Association of catastrophic condylar fracture with bony changes of the third metacarpal bone identified by use of standing magnetic resonance imaging in forelimbs from cadavers of Thoroughbred racehorses in the United States

Comparison of radiography and computed tomography for identification of third metacarpal structural change and associated assessment of condylar stress fracture risk in Thoroughbred racehorses

BACKGROUND

Catastrophic injury has a low incidence but leads to the death of many Thoroughbred racehorses.

OBJECTIVES

To determine sensitivity, specificity, and reliability for third metacarpal condylar stress fracture risk assessment from digital radiographs (DR) and standing computed tomography (sCT).

STUDY DESIGN

Controlled ex vivo experiment.

METHODS

A blinded set of metacarpophalangeal joint DR and sCT images were prepared from 31 Thoroughbreds. Four observers evaluated the condyles and parasagittal grooves (PSG) of the third metacarpal bone for the extent of dense bone and lucency/fissure and assigned a risk assessment grade for condylar stress fracture based on imaging features. Sensitivity and specificity for detection of subchondral structural changes in the condyles and PSG, and for risk assessment for condylar stress fracture were determined by comparison with a reference assessment based on sCT and joint surface examination. Agreement between observers and the reference assessment and reliability between observers were determined. Intra-observer repeatability was also assessed.

RESULTS

Sensitivity for detection of structural change was lower than specificity for both imaging methods and all observers. For agreement with the reference assessment of structural change, correlation coefficients were generally below 0.5 for DR and 0.49-0.82 for sCT. For horses categorised as normal risk on reference assessment, observer assessment often agreed with the reference. Sensitivity for risk assessment was lower than specificity for all observers. For horses with a reference assessment of high risk of injury, observers generally underestimated risk. Diagnostic sensitivity of risk assessment was improved with sCT imaging, particularly for horses categorised as having elevated risk of injury from the reference assessment. Assessment repeatability and reliability was better with sCT than DR.

MAIN LIMITATIONS

The ex vivo study design influenced DR image sets.

CONCLUSIONS

Risk assessment through screening with diagnostic imaging is a promising approach to improve injury prevention in racing Thoroughbreds. Knowledge of sensitivity and specificity of fetlock lesion detection provides the critical guidance needed to improve racehorse screening programs. We found improved detection of MC3 subchondral structural change and risk assessment for condylar stress fracture with sCT ex vivo.

Tuning and validation of a virtual mechanical testing pipeline for condylar stress fracture risk assessment in Thoroughbred racehorses

Condylar stress fracture of the third metacarpal/metatarsal bone (MC3/MT3) in Thoroughbred racehorses is a common catastrophic injury, putting both the racehorse and the jockey at risk. Microdamage forms in the distal MC3 and may result in strain elevation and higher risk of stress fracture, directly and through focal osteolysis resulting from the associated damage repair by remodelling in the condylar parasagittal grooves (PSG). Standing computed tomography (sCT) is a practical screening tool for detecting fatigue-induced structural changes, but clinical interpretation remains subjective. The goal of this study was to develop and validate an sCT-based, subject-specific finite element analysis pipeline for virtual mechanical testing of the distal MC3. Twelve (n = 12) MC3 condyles with available ex vivo strain were selected. Half of the specimens were used for tuning Young's modulus in fatigue sites, and the other half were used to evaluate the validity of the pipeline in predicting PSG strain. The tuned model improved the prediction of strain and predicted higher strain in bones with PSG lysis over the untuned model, which is an essential feature for a diagnostic screening tool. The presented pipeline can assist clinicians with the interpretation of sCT-detectable structural changes and, ultimately, with the assessment of condylar fracture risk in racing Thoroughbreds.

Linkage of jockey falls and injuries with racehorse injuries and fatalities in Thoroughbred flat racing in Victoria, Australia

Introduction

Racehorse and jockey incidents on race-days frequently occur together, yet risk factors for their occurrence have historically been investigated separately. Consideration of both horses and humans in tandem is required for a One Health approach to risk reduction. Our objectives were to therefore identify modifiable risk factors for adverse outcomes that are common or conflicting to both horses and their jockeys in Thoroughbred racing.

Methods

Australian Single National System records for the 2004/05 to 2018/19 flat racing season were merged with the corresponding Australian Racing Incident Database records. Incidence rate ratios (IRR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were estimated for the outcomes of racehorse musculoskeletal injury (MSI), racehorse fatality, jockey falls and jockey injury using Poisson regression. Horse-level, race-level, jockey-level and trainer-level factors associated with each adverse outcome during or post-race were identified using multivariable logistic regression.

Results

The incidence of MSI was 21.21 (20.84, 21.59), racehorse fatalities 0.55 (0.50, 0.61), jockey falls was 3.01 (2.80, 3.24), and jockey injuries 1.79 (1.63, 1.97) per 1000 flat race starts. There was a decrease in racehorse MSI and jockey falls over the study period but no change in racehorse fatality or jockey injury incidence. In multivariable analysis, longer race distances and higher caliber races were associated with horse (p < 0.01), but not jockey, incidents. Firmer turf surfaces were associated with greater risk of both horse incidents and jockey falls (p < 0.05). Racehorses that were of older age at their first start, and/or had prior race-day injuries had a greater risk of injury and fatality (p < 0.001, p < 0.01, respectively). The most prominent risk factor for jockey fall or injury was a racehorse incident, although overall contributing to a relatively small proportion; 8.6% (n = 42/489) of jockey falls and 15.3% (n = 24/147) of injuries. Jockeys with fewer career starts were at greater risk of falling, and those with a higher percentage of last place finishing positions were at greater risk of injury (p < 0.001).

Discussion

As there were no conflicting risk factors identified between racehorse and jockey injury, policies aimed at reducing horse injury risk are also expected to benefit their riders.

Condylar fracture location is correlated to exercise history in Thoroughbred racehorses

BACKGROUND

Condylar fractures are a major cause of morbidity and mortality in Thoroughbred racehorses. Condylar fractures have a variety of fracture configurations that suggest there may be differences in aetiopathogenesis.

OBJECTIVE

To determine if exercise history differs with condylar fracture location in a population of Thoroughbred racehorses.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of clinical and exercise data.

METHODS

Exercise history of Thoroughbred racehorses that had condylar fracture repair between 1 January 2018 and 28 February 2021 was compared between racehorses that had fractures located radiographically either within the parasagittal groove (PSG) or abaxial to the PSG (non-PSG). Age, sex, and last event (race, timed work) matched control groups were compared between the PSG and non-PSG groups. Additionally, exercise history variables of both groups were each compared with a group-specific control population, each consisting of three control racehorses of equivalent age and sex matched to each affected racehorse by last event (race or official timed work) before fracture.

RESULTS

Eighty-two horses with 84 fractures (45 PSG, 39 non-PSG) met inclusion criteria. Age was not different between groups (PSG: 3.4 ± 1.3 years [mean ± SD], non-PSG: 3.7 ± 1.3, p = 0.3). Number of races (PSG: 5.3 ± 7.1, non-PSG: 11.4 ± 8.9, p < 0.001), total race furlongs (PSG: 38.2 ± 54.7, non-PSG: 79.2 ± 64, p = 0.003), and number of active days (PSG: 304 ± 224, non-PSG: 488 ± 314, p = 0.003) before fracture were greater; while mean number of layups was fewer (PSG: 1.0 ± 1.2, non-PSG: 0.5 ± 0.7, p = 0.02) in horses with non-PSG fracture. Horses with non-PSG fracture had more differences compared with their respective control group than horses with PSG fractures. Outcomes following fracture repair were not different between groups.

MAIN LIMITATIONS

Retrospective study, one regional racehorse population, two-dimensional imaging and potential inherent bias for fracture localisation, low statistical power for return to performance analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

Thoroughbred racehorses with non-PSG condylar fractures have a more extensive exercise history than horses with PSG condylar fractures, suggesting differences in fracture aetiopathogenesis.

Subchondral bone fatigue injury in the parasagittal condylar grooves of the third metacarpal bone in thoroughbred racehorses elevates site-specific strain concentration

Condylar stress fracture of the distal end of the third metacarpal/metatarsal (MC3/MT3) bones is a major cause of Thoroughbred racehorse injury and euthanasia worldwide. Functional adaptation to exercise and fatigue damage lead to structural changes in the subchondral bone that include increased modeling (resulting in sclerotic bone tissue) and targeted remodeling repair (resulting in focal resorption spaces in the parasagittal groove). Whether these focal structural changes, as detectable by standing computed tomography (sCT), lead to elevated strain at the common site of condylar stress fracture has not been demonstrated. Therefore, the goal of the present study was to compare full-field three-dimensional (3D) strain on the distopalmar aspect of MC3 bone specimens with and without focal subchondral bone injury (SBI). Thirteen forelimb specimens were collected from racing Thoroughbreds for mechanical testing ex vivo and underwent sCT. Subsequently, full-field displacement and strain at the joint surface were determined using stereo digital image correlation. Strain concentration was observed in the parasagittal groove (PSG) of the loaded condyles, and those with SBI in the PSG showed higher strain rates in this region than control bones. PSG strain rate in condyles with PSG SBI was more sensitive to CT density distribution in comparison with condyles with no sCT-detectable injury. Findings from this study help to interpret structural changes in the subchondral bone due to fatigue damage and to assess risk of incipient stress fracture in a patient-specific manner.

Fractures in Thoroughbred racing and the potential for pre-race identification of horses at risk

Risk rates for and predisposing factors to fractures occurring in Thoroughbred racing that have been published in peer reviewed journals are documented. The potential for currently available techniques to identify horses at increased risk for fracture is discussed on the bases of principles, practicalities, advantages, disadvantages and current data. All are reviewed in light of justifiable decision making and importance of fractures to horseracing's social license.

Positron emission tomography assessment of metacarpal/metatarsal condylar fractures post surgical repair: Prospective study in 14 racehorses

OBJECTIVES

To assess 18F-sodium fluoride (18F-NaF) positron emission tomography (PET) findings associated with metacarpal/metatarsal condylar fractures at the time of fracture repair and through healing.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective descriptive study.

ANIMALS

Fourteen Thoroughbred racehorses.

METHODS

18F-NaF PET was performed within 4 days of surgical metacarpal/metatarsal condylar fracture repair, on both the injured and contralateral limb. Follow-up PET scans were offered at 3- and 5-months post fracture repair. Areas of abnormal uptake were assessed using a previously validated grading system.

RESULTS

Eight fractures were located in the parasagittal groove (PSG) (six lateral and two medial) and six fractures were located abaxial to the PSG (non-PSG) through the palmar/plantar condyle (all lateral). All horses in the latter group had uptake in the lateral palmar condyle of the contralateral limb suggestive of stress remodeling. Three horses with PSG fractures had uptake in a similar location in the contralateral limb. Horses with lateral condylar fracture only presented minimal or mild uptake in the medial condyle, which is considered atypical in the front limbs for horses in full training. Four horses developed periarticular uptake in the postoperative period suggestive of degenerative joint disease, three of these horses had persistent uptake at the fracture site. These four horses did not return to racing successfully.

CONCLUSION

The findings of this study provide evidence of pre-existing lesions and specific uptake patterns in racehorses suffering from metacarpal/metatarsal condylar fractures.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

PET has a possible role in the prevention, diagnosis, and postoperative monitoring of metacarpal/metatarsal condylar fractures in racehorses.

Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Computed Tomographic and Radiographic Findings in the Metacarpophalangeal Joints of 40 Non-Lame Thoroughbred Yearlings

Most catastrophic injuries in Thoroughbred racehorses involve the fetlock. There is no description of comparative imaging in Thoroughbreds entering racehorse training. The aim was to describe MRI, CT and radiographic findings in the metacarpophalangeal joint of non-lame Thoroughbred yearlings. Forty Thoroughbreds underwent low-field MRI, fan-beam CT and radiographic examinations of both metacarpophalangeal joints. Images were assessed subjectively. A hypoattenuating lesion of the sagittal ridge of the third metacarpal bone (McIII) was identified in 33/80 limbs in CT reconstructions. Cone-shaped mineralisation in the sagittal ridge was detected in MR images (n = 17) and in CT images (n = 5). Mild hyperattenuation was common in trabecular bone in the dorsomedial (36/80) and palmarolateral (25/80) metacarpal condyles in CT reconstructions. A focal lesion in the subchondral bone was seen in the proximal phalanx (n = 19) and in McIII (n = 11). Enlarged vascular channels were detected in the metacarpal condyles in 57/80 limbs and in the proximal sesamoid bones in all limbs. Signs of bone modelling are seen in yearling Thoroughbred fetlocks. Sagittal ridge lesions were common and are likely associated with osteochondrosis or other developmental osteochondral defects. Focal lesions in the subchondral bone of McIII and proximal phalanx can indicate developmental abnormalities or subtle subchondral bone injuries.

QCT-based computational bone strength assessment updated with MRI-derived 'hidden' microporosity

Microdamage accumulated through sustained periods of cyclic loading or single overloading events contributes to bone fragility through a reduction in stiffness and strength. Monitoring microdamage in vivo remains unattainable by clinical imaging modalities. As such, there are no established computational methods for clinical fracture risk assessment that account for microdamage that exists in vivo at any specific timepoint. We propose a method that combines multiple clinical imaging modalities to identify an indicative surrogate, which we term 'hidden porosity', that incorporates pre-existing bone microdamage in vivo. To do so, we use the third metacarpal bone of the equine athlete as an exemplary model for fatigue induced microdamage, which coalesces in the subchondral bone. N = 10 metacarpals were scanned by clinical quantitative computed tomography (QCT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). We used a patch-based similarity method to quantify the signal intensity of a fluid sensitive MRI sequence in bone regions where microdamage coalesces. The method generated MRI-derived pseudoCT images which were then used to determine a pre-existing damage (Dpex) variable to quantify the proposed surrogate and which we incorporate into a nonlinear constitutive model for bone tissue. The minimum, median, and maximum detected Dpex of 0.059, 0.209, and 0.353 reduced material stiffness by 5.9%, 20.9%, and 35.3% as well as yield stress by 5.9%, 20.3%, and 35.3%. Limb-specific voxel-based finite element meshes were equipped with the updated material model. Lateral and medial condyles of each metacarpal were loaded to simulate physiological joint loading during gallop. The degree of detected Dpex correlated with a relative reduction in both condylar stiffness (p = 0.001, R2 > 0.74) and strength (p < 0.001, R2 > 0.80). Our results illustrate the complementary value of looking beyond clinical CT, which neglects the inclusion of microdamage due to partial volume effects. As we use clinically available imaging techniques, our results may aid research beyond the equine model on fracture risk assessment in human diseases such as osteoarthritis, bone cancer, or osteoporosis.

When radiography and ultrasonography are not enough: the use of computed tomography and magnetic resonance imaging for equine lameness cases

MRI and CT have enhanced our diagnostic abilities for equine lameness beyond what is available using radiography and ultrasonography. This has allowed veterinarians to better prognosticate and treat lameness conditions, improving patient outcomes. This article discusses the basic principles behind MRI and CT, their advantages and disadvantages, the different types of equipment available for clinical use in horses, the typical diagnostic workup prior to pursuing advanced imaging, and common regions where MRI and CT are used clinically. The companion Currents in One Health by Spriet, AJVR, July 2022, discusses even more advanced equine imaging in the form of positron emission tomography. Combined, these future directions of MRI, CT, and positron emission tomography may include improved ability to image standing horses or screen for injury prevention.

Imaging and Gross Pathological Appearance of Changes in the Parasagittal Grooves of Thoroughbred Racehorses

Simple Summary

Early detection of racehorses at risk of stress fracture is key to reducing the number of horses with catastrophic fractures while racing. Bone changes are often visible in the limbs of Thoroughbred racehorses in work, particularly in the fetlock region. However, it is currently unknown whether some of these changes indicate an impending fracture or are a healthy adaptation to high-speed exercise. This study looks at imaging and gross changes in a specific area (parasagittal grooves (PSGs) of the cannon bone) and the utility of X-ray, computed tomography (CT) and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to detect the changes. All fetlock joints were assessed from twenty horses that died during racing or training, including horses with and without fetlock fracture. Overall, X-ray was poor for detecting PSG changes. Some PSG changes on CT and MRI were common in Thoroughbred racehorses and possibly represent normal bone adaptation when seen in clinical cases. However, certain CT and MRI findings were more prevalent in horses with a fracture, possibly indicating microdamage accumulation and increased risk of fracture. Bilateral advanced imaging is recommended in clinical cases of suspected fetlock pathology.

Abstract

(1) Background: Parasagittal groove (PSG) changes are often present on advanced imaging of racing Thoroughbred fetlocks and have been suggested to indicate increased fracture risk. Currently, there is limited evidence differentiating the imaging appearance of prodromal changes in horses at risk of fracture from horses with normal adaptive modelling in response to galloping. This study aims to investigate imaging and gross PSG findings in racing Thoroughbreds and the comparative utility of different imaging modalities to detect PSG changes. (2) Methods: Cadaver limbs were collected from twenty deceased racing/training Thoroughbreds. All fetlocks of each horse were examined with radiography, low-field magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), computed tomography (CT), contrast arthrography and gross pathology. (3) Results: Horses with fetlock fracture were more likely to have lateromedial PSG sclerosis asymmetry and/or lateral PSG lysis. PSG lysis was not readily detected using MRI. PSG subchondral bone defects were difficult to differentiate from cartilage defects on MRI and were not associated with fractures. The clinical relevance of PSG STIR hyperintensity remains unclear. Overall, radiography was poor for detecting PSG changes. (4) Conclusions: Some PSG changes in Thoroughbred racehorses are common; however, certain findings are more prevalent in horses with fractures, possibly indicating microdamage accumulation. Bilateral advanced imaging is recommended in racehorses with suspected fetlock pathology.

Determination of correlation of proximal sesamoid bone osteoarthritis with high-speed furlong exercise and catastrophic sesamoid bone fracture in Thoroughbred racehorses

OBJECTIVE

To examine whether proximal sesamoid bone (PSB) articular cartilage and bone osteoarthritic changes or palmar osteochondral disease (POD) scores were associated with exercise history and catastrophic PSB fracture in Thoroughbred racehorses.

SAMPLES

PSBs from 16 Thoroughbred racehorses (8 with and 8 without PSB fracture).

PROCEDURES

Exercise history was collected, and total career high-speed furlongs was used as the measure of total exercise per horse. At necropsy, medial and lateral condyles of the third metacarpus from each forelimb were assigned a POD score, followed by imaging with micro-CT for evaluation of osteophyte size. Three investigators that were blinded to the type of PSB (fracture or no fracture) used the Osteoarthritis Research Society International (OARSI) scoring system to evaluate acellularity, chondrocyte necrosis, cartilage fibrillation, chondrone formation, safranin O stain uptake, and tidemark advancement of 1 central sagittal tissue section/PSB (4 PSBs/horse). Cartilage thickness and bone necrosis were scored on the basis of histologic examination.

RESULTS

POD score, osteophyte size score, percentage of bone necrosis, tidemark advancement, chondrone formation, and total OARSI score were greater in horses with more accrued total career high-speed furlongs. Scores for POD, osteophyte size, fibrillation, acellularity, chondrone formation, and total OARSI were greater for horses with PSB fracture.

CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL REVELANCE

OARSI scoring revealed that more advanced osteoarthritic changes strongly correlated with total career high-speed furlongs and PSB fracture. However, the effect of exercise was dominant, suggesting that exercise history will be important to include in future models that aim to assess risk factors for catastrophic PSB fracture.

Does the Low-Field MRI Appearance of Intraosseous STIR Hyperintensity in Equine Cadaver Limbs Change when Subjected to a Freeze-Thaw Process?

Simple Summary

Research into the advanced imaging appearance of Thoroughbred racehorse fetlocks is receiving increased attention in an effort to better understand and potentially reduce the occurrence of catastrophic fracture in these horses. Studies in this area commonly use cadaver equine limbs from racehorses and a freeze-thaw process prior to imaging. The low-field magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) appearance of the bones of the fetlock joint is of particular interest in the diagnosis of impending fracture in this location. However, little is known about the effect of the freeze-thaw process on the appearance of certain signal changes (“STIR hyperintensity”) seen commonly in racehorses. This study compares the low-field MRI appearance of short tau inversion recovery (STIR) hyperintensity in the bones of cadaver fetlocks from Thoroughbreds in race training, before and after a freeze-thaw protocol. Fifteen cadaver fetlocks with abnormal bone signal were included in the study. Blinded and unblinded statistical comparisons were made. No overall clinical or statistical difference was detected in intensity and distribution of the STIR signal before and after freeze-thaw. This indicates that the MRI appearance of STIR hyperintensity in freeze-thawed cadaver fetlocks can be considered representative of the appearance of pathology in the recently euthanized horse. This is important information to further advance research in the area of Thoroughbred racing fatality reduction.

Abstract

Equine advanced imaging research involving racehorse fetlock pathology commonly uses cadaver limbs and a freeze-thaw process. The presence of short tau inversion recovery (STIR) signal intensity in the distal third metacarpal/metatarsal bone is of particular interest and may be clinically relevant in the diagnosis of horses at risk of fracture. However, little is known about the effect of the freeze-thaw process on the MRI appearance of STIR hyperintensity in these bones. This study compares the low-field MRI appearance of the distal third metacarpal/metatarsal bone from cadaver limbs of Thoroughbreds in race training before and after a freeze-thaw protocol. Blinded and unblinded comparisons were made using objective SNR values and subjective grading. Fifteen cadaver limbs with STIR hyperintensity in the distal third metacarpal/metatarsal bone were included. No overall clinical or statistical significance was detected in STIR signal intensity and distribution after freeze-thaw. Three limbs from one horse had individual changes in STIR hyperintensity that were hypothesized to be attributable to ante-mortem haemodynamic abnormalities caused by anaesthesia. These results indicate that the distribution and intensity of STIR hyperintensity in freeze-thawed cadaver fetlocks can be considered representative of the appearance of pathology in the recently euthanized horse. However, care should be taken with horse selection and handling of the cadaver limbs to ensure reliable appearance of STIR signal after freeze-thaw.

A Thoroughbred racehorse with a unicortical palmar lateral condylar fracture returned to training 14 days after surgery: a hypothesis on the role of a single bone screw on crack propagation

A 2-year-old Thoroughbred racehorse had LF lameness that began post high-speed exercise and persisted for two days before the horse once again became sound. Diagnostic analgesia localized the lameness to the LF distal metacarpus, and a standing MRI identified a unicortical condylar fracture. A single 5.5 mm cortical screw was placed in lag fashion. The horse began hand walking at 14 days, racetrack jogging at 30 days, and racing at 5 months after the day of surgery. Placement of a single lag screw ahead of the tip of the crack in unicortical condylar fracture may be useful for reducing the recovery period for horses returning to training and racing.