Sex differences in heart rate and heart rate variability in rats: Implications for translational research

Sex difference of LiCl-induced feeding suppression and, autonomic and HPA axis responses in crows

Visceral sensation is crucial for feeding, emotion, and decision making in humans and non-human animals. Visceral discomforting stimulation activates stress-coping systems, such as the autonomic nervous system (ANS) and hypothalamus-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis, with varied responses and thresholds between sexes. Despite these systems working together during visceral discomfort, ANS and HPA have been separately investigated with few studies examining the co-occurrence of the ANS and HPA responses to visceral stimulations. The basic profiles of the ANS and HPA responses to visceral discomfort and sex differences in birds are poorly elucidated. This study investigated the effects of visceral stimulation via intraperitoneal injection of lithium chloride (LiCl) on feeding behavior, ANS and HPA activities, and sex differences in crows. We identified the LiCl dose that suppressed the intake of a preferred food and compared the LiCl-induced feeding suppression between sexes. Changes in heart rate variability (HRV), as a proxy of sympathetic and parasympathetic activities, and serum corticosterone (CORT) levels by LiCl injection were compared. Feeding suppression occurred at higher LiCl doses in males than in females. HRV analysis revealed that LiCl injection reduced HR and increased parasympathetic activity; however, it did not change sympathetic activity, with no sex differences in any variables. In contrast, LiCl injections at lower doses increased serum CORT levels more in males than in females. Our findings provide the first evidence of sex-specific response profiles to feeding suppression and ANS and HPA activities associated with LiCl-induced visceral discomfort in birds.

Prenatal dexamethasone programs autonomic dysregulation in female rats

Autonomic dysfunction is associated with cardiovascular and neurological diseases, including hypertension, heart failure, anxiety, and stress-related disorders. Prior studies demonstrated that late gestation exposure to dexamethasone (DEX) resulted in female-biased increases in stress-responsive mean arterial pressure (MAP) and heart rate (HR), suggesting a role for glucocorticoid-mediated programming of autonomic dysfunction. The present study investigated the influence of sympathetic (SYM) or parasympathetic (PS) blockade on cardiovascular function in male and female rat offspring of mothers injected with DEX in utero [gestation days (GD) 18-21]. At 11-12-wk of age, MAP, HR, and heart rate variability (HRV) were evaluated at baseline and in response to SYM antagonists (α1-adrenoceptor + β1-adrenoceptor), a PS (muscarinic) antagonist, or saline (SAL). To assess stress-responsive function, rats were exposed to acute restraint. Tyrosine hydroxylase was measured in the adrenals and left ventricle, and expression of the β1 adrenergic receptor, choline acetyltransferase, and acetylcholinesterase were measured in the left ventricle. Maternal DEX injection reduced basal HRV in male and female offspring. SYM blockade attenuated increases in stress-responsive HR and MAP. PS blockade elevated stress-responsive HR and MAP to a greater extent in vehicle females. SYM and PS blockade produced equivalent effects on HR and MAP responses in male offspring, regardless of maternal treatment. Based on these findings, we suggest that maternal DEX injection disrupted autonomic regulation of cardiovascular function in females, resulting in a shift toward greater SYM input and less input from PS. Future studies will investigate whether changes in autonomic function are mediated by changes in central autonomic circuitry.NEW & NOTEWORTHY Pharmacological antagonists are used to characterize the nature of the autonomic dysregulation induced in female offspring exposed to dexamethasone, in utero. The female offspring of dams injected with dexamethasone in late gestation show a reduction in vulnerability to parasympathetic blockade and an increase in responses to acute restraint stress even in the presence of sympathetic blockade. This suggests that late gestation dexamethasone disrupts the normal development of the autonomic function in females, shifting sympathovagal balance.

Identifying sex similarities and differences in structure and function of the sinoatrial node in the mouse heart

Background

The sinoatrial node (SN) generates the heart rate (HR). Its spontaneous activity is regulated by a complex interplay between the modulation by the autonomic nervous system (ANS) and intrinsic factors including ion channels in SN cells. However, the systemic and intrinsic regulatory mechanisms are still poorly understood. This study aimed to elucidate the sex-specific differences in heart morphology and SN function, particularly focusing on basal HR, expression and function of hyperpolarization-activated HCN4 and HCN1 channels and mRNA abundance of ion channels and mRNA abundance of ion channels contributing to diastolic depolarization (DD) and spontaneous action potentials (APs).

Methods

Body weight, heart weight and tibia length of 2- to 3-month-old male and female mice were measured. Conscious in-vivo HR of male and female mice was recorded via electrocardiography (ECG). Unconscious ex-vivo HR, stroke volume (SV) and ejection fraction (EF) were recorded via echocardiography. Ex-vivo HR was measured via Langendorff apparatus. Volume of atria, ventricles and whole hearts were measured from the ex-vivo hearts by microcomputed tomography (micro-CT). Immunohistochemistry targeting HCN4 and HCN1 was conducted in the SN and RA tissues from both male and female hearts. The funny current (I f) of SN cells in 1 nM and following wash-on of 1 μM isoproterenol (ISO) were recorded via whole cell patch clamp. The APs of SN tissue were recorded via sharp microelectrode and optical mapping of membrane voltage. The relative abundance of mRNAs was measured in male and female mice by qPCR.

Results

Heart weight to tibia length ratio and heart volume of females were significantly smaller than males. Unconscious in-vivo HR in male mice was higher than that in females. Conscious in-vivo HR, ex-vivo HR, SV, and EF showed no notable difference between male and female mice. Immunohistochemistry revealed HCN4, HCN1, and the sum of HCN4 and HCN1, expression in the SN was notably elevated compared with the RA in both male and females, but there was no sex difference in these channels expression. There were also no significant sex differences in the V 0.5 of I f in SN cells in the presence of 1 nM ISO, however wash-on 1 μM ISO in the same cells induced a significantly increased shift of V 0.5 to more positive voltages in males than in females. The expression of mRNA coding for adrenergic receptor beta-1 (Adrb1) and cholinergic receptors muscarinic 2 (chrm2) in male mice was higher compared with that in female mice. Early diastolic depolarization (EDD) rate in APs from peripheral SN (pSN) from male mice were higher than these in female mice. Mice of both sexes showed equivalent frequency of SN APs and spatial localization of the leading site in control, and similar significant response to ISO 100 nM superfusion.

Conclusion

Males display faster in-vivo HR, but not ex-vivo HR, than females associated with increased expression of Adrb1 in male versus female. This suggests a possible difference in the β-adrenergic modulation in males and females, possibly related to the greater ISO response of I f observed in cells from males. The role of hormonal influences or differential expression of other ion channels may explain these sex-specific variations in HR dynamics. Further investigations are necessary to pinpoint the precise molecular substrates responsible for these differences.

Sex-specific behavioral, cardiac, and neuroendocrine responses to repeated witness social stress in adult rats

In humans, sex disparities exist in the prevalence of social stress-related disorders, yet our understanding of the predisposing factors and underlying mechanisms is still elusive. Also at the preclinical level, the investigation of sex differences in social stress responses is limited. In this study, adult male and female wild-type Groningen rats were repeatedly exposed to witness social defeat stress (WS) to assess sex-specific behavioral, neuroendocrine, and cardiac responses to the same social stress paradigm. Male and female rats bore witness to an aggressive social defeat episode between two males for nine consecutive days or were exposed to a control (CTR) procedure. Stress-related parameters were assessed in correspondence to the first and last WS/CTR exposure and also during subsequent exposure to the stress context alone in the absence of social defeat. During WS, rats of both sexes displayed larger amounts of burying behavior and smaller amounts of rearing and grooming behaviors, but with a greater extent in female witnesses. Cardiac autonomic responses to WS were similar between the sexes, yet only females displayed higher plasma corticosterone levels after the first WS exposure compared to CTRs, and had a larger corticosterone increase than male witnesses upon repeated WS. Exposure to the stress context alone (i.e., without the presence of the aggressive resident rat) elicited greater amount of burying behavior and more pronounced and persistent tachycardic responses in females than males with a history of WS. Our findings suggest sex-disparities in the response of adult rats to WS at multiple behavioral, cardiac, and neuroendocrine levels, highlighting the utility of this social stress paradigm for investigating predisposing factors and pathophysiological mechanisms underlying sex-specific vulnerabilities to stress-related pathologies.

Heart rate variability: A primer for alcohol researchers

Problem alcohol drinking remains a major cost and burden for society. Also, rates of problem drinking in women have dramatically increased in recent decades, and women are at risk for more alcohol problems and comorbidities. The purpose of this commentary is to discuss the potential utility of cardiac measures, including heart rate (HR) and HR variability (HRV), as markers of individual and sex differences in the drive to drink alcohol. We recently used cardiac telemetry in female and male adult rats to determine whether different cardiac markers, including HR and HRV, would differently predict alcohol and anxiety-like behavior across the sexes. Indeed, female behaviors related to HRV measures that indicate more parasympathetic (PNS) influence (the "rest and digest" system). In contrast, male behaviors are associated more with sympathetic (SNS) indicators (the activation system). Remarkably, similar sex differences in PNS versus SNS engagement under challenge are seen in several human studies, suggesting strong cross-species convergence in differential autonomic regulation in females and males. Here, we describe the larger challenges that alcohol addiction presents, and how HRV measures may provide new biomarkers to help enhance development of more individualized and sex-specific treatments. We briefly explain the physiological systems underlying cardiac PNS and SNS states, and how specific HRV metrics are defined and validated, especially why particular HRV measures are considered to reflect more PNS versus SNS influence. Finally, we describe hormonal influences and sex differences in brain circuits related to cardiac autonomic regulation. Together, these findings show that HR and HRV have potential for uncovering key underlying mechanisms of sex and individual differences in autonomic drivers, which could guide more personalized treatment.

Prenatal Dexamethasone Programs Autonomic Dysregulation in Female Rats

Autonomic dysfunction is associated with cardiovascular and neurological disease, including hypertension, heart failure, anxiety, and stress-related disorders. Prior studies demonstrated that late gestation exposure to dexamethasone (DEX) resulted in female-biased increases in stress-responsive mean arterial pressure (MAP) and heart rate (HR), suggesting a role for glucocorticoid-mediated programming of autonomic dysfunction. The present study investigated the influence of sympathetic (SYM) or parasympathetic (PS) blockade on cardiovascular function in male and female rat offspring of mothers injected with DEX in utero (gestation days [GD]18-21). At 11-12-weeks of age, MAP, HR, and heart rate variability (HRV) were evaluated at baseline and in response to SYM antagonists (α 1 -adrenoceptor + β 1 -adrenoceptor), a PS (muscarinic) antagonist, or saline (SAL). To assess stress-responsive function, rats were exposed to acute restraint. Tyrosine hydroxylase was measured in adrenals and left ventricle, and gene expression for the β 1 adrenergic receptor was measured in left ventricle. Maternal DEX injection reduced basal HRV in male and female offspring. SYM blockade attenuated increases in stress-responsive HR and MAP. PS blockade elevated stress-responsive HR and MAP to a greater extent in Vehicle females. SYM and PS blockade produced equivalent effects on HR and MAP responses in male offspring, regardless of maternal treatment. Based on these findings, we suggest that maternal DEX injection disrupted autonomic regulation of cardiovascular function in females, resulting in a shift toward greater SYM input and less input from PS. Future studies will investigate whether changes in autonomic function are mediated by changes in central autonomic circuitry.

New and Noteworthy

These studies use pharmacological antagonists to characterize the nature of the autonomic dysregulation induced in female offspring exposed to the synthetic glucocorticoid, dexamethasone, in utero . The female offspring of dams injected with dexamethasone in late gestation show a reduction in vulnerability to parasympathetic blockade and an increase in responses to acute restraint stress even in the presence of sympathetic blockade. This suggests that late gestation dexamethasone disrupts the normal development of the autonomic function in females leading to a shift in the sympathovagal balance.

Voluntary wheel running as a promising strategy to promote autonomic resilience to social stress in females: Vagal tone lies at the heart of the matter

Social stress is a major risk factor for comorbid conditions including cardiovascular disease and depression. While women exhibit 2-3× the risk for these stress-related disorders compared to men, the mechanisms underlying heightened stress susceptibility among females remain largely unknown. Due to a lack in understanding of the pathophysiology underlying stress-induced comorbidities among women, there has been a significant challenge in developing effective therapeutics. Recently, a causal role for inflammation has been established in the onset and progression of comorbid cardiovascular disease/depression, with women exhibiting increased sensitivity to stress-induced immune signaling. Importantly, reduced vagal tone is also implicated in stress susceptibility, through a reduction in the vagus nerve's well-recognized anti-inflammatory properties. Thus, examining therapeutic strategies that stabilize vagal tone during stress may shed light on novel targets for promoting stress resilience among women. Recently, accumulating evidence has demonstrated that physical activity exerts cardio- and neuro-protective effects by enhancing vagal tone. Based on this evidence, this mini review provides an overview of comorbid cardiovascular and behavioral dysfunction in females, the role of inflammation in these disorders, how stress may impart its negative effects on the vagus nerve, and how exercise may act as a preventative. Further, we highlight a critical gap in the literature with regard to the study of females in this field. This review also presents novel data that are the first to demonstrate a protective role for voluntary wheel running over vagal tone and biomarkers of cardiac dysfunction in the face of social stress exposure in female rats.

Sex differences in heart rate variability measures that predict alcohol drinking in rats

Problem alcohol drinking continues to be a substantial cost and burden. In addition, alcohol consumption in women has increased in recent decades, and women can have greater alcohol problems and comorbidities. Thus, there is a significant need for novel therapeutics to enhance sex-specific, individualized treatment. Heart rate (HR) and HR variability (HRV) are of broad interest because they may be both biomarkers for and drivers of pathological states. HRV reflects the dynamic balance between sympathetic (SNS, 'fight or flight') and parasympathetic (PNS, 'rest and digest') systems. Evidence from human studies suggest PNS predominance in women and SNS in men during autonomic regulation, indicating the possibility of sex differences in risk factors and physiological drivers of problem drinking. To better understand the association between HRV sex differences and alcohol drinking, we examined whether alcohol consumption levels correlated with time domain HRV measures (SDNN and rMSSD) at baseline, at alcohol drinking onset, and across 10 min of drinking, in adult female and male Wistar rats. In particular, we compared both HRV and HR measures under alcohol-only and compulsion-like conditions (alcohol + 10 mg/L quinine), because compulsion can often be a significant barrier to treatment of alcohol misuse. Importantly, previous work supports the possibility that different HRV measures could be interpreted to reflect PNS versus SNS influences. Here, we show that females with higher putative PNS indicators at baseline and at drinking onset had greater alcohol consumption. In contrast, male intake levels related to increased potential SNS measures at drinking onset. Once alcohol was consumed, HR predicted intake level in females, perhaps a pharmacological effect of alcohol. However, HRV changes were greater during compulsion-like intake versus alcohol-only, suggesting HRV changes (reduced SNS in females, reduced PNS and increased HR in males) specifically related to aversion-resistant intake. We find novel and likely clinically relevant autonomic differences associated with biological sex and alcohol drinking, suggesting that different autonomic mechanisms may promote differing aspects of female and male alcohol consumption.

Heart rate variability measures indicating sex differences in autonomic regulation during anxiety-like behavior in rats

Introduction

Mental health conditions remain a substantial and costly challenge to society, especially in women since they have nearly twice the prevalence of anxiety disorders. However, critical mechanisms underlying sex differences remain incompletely understood. Measures of cardiac function, including heart rate (HR) and HR variability (HRV), reflect balance between sympathetic (SNS) and parasympathetic (PNS) systems and are potential biomarkers for pathological states.

Methods

To better understand sex differences in anxiety-related autonomic mechanisms, we examined HR/HRV telemetry in food-restricted adult rats during novelty suppression of feeding (NSF), with conflict between food under bright light in the arena center. To assess HRV, we calculated the SDNN (reflective of both SNS and PNS contribution) and rMSSD (reflective of PNS contribution) and compared these metrics to behaviors within the anxiety task.

Results

Females had greater HR and lower SNS indicators at baseline, as in humans. Further, females (but not males) with higher basal HR carried this state into NSF, delaying first approach to center. In contrast, males with lower SNS measures approached and spent more time in the brightly-lit center. Further, females with lower SNS indicators consumed significantly more food. In males, a high-SNS subpopulation consumed no food. Among consumers, males with greater SNS ate more food.

Discussion

Together, these are congruent with human findings suggesting women engage PNS more, and men SNS more. Our previous behavior-only work also observed female differences from males during initial movement and food intake. Thus, high basal SNS in females reduced behavior early in NSF, while subsequent reduced SNS allowed greater food intake. In males, lower SNS increased engagement with arena center, but greater SNS predicted higher consumption. Our findings show novel and likely clinically relevant sex differences in HRV-behavior relationships.