Clinical outcome of proton therapy for patients with chordomas

Proton beam therapy for clival chordoma: Optimising rare cancer treatments in Australia

With the anticipated launch of the Australian Bragg Centre for Proton Therapy and Research (ABCPTR) in Adelaide, Australia, proton therapy will become a significant addition to existing cancer treatment options for Australians. The anticipated benefits will be particularly evident in rare cancers such as clival chordomas, a challenging tumour entity due to the anatomical relationship with critical structures, and proven radio-resistance to conventional radiation therapy. The article synthesises key findings from major studies and evaluates the current evidence supporting various management strategies for clival chordomas. It also considers the influence of institutional volume and multidisciplinary team management on patient outcomes and outlines how high-quality care can be effectively delivered within the Australian healthcare system, emphasising the potential impact of proton therapy on the treatment paradigm of clival chordomas in Australia.

Intensity-modulated radiotherapy for the management of primary and recurrent chordomas: a retrospective long-term follow-up study

Background

Chordomas have a high risk of recurrence. Radiotherapy (RT) is required as adjuvant therapy after resection. Sufficient radiation doses for local control (LC) can be achieved using either particle therapy, if this technology is available and feasible, or intensity-modulated radiotherapy.

Materials and methods

57 patients (age, 11.8-81.6 years) with chordomas of the skull base, spine and pelvis who received photon radiotherapy between 1995 and 2017 were enrolled in the study. Patients were treated at the time of initial diagnosis (68.4%) or during recurrence (31.6%). 44 patients received adjuvant radiotherapy and 13 received definitive radiotherapy. The median total dose to the physical target volume was 70 Gy equivalent dose in 2 Gy fractions (EQD2) (range: 54.7-82.5) in 22-36 fractions.

Results

LC was 76.4%, 58.4%, 46.7% and 39.9% and overall survival (OS) was 98.3%, 89%, 76.9% and 47.9% after 1, 3, 5 and 10 years, respectively, with a median follow-up period of 6.5 years (range, 0.5-24.3 years). Age, dose and treatment concept (post-operative or definitive) were significant prognostic factors for OS. Primary treatment, macroscopic tumour at RT and size of the irradiated volume were statistically significant prognostic factors for LC.

Conclusion

Photon treatment is a safe and effective treatment for chordomas if no particle therapy is available. The best results can be achieved against primary tumours if the application of curative doses is possible due to organs at risk in direct proximity. We recommend high-dose radiotherapy, regardless of the resection status, as part of the initial treatment of chordoma, using the high conformal radiation technique if particle therapy is not feasible.

Clinical outcomes and toxicities of 100 patients treated with proton therapy for chordoma on the proton collaborative group prospective registry

BACKGROUND

We present efficacy and toxicity outcomes among patients with chordoma treated on the Proton Collaborative Group prospective registry.

METHODS

Consecutive chordoma patients treated between 2010-2018 were evaluated. One hundred fifty patients were identified, 100 had adequate follow-up information. Locations included base of skull (61%), spine (23%), and sacrum (16%). Patients had a performance status of ECOG 0-1 (82%) and median age of 58 years. Eighty-five percent of patients underwent surgical resection. The median proton RT dose was 74 Gy (RBE) (range 21-86 Gy (RBE)) using passive scatter proton RT (PS-PBT) (13%), uniform scanning proton RT (US-PBT) (54%) and pencil beam scanning proton RT (PBS-PBT) (33%). Rates of local control (LC), progression-free survival (PFS), overall survival (OS) and acute and late toxicities were assessed.

RESULTS

2/3-year LC, PFS, and OS rates are 97%/94%, 89%/74%, and 89%/83%, respectively. LC did not differ based on surgical resection (p = 0.61), though this is likely limited by most patients having undergone a prior resection. Eight patients experienced acute grade 3 toxicities, most commonly pain (n = 3), radiation dermatitis (n = 2), fatigue (n = 1), insomnia (n = 1) and dizziness (n = 1). No grade ≥ 4 acute toxicities were reported. No grade ≥ 3 late toxicities were reported, and most common grade 2 toxicities were fatigue (n = 5), headache (n = 2), CNS necrosis (n = 1), and pain (n = 1).

CONCLUSIONS

In our series, PBT achieved excellent safety and efficacy outcomes with very low rates of treatment failure. CNS necrosis is exceedingly low (<1%) despite the high doses of PBT delivered. Further maturation of data and larger patient numbers are necessary to optimize therapy in chordoma.

Recurrent L3 Chordoma Presented as Intradural Extramedullary Mass With Distant Metastasis: A Case Report

Here, we report a rare case of L3 chordoma progressed to an intradural extramedullary (IDEM) mass and distant metastasis to the fascia lata. A 64-year old female patient presented to a local university hospital due to back pain and received excisional biopsy for a L3 destructive bony lesion. Local radiation therapy was initially administered, assuming a malignancy of unknown origin, but she developed cerebrospinal fluid leakage during adjuvant radiation therapy, which was managed by wound revision and lumbar drainage. As the destructive lesion progressed, she visited our hospital for a second opinion 3 months after the biopsy. After review of outside pathology, we diagnosed the lesion to be a chordoma, and performed a L3 corpectomy with cage and plate fixation. One and a half years later, positron emission tomography and computed tomography (PET-CT) revealed a right tensor fascia lata hypermetabolic lesion. Excisional biopsy confirmed a distant metastasis of the chordoma. One year later, she complained of L2 radiating pain. PET-CT and CT myelogram revealed an IDEM lesion. Surgical excision confirmed the transdural invasion of the chordoma. To our knowledge, this is the first report of an iatrogenic IDEM invasion and distant metastasis to the tensor of the fascia lata by a L3 chordoma.

Who Will Benefit from Charged-Particle Therapy?

Charged-particle therapy (CPT) such as proton beam therapy (PBT) and carbon-ion radiotherapy (CIRT) exhibit substantial physical and biological advantages compared to conventional photon radiotherapy. As it can reduce the amount of radiation irradiated in the normal organ, CPT has been mainly applied to pediatric cancer and radioresistent tumors in the eloquent area. Although there is a possibility of greater benefits, high set-up cost and dearth of high level of clinical evidence hinder wide applications of CPT. This review aims to present recent clinical results of PBT and CIRT in selected diseases focusing on possible indications of CPT. We also discussed how clinical studies are conducted to increase the number of patients who can benefit from CPT despite its high cost.

High-dose proton therapy and tomotherapy for the treatment of sacral chordoma: a retrospective monocentric study

OBJECTIVE

Radiation therapy (RT) is used for the treatment of sacral chordoma, in combination with surgery or alone for unresected tumours, to improve local control (LC) and potentially overall survival (OS). The purpose of the present study was to evaluate efficacy and toxicity of proton therapy (PT), and/or intensity modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), particularly Tomotherapy, for sacral chordoma treatment. Material: Between November 2005 and June 2018, 41 consecutive patients who were not included in clinical trials, received sacral chordoma radiation treatment in Institut Curie with Tomotherapy alone in 13 patients, and combined PT and Tomotherapy boost (Proton - Tomo) in 28 patients. RT was delivered as the exclusive local treatment in 11 patients, and as a post-operative complementary treatment in 30 patients.

RESULTS

After a median follow-up of 46 months (range, 0-125 months), eight local relapses were observed, and seven patients developed distant metastasis (particularly bone and lung). The 2- and 5- year local relapse rates were 11.4% CI (0.65-22.2%) and 29% (10.5-47.4%), respectively. Over the follow-up period, ten patients died (24.4%). The estimated 2- and 5-year OS rates were 91.4% CI (82.5-100%) and 74.5% (59.4-93.5%), respectively. Fibrosis, cauda equina syndrome, and pain were the most common late toxicities. The comparison between Tomotherapy alone and Proton - Tomo revealed that acute and late cystitis were significantly more frequent in the Tomotherapy group: SHR = 0.12 IC95% (0.01-0.90 [p = .04]), as well as late proctitis. A dosimetric comparison confirmed the interest of PT to spare rectum and bladder in this context.

CONCLUSION

RT remains essential to improve local control in sacral chordoma. The combination of proton and photon seems to improve organ at risk sparing, resulting in a decreased rate of reported late toxicities.

Radiation Strategies for Spine Chordoma: Proton Beam, Carbon Ions, and Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy

Surgery alone provides suboptimal local control of spine and sacral chordomas. Radiotherapy (RT) may improve local control in patients undergoing surgery and be used as definitive-intent treatment in patients not undergoing surgery. Although conventional-dose RT is inadequate for these radioresistant tumors, newer techniques allow treatment of the tumor to higher, more effective doses while limiting spinal cord dose to safe levels. The best local control is achieved when RT is delivered in the primary setting; RT dose is a critical determinant of local control. RT should be considered for all spine and sacral chordoma patients.

Giant cell tumors of the sacrum: is non-operative treatment effective?

PURPOSE

Giant cell tumors of sacrum in which surgery could endanger important neural components were treated with short term denosumab, angioembolisation and radiotherapy in different combinations to provide a non-operative function preserving treatment option.

METHODS

Between April 2013 and April 2017, 13 sacral GCTs [proximal extent of disease-S1 (10), S2 (2) and S3 (1)] were treated. Age ranged from 20 to 50 years. One patient had loss of bladder control at presentation. Treatment protocol included short term denosumab, angioembolisation and radiotherapy in different combinations. Patients were evaluated every 10-12 weeks. If disease ceased to progress no further treatment was advised. In case of progress, patient was advised additional denosumab and/or angioembolisation and/or radiotherapy till disease stopped progressing.

RESULTS

10 patients have non-progressive disease and are asymptomatic, 2 have non-progressive disease with occasional pain, 1 patient died. Follow-up duration (since final non-progression of disease) ranged from 15 to 54 months (mean 31 months). Total number of angio embolisation sessions ranged from 0 to 12 (mean = 4), total number of denosumab doses ranged from 5 to 16 (mean = 9). Five patients did not receive any radiotherapy, 5 received 50.4 Gy and one patient each received 50.4 + 30 + 12 Gy, 50.4 + 30 Gy and 50.4 + 12 Gy. The patient with loss of bladder control at presentation recovered. There were no other long-term complications.

CONCLUSION

This study offers a non-surgical management option that provides good mid-term local control while preserving neurological function in these complex lesions.

The sacral chordoma margin

OBJECTIVE

Aim of the manuscript is to discuss how to improve margins in sacral chordoma.

BACKGROUND

Chordoma is a rare neoplasm, arising in half cases from the sacrum, with reported local failure in >50% after surgery.

METHODS

A multidisciplinary meeting of the "Chordoma Global Consensus Group" was held in Milan in 2017, focusing on challenges in defining and achieving optimal margins in chordoma with respect to surgery, definitive particle radiation therapy (RT) and medical therapies. This review aims to report on the outcome of the consensus meeting and to provide a summary of the most recent evidence in this field. Possible new ways forward, including on-going international clinical studies, are discussed.

RESULTS

En-bloc tumor-sacrum resection is the cornerstone of treatment of primary sacral chordoma, aiming to achieve negative microscopic margins. Radical definitive particle therapy seems to offer a similar outcome compared to surgery, although confirmation in comparative trials is lacking; besides there is still a certain degree of technical variability across institutions, corresponding to different fields of treatment and different tumor coverage. To address some of these questions, a prospective, randomized international study comparing surgery versus definitive high-dose RT is ongoing. Available data do not support the routine use of any medical therapy as (neo)adjuvant/cytoreductive treatment.

CONCLUSION

Given the significant influence of margins status on local control in patients with primary localized sacral chordoma, the clear definition of adequate margins and a standard local approach across institutions for both surgery and particle RT is vital for improving the management of these patients.

Proton therapy for brain tumours in the area of evidence-based medicine

ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE

This review details the indication of brain tumors for proton therapy and give a list of the open prospective trials for these challenging tumors.

Chordomas: Histopathological Study in View of Anatomical Location

BACKGROUND

Chordomas are aggressive bone tumors that have a predilection for the axial skeleton including the skull base and spinal/sacral bones. However, the histopathological and clinical differences between skull base chordoma (SBC) and sacral/spinal chordoma (SC) are unclear as previous studies have been focused on patient prognosis and treatment outcome. This study aimed to evaluate the clinicopathologic features and prognosis of chordoma according to its location.

METHODS

Patients with chordomas were enrolled, and the histopathologic features were compared according to the tumor location.

RESULTS

A total of 52 patients were enrolled. SBCs had more abundant chondroid matrix and diffuse growth pattern, while SCs had non-chondroid, myxoid matrix and a lobulating pattern, typical of chordoma. Old age and residual tumors were risk factors for shorter overall survival in SBCs. The chondroid matrix was an independent risk factor for shorter disease-free survival in the overall population.

CONCLUSION

Chordomas have different histopathologic features depending on the anatomical location.