Dynamic bowtie for fan-beam CT

Design Optimization of Spatial-Spectral Filters for Cone-Beam CT Material Decomposition

Spectral CT has shown promise for high-sensitivity quantitative imaging and material decomposition. This work presents a new device called a spatial-spectral filter (SSF) which consists of a tiled array of filter materials positioned near the x-ray source that is used to modulate the spectral shape of the x-ray beam. The filter is moved to obtain projection data that is sparse in each spectral channel. To process this sparse data, we employ a one-step direct model-based material decomposition (MBMD) to reconstruct basis material density images directly from the SSF CT data. To evaluate different possible SSF designs, we define a new Fisher-information-based predictive image quality metric called separability index which characterizes the ability of a spectral CT system to distinguish between the signals from two or more materials. This spectral CT performance metric can be used to optimize spectral CT system design. We conducted simulation-based design optimization study to find optimized combinations of filter materials, filter thicknesses, filter widths, and source settings. Finally, we present MBMD results using simulated SSF CT measurements from the optimized designs to demonstrate the ability to reconstruct basis material density images and to show the benefits of the optimized designs. Our results indicate that optimizing SSF CT for separability leads to high-performance at material discrimination tasks.

On the potential of ROI imaging in x-ray CT - A comparison of novel dynamic beam attenuators with current technology

PURPOSE

In this work, we explore the potential of region-of-interest (ROI) imaging in x-ray computed tomography (CT). Using two dynamic beam attenuator (DBA) concepts for fluence field modulation (FFM) previously developed, we investigate and evaluate the potential dose savings in comparison with current FFM technology.

METHODS

ROI imaging is a special application of FFM where the bulk of x-ray radiation is propagated toward a certain anatomical target (ROI), specified by the imaging task, while the surrounding tissue is spared from radiation. We introduce a criterion suitable to quantitatively describe the balance between image quality inside an ROI and total radiation dose with respect to a given ROI imaging task. It accounts for the mean image variance at the ROI and the effective patient dose calculated from Monte Carlo simulations. The criterion is further used to compile task-specific DBA trajectories determining the primary x-ray fluence, and eventually used for comparing different FFM techniques, namely the sheet-based dynamic beam attenuator (sbDBA), the z-aligned sbDBA (z-sbDBA), and an adjustable static operation mode of the z-sbDBA. Furthermore, two static bowtie filters and the influence of tube current modulation (TCM) are included in the comparison.

RESULTS

Our findings demonstrate by simulations that the presented trajectory optimization method determines reasonable DBA trajectories. The influence of TCM is strongly depending on the imaging task. The narrow bowtie filter allows for dose reductions of about 10% compared to the regular bowtie filter in the considered ROI imaging tasks. The DBAs are shown to realize substantially larger dose reductions. In our cardiac imaging scenario, the DBAs can reduce the effective dose by about 30% (z-sbDBA) or 60% (sbDBA). We can further verify that the noise characteristics are not adversely affected by the DBAs.

CONCLUSION

Our research demonstrates that ROI imaging using the presented DBA concepts is a promising technique toward a more patient- and task-specific CT imaging requiring lower radiation dose. Both the sbDBA and the z-sbDBA are potential technical solutions for realizing ROI imaging in x-ray CT.

The z-sbDBA, a new concept for a dynamic sheet-based fluence field modulator in x-ray CT

PURPOSE

We present a new concept for dynamic fluence field modulation (FFM) in x-ray computed tomography (CT). The so-called z-aligned sheet-based dynamic beam attenuator (z-sbDBA) is developed to dynamically compensate variations in patient attenuation across the fan beam and the projection angle. The goal is to enhance image quality and to reduce patient radiation dose.

METHODS

The z-sbDBA consists of an array of attenuation sheets aligned along the z direction. In neutral position, the array is focused toward the focal spot. Tilting the z-sbDBA defocuses the sheets, thus reducing the transmission for larger fan beam angles. The structure of the z-sbDBA significantly differs from the previous sheet-based dynamic beam attenuator (sbDBA) in two features: (a) The sheets of the z-sbDBA are aligned parallel to the detector rows, and (b) the height of the sheets increases from the center toward larger fan beam angles. We built a motor actuated prototype of the z-sbDBA integrated into a clinical CT scanner. In experiments, we investigated its feasibility for FFM. We compared the z-sbDBA to common CT bowtie filters in terms of the spectral dependency of the transmission and possible image variance distribution in reconstructed phantom images. Additionally, the potential radiation dose saving using z-sbDBA for region-of-interest (ROI) imaging was studied.

RESULTS

Our experimental results confirm that the z-sbDBA can realize variable transmission profiles of the radiation fluence by only small tilts. Compared to the sbDBA, the z-sbDBA can mitigate some practical and mechanical issues. In comparison to bowtie filters, the spectral dependency is considerably reduced when using the z-sbDBA. Likewise, more homogeneous image variance distributions can be attained in reconstructed phantom images. The z-sbDBA allows controlling the spatial image variance distribution which makes it suitable for ROI imaging. Our comparison on ROI imaging reveals skin dose reductions of up to 35% at equal ROI image quality by using the z-sbDBA.

CONCLUSION

Our new concept for FFM in x-ray CT, the z-sbDBA, was experimentally validated on a clinical CT scanner. It facilitates dynamic FFM by realizing variable transmission profiles across the fan beam angle on a projection-wise basis. This key feature allows for substantial improvements in image quality, a reduction in patient radiation dose, and additionally provides a technical solution for ROI imaging.

Fluid-filled dynamic bowtie filter: Description and comparison with other modulators

PURPOSE

A dynamic bowtie filter can modulate flux along both fan and view angles for reduced patient dose, scatter, and required photon flux, which is especially important for photon counting detectors (PCDs). Among the proposed dynamic bowtie designs, the piecewise-linear attenuator (Hsieh and Pelc, Med Phys. 2013;40:031910) offers more flexibility than conventional filters, but relies on analog positioning of a limited number of wedges. In this work, we study our previously proposed dynamic attenuator design, the fluid-filled dynamic bowtie filter (FDBF) that has digital control. Specifically, we use computer simulations to study fluence modulation, reconstructed image noise, and radiation dose and to compare it to other attenuators. FDBF is an array of small channels each of which, if it can be filled with dense fluid or emptied quickly, has a binary effect on the flux. The cumulative attenuation from each channel along the x-ray path contributes to the FDBF total attenuation.

METHODS

An algorithm is proposed for selecting which FDBF channels should be filled. Two optimization metrics are considered: minimizing the maximum-count-rate for PCDs and minimizing peak-variance for energy-integrating detectors (EIDs) at fixed radiation dose (for optimizing dose efficiency). Using simulated chest, abdomen, and shoulder data, the performance is compared with a conventional bowtie and a piecewise-linear attenuator. For minimizing peak-variance, a perfect-attenuator (hypothetical filter capable of adjusting the fluence of each ray individually) and flat-variance attenuator are also included in the comparison. Two possible fluids, solutions of zinc bromide and gadolinium chloride, were tested.

RESULTS

To obtain the same SNR as routine clinical protocols, the proposed FDBF reduces the maximum-count-rate (across projection data, averaged over the test objects) of PCDs to 1.2 Mcps/mm² , which is 55.8 and 3.3 times lower than the max-count-rate of the conventional bowtie and the piecewise-linear bowtie, respectively. (Averaged across objects for FDBF, the max-count-rate without object and FDBF is 2063.5 Mcps/mm² , and the max-count-rate with object without FDBF is 749.8 Mcps/mm² .) Moreover, for the peak-variance analysis, the FDBF can reduce entrance-energy-fluence (sum of energy incident on objects, used as a surrogate for dose) to 34% of the entrance-energy-fluence from the conventional filter on average while achieving the same peak noise level. Its entrance-energy-fluence reduction performance is only 7% worse than the perfect-attenuator on average and is 13% better than the piecewise-linear filter for chest and shoulder. Furthermore, the noise-map in reconstructed image domain from the FDBF is more uniform than the piecewise-linear filter, with 3 times less variation across the object. For the dose reduction task, the zinc bromide solution performed slightly poorer than stainless steel but was better than the gadolinium chloride solution.

CONCLUSIONS

The FDBF allows finer control over flux distribution compared to piecewise-linear and conventional bowtie filters. It can reduce the required maximum-count-rate for PCDs to a level achievable by current detector designs and offers a high dose reduction factor.

Task-Driven Optimization of Fluence Field and Regularization for Model-Based Iterative Reconstruction in Computed Tomography

This paper presents a joint optimization of dynamic fluence field modulation (FFM) and regularization in quadratic penalized-likelihood reconstruction that maximizes a task-based imaging performance metric. We adopted a task-driven imaging framework for prospective designs of the imaging parameters. A maxi-min objective function was adopted to maximize the minimum detectability index ( ) throughout the image. The optimization algorithm alternates between FFM (represented by low-dimensional basis functions) and local regularization (including the regularization strength and directional penalty weights). The task-driven approach was compared with three FFM strategies commonly proposed for FBP reconstruction (as well as a task-driven TCM strategy) for a discrimination task in an abdomen phantom. The task-driven FFM assigned more fluence to less attenuating anteroposterior views and yielded approximately constant fluence behind the object. The optimal regularization was almost uniform throughout image. Furthermore, the task-driven FFM strategy redistribute fluence across detector elements in order to prescribe more fluence to the more attenuating central region of the phantom. Compared with all strategies, the task-driven FFM strategy not only improved minimum by at least 17.8%, but yielded higher over a large area inside the object. The optimal FFM was highly dependent on the amount of regularization, indicating the importance of a joint optimization. Sample reconstructions of simulated data generally support the performance estimates based on computed . The improvements in detectability show the potential of the task-driven imaging framework to improve imaging performance at a fixed dose, or, equivalently, to provide a similar level of performance at reduced dose.

A dynamic attenuator improves spectral imaging with energy-discriminating, photon counting detectors

Energy-discriminating, photon counting (EDPC) detectors have high potential in spectral imaging applications but exhibit degraded performance when the incident count rate approaches or exceeds the characteristic count rate of the detector. In order to reduce the requirements on the detector, we explore the strategy of modulating the X-ray flux field using a recently proposed dynamic, piecewise-linear attenuator. A previous paper studied this modulation for photon counting detectors but did not explore the impact on spectral applications. In this work, we modeled detection with a bipolar triangular pulse shape (Taguchi et al., 2011) and estimated the Cramer-Rao lower bound (CRLB) of the variance of material selective and equivalent monoenergetic images, assuming deterministic errors at high flux could be corrected. We compared different materials for the dynamic attenuator and found that rare earth elements, such as erbium, outperformed previously proposed materials such as iron in spectral imaging. The redistribution of flux reduces the variance or dose, consistent with previous studies on benefits with conventional detectors. Numerical simulations based on DICOM datasets were used to assess the impact of the dynamic attenuator for detectors with several different characteristic count rates. The dynamic attenuator reduced the peak incident count rate by a factor of 4 in the thorax and 44 in the pelvis, and a 10 Mcps/mm (2) EDPC detector with dynamic attenuator provided generally superior image quality to a 100 Mcps/mm (2) detector with reference bowtie filter for the same dose. The improvement is more pronounced in the material images.

Control algorithms for dynamic attenuators

PURPOSE

The authors describe algorithms to control dynamic attenuators in CT and compare their performance using simulated scans. Dynamic attenuators are prepatient beam shaping filters that modulate the distribution of x-ray fluence incident on the patient on a view-by-view basis. These attenuators can reduce dose while improving key image quality metrics such as peak or mean variance. In each view, the attenuator presents several degrees of freedom which may be individually adjusted. The total number of degrees of freedom across all views is very large, making many optimization techniques impractical. The authors develop a theory for optimally controlling these attenuators. Special attention is paid to a theoretically perfect attenuator which controls the fluence for each ray individually, but the authors also investigate and compare three other, practical attenuator designs which have been previously proposed: the piecewise-linear attenuator, the translating attenuator, and the double wedge attenuator.

METHODS

The authors pose and solve the optimization problems of minimizing the mean and peak variance subject to a fixed dose limit. For a perfect attenuator and mean variance minimization, this problem can be solved in simple, closed form. For other attenuator designs, the problem can be decomposed into separate problems for each view to greatly reduce the computational complexity. Peak variance minimization can be approximately solved using iterated, weighted mean variance (WMV) minimization. Also, the authors develop heuristics for the perfect and piecewise-linear attenuators which do not require a priori knowledge of the patient anatomy. The authors compare these control algorithms on different types of dynamic attenuators using simulated raw data from forward projected DICOM files of a thorax and an abdomen.

RESULTS

The translating and double wedge attenuators reduce dose by an average of 30% relative to current techniques (bowtie filter with tube current modulation) without increasing peak variance. The 15-element piecewise-linear dynamic attenuator reduces dose by an average of 42%, and the perfect attenuator reduces dose by an average of 50%. Improvements in peak variance are several times larger than improvements in mean variance. Heuristic control eliminates the need for a prescan. For the piecewise-linear attenuator, the cost of heuristic control is an increase in dose of 9%. The proposed iterated WMV minimization produces results that are within a few percent of the true solution.

CONCLUSIONS

Dynamic attenuators show potential for significant dose reduction. A wide class of dynamic attenuators can be accurately controlled using the described methods.

Dynamic bowtie filter for cone-beam/multi-slice CT

A pre-patient attenuator ("bowtie filter" or "bowtie") is used to modulate an incoming x-ray beam as a function of the angle of the x-ray with respect to a patient to balance the photon flux on a detector array. While the current dynamic bowtie design is focused on fan-beam geometry, in this study we propose a methodology for dynamic bowtie design in multi-slice/cone-beam geometry. The proposed 3D dynamic bowtie is an extension of the 2D prior art. The 3D bowtie consists of a highly attenuating bowtie (HB) filled in with heavy liquid and a weakly attenuating bowtie (WB) immersed in the liquid of the HB. The HB targets a balanced flux distribution on a detector array when no object is in the field of view (FOV). The WB compensates for an object in the FOV, and hence is a scaled-down version of the object. The WB is rotated and translated in synchrony with the source rotation and patient translation so that the overall flux balance is maintained on the detector array. First, the mathematical models of different scanning modes are established for an elliptical water phantom. Then, a numerical simulation study is performed to compare the performance of the scanning modes in the cases of the water phantom and a patient cross-section without any bowtie and with a dynamic bowtie. The dynamic bowtie can equalize the numbers of detected photons in the case of the water phantom. In practical cases, the dynamic bowtie can effectively reduce the dynamic range of detected signals inside the FOV. Furthermore, the WB can be individualized using a 3D printing technique as the gold standard. We have extended the dynamic bowtie concept from 2D to 3D by using highly attenuating liquid and moving a scale-reduced negative copy of an object being scanned. Our methodology can be applied to reduce radiation dose and facilitate photon-counting detection.