An examination of the dose rate effect in mice assuming that the carcinogenic effect of radiation is life shortening resulting from a tissue reaction

PURPOSE

Radiation exposures do not seem to increase the proportion of mice dying from tumors, but rather cause a shift in the appearance of spontaneous cancers, allowing them to appear earlier, and hence produce a life shortening effect. Then, it was possible to estimate the effect of the dose rate on the carcinogenic effects of radiation using life shortening effects as a measure.

CONCLUSION

The dose response for the induction of life shortening was linear under acute exposure conditions, which indicates that the response under chronic exposure conditions is also likely to be linear, and hence the dose rate factor (DRF) would be constant throughout the dose. Furthermore, the life shortening effect decreased sharply with an increase in age at exposure. To separate the dose rate effect from the effects of age under long-term exposure conditions, a thought experiment was designed which consisted of 8 repeated exposures to an acute 1 Gy dose at intervals of 50 days with an assumption that the effect is additive, and the results were compared with those observed in a chronic continuous exposure experiment (20 mGy per day for 400 days, for a total of 8 Gy: Tanaka et al. 2003). The results showed 211 days of life shortening in the former and 120 days in the latter, which provided a DRF of 1.8 (211/120). If one assumes that a tissue reaction is the primary cause of radiation carcinogenesis, the contrasting two concepts, radiation hormesis and linear-non-threshold model at low doses, would become compatible.

Influence of Age on Leukemia Mortality Associated with Exposure to γ rays and 2-MeV Fast Neutrons in Male C3H Mice

The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of densely ionizing radiation can depend on the biological context. From a radiological perspective, age is an important factor affecting health risks of radiation exposure, but little is known about the modifying impact of age on the effects of densely ionizing radiation. Herein, we addressed the influence of age on leukemogenesis induced by accelerator-generated fast neutrons (mean energy, ∼2 MeV). Male C3H/HeNrs mice were exposed to 137Cs γ rays (0.2-3.0 Gy) or neutrons (0.0485-0.97 Gy, γ ray contamination 0.0105-0.21 Gy) at 1, 3, 8, or 35 weeks of age and observed over their lifetimes under specific pathogen-free conditions. Leukemia and lymphoma were diagnosed pathologically. Hazard ratio (HR) and RBE for myeloid leukemia mortality as well as the age dependence of these two parameters were modeled and analyzed using Cox regression. Neutron exposure increased HR concordant with a linear dose response. The increase of HR per dose depended on age at exposure, with no significant dose dependence at age 1 or 3 weeks but a significant increase in HR of 5.5 per Gy (γ rays) and 16 per Gy (neutrons) at 8 weeks and 5.8 per Gy (γ rays) and 9 per Gy (neutrons) at 35 weeks. The RBE of neutrons was 2.1 (95% confidence interval, 1.1-3.7), with no dependence on age. The development of lymphoid neoplasms was not related to radiation exposure. The observed increasing trend of radiation-associated mortality of myeloid leukemia with age at exposure supports previous epidemiological and experimental findings. The results also suggest that exposure at the susceptible age of 8 or 35 weeks does not significantly influence the RBE value for neutrons for induction of leukemia, unlike what has been documented for breast and brain tumors.

Findings from international archived data: Fractionation reduces mortality risk of ionizing radiation for total doses below 4 Gray in rodents

Ionizing radiation is omnipresent and unavoidable on Earth; nevertheless, the range of doses and modes of radiation delivery that represent health risks remain controversial. Radiation protection policy for civilians in US is set at 1 mSv per year. Average persons from contemporary populations are exposed to several hundred milliSieverts (mSv) over their lifetimes from both natural and human made sources such as radon, cosmic rays, CT-scans (20-50 mSv partial body exposure per scan), etc. Health risks associated with these and larger exposures are focus of many epidemiological studies, but uncertainties of these estimates coupled with individual and environmental variation make it is prudent to attempt to use animal models and tightly controlled experimental conditions to supplement our evaluation of radiation risk question. Data on 11,528 of rodents of both genders exposed to x-ray or gamma-ray radiation in facilities in US and Europe were used for this analysis; animal mortality data argue that fractionated radiation exposures have about 2 fold less risk per Gray than acute radiation exposures in the range of doses between 0.25 and 4 Gy.

Risk of second cancer after ion beam radiotherapy: insights from animal carcinogenesis studies

Purpose: To review recent studies to better understand the risk of second cancer after ion beam radiotherapy and to clarify the importance of animal radiobiology therein. Results: Risk of developing second cancer after radiotherapy is a concern, particularly for survivors of childhood tumors. Ion beam radiotherapy is expected to reduce the risk of second cancer by reducing exposure of normal tissues to radiation. Large uncertainty lies, however, in the choice of relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of high linear energy transfer (LET) radiation (e.g. carbon ions and neutrons) in cancer induction, especially for children. Studies have attempted to predict the risk of second cancer after ion beam radiotherapy based on an assessment of radiation dose, the risk of low LET radiation, and assumptions about RBE. Animal experiments have yielded RBE values for selected tissues, radiation types, and age at the time of irradiation; the results indicate potentially variable RBE which depends on tissues, ages, and dose levels. Animal studies have also attempted to identify genetic alterations in tumors induced by high LET radiation. Conclusions: Estimating the RBE value for cancer induction is important for understanding the risk of second cancer after ion beam radiotherapy. More comprehensive animal radiobiology studies are needed.

Low Dose Effects: Benefit or Harm?

This forum article discusses issues related to the effects of low dose radiation, an area that is under intense study but difficult to assess. Experiments with large-scale animal studies are included in this paper; these studies point to the need for international consortia to examine and balance the results of these large-scale studies and databases.

The role of age, sex and steroid sex hormones in radiation cataractogenesis

It is critical to identify and gain a better understanding of the factors that enhance or reduce the risk of cataractogenesis, to minimize the possibility of occurrence after deliberate (e.g., radiation therapy, interplanetary travel) or unintentional exposure to ionizing radiation. Both gender and age at the time of exposure have been established as key determinants of cataractogenesis induced by sparsely ionizing (low-LET) and densely ionizing (high-LET) radiation. However, animal data from several older studies are often conflicting and somewhat difficult to interpret, in that the experiments suffered from small group sizes, limited dose ranges or short periods of observation, and human data are sparse or statistical significance is sometimes limited. Steroid sex hormones (SSH) may underlie age and gender-based differences in the progression and prevalence of cataracts that otherwise occur spontaneously in humans and animal models, and may also underlie age and sex-related differences in radiation cataractogenesis. Here, we review data that have aided in our understanding of the role of age, sex and steroid sex hormones in radiation cataractogenesis.

Protection against prenatal irradiation‐induced genomic instability and its consequences in adult mice byOcimumflavonoids, orientin and vicenin

PURPOSE

To study the protective effect of orientin and vicenin against early genomic effects of foetal irradiation and their late consequences in mice.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fourteen-day pregnant mice were exposed to 1 Gy 60Co gamma-radiation 30 min after an intraperitoneal injection of orientin or vicenin (50 microg kg(-1) body weight). Chromosomal aberrations were studied in foetal liver cells and their spleen colonies (three passages, colony-forming units-spleen CFU-S1, CFU-S2, CFU-S3) and 1-12 months post-partum bone marrow. Peripheral blood counts and solid tumours were recorded to 12 and 20 months, respectively.

RESULTS

Irradiation significantly increased the percent aberrant cells and aberrations/cell in foetal liver and CFU-S1. These effects decreased in later passages of CFU-S and were not seen at 1-6 months post-partum, but increased significantly from 9 months. Total blood counts showed significant reduction from 6 months, while neutrophils increased from 3 months post-partum. Solid tumour incidence in adults increased significantly, with a decrease in age at detection. Orientin/vicenin significantly reduced the chromosomal anomalies in foetal and adult haemopoietic cells, restored blood counts to the normal range, and significantly reduced tumour incidence and delayed tumour development to control age.

CONCLUSIONS

Orientin and vicenin protect against foetal irradiation-induced genomic damage and instability, thereby reducing the delayed chromosomal abnormalities and tumorigenesis in adult.

Temporal variation of excess mortality rate from solid tumors in mice irradiated at various ages with gamma rays

The influence of age at the time of irradiation on the lifetime risk for excess mortality from solid tumors, and on the temporal pattern of variation in the excess mortality rate, was analyzed using data obtained from a study of female B6C3F1 mice, which was conducted at the National Institute of Radiological Sciences, Chiba, Japan. Mice were irradiated with 1.9-Gy gamma rays at day 17 in intra-uterine age, or day 0, 7, 35, 105 or 365 in postnatal age. Control and irradiated mice were allowed to live out their entire life span under a specific pathogen-free condition. The primary cause of death for each mouse was determined by macroscopic and microscopic examination. The lifetime excess mortality from solid tumors was apparently higher in the mice irradiated during the neonatal to puberty period than in the mice irradiated during the intra-uterine or adult period. The median of time for manifestation of lifetime excess mortality since irradiation was shortest among mice exposed at 365 days of age and longest among mice exposed at 17 days of intra-uterine age. The excess mortality rate at any attained age was not independent of the age at irradiation. The excess mortality rate increased with increasing age, and the excess relative risk decreased with increasing age. The temporal variations of the excess mortality rate and background mortality rate were analyzed using the additive multi-stage model, which includes the assumptions that radiation-related carcinogenesis superimposes on background carcinogenesis, and that both radiation-related and background carcinogenesis involve multiple stages. The results of the analysis strongly suggested that the number of stages for manifestation of radiation-related carcinogenesis was less than that in background carcinogenesis for various types of solid tumors, and that the majority of stages were common in both radiation-related and background carcinogenesis. The additive multi-stage model well described the observed findings on the length of the latent period and temporal variations of the excess mortality rate and excess relative risk. It should be stressed that the magnitude of the lifetime risk was not only determined by a decrease in the number of hits for carcinogenesis but was also determined by another parameter which decides the initial value of excess mortality rate. Furthermore, we estimated the rate of decrease in the number of remaining hits for carcinogenesis, and it was found that the rate of decrease in the number of remaining hits was higher in several irradiated groups than that in the background carcinogenesis. However, radiation-induced genomic instability and/or delayed mutation may be of secondary importance when radiation was delivered promptly, because the present analysis revealed that the major action of radiation took place soon after irradiation, as one or more hits for transitions of stages for carcinogenesis.

Carcinogenesis in laboratory mice after low doses of ionizing radiation

Experimental data on the incidence of solid tumors from various long-term mouse studies performed at the Casaccia laboratories over several years were reconsidered, limiting the analysis to the results available for doses equal to or less than 17 cGy of neutrons and 32 cGy of X rays since these dose limits are reasonably close to the generally accepted low-dose levels for high- and low-LET radiation (i.e. D(high-LET) < 5 cGy and D(low-LET) < 20 cGy, respectively). The following long-term experiments with BC3F1 mice were reviewed: (a) females treated with single doses of 1.5 MeV neutrons or 250 kVp X rays, (b) males treated with fractionated doses of fission neutrons, and (c) mice of both sexes irradiated in utero 17.5 days post coitus with single doses of fission neutrons or X rays. An experiment with CBA mice of both sexes treated with single doses of fission neutrons was also included in this study. Analysis was done on animals at risk; thus all incidences of tumor-bearing animals were expressed as the percentage excess incidence with respect to the controls. Ovarian tumors and other solid neoplasms were considered. The percentage frequencies and mean survival times of tumor-free mice were also recalculated. The results indicate the existence of a region at low doses where the final incidence of solid neoplasms is indistinguishable from the background incidence. These data reinforce the idea that at low doses the effectiveness of ionizing radiation in inducing solid neoplasms in laboratory mice is very low.

How radiosensitive are the developing embryo and fetus?

In its 1990 recommendations, the ICRP considered the radiation risks after exposure during prenatal development. This report is a critical review of new experimental animal data on biological effects and evaluations of human studies after prenatal radiation published since the 1990 recommendations.

Thus, the report discusses the effects after radiation exposure during pre-implantation, organogenesis, and fetogenesis. The aetiology of long-term effects on brain development is discussed, as well as evidence from studies in man on the effects of in-utero radiation exposure on neurological and mental processes. Animal studies of carcinogenic risk from in-utero radiation and the epidemiology of childhood cancer are discussed, and the carcinogenic risk to man from in-utero radiation is assessed. Open questions and needs for future research are elaborated.

The report reiterates that the mammalian embryo and fetus are highly radiosensitive. The nature and sensitivity of induced biological effects depend upon dose and developmental stage at irradiation. The various effects, as studied in experimental systems and in man, are discussed in detail. It is concluded that the findings in the report strengthen and supplement the 1990 recommendations of the ICRP.

On the shape of neutron dose-effect curves for radiogenic cancers and life shortening in mice

Male and female hybrid BCF1 (C57BL/6 Bd x BALB/c Bd) were exposed to total neutron doses of 0.06, 0.12, 0.24, and 0.48 Gy in fractions over a period of 24 weeks. The fractionation regimens were: 24 weekly fractions of 0.0025 Gy, 12 fractions of 0.01 Gy every 2 weeks, 6 fractions of 0.04 Gy every 4 weeks, and 3 fractions of 0.16 Gy every 8 weeks. In order to detect any change in susceptibility with age over the period of exposures from 16 weeks to 40 weeks of age, mice were exposed to single doses of 0.025, 0.05, 0.10, and 0.2 Gy at 16 and 40 weeks of age. These experiments were designed to test whether the initial parts of the dose-response relationships for life shortening and cancer induction could be determined economically by using fractionated exposures and whether or not the initial slopes were linear. The conclusions were that for life shortening and most radiogenic cancers, the dose-effect curves are linear and that fractionation of the neutron dose has no effect on the magnitude of the response of equal total doses over the range of doses studied. The ratio of such initial slopes and comparable linear initial slopes for a reference radiation should provide maximum and constant relative biological effectiveness values.

Radiation-induced diploid spermatids in mice

Diploid elongated spermatids of mice were enriched by flow cytometry and cell sorting using a new type of sorter (Partec). The sorted abnormal spermatids were identified morphologically and by nuclear area integration. The radiation-induced increase in the frequency of diploid elongated spermatids was monitored with time following acute X-ray exposure of mice. Dose-response curves for acute 60Co-gamma and 14 MeV neutron irradiations yielded an RBE value of 4.3 for the doubling of the control level.

Flow cytometric analysis of the effects of 0.4 MeV fission neutrons on mouse spermatogenesis

(C57Bl/Cne X C3H/Cne)F1 male mice were irradiated with single acute doses of 0.4 MeV neutrons ranging from 0.05 to 2 Gy, and testis cell suspensions were prepared for cytometric analysis of the DNA content 2-70 days after irradiation. Various cell subpopulations could be identified in the control histogram including mature and immature spermatids, diploid spermatogonia and spermatocytes, tetraploid cells and cells in the S-phase. Variations in the relative proportions of different cell types were detected at each dose and time, reflecting lethal damage induced on specific spermatogenetic stages. The reduction of the number of elongated spermatids 28 days after irradiation was shown to be a particularly sensitive parameter for the cytometrical assessment of the radiosensitivity of differentiating gonia. A D0 value of 0.13 Gy was calculated and compared with data obtained after X-irradiation, using the same experimental protocol. In the latter case a biphasic curve was obtained over the dose range from 0.25 to 10 Gy, possibly reflecting the existence of some cell population heterogeneity. RBE values were estimated at different neutron doses relative to the radiosensitive component of the X-ray curve, and ranged from 3.3 to 4, in agreement with data in the literature. Genotoxic effects were monitored 7 days after irradiation by a dose-dependent increase of the coefficient of variation (CV) values of the round spermatid peak, reflecting the induction of numerical and structural chromosome aberrations, and 14 or 21 days after irradiation by the detection of diploid elongated spermatids, probably arising from a radiation-induced complete failure of the first or second meiotic division.

Radiation carcinogenesis in experimental animals and its implications for radiation protection

Cancer induction is generally considered to be the most important somatic effect of low doses of ionizing radiation. It is therefore of great concern to assess the quantitative cancer risk of exposure to radiations of different quality and to obtain information on the dose-response relationships for carcinogenesis. Tissues in the human with a high sensitivity for cancer induction include the bone marrow, the lung, the thyroid and the breast in women. If the revised dosimetry estimates for the Japanese survivors of the atomic bomb explosions are correct, there is no useful data base left to derive r.b.e. values for human carcinogenesis. As a consequence, it will be necessary to rely on results obtained in biological systems, including experimental animals, for these estimates. With respect to radiation protection, the following aspects of experimental studies on radiation carcinogenesis are of relevance: Assessment of the nature of dose-response relationships. Determination of the relative biological effectiveness of radiations of different quality. Effects of fractionation or protraction of the dose on tumour development. For the analysis of tumour data in animals, specific approaches have to be applied which correct for competing risks. These methods include actuarial estimates, non-parametric models and analytical models. The dose-response curves for radiation-induced cancers in different tissues vary in shape. This is exemplified by studies on myeloid leukaemia in mice and mammary neoplasms in different rat strains. The results on radiation carcinogenesis in animal models clearly indicate that the highest r.b.e. values are observed for neutrons with energies between 0.5 and 1 MeV. On the basis of such results it might be concluded that the maximum quality factor of 10 for neutrons should be increased. Based on current evidence, an increase by a factor of 2 to 3 seems more realistic than a tenfold rise. The diversity of dose-response relationships point to different mechanisms involved in the induction of different tumours in various species and even in different strains of the same species.