Concatenation of Transgenic DNA: Random or Orchestrated?

Prevalent integration of genomic repetitive and regulatory elements and donor sequences at CRISPR-Cas9-induced breaks

CRISPR-Cas9 genome editing has been extensively applied in both academia and clinical settings, but its genotoxic risks, including large insertions (LgIns), remain poorly studied due to methodological limitations. This study presents the first detailed report of unintended LgIns consistently induced by different Cas9 editing regimes using various types of donors across multiple gene loci. Among these insertions, retrotransposable elements (REs) and host genomic coding and regulatory sequences are prevalent. RE frequencies and 3D genome organization analysis suggest LgIns originate from randomly acquired genomic fragments by DNA repair mechanisms. Additionally, significant unintended full-length and concatemeric double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) donor integrations occur when donor DNA is present. We further demonstrate that phosphorylated dsDNA donors consistently reduce large insertions and deletions by almost two-fold without compromising homology-directed repair (HDR) efficiency. Taken together, our study addresses a ubiquitous and overlooked risk of unintended LgIns in Cas9 editing, contributing valuable insights for the safe use of Cas9 editing tools.

The widely used Ucp1-Cre transgene elicits complex developmental and metabolic phenotypes

Bacterial artificial chromosome transgenic models, including most Cre-recombinases, enable potent interrogation of gene function in vivo but require rigorous validation as limitations emerge. Due to its high relevance to metabolic studies, we perform comprehensive analysis of the Ucp1-CreEvdr line which is widely used for brown fat research. Hemizygotes exhibit major brown and white fat transcriptomic dysregulation, indicating potential altered tissue function. Ucp1-CreEvdr homozygotes also show high mortality, tissue specific growth defects, and craniofacial abnormalities. Mapping the transgene insertion site reveals insertion in chromosome 1 accompanied by large genomic alterations disrupting several genes expressed in a range of tissues. Notably, Ucp1-CreEvdr transgene retains an extra Ucp1 gene copy that may be highly expressed under high thermogenic burden. Our multi-faceted analysis highlights a complex phenotype arising from the presence of the Ucp1-CreEvdr transgene independently of intended genetic manipulations. Overall, comprehensive validation of transgenic mice is imperative to maximize discovery while mitigating unexpected, off-target effects.

Characterizing a lethal CAG-ACE2 transgenic mouse model for SARS-CoV-2 infection using Cas9-enhanced nanopore sequencing

The SARS-CoV-2 pandemic has underscored the necessity for functional transgenic animal models for testing. Mouse lines with overexpression of the human receptor ACE2 serve as the common animal model to study COVID-19 infection. Overexpression of ACE2 under a strong ubiquitous promoter facilitates convenient and sensitive testing of COVID-19 pathology. We performed pronuclear microinjections using a 5 kb CAG-ACE2 linear transgene construct and identified three founder lines with 140, 72, and 73 copies, respectively. Two of these lines were further analyzed for ACE2 expression profiles and sensitivity to SARS-CoV-2 infection. Both lines expressed ACE2 in all organs analyzed. Embryonic fibroblast cell lines derived from transgenic embryos demonstrated severe cytopathic effects following infection, even at low doses of SARS-CoV-2 (0,1-1.0 TCID50). Infected mice from the two lines began to show COVID-19 clinical signs three days post-infection and succumbed between days 4 and 7. Histological examination of lung tissues from terminally ill mice revealed severe pathological alterations. To further characterize the integration site in one of the lines, we applied nanopore sequencing combined with Cas9 enrichment to examine the internal transgene concatemer structure. Oxford Nanopore sequencing (ONT) is becoming the gold standard for transgene insert characterization, but it is relatively inefficient without targeted region enrichment. We digested genomic DNA with Cas9 and gRNA against the ACE2 transgene to create ends suitable for ONT adapter ligation. ONT data analysis revealed that most of the transgene copies were arranged in a head-to-tail configuration, with palindromic junctions being rare. We also detected occasional plasmid backbone fragments within the concatemer, likely co-purified during transgene gel extraction, which is a common occurrence in pronuclear microinjections.

The widely used Ucp1-CreEvdr transgene elicits complex developmental and metabolic phenotypes

Bacterial artificial chromosome transgenic models, including most Cre-recombinases, enable potent interrogation of gene function in vivo but require rigorous validation as limitations emerge. Due to its high relevance to metabolic studies, we performed comprehensive analysis of the Ucp1-CreEvdr line which is widely used for brown fat research. Hemizygotes exhibited major brown and white fat transcriptomic dysregulation, indicating potential altered tissue function. Ucp1-CreEvdr homozygotes also show high mortality, growth defects, and craniofacial abnormalities. Mapping the transgene insertion site revealed insertion in chromosome 1 accompanied by large genomic alterations disrupting several genes expressed in a range of tissues. Notably, Ucp1-CreEvdr transgene retains an extra Ucp1 gene copy that may be highly expressed under high thermogenic burden. Our multi-faceted analysis highlights a complex phenotype arising from the presence of the Ucp1-CreEvdr transgene independently of the intended genetic manipulations. Overall, comprehensive validation of transgenic mice is imperative to maximize discovery while mitigating unexpected, off-target effects.

An efficient transformation method for genome editing of elite bread wheat cultivars

An efficient genetic transformation protocol is necessary to edit genes for trait improvement directly in elite bread wheat cultivars. We used a protein fusion between a wheat growth-regulating factor 4 (GRF4) and its interacting factor (GIF1) to develop a reproducible genetic transformation and regeneration protocol, which we then used to successfully transform elite bread wheat cultivars Baj, Kachu, Morocco, Reedling, RL6077, and Sujata in addition to the experimental cultivar Fielder. Immature embryos were transformed with the vector using particle bombardment method. Transformation frequency increased nearly 60-fold with the GRF4-GIF1-containing vectors as compared to the control vector and ranged from ~5% in the cultivar Kachu to 13% in the cultivar RL6077. We then edited two genes that confer resistance against leaf rust and powdery mildew directly in the aforementioned elite cultivars. A wheat promoter, TaU3 or TaU6, to drive the expression of guide RNA was effective in gene editing whereas the OsU3 promoter failed to generate any edits. Editing efficiency was nearly perfect with the wheat promoters. Our protocol has made it possible to edit genes directly in elite wheat cultivars and would be useful for gene editing in other wheat varieties, which have been recalcitrant to transformation thus far.

Deciphering integration loci of CHO manufacturing cell lines using long read nanopore sequencing

Despite advances in genetic characterization of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cell lines regarding identification of integration sites using next generation sequencing, e.g. targeted locus amplification sequencing (TLA-seq), the concatemer structure of the integrated vectors remains elusive. Here, the entire integration locus of two CHO manufacturing cell lines was reconstructed combining CRISPR/Cas9 target enrichment, nanopore sequencing and the Canu de novo assembly pipeline. An IgG producing CHO cell line integrated 3 vector copies, which were near full-length and contained all relevant vector elements such as transgenes and their promoters on each of the vector copies. In contrast, a second CHO cell line producing a bivalent bispecific antibody integrated 7 highly fragmented vector copies in different orientations leading to head-to-head and tail-to-tail fusions. The size of the vector fragments ranged from 3.0 to 11.4 kbp each carrying 1-3 transgenes. The breakpoints of the genome-vector and vector-vector junctions were validated using Sanger sequencing and Southern blotting. A comparison to TLA-seq data confirmed the genomic breakpoints, but most of the breakpoints of the vector-vector fusions were missed by TLA-seq. For the first time, the complete transgene locus of CHO manufacturing cell lines could be deciphered. Strikingly, the application of the nanopore long-read sequencing technology led to novel insights into the complexity of genomic transgene integrations of CHO manufacturing cell lines generated via random integration.

Increased On-Target Rate and Risk of Concatemerization after CRISPR-Enhanced Targeting in ES Cells

The French mouse clinic (Institut Clinique de la Souris; ICS) has produced more than 2000 targeting vectors for 'à la carte' mutagenesis in C57BL/6N mice. Although most of the vectors were used successfully for homologous recombination in murine embryonic stem cells (ESCs), a few have failed to target a specific locus after several attempts. We show here that co-electroporation of a CRISPR plasmid with the same targeting construct as the one that failed previously allows the systematic achievement of positive clones. A careful validation of these clones is, however, necessary as a significant number of clones (but not all) show a concatemerization of the targeting plasmid at the locus. A detailed Southern blot analysis permitted characterization of the nature of these events as standard long-range 5' and 3' PCRs were not able to distinguish between correct and incorrect alleles. We show that a simple and inexpensive PCR performed prior to ESC amplification allows detection and elimination of those clones with concatemers. Finally, although we only tested murine ESCs, our results highlight the risk of mis-validation of any genetically modified cell line (such as established lines, induced pluripotent stem cells or those used for ex vivo gene therapy) that combines the use of CRISPR/Cas9 and a circular double-stranded donor. We strongly advise the CRISPR community to perform a Southern blot with internal probes when using CRISPR to enhance homologous recombination in any cell type, including fertilized oocytes.

Genetic quality: a complex issue for experimental study reproducibility

Laboratory animal research involving mice, requires consideration of many factors to be controlled. Genetic quality is one factor that is often overlooked but is essential for the generation of reproducible experimental results. Whether experimental research involves inbred mice, spontaneous mutant, or genetically modified strains, exercising genetic quality through careful breeding, good recordkeeping, and prudent quality control steps such as validation of the presence of mutations and verification of the genetic background, will help ensure that experimental results are accurate and that reference controls are representative for the particular experiment. In this review paper, we will discuss various techniques used for the generation of genetically altered mice, and the different aspects to be considered regarding genetic quality, including inbred strains and substrains used, quality check controls during and after genetic manipulation and breeding. We also provide examples for when to use the different techniques and considerations on genetic quality checks. Further, we emphasize on the importance of establishing an in-house genetic quality program.

The human EF1a promoter does not provide expression of the transgene in mice

In this work, we set out to create mice susceptible to the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus. To ensure the ubiquitous expression of the human ACE2 gene we used the human EF1a promoter. Using pronuclear microinjection of the transgene construct, we obtained six founders with the insertion of the EF1a-hACE2 transgene, from which four independent mouse lines were established. Unfortunately, only one line had low levels of hACE2 expression in some organs. In addition, we did not detect the hACE2 protein in primary lung fibroblasts from any of the transgenic lines. Bisulfite sequencing analysis revealed that the EF1a promoter was hypermethylated in the genomes of transgenic animals. Extensive analysis of published works about transgenic animals indicated that EF1a transgenic constructs are frequently inactive. Thus, our case cautions against using the EF1a promoter to generate transgenic animals, as it is prone to epigenetic silencing.