Immune Tolerance-Adjusted Personalized Immunogenicity Prediction for Pompe Disease

Proceedings of the 15th European immunogenicity platform open symposium on immunogenicity of biopharmaceuticals

The European Immunogenicity Platform (EIP) celebrated the 15th edition of its Open Symposium on Immunogenicity of Biopharmaceuticals and its associated one-day workshop on 22-24 February 2024 in Lisbon. The meeting attracted experts and newcomers across industry, regulatory agencies, and academia, who actively participated in 3 days of discussion on risk assessment, monitoring, and mitigation of unwanted immunogenicity of biologics. Besides oral presentations, poster sessions were held to maximize scientific exchange and networking opportunities. Therapeutic proteins and emerging gene and cell-based therapies present promising therapeutic options for addressing unmet medical needs or when conventional treatment approaches have failed. Nonetheless, the development of an immune response against these therapeutic agents is a significant concern, as it occurs in a considerable number of cases across various products and indications. The specific anti-drug antibodies that develop can lead to adverse safety events, inhibition of drug activity, or accelerated clearance, all of which result in a loss of treatment efficacy. The EIP serves as a forum for experts and newcomers in the immunogenicity field, fostering discussion among scientists from industry and academia, encouraging interactions with regulatory agencies, and disseminating knowledge and advancements in immunogenicity sciences to the broader scientific community. This report covers the main topics discussed during the EIP 15th Open Symposium on Immunogenicity of Biopharmaceuticals, and the one-day workshop on practical aspects of immunogenicity held prior to the conference. Key topics included immunogenicity testing, clinical relevance of immunogenicity, immunogenicity risk assessment and mitigation, and current regulatory considerations.

Regulatory T cell epitope content in human antibodies decreases during maturation

Introduction

Antibody maturation in the lymphoid follicle produces antibodies with improved binding affinity. This process requires iterative rounds of mutation and B cell expansion, supported by T cells that recognize epitopes presented on the B cell's MHC-II. In this comprehensive antibody repertoire analysis, we find that established regulatory T cell epitopes (Tregitopes) decline in maturing antibody sequences as somatic hypermutation (SHM) increases, but potential T effector epitopes do not decline. A previous analysis of B cell receptor (BCR)-derived HLA-DR epitopes present in memory antibody repertoires from seven healthy human donors revealed a decrease in donor-specific epitope content with SHM. Moreover, T cell epitope depletion was associated with class-switching and long-term secretion of antibody into serum. Significant depletion of high-affinity germline-encoded epitopes in high SHM sequences was also observed, but the predicted phenotype of T cells responding to the BCR-derived epitopes (regulatory vs. effector) was not previously evaluated.

Methods

In this follow-on study, we screened a different set of four donor repertoires to investigate the dynamics of donor-specific HLA-DR T cell epitopes and three subsets of T cell epitope content: previously validated T cell epitopes recognized by thymus-derived Tregs (Tregitopes), potentially tolerated T cell epitopes, and potential effector T cell epitopes.

Results

Our results show that Tregitope content reduction is correlated with SHM, suggesting that Tregitopes are removed during maturation. Moreover, T cell epitopes that are likely to be tolerated or tolerogenic were also removed with SHM progression. In contrast, potential T effector epitope content increased with SHM. Tregitope depletion occurred in multiple V-gene pair combinations and was the most frequent T cell epitope change. Furthermore, Tregitope content in IgA and IgG sequences was lower and had greater negative correlation with SHM than IgM, indicating that Tregitope removal is likely associated with class-switching. Tregitope depletion was also associated with maturation to plasmablasts. In vitro, representative Tregitopes inhibited CD4+ T cell proliferation. Mutations introduced by SHM altered Tregitope HLA-DR binding affinities.

Discussion

The correlation of Tregitope depletion with increasing SHM implies that the activity of thymus-derived Treg cells in immune responses to antibodies is diminished with SHM, maturation, and isotype switching, supporting the generation of anti-idiotype responses.

Restoring immune balance with Tregitopes: A new approach to treating immunological disorders

The induction of immunological tolerance is a promising strategy for managing autoimmune diseases, allergies, and transplant rejection. Tregitopes, a class of peptides, have emerged as potential agents for this purpose. They activate regulatory T cells, which are pivotal in reducing inflammation and promoting tolerance, by binding to MHC II molecules and facilitating their processing and presentation to Treg cells, thereby encouraging their proliferation. Moreover, Tregitopes influence the phenotype of antigen-presenting cells by attenuating the expression of CD80, CD86, and MHC class II while enhancing ILT3, resulting in the inhibition of NF-kappa B signaling pathways. Various techniques, including in vitro and in silico methods, are applied to identify Tregitope candidates. Currently, Tregitopes play a vital role in balancing immune activation and tolerance in clinical applications such as Pompe disease, diabetes-related antigens, and the prevention of spontaneous abortions in autoimmune diseases. Similarly, Tregitopes can induce antigen-specific regulatory T cells. Their anti-inflammatory effects are significant in conditions such as autoimmune encephalomyelitis, inflammatory bowel disease, and Guillain-Barré syndrome. Additionally, Tregitopes have been leveraged to enhance vaccine design and efficacy. Recent advancements in understanding the potential benefits and drawbacks of IVIG and the discovery of the function and mechanism of Tregitopes have introduced Tregitopes as a popular option for immune system modulation. It is expected that they will bring about a significant revolution in the management and treatment of autoimmune and immunological diseases. This article is a comprehensive review of Tregitopes, concluding with the potential of these epitopes as a therapeutic avenue for immunological disorders.

Individual and population-level variability in HLA-DR associated immunogenicity risk of biologics used for the treatment of rheumatoid arthritis

Hypothesis

While conventional in silico immunogenicity risk assessments focus on measuring immunogenicity based on the potential of therapeutic proteins to be processed and presented by a global population-wide set of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) alleles to T cells, future refinements might adjust for HLA allele frequencies in different geographic regions or populations, as well for as individuals in those populations. Adjustment by HLA allele distribution may reveal risk patterns that are specific to population groups or individuals, which current methods that rely on global-population HLA prevalence may obscure.

Key findings

This analysis uses HLA frequency-weighted binding predictions to define immunogenicity risk for global and sub-global populations. A comparison of assessments tuned for North American/European versus Japanese/Asian populations suggests that the potential for anti-therapeutic responses (anti-therapeutic antibodies or ATA) for several commonly prescribed Rheumatoid Arthritis (RA) therapeutic biologics may differ, significantly, between the Caucasian and Japanese populations. This appears to align with reports of differing product-related immunogenicity that is observed in different populations.

Relevance to clinical practice

Further definition of population-level (regional) and individual patient-specific immunogenic risk profiles may enable prescription of the RA therapeutic with the highest probability of success to each patient, depending on their population of origin and/or their individual HLA background. Furthermore, HLA-specific immunogenicity outcomes data are limited, thus there is a need to expand HLA-association studies that examine the relationship between HLA haplotype and ATA in the clinic.

Does human homology reduce the potential immunogenicity of non-antibody scaffolds?

Biologics developers are moving beyond antibodies for delivery of a wide range of therapeutic interventions. These non-antibody modalities are often based on 'natural' protein scaffolds that are modified to deliver bioactive sequences. Both human-derived and non-human-sourced scaffold proteins have been developed. New types of "non-antibody" scaffolds are still being discovered, as they offer attractive alternatives to monoclonals due to their smaller size, improved stability, and ease of synthesis. They are believed to have low immunogenic potential. However, while several human-sourced protein scaffolds have not been immunogenic in clinical studies, this may not predict their overall performance in other therapeutic applications. A preliminary evaluation of their potential for immunogenicity is warranted. Immunogenicity risk potential has been clearly linked to the presence of T "helper" epitopes in the sequence of biologic therapeutics. In addition, tolerogenic epitopes are present in some human proteins and may decrease their immunogenic potential. While the detailed sequences of many non-antibody scaffold therapeutic candidates remain unpublished, their backbone sequences are available for review and analysis. We assessed 12 example non-antibody scaffold backbone sequences using our epitope-mapping tools (EpiMatrix) for this perspective. Based on EpiMatrix scoring, their HLA DRB1-restricted T cell epitope content appears to be lower than the average protein, and sequences that may act as tolerogenic epitopes are present in selected human-derived scaffolds. Assessing the potential immunogenicity of scaffold proteins regarding self and non-self T cell epitopes may be of use for drug developers and clinicians, as these exciting new non-antibody molecules begin to emerge from the preclinical pipeline into clinical use.

Immunoinformatic Risk Assessment of Host Cell Proteins During Process Development for Biologic Therapeutics

The identification and removal of host cell proteins (HCPs) from biologic products is a critical step in drug development. Despite recent improvements to purification processes, biologics such as monoclonal antibodies, enzyme replacement therapies, and vaccines that are manufactured in a range of cell lines and purified using diverse processes may contain HCP impurities, making it necessary for developers to identify and quantify impurities during process development for each drug product. HCPs that contain sequences that are less conserved with human homologs may be more immunogenic than those that are more conserved. We have developed a computational tool, ISPRI-HCP, that estimates the immunogenic potential of HCP sequences by evaluating and quantifying T cell epitope density and relative conservation with similar T cell epitopes in the human proteome. Here we describe several case studies that support the use of this method for classifying candidate HCP impurities according to their immunogenicity risk.

Motor outcomes in patients with infantile and juvenile Pompe disease: Lessons from neurophysiological findings

In Infantile Onset Pompe Disease (IOPD), enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) may improve survival, cardiac function, and motor development. However, even with early enzyme replacement therapy, some patients experienced poor response to ERT and abnormal motor milestones that could be due to motor neuron involvement. In this long-term retrospective study, we analyzed concomitant clinical motor outcomes and electroneuromyography (ENMG) findings in patients with IOPD and Juvenile Onset Pompe Disease (JOPD). Twenty-nine pediatric patients were included and 20 surviving were analyzed for neuromotor studies: 12 had IOPD (group 1), 4 had JOPD (group 2) and 4 (group 3) received ERT in the first month of age. Motor nerve conduction studies were mostly normal. Needle EMG performed at diagnosis always indicated the existence of myopathy that responded to ERT. Two IOPD patients (group 1) presenting with mixed motor neuropathy and myopathy displayed a poor outcome and never walked. Two patients became non-walkers (one IOPD patient and one patient of group 3) at respectively 9 and 3 years of age. One JOPD patient is about to lose walking ability. This motor deterioration was associated with the development of a motor neuropathy. Patients older than 10 years of age develop a motor neuropathy. Initial or secondary motor neuron involvement seems to be associated with a poor motor outcome showing that ERT may fail to prevent the accumulation of glycogen in motor neuron. Neurophysiological findings are important to assess severity of motor neuron damage in all Pompe pediatric patients and should be systematically performed.

Infantile-onset Pompe disease with neutropenia: Treatment decisions in the face of a unique phenotype

Infantile-onset Pompe disease manifests with early signs of cardiomyopathy during the first few days to weeks of life. We present the case of a newborn born via emergency cesarean section with atrial flutter and moderate biventricular hypertrophy who was diagnosed with Pompe disease on New York State newborn screen. Diagnosis was confirmed with repeat leukocyte acid alpha-glucosidase (GAA) enzyme activity, GAA gene sequencing, urine Hex4, and evaluation of Cross-Reactive Immunological Material (CRIM) status. The patient was also found to be persistently neutropenic which to our knowledge has not been previously reported in the literature in association with Pompe disease. This report highlights the impact that newborn screening had on time to diagnosis and initiation of treatment with enzyme replacement therapy. We also discuss how our patient's concurrent neutropenia impacted decision making related to immune tolerance induction prior to starting enzyme replacement therapy.

Therapeutic Options for the Management of Pompe Disease: Current Challenges and Clinical Evidence in Therapeutics and Clinical Risk Management

Pompe disease is a genetic disorder produced by mutations in the GAA gene leading to absence or reduced expression of acid alpha-glucosidase, an enzyme that metabolizes the breakdown of glycogen into glucose. There are two main phenotypes, the infantile consisting of early onset severe weakness and cardiomyopathy, and the adult which is characterized by slowly progressive skeletal and respiratory muscle weakness. Enzymatic replacement therapy (ERT) has been available for Pompe disease for more than 15 years. Although the treatment has improved many aspects of the disease, such as prolonged survival through improved cardiomyopathy and acquisition of motor milestones in infants and slower progression rate in adults, ERT is far from being a cure as both infantile and adult patients continue to progress. This fact has prompted the development of improved or new enzymes and other treatments such as gene therapy or substrate reduction strategies. Here, we review the data obtained from randomized clinical trials but also from open-label studies published so far that have assessed the advantages and limitations of this therapy. Moreover, we also review the new therapeutic strategies that are under development and provide our opinion on which are the unmet needs for patients with this disease.

What's new and what's next for gene therapy in Pompe disease?

INTRODUCTION

Pompe disease is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by a deficiency of acid-α-glucosidase (GAA), an enzyme responsible for hydrolyzing lysosomal glycogen. A lack of GAA leads to accumulation of glycogen in the lysosomes of cardiac, skeletal, and smooth muscle cells, as well as in the central and peripheral nervous system. Enzyme replacement therapy has been the standard of care for 15 years and slows disease progression, particularly in the heart, and improves survival. However, there are limitations of ERT success, which gene therapy can overcome.

AREAS COVERED

Gene therapy offers several advantages including prolonged and consistent GAA expression and correction of skeletal muscle as well as the critical CNS pathology. We provide a systematic review of the preclinical and clinical outcomes of adeno-associated viral mediated gene therapy and alternative gene therapy strategies, highlighting what has been successful.

EXPERT OPINION

Although the preclinical and clinical studies so far have been promising, barriers exist that need to be addressed in gene therapy for Pompe disease. New strategies including novel capsids for better targeting, optimized DNA vectors, and adjuctive therapies will allow for a lower dose, and ameliorate the immune response.

Case Report: Identification of Compound Heterozygous Mutations in a Patient With Late-Onset Glycogen Storage Disease Type II (Pompe Disease)

Pompe disease is an autosomal recessive hereditary lysosomal disorder and correlated with acid α-glucosidase enzyme (GAA) deficiencies, which lead to accumulation of glycogen in all tissues, most notably in skeletal muscles. Adult late-onset Pompe disease (LOPD) is a slowly progressive disease of proximal myopathy with later involvement of the respiratory muscles, resulting in respiratory failure. In this study, we reported a 22-year-old Chinese woman with inability to withstand heavy physical activity since childhood, who presented with respiratory and ambulation weakness in 2 months. On admission, her bilateral upper limbs strength was 4/5 and lower limbs strength was 3/5 according to Medical Research Council (MRC) score. The patient had compound heterozygotes containing a newly identified 4 nt deletion of coding sequence (deletion nt 1411_1414) in one of the acid α-glucosidase alleles and a c.2238G>C (p.Trp746Cys) missense mutation. This deletion has been reported in infant-onset Pompe disease (IOPD) but not LOPD. Intriguingly, this deletion mutation was not found in the patient's family and was considered as pathogenic. Muscle biopsy showed scattered vacuoles with basophilic granules inside the subsarcolemmal area, which were strongly stained by periodic acid-Schiff (PAS). Laboratory tests revealed a significant increase of creatine kinase MB isoenzyme (CK-MB) and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH). GAA level was 9.77 nmol/1 h/mg and was not sufficient for the diagnosis of GAA activity deficiency (0–3.78 nmol/1 h/mg). In summary, mutational analysis of GAA and muscle biopsy are crucial in the diagnosis of Pompe disease.

Antibodies against recombinant human alpha-glucosidase do not seem to affect clinical outcome in childhood onset Pompe disease

Background

Enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) with recombinant human alpha-glucosidase (rhGAA, alglucosidase alfa) has improved survival, motor outcomes, daily life activity and quality of life in Pompe patients. However, ERT in Pompe disease often induces formation of antibodies, which may reduce the efficacy of treatment and can lead to adverse events. In this study antibody formation and their effect on clinical outcome in patients with childhood onset Pompe disease treated with enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) with recombinant human alpha-glucosidase (rhGAA) are analyzed.

Methods

Enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) was used to determine anti-rhGAA antibody titers at predefined time points. The effect of antibodies on rhGAA activity (neutralizing effects) was measured in vitro. Clinical effects were evaluated by assessing muscle strength (MRC score) and function (QMFT-score), pulmonary function and infusion associated reactions (IARs).

Results

Twenty-two patients were included (age at start ERT 1.1–16.4 years, median treatment duration 12.4 years). Peak antibody titers were low (< 1:1250) in 9%, intermediate (1:1250–1:31,250) in 68% and high (≥ 1:31250) in 23% of patients; three patients (14%) had more than one titer of ≥ 1:31,250. Four patients (18%) experienced IARs; two patients from the high titer group had 86% of all IARs. Inhibition of intracellular GAA activity (58%) in vitro was found in one sample. The clinical course did not appear to be influenced by antibody titers.

Conclusions

Ninety-one percent of childhood onset Pompe patients developed anti-rhGAA antibodies (above background level), a minority of whom had high antibody titers at repeated time points, which do not seem to interfere with clinical outcome. High antibody titers may be associated with the occurrence of IARs. Although the majority of patients does not develop high titers; antibody titers should be determined in case of clinical deterioration.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13023-022-02175-2.

Neoantigen-based personalized cancer vaccines: the emergence of precision cancer immunotherapy

INTRODUCTION

The field of cancer therapy has undergone a major transformation in less than a decade due to the introduction of checkpoint inhibitors, the advent of next generation sequencing and the discovery of neoantigens. The key observation that the breadth of each patient's immune response to the unique mutations or neoantigens present in their tumor is directly related to their survival has led oncologists to focus on driving immune responses to neoantigens through vaccination. Oncology has entered the era of precision immunotherapy, and cancer vaccine development is undergoing a paradigm shift.

AREAS COVERED

Neoantigens are short peptide sequences found in tumors, but not noncancerous tissues, the vast majority of which are unique to each patient. In addition to providing a description of the distinguishing features of neoantigen discovery platforms, this review will address cross-cutting personalized cancer vaccine design themes and developmental stumbling blocks.

EXPERT OPINION

Immunoinformatic pipelines that can rapidly scan cancer genomes and identify 'the best' neoantigens are in high demand. Despite the need for such tools, immunoinformatic methods for identifying neoepitopes in cancer genomes are diverse and have not been well-validated. Validation of 'personalized vaccine design pipelines' will bring about a revolution in neoantigen-based vaccine design and delivery.