Recombination Does Not Hinder Formation or Detection of Ecological Species of Synechococcus Inhabiting a Hot Spring Cyanobacterial Mat

Signatures of selection in core and accessory genomes indicate different ecological drivers of diversification among Bacillus cereus clades

Bacterial clades are often ecologically distinct, despite extensive horizontal gene transfer (HGT). How selection works on different parts of bacterial pan‐genomes to drive and maintain the emergence of clades is unclear. Focusing on the three largest clades in the diverse and well‐studied Bacillus cereus sensu lato group, we identified clade‐specific core genes (present in all clade members) and then used clade‐specific allelic diversity to identify genes under purifying and diversifying selection. Clade‐specific accessory genes (present in a subset of strains within a clade) were characterized as being under selection using presence/absence in specific clades. Gene ontology analyses of genes under selection revealed that different gene functions were enriched in different clades. Furthermore, some gene functions were enriched only amongst clade‐specific core or accessory genomes. Genes under purifying selection were often clade‐specific, while genes under diversifying selection showed signs of frequent HGT. These patterns are consistent with different selection pressures acting on both the core and the accessory genomes of different clades and can lead to ecological divergence in both cases. Examining variation in allelic diversity allows us to uncover genes under clade‐specific selection, allowing ready identification of strains and their ecological niche.

Genotyping and multivariate regression trees reveal ecological diversification within the Microcystis aeruginosa complex along a wide environmental gradient

Addressing the ecological and evolutionary processes underlying biodiversity patterns is essential to identify the mechanisms shaping community structure and function. In bacteria, the formation of new ecologically distinct populations (ecotypes) is proposed as one of the main drivers of diversification. New ecotypes arise when mutations in key functional genes or acquisition of new metabolic pathways by horizontal gene transfer allow the population to exploit new resources, permitting their coexistence with the parental population. We previously reported the presence of microcystin-producing organisms of the Microcystis aeruginosa complex (toxic MAC) through an 800 km environmental gradient ranging from freshwater to estuarine-marine waters in South America. We hypothesize that the success of toxic MAC in such a gradient is due to the existence of very closely related populations that are ecologically distinct (ecotypes), each specialized to a specific arrangement of environmental variables. Here, we analyzed toxic MAC genetic diversity through qPCR and high-resolution melting analysis (HRMA) of a functional gene (mcyJ, microcystin synthetase cluster). We explored the variability of the mcyJ gene along the environmental gradient by multivariate classification and regression trees (mCART). Six groups of mcyJ genotypes were distinguished and associated with different combinations of water temperature, conductivity and turbidity. We propose that each mcyJ variant associated to a defined environmental condition is an ecotype (or species) whose relative abundances vary according to their fitness in the local environment. This mechanism would explain the success of toxic MAC in such a wide array of environmental conditions. Importance Organisms of the Microcystis aeruginosa Complex form harmful algal blooms (HABs) in nutrient-rich water bodies worldwide. MAC HABs are difficult to manage owing to the production of potent toxins (microcystins) that resist water treatment. Besides, the role of microcystins in the ecology of MAC organisms is still elusive, meaning that the environmental conditions driving the toxicity of the bloom are not clear. Furthermore, the lack of coherence between morphology-based and genomic-based species classification makes it difficult to draw sound conclusions about when and where each member species of the MAC will dominate the bloom. Here, we propose that the diversification process and success of toxic MAC in a wide range of waterbodies involves the generation of ecotypes, each specialized in a particular niche, whose relative abundance varies according to its fitness in the local environment. This knowledge can improve the generation of accurate prediction models of MAC growth and toxicity, helping to prevent human and animal intoxication.

Microcoleus (Cyanobacteria) form watershed-wide populations without strong gradients in population structure

The relative importance of separation by distance and by environment to population genetic diversity can be conveniently tested in river networks, where these two drivers are often independently distributed over space. To evaluate the importance of dispersal and environmental conditions in shaping microbial population structures, we performed genome‐resolved metagenomic analyses of benthic Microcoleus‐dominated cyanobacterial mats collected in the Eel and Russian River networks (California, USA). The 64 Microcoleus genomes were clustered into three species that shared >96.5% average nucleotide identity (ANI). Most mats were dominated by one strain, but minor alleles within mats were often shared, even over large spatial distances (>300 km). Within the most common Microcoleus species, the ANI between the dominant strains within mats decreased with increasing spatial separation. However, over shorter spatial distances (tens of kilometres), mats from different subwatersheds had lower ANI than mats from the same subwatershed, suggesting that at shorter spatial distances environmental differences between subwatersheds in factors like canopy cover, conductivity, and mean annual temperature decreases ANI. Since mats in smaller creeks had similar levels of nucleotide diversity (π) as mats in larger downstream subwatersheds, within‐mat genetic diversity does not appear to depend on the downstream accumulation of upstream‐derived strains. The four‐gamete test and sequence length bias suggest recombination occurs between almost all strains within each species, even between populations separated by large distances or living in different habitats. Overall, our results show that, despite some isolation by distance and environmental conditions, sufficient gene‐flow occurs among cyanobacterial strains to prevent either driver from producing distinctive population structures across the watershed.

The role of recombination, niche-specific gene pools and flexible genomes in the ecological speciation of bacteria

Bacteria diversify into genetic clusters analogous to those observed in sexual eukaryotes, but the definition of bacterial species is an ongoing problem. Recent work has focused on adaptation to distinct ecological niches as the main driver of clustering, but there remains debate about the role of recombination in that process. One view is that homologous recombination occurs too rarely for gene flow to constrain divergent selection. Another view is that homologous recombination is frequent enough in many bacterial populations that barriers to gene flow are needed to permit divergence. Niche-specific gene pools have been proposed as a general mechanism to limit gene flow. We use theoretical models to evaluate additional hypotheses that evolving genetic architecture, specifically the effect sizes of genes and gene gain and loss, can limit gene flow between diverging populations. Our model predicts that (a) in the presence of gene flow and recombination, ecological divergence is concentrated in few loci of large effect and (b) high rates of gene flow plus recombination promote gene loss and favor the evolution of niche-specific genes. The results show that changing genetic architecture and gene loss can facilitate ecological divergence, even without niche-specific gene pools. We discuss these results in the context of recent studies of sympatric divergence in microbes.

Probing the ecological and evolutionary history of a thermophilic cyanobacterial population via statistical properties of its microdiversity

Despite extensive DNA sequencing data derived from natural microbial communities, it remains a major challenge to identify the key evolutionary and ecological forces that shape microbial populations. We have focused on the extensive microdiversity of the cyanobacterium Synechococcus sp., which is a dominant member of the dense phototrophic biofilms in the hot springs of Yellowstone National Park. From deep amplicon sequencing of many loci and statistical analyses of these data, we showed previously that the population has undergone an unexpectedly high degree of homologous recombination, unlinking synonymous SNP-pair correlations even on intragenic length scales. Here, we analyze the genic amino acid diversity, which provides new evidence of selection and insights into the evolutionary history of the population. Surprisingly, some features of the data, including the spectrum of distances between genic-alleles, appear consistent with primarily asexual neutral drift. Yet the non-synonymous site frequency spectrum has too large an excess of low-frequency polymorphisms to result from negative selection on deleterious mutations given the distribution of coalescent times that we infer. And our previous analyses showed that the population is not asexual. Taken together, these apparently contradictory data suggest that selection, epistasis, and hitchhiking all play essential roles in generating and stabilizing the diversity. We discuss these as well as potential roles of ecological niches at genomic and genic levels. From quantitative properties of the diversity and comparative genomic data, we infer aspects of the history and inter-spring dispersal of the meta-population since it was established in the Yellowstone Caldera. Our investigations illustrate the need for combining multiple types of sequencing data and quantitative statistical analyses to develop an understanding of microdiversity in natural microbial populations.

Genomic Inference of Recombination-Mediated Evolution in Xanthomonas euvesicatoria and X. perforans

Recombination is a major driver of evolution in bacterial populations, because it can spread and combine independently evolved beneficial mutations. Recombinant lineages of bacterial pathogens of plants are typically associated with the colonization of novel hosts and the emergence of new diseases. Here we show that recombination between evolutionarily and phenotypically distinct plant-pathogenic lineages generated recombinant lineages with unique combinations of pathogenicity and virulence factors. Xanthomonas euvesicatoria and Xanthomonas perforans are two closely related lineages causing bacterial spot disease on tomato and pepper worldwide. We sequenced the genomes of atypical strains collected from tomato in Nigeria and observed recombination in the type III secretion system and effector genes, which showed alleles from both X. euvesicatoria and X. perforans Wider horizontal gene transfer was indicated by the fact that the lipopolysaccharide cluster of one strain was most similar to that of a distantly related Xanthomonas pathogen of barley. This strain and others have experienced extensive genomewide homologous recombination, and both species exhibited dynamic open pangenomes. Variation in effector gene repertoires within and between species must be taken into consideration when one is breeding tomatoes for disease resistance. Resistance breeding strategies that target specific effectors must consider possibly dramatic variation in bacterial spot populations across global production regions, as illustrated by the recombinant strains observed here.IMPORTANCE The pathogens that cause bacterial spot of tomato and pepper are extensively studied models of plant-microbe interactions and cause problematic disease worldwide. Atypical bacterial spot strains collected from tomato in Nigeria, and other strains from Italy, India, and Florida, showed evidence of genomewide recombination that generated genetically distinct pathogenic lineages. The strains from Nigeria and Italy were found to have a mix of type III secretion system genes from X. perforans and X. euvesicatoria, as well as effectors from Xanthomonas gardneri These genes and effectors are important in the establishment of disease, and effectors are common targets of resistance breeding. Our findings point to global diversity in the genomes of bacterial spot pathogens, which is likely to affect the host-pathogen interaction and influence management decisions.

Transmission in the Origins of Bacterial Diversity, From Ecotypes to Phyla

Any two lineages, no matter how distant they are now, began their divergence as one population splitting into two lineages that could coexist indefinitely. The rate of origin of higher-level taxa is therefore the product of the rate of speciation times the probability that two new species coexist long enough to reach a particular level of divergence. Here I have explored these two parameters of disparification in bacteria. Owing to low recombination rates, sexual isolation is not a necessary milestone of bacterial speciation. Rather, irreversible and indefinite divergence begins with ecological diversification, that is, transmission of a bacterial lineage to a new ecological niche, possibly to a new microhabitat but at least to new resources. Several algorithms use sequence data from a taxon of focus to identify phylogenetic groups likely to bear the dynamic properties of species. Identifying these newly divergent lineages allows us to characterize the genetic bases of speciation, as well as the ecological dimensions upon which new species diverge. Speciation appears to be least frequent when a given lineage has few new resources it can adopt, as exemplified by photoautotrophs, C1 heterotrophs, and obligately intracellular pathogens; speciation is likely most rapid for generalist heterotrophs. The genetic basis of ecological divergence may determine whether ecological divergence is irreversible and whether lineages will diverge indefinitely into the future. Long-term coexistence is most likely when newly divergent lineages utilize at least some resources not shared with the other and when the resources themselves will coexist into the remote future.

How clonal are bacteria over time?

Bacteria and archaea reproduce clonally (vertical descent), but exchange genes by recombination (horizontal transfer). Recombination allows adaptive mutations or genes to spread rapidly within (or even between) species, and reduces the burden of deleterious mutations. Clonality-defined here as the balance between vertical and horizontal inheritance-is therefore a key microbial trait, determining how quickly a population can adapt and the size of its gene pool. Here, I discuss whether clonality varies over time and if it can be considered a stable trait of a given population. I show that, in some cases, clonality is clearly not static. For example, non-clonal (highly recombining) populations can give rise to clonal expansions, often of pathogens. However, an analysis of time-course metagenomic data from a lake suggests that a bacterial population's past clonality (as measured by its genetic diversity) is a good predictor of its future clonality. Clonality therefore appears to be relatively-but not completely-stable over evolutionary time.