Optimization Protocol of Fixation Method for Trophoblast Retrieval from the Cervix (TRIC): A Preliminary Study

Cervical EVT isolation for non-invasive fetal HLA typing in early pregnancy is limited by purity and maternal cell contamination; a methodological comparison

Introduction

Maternal-fetal HLA compatibility influences pregnancy outcome, including preeclampsia risk. Cervical extravillous trophoblasts (EVT) in early pregnancy provide a non-invasive source for fetal genome acquisition, potentially enabling fetal HLA typing for obstetric risk assessment. This study aimed to achieve fetal HLA typing through EVT isolation using HLA-G-coupled nanoparticle immunomagnetic separation (TRIC) and fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS).

Method

Cervical samples from 32 pregnant women were collected by cytobrush. Saliva and umbilical cord blood (n=13) served as maternal and fetal HLA genotype controls, respectively. Cervical samples from non-pregnant women, primary cultured EVT, and cryo-sectioned term placentas served as controls for cell phenotype, protein expression, and effect of fixation. FACS and TRIC were applied to isolate EVT from maternal cells, followed by RSSO-PCR for HLA typing. EVT presence pre- and post-isolation was determined through HLA-G, β-hCG, and Cytokeratin-7 (CK-7) expression. TRIC was optimized by improving antibody-binding-efficiency, and comparing three (nano)beads types and two magnets.

Results

Purity and yield of HLA-G+β-hCG+CK-7+ cells after TRIC failed to match pre-isolation HLA-G+ cell counts, despite protocol optimization. FACS revealed a fetal HLA genotype. In contrast, only the maternal HLA genotype was detected in TRIC-isolated cells.

Conclusion

EVT counts and maternal cell contamination limit reliable fetal HLA typing from cervical samples. Refining non-invasive EVT isolation techniques may enable fetal HLA typing to be included in risk assessment of pregnancy complications.

Limitations of Semi-Automated Immunomagnetic Separation of HLA-G-Positive Trophoblasts from Papanicolaou Smears for Prenatal Genetic Diagnostics

Background: In prenatal genetic diagnostics, the detection of single-gene defects relies on chorionic villus sampling (CVS) and amniocentesis, which carry a miscarriage risk of 0.2-0.3%. To mitigate this risk, fetal trophoblasts have been isolated from a Papanicolaou smear using Trophoblast Retrieval and Isolation from the Cervix (TRIC). However, this method is labor-intensive and has been shown to be challenging to implement in clinical practice. Here, we describe our experiences in using semi-automated immunomagnetic cell sorting for isolating trophoblasts from clinically obtained Papanicolaou smears during ongoing pregnancies. Methods: Using HLA-G-positive Jeg-3 and HLA-G-negative HeLa cell lines in 10%, 1%, and 0.1% dilutions, we tested and optimized the isolation of HLA-G-positive cells using FACS and semi-automated immunomagnetic cell sorting. We used the latter technique for isolation of HLA-G-positive cells from Papanicolaou smears collected from 26 pregnant women, gestational age between 6 and 20 weeks, who underwent CVS. Results: In four independent dilution series, the mean percentages of Jeg-3 cells went from 7.1% to 53.5%, 0.9% to 32.6%, and 0.4% to 2.6% (7.5, 36, and 6.5-fold enrichment, respectively) using immunomagnetic cell sorting. After sorting of the Papanicolaou smears, HLA-G-positive cells were moderately increased in the positive (14.61 vs. 11.63%) and decreased in the negative fraction (7.87 vs. 11.63%) compared to baseline pre-sorting. However, we could not identify fetal cells using XY-chromosomal FISH in a male sample. Conclusions: Our study supports previous findings that careful sampling of fetal cells from Papanicolaou smears in a clinical context poses significant challenges to cell retrieval.

A Novel Paradigm for Non-Invasive Prenatal Genetic Screening: Trophoblast Retrieval and Isolation from the Cervix (TRIC)

As the prevalence of pregnancies with advanced maternal age increases, the risk of fetal chromosomal abnormalities is on the rise. Therefore, prenatal genetic screening and diagnosis have become essential elements in contemporary obstetrical care. Trophoblast retrieval and isolation from the cervix (TRIC) is a non-invasive procedure that can be utilized for prenatal genetic diagnosis. The method involves the isolation of fetal cells (extravillous trophoblasts) by transcervical sampling; along with its non-invasiveness, TRIC exhibits many other advantages such as its usefulness in early pregnancy at 5 weeks of gestation, and no interference by various fetal and maternal factors. Moreover, the trophoblast yields from TRIC can provide valuable information about obstetrical complications related to abnormal placentation even before clinical symptoms arise. The standardization of this clinical tool is still under investigation, and the upcoming advancements in TRIC are expected to meet the increasing need for a safe and accurate option for prenatal diagnosis.

Advanced Strategy of Trophoblasts Retrieval and Isolation from the Cervix (TRIC): Comparison of Two HLA-G Antibodies for Immunomagnetic Isolation of Trophoblasts

Trophoblasts retrieval and isolation from the cervix (TRIC) is a non-invasive method which enables analysis of fetal genetic information from the extravillous trophoblast cells (EVTs). The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy of the HLA-G antibodies—G233 and 4H84—in isolating EVT cells and provide an optimized protocol of TRIC. We analyzed EVTs from 23 pregnant women in between 5 to 20 weeks of gestation who underwent invasive prenatal testing. Two HLA-G antibodies—G233 and 4H84—were used in a subgroup of 11 and 12 samples for immunomagnetic isolation. Cells with β-hCG expression were counted to compare the rate of isolated trophoblast cells. The rate of β-hCG positive cells was significantly different between the G233 and the 4H84 by immunefluorescence microscopy (p < 0.001). The percentage of β-hCG expressing cells in G233 and 4H84 groups were 62.4 ± 8.24% and 82.6 ± 7.1%, respectively (p < 0.001). The average fetal cell positive rate was 14.1 ± 3.78 in the G233 group while it was 25.8 ± 3.9 in the 4H84 group by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) (p = 0.011). Immunoisolation of trophoblast cells using 4H84 HLA-G antibody was more efficient in capturing EVT cells than using G233 for successful clinical application of TRIC.

Tricky TRIC: A replication study using trophoblast retrieval and isolation from the cervix to study genetic birth defects

OBJECTIVE

Noninvasive Prenatal Diagnosis has recently been introduced for a limited number of monogenetic disorders. However, the majority of DNA diagnostics still require fetal material obtained using an invasive test. Recently, a novel technique, TRIC (Trophoblast Retrieval and Isolation from the Cervix), has been described, which collects fetal trophoblast cells by endocervical sampling. Since this technique has not been successfully replicated by other groups, we aimed to achieve this in the current study.

METHOD

Pregnant women referred for transvaginal chorionic villous sampling (CVS) were asked for an endocervical sample prior to CVS. The TRIC samples were processed to isolate trophoblast DNA. TRIC DNA was used in ForenSeq to determine the amount of maternal DNA contamination, and for Sanger sequencing in case of a monogenic disorder.

RESULTS

23%-44% of samples had a sufficiently high fetal DNA fraction to allow genetic testing, as calculated by Sanger sequencing and ForenSeq, respectively.

CONCLUSION

We have been able to successfully replicate the TRIC protocol, although with a much lower success rate as described by the original study performing TRIC. As we obtained the samples in the actual clinical setting envisioned, the method in its current setup is not advisable for use in prenatal diagnostics.

Rarity of fetal cells in exocervical samples for noninvasive prenatal diagnosis

OBJECTIVES

The possibility to isolate fetal cells from pregnant women cervical samples has been discussed for five decades but is not currently applied in clinical practice. This study aimed at offering prenatal genetic diagnosis from fetal cells obtained through noninvasive exocervical sampling and immuno-sorted based on expression of HLA-G.

METHODS

We first developed and validated robust protocols for cell detection and isolation on control cell lines expressing (JEG-3) or not (JAR) the HLA-G antigen, a specific marker for extravillous trophoblasts. We then applied these protocols to noninvasive exocervical samples collected from pregnant women between 6 and 14 weeks of gestational age. Sampling was performed through insertion and rotation of a brush at the ectocervix close to the external os of the endocervical canal. Finally, we attempted to detect and quantify trophoblasts in exocervical samples from pregnant women by ddPCR targeting the male SRY locus.

RESULTS

For immunohistochemistry, a strong specific signal for HLA-G was observed in the positive control cell line and for rare cells in exocervical samples, but only in non-fixative conditions. HLA-G positive cells diluted in HLA-G negative cells were isolated by flow cytometry or magnetic cell sorting. However, no HLA-G positive cells could be recovered from exocervical samples. SRY gene was detected by ddPCR in exocervical samples from male (50%) but also female (27%) pregnancies.

CONCLUSIONS

Our data suggest that trophoblasts are too rarely and inconstantly present in noninvasive exocervical samples to be reliably retrieved by standard immunoisolation techniques and therefore cannot replace the current practice for prenatal screening and diagnosis.

Overview and recent developments in cell-based noninvasive prenatal testing

Investigators have long been interested in the natural phenomenon of fetal and placental cell trafficking into the maternal circulation. The scarcity of these circulating cells makes their detection and isolation technically challenging. However, as a DNA source of fetal origin not mixed with maternal DNA, they have the potential of considerable benefit over circulating cell-free DNA-based noninvasive prenatal genetic testing (NIPT). Endocervical trophoblasts, which are less rare but more challenging to recover are also being investigated as an approach for cell-based NIPT. We review published studies from around the world describing both forms of cell-based NIPT and highlight the different approaches' advantages and drawbacks. We also offer guidance for developing a sound cell-based NIPT protocol.