Total colonic aganglionosis: case report, practical diagnostic approach and pitfalls

A Rare Case Presentation on Total Colonic Aganglionosis in a Female Infant of Indian Origin

Total colonic aganglionosis, also called total colonic Hirschsprung's disease, is a known congenital disorder caused by the migration of abnormal embryonic neuroblasts. RET, NRG1, and L1CAM genes are reported as pathological gene variants associated with the incidence of different variants of Hirschsprung's disease. Major clinical presentations are well documented as inefficiency to pass stools, vomiting, fever, persistent crying, and other features of intestinal obstruction. We present here the case of a two-day-old female infant of Indian origin and its diagnostic, clinical, and case management data.

Histopathology of Ganglion Cells in the Proximal Resected Bowel Correlates With the Clinical Outcome in Hirschsprung Disease: A Pilot Study

INTRODUCTION

Intraoperative leveling biopsy by identifying ganglion cells is crucial to determine surgical margin during surgery for Hirschsprung disease (HSCR). The anastomosis should be performed at least 5 cm proximal to the ganglionic segment to prevent transition zone pull-through. However, the length of the transition zone could be much longer than expected and the histological evaluation of the entire circumference of the proximal margin is recommended, which is time-consuming and not applicable for leveling biopsy. We found that the histopathologic features of ganglion cells varied in the examined bowel specimens and demonstrated a pattern similar to immature and degenerated neuron cells. We assumed that the histopathologic features of ganglion cells in the proximal resected bowel were associated with the clinical outcome and might guide the leveling biopsy. In this study, we described a histopathologic grade of ganglion cells based on the degree of maturity and degeneration. We assessed the correlation between the histopathological grade of ganglion cells in the proximal surgical margin and clinical outcome.

METHODS

Three hundred fifty seven patients with HSCR treated between 2013 and 2020 were included. The ganglion cells were divided into six grades based on the histopathologic features in frozen sections. Medical records and detailed histopathologic results of intraoperative frozen sections were reviewed. Follow-up data were collected to evaluate clinical outcomes. The pediatric incontinence and constipation scoring system was used to predict bowel function.

RESULTS

The histopathologic results of proximal resected bowel from 357 HSCR patients were presented as follows: Grade I in 52 patients (14.6%), Grade II in 186 patients (52.1%), Grade III in 107 patients (30.0%), and Grade IV in 12 patients (3.4%). The median follow-up time was 46.8 mo (13.0-97.6 mo). The histopathologic grade of ganglion cells from the proximal resected margin was significantly related to postoperative constipation problems and the incidence of Hirschsprung-associated enterocolitis. The results from the pediatric incontinence and constipation scoring system indicated a positive correlation between better postoperative bowel function and lower histopathologic grade of ganglion cells.

CONCLUSIONS

This pilot study showed an association between the histopathologic features of ganglion cells in the proximal surgical margin and the clinical outcome. It may provide additional information for intraoperative pathologic consultation in leveling biopsy to prevent insufficient resection of the affected colon. A prospective study is warranted to validate these findings before clinical application.

Rare presentation and retrograde diagnosis of total colonic aganglionosis in a female infant: a case report

BACKGROUND

Total colonic aganglionosis is an extremely rare variant of Hirschsprung's disease, which is predominant in males and can be seen in 1:50,000 live births. The presented case not only depicts a rare case, but also unusual clinical, laboratory, and instrumental data.

CASE PRESENTATION

A 2-day-old Caucasian female newborn was transferred to our hospital from maternity. The initial presentation was reverse peristalsis, abdominal distention, and inability to pass stool. Fever had started before the patient was transferred. Hirschsprung's disease was suspected, and tests such as contrast enema and rectal suction biopsy were done. Before enterostomy, the management of the disease included fluid resuscitation, colonic irrigation, antibiotic administration, enteral feeding, and supportive therapy. During ileostomy operation, no transition zone was visualized and full-thickness biopsy samples were retrieved from the rectum and descending colon. After surgical intervention, status significantly improved-defervescence and weight gain most importantly improved.

CONCLUSION

It is well known that diagnosis of total colonic aganglionosis may be delayed for months or even years since the transition zone may not be visible and rectal suction biopsy, unlike full-thickness biopsy, is not always reliable. It might be more prudent not to be derailed because of negative radiography and rectal suction biopsy. Also, doctors should be more suspicious of the disease if signs and symptoms are starting to be consistent with Hirschsprung-associated enterocolitis, despite biopsy and radiology results.

Is the appendix a good organ to diagnose total colonic aganglionosis?

PURPOSE

The use of the appendix for diagnosis of Total Colonic Aganglionosis (TCA) remains controversial. This study aimed to categorize the presence of ganglion cells in the appendix and determine its reliability as a histological specimen for the diagnosis of TCA.

METHODS

This was a combined retrospective and prospective study. Permanent histological specimens of normal appendices removed during appendectomy for malrotation or falsely presumed appendicitis, and from patients with short segment Hirschsprung's disease (HD) or TCA were included. Permanent specimens of the appendix tip from Malone procedures were prospectively collected. All specimens were independently reviewed by two experienced pathologists in a standardized manner to assess for the presence of ganglion cells.

RESULTS

A total of 112 appendices were evaluated. Nine came from patients with a diagnosis of TCA, and five from patients with HD. Ganglion cells were present in all specimens from patients with diagnoses other than TCA and were absent in all specimens from patients with TCA.

CONCLUSION

In the correct clinical setting, the absence of ganglion cells in the appendix can allow for a reliable diagnosis of TCA.

Unexpected gap between intraoperative caliber change of the intestine and normoganglia in patients with intestinal aganglionosis

PURPOSE

Intestinal aganglionosis (IA) is so rare that the entity remains unclear. The aim of the present study was to compare the outcomes of patients with IA and those with total colonic aganglionosis (TCA).

METHODS

The hospital records were retrospectively reviewed from 1977 to 2018. Outcomes were analyzed for the IA group and the TCA group, including clinical presentation, initial management, and operative details.

RESULTS

There were six patients were managed in IA (all male) and seven patients in TCA (4 male). The median age at the first operation was significantly younger in IA than TCA (2 days vs 24 days, p = 0.01). The gap between the intraoperative caliber change (CC) of the intestine and the initial stoma location was not significantly different (7.5 cm vs 12 cm, p = 0.61), but the rate of stoma dysfunction was significantly higher in IA (83% vs 0%, p = 0.005). The gap between the CC and the ganglionated bowel was significantly longer in IA (85 cm vs 10 cm, p = 0.003).

CONCLUSION

Patients with IA appear to have a high risk for stoma dysfunction after the first operation because of the unexpected gap between the CC and normoganglia. The initial location of the stoma requires careful consideration.

Appendicular Biopsy in Total Colonic Aganglionosis: A Histologically Challenging and Inadvisable Practice

Background The reliability of intraoperative evaluation of ganglion cells in the appendix as a guide to a diagnosis of total colonic aganglionosis is unclear. Objective To evaluate the diagnostic utility of appendicular innervation in colonic Hirschsprung disease (HD) and TCA. Methods Prospective, systematic study of ganglion cells and the neural plexii in appendices from cases (HD and TCA) and age matched controls with frozen and paraffin sections, rapid acetylcholinesterase (AChE) and immunohistochemistry. Results A total of 48 appendices (28 controls, 20 cases; 19 frozen) were evaluated. Of these 48, 30 were neonates. Ganglion cell clusters were smaller in controls (28) and HD (6) than those in the rectum, distorted at places and mimicked lymphocytes and endothelial cells, especially in neonates. Complete study of 13 appendices in TCA showed absence of ganglion cells, hypertrophic nerves, AChE activity, and calretinin staining. In 2/13 TCA, an erroneous frozen section identification of ganglia was later corrected based on AChE histochemistry and a panel of IHC stains. Ileal biopsies guided the placement of a ganglionic ileostomy in all. One case each of skip segment aganglionosis in a TCA and variable hypoganglionosis in long segment colonic HD is reported. Conclusion Intraoperative characterization of appendicular innervation as a guide to the diagnosis of TCA is unreliable, in part because of the possibility of skip segment disease/variable hypoganglionosis. We propose terminal ileal biopsies for diagnosis and leveling of aganglionosis. AChE on frozen/calretinin on paraffin tissue is the best approach to avoid diagnostic errors.

Diagnostic roles of calretinin in hirschsprung disease: A comparison to neuron-specific enolase

BACKGROUND/AIM

Diagnosis of Hirschsprung's disease (HD) can be hard and requires good experience, principally for pathologists who infrequently encounter the disease. However, diagnosis is not always possible with hematoxylin and eosin (H and E) because staining has limitations in the identification of immature ganglion cells in neonates and the submucosal area.

AIM

To assess the diagnostic role of calretinin immunostaining in HD in comparison to neuron-specific enolase.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Formalin-fixed paraffin tissue blocks of full-thickness distal colonic and rectal biopsies for 48 patients who clinically presented with symptoms suspicious for HD were collected for the period from December 2012 to January 2016. All biopsies were already studied by routine H and E histopathological examination for the presence or absence of ganglion cells. Further confirmation of ganglion cells and nerve fibers was performed by immunohistochemical study for neuron-specific enolase and calretinin, respectively, in a private pathology laboratory.

RESULTS

According to the histopathological assessment, cases with absent ganglionic cells were considered to be HD, which comprised 40 cases out of the total 48 cases. The mean age for HD cases was 19.43 months. The male-to-female ratio in HD cases was 2.34:1. All HD cases showed negative expression of calretinin in small nerve fibers of the lamina propria, musularis mucosae, and submucosa, and negative expression of neuron-specific enolase in ganglionic cells. The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive values for both the markers in the confirmation of diagnosis of HD were all 100%.

CONCLUSION

Calretinin immunostaining, similar to that of neuron-specific enolase, is a highly sensitive and specific diagnostic aid to histopathological examination in suspected HD.

Effectiveness of calretinin and role of age in the diagnosis of Hirschsprung disease

OBJECTIVE

Gold standard in Hirschsprung disease (HD) diagnosis is rectal suction biopsy (RSB) with hematoxylin and eosin and acetylcholinesterase (ACE) stainings. Sensitivity is 83-93 % and specificity is between 95 and 99 %. The rate of non-conclusive results (NC) due to inadequate samples or variability in the interpretation is about 11-37.8 %. Interpretation is still difficult in neonates. Calretinin (C) is a calcium-binding protein, expressed in the nervous system. It has been introduced as a marker to improve the diagnosis accuracy in HD. We compare sensitivity, specificity between ACE and ACE + C and investigate whether the introduction of C could reduce the rate of inconclusive results. We also tried to define the most adequate age to obtain accurate results from RSB.

METHODS

Data from patients undergoing rectal suction biopsies from 2005 to 2014 was analyzed. Until 2010 we used ACE; since 2011 we used ACE + C. The ROC curve analysis of the NC results regarding the age, showed an optimal cut-off point at 1.5 months (m). It divides the sample into two groups which we compared.

RESULTS

We analyzed 91 patients. Results of the RSB: 40 HD (44 %), 34 no Hirschsprung (37.4 %) and 17 NC (18.7 %). Sensitivity = 97.5 %, specificity = 97.1 %, not including the NC (1 false positive, 1 false negative). Results depending on the staining: ACE (n = 58) (%) ACE + C (n = 33) (%) p Sensitivity 96 100 1 Specificity 94.7 100 1 NC 24.1 9.1 0.077 Results depending on the age: <1.5 m (n = 27) (%) >1.5 m (n = 64) (%) p Sensitivity 92.3 100 0.325 Specificity 100 96.8 1 NC 40.7 9.4 0.001 CONCLUSION: Calretinin decreases the rate of inconclusive results, but not significantly. The percentage of inconclusive results decreases in patients olders than 1.5 m. Further studies are necessary to determine if this technique is useful to improve RSB results in infants younger than 1.5 months.

Hirschsprung's disease - Postsurgical intestinal dysmotility

OBJECTIVE

To describe the case of an infant with Hirschsprung's disease presenting as total colonic aganglionosis, which, after surgical resection of the aganglionic segment persisted with irreversible functional intestinal obstruction; discuss the difficulties in managing this form of congenital aganglionosis and discuss a plausible pathogenetic mechanism for this case.

CASE DESCRIPTION

The diagnosis of Hirschsprung's disease presenting as total colonic aganglionosis was established in a two-month-old infant, after an episode of enterocolitis, hypovolemic shock and severe malnutrition. After colonic resection, the patient did not recover intestinal motor function that would allow enteral feeding. Postoperative examination of remnant ileum showed the presence of ganglionic plexus and a reduced number of interstitial cells of Cajal in the proximal bowel segments. At 12 months, the patient remains dependent on total parenteral nutrition.

COMMENTS

Hirschsprung's disease presenting as total colonic aganglionosis has clinical and surgical characteristics that differentiate it from the classic forms, complicating the diagnosis and the clinical and surgical management. The postoperative course may be associated with permanent morbidity due to intestinal dysmotility. The numerical reduction or alteration of neural connections in the interstitial cells of Cajal may represent a possible physiopathological basis for the condition.

Aganglionosis with the absence of hypertrophied nerve fibres predicts disease proximal to rectosigmoid colon

PURPOSE

The gold standard for the diagnosis of Hirschsprung's disease (HSCR) is the pathologic evaluation of a rectal biopsy that demonstrates the absence of ganglion cells and nerve fibre hypertrophy. However, it has been frequently reported that hypertrophic nerves may not be present in some variants like long-segment HSCR, total colonic aganglionosis, premature and very young infants. The aim of this study was to determine this association.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective review of the HSCR database at our tertiary care children's hospital from 2000 to 2013. In order to analyse the relationship between the diameter of the nerve fibres and the level of aganglionosis, we classified the patient sample into two groups-fibres ≤40 and >40 μm. The groups were statistically compared with P < 0.05 being significant.

RESULTS

Rectal biopsies of 92 patients confirmed as HSCR with definitive operation performed at the same institution were reviewed. The mean nerve diameter was 50.1 μm (range 20-87.5 μm). Nerve fibre diameter ≤40 μm was predictive of transition zone above the sigmoid colon. A specificity of 77.3 % and a likelihood ratio of 2.03 supported this perception. No correlation was noted between nerve fibre diameter and gestational age at birth, birth weight or age at biopsy.

CONCLUSION

The absence of nerve fibre hypertrophy in the presence of aganglionosis on rectal biopsy specimens is predictive of long-segment HSCR.

Total colonic aganglionosis and Hirschsprung's disease: a review

Total colonic aganglionosis is a relatively uncommon form of Hirschsprung's disease (HSCR). It occurs in approximately 2-13 % of HSCR cases and involves the entire colon which is aganglionic but may extend proximally into varying lengths of small bowel. As a result, it should be separated into Total colonic aganglionosis (TCA) [defined as aganglionosis extending from the anus to at least the ileocaecal valve but no more than 50 cm small bowel proximal to the ileocaecal valve] and total colonic and small bowel aganglionosis (TCSA) which may involve very long segments of small bowel aganglionosis. Clinically, TCA appears to represent a different spectrum of disease in terms of presentation and difficulties which may be experienced in diagnosis suggesting a different pathophysiology from the more common forms of HSCR. It is therefore not yet clear whether TCA merely represents a long form of HSCR or a different expression of the disease. A number of differences exist between TCA and other forms of HSCR which require explanation if its ubiquitous clinical features are to be understood. In addition to the usual explanations for the aganglionosis of HSCR, there is some evidence suggesting that in place of being purely congenital, it may represent certain different pathophysiologic mechanisms, some of which may continue to be active after birth. This study reviews what is known about the clinical, radiological and histopathologic differences between TCA and the more frequently encountered recto-sigmoid (or short-segment; S-HSCR) and correlates them with what is currently known about the genetic and molecular biologic background to find possible pathogenetic mechanisms.

A variant pattern of calretinin immunohistochemistry on rectal suction-biopsies is fully specific of short-segment Hirschsprung's disease

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Calretinin immunohistochemistry is now widely used to diagnose Hirschsprung's disease (HD), since loss of calretinin expression within the mucosa and muscularis mucosae of rectal suction-biopsy is pathognomonic of HD. However, a stippled staining may be observed within hypertrophic nerves in the submucosae in some HD patients. The aim of the study was to test the hypothesis that such findings may announce the beginning of the transitional zone.

METHODS

We retrieved 44 consecutive patients (10 girls and 34 boys; median age 6.5 days), diagnosed with aganglionosis on rectal suction biopsies, followed by surgery. According to calretinin immunohistochemistry performed on all paraffin-embedded rectal biopsies, we defined two HD groups: P- showing an absence of any staining within mucosa, muscularis mucosae and submucosa et P+ showing an absence of staining within the mucosa and muscularis mucosae, but a positivity of some submucosal hypertrophic nerves. These data were correlated to the length of total pathological segment (aganglionic and transitional zones) obtained from the original surgery reports.

RESULTS

18/44 patients (40.9 %) belonged to the P+ group and 26/44 (59 %) patients were within the P- group. In the P+ group, the maximal length of the aganglionic zone was 9 cm [mean 4 (1-9)] and the total pathological zone never exceeded 14 cm [mean 8 (3.8-14)]. In the P- group, the maximal length of aganglionic zone was 55.5 cm [mean 11.3 (2.5; 55.5)] and the total pathological zone extended to 59.5 cm [mean 17.75 (4.5; 59.5)]. Aganglionic segment was significantly shorter in the P+ group (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

Staining of some hypertrophic nerves in the submucosa in suction rectal biopsy of HD patients using calretinin immunohistochemistry is only encountered in short-segment aganglionosis with a pathological zone always restricted to rectal and sigmoid colon. This information could be crucial for the surgeons in the decision to choose a transanal procedure.

Predictive value of nerve trunk size in the neonate

PURPOSE

The diagnosis of Hirschsprung's disease (HD) remains challenging. The identification of ganglion cells is difficult and acetycholine esterase (AChE) staining can be subject to a great variability, particularly in the neonatal period (<8 weeks). Nerve trunks greater than 40 µm are considered to be predictive for HD. The aim of this study was to evaluate the usefulness of measuring nerve trunk size in the newborn with HD.

METHODS

Out of 292 biopsies 69 could be reanalyzed by three independent researchers. 40 µm was used as cutoff point for nerve trunk size. They were subdivided into three groups: (a) diagnosis of HD certain at the first biopsy, (b) no HD and (c) diagnosis of HD remains doubtful and re-biopsy taken.

RESULTS

In 87 % of group A nerve trunk size was ≥ 40 µm (SD 13.8). In 84 % of group B trunk size was < 40 µm (SD 16.2). In group C only 60 % of the patients showed a positive correlation between final diagnosis and nerve trunk size.

CONCLUSION

Using 40 µm as the cutoff point gave 13 % false-negative and 16 % false-positive cases. Measurement of the nerve trunk in the neonatal period does not seem to be a reliable method for detecting HD.

Total colonic aganglionosis--a diagnostic intricacy

Total colonic aganglionosis (TCA) is an unusual variety of aganglionosis. Although appearing to be an extension of Hirschprung's disease (HD), it may differ from it in many ways and thus is difficult to diagnose on the basis of features applied for HD. The aim of this case report is to discuss the difficulties encountered in recognition of TCA and identification of features which can help in early diagnosis.

Total colonic aganglionosis: a surgical challenge. How to avoid complications?

INTRODUCTION

Total colonic aganglionosis represents a significant challenge for pediatric surgeons. Long-term results are suboptimal and complications are very common. We analyzed our experience to formulate recommendations to achieve better results and avoid complications and sequelae.

METHODS

The medical records of patients with total colonic aganglionosis that were operated on by us primarily or secondarily were reviewed. We evaluated: number of operations performed, preventable complications, bowel control or presence of stomas, and clinical follow-up. Based on this experience we describe our current approach for this condition. IRB approval was obtained.

RESULTS

27 patients were identified (19 males, 8 females). 12 patients had the primary pullthrough performed by us and 15 were operated on elsewhere before coming to us for reoperation. The average number of operations per patient was 6.8 (1-40). We identified several preventable complications: ileostomy prolapse or stricture (21), severe diaper rash (10), obstructive symptoms following a pouch or patch-type of pullthrough (9), infection, abscess, and fistula after the pullthrough (5); wrong histologic diagnosis leading to colostomy opening in aganglionic bowel (4) with consequent pullthrough of aganglionic intestine in two of them; anastomotic stricture/acquired atresia (3); and destroyed anal canal and permanent fecal incontinence (2). 15 patients have bowel control; 11 have an ileostomy: temporary (7) and permanent (4); and one is less than 3 years of age. Length of follow-up ranged from 1 to 17 years. Based on this experience, our approach for this condition consists of: colectomy with straight ileoanal anastomosis and ileostomy at presentation, followed by ileostomy closure only when the child is toilet trained for urine and is willing to tolerate rectal irrigations.

CONCLUSION

Total colonic aganglionosis remains a serious surgical challenge. Patients suffering from the condition, have multiple complications, sequelae, and often require reoperations. We found that it is possible to prevent many of these by properly fixing the stoma, avoiding pouch or patch procedures, delaying ileostomy closure, having pathology expertise, and with meticulous surgical technique starting the dissection/anastomosis well above the dentate line.

A preliminary report on the significance of excessively long segment congenital hypoganglionosis management during early infancy

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE

Excessively long segment of congenital hypoganglionosis is rare, and therapeutic strategies to treat this disorder are not well established. The purpose of this study is to describe the significance of management in the neonatal and early infancy period.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Four patients (aged 1-4 years) with hypoganglionosis were selected for this study, of which 3 were treated at our hospital. In the initial treatment of 3 cases, an intraoperative pathological diagnosis was made on the basis of findings from simultaneous biopsies taken from the jejunum and sigmoid colon. Retrospective reviews of these patients were performed.

RESULTS

Initial double-barrel jejunostomy at less than 50 cm from the ligament of Treitz allowed patients to start oral nutrition within a week following surgery. Subsequent refashioning of the initial jejunostomy to the Bishop-Koop type was performed at 3 to 6 months of age. Intravenous hyperalimentation was required to meet less than 50% of nutritional requirements, and patients were able to maintain their body weight within 1.5 SD of the normal mean body weight. Liver function test results were also within normal limits in the 3 patients treated at our hospital.

CONCLUSION

Early diagnosis and treatment may help improve the management of patients in the early stages of hypoganglionosis.