Oronasal fistulas in cleft palate patients and their influence on speech

Unraveling a Major Burden of Orofacial Clefts Analyses: Classification of Cleft Palate Fistulas by Cleft Surgeons

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to investigate how cleft surgeons classify palatal fistulas. We focused on three different anatomical locations (ie, hard palate, soft palate, junction hard/soft palate) to analyze agreement/disagreement at various anatomical locations.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional survey study.

PARTICIPANTS

Participants in an international webinar that focused on palatal fistula treatment were included.

INTERVENTION

Participants were presented with a survey pre- and post-webinar.

MAIN OUTCOMES

Frequency of used classification systems for classifying oronasal fistulas and the inter-rater reliability of the Pittsburgh classification system.

RESULTS

A total of 141 participants completed the questionnaires prior to the webinar and 109 participants completed the survey after the webinar. In total, four classification systems were used (ie, Pittsburgh, Pakistan Comprehensive Fistula Classification [PCFC], anatomical and 'other'). The Pittsburgh classification was the most commonly used system in all cases. However, Pittsburgh inter-rater reliability was low (κ = 0.136 pre-webinar, and κ = 0.174 post-webinar). Surprisingly, a substantial shift was observed from the anatomical to Pittsburgh classification after the webinar, indicating increased awareness of the usability of the Pittsburgh classification system.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates a large heterogeneity with regards to the classification of cleft palate fistulas. Interestingly, a shift was observed from the anatomical to Pittsburgh classification after the webinar. However, the inter-rater reliability for using the Pittsburgh classification was low. Classifying palatal fistulas in a homogenous fashion could enhance comparison of primary palate repair and could improve treatment of palatal fistulas.

The Impact of Fan-Type Rapid Palatal Expanders on Speech in Patients With Unilateral Cleft Lip and Palate

Rapid palatal expanders (RPEs) are commonly used in patients with cleft lip and palate (CLP) prior to secondary alveolar bone grafting (SABG). Their position and size can impede tongue movement and affect speech. This study assessed changes in perception and production of speech over the course of RPE treatment.

Prospective longitudinal.

Tertiary university-affiliated hospital.

Twenty-five patients with unilateral CLP treated with Fan-type RPEs, and their parents.

Patient and parent speech questionnaires and patient speech recordings were collected at baseline before RPE insertion (T1), directly after RPE insertion (T2), during RPE expansion (T3), during RPE retention (T4), directly after RPE removal but before SABG (T5), and at short-term follow-up after RPE removal and SABG (T6).

Ratings for patient and parent questionnaires, first (F1) and second (F2) formants for vowels /a/, /i/, and /u/, and nasalance scores for non-nasal and nasal sentences, were obtained and analyzed using mixed model analyses of variance.

Ratings worsened at T2. For the vowel /a/, F1 and F2 were unchanged at T2. For the vowel /i/, F1 increased and F2 decreased at T2. For the vowel /u/, F1 was unchanged and F2 decreased at T2. Nasalance was unchanged at T2. All outcome measures returned to T1 levels by T4.

RPE insertion resulted in initial adverse effects on speech perception and production, which decreased to baseline prior to removal. Information regarding transient speech dysfunction and distress may help prepare patients for treatment.

Better speech outcomes after very early palatal repair?-A longitudinal case-control study in Ugandan children with cleft palate

INTRODUCTION

Children born with cleft palate with or without cleft lip (CP±L) tend to use less oral pressure consonants and more glottal sounds in their babbling. The purpose of very early palatal repair (i.e., one-stage palatal closure prior to 6 months of age) is to make the palate functional before the onset of speech acquisition to reduce the anchoring of wrong patterns in the child's developing phonological system. As a result, less compensatory articulation errors are expected to be present. Currently, no detailed longitudinal speech outcomes after very early palatal closure are available. This study aimed to provide longitudinal speech outcomes in Ugandan children with CP±L who received palatal closure prior to the age of 6 months.

METHODS

Ten children with CP±L were assessed at a mean age of 5 and 10 years old. Speech understandability, speech acceptability, resonance, nasal airflow and articulation were perceptually rated by two experienced speech-language pathologists. Velopharyngeal function was estimated using the velopharyngeal composite score (VPC-sum). Information regarding speech therapy, fistula rate, and secondary (speech) surgery was collected. The outcomes were compared with the longitudinal outcomes of an age- and gender-matched control group of 10 Ugandan children without CP±L.

RESULTS

Speech understandability and acceptability improved significantly over time in the group with CP±L (all p's ≤ 0.05, all Z's > -2.43). At both test dates, significantly worse judgments were found for the group with CP±L compared to the control group for these variables and variables related to passive speech errors (all p's ≤ 0.05, all Z's > 2.49). A statistically significant difference with the control group was found for the presence of compensatory articulation errors at the age of 5 years but not at the age of 10 years, indicating a catch up by the children with CP±L.

CONCLUSION

Whether a one-stage palatal closure prior to the age of 6 months is more favorable for speech outcomes compared to one-stage palatal closure at 12 months is still not clear. Speech of the children with CP±L improved over time, but significantly differed from the control group at the age of 5 and 10 years old. Limited access to health care facilities and possible influence of malnutrition on wound healing need to be considered when interpreting the results. Whether palatal closure prior to the age of 6 months is transferable to other countries is subject for further research, including both longitudinal and prospective designs with larger samples.

Speech and Language Issues in the Cleft Palate Population: The State of the Art

Objective

State-of-the-art activity demands a look back, a look around, and, importantly, a look into the new millennium. The area of speech and language has been an integral part of cleft palate care from the very beginning. This article reviews the development and progression of our knowledge base over the last several decades in the areas of speech; language; anatomy and physiology of the velopharynx; assessment of velopharyngeal function; and treatment, both behavioral and physical, for velopharyngeal problems.

Method

The clear focus is on the cleft palate condition. However, much of what is reviewed applies to persons with other craniofacial disorders and with other underlying causes of velopharyngeal impairment. A major challenge in the next several years is to sort through speech disorders that have a clear anatomic underpinning, and thus are more amenable to physical management, versus those that may be treated successfully using behavioral approaches. Speech professionals must do a better job of finding and applying ways of treating individuals with less severe velopharyngeal impairment, thus avoiding the need for physical management in these persons or ignoring the speech problem altogether.

Conclusion

Early and aggressive management for speech and language disorders should be conducted. For most individuals born with cleft conditions, a realistic goal should be normal speech and language usage by the time the child reaches the school-age years.

Speech outcome in complete unilateral cleft lip and palate - a comparison of three methods of the hard palate closure

The aim of this study was to compare the speech in subjects with cleft lip and palate, in whom three methods of the hard palate closure were used. One hundred and thirty-seven children (96 boys, 41 girls; mean age = 12 years, SD = 1·2) with complete unilateral cleft lip and palate (CUCLP) operated by a single surgeon with a one-stage method were evaluated. The management of the cleft lip and soft palate was comparable in all subjects; for hard palate repair, three different methods were used: bilateral von Langenbeck closure (b-vL group, n = 39), unilateral von Langenbeck closure (u-vL group, n = 56) and vomerplasty (v-p group, n = 42). Speech was assessed: (i) perceptually for the presence of a) hypernasality, b) compensatory articulations (CAs), c) audible nasal air emissions (ANE) and d) speech intelligibility; (ii) for the presence of compensatory facial grimacing, (iii) with clinical intra-oral evaluation and (iv) with videonasendoscopy. A total rate of hypernasality requiring pharyngoplasty was 5·1%; total incidence post-oral compensatory articulations (CAs) was 2·2%. The overall speech intelligibility was good in 84·7% of cases. Oronasal fistulas (ONFs) occurred in 15·7% b-vL subjects, 7·1% u-vL subjects and 50% v-p subjects (P < 0·001). No statistically significant intergroup differences for hypernasality, CAs and intelligibility were found (P > 0·1). In conclusion, the speech after early one-stage repair of CUCLP was satisfactory. The method of hard palate repair affected the incidence of ONFs, which, however, caused relatively mild and inconsistent speech errors.

Impact of obturation of palatal fistulae on speech quality and aerodynamic parameters in patients with cleft palates

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this prospective study was to measure nasal and oral airflow during speech, before and after obturation.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Included were children aged 3-18 years with nonsyndromic clefts and palatal fistulae. The corpus used was: syllable /pi/; a sentence containing stop consonants and a nasal phoneme; and the description of a picture of a scene. Analysis criteria were: percentage of nasality; value of average flow for the explosion; perceived nasality and intelligibility; and tolerance of the proposed device.

RESULTS

Only 5 children were included due to the observation of an increase in the percentage of nasality after obturation. The value of average flow for the explosion increased in all patients. A decrease in perceived nasality was noted in all but 1 patient. An improvement in intelligibility was observed in 3 out of the 5 children. The tolerance of the device was good.

CONCLUSION

While the small number of patients studied does not permit firm conclusions concerning the efficiency of the obturation, the method described, as well as the introduction of 'speed of explosion' of stop consonants, offer new perspectives to prospectively study obturator effects on speech.

Repair of oronasal fistulae by interposition of multilayered amniotic membrane allograft

BACKGROUND

Oronasal fistulas are a frequent complication after cleft palate surgery. Numerous repair methods have been described, but wound-healing problems occur often. The authors investigated, for the first time, the suitability of multilayered amniotic membrane allograft for fistula repair in a laboratory experiment (part A), a swine model (part B), and an initial patient series (part C).

METHODS

In part A, one-, two-, and four-layer porcine and human amniotic membranes (n = 20 each) were fixed in a digital towing device and the force needed for rupture was determined. In part B, iatrogenic oronasal fistulas in 18 piglets were repaired with amniotic membrane allograft, autofetal amniotic membrane, or small intestinal submucosa (n = 6 each). Healing was evaluated by probing and visual inflammation control (no/moderate/strong) on postoperative days 3, 7, 10, and 76. Histological analysis was performed to visualize tissue architecture. In part C, four patients (two women and two men, ages 21 to 51 years) were treated with multilayered amniotic membrane allograft.

RESULTS

In part A, forces needed for amniotic membrane rupture increased with additional layers (p < 0.001). Human amniotic membrane was stronger than porcine membrane (p < 0.001). In part B, fistula closure succeeded in all animals treated with amniotic membrane with less inflammation than in the small intestinal submucosa group. One fistula remained persistent in the small intestinal submucosa group. In part C, all fistulas healed completely without inflammation.

CONCLUSIONS

Amniotic membrane is an easily available biomaterial and can be used successfully for oronasal fistula repair. The multilayer technique and protective plates should be utilized to prevent membrane ruptures.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, V.

Influence of Timing of Hard Palate Repair in a Two-Stage Procedure on Early Speech Development in Danish Children with Cleft Palate

Objective

To investigate the influence of timing of hard palate closure on early speech development from 18 months to 3 years of age.

Design

A prospective, randomized clinical trial.

Participants

Thirty-four children with unilateral cleft lip and palate (UCLP) with velum closure at 4 months of age, and hard palate closure at 12 months (early hard palate repair, EarlyHPR) or 36 months (late hard palate unrepaired, LateHPU) by random assignment. Thirty-five control children were matched for gender and age.

Methods

All children were video recorded during a play interaction with a parent at 18 months of age. These recordings were transcribed according to the International Phonetic Alphabet. At 36 months a single word naming test was administered.

Results

At 18 months the LateHPU group produced fewer labial stops and more velar stops than the EarlyHPR group. Unlike the EarlyHPR group, the LateHPU group produced fewer vocalizations, consonants, and consonants permissible in word-initial position than the control group. Additionally, both cleft palate groups had a smaller productive vocabulary than the control group, but unlike the EarlyHPR group, the LateHPU group produced a smaller number of word tokens in social interaction than the control group. By 3 years of age, the LateHPU group had a (severely) restricted phonological system and produced more cleft speech characteristics than the EarlyHPR group.

Conclusions

Surgical timing of hard palate repair in a two-stage procedure appears to have an influence on early speech development in children with cleft palate.

Staphylococcus aureus transmission through oronasal fistula in children with cleft lip and palate

OBJECTIVE

To determine the presence of Staphylococcus aureus in a nasal flora and oral environment, the correlation between frequency of transmission of S. aureus and oronasal fistula size, and the pattern of methicillin resistance on S. aureus strains in children with cleft lip and palate (CLP).

DESIGN

Thirty-two CLP children with and without oronasal fistulas, ranging in age from 5 to 13 years were examined for oronasal fistula presence and size. Stimulated saliva samples and nasal swab samples were taken and investigated for S. aureus presence. S. aureus presence and counts were correlated with fistula presence and size.

RESULTS

Saliva samples showed statistical differences between the groups with and without oronasal fistulas with an area ranging from 0.80 to 28.26 mm2. The S. aureus counts were significantly higher (r = .535, p = .002) in saliva samples from children with larger oronasal fistula. The S. aureus count was not significantly different (r = -.013, p = .942) in nasal samples compared with oronasal fistula size. Methicillin resistance with disk-diffusion method was recorded as sensitive (> or =13 mm) in all S. aureus strains.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study indicate a positive correlation between fistula size and S. aureus transmission to one oral environment through oronasal fistulae, and a positive correlation between frequency of S. aureus transmission and fistula size. All S. aureus strains were sensitive to methicillin. These results may have implications for preventive treatment of CLP children.

The use of decellularized dermal grafting (AlloDerm) in persistent oro-nasal fistulas after tertiary cleft palate repair

To assess the efficacy of decellularized dermal grafting as an adjunct to the closure of recurrent oro-nasal fistulas. Five consecutive patients with recurrent oro-nasal fistulas were repaired with decellularized dermal grafting sandwiched between oral and nasal flaps of a von Langenbeck palatal repair. All patients had previously undergone a minimum of three prior palatal repairs with the recurrence of their oro-nasal fistula in the post-alveolar area. Decellularized dermal graft was placed between the nasal mucosa and the levator veli palatine muscle. Patients were followed postoperatively and assessed for infection, dehiscence, signs of rejection, and fistula recurrence. All patients were followed for an average of three months. Clinical examination revealed no recurrence of their oro-nasal fistula nor associated symptoms of nasal reflux. Decellularized dermal grafts were not rejected nor extruded from the site of surgical repair. Decellularized dermal graft should be considered for use in the treatment of recurrent oro-nasal fistula after cleft palate repair. We would also like to encourage further clinical study.

Immediate and sustained changes in tongue movement with an experimental palatal "fistula": a case study

OBJECTIVE

To determine the immediate and longer-term effect(s) on tongue movement following the placement of an experimental opening through a palatal obturator (replicate of subject's prosthesis) worn by an adult male with an unrepaired cleft of the hard and soft palate.

METHODS

Tongue movements associated with an anterior experimental opening of 20 mm(2) were examined under three conditions: a control condition in which the subject wore the experimental obturator completely occluded, a condition immediately after drilling the experimental openings through the obturator, and a condition after 5 days in which the subject wore the experimental obturator with the experimental opening. An Electromagnetic Articulograph was used for obtaining tongue movements during speech.

RESULTS

The findings partly revealed that the immediate introduction of a perturbation to the speech system (experimental fistula) had a temporary effect on tongue movement. After sustained perturbation (for 5 days), the system normalized (going back toward control condition's behavior). Perceptual data were consistent with kinematic tongue movement direction in most of the cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the immediate response can be interpreted as indicative of the subject's attempts to move the tongue toward the opening to compensate for air loss, the findings following a sustained perturbation indicate that with time, other physiological adjustments (such as respiratory adjustments, for example) may help reestablish the requirements of a pressure-regulating system.

Use of cartilage grafts for closure of cleft palate fistulae

We describe the results of using a free cartilage graft in the closure of cleft palate fistulae in 14 patients with a mean follow-up of 8.6 months. Complete closure of the fistula was achieved in 11 patients (79%), with partial closure in the remaining three patients. This technique is simple, causes relatively little discomfort, involves little tissue dissection and can be performed as a day-case procedure. The success rate is comparable with or better than other methods, and we consider it the treatment of choice for small cleft palate fistulae.

Von Langenbeck or Wardill procedures for primary palatal repair in patients with isolated cleft palate--speech results

Sixty-six patients operated on for isolated cleft palate were evaluated as adults, and their speech was assessed clinically. Forty-four had undergone a von Langenbeck repair at the age of 7 months and 22 a Wardill repair at the age of 18 months. Speech was judged subjectively by the patients themselves, and perceptual assessment was made by three speech pathologists. The remaining speech problems, mainly hypernasality, were moderate or severe in 7 (16%) of the patients in the von Langenbeck group, and in 7 (32%) in the Wardill group. On the other hand, the patients in the Wardill group had fewer fistulas closed, and fewer velopharyngoplasties. There were no significant differences between the two methods regarding speech in adulthood. The Wardill method produced significantly more scar tissue clinically, which carries the potential risk of inhibition of facial growth. The present speech results will therefore be weighed against the outcome of maxillofacial growth for these patients.

Adaptation of pharyngeal wall adduction after pharyngeal flap surgery

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this investigation was to study lateral pharyngeal wall adduction relative to pharyngeal flaps of different widths. The hypothesis to be tested was that pharyngeal wall adduction does not increase postoperatively but may decrease due to the mechanical hindrance of a wide flap.

DESIGN

In this prospective study, adaptation of lateral pharyngeal wall adduction during speech was studied relative to pharyngeal flaps of different widths utilizing videoradiography. Flap width was determined nasopharyngoscopically.

SETTING

All patients were treated by the Stockholm Cleft Palate Team, Sweden.

PATIENTS

Fifty-three patients were strictly selected by discarding conditions known to exert uncontrolled influence on velopharyngeal sphincter function.

RESULTS

The results revealed a potential for adaptation of pharyngeal wall adduction to different flap widths. The magnitude and character (increase or decrease) of change in adduction was significantly correlated with the degree of preoperative adduction and with the width of the flap. In patients with limited preoperative adduction, pharyngeal wall activity increased, more in the presence of a narrow flap while less if the flap was wide. When preoperative adduction was pronounced, the postoperative activity decreased because of mechanical hindrance by the flap, and the degree of impediment was correlated to the width of the flap.

CONCLUSION

A potential for increased lateral pharyngeal wall adduction after pharyngeal flap surgery was verified, but the result cannot be interpreted as generally applicable because of the strict selection of patients.

Effect of temporary closure of oronasal fistulae on levator veli palatini muscle activity

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to clarify electromyographically the effects of closing an oronasal fistula on levator muscle activity and oral air pressure in patients with velopharyngeal incompetence and in those with adequate velopharyngeal function.

SUBJECTS

Five patients with adequate velopharyngeal function and six patients with velopharyngeal incompetence were studied. All subjects had an oronasal fistula at the anterior third portion of the hard palate in spite of primary palatal closure using palatal push-back operation.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The smoothed electromyographic activity of the levator veli palatini muscle was measured with the fistula closed with a cotton swab dipped in saline and with the fistula left open.

RESULTS

Under the closed fistula condition, oral air pressure was greater than that observed under the open fistula condition irrespective of velopharyngeal function. Levator veli palatini muscle activity was significantly lower in magnitude under the condition of closure than under the open condition in the patients with adequate velopharyngeal function, whereas in those with velopharyngeal incompetence, it was not significantly changed.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that velopharyngeal function is affected by temporary closure of an oronasal fistula, and that the magnitude of the effect is greater for subjects with adequate velopharyngeal function than for subjects with velopharyngeal incompetence.

Residual clefts in the hard palate: correlation between cleft size and speech

OBJECTIVE

This study was conducted to evaluate the relationship between size of residual clefts in the hard palate and speech.

SUBJECTS

Fifteen 7-year-old children born with complete cleft lip and palate were investigated.

METHODS

All of the children were treated according to a surgical regimen involving early soft palate repair and delayed hard palate closure. Measures were taken of the area, length, and maximal width of the residual cleft in the hard palate about a year before its closure and correlated with a perceptual judgment of several speech variables.

RESULTS

Significant positive correlations were obtained between the size of the cleft and two variables: weak pressure consonants and hypernasality. Nasal escape was very common among the patients, and almost half the children had retracted palatal or velar articulation of dental stop consonants. Neither of these two variables correlated with the size of the residual cleft.

CONCLUSION

Perceived oral pressure and, perhaps, resonance seem to be related to size of the opening of the residual cleft, whereas audible nasal escape and articulatory compensations are not, at least not the latter once established.

Speech and velopharyngeal function in children with an open residual cleft in the hard palate, and the influence of temporary covering

The influence of an open residual cleft in the hard palate on speech was studied in nine children with cleft lip and palate at about 7 years of age. The subjects were treated by early repair of the velum (before 12 months of age), whereas the repair of the cleft in the hard palate was postponed until about 8 years of age. Speech and velopharyngeal function were assessed systematically with the residual cleft open and temporarily covered with an oral bandage. Listeners' judgments, the Nasal Oral RAtio Meter (NORAM), videofluoroscopy, and cephalometrics were used for the analyses. Four patients were also examined with a pressure-flow technique. Nasality registered by NORAM, nasal escape, and weak pressure consonants judged by listeners were common but decreased appreciably when the residual cleft was covered. Retracted articulation was found in four patients (44%) and glottal compensations in one (11%), with no improvement after covering.