Relevant Aspects of Titanium and Zirconia Dental Implants for Their Fatigue and Osseointegration Behaviors

Comparison of Hydrophilic Properties of Titanium and Zirconia Dental Implants' Surfaces

One of the key factors influencing osseointegration is the hydrophilicity of the surface of dental implants; high hydrophilicity is more advantageous than low hydrophilicity. This study aimed to compare the hydrophilic properties of titanium and zirconia implants from different manufacturers. An in vitro analysis was conducted on 15 implants-13 titanium and 2 zirconia-each featuring distinct compositions and surface treatments. Their hydrophilicity was assessed using the contact angle method, where a drop of saline solution was pipetted onto the apical part of the implant. For each implant, 30 contact angle measurements were taken at three different surface wetting time intervals. The contact angle is defined as the internal angle between the tangent to the surface of the liquid and the surface at the point of tangency; a smaller angle means a higher hydrophilicity. The results show that titanium implants from BTI UniCa, Nobel TiUltra, and Straumann Roxolid SLActive-which are classified as premium implants-exhibited the highest hydrophilicity. In contrast, zirconia implants demonstrated significantly lower hydrophilicity. Within this group, the Nobel Pearl implant exhibited smaller contact angles than the Bredent WhiteSKY implant. Our findings confirm that high-quality titanium implants show superior hydrophilicity, potentially improving clinical outcomes by accelerating healing and facilitating immediate loading protocols, but this could only be proven with an in vivo animal study. Conversely, the relatively lower hydrophilicity of zirconia implants highlights the need for continued advancements in zirconia composition and surface modification to optimize their osseointegration potential.

Residual Stress Homogenization of Hybrid Implants

OBJECTIVES

Hybrid implants commonly exhibit decreased corrosion resistance and fatigue due to differences in compressive residual stresses between the smooth and rough surfaces. The main objective of this study was to investigate the influence of an annealing heat treatment to reduce the residual stresses in hybrid implants.

METHODOLOGY

Commercially pure titanium (CpTi) bars were heat-treated at 800 °C and different annealing times. Optical microscopy was used to analyze the resulting grain growth kinetics. Diffractometry was used to measure residual stress after heat treatment, corrosion resistance by open circuit potential (EOCP), corrosion potentials (ECORR), and corrosion currents (ICORR) of heat-treated samples, as well as fatigue behavior by creep testing. The von Mises distribution and the resulting microstrains in heat-treated hybrid implants and in cortical and trabecular bone were assessed by finite element analysis. The results of treated hybrid implants were compared to those of untreated hybrid implants and hybrid implants with a rough surface (shot-blasted).

RESULTS

The proposed heat treatment (800 °C for 30 min, followed by quenching in water at 20 °C) could successfully homogenize the residual stress difference between the two surfaces of the hybrid implant (-20.2 MPa). It provides better fatigue behavior and corrosion resistance (p ˂ 0.05, ANOVA). Stress distribution was significantly improved in the trabecular bone. Heat-treated hybrid implants performed worse than implants with a rough surface.

CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE

Annealing heat treatment can be used to improve the mechanical properties and corrosion resistance of hybrid surface implants by homogenizing residual stresses.

In vitro evaluation of the biocompatibility and bioactivity of a SLM-fabricated NiTi alloy with superior tensile property

Because nickel-titanium (NiTi) alloys have unique functions, such as superelasticity, shape memory, and hysteresis similar to bone in the loading-unloading cycles of their recoverable deformations. They likely offer good bone integration, a low loosening rate, individual customization, and ease of insertion. Due to the poor processability of NITI, traditional methods cannot manufacture NiTi products with complex shapes. Orthopedic NiTi implants need to show an adequate fracture elongation of at least 8%. Additive manufacturing can be used to prepare NiTi implants with complex structures and tunable porosity. However, as previously reported, additively manufactured NiTi alloys could only exhibit a maximum tensile fracture strain of 7%. In new reports, a selective laser melting (SLM)-NiTi alloy has shown greater tensile strain (15.6%). Nevertheless, due to the unique microstructure of additive manufacturing NiTi that differs from traditional NITI, the biocompatibility of SLM-NITI manufactured by this new process requires further evaluation In this study, the effects of the improved NiTi alloy on bone marrow mesenchymal stem cell (BMSC) proliferation, adhesion, and cell viability were investigated via in vitro studies. A commercial Ti-6Al-4V alloy was studied side-by-side for comparison. Like the Ti-6Al-4V alloy, the SLM-NiTi alloy exhibited low cytotoxicity toward BMSCs and similar effect on cell adhesion or cell viability. This study demonstrates that the new SLM-NiTi alloy, which has exhibited improved mechanical properties, also displays excellent biocompatibility. Therefore, this alloy may be a superior implant material in biomedical implantation.

Influence of Titanium Surface Residual Stresses on Osteoblastic Response and Bacteria Colonization

Grit basting is the most common process applied to titanium dental implants to give them a roughness that favors bone colonization. There are numerous studies on the influence of roughness on osseointegration, but the influence of the compressive residual stress associated with this treatment on biological behavior has not been determined. For this purpose, four types of surfaces have been studied using 60 titanium discs: smooth, smooth with residual stress, rough without stress, and rough with residual stress. Roughness was studied by optic interferometry; wettability and surface energy (polar and dispersive components) by contact angle equipment using three solvents; and residual stresses by Bragg-Bentano X-ray diffraction. The adhesion and alkaline phosphatase (ALP) levels on the different surfaces were studied using Saos-2 osteoblastic cultures. The bacterial strains Streptococcus sanguinis and Lactobacillus salivarius were cultured on different surfaces, determining the adhesion. The results showed that residual stresses lead to increased hydrophilicity on the surfaces, as well as an increase in surface energy, especially on the polar component. From the culture results, higher adhesion and higher ALP levels were observed in the discs with residual stresses when compared between smooth and roughened discs. It was also found that roughness was the property that mostly influenced osteoblasts' response. Bacteria colonize rough surfaces better than smooth surfaces, but no changes are observed due to residual surface tension.

Biological effects of gamma-ray sterilization on 3 mol% yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystal: An in vitro study

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Selecting the sterilization method is important because sterilization can alter the surface chemistry of implant materials, including zirconia, and influence their cellular biocompatibility. Studies on the biological effects of sterilization on implant materials are lacking.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this in vitro study was to evaluate the biocompatibility of gamma-ray irradiated 3 mol% yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia polycrystal (3Y-TZP) compared with unirradiated titanium, 3Y-TZP, and pure gold.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Disk-shaped specimens each of commercially pure grade 4 titanium, 3Y-TZP, gamma-rayed 3Y-TZP, and pure gold were prepared and evaluated for osteogenic potential by using a clonal murine cell line of immature osteoblasts derived from mice (MC3T3-E1 cells). The surface topography (n=3), chemical analysis of the disks (n=3), and cell morphology cultured on these surfaces were examined using scanning electron microscopy, confocal laser scanning microscopy, and energy dispersive spectroscopy. Cellular biocompatibility was analyzed for 1 and 3 days after seeding. Cell adhesion and spreading were evaluated using confocal laser scanning microscopy (n=3). Cell proliferation was evaluated using methyl thiazolyl tetrazolium assay (n=3). Kruskal-Wallis and Bonferroni corrections were used to evaluate the statistical significance of the intergroup differences (α=.05).

RESULTS

Gamma-ray sterilization of 3Y-TZP showed significantly higher surface roughness compared with titanium and gold (P<.002). On day 1, the proliferation and adhesion of MC3T3-E1 cells cultured on gamma-rayed 3Y-TZP were significantly higher than those cultured on gold (P<.05); however, cell spreading was significantly lower than that of titanium on days 1 and 3 (P<.05). On day 3, cell proliferation of gamma-rayed 3Y-TZP was significantly lower than that of unirradiated 3Y-TZP (P<.05). Cell adhesion of gamma-rayed 3Y-TZP was slightly lower than that of zirconia and titanium but without significant difference (P>.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Gamma-rayed zirconia exhibited increased surface roughness compared with titanium and significantly decreased bioactivity compared with titanium and zirconia. The use of gamma-ray sterilization on zirconia is not promising regarding biocompatibility, and the effect of this sterilization method on implant materials warrants further investigation.

Stress-strain and fatigue life numerical evaluation of two different dental implants considering isotropic and anisotropic human jaw

Dental prostheses are currently a valid solution for replacing potential missing tooth or edentulism clinical condition. Nevertheless, the oral cavity is a dynamic and complex system: occlusal loads, external agents, or other unpleasant events can impact on implants functionality and stability causing a future revision surgery. One of the failure origins is certainly the dynamic loading originated from daily oral activities like eating, chewing, and so on. The aim of this paper was to evaluate, by a numerical analysis based on Finite Elements Method (FEM), and to discuss in a comparative way, firstly, the stress-strain of two different adopted dental implants and, subsequently, their fatigue life according to common standard of calculations. For this investigation, the jawbone was modeled accounting for either isotropic or anisotropic behavior. It was composed of cortical and cancellous regions, considering it completely osseointegrated with the implants. The impact of implants' fixture design, loading conditions, and their effect on the mandible bone was finally investigated, on the basis of the achieved numerical results. Lastly, the life cycle of the investigated implants was estimated according to the well-established theories of Goodman, Soderberg, and Gerber by exploiting the outcomes obtained by the numerical simulations, providing interesting conclusions useful in the dental practice.

Investigation of the Influence of Roughness and Dental Implant Design on Primary Stability via Analysis of Insertion Torque and Implant Stability Quotient: An In Vitro Study

In the placement of dental implants, the primary fixation between the dental implant and the bone is of great importance and corresponds to compressive mechanical fixation that aims to prevent micromovement of the implant. The aim of this research was to determine the role of roughness and the type of dental implant (tissue-level or bone-level) in implant stability, measured using resonance frequency analysis (RFA) and insertion torque (IT). We analyzed 234 titanium dental implants, placed in fresh calf ribs, at the half-tissue level and half-bone level. The implant surface was subjected to grit-blasting treatments with alumina particles of 120, 300, and 600 μm at a projection pressure of 2.5 bar, resulting in three types of roughness. Roughness was determined via optical interferometry. The wettability of the surfaces was also determined. Implant stability was measured using a high-precision torquemeter to obtain IT, and RFA was used to determine the implant stability quotient (ISQ). The results show that rough surfaces with Sa values of 0.5 to 4 μm do not affect the primary stability. However, the type of implant is important; bone-level implants obtained the highest primary stability values. A good correlation between the primary stability values obtained via IT and ISQ was demonstrated. New in vivo studies are necessary to know whether these results can be maintained in the long term.

Retentive force of a conical crown with CAD/CAM-fabricated PEEK and zirconia secondary crowns on titanium implant abutments

This study aimed to evaluate the retentive force of polyetheretherketone (PEEK) and zirconia secondary crowns on ready-made titanium implant abutments (with height, diameter, and taper as 5.5 mm, 4.5 mm, and 6°, respectively) as the primary crown. PEEK, zirconia, and titanium secondary crowns were fabricated using a CAD/CAM system. Insertion and removal tests of secondary crowns on the primary crown were conducted for 2,000 cycles. The initial retentive forces recorded at the 100th cycle for PEEK, zirconia, and titanium were 13.0±7.9, 2.9±2.6, and 27.6±1.7 N, respectively. The retentive forces of PEEK and zirconia showed no significant difference among all cycles. However, the retentive force of the titanium used as a control decreased (20.3±2.8 N) significantly at the 2,000th cycle. Although the retentive force of PEEK was lower than that of titanium, it was within the range that can provide a suitable retentive force of 5 N for removable dental prostheses.