should be repaired whenever disrupted. Medial collateral ligament disruptions seem to heal reliably without surgical repair provided all other involved structures are addressed.The most common mistakes in the management of trans-olecranon fracture dislocations are suboptimal fixation, lack of fixation of coronoid fragments, and lack of restoration of the natural dorsal angulation of the ulna. Cite this article: Sanchez-Sotelo J, Morrey M. Complex elbow instability. EFORT Open Rev 2016;1:183-190.

Prosthetic replacement for coronoid deficiency: report of three cases

BACKGROUND

Persistent elbow instability associated with coronoid deficiency is a difficult condition to treat. Several surgical techniques have been described for coronoid reconstruction, but the resulting outcomes have been unpredictable. We hypothesized that a coronoid prosthesis could restore elbow stability.

METHODS

A nonanatomically shaped metallic coronoid prosthesis was custom designed for each of 3 patients. Each had a chronic fracture-subluxation with persistent instability, deficiencies of the coronoid, and compromise of the radial head. Each patient had undergone 2 to 4 prior failed operations.

RESULTS

At a mean follow-up of 11 years (range, 10-12), 2 of the 3 patients were completely pain free; the third had a visual analog scale pain score not greater than 3/10. All 3 maintained a stable joint, although a functional range of motion was not able to be maintained in any. Two patients rated themselves "improved" and 1 patient rated himself "almost normal" on the Summary Outcome Determination scale. All radiographic follow-up showed the coronoid prosthesis in proper position without loosening.

CONCLUSION

Prosthetic replacement of the coronoid appears successful in restoring stability in chronically unstable elbows with coronoid deficiency.

Restoring independency with an osteochondral graft of the navicular for coronoid process reconstruction

INTRODUCTION

The coronoid is a crucial element for elbow stability. In case of posttraumatic instability or reduced range of motion, a complex reconstruction might be necessary.

CASE

We present the case of a polytraumatized patient with complex upper extremity injury and initial poor outcome. Subluxation after initial surgery was treated by sublime tubercle reconstruction with a corticocancellous iliac crest graft. Due to massive ossification, the elbow remained stiff and the paraplegic patient was unable to use a manually propelled wheelchair. After arthrolysis, the unstable elbow was treated with an osteocartilaginous graft from the navicular of the foot as well as ulnar and radial collateral ligamentoplasties. At the time of follow-up, the patient had a stable joint and was able to independently perform activities of daily living.

CONCLUSION

An autologous navicular graft seems to be an excellent option for our paraplegic patient as the shape matches the sublime tubercle of the ulna.

[Chronic bony instability of the elbow joint]

The high stability of the elbow joint is provided by the congruent articular surfaces in combination with soft tissue stabilizers. The main osseous contributor of elbow stability is the coronoid, which is therefore referred to as a primary stabilizer. The radial head as a secondary stabilizer together with the medial collateral ligament assures valgus stability and together with the coronoid it assures posterolateral stability. Insufficiency of the osseous stabilizers may lead to difficulties in the treatment of chronic dislocation and complex instability. Thereby reconstruction of the osseous constraints of the elbow joint is not performed in isolation from addressing insufficient soft-tissue stabilizers. Bony stabilizers and reconstructional procedures are discussed in this review.