Improved Ablation Efficiency in PVI Guided by Contact Force and Local Impedance: Chronic Canine Model

The "16-gram window" of contact-force: A new criterion for very high-power short-duration ablation

Background

Very high-power short-duration (vHPSD) ablation with the novel QDOT™ catheter allows the regulation of target temperature by automatically adjusting flow and power during a 4 s application of 90 W. However, the optimal contact force for sufficient lesion creation is unknown.

Methods

We enrolled 73 patients with symptomatic atrial fibrillation undergoing pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) using the QDOT catheter in the vHPSD mode (90 W, 4 s). Ablation metrics associated with suboptimal applications, defined as either an impedance drop of ≤5% or a cumulative temperature-limited energy ≤330 J, were collected and analyzed.

Results

A total of 3881 vHPSD applications (53.2 applications per patient) with a mean contact force (CF) of 12.8 ± 6.6 g were analyzed. Significant CF variability and intermittent loss of contact were documented in 18.2% and 8.8% of the applications, respectively. A ΔImp ≤ 5% occurred in 3.9% of vHPSD applications, while a cumulative energy ≤ 330 J was observed in 3% of the applications. Applications with a mean CF < 6 g and >22 g were associated with an inadequate impedance drop (10.3%, Phi coefficient 0.118, p < .001) and total applied energy (7.8%, Phi coefficient 0.094, p < .001) respectively. At superior PV segments with thick atrial walls, significantly more applications with cumulative energy ≤330 J (4.2% vs. 2.5%; p = .007) were observed, especially when mean CF > 18 g was applied (8.4%, Phi coefficient 0.093, p = .003).

Conclusion

A lower but also a higher mean contact-force was associated with suboptimal vHPSD applications. Hence, a "16-gram window" of contact-force, from 6 to 22 g, could optimize energy application in vHPSD ablation.

Early rapid local impedance drop is associated with acute lesion efficacy during pulmonary vein isolation

AIMS

The predictive role of local impedance (LI) drop in lesion formation using a novel contact force sensing ablation catheter was recently described. The purpose of our current study was to assess the temporal characteristics of LI drop during ablation and its correlation with acute lesion efficacy.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Point-by-point pulmonary vein isolation was performed. The efficacy of applications was determined by pacing along the circular ablation line and assessing loss of capture. Local impedance, contact force, and catheter position data with high resolution were analysed and compared in successful and unsuccessful applications. Five hundred and fifty-nine successful and 84 unsuccessful applications were analysed. The successful applications showed higher baseline LI (P < 0.001) and larger LI drop during ablation (P < 0.001, for all). In case of unsuccessful applications, after a moderate but significant drop from baseline to the 2 s time point (153 vs. 145 Ω, P < 0.001), LI did not change further (P = 0.99). Contradictorily, in case of successful applications, the LI significantly decreased further (baseline-2 s-10 s: 161-150-141 Ω, P < 0.001 for all). The optimal cut-point for the LI drop indicating unsuccessful application was <9 Ω at the 4-s time point [AUC = 0.73 (0.67-0.76), P < 0.001]. Failing to reach this cut-point predicted unsuccessful applications [OR 3.82 (2.34-6.25); P < 0.001].

CONCLUSION

A rapid and enduring drop of the LI may predict effective lesion formation, while slightly changing or unchanged LI is associated with unsuccessful applications. A moderate LI drop during the first 4 s of radiofrequency application predicts ineffective radiofrequency delivery.

Interactions of contact force, impedance, and power during repeated atrial arrhythmia ablation after previous atrial fibrillation ablation

BACKGROUND

Acutely effective repeated radiofrequency catheter ablation (RFCA) after previous atrial fibrillation ablation depends on several parameters including local impedance (LI), contact force (CF), and power.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to investigate the relationship of LI, CF, and power to the LI drop in a repeated atrial RFCA environment.

METHODS

Consecutive patients undergoing repeated atrial RFCA were studied. High-quality local electrograms were analyzed for morphology changes indicating effective RFCA and associated LI dynamics. The influence of baseline LI, mean CF, and power on the LI drop was analyzed. Investigated power levels included ≤25 W, 30 W, and ≥40 W.

RESULTS

A total of 1390 RFCA points from 48 patients (48% female; median age, 70 years) were analyzed. Of 309 analyzed electrograms, 40.5% showed effective RFCA morphology changes with an elevated median LI drop (effective, 19.7 Ω; partially effective, 14.1 Ω; P < .001). CF showed the highest correlation to the LI drop within high baseline LI and when applying ≥40 W (low baseline LI, R = 0.39; intermediate, R = 0.66; high, R = 0.72). Within low baseline LI regions, CF levels showed a lower correlation to the LI drop (≤25 W, R = 0.30; 30 W, R = 0.35; ≥40 W, R = 0.39). A mean CF ≥10 g resulted in elevated LI drops with higher power compared with lower power within all baseline LI tertiles (P < .001 each).

CONCLUSION

Within high baseline LI regions, CF plays a greater role for the maximum LI drop when higher power is chosen. A mean CF ≥10 g ensures elevated LI drops with increasing power levels.

Ablation Parameters Predicting Pulmonary Vein Reconnection after Very High-Power Short-Duration Pulmonary Vein Isolation

BACKGROUND

Recurrences due to discontinuity in ablation lines are substantial after pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) with radiofrequency ablation for atrial fibrillation. Data are scarce regarding the durability predictors for very high-power short-duration (vHPSD, 90 W/4 s) ablation.

METHODS

A total of 20 patients were enrolled, who underwent 90 W PVI and a mandatory remapping procedure at 3 months. First-pass isolation (FPI) gaps, and acute pulmonary vein reconnection (PVR) sites were identified at the index procedure; and chronic PVR sites were identified at the repeated procedure. We analyzed parameters of ablation points (n = 1357), and evaluated their roles in predicting a composite endpoint of FPI gaps, acute and chronic PVR.

RESULTS

In total, 45 initial ablation points corresponding to gaps in the ablation lines were analyzed. Parameters associated with gaps were interlesion distance (ILD), baseline generator impedance, mean current, total charge, and loss of catheter-tissue contact. The optimal ILD cut-off for predicting gaps was 3.5 mm anteriorly, and 4 mm posteriorly.

CONCLUSIONS

Biophysical characteristics dependent on generator impedance could affect the efficacy of vHPSD PVI. The use of smaller ILDs is required for effective and durable PVI with vHPSD compared to the consensus targets with lower power ablation, and lower ILDs for anterior applications seem necessary compared to posterior points.

Impact of Contact Force on Pulsed Field Ablation Outcomes Using Focal Point Catheter

BACKGROUND

Conventional focal radiofrequency catheters may be modified to enable multiple energy modalities (radiofrequency or pulsed field [PF]) with the benefit of contact force (CF) feedback, providing greater flexibility in the treatment of arrhythmias. Information on the impact of CF on lesion formation in PF ablations remains limited.

METHODS

An in vivo study was performed with 8 swine using an investigational dual-energy CF focal catheter with local impedance. Experiment I: To evaluate atrial lesion formation, contiguity, and width, a point-by-point approach was used to create an intercaval line. The distance between the points was prespecified at 4±1 mm. Half of the line was created with radiofrequency energy, whereas the other half utilized PF (single 2.0 kV application with a proprietary waveform). Experiment II: To evaluate single application lesion dimensions with a proprietary waveform, discrete ventricular lesions were performed with PFA (single 2.0 kV application) with targeted levels of CF: low, 5 to 15 g; medium, 20 to 30 g; and high, 35 to 45 g. Following 1 week of survival, animals underwent endocardial/epicardial remapping, and euthanasia to enable histopathologic examination.

RESULTS

Experiment I: Both energy modalities resulted in a complete intercaval line of transmural ablation. PF resulted in significantly wider lines than radiofrequency: minimum width, 14.9±2.3 versus 5.0±1.6 mm; maximum width, 21.8±3.4 versus 7.3±2.1 mm, respectively; P<0.01 for each. Histology confirmed transmural lesions with both modalities. Experiment II: With PF, lesion depth, width, and volume were larger with higher degrees of CF (depth: r=0.82, P<0.001; width: r=0.26, P=0.052; and volume: r=0.55, P<0.001), with depth increasing at a faster rate than width. The mean depths were as follows: low (n=17), 4.3±1.0 mm; medium (n=26), 6.4±1.2 mm; and high (n=14), 9.1±1.4 mm.

CONCLUSIONS

Using the same focal point CF-sensing catheter, a novel PF ablation waveform with a single application resulted in transmural atrial lesions that were significantly wider than radiofrequency. Lesion depth showed a significant positive correlation with CF with depths of 6.4 mm at moderate CF.

Determinants of left atrial local impedance: Relationships with contact force, atrial fibrosis, and rhythm

INTRODUCTION

The relationships between baseline tissue local impedance (LI), contact force (CF), atrial fibrosis, and atrial rhythm are uninvestigated in a clinical setting. We compared the relationship of LI and CF between atrial fibrillation (AF) and sinus rhythm (SR) accounting for the effects of atrial fibrosis as assessed by bipolar voltage and LI.

METHODS

Patients undergoing persistent AF ablation were recruited. LI was recorded referenced to patient blood pool (LIr) and concurrent to changes in CF, with data collected at the same locations in AF and SR.

RESULTS

Twenty patients were recruited. 109 locations were sampled obtaining 1903 data points (SR: 966, AF: 937). CF correlated strongly with LI (repeated measures correlation = 0.64). The relationship between CF and LIr was logarithmic. Rhythm and CF had a significant main (both p < .0005) and interaction effect (p = .022) on tissue LI: AF demonstrated higher LIr values than SR for similar CF. Bipolar voltage had no effect on the relationship of CF to LIr in either rhythm. Assessing fibrosis using LIr showed an interaction effect with CF for LIr in SR and AF, (SR: p < .0005, AF: p = .01), with increased fibrosis showing lesser change in LIr per gram of CF.

CONCLUSIONS

CF and rhythm significantly affect the measured LIr of LA myocardium. Optimal catheter-tissue coupling may be better achieved with higher levels of CF and in AF rather than SR. Atrial fibrosis, as assessed by LIr but not bipolar voltage, affected the CF-LI relationship.

Combined contact force and local impedance dynamics during repeat atrial fibrillation catheter ablation

Background: Optimal lesion formation during catheter-based radiofrequency current (RFC) ablation depends on electro-mechanical tip-tissue coupling measurable via contact force (CF) and local impedance (LI) monitoring. We aimed to investigate CF and LI dynamics in patients with previous atrial fibrillation (AF) ablation who frequently present with heterogenous arrhythmia substrate.

Methods: Data from consecutive patients presenting for repeat AF or atrial tachycardia ablation using a novel open-irrigated single-tip ablation catheter were studied. RFC applications were investigated regarding CF, LI and the maximum LI drop (∆LI) for evaluation of ablation efficacy. ∆LI > 20 Ω was defined as a successful RFC application.

Results: A total of 730 RFC applications in 20 patients were analyzed. Baseline CF was not associated with baseline LI (R = 0.06, p = 0.17). A mean CF < 8 g during ablation resulted in lower ∆LI (<8 g: 13 Ω vs. ≥ 8 g: 16 Ω, p < 0.001). Baseline LI showed a better correlation with ∆LI (R = 0.35, p < 0.001) compared to mean CF (R = 0.17, p < 0.001). Mean CF correlated better with ∆LI in regions of low (R = 0.31, p < 0.001) compared to high (R = 0.21, p = 0.02) and intermediate voltage (R = 0.17, p = 0.004). Combined CF and baseline LI predicted ∆LI > 20 Ω (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUC) 0.75) better compared to baseline LI (AUC 0.72), mean CF (AUC 0.60), force-time integral (AUC 0.59) and local bipolar voltage (0.55).

Conclusion: Combination of CF and LI may aid monitoring real-time catheter-tissue electro-mechanical coupling and lesion formation within heterogenous atrial arrhythmia substrate in patients with repeat AF or atrial tachycardia ablation.

Characteristics of Very High-Power, Short-Duration Radiofrequency Applications

Introduction

Pulmonary vein isolation is the cornerstone of rhythm-control therapy for atrial fibrillation (AF). The very high-power, short-duration (vHPSD) radiofrequency (RF) ablation is a novel technology that favors resistive heating while decreasing the role of conductive heating. Our study aimed to evaluate the correlations between contact force (CF), power, impedance drop (ID), and temperature; and to assess their role in lesion formation with the vHPSD technique.

Methods

Consecutive patients who underwent initial point-by-point RF catheter ablation for AF were enrolled in the study. The vHPSD ablation was performed applying 90 W for 4 s with an 8 ml/min irrigation rate.

Results

Data from 85 patients [median age 65 (59–71) years, 34% female] were collected. The median procedure time, left atrial dwelling time, and fluoroscopy time were 70 (60–90) min, 49 (42–58) min, and 7 (5–11) min, respectively. The median RF time was 312 (237-365) sec. No steam pop nor major complications occurred. A total of 6,551 vHPSD RF points were analyzed. The median of CF, maximum temperature, and ID were 14 (10–21) g, 47.6 (45.1–50.4) °C, and 8 (6–10) Ohms, respectively. CF correlated significantly with the maximum temperature (p < 0.0001). A CF of 5 g and above was associated with a significantly higher temperature compared to those lesions with a CF below 5 grams (p < 0.0001). Bilateral first-pass isolation rate was 84%. The 6-month AF-recurrence rate was 7%.

Conclusion

The maximum temperature and CF significantly correlate with each other during vHPSD applications. A CF ≥ 5 g leads to better tissue heating and thus might be more likely to result in good lesion formation, although this clinical study was unable to assess actual lesion sizes.