Methionine restriction-induced sulfur deficiency impairs antitumour immunity partially through gut microbiota

Restriction of methionine (MR), a sulfur-containing essential amino acid, has been reported to repress cancer growth and improve therapeutic responses in several preclinical settings. However, how MR impacts cancer progression in the context of the intact immune system is unknown. Here we report that while inhibiting cancer growth in immunocompromised mice, MR reduces T cell abundance, exacerbates tumour growth and impairs tumour response to immunotherapy in immunocompetent male and female mice. Mechanistically, MR reduces microbial production of hydrogen sulfide, which is critical for immune cell survival/activation. Dietary supplementation of a hydrogen sulfide donor or a precursor, or methionine, stimulates antitumour immunity and suppresses tumour progression. Our findings reveal an unexpected negative interaction between MR, sulfur deficiency and antitumour immunity and further uncover a vital role of gut microbiota in mediating this interaction. Our study suggests that any possible anticancer benefits of MR require careful consideration of both the microbiota and the immune system.

CTLA-4 inhibition facilitates follicular T and B cell interaction and the production of tumor-specific antibodies

Immune checkpoint inhibitors (ICIs) induce activation and expansion of cytotoxic T cells. To depict a comprehensive immune cell landscape reshaped by the CTLA-4 checkpoint inhibitor, we performed single-cell RNA sequencing in a mouse syngeneic tumor transplant model. After CTLA-4 inhibition, tumor regression was accompanied by massive immune cell expansion, especially in T and B cells. We found that B cells in tumor transplant represented follicular, germinal center and plasma B cells, some of which shared identical B cell receptor clonotypes and possessed tumor reactivity. Furthermore, the posttreatment tumor contained a tertiary lymphoid-like structure with intermingled T and B cells. These data suggest germinal center formation within the tumor mass and in situ differentiation of tumor-specific plasma cells. Taken together, our data provide a panoramic view of the immune microenvironment after CTLA-4 inhibition and suggest a role for tumor-specific B cells in antitumor immunity.

Unopposed Production of Granulocyte-Macrophage Colony-Stimulating Factor by Tumors Inhibits CD8+ T Cell Responses by Dysregulating Antigen-Presenting Cell Maturation

Tumor cells gene-modified to produce GM-CSF potently stimulate antitumor immune responses, in part, by causing the growth and differentiation of dendritic cells (DC). However, GM-CSF-modified tumor cells must be γ-irradiated or they will grow progressively, killing the host. We observed that 23 of 75 (31%) human tumor lines and two commonly used mouse tumor lines spontaneously produced GM-CSF. In mice, chronic GM-CSF production by tumors suppressed Ag-specific CD8+ T cell responses. Interestingly, an inhibitory population of adherent CD11b(Mac-1)/Gr-1 double-positive cells caused the observed impairment of CD8+ T cell function upon direct cell-to-cell contact. The inhibitory cells were positive for some markers associated with Ag presenting cells, like F4/80, but were negative for markers associated with fully mature DC like DEC205, B7.2, and MHC class II. We have previously reported that a similar or identical population of inhibitory “immature” APC was elicited after immunization with powerful recombinant immunogens. We show here that these inhibitory cells can be elicited by the administration of recombinant GM-CSF alone, and, furthermore, that they can be differentiated ex vivo into “mature” APC by the addition of IL-4 and GM-CSF. Thus, tumors may be able to escape from immune detection by producing “unopposed” GM-CSF, thereby disrupting the balance of cytokines needed for the maturation of fully functional DC. Further, CD11b/Gr-1 double-positive cells may function as “inhibitory” APC under the influence of GM-CSF alone.

Apoptotic Death of CD8+ T Lymphocytes After Immunization: Induction of a Suppressive Population of Mac-1+/Gr-1+ Cells

Following an infection or immunization, a primary CD8+ T cell response generally rises then falls rapidly before giving rise to a “memory” response. When we immunized mice with recombinant viral immunogens optimized to enhance the lytic capability of CD8+ T cells, we measured a profound depression in Ag-specific effector function after early restimulation. Indeed, a “mirror image” cytolytic capability was observed: the most powerful immunogens, as measured by cytolytic capacity 6 days after immunization, elicited the weakest secondary immune response when evaluated following an additional 6 days after restimulation. To understand the mechanism of this suppression, we examined the fate of splenocytes immunized with a vaccinia virus encoding Ag and IL-2 then restimulated ex vivo. We found that these splenocytes underwent an apoptotic cell death, upon early restimulation, that was not dependent on the engagement of the FasR (CD95). Unlike previously described mechanisms of “propriocidal cell death” and “clonal exhaustion,” the cell death we observed was not an inherent property of the CD8+ T cells but rather was due to a population of splenocytes that stained positive for both the Mac-1 and Gr-1 surface markers. Deletion of these cells in vitro or in vivo completely abrogated the observed suppression of cytolytic reactivity of Ag-specific CD8+ T cells. These observations could account for the apparent absence of Ag-specific immune responses after some current vaccination regimens employing powerful immunogens. Finally, our results may shed new light on a mechanism for the suppression of CD8+ T cell responses and its effect on vaccine efficacy and on immune memory.

In Situ Cancer Vaccination: An IL-12 Defective Vector/Replication-Competent Herpes Simplex Virus Combination Induces Local and Systemic Antitumor Activity

Intratumoral inoculation of replication-competent, attenuated herpes simplex virus (HSV) mutants inhibits tumor growth by direct cytotoxic viral replication and induction of a tumor-specific immune response. To boost the antitumor response, we describe a defective HSV vector encoding IL-12 as an adjuvant to in situ vaccination by the replication-competent HSV helper virus. The defective HSV vector system consists of defective particles containing tandem repeats of the cytokine genes (p40 and p35) in combination with a HSV helper virus. Heterodimeric IL-12 was expressed and secreted after IL-12 defective vector infection of tumor cells. In a syngeneic, bilateral established tumor model with CT26 murine colon carcinoma, unilateral intratumoral inoculation with an IL-12 defective/replication-competent HSV vector combination significantly reduced tumor growth of the inoculated and noninoculated contralateral tumors. This antitumor effect was significantly greater than with a lacZ-defective/replication-competent HSV vector combination, which itself was significantly greater than the mock inoculation. Efficacy is associated with enhancement of tumor-specific CTL activity, including specificity against the CT26 immunodominant MHC class I restricted Ag AH1, and IFN-γ production. There was no significant tumor growth inhibition after intratumoral inoculation of s.c. CT26 tumors in athymic mice. We conclude that this defective HSV vector system is an effective method for cytokine gene delivery to tumors in situ and IL-12 expression in tumors synergizes the antitumor activity mediated by the replication-competent HSV helper virus.

Autologous Human Monocyte-Derived Dendritic Cells Genetically Modified to Express Melanoma Antigens Elicit Primary Cytotoxic T Cell Responses In Vitro: Enhancement by Cotransfection of Genes Encoding the Th1-Biasing Cytokines IL-12 and IFN-α

DNA-based immunization strategies designed to elicit cellular antitumor immunity offer an attractive alternative to protein- or peptide-based approaches. In the present study we have evaluated the feasibility of DNA vaccination for the induction of CTL reactivity to five different melanoma Ags in vitro. Cultured, monocyte-derived dendritic cells (DC) were transiently transfected with plasmid DNA encoding human MART-1/Melan-A, pMel-17/gp100, tyrosinase, MAGE-1, or MAGE-3 by particle bombardment and used to stimulate autologous PBMC responder T cells. CTL reactivity to these previously identified melanoma Ags was reproducibly generated after two or three stimulations with genetically modified DC. Co-ordinate transfection of two melanoma Ag cDNAs into DC promoted CTL responders capable of recognizing epitopes from both gene products. Coinsertion of genes encoding the Th1-biasing cytokines IL-12 or IFN-α consistently enhanced the magnitude of the resulting Ag-specific CTL reactivity. Importantly, DC transfected with a single melanoma Ag cDNA were capable of stimulating Ag-specific CTL reactivity restricted by multiple host MHC alleles, some of which had not been previously identified. These results support the inherent strengths of gene-based vaccine approaches that do not require prior knowledge of responder MHC haplotypes or of relevant MHC-restricted peptide epitopes. Given previous observations of in situ tumor HLA allele-loss variants, DC gene vaccine strategies may elicit a greater diversity of host therapeutic immunity, thereby enhancing the clinical utility and success of such approaches.