Wear and loosening of the hip prosthesis. A roentgen stereophotogrammetric 3-year study of 14 cases

Hip prosthetic loosening: A very personal review

Hip prosthetic loosening is often difficult to detect at an early stage, and there has been uncertainty for a long time as to when the loosening occurs and thus to the basic causes. By comparing different diagnostic methods, we found that loosening is best defined as prosthetic migration and measured by radiostereometric analysis. Convincing evidence indicates that poor interlock, poor bone quality, and resorption of a necrotic bone bed may initiate loosening during or shortly after surgery; this forms the basis of the theory of early loosening. Biomechanical factors do affect the subsequent progression of loosening, which may increase subclinically during a long period of time. Eventually, the loosening may be detected on standard radiographs and may be interpreted as late loosening but should to be interpreted as late detection of loosening. The theory of early loosening explains the rapid early migration, the development of periprosthetic osteolysis and granulomas, the causality between wear and loosening, and largely the epidemiology of clinical failure of hip prostheses. Aspects discussed are definition of loosening, the pattern of early migration, the choice of migration threshold, the current understanding of loosening, a less exothermic bone cement, cemented taper-slip stems, a new exciting computed tomography-based technique for simpler implant migration studies, and research suggestions.

Revision of Metal-on-metal Hip Arthroplasty with Well Fixed and Positioned Acetabular Component Using a Dual-mobility Head and Review of Literature

Background:

As a consequence of use of metal-on-metal hip arthroplasties some patients have precised revision for pain or metal hipersensivity reactions among other causes. We propose to salvage monoblock acetabular component and femoral component using a dual-mobility head and perform a lower morbidity operation in young patients preserving host bone stock in cases with well fixed and positioned components.

Objective:

(1) What clinical problems have been reported in patients with Metal-on-metal hip arthroplasties? (2) Could the tribocorrosion potentially cause a fracture of neck femoral component? (3) Can be the dual-mobility head a recourse in metal-on-metal hip revision?

Methods:

Ten patients were revised for pain or/and raised Cobalt/Chromium levels between August 2012 and December 2015. In three cases femoral neck component was fractured and femoral revision was necessary. In four hips, acetabular and femoral components could be maintained. Age, body index mass, ion levels, acetabular position, size of acetabular component and femoral head, approach, blood transfunsion and time of hospitalization were analized.

Results:

At a mean follow-up of 25,6 months (6 to 45) the mean postoperative HHS was 92. It was not statistically significant because several patients were low sintomatic before surgery, but had raised Cobalt/Chromium levels in the blood. All patients had near-normal levels of Cobalt/Chromium during the first 6 months after revision surgery. No relevant complications were reported.

Conclusion:

The use of dual-mobility head can be an acceptable option to revise metal-on-metal arthroplasties correctly oriented with abscence of loosening or infection signs and keeping bone stock in young patients.

Dual mobility hip arthroplasty wear measurement: Experimental accuracy assessment using radiostereometric analysis (RSA)

INTRODUCTION

The use of dual mobility cups is an effective method to prevent dislocations. However, the specific design of these implants can raise the suspicion of increased wear and subsequent periprosthetic osteolysis.

HYPOTHESIS

Using radiostereometric analysis (RSA), migration of the femoral head inside the cup of a dual mobility implant can be defined to apprehend polyethylene wear rate.

STUDY OBJECTIVES

The study aimed to establish the precision of RSA measurement of femoral head migration in the cup of a dual mobility implant, and its intra- and interobserver variability.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total hip prosthesis phantom was implanted and placed under weight loading conditions in a simulator. Model-based RSA measurement of implant penetration involved specially machined polyethylene liners with increasing concentric wear (no wear, then 0.25, 0.5 and 0.75mm). Three examiners, blinded to the level of wear, analyzed (10 times) the radiostereometric films of the four liners. There was one experienced, one trained, and one inexperienced examiner. Statistical analysis measured the accuracy, precision, and intra- and interobserver variability by calculating Root Mean Square Error (RMSE), Concordance Correlation Coefficient (CCC), Intra Class correlation Coefficient (ICC), and Bland-Altman plots.

RESULTS

Our protocol, that used a simple geometric model rather than the manufacturer's CAD files, showed precision of 0.072mm and accuracy of 0.034mm, comparable with machining tolerances with low variability. Correlation between wear measurement and true value was excellent with a CCC of 0.9772. Intraobserver reproducibility was very good with an ICC of 0.9856, 0.9883 and 0.9842, respectively for examiners 1, 2 and 3. Interobserver reproducibility was excellent with a CCC of 0.9818 between examiners 2 and 1, and 0.9713 between examiners 3 and 1.

DISCUSSION

Quantification of wear is indispensable for the surveillance of dual mobility implants. This in vitro study validates our measurement method. Our results, and comparison with other studies using different measurement technologies (RSA, standard radiographs, Martell method) make model-based RSA the reference method for measuring the wear of total hip prostheses in vivo.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level 3. Prospective diagnostic study.

Corrosion degradation and prevention by surface modification of biometallic materials

Metals, in addition to ceramics and polymers, are important class of materials considered for replacement of non-functional parts in the body. Stainless steel 316, titanium and titanium alloys, Co-Cr, and nitinol shape memory alloys are the most frequently used metallic materials. These alloys are prone to corrosion in various extents. This review briefly discusses the important biomaterials, their properties, and the physiological environment to which these materials are exposed. Corrosion performance of currently used metallic materials has been assessed and threat to the biocompatibility from corrosion products/metal ions is discussed. The possible preventive measures to improve corrosion resistance by surface modification and to increase the bioactivity of the metallic surfaces have also been discussed. Importance of the formation of oxide layers on the metal surface, another aspect of corrosion process, has been correlated with the host response. The gap areas and future direction of research are also outlined in the paper.

Total hip replacement with a zirconium oxide ceramic femoral head: a randomised roentgen stereophotogrammetric study

We investigated the wear characteristics and clinical performance of four different total hip joint articulations in 114 patients. Wear and migration was measured by roentgenstereophotogrammetric analysis at five years or at the last follow-up. The mean annual wear was 0.11 mm for a stainless steel/Enduron articulation, 0.34 mm for stainless steel/Hylamer cup, 0.17 mm for zirconium oxide ceramic/Enduron and 0.40 mm for zirconium oxide ceramic/Hylamer. The difference between the groups was significant (p < 0.008) except for stainless steel/Hylamer vs zirconium oxide ceramic/Hylamer (p = 0.26). At present, 12 patients have undergone a revision procedure, four at five years and eight thereafter. No patient who received a stainless steel/Enduron articulation at their primary replacement required revision. Conflicting results have been reported about the performance of the zirconium oxide ceramic femoral head, but our findings suggest that it should not be used with a polymethylmethacrylate acetabular component. Hylamer has already been withdrawn from the market.

Accuracy of radiographic and radiostereometric wear measurement of different hip prostheses: an experimental study

BACKGROUND

In vivo measurement of wear in the ball and socket articulation of total hip arthroplasties is of interest in the evaluation of both existing and new implants. Controversy reigns regarding the accuracy of different radiological measurement techniques and in particular how accuracy has been assessed.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We assessed the accuracy of 2 radiostereometric (RSA) techniques for wear measurement and 3 standard radiographic techniques, namely Imagika (image analyzing software), Imagika corrected for head center displacement, and the Charnley Duo method. 5 custom-made adjustable phantoms with different prosthetic components were used.

RESULTS

In 20 measurements of all 5 phantoms at 3 levels of simulated wear (0.2 mm, 1.0 mm and 1.5 mm), the mean measurement error of the digital RSA examinations was 0.010 mm (accuracy 0.42). The corresponding error values for the three radiographic techniques were 0.19 (accuracy 1.3) for Charnley Duo, 0.13 (accuracy 1.3) for Imagika corrected, and 1.021 (accuracy 2.99) for Imagika. Measurement error decreased from 0.011 mm with ordinary RSA to 0.004 with RSA digital measurement. Head size, direction of wear in relation to the cup or type of prosthetic component did not influence the measurement error. The results of Charnley Duo and Imagika corrected were similar but the latter had an inexplicable systematic error in measuring one of the phantoms. Imagika had the worst results due to its inability to compensate for the out-of-head center effect. Alumina heads were difficult to analyze with all methods.

INTERPRETATION

By using the ISO standard for assessing accuracy, RSA can be expected to measure wear with an accuracy of about 0.4 mm irrespective of prosthetic component studied or direction of wear, whereas the best technique, in our study, based on standard radiographs can be accurate to about 1.3 mm.

Evaluation of contemporary software methods used to quantify polyethylene wear after total hip arthroplasty

BACKGROUND

Radiographic measurements of the wear of total hip arthroplasty implants are indirect measurements based on radiographic determinations of the location of the femoral head relative to the acetabular component. Using the simplest case of zero wear, we assessed the reproducibility and accuracy of two software applications designed to quantify wear from clinical radiographs.

METHODS

After a cobalt-chromium head was glued into the polyethylene liner of a titanium shell, one cross-table lateral radiograph and three anteroposterior pelvic radiographs were made for twelve permutations of acetabular component angulation. The three anteroposterior radiographs differed only with regard to the cephalocaudal positioning of the prosthesis relative to the x-ray tube. To assess method reproducibility, each anteroposterior radiograph was assumed to be both the initial and the latest follow-up radiograph of a wear analysis. To assess method accuracy, each anteroposterior radiograph was paired in a wear analysis with each of the two anteroposterior radiographs made when the component was in the same angulation but at a different cephalocaudal position relative to the tube (one radiograph was the initial follow-up radiograph while the second was the latest follow-up radiograph). The analyses of reproducibility and accuracy were performed both with and without inclusion of the lateral radiograph made with the component in the same angulation.

RESULTS

Both methods fared well in the reproducibility analyses, with mean linear and volumetric wear values of 0.00 to 0.07 mm and 0 to 24 mm(3), respectively. In the accuracy analyses, the mean linear and volumetric wear values derived with the two methods were 0.26 to 0.40 mm and 78 to 126 mm(3), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Whereas the results of the reproducibility analyses showed that the methods were consistent in determining the relative positions of the head and shell from a given anteroposterior radiograph or pair of anteroposterior and lateral radiographs, the non-zero wear results obtained in the accuracy analyses proved that these positional determinations were often inaccurate. Thus, while contemporary software methods may yield reproducible results, their accuracy is limited by their inability to correctly determine the position of the head relative to the acetabular component.

Highly cross-linked polyethylene in cemented THA: randomized study of 61 hips

Highly cross-linked polyethylene (PE) has been introduced as an alternative bearing material in total hip arthroplasty (THA) because of high wear resistance in laboratory tests but the clinical experience of this material is limited. We evaluated a highly cross-linked PE (warm irradiated adiabatic melting, absorbed dose, 95 kGy) in a randomized study of cemented THAs. Cups of the same design but made of conventionally gamma irradiated PE (absorbed dose, 25-40 kGy) constituted the control group. Sixty-one hips (30 women, 30 men) with a median age of 55 years (range, 35-70 years) were included. All patients received a Spectron stem with 28-mm CoCr head. Radiostereometric examinations with the patient supine or standing were done at regular intervals. Wear was measured with the patient in the supine position from the first postoperative week, whereas examinations done with the patient standing were initiated 3 months after the operation. Dual x-ray absorptiometry and conventional radiography were used to evaluate the bone mineral density and the radiolucencies around the acetabular component. Fifty-two patients (53 hips; 25 highly cross-linked, 28 control) have been followed up for 2 years. At the 2-year followup, the highly cross-linked cups showed 50% reduction of proximal wear compared with the control group, when the patients were studied standing. When evaluated supine, the difference in proximal wear did not reach significance. The migration of the socket, the relative changes of periprosthetic bone mineral density, and the progression of radiolucencies between the immediately postoperative followup and 2-year followup did not differ. Highly cross-linked PE showed increase resistance to wear. Different mechanical properties of the two types of PE studied did not alter the performance of the cup in terms of fixation, periprosthetic bone loss, and radiographic appearance. However, the followup is short and these results are preliminary.

Polyethylene wear in total hip and knee arthroplasties

The role that ultrahigh molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) wear at bearing surfaces in total hip and knee arthroplasties plays in the clinical life of these implants cannot be overemphasized. This subject has therefore been attracting enormous research attention on both fundamental and technological levels. Given this, it is important to detail the main features of the knowledge base and describe research directions that may culminate in the production of new and/or improved varieties of UHMWPE material and components. These aspects are the subject of the present review.

Wear rates of ceramic-on-ceramic bearing surfaces in total hip implants: a 12-year follow-up study

A retrospective clinical and radiographic analysis was performed on 58 patients (60 hips; mean age at time of surgery, 45.2 years) at a minimum of 10-year follow-up (mean, 12.7 years) after total hip replacement using a ceramic-on-ceramic hearing total hip implant (Autophor, Smith and Nephew, Memphis, TN). Mean wear rate at final follow-up was 0.21 mim, averaging 0.016 mm/y. There were no cases of periprosthetic osteolysis in the acetabuulum or femur. For the unrevised components, there were 3 (5%) cases of protrusio acetabuli and 4 (7%) cases of acetabular component loosening. On the femoral side, 78.3% had distal pedestal formation, and 83% had greater than 2 mm implant-bone radiolucencies in more than 5 Gruen zones as a result of gross motion of the stem. Despite radiographic evidence of implant loosening, this hard bearing articulation functioned well in vivo for more than 12 years with remarkably low wear--approximately one tenth the rate reported for metal-on-polyethylene total hip bearings.

Migration, particles, and fluid pressure. A discussion of causes of prosthetic loosening

Distal migration of the femoral component of a total hip replacement by as little as 0.33 mm during the first 6 postoperative months is predictive of the need for revision many years later. Because the fate of the prostheses is defined so early, it is unlikely that wear particles initiate loosening. However, the progression from the stage of early migration to clinical loosening has unknown causes, of which particles may be one. Slight instability associated with migration will lead to locally high fluid pressures surrounding the migrating prosthesis. Recent experiments applied a moderate fluid pressure to an implant to bone interface. This induced osteocyte death near the implant and subsequent bone resorption. Thus, there is evidence that fluid pressure and ensuing flow could be a main cause of not only pain, but also osteolysis necessitating revision.

Socket wear in ceramic-on-polyethylene total hip arthroplasties: fixed versus rotating heads

We measured radiographically the polyethylene socket wear in 34 hip prostheses with a 32 mm Al2O3-ceramic head with a rotating bearing and in 37 prostheses with a "fixed" ceramic head. The mean follow-up was 12 years in both groups. The mean annual linear wear of the polyethylene was 0.034 and 0.069 mm, respectively, (Mann-Whitney U-test p < 0.0001) in the "rotation" and the "fixed" group. A rotating bearing between the head and neck in a modular total hip system seems to reduce socket wear as compared to fixed taper junctions.

Measurement accuracy in acetabular cup wear. Three retrospective methods compared with Roentgen stereophotogrammetry

The accuracy of three methods (the simple and noncomputerized Scheier-Sandel and Charnley-Duo methods and the computerized Ein Bild Roentgen Analyse [EBRA] method) for retrospective wear measurements of the acetabular cup from standard pelvis radiographs was studied. Measurements on 13 hip prostheses were compared with those obtained by roentgen stereophotogrammetry analysis. The Scheier-Sandel method had the lowest accuracy and the EBRA method had the best accuracy. The Charnley-Duo method was almost as good when starting analysis 3 months after surgery and is easier to use. The EBRA method is useful for accurate measurements on a small number of patients; the Charnley-Duo method is recommended for clinical wear studies on a larger number of patients.

Osteolysis, wear and failure of a migrating acetabular component. A roentgen stereophotogram case report

The migration of an acetabular component, revised 12 years postoperatively, was clearly detectable within the first year after operation by roentgen stereophotogram analysis. The failure was probably the result of an early initiated prosthetic loosening.

Theories of wear and loosening in hip prostheses. Wear-induced loosening vs loosening-induced wear--a review

The observation of perioprosthetic granulomas containing wear debris around apparently well-fixed as well as around loose-fitting prosthetic components has led to the development of the hypothesis of wear-induced loosening. However, the hypothesis of wear-induced loosening can neither explain the rapid early prosthetic migration detected by roentgen stereophotogrammetry nor the epidemiology of clinical failure without supplementary ad hoc-assumptions. By contrast, apart from explaining the rapid early prosthetic migration detected by roentgen stereophotogrammetry, the theory of early loosening can explain the development of wear granulomas as well as to a great extent the epidemiology of clinical failure.

Reproducible radiographs of acetabular prostheses. A method assessed in 35 patients

35 patients with a smooth, threaded acetabular Mecron type prosthesis were examined with the aid of a table top with wiremarkers and a fixed 30-degree wedge to allow for reproducible positioning. Under fluoroscopic control, pelvic and spot films were made. The inter- and intraobserver variability of anteversion and inclination angle measurements of the prostheses had a standard deviation of less than 1 degree. The method can be applied to other acetabular prostheses as well.

Metal backing improves the survival of surface replacement of the hip

Nineteen patients with juvenile chronic arthritis underwent 29 resurfacing hip arthroplasties. In 22 the original all-plastic Wagner acetabular component was used and in 7 the metal-backed Wagner-Tillmann component. After a mean of 11 (range 8-13) years 19 of the Wagner acetabular components had been revised and another 2 showed radiographic loosening. After a mean of 7 (range 5-9) years no metal-backed acetabular cup had been revised and only 1 was definitely loose.

Fixation and loosening of hip prostheses. A review

Studies using roentgen stereophotogrammetry and bone scintigraphy support a narrow definition of prosthetic fixation (viz., nonmigration), and consequently a broad definition of loosening. Roentgen stereophotogrammetric research indicates that if loosening occurs, it is initiated at an early stage; insufficient initial fixation or loss of fixation by resorption of a layer of heat-injured bone may cause prosthetic instability and progressive bone resorption. Migration of one or both prosthetic components can be revealed by roentgen stereophotogrammetry in many asymptomatic hips during the first postoperative year--some of these components will probably fail in the future. The femoral component is exposed to greater shear stresses than the acetabular component, and it is uncertain whether fixation of the femoral component can be achieved more than occasionally without the use of bone cement.