Tolerance induction by veto CTLs in the TCR transgenic 2C mouse model. I. Relative reactivity of different veto cells

Generation of Non-Alloreactive Antiviral Central Memory CD8 Human Veto T Cells for Cell Therapy

Previous studies in mice demonstrated that CD8 T cells exhibit marked veto activity enhancing engraftment in several models for T cell-depleted bone marrow (TDBM) allografting. To reduce the risk of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) associated with allogeneic CD8 veto T cells, these studies made use of naive CD8 T cells stimulated against third-party stimulators under cytokine deprivation and subsequent expansion in the presence of IL-15. More recently, it was shown that mouse CD8 veto T cells can be generated by stimulating CD8 memory T cells from ovalbumin immunized mice under cytokine deprivation, using ovalbumin as a third-party antigen. These cells also exhibited substantial enhancement of BM allografting without GVHD. In this study, we tested the hypothesis that stimulation and expansion of human CD8 memory T cells under IL-15 and IL-7 deprivation during the early phase of activation against recall viral antigens can lead to substantial loss of alloreactive T clones while retaining marked veto activity. Memory CD8 T cells were enriched by removal of CD45RA+, CD4+, and CD56+ cells from peripheral blood of cytomegalovirus (CMV)- and Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-positive donors. In parallel, CD14+ monocytes were isolated; differentiated into mature dendritic cells (mDCs); pulsed with a library of CMV, EBV, adenovirus, and BK virus peptides; and irradiated. The CD8 T cell-enriched fraction was then cultured with the pulsed mDCs in the presence of IL-21 for 3 days, after which IL-15 and IL-7 were added. After 12 days of culture, the cells were tested by limiting dilution analysis for the frequency of alloreactive T cell clones and their veto activity. In preclinical runs using GMP reagents, we established that within 12 days of culture, a large number of highly homogenous CD8 T cells, predominantly expressing a central memory phenotype, could be harvested. These cells exhibited marked veto activity in vitro and >3-log depletion of alloreactivity. Based on these preclinical data, a phase 1-2 clinical trial was initiated to test the safety and efficacy of these antiviral CD8 central memory veto cells in the context of nonmyeloablative (NMA) T cell-depleted haploidentical hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT). In 2 validation runs and 11 clinical runs using GMP reagents, >1 × 1010 cells were generated from a single leukapheresis in 12 out of 13 experiments. At the end of 12 days of culture, there were 97 ± 2.5% CD3+CD8+ T cells, of which 84 ± 9.0% (range, 71.5% to 95.1%) exhibited the CD45RO+CD62L+ CM phenotype. Antiviral activity tested by intracellular expression of INF-γ and TNF-α and showed an average of 38.8 ± 19.6% positive cells on 6 hours of stimulation against the viral peptide mixture. Our results demonstrate a novel approach for depleting alloreactive T cell clones from preparations of antiviral CD8 veto cells. Based on these results, a phase 1-2 clinical trial is currently in progress to test the safety and efficacy of these veto cells in the context of NMA haploidentical T cell-depleted HSCT. Studies testing the hypothesis that these non-alloreactive CD8 T cells could potentially offer a platform for off-the-shelf veto chimeric antigen receptor T cell therapy in allogenic recipients, are warranted.

A strategy to protect off-the-shelf cell therapy products using virus-specific T-cells engineered to eliminate alloreactive T-cells

Background

The use of “off-the-shelf” cellular therapy products derived from healthy donors addresses many of the challenges associated with customized cell products. However, the potential of allogeneic cell products to produce graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), and their likely rejection by host alloreactive T-cells are major barriers to their clinical safety and efficacy. We have developed a molecule that when expressed in T-cells, can eliminate alloreactive T-cells and hence can be used to protect cell therapy products from allospecific rejection. Further, expression of this molecule in virus-specific T-cells (VSTs) should virtually eliminate the potential for recipients to develop GVHD.

Methods

To generate a molecule that can mediate killing of cognate alloreactive T-cells, we fused beta-2 microglobulin (B2M), a universal component of all human leukocyte antigen (HLA) class I molecules, to the cytolytic endodomain of the T cell receptor ζ chain, to create a chimeric HLA accessory receptor (CHAR). To determine if CHAR-modified human VSTs could eliminate alloreactive T-cells, we co-cultured them with allogeneic peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), and assessed proliferation of PBMC-derived alloreactive T-cells and the survival of CHAR-modified VSTs by flow cytometry.

Results

The CHAR was able to transport HLA molecules to the cell surface of Daudi cells, that lack HLA class I expression due to defective B2M expression, illustrating its ability to complex with human HLA class I molecules. Furthermore, VSTs expressing CHAR were protected from allospecific elimination in co-cultures with allogeneic PBMCs compared to unmodified VSTs, and mediated killing of alloreactive T-cells. Unexpectedly, CHAR-modified VSTs eliminated not only alloreactive HLA class I restricted CD8 T-cells, but also alloreactive CD4 T-cells. This beneficial effect resulted from non-specific elimination of activated T-cells. Of note, we confirmed that CHAR-modified VSTs did not affect pathogen-specific T-cells which are essential for protective immunity.

Conclusions

Human T-cells can be genetically modified to eliminate alloreactive T-cells, providing a unique strategy to protect off-the-shelf cell therapy products. Allogeneic cell therapies have already proved effective in treating viral infections in the stem cell transplant setting, and have potential in other fields such as regenerative medicine. A strategy to prevent allograft rejection would greatly increase their efficacy and commercial viability.

Electronic supplementary material

The online version of this article (10.1186/s12967-019-1988-y) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Murine anti-third-party central-memory CD8(+) T cells promote hematopoietic chimerism under mild conditioning: lymph-node sequestration and deletion of anti-donor T cells

Transplantation of T cell-depleted BM (TDBM) under mild conditioning, associated with minimal toxicity and reduced risk of GVHD, offers an attractive therapeutic option for patients with nonmalignant hematologic disorders and can mediate immune tolerance to subsequent organ transplantation. However, overcoming TDBM rejection after reduced conditioning remains a challenge. Here, we address this barrier using donorderived central memory CD8(+) T cells (Tcms), directed against third-party antigens. Our results show that fully allogeneic or (hostXdonor)F1-Tcm, support donor chimerism (> 6 months) in sublethally irradiated (5.5Gy) mice, without GVHD symptoms. Chimerism under yet lower irradiation (4.5Gy) was achieved by combining Tcm with short-term administration of low-dose Rapamycin. Importantly, this chimerism resulted in successful donor skin acceptance, whereas third-party skin was rejected. Tracking of host anti-donor T cells (HADTCs), that mediate TDBMT rejection, in a novel bioluminescence-imaging model revealed that Tcms both induce accumulation and eradicate HADTCs in the LNs,concomitant with their elimination from other organs, including the BM. Further analysis with 2-photon microcopy revealed that Tcms form conjugates with HADTCs, resulting in decelerated and confined movement of HADTCs within the LNs in an antigen-specific manner. Thus, anti-third-party Tcms support TDBMT engraftment under reduced-conditioning through lymph-node sequestration and deletion of HADTCs, offering a novel and potentially safe approach for attaining stable hematopoietic chimerism.

The use of donor-derived veto cells in hematopoietic stem cell transplantation

The induction of immune tolerance by specific agents, as opposed to general immune suppression, is a most desirable goal in transplantation biology. One approach to attain this goal is afforded by the use of donor-derived cells endowed with veto activity, which is the ability of a cell to specifically suppress only T cells directed against its antigens. A megadose of purified veto CD34(+) hematopoietic stem cells is already used in patients to allow hematopoietic stem cells transplantation (HSCT) across major genetic barriers, while avoiding severe graft versus host disease (GVHD). However, allowing engraftment of such T cell-depleted HSCT under safer reduced intensity conditioning (RIC) protocols still remains a challenge. Therefore, combining megadose of CD34(+) HSCT with other GVHD-depleted veto cells could enable facilitation of engraftment of HSCT under RIC without the adverse complication of GVHD. This approach might provide a safer modality for enabling engraftment of HSCT, enabling its application in elderly patients who cannot tolerate intensive protocols and to a variety of patients with non-malignant disorders, associated with longer life expectancy, in whom the use of a high risk conditioning cannot be considered.

CTLs respond with activation and granule secretion when serving as targets for T-cell recognition

Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) suppress T cell responses directed against their antigens regardless of their own T cell receptor (TCR) specificity. This makes the use of CTLs promising for tolerance induction in autoimmunity and transplantation. It has been established that binding of the CTL CD8 molecule to the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I α3 domain of the recognizing T cell must be permitted for death of the latter cell to ensue. However, the signaling events triggered in the CTL by this molecular interaction in the absence of TCR recognition have never been clarified. Here we use single-cell imaging to study the events occurring in CTLs serving as targets for recognition by specific T cells. We demonstrate that CTLs actively respond to recognition by polarizing their cytotoxic granules to the contact area, releasing their lethal cargo, and vigorously proliferating. Using CTLs from perforin knockout (KO) mice and lymphocyte specific kinase (Lck) knockdown with specific small interfering RNA (siRNA), we show that the killing of the recognizing CD8 T cell is perforin dependent and is initiated by Lck signaling in the CTL. Collectively, these data suggest a novel mechanism in which the entire cascade generally triggered by TCR engagement is "hijacked" in CTLs serving as targets for T cell recognition without TCR ligation.

Deletion of alloreactive T cells by veto cytotoxic T lymphocytes is mediated through extracellular signal-regulated kinase phosphorylation

BACKGROUND

Anti third-party cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) were shown to exhibit marked veto activity, thereby inducing transplantation tolerance across major histocompatibility antigens. Elimination of effector cells requires co-expression of CD8 and FasL on the veto cells and is mediated through CD8-major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class I interaction and Fas-Fas ligand signaling.

METHODS

To further interrogate the signaling events induced in the effector cells on their interaction with veto cell populations, effector cells from 2C transgenic mice were preincubated with different signaling inhibitors and were subject to fluorescence-activated cell sorting and western blot analysis.

RESULTS

Screening with inhibitors revealed specific inhibition only with the map kinase (MEK)/extracellular signal regulated kinase (ERK) inhibitor, U0126. Accordingly, fluorescence-activated cell sorting and western blot analysis showed that ERK phosphorylation is induced in the effector cells within 1 hr of incubation with the veto cells. ERK phosphorylation had no effect on the Fas expression level, nor was it reduced when using effector cells from Fas KO mice. Examination of ERK phosphorylation in high and low MHC-I expressing effectors revealed marked differences, suggesting that the interaction between CD8 on the veto CTL, and MHC-I on the effector cells is likely responsible for ERK phosphorylation. Furthermore, XIAP in 2C cells is specifically reduced on binding to the cognate veto cells during the mixed lymphocyte reaction but before the appearance of Annexin V reactivity.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the interaction between CD8 on veto CTL and the MHC class I alpha3 domain on the effector cell, leads to phosphorylation of MEK/ERK in the latter cell, associated with a significant reduction of XIAP levels which, in turn, enables potent triggering of Fas-FasL mediated apoptosis on cognate binding of the veto CTLs.

Induction of B-cell immune tolerance by antigen-modified cytotoxic T lymphocytes

BACKGROUND

Third-party-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), or veto CTL, are being assessed as a cellular therapeutic for the induction of T-cell tolerance during transplantation. Conceptually, veto cell-expressed antigens (Ags) may induce B-cell immune responses, and this may have deleterious consequences. Whether veto cells induce immunity, tolerance, or are ignored by B lymphocytes has, however, not been addressed.

METHODS

CTL were retrovirally transduced with a model cell surface Ag to generate veto CTL. The impact of CTL-specific Ag expression on the activation and tolerization of Ag-specific B cells was assessed in vitro and, using adoptive transfer models, in vivo.

RESULTS

In vitro, CTL-expressed Ag induced an abortive proliferative response in specific B lymphocytes, whereby an initial proliferative burst was followed by cell death. In vivo, the administration of veto CTL also induced B-cell tolerance. Specific immunoglobulin was not detected after subsequent immunization with a veto cell-expressed Ag. Modeling of this effect with Ag-specific B-cell receptor transgenic B lymphocytes demonstrated that Ag-specific B cells were eliminated by the veto CTL; the cell division was accompanied by the exhaustion and depletion of responding cells. Veto-induced B-cell tolerance could be wholly abrogated by treatment with the toll-like receptor ligand lipopolysaccharide, implying that this tolerance resulted from the absence of adequate supplemental signals during antigenic stimulation.

CONCLUSIONS

Veto CTL are effective promoters of B-cell tolerance. Further assessment of their therapeutic potential in this regard is warranted.

Activated allogeneic NK cells as suppressors of alloreactive responses

Donor NK cells have been shown to be able to promote engraftment during allogeneic bone marrow transplantation. They could specifically suppress or delete host reactive cells, thereby facilitating engraftment of donor marrow. To further elucidate the mechanism, we showed that activated H2(d) ALAK cells (adherent lymphokine activated killer, IL-2 activated T cell-depleted bone marrow and spleen cells) from BALB/c mice significantly suppressed the proliferation of H2(b) splenocytes from C57BL/6 mice in mixed lymphocyte responses (MLR) stimulated with irradiated H2(d) splenocytes from BALB/c mice (P < .01). The ability for H2(b) splenocytes to kill H2(d) tumor targets was also significantly inhibited by activated H2(d) ALAK cells (P < .01). The same number of H2(b) ALAK cells or H2(d) splenocytes did not show the same suppressive effect. These results suggested that activated H2(d) ALAK cells could specifically suppress the anti-H2(d) activity of the H2(b) splenocytes. Anti-tumor growth factor (TGF)beta antibody blockade did not diminish this suppressive effect of ALAK cells, suggesting that this activity is not dependent on TGF-beta secretion. ALAKs from gld (FasL mutant) mice suppressed the allo-responses as well as the wild-type ALAK cells. The ALAKs from pfp (perforin knockout) mice did not completely block the inhibitory effect, which suggested that the suppressive effect of the allogeneic ALAK cells could be partially caused by perforin-mediated killing. We further demonstrated that donor ALAK cells could promote engraftment by suppressing host alloreactive responses in a nonmyeloablative allogeneic BMT model. These studies suggest that activated donor NK cells specifically suppress the alloreactive cells and provide a promising way to promote donor engraftment without involving systemic and nonspecific suppression of the immune system.

Induction of tolerance to bone marrow allografts by donor-derived host nonreactive ex vivo-induced central memory CD8 T cells

Enabling engraftment of allogeneic T cell-depleted bone marrow (TDBM) under reduced-intensity conditioning represents a major challenge in bone marrow transplantation (BMT). Anti-third-party cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) were previously shown to be endowed with marked ability to delete host antidonor T cells in vitro, but were found to be less effective in vivo. This could result from diminished lymph node (LN) homing caused by the prolonged activation, which induces a CD44(+)CD62L(-) effector phenotype, and thereby prevents effective colocalization with, and neutralization of, alloreactive host T cells (HTCs). In the present study, LN homing, determined by imaging, was enhanced upon culture conditions that favor the acquisition of CD44(+)CD62L(+) central memory cell (Tcm) phenotype by anti-third-party CD8(+) cells. These Tcm-like cells displayed strong proliferation and prolonged persistence in BM transplant recipients. Importantly, adoptively transferred HTCs bearing a transgenic T-cell receptor (TCR) with antidonor specificity were efficiently deleted only by donor-type Tcms. All these attributes were found to be associated with improved efficacy in overcoming T cell-mediated rejection of TDBM, thereby enabling high survival rate and long-term donor chimerism, without causing graft-versus-host disease. In conclusion, anti-third-party Tcms, which home to recipient LNs and effectively delete antidonor T cells, could provide an effective and novel tool for overcoming rejection of BM allografts.

Graft rejection as a Th1-type process amenable to regulation by donor Th2-type cells through an interleukin-4/STAT6 pathway

Graft rejection has been defined as the mirror image of graft-versus-host disease, which is biologically characterized primarily as a Th1-type process. As such, we reasoned that graft rejection would represent a Th1 response amenable to Th2 modulation. Indeed, adoptive transfer of host Th1-type cells mediated rejection of fully MHC-disparate murine bone marrow allografts more effectively than host Th2-type cells. Furthermore, STAT1-deficient host T cells did not differentiate into Th1-type cells in vivo and failed to mediate rejection. We next hypothesized that donor Th2 cell allograft augmentation would prevent rejection by modulation of the host Th1/Th2 balance. In the setting of donor Th2 cell therapy, host-anti-donor allospecific T cells acquired Th2 polarity, persisted posttransplantation, and did not mediate rejection. Abrogation of rejection required donor Th2 cell IL-4 secretion and host T-cell STAT6 signaling. In conclusion, T cell-mediated marrow graft rejection primarily resembles a Th1-type process that can be abrogated by donor Th2 cell therapy that promotes engraftment through a novel mechanism whereby cytokine polarization is transferred to host T cells.

Tolerance induction in presensitized bone marrow recipients by veto CTLs: effective deletion of host anti-donor memory effector cells

Veto cells have been defined as cells capable of inducing apoptosis of effector CD8 cells recognizing their disparate MHC Ags. Tolerance induced by donor-type veto cells is desirable, because it is restricted to depletion of anti-donor clones without depletion of other immune specificities. It has been shown that anti-third party CTLs exhibit marked veto activity with reduced capacity to induce graft-vs-host disease, when tested on naive effector cells. However, presensitized T cells could play an important role in graft rejection, and therefore, their sensitivity to veto cells could be critical to the implementation of the latter cells in bone marrow transplantation. To address this question, we compared naive and presensitized TCR transgenic effector CD8 T cells, bearing a TCR against H-2(d). Both cell types exhibited similar predisposition to killing by veto CTLs in vitro, and this killing was dependent in both cell types on Fas-FasL signaling as shown by using Fas-deficient CD8 T cells from (lprx2c) F(1) mice. When tested in a stringent mouse model, in which bone marrow rejection is mediated by adoptively transferred host type T cells into lethally irradiated recipients, veto CTLs were equally effective in overcoming rejection of naive or presensitized host T cells.

Gammadelta T cells do not require fully functional cytotoxic pathways or the ability to recognize recipient alloantigens to prevent graft rejection

Gammadelta T cells are a unique and minor T-cell subset that differs from conventional alphabeta T cells by virtue of their tissue localization and antigen processing requirements. We have previously shown that ex vivo-activated gammadelta T cells are able to prevent graft rejection without causing clinically significant graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). In the present study, we examined how gammadelta T cells facilitate alloengraftment and to what extent mechanisms used by conventional alphabeta T cells are also used by gammadelta T cells. We observed that, unlike alphabeta T cells, for which CD8(+) T cells are primarily responsible for facilitating engraftment, purified CD8(+)gammadelta(+) T cells administered at the same fractional dose as for the unseparated activated gammadelta T-cell population were insufficient to prevent graft rejection. Furthermore, the ability to prevent graft rejection was not affected by the absence of fully functional fas ligand or perforin cytotoxic pathways, nor was it contingent on the ability of gammadelta T cells to recognize recipient major histocompatibility process alloantigens. Repetitive infusions of a suboptimal dose of gammadelta T cells however were able to rescue mice from graft rejection, suggesting that the persistence of these cells in vivo was critical in facilitating alloengraftment. These studies demonstrate that gammadelta T cells do not use mechanisms used by conventional nontolerant alphabeta T cells to prevent graft rejection. The ability of these cells to promote engraftment without causing GVHD further distinguishes these cells from alphabeta T cells and may be an attribute that can be exploited in the clinical transplantation setting.