Processes underlying treatment success and failure in assertive community treatment

A Qualitative Evaluation of an Adapted Assertive Community Treatment Program: Perspectives During COVID-19

The Pinellas County Empowerment Team (PCET) was an adapted assertive community treatment (ACT) program created to meet the needs of Pinellas County residents with serious behavioral health concerns and high frequency of hospitalization (medical and psychiatric) and incarceration. Recent research demonstrates that individuals participating in ACT programs can transition to lower-intensity services. To understand the needs and barriers in transitioning PCET clients to lower-intensity services and the unique experiences during the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, the researchers conducted a qualitative evaluation which includes a case record review and in-depth interviews with clients of PCET and staff members. Our findings indicated several barriers to transitioning PCET clients, including a lack of sufficient behavioral health support outside the ACT program and some clients' concerns regarding their abilities once out of the program.

Evaluation of new flexible and integrative psychiatric treatment models in Germany- assessment and preliminary validation of specific program components

BACKGROUND

Flexible and integrative treatment (FIT) models are rather novel in German mental health care. This study aimed at identifying and evaluating empirically based, practicable, and quantifiable program components that describe the specific treatment structures and processes of German FIT models.

METHODS

A multi-step, iterative research process, based on Grounded Theory Methodology (GTM), was used to identify and operationalise components. A complex algorithm and expert-interviews were applied to quantify the relative weight of each component and to develop a sum score. Face and content validity were examined and internal consistency was tested by Cronbach's α coefficient.

RESULTS

Ten of eleven FIT components could be operationalised, quantified and united in the total score. All operationalised components showed sufficient face and content validity and eight components had a good reliability.

CONCLUSIONS

The components are a first step in the process of operationally defining German FIT models. They considerably overlap with various critical ingredients of international FIT models and may serve as a theoretical basis for constructing fidelity tools and research guides to enable process and outcome evaluation of German FIT models.