Discovery of interesting new polymorphisms in a sugar beet (elite [Formula: see text] exotic) progeny by comparison with an elite panel

KEY MESSAGE

The comparison of QTL detection performed on an elite panel and an (elite [Formula: see text] exotic) progeny shows that introducing exotic germplasm into breeding programs can bring new interesting allelic diversity. Selection of stable varieties producing the highest amount of extractable sugar per hectare (ha), resistant to diseases, and respecting environmental criteria is undoubtedly the main target for sugar beet breeding. As sodium, potassium, and [Formula: see text]-amino nitrogen in sugar beets are the impurities that have the biggest negative impact on white sugar extraction, it is interesting to reduce their concentration in further varieties. However, domestication history and strong selection pressures have affected the genetic diversity needed to achieve this goal. In this study, quantitative trait locus (QTL) detection was performed on two populations, an (elite [Formula: see text] exotic) sugar beet progeny and an elite panel, to find potentially new interesting regions brought by the exotic accession. The three traits linked with impurities content were studied. Some QTLs were detected in both populations, the majority in the elite panel because of most statistical power. Some of the QTLs were colocated and had favorable effect in the progeny since the exotic allele was linked with a decrease in the impurity content. A few number of favorable QTLs were detected in the progeny, only. Consequently, introgressing exotic genetic material into sugar beet breeding programs can allow the incorporation of new interesting alleles.

Identification of quantitative trait loci for milk protein percentage in Murrah buffaloes

Milk protein is an important constituent of milk in buffaloes and is moderately heritable. The milk protein percentage varies significantly between breeds/herds/species. Buffaloes can be selected for higher milk protein percentage and this paper provides QTLs for marker assisted selection in buffaloes. The milk protein percentage records on 2,028 daughters belonging to 12 half sib families were analyzed for the identification of QTLs on 8 chromosomes in buffaloes using chromosome scans. The single marker analysis revealed 74 markers to be associated with milk protein percentage in 12 sire families. When common markers were removed from the analysis, 51 markers remained. The Interval mapping using R/qtl identified 69 QTLs in 12 half sib families on 8 chromosomes of buffalo. The meta QTL analysis defined 25 consensus QTL regions in buffaloes for milk protein percentage. Most of the QTLs identified have been reported for cattle however few new chromosomal locations were also identified to be associated with milk protein percentage in buffaloes. Comparative genomics revealed 1117 genes underlying the QTL regions associated with milk protein percentage. Among these, 109 genes were directly associated with protein metabolism. The protein-protein interaction among the genes and gene ontology analysis and pathways have been identified. These 109 genes have potential to be candidate genes for milk protein percentage in buffaloes.

Identification of quantitative trait loci for fat percentage in buffaloes

The milk fat percentage records of 2174 daughters belonging to 12 half sib families were analyzed for the identification of QTLs on 8 chromosomes in buffaloes using chromosome scans. The single marker analysis revealed 49 markers to be associated with milk fat percentage in 10 sire families. The interval mapping using R/qtl identified 43 QTLs on 8 chromosomes of buffalo. The meta-QTL analysis was carried out to define consensus QTLs in buffaloes and total 28 meta-QTL regions could be identified for milk fat percentage. Most of the QTLs identified in the experiments have been reported for cattle; however, few new chromosomal locations were also identified to be associated with fat percentage in buffaloes. The additional QTLs identified in buffalo may be due to high level of heterozygosity in buffalo compared to Holstein Friesian and other exotic milk breeds for which QTLs have beenreported. Assuming buffalo-cattle synteny, a total of 1118 genes were identified underlying the QTL regions, out of these 45 genes were identified to be associated with lipid metabolism. The interaction among the genes and gene ontology analysis confirmed their association with lipid metabolism. These 45 genes have potential to be candidate genes for milk fat percentage in buffaloes and underlie the QTL regions identified in buffaloes in the present study.

Clusthaplo: a plug-in for MCQTL to enhance QTL detection using ancestral alleles in multi-cross design

We enhance power and accuracy of QTL mapping in multiple related families, by clustering the founders of the families on their local genomic similarity. MCQTL is a linkage mapping software application that allows the joint QTL mapping of multiple related families. In its current implementation, QTLs are modeled with one or two parameters for each parent that is a founder of the multi-cross design. The higher the number of parents, the higher the number of model parameters which can impact the power and the accuracy of the mapping. We propose to make use of the availability of denser and denser genotyping information on the founders to lessen the number of MCQTL parameters and thus boost the QTL discovery. We developed clusthaplo, an R package ( http://cran.r-project.org/web/packages/clusthaplo/index.html ), which aims to cluster haplotypes using a genomic similarity that reflects the probability of sharing the same ancestral allele. Computed in a sliding window along the genome and followed by a clustering method, the genomic similarity allows the local clustering of the parent haplotypes. Our assumption is that the haplotypes belonging to the same class transmit the same ancestral allele. So their putative QTL allelic effects can be modeled with the same parameter, leading to a parsimonious model, that is plugged in MCQTL. Intensive simulations using three maize data sets showed the significant gain in power and in accuracy of the QTL mapping with the ancestral allele model compared to the classical MCQTL model. MCQTL_LD (clusthaplo outputs plug in MCQTL) is a versatile and powerful tool for QTL mapping in multiple related families that makes use of linkage and linkage disequilibrium (web site http://carlit.toulouse.inra.fr/MCQTL/ ).

QTL analysis of behavior in nine-spined sticklebacks (Pungitius pungitius)

The genetic architecture of behavioral traits is yet relatively poorly understood in most non-model organisms. Using an F2-intercross (n = 283 offspring) between behaviorally divergent nine-spined stickleback (Pungitius pungitius) populations, we tested for and explored the genetic basis of different behavioral traits with the aid of quantitative trait locus (QTL) analyses based on 226 microsatellite markers. The behaviors were analyzed both separately (viz. feeding activity, risk-taking and exploration) and combined in order to map composite behavioral type. Two significant QTL-explaining on average 6 % of the phenotypic variance-were detected for composite behavioral type on the experiment-wide level, located on linkage groups 3 and 8. In addition, several suggestive QTL located on six other linkage groups were detected on the chromosome-wide level. Apart from providing evidence for the genetic basis of behavioral variation, the results provide a good starting point for finer-scale analyses of genetic factors influencing behavioral variation in the nine-spined stickleback.

Composite interval mapping and multiple interval mapping: procedures and guidelines for using Windows QTL Cartographer

Tremendous progress has been made in recent years on developing statistical methods for mapping quantitative trait loci (QTL) from crosses of inbred lines. In this chapter, we provide an introduction of composite interval mapping and multiple interval mapping methods for mapping QTL from inbred line crosses and also detailed instructions to perform the analyses in Windows QTL Cartographer. For each method, we discuss the meaning of each option in the analysis procedures and how to understand and interpret the mapping results through a work-out example.

Power of different F2 schemes for QTL detection in livestock

The power for detection of quantitative trait loci (QTL) using marker information was compared in several schemes differing in the mating type and the number of parents involved. An experiment based on an F2 population of fixed size obtained by crossing two lines differing phenotypically for a single trait was simulated, assuming that QTLs could be fixed or segregating in the lines crossed. Different additive and dominant QTL effect values and allele frequencies were considered covering a range of different favourable situations for the detection of the QTL. Comparison was done by regression using flanking marker information. Mating animals at the F1 generation level minimizing relationships was not worse than mating at random or maximizing relationships. The number of parents used affected the power of the experiment when the QTL was segregating in the original crossed lines. Differences in power were mainly related to the number of males from the original line. When the power of the experiment was high as a result of genetic hypothesis assumed, considering several males increased the power. However, when the genetic hypothesis assumed led there to be less power to detect a QTL, the power was higher when fewer males were used.

Six quantitative trait loci influence task thresholds for hygienic behaviour in honeybees (Apis mellifera)

Honeybee hygienic behaviour provides colonies with protection from many pathogens and is an important model system of the genetics of a complex behaviour. It is a textbook example of complex behaviour under simple genetic control: hygienic behaviour consists of two components--uncapping a diseased brood cell, followed by removal of the contents--each of which are thought to be modulated independently by a few loci of medium to large effect. A worker's genetic propensity to engage in hygienic tasks affects the intensity of the stimulus required before she initiates the behaviour. Genetic diversity within colonies leads to task specialization among workers, with a minority of workers performing the majority of nest-cleaning tasks. We identify three quantitative trait loci that influence the likelihood that workers will engage in hygienic behaviour and account for up to 30% of the phenotypic variability in hygienic behaviour in our population. Furthermore, we identify two loci that influence the likelihood that a worker will perform uncapping behaviour only, and one locus that influences removal behaviour. We report the first candidate genes associated with engaging in hygienic behaviour, including four genes involved in olfaction, learning and social behaviour, and one gene involved in circadian locomotion. These candidates will allow molecular characterization of this distinctive behavioural mode of disease resistance, as well as providing the opportunity for marker-assisted selection for this commercially significant trait.

QTL mapping in intercross and backcross populations

In the past two decades, various statistical approaches have been developed to identify quantitative trait locus with experimental organisms. In this chapter, we introduce several commonly used QTL mapping methods for intercross and backcross populations. Important issues related to QTL mapping, such as threshold and confidence interval calculations are also discussed. We list and describe five public domain QTL software packages commonly used by biologists.

Mixture cure model with an application to interval mapping of quantitative trait loci

When censored time-to-event data are used to map quantitative trait loci (QTL), the existence of nonsusceptible subjects entails extra challenges. If the heterogeneous susceptibility is ignored or inappropriately handled, we may either fail to detect the responsible genetic factors or find spuriously significant locations. In this article, an interval mapping method based on parametric mixture cure models is proposed, which takes into consideration of nonsusceptible subjects. The proposed model can be used to detect the QTL that are responsible for differential susceptibility and/or time-to-event trait distribution. In particular, we propose a likelihood-based testing procedure with genome-wide significance levels calculated using a resampling method. The performance of the proposed method and the importance of considering the heterogeneous susceptibility are demonstrated by simulation studies and an application to survival data from an experiment on mice infected with Listeria monocytogenes.

Power of mixed-model QTL mapping from phenotypic, pedigree and marker data in self-pollinated crops

The power of QTL mapping by a mixed-model approach has been studied for hybrid crops but remains unknown in self-pollinated crops. Our objective was to evaluate the usefulness of mixed-model QTL mapping in the context of a breeding program for a self-pollinated crop. Specifically, we simulated a soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) breeding program and applied a mixed-model approach that comprised three steps: variance component estimation, single-marker analyses, and multiple-marker analysis. Average power to detect QTL ranged from <1 to 47% depending on the significance level (0.01 or 0.0001), number of QTL (20 or 80), heritability of the trait (0.40 or 0.70), population size (600 or 1,200 inbreds), and number of markers (300 or 600). The corresponding false discovery rate ranged from 2 to 43%. Larger populations, higher heritability, and fewer QTL controlling the trait led to a substantial increase in power and to a reduction in the false discovery rate and bias. A stringent significance level reduced both the power and false discovery rate. There was greater power to detect major QTL than minor QTL. Power was higher and the false discovery rate was lower in hybrid crops than in self-pollinated crops. We conclude that mixed-model QTL mapping is useful for gene discovery in plant breeding programs of self-pollinated crops.

Regression-based quantitative trait loci mapping: robust, efficient and effective

Regression has always been an important tool for quantitative geneticists. The use of maximum likelihood (ML) has been advocated for the detection of quantitative trait loci (QTL) through linkage with molecular markers, and this approach can be very effective. However, linear regression models have also been proposed which perform similarly to ML, while retaining the many beneficial features of regression and, hence, can be more tractable and versatile than ML in some circumstances. Here, the use of linear regression to detect QTL in structured outbred populations is reviewed and its perceived shortfalls are revisited. It is argued that the approach is valuable now and will remain so in the future.

An efficient resampling method for assessing genome-wide statistical significance in mapping quantitative trait Loci

Assessing genome-wide statistical significance is an important and difficult problem in multipoint linkage analysis. Due to multiple tests on the same genome, the usual pointwise significance level based on the chi-square approximation is inappropriate. Permutation is widely used to determine genome-wide significance. Theoretical approximations are available for simple experimental crosses. In this article, we propose a resampling procedure to assess the significance of genome-wide QTL mapping for experimental crosses. The proposed method is computationally much less intensive than the permutation procedure (in the order of 10(2) or higher) and is applicable to complex breeding designs and sophisticated genetic models that cannot be handled by the permutation and theoretical methods. The usefulness of the proposed method is demonstrated through simulation studies and an application to a Drosophila backcross.

QTL associations for density and diameter in Pinus radiata and the potential for marker-aided selection

A large full-sib family of radiata pine ( Pinus radiata Donn. ex D. Don) was used for quantitative trait locus (QTL) detection and independent verification. QTL detection experiments were carried out for juvenile wood density (JWD) and stem diameter at breast height (DBH) using selective genotyping. Evenly spaced RFLP and microsatellite markers were selected from an existing linkage map. QTLs were verified in an independent set of progeny from the same family. Based on map location, at least eight QTL positions for JWD and two for DBH were detected and verified. The percent variance accounted for by the markers ranged from 0.78% to 3.58%, suggesting a genomic architecture of many genes with small effect. Two unrelated "bridging" families were chosen as candidates for marker-aided selection (MAS), and six microsatellite markers showing an association with JWD or DBH were tested in these families. Of these, four markers showed a consistent association with JWD in one or both of the bridging families. Results from this study provide a basis for MAS in P. radiata.

Statistical issues in the analysis of quantitative traits in combined crosses

We consider some practical statistical issues in QTL analysis where several crosses originate in multiple inbred parents. Our results show that ignoring background polygenic variation in different crosses may lead to biased interval mapping estimates of QTL effects or loss of efficiency. Threshold and power approximations are derived by extending earlier results based on the Ornstein-Uhlenbeck diffusion process. The results are useful in the design and analysis of genome screen experiments. Several common designs are evaluated in terms of their power to detect QTL.

Marker pair selection for mapping quantitative trait loci

Mapping of quantitative trait loci (QTL) for backcross and F(2) populations may be set up as a multiple linear regression problem, where marker types are the regressor variables. It has been shown previously that flanking markers absorb all information on isolated QTL. Therefore, selection of pairs of markers flanking QTL is useful as a direct approach to QTL detection. Alternatively, selected pairs of flanking markers can be used as cofactors in composite interval mapping (CIM). Overfitting is a serious problem, especially if the number of regressor variables is large. We suggest a procedure denoted as marker pair selection (MPS) that uses model selection criteria for multiple linear regression. Markers enter the model in pairs, which reduces the number of models to be considered, thus alleviating the problem of overfitting and increasing the chances of detecting QTL. MPS entails an exhaustive search per chromosome to maximize the chance of finding the best-fitting models. A simulation study is conducted to study the merits of different model selection criteria for MPS. On the basis of our results, we recommend the Schwarz Bayesian criterion (SBC) for use in practice.

A quick method for computing approximate thresholds for quantitative trait loci detection

This article proposes a quick method for computing approximate threshold levels that control the genome-wise type I error rate of tests for quantitative trait locus (QTL) detection in interval mapping (IM) and composite interval mapping (CIM). The procedure is completely general, allowing any population structure to be handled, e.g., BC(1), advanced backcross, F(2), and advanced intercross lines. Its main advantage is applicability in complex situations where no closed form approximate thresholds are available. Extensive simulations demonstrate that the method works well over a range of situations. Moreover, the method is computationally inexpensive and may thus be used as an alternative to permutation procedures. For given values of the likelihood-ratio (LR)-profile, computations involve just a few seconds on a Pentium PC. Computations are simple to perform, requiring only the values of the LR statistics (or LOD scores) of a QTL scan across the genome as input. For CIM, the window size and the position of cofactors are also needed. For the approximation to work well, it is suggested that scans be performed with a relatively small step size between 1 and 2 cM.

Optimal marker density for interval mapping in a backcross population

An important question in QTL mapping is the optimal choice of marker density. Using analytical results, it is shown for the case of interval mapping in a backcross population, that the power of QTL detection and the standard errors of genetic effect estimates are little affected by an increase of marker density beyond 10 cM. This finding confirms published simulation results by other authors.

Statistical methods for mapping quantitative trait loci from a dense set of markers

Lander and Botstein introduced statistical methods for searching an entire genome for quantitative trait loci (QTL) in experimental organisms, with emphasis on a backcross design and QTL having only additive effects. We extend their results to intercross and other designs, and we compare the power of the resulting test as a function of the magnitude of the additive and dominance effects, the sample size and intermarker distances. We also compare three methods for constructing confidence regions for a QTL: likelihood regions, Bayesian credible sets, and support regions. We show that with an appropriate evaluation of the coverage probability a support region is approximately a confidence region, and we provide a theroretical explanation of the empirical observation that the size of the support region is proportional to the sample size, not the square root of the sample size, as one might expect from standard statistical theory.

A nonparametric bootstrap method for testing close linkage vs. pleiotropy of coincident quantitative trait loci

A novel method using the nonparametric bootstrap is proposed for testing whether a quantitative trait locus (QTL) at one chromosomal position could explain effects on two separate traits. If the single-QTL hypothesis is accepted, pleiotropy could explain the effect on two traits. If it is rejected, then the effects on two traits are due to linked QTLs. The method can be used in conjunction with several QTL mapping methods as long as they provide a straightforward estimate of the number of QTLs detectable from the data set. A selection step was introduced in the bootstrap procedure to reduce the conservativeness of the test of close linkage vs. pleiotropy, so that the erroneous rejection of the null hypothesis of pleiotropy only happens at a frequency equal to the nominal type I error risk specified by the user. The approach was assessed using computer simulations and proved to be relatively unbiased and robust over the range of genetic situations tested. An example of its application on a real data set from a saline stress experiment performed on a recombinant population of wheat (Triticum aestivum L. ) doubled haploid lines is also provided.

Genetic mapping of quantitative trait loci affecting susceptibility to Marek's disease virus induced tumors in F2 intercross chickens

Marek's disease (MD) is a lymphoproliferative disease caused by the MD virus (MDV), which costs the poultry industry nearly $1 billion annually. To identify quantitative trait loci (QTL) affecting MD susceptibility, the inbred lines 6(3) (MD resistant) and 7(2) (MD susceptible) were mated to create more than 300 F2 chickens. The F2 chickens were challenged with MDV JM strain, moderately virulent) at 1 wk of age and assessed for MD susceptibility. The QTL analysis was divided into three stages. In stage 1, 65 DNA markers selected from the chicken genetic maps were typed on the 40 most MD-susceptible and the 40 most MD-resistant F2 chickens, and 21 markers residing near suggestive QTL were revealed by analysis of variance (ANOVA). In stage 2, the suggestive markers plus available flanking markers were typed on 272 F2 chickens, and three suggestive QTL were identified by ANOVA. In stage 3, using the interval mapping program Map Manager and permutation tests, two significant and two suggestive MD QTL were identified on four chromosomal subregions. Three to five loci collected explained between 11 and 23% of the phenotypic MD variation, or 32-68% of the genetic variance. This study constitutes the first report in the domestic chicken on the mapping of non-major histocompatibility complex QTL affecting MD susceptibility.

Finding genetic markers for complex phenotypic traits in parasites

The identification, mapping and eventual cloning of genes which determine or influence important epidemiological traits in parasites can have great benefits for the control of parasitic disease. In this review, strategies are outlined for identifying genetic markers for complex, quantitative traits. A genetic marker is a variable DNA sequence which co-occurs with a variable quantitative trait. Candidate markers are chosen because they are thought to directly influence the trait whereas random markers are expected to be linked to another DNA sequence which influences the trait. Association studies compare the value of a quantitative trait between different marker genotype classes in a population, without regard to family structure. Linkage studies compare the value of a quantitative trait between marker genotype classes within families or within a population (usually derived from a cross between inbred lines) which is segregating for both marker and quantitative trait loci. The most commonly used analytical methods for determining the significance of association or linkage between marker and quantitative trait loci, and for estimating parameters such as recombination rate and quantitative gene action, are least-squares and maximum likelihood. Both methods may be used to test either single markers or the interval between flanking markers, and both suffer from the need to minimize type I and type II error rates with multiple tests.

Molecular dissection of quantitative traits: progress and prospects

QTL mapping is an increasingly useful approach to the study and manipulation of complex traits important in agriculture, evolution, and medicine. The molecular dissection of quantitative phenotypes, supplementing the principles of classical quantitative genetics, is accelerating progress in the manipulation of plant and animal genomes. A growing appreciation of the similarities among different organisms and the usefulness of comparative genetic information is making genome analysis more efficient, and providing new opportunities for using model systems to overcome the limitations of less-favorable systems. The expanding repertoire of techniques and information available for studying heredity is removing obstacles to the cloning of QTLs. Although QTL mapping alone is limited to a resolution of 0.1%-1.0% of a genome, use of QTL mapping in conjunction with a search for mapped candidate genes, with emerging technologies for isolation of genes expressed under conditions likely to account for the quantitative phenotype, and with ever more efficient megabase DNA manipulation and characterization bodes well for the prospect of isolating the genetic determinants of QTLs in the foreseeable future. In the words of Thoday (1961), "An extensive attack on quantitative genetics made from this point of view as well as the biometric approach should be a great help in answering questions concerning the nature of polygenes...."