Regression of Giant Olfactory Groove Meningioma and Complete Visual Acuity Recovery after Discontinuation of Cyproterone Acetate

Development and Growth of Intracranial Meningiomas in Transgender Women Taking Cyproterone Acetate as Gender-Affirming Progestogen Therapy: A Systematic Review

Background

Gender-affirming hormone therapy is critical to the management of transgender persons. Cyproterone acetate (CPA) is a synthetic, progesterone-like compound commonly used in high doses as gender-affirming progestogen therapy in transgender women. An association between high-dose CPA and the development and growth of intracranial meningioma, including case reports in transgender women, has been described. This systematic review summarizes these cases at the patient level and discusses their management.

Methods

This systematic review was registered with PROSPERO (CRD42020191965). A detailed search of the PubMed, EMBASE, and Web of Science electronic bibliographic databases was performed (inception-December 20, 2020). Two review authors independently completed screening, data extraction, and risk of bias assessment in duplicate.

Results

Nine records were included describing (n=12) individual case reports and (n=35) intracranial meningiomas. The median age at presentation was 48 years (interquartile range [IQR], 43-55 years), most frequent daily CPA doses were 50 mg/day (n=5) and 100 mg/day (n=5), and the median duration of CPA use was 9.5 years (IQR, 6.5-17.5 years). Multiple meningiomas were common (n=7). For most cases (n=10), surgical resection was the initial preferred management strategy, but two were successfully managed by CPA cessation.

Conclusions

Transgender women receiving high doses of CPA may be at increased risk of intracranial meningioma development and/or growth, although this remains a rare disease. For presumed CPA-associated meningioma, drug cessation appears to be an appropriate management strategy when surgery is not imminently required to manage raised intracranial pressure or prevent neurological deterioration. Given the importance of gender-affirming hormone therapy to transgender persons, a suitable alternative hormone regimen should be offered, although the use of CPA in both high doses and for prolonged periods of time is now in decline.

Meningioma in patients exposed to progestin drugs: results from a real-life screening program

PURPOSE

To report the results of systematic meningioma screening program implemented by French authorities in patients exposed to progestin therapies (cyproterone (CPA), nomegestrol (NA), and chlormadinone (CMA) acetate).

METHODS

We conducted a prospective monocentric study on patients who, between September 2018 and April 2021, underwent standardized MRI (injection of gadolinium, then a T2 axial FLAIR and a 3D-T1 gradient-echo sequence) for meningioma screening.

RESULTS

Of the 210 included patients, 15 (7.1%) had at least one meningioma; seven (7/15, 47%) had multiple meningiomas. Meningiomas were more frequent in older patients and after exposure to CPA (13/103, 13%) compared to NA (1/22, 4%) or CMA (1/85, 1%; P = 0.005). After CPA exposure, meningiomas were associated with longer treatment duration (median = 20 vs 7 years, P = 0.001) and higher cumulative dose (median = 91 g vs. 62 g, P = 0.014). Similarly, their multiplicity was associated with higher dose of CPA (median = 244 g vs 61 g, P = 0.027). Most meningiomas were ≤ 1 cm³ (44/58, 76%) and were convexity meningiomas (36/58, 62%). At diagnosis, patients were non-symptomatic, and all were managed conservatively. Among 14 patients with meningioma who stopped progestin exposure, meningioma burden decreased in 11 (79%) cases with no case of progression during MR follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Systematic MR screening in progestin-exposed patients uncovers small and multiple meningiomas, which can be managed conservatively, decreasing in size after progestin discontinuation. The high rate of meningiomas after CPA exposure reinforces the need for systematic screening. For NA and CMA, further studies are needed to identify patients most likely to benefit from screening.

Estrogen and Progesterone Therapy and Meningiomas

Meningiomas are common intracranial tumors with a female predominance. Their etiology is still poorly documented. The role of sexual hormones has long been evoked, and data have been conflicting across studies. However, a dose-dependent relationship between the incidence and growth of meningiomas and hormonal treatment with the progestin cyproterone acetate (CPA) has recently been established. CPA-associated meningiomas seem to be mainly located in the anterior and middle skull base, are more likely to be multiple, may harbor P1K3CA mutations in up to one-third of cases, and are more common with a longer duration of treatment. A similar but lower risk of meningiomas has been recently reported with the use of chlormadinone acetate and nomegestrol acetate as progestin treatments. Concerning hormonal replacement therapy (HRT) in menopausal patients, evidence from epidemiological studies seem to favor an increased risk of meningiomas in treated patients although a recent study failed to show an increased growth of meningiomas in HRT treated vs nontreated patients. Until larger studies are available, it seems wise to recommend avoiding HRT in patients with meningiomas. Evidence from published data does not seem to support an increased risk of meningiomas with oral contraceptive oral contraceptive (OR) use. Data are too scarce to conclude on fertility treatments. Based on studies demonstrating the expression of hormonal receptors in meningiomas, therapies targeting these receptors have been tried but have failed to show an overall favorable clinical outcome in meningioma treatment.

Atypical evolution of meningiomatosis after discontinuation of cyproterone acetate: clinical cases and histomolecular characterization

PURPOSE

The long-term use of cyproterone acetate (CPA) is associated with an increased risk of developing intracranial meningiomas. CPA discontinuation most often induces a stabilization or regression of the tumor. The underlying biological mechanisms as well as the reasons why some meningiomas still grow after CPA discontinuation remain unknown. We reported a series of patients presenting CPA-induced meningiomatosis with opposed tumor evolutions following CPA discontinuation, highlighting the underlying histological and genetic features.

METHODS

Patients presenting several meningiomas with opposite tumor evolution (coexistence of growing and shrinking tumors) following CPA discontinuation were identified. Clinical and radiological data were reviewed. A retrospective volumetric analysis of the meningiomas was performed. All the growing meningiomas were operated. Each operated tumor was characterized by histological and genetic analyses.

RESULTS

Four women with multiple meningiomas and opposite tumor volume evolutions after CPA discontinuation were identified. Histopathological analysis characterized the convexity and tentorial tumors which continued to grow after CPA discontinuation as fibroblastic meningiomas. The decreasing skull base tumor was characterized as a fibroblastic meningioma with increased fibrosis and a widespread collagen formation. The two growing skull base meningiomas were identified as meningothelial and transitional meningiomas. The molecular characterization found two NF2 mutations among the growing meningiomas and a PIK3CA mutation in the skull base tumor which decreased.

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, this is the first report describing an atypical tumor evolution of CPA-associated meningiomas after CPA discontinuation. The underlying biological mechanisms explaining this observation and especially the close relationship between mutational landscapes and embryologic origins of the meninges in CPA-related meningiomas as well as their clonal origin require further research.

Progestin-related WHO grade II meningiomas behavior-a single-institution comparative case series

WHO grade II progestin-related meningiomas have been reported in recent series but we found no previous study describing their long-term outcome. Our study aimed to evaluate patients operated on for high-grade intracranial meningioma and who underwent long-term exposure to high dose of cyproterone acetate, nomegestrol acetate, and chlormadinone acetate. Our study retrospectively included 9 patients with high-grade progestin-related intracranial meningioma between December 2006 and September 2021. In each patient, clinico-radiological follow-up was performed every 6 months after diagnosis and treatment withdrawal recommendation. The mean progestative exposure was 11.4 years. Edema existence or absence of cleft sign on MRI were the key factors for surgical indication. All patients underwent surgery. Adjuvant radiotherapy was indicated in 1 patient, and Gamma Knife radiosurgery was proposed in 2 other patients for a second location of meningioma. Six patients harbored a grade II chordoid meningioma subtype with 100% PR expression and 3 patients a grade II atypical meningioma subtype with lower PR expression. The mean follow-up was 8.1 years and none of the 9 patients presented with a recurrence. Patients with grade II progestin-related meningiomas have less tumor recurrence after surgery than patients with sporadic grade II meningiomas, especially after progestin withdrawal. The presence/appearance of peri-meningioma edema and the absence of cleft sign before volumetric change should suggest the existence of an underlying WHO grade II meningiomas. In these cases, surgical resection may immediately be considered and adjuvant radiotherapy should be reserved for proven recurrence cases.

Meningiomas in patients with long-term exposition to progestins: Characteristics and outcome

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to describe progestin-associated meningiomas' characteristics, outcome and management.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We included 53 patients operated on and/or followed in the department for meningioma with progestin intake longer than one year and with recent drug discontinuation.

RESULTS

Cyproterone acetate (CPA), nomegestrol acetate (NomA), and chlormadinone acetate (ChlA) were involved in most cases. Mean duration of progestin drugs intake was 17.5 years. Tumors were multiple in 66% of cases and were located in the anterior and the medial skull base in 71% of cases. Transitional subtype represented 16/25 tumors; 19 meningiomas were WHO grade I and 6 were grade II. The rate of transitional subtype and skull base location was significantly higher compared to matched operated meningioma general population. No difference was observed given WHO classification. But Ki67 proliferation index tends to be lower and 5/6 of the WHO grade II meningiomas were classified as WHO grade II because of brain invasion. Strong progesterone receptors expression was observed in most cases. After progestin discontinuation, a spontaneous visual recovery was observed in 6/10 patients. Under CPA (n=24) and ChlA/NomA (n=11), tumor volume decreased in 71% and 18% of patients, was stabilized in 25% and 64% of patients, and increased in 4% and 18% of patients, respectively. Volume outcome was related to meningioma location.

CONCLUSIONS

Outcome at progestins discontinuation is favorable but different comparing CPA versus ChlA-NomA and comparing tumor location. Long-term follow-up is required. In most cases, simple observation is recommended and surgery should be avoided.

Use of high dose cyproterone acetate and risk of intracranial meningioma in women: cohort study

OBJECTIVE

To assess the risk of meningioma associated with use of high dose cyproterone acetate, a progestogen indicated for clinical hyperandrogenism.

DESIGN

Observational cohort study.

SETTING

Data from SNDS, the French administrative healthcare database, between 2007 and 2015.

PARTICIPANTS

253 777 girls and women aged 7-70 years living in France who started cyproterone acetate between 2007 and 2014. Participants had at least one reimbursement for high dose cyproterone acetate and no history of meningioma or benign brain tumour, or long term disease status. Participants were considered to be exposed when they had received a cumulative dose of at least 3 g during the first six months (139 222 participants) and very slightly exposed (control group) when they had received a cumulative dose of less than 3 g (114 555 participants). 10 876 transgender participants (male to female) were included in an additional analysis.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE

Surgery (resection or decompression) or radiotherapy for one or more intracranial meningiomas.

RESULTS

Overall, 69 meningiomas in the exposed group (during 289 544 person years of follow-up) and 20 meningiomas in the control group (during 439 949 person years of follow-up) were treated by surgery or radiotherapy. The incidence of meningioma in the two groups was 23.8 and 4.5 per 100 000 person years, respectively (crude relative risk 5.2, 95% confidence interval 3.2 to 8.6; adjusted hazard ratio 6.6, 95% confidence interval 4.0 to 11.1). The adjusted hazard ratio for a cumulative dose of cyproterone acetate of more than 60 g was 21.7 (10.8 to 43.5). After discontinuation of cyproterone acetate for one year, the risk of meningioma in the exposed group was 1.8-fold higher (1.0 to 3.2) than in the control group. In a complementary analysis, 463 women with meningioma were observed among 123 997 already using cyproterone acetate in 2006 (risk of 383 per 100 000 person years in the group with the highest exposure in terms of cumulative dose). Meningiomas located in the anterior skull base and middle skull base, particularly the medial third of the middle skull base, involving the spheno-orbital region, appeared to be specific to cyproterone acetate. An additional analysis of transgender participants showed a high risk of meningioma (three per 14 460 person years; 20.7 per 100 000 person years).

CONCLUSIONS

A strong dose-effect relation was observed between use of cyproterone acetate and risk of intracranial meningiomas. A noticeable reduction in risk was observed after discontinuation of treatment.

Evolution of the neurosurgical management of progestin-associated meningiomas: a 23-year single-center experience

PURPOSE

The improving knowledge of interactions between meningiomas and progestin refines the management of this specific condition. We assessed the changes over time of the management of progestin-associated meningiomas.

METHODS

We retrospectively studied consecutive adult patients who had at least one meningioma in the context of progestin intake (October 1995-October 2018) in a tertiary adult Neurosurgical Center.

RESULTS

71 adult women with 125 progestin-associated meningiomas were included. The number of progestin-associated meningioma patients increased over time (0.5/year before 2008, 22.0/year after 2017). Progestin treatment was an approved indication in 27.0%. A mean of 1.7 ± 1.2 meningiomas were discovered per patient (median 1, range 1-6). Surgery was performed on 36 (28.8%) meningiomas and the histopathologic grading was WHO grade 1 in 61.1% and grade 2 in 38.9%. The conservative management of meningiomas increased over time (33.3% before 2008, 64.3% after 2017) and progestin treatment withdrawal increased over time (16.7% before 2008, 95.2% after 2017). Treatment withdrawal varied depending on the progestin derivative used (88.9% with cyproterone acetate, 84.6% with chlormadinone acetate, 28.6% with nomegestrol acetate, 66.7% with progestin derivative combination). The main reason for therapeutic management of meningiomas was the presence of clinical signs. Among the 54 meningiomas managed conservatively for which the progestin had been discontinued, MRI follow-up demonstrated a regression in 29.6%, a stability in 68.5%, and an ongoing growth in 1.9% of cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Conservative management, including progestin treatment discontinuation, has grown over time with promising results in terms of efficacy and safety.

Cyproterone acetate and meningioma: a nationwide-wide population based study

BACKGROUND

The study the characteristics of surgical meningiomas in female patients who took CPA and to compare this population to a non-CPA control group.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We processed the French Système National des Données de Santé (SNDS) database to retrieve appropriate cases operated between 2007 and 2017.

RESULTS

1 101 female patients (3.8%) who used to take CPA and underwent a meningioma surgery were extracted from a nationwide population based cohort of 28 924 patients. Median age at CPA prescription was 42 years IQR[36.7-48.9]. The median time between CPA start and surgery was 5.5 years IQR[3.1-7.9]. The median age at surgery was significantly lower in patients who were treated by CPA (47 years, IQR[42-54) compared to the non-CPA population (61 years, IQR[51-70], p < 0.001). Median CPA dose was 40 g, IQR[19-72]. There was a strong correlation between CPA dose and duration (r = 0.58, _95%CI[0.54-0.62], p < 0.001). Middle skull base was the most common (39%) location with a anterior skull base insertion being also far more common compared to the usual population with 21.9% of the tumour. This skull base predominance of CPA-associated meningioma is highly significant (p < 0.001). Increased CPA dose raised the risk of having multiple meningioma surgeries (p < 0.001) and multiple meningioma locations (p < 0.001). Tumour grading was not modified by CPA treatment (p = 0.603). Benign or grade I meningioma accounting for 92%, atypical or grade II for 6.1% and malignant or grade III for 1.9%.

CONCLUSION

In the past 10 years, a significant number of CPA-induced meningiomas have been removed, modifying the global pyramid of age at surgery for female patients. These tumours occur well before the usual age and are preferentially located on the anterior and middle skull base.

Female gender and exogenous progesterone exposition as risk factors for spheno-orbital meningiomas

OBJECTIVE

The great heterogeneity of meningiomas is challenging and we need to distinguish relevant subgroups. Spheno-orbital osteomeningiomas (SOOM) constitute a clinically specific entity, with slow-growing benign osteo-meningiomatous tumors, which recur after surgery in one fourth of cases. Neurosurgical daily practice, supported by the literature, shows that the vast majority of patients with SOOM are women, and we explored whether their epidemiological and hormonal profiles suggest a progesterone influence.

METHODS

We retrospectively documented all radiologically and histologically confirmed cases of SOOM operated in 2005-2019 in our institution. We completed the clinical and hormone history by systematic telephone interviews.

RESULTS

In the literature, SOOM occur significantly more often in women than other meningiomas (749/847, 86.4% versus 73.8%, p = 0.002). Among 175 cases, we included 124 patients, 93.5% were women, younger than men (51 ± 5 versus 63 ± 8, p = 0.02). Women' meningiomas showed more progesterone receptors (96.4% versus 50%, p < 0.001). Exogenous hormonal intake, reliable in 82 cases, concerned 83.3% (64/78) of women, with frequent progesterone intake: 13 oestroprogestogenic treatment only, with old-generation progesterone analogs, 41 progesterone analogs (cyproterone acetate, nomegestrol acetate, chlormadinone, promegestone, etonogestrel, levonogestrel), 7 substitutive hormonal therapy for menopause, 3 others. Duration of treatment was 2-40 years, median 10 years.

CONCLUSIONS

SOOM develop preferentially in women in their fifties, who often received progesterone analogs, and show progesterone receptors. Progesterone analogs are incriminated in skull base meningiomas, and this is the first report on the prevalence of exogenous hormone therapy specifically in SOOM. Whether SOOM reduce after treatment discontinuation, in particular the osteoma part, needs to be explored. Anti-progesterone treatments may represent an avenue for future research in soom.

Symptomatic progestin-associated atypical grade II meningioma. A first case report

BACKGROUND

Long-term use of high-dose progestin is known to promote the development of meningioma. Atypical meningioma in a patient under progestin has not previously been reported.

CASE REPORT

A 53-year-old right-handed woman presented with focal onset seizures, without impaired consciousness. Medical history featured endometriosis, treated successively by cyproterone acetate 25mg/day for 2 months then 50mg/day for 101 months, and chlormadinone acetate 5mg/day for 68 months then 10mg/day for 83 months. Brain MRI revealed multiple extra-axial lesions suggestive of left central meningioma associated with anterior skull base meningiomatosis. Surgical resection of the left central meningioma was achieved and progestin was withdrawn. Neuropathology diagnosed grade II atypical meningioma. Close clinical and imaging monitoring was implemented without adjuvant oncological treatment. At 25 months, imaging follow-up showed no recurrence of the left central meningioma and a significant regression of all other lesions, except for the right frontal lesion.

CONCLUSIONS

Neurosurgeons should be aware of the possible aggressiveness of meningioma in patients under progestin, and particularly those treated by different types of progestin over a long period of time without interruption. This may require systematic close monitoring, to adapt neurosurgical management.

Spontaneous regression of meningiomas after interruption of nomegestrol acetate: a series of three patients

BACKGROUND

The relationship between increased meningioma incidence and growth and long-term hormonal therapy with cyproterone acetate (CPA) in women has been recently established in literature. Following the raise in awareness from hormonal treatment, we describe a potential relationship between the progesterone agonist nomegestrol acetate (NOMAC) and meningioma growth.

METHODS

After implementation of a screening protocol to detect potential interactions between hormonal exposure and occurrence of meningioma, we identified patients taking NOMAC and newly diagnosed with a meningioma. NOMAC was stopped and those patients were followed tightly both clinically and radiologically. Retrospective volumetric analysis of the tumors was performed on the imaging.

RESULTS

Three patients were identified for the study. After cessation of the NOMAC, tumor shrinkage was documented for all meningiomas within the first month. Up to 70% of tumor volume reduction was observed during the first year of follow-up in one of them. None of the patients developed new symptoms.

CONCLUSION

We report the first cases of meningiomas responsiveness to discontinuation of hormonal therapy with NOMAC. Similarly to cases associated with long-term CPA intake, tumor reduction, and improvement of clinical symptoms can be observed after cessation of NOMAC.