Evaluation of the usefulness of open lung biopsies

Utility of open surgical lung biopsy in children

INTRODUCTION

Open lung biopsy (OLB) is commonly used to obtain a definitive histological diagnosis in children with respiratory disorders. This allows correct treatment pathways to be followed and guides discussions surrounding prognosis. Our aim was to determine if OLB is useful in obtaining a conclusive diagnosis in a child with complex respiratory disease.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In total, 179 OLB episodes were identified in children under 18 years from 2006 to 2016. Biopsies confirming congenital thoracic malformations or pulmonary metastatic disease were excluded.

RESULTS

42 patients had 44 episodes of OLB in the period studied. A definitive histological diagnosis was reached in 35 (79%) cases. There were no deaths directly attributable to OLB surgery.

CONCLUSION

OLB contributed substantially in obtaining a definitive diagnosis for our patient population, no increase in mortality. It allowed targeted treatment and provided valuable prognostic information on the likely progression of the disease so families could plan for palliation where appropriate.

An official American Thoracic Society clinical practice guideline: classification, evaluation, and management of childhood interstitial lung disease in infancy

BACKGROUND

There is growing recognition and understanding of the entities that cause interstitial lung disease (ILD) in infants. These entities are distinct from those that cause ILD in older children and adults.

METHODS

A multidisciplinary panel was convened to develop evidence-based guidelines on the classification, diagnosis, and management of ILD in children, focusing on neonates and infants under 2 years of age. Recommendations were formulated using a systematic approach. Outcomes considered important included the accuracy of the diagnostic evaluation, complications of delayed or incorrect diagnosis, psychosocial complications affecting the patient's or family's quality of life, and death.

RESULTS

No controlled clinical trials were identified. Therefore, observational evidence and clinical experience informed judgments. These guidelines: (1) describe the clinical characteristics of neonates and infants (<2 yr of age) with diffuse lung disease (DLD); (2) list the common causes of DLD that should be eliminated during the evaluation of neonates and infants with DLD; (3) recommend methods for further clinical investigation of the remaining infants, who are regarded as having "childhood ILD syndrome"; (4) describe a new pathologic classification scheme of DLD in infants; (5) outline supportive and continuing care; and (6) suggest areas for future research.

CONCLUSIONS

After common causes of DLD are excluded, neonates and infants with childhood ILD syndrome should be evaluated by a knowledgeable subspecialist. The evaluation may include echocardiography, controlled ventilation high-resolution computed tomography, infant pulmonary function testing, bronchoscopy with bronchoalveolar lavage, genetic testing, and/or lung biopsy. Preventive care, family education, and support are essential.

Open lung biopsy in bone marrow transplant recipients has a poor diagnostic yield for a specific diagnosis

The diagnostic yield of open lung biopsy (OLB) in bone marrow transplantation (BMT) recipients having pulmonary infiltrates has not been evaluated recently. Therefore, we reviewed our 2-year experience (1998-99) with such patients at The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center. We found 12 BMT recipients who underwent OLB analysis for the evaluation of pulmonary infiltrates. A treatable infectious etiology leading to the initiation or modification of antimicrobial agent administration was found in only two patients having bilateral nodular disease and one having bilateral parenchymal infiltrates. We conclude that OLB in BMT patients having diffuse pulmonary infiltrates has a low diagnostic yield for treatable infectious etiologies.

Radiologically guided fine needle lung biopsies in the evaluation of focal pulmonary lesions in allogeneic stem cell transplant recipients

Lung problems are common in allogeneic stem cell transplant (SCT) recipients. To evaluate the feasibility and diagnostic yield of radiologically guided fine needle lung biopsy (FNLB) in allogeneic SCT recipients with focal pulmonary lesions, a retrospective analysis was carried out. Between 1989 and 1998, radiologists performed a total of 30 FNLBs in 21 allogeneic SCT recipients, guided either by ultrasound (n = 17) or computed tomography (n = 13). The median time from SCT to the first FNLB was 131 days (20-343 days). Prophylactic platelet transfusions were given in 19 procedures (66%). The complications of FNLB included clinically insignificant pneumothorax in four procedures (13%) and self-limiting haemoptysis in one case (3%). The first FNLB was suggestive of invasive pulmonary aspergillosis (IPA) in five patients (24%). Additional clinically useful findings of FNLB included Pseudomonas (two patients) and Nocardia (one patient). The final diagnosis of pulmonary lesions was IPA in 14 patients, immunological lung problems in four patients and other in three patients. Radiologically guided FNLB is feasible in allogeneic SCT recipients and has a low complication rate. The diagnostic yield is high especially for IPA.

Morbidity and mortality of open lung biopsy in children

OBJECTIVE

In patients with diffuse pulmonary infiltrates, when empiric therapy or less-invasive diagnostic procedures fail, physicians frequently resort to open lung biopsy (OLB) to provide a definite diagnosis and to help redirect therapeutic treatment. OLB is still widely regarded as a safe diagnostic procedure, even in the critically ill child. The objective of this study is to evaluate the accuracy of this view with regard to children with acute respiratory failure (ARF) and, for this purpose, compares the mortality and morbidity of such patients with those without ARF.

DESIGN

Retrospective chart review.

SETTING

University hospital.

PATIENTS

Forty-two patients (mean age, 6.6 years) underwent 47 OLBs for undiagnosed diffuse pulmonary infiltrates between July 1984 and December 1994. Twenty-six patients (55%) were in ARF. Fifteen of these patients were intubated and receiving mechanical ventilatory support before the OLB procedure.

RESULTS

The overall incidence of serious complications associated with the OLB procedure was 51%. Of the patients with ARF, 17 (65%) had at least one major complication compared with 3 (14%) of the patients without ARF. Pleural air complications (62% of the total) occurred only in patients with ARF: pneumothoraces and/or prolonged air leaks developed in 10 (38%) after their OLBs; 9 of these patients died, and 7 had pneumothorax complicating their chest tube removal, which required replacement chest tubes. All patients with ARF preoperatively required prolonged ventilatory support after the OLB procedure, whereas 90% of the patients without ARF could be extubated within 24 hours. Overall, 10 patients (24%) died after the OLB procedure. All deaths occurred in patients with ARF. Both ARF preoperatively and the presence of postoperative complications were significantly associated with decreased survival.

CONCLUSIONS

The morbidity and mortality rates of children with ARF undergoing OLB for diffuse pulmonary infiltrates differ considerably from those of children without ARF. For children with ARF, OLB is associated with the risk of prolonged ventilatory support, recurrent pneumothoraces, and air leaks. These complications may be attributable to such patients' having diseased lungs with poor healing. Moreover, these complications may, in turn, contribute to the patients' poor outcomes.

Open lung biopsy in pediatric patients on extracorporeal membrane oxygenation

Open lung biopsy has proven beneficial in the treatment of life-threatening pulmonary diseases. Its safety and efficacy in infants and children placed on extracorporeal membrane oxygenation (ECMO) for severe respiratory failure is not known. The authors reviewed eight cases (4 neonates, 3 infants, 1 child) who underwent open lung biopsy while on ECMO. The primary diagnoses were pneumonia (4), lymphoma (1), primary pulmonary hypertension (1), and complex congenital heart disease (2). The patients underwent biopsy after they had been on ECMO an average of 9.6 days (range, 1 to 14 days). Biopsy results confirmed the clinical diagnosis in five patients, two of whom had irreversible alveolar destruction resulting in ECMO withdrawal. Three patients had pathological diagnoses, which resulted in major therapy revisions (1 fungal infection and 2 noninfectious lesions that required steroid treatment). The overall average duration of ECMO treatment was 16.3 days (range, 10 to 24 days). Three patients were weaned successfully from ECMO, but only one infant survived to discharge. One nonlethal bleeding complication occurred after biopsy. Open lung biopsy is well tolerated during ECMO. It accurately determines pulmonary pathology and provides valuable prognostic information. Earlier biopsy for patients whose diagnoses are uncertain or who are not responding to ECMO may improve the mortality rate for this high-risk group.

Open lung biopsy provides a higher and more specific diagnostic yield compared to broncho-alveolar lavage in immunocompromised patients. Fungal Study Group

In order to examine the feasibility and safety of undertaking a larger prospective study to compare the diagnostic yield from concurrent open lung biopsy (OLB) and bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) in febrile neutropenic patients with pulmonary infiltrates and the impact of such knowledge on clinical outcome, a pilot exploratory study was performed. 13 immunocompromised patients (mainly with haematological malignancy or bone marrow transplantation recipients) were investigated. At least one diagnostic finding in 12 of 13 patients was provided by OLB compared to 4 of 13 patients by BAL. BAL provided 7 specific diagnoses (pneumocystis 1, fungal infection 3, bacterial pneumonia 1, pulmonary haemorrhage 2) whilst OLB provided 12 specific diagnosis (CMV 2, pneumocystis 3, fungal infection 1, bacterial pneumonia 1, pulmonary haemorrhage 4, pulmonary embolism 1). Five patients with nonspecific interstitial/alveolar inflammation were diagnosed only by OLB. The concordance that the exact same specific diagnoses present in the OLB were found in the BAL was zero. There were 2 minor complications (1 wound infection by OLB, 1 moderate haemorrhage by BAL). Mortality at 28 days was 8 of 13 patients which in no case was related to either procedure. We suggest that OLB is a safe procedure in such patients, provides superior and more complete diagnostic information compared to BAL and a larger controlled study to investigate the impact of early OLB on the outcome of these patients appears to be justified.