Patient Safety Comparison of Frameless and Frame-Based Stereotactic Navigation for Brain Biopsy-A Single Center Cohort Study

Application accuracy of a frameless optical neuronavigation system as a guide for craniotomies in dogs

BACKGROUND

Optical neuronavigation systems using infrared light to create a virtual reality image of the brain allow the surgeon to track instruments in real time. Due to the high vulnerability of the brain, neurosurgical interventions must be performed with a high precision. The aim of the experimental cadaveric study was to determine the application accuracy of a frameless optical neuronavigation system as guide for craniotomies by determining the target point deviation of predefined target points at the skull surface in the area of access to the cerebrum, cerebellum and the pituitary fossa. On each of the five canine cadaver heads ten target points were marked in a preoperative computed tomography (CT) scan. These target points were found on the cadaver skulls using the optical neuronavigation system. Then a small drill hole (1.5 mm) was drilled at these points. Subsequently, another CT scan was made. Both CT data sets were fused into the neuronavigation software, and the actual target point coordinates were identified. The target point deviation was determined as the difference between the planned and drilled target point coordinates. The calculated deviation was compared between two observers.

RESULTS

The analysis of the target point accuracies of all dogs in both observers taken together showed a median target point deviation of 1.57 mm (range: 0.42 to 5.14 mm). No significant differences were found between the observers or the different areas of target regions.

CONCLUSION

The application accuracy of the described system is similar to the accuracy of other optical neuronavigation systems previously described in veterinary medicine, in which mean values of 1.79 to 4.3 mm and median target point deviations of 0.79 to 3.53 mm were determined.

Combined Use of Frameless Neuronavigation and In Situ Optical Guidance in Brain Tumor Needle Biopsies

Brain tumor needle biopsies are performed to retrieve tissue samples for neuropathological analysis. Although preoperative images guide the procedure, there are risks of hemorrhage and sampling of non-tumor tissue. This study aimed to develop and evaluate a method for frameless one-insertion needle biopsies with in situ optical guidance and present a processing pipeline for combined postoperative analysis of optical, MRI, and neuropathological data. An optical system for quantified feedback on tissue microcirculation, gray-whiteness, and the presence of a tumor (protoporphyrin IX (PpIX) accumulation) with a one-insertion optical probe was integrated into a needle biopsy kit that was used for frameless neuronavigation. In Python, a pipeline for signal processing, image registration, and coordinate transformation was set up. The Euclidian distances between the pre- and postoperative coordinates were calculated. The proposed workflow was evaluated on static references, a phantom, and three patients with suspected high-grade gliomas. In total, six biopsy samples that overlapped with the region of the highest PpIX peak without increased microcirculation were taken. The samples were confirmed as being tumorous and postoperative imaging was used to define the biopsy locations. A 2.5 ± 1.2 mm difference between the pre- and postoperative coordinates was found. Optical guidance in frameless brain tumor biopsies could offer benefits such as quantified in situ indication of high-grade tumor tissue and indications of increased blood flow along the needle trajectory before the tissue is removed. Additionally, postoperative visualization enables the combined analysis of MRI, optical, and neuropathological data.