Nephrogenic rest associated with a mesoblastic nephroma--what does it tell us?

The effect of vitamin A deficiency in maternal rats on tumor formation in filial rats

PURPOSE

We established a vitamin A-deficient (VAD) model of pregnant rats to evaluate the effect of vitamin A deficiency in maternal rats on tumor formation in filial rats.

METHODS

Ten pregnant Wistar rats were divided into 2 groups: (1) VAD group, 6 rats were given nonvitamin A diet from 2 weeks before mating till delivery and (2) normal diet (ND) group, 4 rats were given normal diet. Twenty random neonatal rats from each group were killed on the next day of delivery. The rest neonates were given normal diet for 1 year until killed. Serum levels of vitamin A, morphology of the kidney, incidence of tumor formation, and retinoid X receptor (RXR) alpha messenger RNA (mRNA) expression in renal tissue were assessed for the filial rats.

RESULTS

Fifty-six and 49 neonatal rats were born for VAD group and ND group, respectively. The detection rate of nephrogenic rests (NRs) from neonates in VAD group (50%) was significantly higher than that in ND group (20%; P < .05). The incidence of nephroblastoma was 13.9% in filial rats of VAD group and 0% for ND group. The detection rate of NRs for filial rats of VAD group (30.6%) was significantly higher than that of ND group (6.9%; P < .01). The expression of RXRalpha mRNA in tumor tissue of the filial rats of VAD group (3.17 +/- 0.15) was significantly lower than that in kidney tissue of ND group (3.58 +/- 0.20; P < .01).

CONCLUSION

Deficiency in vitamin A for pregnant rats resulted in renal dysplasia, increased NRs, and higher incidence of nephroblastoma.

Clinicopathologic features of nephrogenic rests and nephroblastomatosis

Nephrogenic rests are the consequence of residual metanephric tissue in a fully developed kidney. They usually occur along the perimeter of a mature renal lobe (i.e., perilobar), within the lobe itself (i.e., intralobar), or both (i.e., combined). Nephrogenic rests can be grossly obvious or microscopically discrete. Nephroblastomatosis designates nephrogenic rests that are multifocal or diffuse, and implies more extensive disease. Universal (panlobar) nephroblastomatosis denotes complete replacement of the renal lobe by nephrogenic tissue. The fate of nephrogenic rests and nephroblastomatosis varies and includes obsolescence, sclerosis, dormancy, hyperplasia, or neoplasia. Evidence strongly suggests that neoplastic transformation of nephrogenic rests results in Wilms' tumor (nephroblastoma). Nephrogenic rests almost always occur in the setting of Wilms' tumor; perilobar rests show a strong association with synchronous bilateral Wilms' tumors, whereas intralobar rests are more strongly associated with metachronous tumors. Genetic studies have shown that nephrogenic rests often share many of the same chromosomal defects as Wilms' tumor, which provides further evidence that they are precursors to nephroblastoma. Thus, nephrogenic rests are recognized as clinically significant entities requiring adequate detection and close surveillance. Heightened awareness regarding the clinical relevance of nephrogenic rests and nephroblastomatosis (1) has led to improved detection of these precancerous lesions, (2) fostered more intensive investigation into their biologic behavior, and (3) initiated in-depth discussions about potentially new treatment regimens. The pathologists' ability to identify and detect nephrogenic rests has benefited from the more efficient Beckwith classification. Radiologists have deployed high-resolution radiologic/imaging modalities to improve detection of nephrogenic rests in situ. Clinicians and surgeons are more aware of the impact that nephrogenic rests have upon patient management. Despite this progress, more data is needed to further define these lesions.

Wilms' tumor and related abnormalities in the fetus and newborn

Mesoblastic nephroma, a benign tumor, is the most common renal neoplasm in neonates. Wilms' tumor (WT) may occur in newborn infants, but is more common in older children. The molecular genetics of WT involves one or more genes located on Chromosome #11 and probably other locations not yet elicidated. Germline mutations cause less than 5% of WTs; most WTs are sporadic. Precursor lesions to WT called nephrogenic rests may be detected before evolution to WT by imaging studies. Developmental anomalies comprising several different syndromes are associated with nephrogenic rests and predisposition to WT. Prospective surveillance for WT may be feasible in high risk infants identified on the basis of physical findings followed by testing for predisposing gene defects and periodic imaging of the kidneys and other organs at risk until the period of risk has ended.

Microdissecting the genetic events in nephrogenic rests and Wilms' tumor development

Nephrogenic rests are precursor lesions associated with about 40% of Wilms' tumors. This study identifies genetic steps occurring in the development of Wilms' tumor. Thirty-four Wilms' tumors with nephrogenic rests and/or areas of anaplasia were microdissected from paraffin sections to determine whether and at what stage loss of heterozygosity (LOH) occurred, using polymerase chain reaction-based polymorphic markers at 11p13, 11p15, and 16q. LOH at these loci have been identified in Wilms' tumors and are associated with identified or putative tumor suppressor genes. Three cystic nephromas/cystic partially differentiated nephroblastomas were also examined. LOH was detected in six cases at 11p13 and in six cases at 11p15, and two of these cases had LOH at both loci. All intralobar rests showing LOH also showed LOH in the tumor. A case with a small perilobar rest showed LOH of 11p13 only in the tumor. Five cases showing LOH at 16q were identified (this was identified only in the tumor, and not in the associated rest), and three of these had recurrence of the tumor. Two cases had a WT1 mutation (one germline and the other somatic), as well as LOH in both the intralobar rest and the tumor. A cystic partially differentiated nephroblastoma showed loss at 11p13 and 11p15, as well as at 16q. This study suggests that LOH at 11p13 and 11p15 and WT1 mutations are early events but that LOH at 16q occurs late in the pathogenesis of Wilms' tumor. Intralobar and perilobar nephrogenic rests are known to have different biological behaviors, and this study suggests that they are genetically different. A multistep model of Wilms' tumor pathogenesis is supported by these findings.