Comparison of ablation characteristics of three different radiofrequency applicators in renal sympathetic denervation

OBJECTIVE

Renal sympathetic denervation (RDN) is an alternative treatment for resistant hypertension (RH). This study aims to compare ablation effects using three radiofrequency applicators (i.e., balloon-based four electrodes, spiral and monopolar devices).

METHODS

An idealized three-dimensional model of the renal artery was established using COMSOL Multiphysics to mimic radiofrequency ablation (RFA). Radiofrequency (RF) energy was delivered to the tissue at the same simulation settings, i.e., 4, 6, and 8 W for 60 s, using the three abovementioned RF applicators. The temperature distribution in the tissue was calculated using the coupled electrical-thermal-fluid finite element method. Lesion borders were defined using 50 °C isotherms. The maximum lesion depth, width, area, and circumferential coverage rate were compared among the three applicators at a blood flow of 0.4 m/s. Monopolar RF ablations in a renal artery phantom model were performed to validate the reliability of the simulation method.

RESULTS

The balloon-based system yields greater lesion depths and widths compared with spiral and monopolar denervation under the same power. The range of maximum lesion depth is 1.58-3.11 mm for balloon-based RDN, 0.90-1.81 mm for spiral RDN and 1.12-2.38 mm for monopolar RDN, at a power of 4-8 W. The corresponding ranges of maximum lesion width are 2.22-5.73, 1.48-3.54, and 1.93-5.31 mm, respectively, and the circumferential coverage rates of the renal artery are 41.43%-91.99%, 31.71%-66.23%, and 9.55%-23.06%, respectively. The average velocity after balloon-based, spiral, and monopolar RDN increases by 3, 5, and 1 cm/s, respectively. The validation of the computer model offered prediction errors are <5% in terms of temperature at different locations (i.e., 2, 4, and 8 mm).

CONCLUSIONS

In terms of lesion size, balloon-based RDN appears to be the best option for the treatment of RH. However, the change in flow velocity in the arterial flow field suggests that its hemodynamic changes must be prioritized for investigating its safety. Although spiral catheter ablation yields the smallest lesion size and a significant change in flow velocity in the flow field, its coverage rate is larger than that of monopolar RDN; compared with balloon-based RDN, it did not obstruct most of the blood flow.

Renal Artery Branch Denervation: Evaluation of Lesion Characteristics Using a Thermochromic Liquid Crystal Phantom Model

BACKGROUND

Lately, combined main vessel and branch ablation has been recommended during radiofrequency (RF) renal artery denervation. Utilising a validated renal artery phantom model, we aimed (1) to determine thermal injury extent (lesion depth, width and circumferential coverage) and electrode-tissue interface temperature for branch renal artery ablation, and (2) to compare the extent of thermal injury for branch versus main vessel ablation using the same RF System.

METHODS

We employed a gel based renal artery phantom model simulating variable vessel diameter and flow, which incorporated a temperature sensitive thermochromic-liquid-crystal (TLC) film for assessing RF ablation thermodynamics. Ablations in a branch renal artery model (n = 32) were performed using Symplicity Spyral (Medtronic, Minneapolis, MN, USA). Lesion dimensions defined by the 51 °C isotherm, circumferential injury coverage, and electrode-tissue interface temperature were measured for all ablations at 60 seconds.

RESULTS

Lesion dimensions were 2.13 ± 0.13 mm and 4.13 ± 0.18 mm for depth and width, respectively, involving 23% of the vessel circumference. Maximum electrode-tissue interface temperature was 68.31 ± 2.29 °C. No significant difference in lesion depth between branch and main vessel ablations was found (Δ = 0.02 mm, p = 0.60). However, lesions were wider in the branch (Δ=0.49 mm, p < 0.001) with a larger circumferential coverage compared to main vessel (arc angle of 82.02±3.27° versus 54.90±4.36°, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

In the phantom model, branch ablations were of similar depth but had larger width and circumferential coverage compared to main vessel ablations. Concerning safety, no overheating at the electrode-tissue interface was observed.

Comparison of two different radiofrequency ablation systems for renal artery denervation: Evaluation of short-term and long-term follow up

Objectives

To assess the clinical efficacy of renal artery denervation (RAD) in our center and to compare the efficacy of two different radiofrequency (RF) systems.

Background

Several systems are available for RF renal denervation. Whether there is a difference in clinical efficacy among various systems remains unknown.

Methods

Renal artery denervation was performed on 43 patients with resistant hypertension using either the single electrode Symplicity Flex (n = 20) or the multi‐electrode EnligHTN system (n = 23). Median post‐procedural follow‐up was 32.93 months. The primary outcome was post‐procedural change in office blood pressure (BP) within 1 year (short‐term follow‐up). Secondary outcomes were change in office BP between 1 and 4 years (long‐term follow‐up) and the difference in office BP reduction between the two systems at each follow‐up period.

Results

For the total cohort, mean baseline office BP (systolic/diastolic) was 174/94 mmHg. At follow‐up, mean changes in office BP from baseline were −19.70/−11.86 mmHg (P < 0.001) and −21.90/−13.94 mmHg (P < 0.001) for short‐term and long‐term follow‐up, respectively. The differences in office BP reduction between Symplicity and EnligHTN groups were 8.96/1.23 mmHg (P = 0.42 for systolic BP, P = 0.83 for diastolic BP) and 9.56/7.68 mmHg (P = 0.14 for systolic BP, P = 0.07 for diastolic BP) for short‐term and long‐term follow‐up, respectively.

Conclusions

In our cohort, there was a clinically significant office BP reduction after RAD, which persisted up to 4 years. No significant difference in office BP reduction between the two systems was found.

Renal Denervation by Transaortic Periarterial Ethanol Injection: An Experimental Study in Porcines

AIMS

To evaluate the feasibility, safety and efficacy of renal sympathetic denervation via endoluminal transaortic periarterial ethanol injection.

METHODS AND RESULTS

In 11 normotensive pigs transaortic puncture was performed with a 90-cm 21G needle with subsequent unilateral ethanol injection to the periarterial space. Needle placement was achieved using a 7F steerable sheath fluoroscopically positioned slightly above the renal artery origin. Blood pressure measurements and abdominal CT scans were performed immediately pre- and postintervention and 4 weeks later. After euthanasia norepinephrine concentration of both kidneys (RTNEC) was determined and renal arteries and surrounding tissues histologically examined to assess induced nerve fibre degeneration.

RESULTS

All but one procedure were technically successful. One major complication with accidental ethanol injection into the renal artery and subsequent infarction occurred. One pig died from no intervention-related cardiac arrest. The 4-week follow-up was uneventful in the remaining 10 animals. RTNEC was significantly lower on the treated side in eight of ten pigs (mean decrease 36.6%) with correlating histopathological signs of nerve degeneration.

CONCLUSIONS

Renal sympathicolysis by transaortic periarterial ethanol injection was feasible and effective in a porcine model. This approach may be an alternative to catheter-based RFA or other methods of renal denervation.

Endovascular ultrasound renal denervation to treat hypertension (RADIANCE-HTN SOLO): a multicentre, international, single-blind, randomised, sham-controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Early studies suggest that radiofrequency-based renal denervation reduces blood pressure in patients with moderate hypertension. We investigated whether an alternative technology using endovascular ultrasound renal denervation reduces ambulatory blood pressure in patients with hypertension in the absence of antihypertensive medications.

METHODS

RADIANCE-HTN SOLO was a multicentre, international, single-blind, randomised, sham-controlled trial done at 21 centres in the USA and 18 in Europe. Patients with combined systolic-diastolic hypertension aged 18-75 years were eligible if they had ambulatory blood pressure greater than or equal to 135/85 mm Hg and less than 170/105 mm Hg after a 4-week discontinuation of up to two antihypertensive medications and had suitable renal artery anatomy. Patients were randomised (1:1) to undergo renal denervation with the Paradise system (ReCor Medical, Palo Alto, CA, USA) or a sham procedure consisting of renal angiography only. The randomisation sequence was computer generated and stratified by centres with randomised blocks of four or six and permutation of treatments within each block. Patients and outcome assessors were blinded to randomisation. The primary effectiveness endpoint was the change in daytime ambulatory systolic blood pressure at 2 months in the intention-to-treat population. Patients were to remain off antihypertensive medications throughout the 2 months of follow-up unless specified blood pressure criteria were exceeded. Major adverse events included all-cause mortality, renal failure, an embolic event with end-organ damage, renal artery or other major vascular complications requiring intervention, or admission to hospital for hypertensive crisis within 30 days and new renal artery stenosis within 6 months. This study is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT02649426.

FINDINGS

Between March 28, 2016, and Dec 28, 2017, 803 patients were screened for eligibility and 146 were randomised to undergo renal denervation (n=74) or a sham procedure (n=72). The reduction in daytime ambulatory systolic blood pressure was greater with renal denervation (-8·5 mm Hg, SD 9·3) than with the sham procedure (-2·2 mm Hg, SD 10·0; baseline-adjusted difference between groups: -6·3 mm Hg, 95% CI -9·4 to -3·1, p=0·0001). No major adverse events were reported in either group.

INTERPRETATION

Compared with a sham procedure, endovascular ultrasound renal denervation reduced ambulatory blood pressure at 2 months in patients with combined systolic-diastolic hypertension in the absence of medications.

FUNDING

ReCor Medical.