Intraoperative evoked potentials recorded in man directly from dorsal roots and spinal cord

Dorsal root entry zone procedure and other surgeries for pain

Pain is a very common symptom that often serves a protective function. It is typically treated medically. When pain becomes chronic and intractable, it no longer serves a protective function and often requires more aggressive forms of treatment. Many types of surgeries can be performed for the management of pain. These surgeries can involve ablation (destruction) or augmentation (stimulation or facilitation) of some part of the nervous system. In many of these surgeries, neurophysiologic intraoperative monitoring (NIOM) is not needed, however, in others neuromonitoring serves a mapping and monitoring purpose. The prototype of pain surgery for this chapter is the dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) procedure. Both mapping and monitoring can help improve lesioning precision and outcomes in this surgery. In this chapter, the DREZ procedures and other surgeries for primarily pain relief in which NIOM is used are discussed. Surgeries, such as spinal stenosis, in which pain relief is important but not the sole purpose, are not discussed here and are covered elsewhere.

Dorsal root entry zone lesion, midline myelotomy and anterolateral cordotomy

This review encompasses the most common spinal cord lesioning procedures used for the treatment of pain: dorsal root entry zone lesioning, open cordotomy, percutaneous cordotomy, and midline myelotomy. A literature review and summary of each technique regarding relevant anatomy, patient selection, surgical technique, outcomes, and complications are discussed. A general review of somatic and visceral pain pathways of the spinal cord is included, as each procedure requires an understanding of the advantages and disadvantages of various approaches to lesioning the spinal cord for pain. Neurosurgical education of these rarely used procedures needs to be included in residency and fellowship training.

A novel method for making dorsal horn lesions

OBJECTIVE

Dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) lesioning for intractable pain currently requires a multi-level laminectomy for direct access to all spinal cord segments intended to be lesioned. The hypothesis is that a silastic rubber catheter can be inserted into the dorsal horn (through a single laminectomy site) and advanced down several spinal cord segments, while staying exclusively in the dorsal horn.

METHODS

A cervical laminectomy was performed in four sheep. Standard cerebrospinal fluid drainage catheters were introduced into the dorsal horn through a small incision in the DREZ. The catheters were advanced caudally along the longitudinal cord axis for a distance of 8-11 cm. Neurophysiological monitoring was done. The cord was excised from the spinal canal, fixed in formalin and cut in serial axial slices at 1 cm intervals to assess the position of the catheter within the spinal cord.

RESULTS

The catheter stayed within the grey column of the spinal cord dorsal horn, along the entire length of its insertion. Electrophysiological data confirmed that dorsal horn activity was totally ablated after catheter passage in three sheep, and partially ablated in the fourth.

CONCLUSION

The intrinsic architecture of the spinal cord tissue allows the predictable passage of the catheter through the column of dorsal horn grey matter. Dorsal horn lesioning can be accomplished without direct access to the cord segments selected for surgery.

Dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) localization using direct spinal cord stimulation can improve results of the DREZ thermocoagulation procedure for intractable pain relief

The dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) thermocoagulation for intractable pain after brachial plexus avulsion was performed in 21 patients. Good results in pain relief (relief of more than 75% of preoperative pain) were achieved in 62% of patients, whereby fair results (relief of 25-75% of preoperative pain) in 38% of patients. There was no patient with poor result (relief of less than 25% of preoperative pain). Complication rate was 14%. The whole patient population was subdivided into two groups (Group 1 and Group 2). Direct spinal cord bipolar stimulation and registration with the goal to localize DREZ was performed in the Group 2 consisting of 12 patients (n=12). The point on the spinal cord surface where no response after stimulus of low intensity was obtained was the site (the posterolateral sulcus) we identified as the most suitable point for the placement of radiofrequency thermocoagulation electrode. Comparing with the Group 1 consisting of nine patients (n=9), where the localization of DREZ by evoked potentials was not performed, significantly better effect of pain relief was recorded (P<0.05, odds ratio 10). There was no statistically significant difference (P>0.7) in complication rate in Group 1 and Group 2. Described electrophysiological technique is very helpful in identifying of DREZ and, in combination with microsurgical technique, can create DREZ thermocoagulation more effective.

Radiofrequency procedures in chronic pain

Radiofrequency current is simply a tool used for creating discrete thermal lesions in neural pathways in order to interrupt transmission. In pain medicine, radiofrequency lesions have been used to interrupt nociceptive pathways at various sites. This is a palliative treatment not without complications, so its use should be limited to those patients with cancer pain or chronic non-cancer pain for whom conservative non-surgical therapies have been ineffective or intolerable. With the development of alternatives such as intrathecal opioid infusion and neuromodulation technologies, the number of patients considered for neuroablative therapy may dwindle. Nevertheless, there is evidence that radiofrequency neurotomy has an important role in the management of trigeminal neuralgia, nerve root avulsion and spinal pain. In this chapter the evidence for efficacy and safety is reviewed and interrogated with special emphasis on the available randomized controlled trails and systematic review.

Dorsal root entry zone localization using direct spinal cord stimulation: an experimental study

Direct spinal cord stimulation and recording was performed in five dogs to identify the dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) and long tracts within the dorsal and dorsolateral spinal cord using electrophysiological mapping techniques. Intrathecal recordings were obtained from sites distal to the site of stimulation. Conduction velocity in the fastest conducting fibers was higher following low-intensity stimulation of the dorsolateral spinal cord than after dorsal spinal cord stimulation. The evoked response was larger following dorsolateral than dorsal spinal cord stimulation at a specific stimulus intensity. This technique is useful in identifying the DREZ using electrophysiological criteria alone.

Cervical and scalp recorded short latency somatosensory evoked potentials in response to epidural spinal cord stimulation in patients with peripheral vascular disease

Somatosensory evoked potential (SEP) studies were performed in 14 patients with peripheral vascular disease who received epidural spinal cord stimulation (SCS) for chronic pain relief of the lower limbs. Signals were amplified and filtered between 20-2000 Hz and 200-2000 Hz to better identify activities in the high frequency range. In 7 patients bit-colour maps were also computed. In all the patients a homogeneous short-latency scalp evoked potential with a prevalent diphasic shape (P1-N1) was recorded. In all our scalp records, even with the wide bandpass, small short-latency positive deflections were observed on the descending front of the first major positive wave and they were better defined as a series of up to 6 wavelets, preceding the major negative scalp wave in the tracings filtered through the narrow bandpass. They appeared in an interval ranging from 5.5 to 15.6 msec. Bit-colour maps showed consistent positive fields, with a maximum at the vertex, starting mainly at about 5.5 msec; in 3 patients, a prominent positivity between 8.5 and 10.5 msec was recorded followed by smaller components preceding the major positive-negative (P1-N1) complex. More synchronous volleys during direct SCS produced clear short-latency SEPs. Although they were of larger amplitude, we regarded them as corresponding to those described by previous authors obtained by stimulation of nerves of the lower limbs, and probably arising from subcortical structures.

[Evoked potentials by median nerve stimulation (SSEP): subcortical components]

Este estudo constitui uma revisão de literatura realizada com a finalidade de se relacionar a designação, as características dos campos de potencial e os geradores implicados, para os componentes subcorticais do potencial evocado somatossensorial por estimulação do nervo mediano no punho.

Effects of dorsal root entry zone lesion on spinal cord potentials evoked by segmental, ascending and descending volleys

The spinal cord potentials (SCPs) were recorded from the dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) and posterior epidural space in patients before and after dorsal root entry zone lesion (DREZL) during general anaesthesia. The SCPs from the DREZ activated by segmental, ascending and descending volleys were basically the same in fundamental waveform as those recorded from the posterior epidural space. Segmentally activated slow negative (N1) wave, reflecting synchronized activities of dorsal horn neurones, and positive (P2) wave, thought to indicate primary afferent depolarization, were affected by DREZL in all 4 subjects tested, even by contralateral stimulation, suggesting that these components of the segmental SCPs in man partly reflect the activities of the contralateral dorsal horn. The spike-like potentials activated by ascending volleys were not affected by DREZL, while the subsequent slow components were decreased in the lesioned level. This may indicate that ascending spinal cord tracts are not affected by the operation, and suggests that the origin of the slow components by ascending volleys lies at least in part in the segmental dorsal horn. The slow negative and positive components, recorded at a remote segment from DREZL, in response to the descending volleys, were augmented after DREZL, suggesting that activation of ascending or descending inhibition through a feedback loop via the supraspinal structures might occur at least transiently following DREZL. All components of the SCPs activated by descending volleys were decreased or disappeared in recording from the lesioned level, as expected. Thus, intra-operative recording of the SCPs during DREZL might be beneficial for monitoring and studying human spinal cord function.

The human cervical and lumbo-sacral evoked electrospinogram. Data from intra-operative spinal cord surface recordings

We have undertaken the analysis of the human 'evoked electrospinogram' during intra-dural surgical explorations in 20 patients. Averaged spinal cord surface evoked potentials to peripheral nerve electrical stimulation were obtained from various restricted loci on the pial surface of the cervical and lumbo-sacral spinal cord. The brachial plexus P9 potential and its lumbo-sacral counterpart P17 were recorded as ubiquitous initial far-field positivities. The pre-synaptic compound action potentials N11 and N21 dwelt on the ascending slope of N13 and N24 respectively. They were composed of 1-5 sharp peaks and collected from the dorsal and dorso-lateral positions mainly, on the cervical and lumbo-sacral cord respectively. They are thought to be generated in the proximal portion of the dorsal root, the dorsal funiculus and the afferent collaterals to the dorsal horn. Compound action potentials could also be gathered from the surface of the dorsal roots, the cervical N10 and lumbo-sacral N19 potentials. The large cervical N13 and lumbo-sacral N24 waves originate from a dorso-ventral post-synaptic dipole, generated in deep laminae of the dorsal horn during the activation of large diameter afferent fibers. These waves were maximal on the main entry cord segments of the stimulated nerves and fell off on the 1-4 more rostral and caudal segments. The N2 wave is the dorsal component of another post-synaptic dorso-ventral dipole generated in deep laminae of the dorsal horn but activated by medium diameter afferent fibers. The latest event was the N3 wave, also possibly part of a dorso-ventral post-synaptic dipole, and generated by cells in the dorsalmost and deep dorsal horn laminae during the activation of small diameter afferent fibers. The P wave was a prolonged positive deflection which carried the N2 and N3 waves. It is the manifestation of pre-synaptic inhibition on primary afferent fibers. A supra-segmental ascending spinal cord volley was also described, composed of a long succession of sharp and low voltage peaks.

Somatosensory function following dorsal root entry zone lesions in patients with neurogenic pain or spasticity

The goal of this study was to assess the effects of the dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) lesioning procedure, microsurgical DREZ-otomy (MDT), on spinal cord somatosensory function based on peri- and intraoperative clinical and electrophysiological data. The study was performed prospectively on a series of 20 patients suffering from either chronic neurogenic pain or spasticity. Physiological observations were made of the intraoperative evoked electrospinographic recordings as collected from the surface of the spinal cord. The MDT procedure produced analgesia or severe hypalgesia, moderate hypesthesia, and only slight deficits in proprioception and cutaneous spatial discrimination on the body segments operated on. These clinical data correlated well with evoked electrospinographic recordings, which showed a moderate effect of MDT on presynaptic compound action potentials recorded from the spinal cord (N11 and N21), a partial or even reversible effect on the cortical postcentral N20 wave, a more marked effect on the postsynaptic dorsal horn waves N13 and N24 related to large primary afferent fibers, and a disappearance of dorsal horn waves related to finer afferents (N2 and possibly N3). These data provide evidence for an acceptably selective action of MDT on spinal cord nociceptive mechanisms, and for a partial, often slight, involvement of the other somatosensory domains. The presence of abnormal evoked electrospinographic waves is discussed in relation to the mechanisms of neurogenic pain and spasticity. The hypothesis of a "retuning" of the dorsal horn as the mode of action of MDT is presented.

Distribution of lumbar spinal evoked potentials and their correlation with stimulation-induced paresthesiae

In 7 awake patients with neuropathic lower extremity pain, spinal somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP) were elicited from the non-painful leg by electrical stimulation of the peroneal nerve and mechanical stimulation of the hallux ball. Recording was made epidurally in the thoraco-lumbar region by means of an electrode temporarily inserted for trial of pain-suppressing stimulation. In response to peroneal nerve stimulation, two major SEP complexes were found. The first complex consisted, as has been described earlier, of an initial positivity (P12), a spike-like negativity (N14), a slow negativity (N16) and a slow positivity (P23). The second complex consisted of a slow biphasic wave, conceivably mediated by a supraspinal loop. Both complexes had a similar longitudinal distribution with amplitude maxima at the T12 vertebral body. The SEP evoked by mechanical hallux ball stimulation had a relatively small amplitude, and there was no significant second complex. The relationship between stimulus intensity and SEP amplitude was negatively accelerating. The longitudinal distribution of spinal SEP was compared with the somatotopic distribution of paresthesiae induced by stimulation through the epidural electrode. It was found that stimulation applied at the level of maximal SEP generally induced paresthesiae in the corresponding peripheral region. Therefore, spinal SEP may be used as a guide for optimal positioning of a spinal electrode for therapeutic stimulation when implanted under general anesthesia. An attempt was made to record the antidromic potential in the peroneal nerve elicited from the dorsal columns by epidural stimulation. The antidromic response was, however, very sensitive to minimal changes of stimulus strength and body position of the patient, and was also contaminated by simultaneously evoked muscular reflex potentials. Thus, peripheral responses evoked by epidural stimulation appeared too unreliable to be useful for the permanent implantation of a spinal electrode for therapeutic stimulation.

Epidurally recorded cervical spinal activity evoked by electrical and mechanical stimulation in pain patients

Spinal SEPs to electrical and mechanical stimulation of the upper limb of the non-painful side in 7 pain patients were recorded from the cervical epidural space. In response to electrical stimulation of the median nerve, the longitudinal distribution of the spinal postsynaptic negativity (N13) along the cord had a distinct level of maximal amplitude at the C5 vertebral body. When recorded at increasing distances cranial or caudal to this level, the latency of N13 was successively prolonged, in agreement with a spread-out near-field generator in the dorsal horn. Similar patterns of distribution and levels of maximal amplitude were demonstrated for the N13 wave evoked by electrical stimulation of the ulnar and thumb nerves as well as by mechanical stimulation of the thumb ball. The amplitude ratios of the N13 waves evoked by electrical stimulation of the median nerve and the thumb nerves, and by mechanical stimulation of the thumb ball were 3.9 to 1.4 to 1. The slow positive wave (P18), which has been assumed to represent recurrent presynaptic activity, had a somewhat different distribution, with a lower maximal amplitude and a less marked falling off in amplitude along the cord, as compared to the N13 component. The initial presynaptic positivity (P10) appeared with an almost constant amplitude along the cord. Tactile stimuli produced responses with considerably longer latency and duration than those obtained with electrical stimulation. There seemed to be a non-linear relationship between the amplitude of the response and the depth of skin indentation. The presented data contribute a more detailed picture of epidurally recorded spinal SEPs than previous studies. They will serve as a reference for further analysis of SEPs evoked by stimulation of the affected side in pain patients, to explore whether the painful state is associated with altered SEPs before or after therapeutic intervention.

Three transverse dipolar generators in the human cervical and lumbo-sacral dorsal horn: evidence from direct intraoperative recordings on the spinal cord surface

In the context of the intraoperative study of spinal cord surface evoked potentials in patients operated upon for chronic pain and spasticity, we have undertaken an analysis of the dipolar dorso-ventral organization of surface spinal cord evoked potentials in man. Averaged evoked potentials to peripheral nerve electrical stimulations were obtained from the dorsal and ventral pial surface of the cervical and lumbo-sacral spinal cord (7 pairs from 5 patients), using a small silver ball macroelectrode, positioned during open neurosurgical approaches. We found that the dorsally recorded N13 and N24 waves reversed into ventral P13 and P24 waves respectively. A second negative potential, N2, and a late prolonged positivity, P, similarly reversed into a P2 and an N wave respectively. Our data add up to a collection of skin, oesophageal, epidural, pial and intramedullary recordings in man and animals to provide the evidence for a transverse dipolar organization of the human postsynaptic N13, N24 and N2 potentials, originating from deep layers of the cord dorsal horn, and for a similar organization of the P wave, which has been shown to correlate with presynaptic inhibition on primary afferent fibres.

Subpial spinal evoked potentials in patients undergoing junctional dorsal root entry zone coagulation for pain relief

Seven patients with complete avulsion of the brachial plexus underwent junctional coagulation lesions of the dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) for relief of intractable pain in the paralyzed arm. Intra-operative monitoring by recording spinal cord somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP) resulting from tibial nerve stimulation was done using subpial recording electrodes situated dorsal to the posterior median sulcus at the C4 and T2 segment. SEP on the normal side showed an initial positive wave and two negative waves followed by a group of high frequency waves of relatively high amplitude which continued into high frequency, low amplitude potentials. The conduction velocity of the fastest spinal evoked potential components were, on average, 86 m/s. Recordings from the side of avulsion revealed a steep positive potential of high amplitude which appeared in five patients prior to the creation of the DREZ lesion. This effect was assumed to be secondary to spinal cord damage caused by avulsion. During the DREZ coagulation the SEP from the unaffected side did not change. On the side of DREZ coagulation the velocity of the fastest fibres decreased. Four patients reported sensory deficits after the operation, which were transient in three. In one of these patients, the first two negative potentials disappeared. In the fourth patient, who had permanent sensory deficits, the positive steep potential appeared after generation of the lesion. Our results point to the usefulness of the subpial SEPs monitoring during microneuro-surgical procedures on the spinal cord to provide further insight into evoked electrical activity of the normal and injured spinal cord, and to minimize post-operative neurological morbidity.

Intra-operative spinal cord evoked potentials during cervical and lumbo-sacral microsurgical DREZ-tomy (MDT) for chronic pain and spasticity (preliminary data)

We have undertaken the intra-operative study of spinal cord surface evoked potentials in patients operated upon for pain and/or spasticity using the microsurgical DREZ-tomy (MDT) procedure. The goals of this work were 1) to collect data on spinal cord evoked potential components and 2) to analyze the effects of MDT on spinal cord physiology. The MDT consists of a therapeutic lesion in the ventro-lateral aspect of the dorsal root entry zone, directed to the activatory circuitry, and aiming at returning the dorsal horn physiology towards inhibition. Averaged evoked potentials to peripheral nerve electrical stimulations were obtained from various loci on the surface of the dorsal columns of the cervical and lumbo-sacral spinal cord in 19 patients, using a small uninsulated silver ball electrode. An initial far-field positivity was found, corresponding to a compound action potential in the proximal part of the brachial (or lumbo-sacral) plexus. Pre-synaptic compound action potentials were identified, most often composed of multiple successive sharp peaks. A post-synaptic field potential generated in the dorsal horn was recognized. The MDT caused an immediate and irreversible decrease of amplitude down to a disappearance of the dorsal horn potential. This decrement was proportional to the amount of operated cord segments. In contrast, there has been a relative post-MDT sparing of the pre-synaptic action potentials originating from the operated cord segments, and the scalp contralateral parietal N 20 has been only reversibly affected by the therapeutic lesion. We thus argue for a specific involvement of dorsal horn physiology by the MDT, with a relative sparing of the dorsal column system.

Lumbosacral evoked potentials (LSEPs) and cortical somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) in patients with lesions of the conus medullaris and cauda equina

Evoked potentials from unilateral stimulation of the posterior tibial nerve at the knee were recorded over the spinous processes S1, L4, L2, T12 and from the 'lower extremity' portion of the sensory cortex (Cz) in 29 patients who exhibited clinical and electromyographic signs of conus medullaris or cauda equina lesions. Simultaneous recording of the lumbosacral evoked potentials (LSEPs) and cortical somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) permitted evaluation of the relative effectiveness of the peripheral stimulus in eliciting responses in the lumbosacral segments of the spinal cord and in the cortex of the brain. In patients with cauda equina lesion, each major component of LSEP can be absent or the peak can have a reduced amplitude and a prolonged latency. The degree of impairment of the LSEP runs in parallel to the degree of severeness of the cauda equina lesion. The recording of LSEP responses with surface electrodes represents a reliable test for the detection of mild cauda equina abnormalities, but the surface recording technique is not sensitive enough to differentiate between severe incomplete and severe complete cauda equina lesions. On the other hand, concurrent recording of responses evoked at lumbosacral and cortical levels by the same stimuli did detect instances in which the first-order afferents were capable of delivering an adequate volley of impulses to evoke a sizeable cortical response without evidence of an associated postsynaptic response in the spinal cord. Such findings are good evidence of a problem localized in the gray matter of the spinal cord.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Motor and somatosensory evoked potentials recorded from the rat

An accurate neurophysiological technique that is able to monitor both the sensory and motor tracts of the spinal cord is required to assess patients with injury or other lesions of the cord, and for the evaluation of experimental studies of cord injury. We have recorded and characterized the motor and somatosensory evoked potentials (MEPs and SSEPs) from 20 normal rats and from 16 rats with cord lesions. MEPs were elicited by applying constant current anodal stimuli to the sensorimotor cortex (SMC) with the responses recorded from microelectrodes in the spinal cord at T10 (MEP-C) and from a bipolar electrode placed on the contralateral sciatic nerve (MEP-N). SSEPs were elicited by stimulating the sciatic nerve and were recorded from the cord at T10 and the contralateral SMC. The MEP-C consisted of an initial D wave (mean latency 1.21 +/- 0.12 msec and 4 subsequent I waves, 11-14). The D wave was elicited at stimulation frequencies exceeding 100 Hz. The initial positive wave of the MEP-N (mean latency 3.09 +/- 0.19 msec) was followed by several slower components which were attenuated by repetition rates exceeding 8.2 Hz. The grand mean SSEP consisted of 7 peaks. Sectioning of the dorsal columns abolished the SSEP but spared the MEP. Complete cord transection abolished both the MEP and SSEP. These experiments demonstrate that the combined recording of MEPs and SSEPs is an accurate and easily performed method of monitoring the functional integrity of the rat cord, and suggest that this technique would be of value in patients, especially those undergoing operative treatment of spinal lesions.

Neural generators of the somatosensory evoked potentials: recording from the cuneate nucleus in man and monkeys

The neural generators of the somatosensory evoked potentials (SEPs) elicited by electrical stimulation of the median nerve were studied in man and in rhesus monkeys. Recordings from the cuneate nucleus were compared to the far-field potentials recorded from electrodes placed on the scalp. It was found that the shape of the response from the surface of the human cuneate nucleus to stimulation of the median nerve is similar to that of the response recorded more caudally in the dorsal column, i.e., an initially small positivity followed by a negative wave that is in turn followed by a slow positive wave. The beginning of the negative wave coincides in time with the N14 peak in the SEP recorded from the scalp, and its latency is 13 msec. The response from the cuneate nucleus in the rhesus monkey has a similar shape and its negative peak appears with the same latency as the positive peak in the vertex response that has a latency of 4.5 msec; the peak negativity has a latency of about 6 msec and thus coincides with P6.2 in the vertex recording. Depth recordings from the cuneate nucleus and antidromic stimulation of the dorsal column fibers in the monkey provide evidence that the early components of the response from the surface of the cuneate nucleus are generated by the dorsal column fibers that terminate in the nucleus. The results support the hypothesis that the P14 peak in the human SEP is generated by the termination of the dorsal column fibers and that the cuneate nucleus itself contributes little to the far-field potentials.