The Growing Medical Need for Tracheal Replacement: Reconstructive Strategies Should Overcome Their Limits

Tracheobronchial Replacement: A Systematic Review

Importance

Tracheobronchial replacement remains a surgical and biological challenge despite several decades of experimental and clinical research.

Objective

To compile a comprehensive state-of-the-science review examining the current indications, techniques, and outcomes of tracheobronchial replacement in human patients.

Evidence Review

A systematic review of the literature was conducted on July 1, 2024, to identify studies examining tracheobronchial replacement. This review was performed according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analyses (PRISMA) reporting guidelines and the PRISMA 2020 statement. We selected the following 3 databases: (1) PubMed via the US National Library of Medicine's PubMed.gov; (2) Embase via Elsevier's Embase.com; and (3) the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTER) via Wiley's Cochrane Library. An additional search was performed using the following clinical trials registers: the World Health Organization's International Clinical Trials Registry Platform and ClinicalTrials.gov, provided by the US National Library of Medicine.

Findings

The initial search produced 6043 results, with a total of 126 publications included in the final review. Only 1 prospective cohort study and 1 registry, both concerning the use of cryopreserved aortic allografts, were identified. Most publications were case reports and series. From July 1, 2002, to July 1, 2024, a total of 137 cases of tracheobronchial replacement were published. Tracheobronchial replacement was indicated for extensive neoplastic tumors (108 cases [78.8%]) or benign stenoses (29 cases [21.2%]). The most common malignancies were thyroid cancers and adenoid cystic carcinomas. The most frequent resections involved the upper half of the trachea, with reconstructions using muscle flaps, or, most notably, cryopreserved aortic allografts, which have shown promising outcomes and have become the most widely used method since 2022. In the only available registry, the 30-day postoperative mortality and morbidity rates were 2.9% and 22.9%, respectively. Long-term follow-up showed that mortality was related to local recurrences and metastases in patients with cancer.

Conclusions and Relevance

This systematic review indicates that extensive malignant lesions are the primary indication for tracheobronchial replacement, with cryopreserved aortic allografts being the only scientifically evaluated surgical technique. Postoperative outcomes were comparable to other major thoracic surgical procedures, while long-term results depended on the underlying disease, especially in cancer cases.

Sustainable Nonwoven Scaffolds Engineered with Recycled Carbon Fiber for Enhanced Biocompatibility and Cell Interaction: From Waste to Health

Carbon fibers, driven by ever-increasing demand, are contributing to a continuous rise in the generation of waste and byproducts destined for landfills or incineration. Recycling carbon fibers presents a promising strategy for reducing carbon emissions and conserving resources, thus contributing to more sustainable waste management practices. Discovering applications of recycled carbon fibers (rCFs) would inevitably accelerate the targeted integration of sustainable materials, fostering a circular economy. Herein, we have engineered rCF-based needlepunched nonwoven scaffolds and their blends with polypropylene (PP) fibers, providing the first example of investigating their interactions with human lung epithelial cells (Calu-3) and murine fibroblast cells (NIH/3T3). To promote the adsorption of extracellular matrix proteins such as laminin, these three-dimensional (3D) nonwoven scaffolds are designed and developed to feature tunable porous characteristics and wetting properties. Although cell adhesion and laminin adsorption are minimal on PP fibers, cells are preferentially organized on the rCFs. These nonwovens, composed exclusively of rCFs or their blends with PP fibers, exhibit no cytotoxic effects, with both cell types showing proliferation on the scaffolds and a progressive increase in cell numbers over time. Cell viability and apoptosis assays are also employed to comprehensively evaluate biocompatibility. Thus, our study proves rCF-based nonwoven scaffolds as potential candidates for artificial lung tissue scaffolds.

The Development of Lung Tissue Engineering: From Biomaterials to Multicellular Systems

The challenge of the treatment of end-stage lung disease poses an urgent clinical demand for lung tissue engineering. Over the past few years, various lung tissue-engineered constructs are developed for lung tissue regeneration and respiratory pathology study. In this review, an overview of recent achievements in the field of lung tissue engineering is proposed. The introduction of lung structure and lung injury are stated briefly at first. After that, the lung tissue-engineered constructs are categorized into three types: acellular, monocellular, and multicellular systems. The different bioengineered constructs included in each system that can be applied to the reconstruction of the trachea, airway epithelium, alveoli, and even whole lung are described in detail, followed by the highlight of relevant representative research. Finally, the challenges and future directions of biomaterials, manufacturing technologies, and cells involved in lung tissue engineering are discussed. Overall, this review can provide referable ideas for the realization of functional lung regeneration and permanent lung substitution.

Establishing Benchmarks for Airway Replacement: Long-Term Outcomes of Tracheal Autografts in a Large Animal Model

OBJECTIVE

Airway replacement is a challenging surgical intervention and remains an unmet clinical need. Due to the risk of airway stenosis, anastomotic separation, poor vascularization, and necrosis, it is necessary to establish the gold-standard outcomes of tracheal replacement. In this study, we use a large animal autograft model to assess long-term outcomes following tracheal replacement.

METHODS

Four New Zealand White rabbits underwent tracheal autograft surgery and were observed for 6 months. Clinical and radiographic surveillance were recorded, and grafts were analyzed histologically and radiographically at endpoint.

RESULTS

All animals survived to the endpoint with minimal respiratory symptoms and normal growth rates. No complications were observed. Computed tomography scans of the post-surgical airway demonstrated graft patency at all time points. Histological sections showed no sign of stenosis or necrosis with preservation of the native structure of the trachea.

CONCLUSION

We established benchmarks for airway replacement. Our findings suggest that a rabbit model of tracheal autograft with direct reimplantation is feasible and does not result in graft stenosis or airway collapse.

Challenges and Opportunities in Developing Tracheal Substitutes for the Recovery of Long-Segment Defects

Tracheal resection and reconstruction procedures are necessary when stenosis, tracheomalacia, tumors, vascular lesions, or tracheal injury cause a tracheal blockage. Replacement with a tracheal substitute is often recommended when the trauma exceeds 50% of the total length of the trachea in adults and 30% in children. Recently, tissue engineering and other advanced techniques have shown promise in fabricating biocompatible tracheal substitutes with physical, morphological, biomechanical, and biological characteristics similar to native trachea. Different polymers and biometals are explored. Even with limited success with tissue-engineered grafts in clinical settings, complete healing of tracheal defects remains a substantial challenge due to low mechanical strength and durability of the graft materials, inadequate re-epithelialization and vascularization, and restenosis. This review has covered a range of reconstructive and regenerative techniques, design criteria, the use of bioprostheses and synthetic grafts for the recovery of tracheal defects, as well as the traditional and cutting-edge methods of their fabrication, surface modification for increased immuno- or biocompatibility, and associated challenges.

Promoting successful healing of artificial trachea by intratracheal administration of basic fibroblast growth factor†

OBJECTIVES

This study evaluated the effect of intratracheal administration of basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF) on tracheal healing following implantation of a novel layered polyglycolic acid (PGA) material to replace a critical-size defect in rat trachea.

METHODS

A critical-size defect in the rat cervical trachea was covered with PGA. Distilled water (DW) or 3.125, 6.25, 12.5 or 25 µg bFGF was administered into the trachea for 2 weeks (n = 6 for each of 5 groups). Regenerated areas of cilia, ciliary beat frequency and ciliary transport function (CTF) in the centre of the PGA were measured. To examine potential side effects of intratracheal administration of bFGF, the right lower lobe was pathologically evaluated.

RESULTS

All rats survived during the study period. Histological examination showed ciliated epithelization on the PGA material after 2 weeks. Bronchoscopy revealed stenosis due to granulation following administration of high concentrations of bFGF (12.5 and 25 µg). Compared with the DW group, groups administered 3.125, 6.25, 12.5 and 25 µg bFGF had significantly larger areas of regenerated cilia (15.2%, 27.0%, 41.3%, 33.1% and 31.0%, respectively; P = 0.00143), improved ciliary beat frequency (7.10, 8.18, 10.10, 9.50 and 9.50 Hz, respectively), and improved CTS (6.40, 9.54, 16.89, 16.41 and 14.29 µm/sec, respectively). Pathological examination of the right lower lobe revealed pulmonary fibrosis and hyperplasia with high concentrations of bFGF (12.5 and 25 µg).

CONCLUSIONS

Intratracheal administration of bFGF effectively promoted tracheal regeneration at an optimal dose of 6.25 µg following implantation of an artificial trachea.

Tissue-engineered tracheal implants: Advancements, challenges, and clinical considerations

Restoration of extensive tracheal damage remains a significant challenge in respiratory medicine, particularly in instances stemming from conditions like infection, congenital anomalies, or stenosis. The trachea, an essential element of the lower respiratory tract, constitutes a fibrocartilaginous tube spanning approximately 10-12 cm in length. It is characterized by 18 ± 2 tracheal cartilages distributed anterolaterally with the dynamic trachealis muscle located posteriorly. While tracheotomy is a common approach for patients with short-length defects, situations requiring replacement arise when the extent of lesion exceeds 1/2 of the length in adults (or 1/3 in children). Tissue engineering (TE) holds promise in developing biocompatible airway grafts for addressing challenges in tracheal regeneration. Despite the potential, the extensive clinical application of tissue-engineered tracheal substitutes encounters obstacles, including insufficient revascularization, inadequate re-epithelialization, suboptimal mechanical properties, and insufficient durability. These limitations have led to limited success in implementing tissue-engineered tracheal implants in clinical settings. This review provides a comprehensive exploration of historical attempts and lessons learned in the field of tracheal TE, contextualizing the clinical prerequisites and vital criteria for effective tracheal grafts. The manufacturing approaches employed in TE, along with the clinical application of both tissue-engineered and non-tissue-engineered approaches for tracheal reconstruction, are discussed in detail. By offering a holistic view on TE substitutes and their implications for the clinical management of long-segment tracheal lesions, this review aims to contribute to the understanding and advancement of strategies in this critical area of respiratory medicine.

Breathing room: Toward next-generation tracheal engineering

The creation of an engineered trachea with robust phenotype and sufficient mechanical properties for clinical application remains a challenge. In their work, Tang et al.1 propose a stacked approach of alternating cartilaginous and fibrous rings to form a tracheal segment, which integrated and retain patency in rabbits for 8 weeks.

Application of tissue engineering techniques in tracheal repair: a bibliometric study

Transplantation of tissue-engineered trachea is an effective treatment for long-segment tracheal injury. This technology avoids problems associated with a lack of donor resources and immune rejection, generating an artificial trachea with good biocompatibility. To our knowledge, a systematic summary of basic and clinical research on tissue-engineered trachea in the last 20 years has not been conducted. Here, we analyzed the development trends of tissue-engineered trachea research by bibliometric means and outlined the future perspectives in this field. The Web of Science portal was selected as the data source. CiteSpace, VOSviewer, and the Bibliometric Online Analysis Platform were used to analyze the number of publications, journals, countries, institutions, authors, and keywords from 475 screened studies. Between 2000 and 2023, the number of published studies on tissue-engineered trachea has been increasing. Biomaterials published the largest number of papers. The United States and China have made the largest contributions to this field. University College London published the highest number of studies, and the most productive researcher was an Italian scholar, Paolo Macchiarini. However, close collaborations between various researchers and institutions from different countries were generally lacking. Despite this, keyword analysis showed that manufacturing methods for tracheal stents, hydrogel materials, and 3D bioprinting technology are current popular research topics. Our bibliometric study will help scientists in this field gain an in-depth understanding of the current research progress and development trends to guide their future work, and researchers in related fields will benefit from the introduction to transplantation methods of tissue-engineered trachea.

Advances in lung bioengineering: Where we are, where we need to go, and how to get there

Lung transplantation is the only potentially curative treatment for end-stage lung failure and successfully improves both long-term survival and quality of life. However, lung transplantation is limited by the shortage of suitable donor lungs. This discrepancy in organ supply and demand has prompted researchers to seek alternative therapies for end-stage lung failure. Tissue engineering (bioengineering) organs has become an attractive and promising avenue of research, allowing for the customized production of organs on demand, with potentially perfect biocompatibility. While breakthroughs in tissue engineering have shown feasibility in practice, they have also uncovered challenges in solid organ applications due to the need not only for structural support, but also vascular membrane integrity and gas exchange. This requires a complex engineered interaction of multiple cell types in precise anatomical locations. In this article, we discuss the process of creating bioengineered lungs and the challenges inherent therein. We summarize the relevant literature for selecting appropriate lung scaffolds, creating decellularization protocols, and using bioreactors. The development of completely artificial lung substitutes will also be reviewed. Lastly, we describe the state of current research, as well as future studies required for bioengineered lungs to become a realistic therapeutic modality for end-stage lung disease. Applications of bioengineering may allow for earlier intervention in end-stage lung disease and have the potential to not only halt organ failure, but also significantly reverse disease progression.

Computational, Ex Vivo, and Tissue Engineering Techniques for Modeling Large Airways

The large airways are a critical component of the respiratory tree serving both an immunoprotective role and a physiological role for ventilation. The physiological role of the large airways is to move a large amount of air to and from the gas exchange surfaces of the alveoli. This air becomes divided along the respiratory tree as it moves from the large airways to smaller airways, bronchioles, and alveoli. The large airways are incredibly important from an immunoprotective role as the large airways are an early line of defense against inhaled particles, bacteria, and viruses. The key immunoprotective feature of the large airways is mucus production and mucociliary clearance mechanism. Each of these key features of the lung is important from both a basic physiology perspective and an engineering perspective for regenerative medicine. In this chapter, we will cover the large airways from an engineering perspective to highlight existing models of the large airways as well as future directions for modeling and repair.