A novel index to evaluate ineffective erythropoiesis in hematological diseases offers insights into sickle cell disease

Cellular and biochemical heterogeneity contributes to the phenotypic diversity of transfusion-dependent β-thalassemia

ABSTRACT

Transfusion-dependent thalassemia (TDT) is a type of protein aggregation disease. Its clinical heterogeneity imposes challenges in effective management. Red blood cell (RBC) variables may be clinically relevant as mechanistic parts or tellers of TDT pathophysiology. This is a cross-sectional study of RBC and plasma physiology in adult patients with TDT vs healthy control. TDT plasma was characterized by increased protein carbonylation, antioxidants, and larger than normal extracellular vesicles. RBCs were osmotically resistant but prone to oxidative hemolysis. They overexposed phosphatidylserine and exhibited pathologically low proteasome proteolytic activity (PPA), which correlated with metabolic markers of the disease. RBC ultrastructure was distorted, with splenectomy-related membrane pits of 300 to 800 nm. Plasma metabolomics revealed differences in heme metabolism, redox potential, short-chain fatty acids, and nitric oxide bioavailability, but also in catecholamine pathways. According to coefficient of variation assessment, hemolysis, iron homeostasis, PPA, and phosphatidylserine exposure were highly variable among patients, as opposed to RBC fragility and plasma antioxidants, amino acids, and catecholamines. Sex-based differences were detected in hemolysis, redox, and energy variables, whereas splenectomy-related differences referred to thrombotic risk, RBC morphology, and plasma metabolites with neuroendocrine activity. Hepcidin varied according to oxidative hemolysis and metabolic markers of bacterial activity. Patients with higher pretransfusion hemoglobin levels (>10 g/dL) presented mildly distorted profiles and lower membrane-associated PPA, whereas classification by severity of mutations revealed different levels of hemostasis, inflammation, plasma epinephrine, hexosamines, and methyltransferase activity markers. The currently reported heterogeneity of cellular and biochemical features probably contributes to the wide phenotypic diversity of TDT at clinical level.

Gene-environmental influence of space and microgravity on red blood cells with sickle cell disease

A fundamental question in human biology and for hematological disease is how do complex gene-environment interactions lead to individual disease outcome? This is no less the case for sickle cell disease (SCD), a monogenic disorder of Mendelian inheritance, both clinical course, severity, and treatment response, is variable amongst affected individuals. New insight and discovery often lie between the intersection of seemingly disparate disciplines. Recently, opportunities for space medicine have flourished and have offered a new paradigm for study. Two recent Nature papers have shown that hemolysis and oxidative stress play key mechanistic roles in erythrocyte pathogenesis during spaceflight. This paper reviews existing genetic and environmental modifiers of the sickle cell disease phenotype. It reviews evidence for erythrocyte pathology in microgravity environments and demonstrates why this may be relevant for the unique gene-environment interaction of the SCD phenotype. It also introduces the hematology and scientific community to methodological tools for evaluation in space and microgravity research. The increasing understanding of space biology may yield insight into gene-environment influences and new treatment paradigms in SCD and other hematological disease phenotypes.

Molecular and cellular effects of in vivo chronic intravascular hemolysis and anti-inflammatory therapeutic approaches

Intravascular hemolysis (IVH) occurs in numerous inherited and acquired disorders, including sickle cell disease (SCD), malaria and sepsis. These diseases display unique symptoms, but often share complications, such as vasomotor dysfunction and pulmonary hypertension. Consequently, in vivo models are needed to study the effects of continuous intravascular hemolytic processes, independently of the molecular or extrinsic alteration that leads to erythrocyte destruction. We gave twice-weekly low-dose phenylhydrazine (LDPHZ) to C57BL/6 J mice for 4 weeks, and measured parameters indicative of anemia, hemoglobin-clearance pathways, inflammation and iron turnover, comparing these to those of a murine model of SCD, which displays associated IVH. LDPHZ administration provoked discreet anemia in mice and significant reticulocytosis, in association with hemoglobin/heme-clearance pathway protein depletion. Mice subjected to chronic hemolysis displayed elevated leukocyte counts and plasma levels of interleukin (IL)-1β, TNF-α, IL-6, soluble ICAM-1, endothelin-1 and anti-inflammatory IL-10, closely emulating alterations indicative of systemic inflammatory and endothelial activation in SCD, and confirming chronic IVH in itself as a serious complication. Discreet accelerations in hepatic and splenic iron turnover also occurred in LDPHZ mice, without alterations in liver damage markers. Examining the effects of two therapies on hemolysis-induced inflammation, the administration of hydroxyurea (and to a lesser extent, l-glutamine) significantly abrogated hemolytic inflammation in mice, without apparent inhibition of hemolysis. In conclusion, the isolation of chronic IVH, a common disease mechanism, using this model, may allow the study of hemolysis-specific sequelae at the cellular and systemic level, and the investigation of candidate agents that could potentially counter hemolytic inflammation.

Emerging drug targets for sickle cell disease: shedding light on new knowledge and advances at the molecular level

INTRODUCTION

In sickle cell disease (SCD), a single amino acid substitution at β6 of the hemoglobin (Hb) chain replaces glutamate with valine, forming HbS instead of the normal adult HbA. Loss of a negative charge, and the conformational change in deoxygenated HbS molecules, enables formation of HbS polymers. These not only distort red cell morphology but also have other profound effects so that this simple etiology belies a complex pathogenesis with multiple complications. Although SCD represents a common severe inherited disorder with life-long consequences, approved treatments remain inadequate. Hydroxyurea is currently the most effective, with a handful of newer treatments, but there remains a real need for novel, efficacious therapies.

AREAS COVERED

This review summarizes important early events in pathogenesis to highlight key targets for novel treatments.

EXPERT OPINION

A thorough understanding of early events in pathogenesis closely associated with the presence of HbS is the logical starting point for identification of new targets rather than concentrating on more downstream effects. We discuss ways of reducing HbS levels, reducing the impact of HbS polymers, and of membrane events perturbing cell function, and suggest using the unique permeability of sickle cells to target drugs specifically into those more severely compromised.

Extramedullary haematopoiesis in patients with transfusion dependent β-thalassaemia (TDT): a systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Around 5% of the world's population is expected to have some degree and type of thalassaemia. Beta thalassaemia (BT) occurs due to a deficient production of the beta-globin chain of haemoglobin. Extramedullary haematopoiesis (EMH) is one of the complications of BT, mainly observed in minor/intermedia subtypes. EMH is the production of blood cells outside the marrow as a compensatory response to longstanding hypoxia. Due to chronic transfusions, it is not expected in patients with beta-thalassaemia major (BTM). However, there are increasingly reported cases of EMH in BTM. The incidence of EMH in BTM is thought to be <1%. We aim to pool the available data and provide cumulative evidence on the occurrence of EMH in BTM patients.

METHODS

This is a systematic review of case reports, series, and retrospective studies that presented data on the occurrence of EMH in BTM patients. Data were recorded and analyzed in Microsoft Excel 2016 and SPSS 26. The protocol has been registered in PROSPERO: CRD42021242943.

RESULTS

Data from 253 cases of EMH in BTM patients were extracted with a mean age of 35.3 years. Mean haemoglobin at presentation with EMH was 8.2 mg/dL. Lower limb weakness was the most common presenting feature (N = 23) (paraspinal EMH). Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was the most widely used diagnostic modality (226). Overall, blood transfusion was the commonest reported treatment (30), followed by radiotherapy (20), surgery (15), hydroxyurea (12), steroids (6), and exchange transfusion (2). An outcome was reported in 20% of patients, all recovered, except one who died as a result of nosocomial infection.

CONCLUSION

EMH is rare in BTM and can occur in any organ system with varied clinical features. MRI can effectively diagnose EMH, and conservative management has similar results compared to invasive treatments. Larger studies, focussing on outcomes may enhance guidelines on preventive and therapeutic strategies for managing EMH in BTM.KEY MESSAGESExtramedullary haematopoiesis is a rare complication in beta thalassaemia. Although it is more common in non-transfusion dependent thalassaemia, increasingly reported cases suggest a higher prevalence of EMH in TDT than what is known before.There are no clear guidelines on the management of EMH in TDT, with reported patients showing similar outcomes with conservative invasive treatment modalities.More extensive and preferably prospectively designed studies are required focussing on the management of EMH and its outcomes in patients with TDT to formulate evidence-based guidelines.

Does Hepcidin Tuning Have a Role among Emerging Treatments for Thalassemia?

The treatments available for thalassemia are rapidly evolving, with major advances made in gene therapy and the modulation of erythropoiesis. The latter includes the therapeutic potential of hepcidin tuning. In thalassemia, hepcidin is significantly depressed, and any rise in hepcidin function has a positive effect on both iron metabolism and erythropoiesis. Synthetic hepcidin and hepcidin mimetics have been developed to the stage of clinical trials. However, they have failed to produce an acceptable efficacy/safety profile. It seems difficult to avoid iron over-restricted erythropoiesis when directly using hepcidin as a drug. Indirect approaches, each one with their advantages and disadvantages, are many and in full development. The ideal approach is to target erythroferrone, the main inhibitor of hepcidin expression, the plasma concentrations of which are greatly increased in iron-loading anemias. Potential means of improving hepcidin function in thalassemia also include acting on TMPRSS6, TfR1, TfR2 or ferroportin, the target of hepcidin. Only having a better understanding of the crosslinks between iron metabolism and erythropoiesis will elucidate the best single option. In the meantime, many potential combinations are currently being explored in preclinical studies. Any long-term clinical study on this approach should include the wide monitoring of functions, as the effects of hepcidin and its modulators are not limited to iron metabolism and erythropoiesis. It is likely that some of the aspects of hepcidin tuning described briefly in this review will play a role in the future treatment of thalassemia.

Precision Medicine and Sickle Cell Disease

Sickle cell disease (SCD) is characterized by variable clinical outcomes, with some patients suffering life-threatening complications during childhood, and others living relatively symptom-free into old age. Because of this variability, there is an important potential role for precision medicine, in which particular different treatments are selected for different groups of patients. However, the application of precision medicine in SCD is limited by difficulties in identifying different prognostic groups and the small number of available treatments. The main genetic determinant of outcomes in SCD is the underlying β-globin genotype, with sickle cell anemia (HbSS) and hemoglobin SC disease (HbSC) forming the 2 major forms of the disease in most populations of African origin. Although there are clear differences in clinical outcomes between these conditions, treatments approaches are very similar, with little evidence on how to treat HbSC in particular. Other genomic information, such as the co-inheritance of α-thalassemia, or high fetal hemoglobin (HbF) levels, is of some prognostic value but insufficient to determine treatments. Precision medicine is further limited by the fact that the 2 main drugs used in SCD, penicillin and hydroxyurea, are currently recommended for all patients. Newer treatments, such as crizanlizumab and voxelotor, raise the possibility that groups will emerge who respond best to particular drugs or combinations. Perhaps the best current example of precision medicine in SCD is the selective use of blood transfusions as primary stroke prevention in children with evidence of cerebral vasculopathy. More precise treatments may emerge as we understand more about the pathology of SCD, including problems with erythropoiesis.