How subtle changes in 3D structure can create large changes in transcription

Cohesin organizes 3D DNA contacts surrounding active enhancers in C. elegans

In mammals, cohesin and CTCF organize the 3D genome into topologically associating domains (TADs) to regulate communication between cis-regulatory elements. Many organisms, including S. cerevisiae, C. elegans, and A. thaliana contain cohesin but lack CTCF. Here, we used C. elegans to investigate the function of cohesin in 3D genome organization in the absence of CTCF. Using Hi-C data, we observe cohesin-dependent features called "fountains," which have also been reported in zebrafish and mice. These are population average reflections of DNA loops originating from distinct genomic regions and are ∼20-40 kb in C. elegans Hi-C analysis upon cohesin and WAPL-1 depletion supports the idea that cohesin is preferentially loaded at sites bound by the C. elegans ortholog of NIPBL and loop extrudes in an effectively two-sided manner. ChIP-seq analyses show that cohesin translocation along the fountain trajectory depends on a fully intact complex and is extended upon WAPL-1 depletion. Hi-C contact patterns at individual fountains suggest that cohesin processivity is unequal on each side, possibly owing to collision with cohesin loaded from surrounding sites. The putative cohesin loading sites are closest to active enhancers, and fountain strength is associated with transcription. Compared with mammals, the average processivity of C. elegans cohesin is about 10-fold shorter, and the binding of NIPBL ortholog does not depend on cohesin. We propose that preferential loading and loop extrusion by cohesin is an evolutionarily conserved mechanism that regulates the 3D interactions of enhancers in animal genomes.

Chrombus-XMBD: a graph convolution model predicting 3D-genome from chromatin features

The 3D conformation of the chromatin is crucial for transcriptional regulation. However, current experimental techniques for detecting the 3D structure of the genome are costly and limited to the biological conditions. Here, we described "ChrombusXMBD," a graph convolution model capable of predicting chromatin interactions ab initio based on available chromatin features. Using dynamic edge convolution with multihead attention mechanism, Chrombus encodes the 2D-chromatin features into a learnable embedding space, thereby generating a genome-wide 3D-contactmap. In validation, Chrombus effectively recapitulated the topological associated domains, expression quantitative trait loci, and promoter/enhancer interactions. Especially, Chrombus outperforms existing algorithms in predicting chromatin interactions over 1-2 Mb, increasing prediction correlation by 11.8%-48.7%, and predicts long-range interactions over 2 Mb (Pearson's coefficient 0.243-0.582). Chrombus also exhibits strong generalizability across human and mouse-derived cell lines. Additionally, the parameters of Chrombus inform the biological mechanisms underlying cistrome. Our model provides a new, generalizable analytical tool for understanding the complex dynamics of chromatin interactions and the landscape of cis-regulation of gene expression.

Predicting gene expression changes from chromatin structure modification

Spatial organization of chromatin plays a critical role in gene transcription, but connecting population-averaged HiC data to functional outcomes remains a challenge. We present a computational framework linking HiC contact map to gene transcription. Utilizing a bead-spring polymer model informed by HiC contact maps, we generate an ensemble of 3D conformations for a given genomic locus. These conformations are then coupled to gene transcription levels through a Markov chain model, with transition rates derived from molecular dynamics simulations. The efficacy of this framework is demonstrated by simulating the perturbation of a CTCF-mediated TAD boundary, impacting the expression of sox9 and kcnj2. Our model quantitatively reproduces experimentally observed changes in gene expression, revealing that the increased kcnj2 transcription is a consequence of enhancers within the sox9 TAD becoming accessible upon boundary disruption. Quantifying enhancer impact, our model can also identify functional enhancers. This framework enhances our understanding of the relationship between chromosome spatial architecture and gene regulation.

3D genome folding in epigenetic regulation and cellular memory

The 3D folding of the genome is tightly linked to its epigenetic state which maintains gene expression programmes. Although the relationship between gene expression and genome organisation is highly context dependent, 3D genome organisation is emerging as a novel epigenetic layer to reinforce and stabilise transcriptional states. Whether regulatory information carried in genome folding could be transmitted through mitosis is an area of active investigation. In this review, we discuss the relationship between epigenetic state and nuclear organisation, as well as the interplay between transcriptional regulation and epigenetic genome folding. We also consider the architectural remodelling of nuclei as cells enter and exit mitosis, and evaluate the potential of the 3D genome to contribute to cellular memory.

Omics analyses uncover host networks defining virus-permissive and -hostile cellular states

The capacity of host cells to sustain or restrict virus infection is influenced by their proteome. Understanding the compendium of proteins defining cellular permissiveness is key to many questions in fundamental virology. Here, we apply a multiomic approach to determine the proteins that are associated with highly permissive, intermediate, and hostile cellular states. We observed two groups of differentially regulated genes: i) with robust changes in mRNA and protein levels, and ii) with protein/RNA discordances. Whereas many of the latter are classified as interferon stimulated genes (ISGs), most exhibit no antiviral effects in overexpression screens. This suggest that IFN-dependent protein changes can be better indicators of antiviral function than mRNA levels. Phosphoproteomics revealed an additional regulatory layer involving non-signalling proteins with altered phosphorylation. Indeed, we confirmed that several permissiveness-associated proteins with changes in abundance or phosphorylation regulate infection fitness. Altogether, our study provides a comprehensive and systematic map of the cellular alterations driving virus susceptibility.

Kinetic organization of the genome revealed by ultra-resolution, multiscale live imaging

In the last decade, sequencing methods like Hi-C have made it clear the genome is intricately folded, and that this organization contributes significantly to the control of gene expression and thence cell fate and behavior. Single-cell DNA tracing microscopy and polymer physics-based simulations of genome folding have proposed these population-scale patterns arise from motor- driven, heterogeneous movement, rather than stable 3D genomic architecture, implying that motion, rather than structure, is key to understanding genome function. However, tools to directly observe this motion in vivo have been limited in coverage and resolution. Here we describe TRansposon Assisted Chromatin Kinetic Imaging Technology (TRACK-IT), which combines a suite of imaging and labeling improvements to achieve ultra-resolution in space and time, with self-mapping transposons to distribute labels across the chromosome, uncovering dynamic behaviors across four orders of magnitude of genomic separation. We find that sequences separated by sub-megabase distances, typically 200-500 nm of nanometers apart, can transition to close proximity in tens of seconds - faster than previously hypothesized. This rapid motion is dependent upon cohesin and is exhibited only within certain genomic domains. Domain borders act as kinetic impediments to this search process, substantially slowing the rate and frequency of the transition to proximity. The genomic separation-dependent scaling of the search time for cis-interactions within a domain violates predictions of diffusion, suggesting motor driven folding. This distinctive scaling is lost following cohesin depletion, replaced with a behavior consistent with diffusion. Finally, we found cohesin containing cells exhibited rare, processive movements, not seen in cohesin depleted cells. These processive trajectories exhibit extrusion rates of ∼2.7 kb/s across three distinct genomic intervals, faster than recent in vitro measurements and prior estimates from in vivo data. Taken together, these results reveal a genome in motion across multiple genomic and temporal scales, where motor-dependent extrusion divides the sequence, not into spatially separate domains, but into kinetically separated domains that experience accelerated local search.

CHD7 binds to insulators during neuronal differentiation

Spiral ganglion neurons (SGNs) are crucial for hearing, and the loss of SGNs causes hearing loss. Stem cell-based therapies offer a promising approach for SGN regeneration and require understanding the mechanisms governing SGN differentiation. We investigated the chromatin remodeler CHD7 in neuronal differentiation using immortalized multipotent otic progenitor (iMOP) cells. We demonstrated that CHD7 knockdown impaired neuronal differentiation. Genome-wide analysis revealed CHD7 binding at diverse cis-regulatory elements, with notable enrichment at sites marked by the insulator-binding protein CTCF between topologically associating domains (TADs). Insulators marked by the enrichment of CHD7 and CTCF resided near genes critical for neuronal differentiation, including Mir9-2. Targeting these regulatory regions in iMOPs with CRISPR interference (CRISPRi) and activation (CRISPRa) increased miR-9 transcription, irrespective of the method. Blocking the CHD7 and CTCF marked sites suggested that the elements function as insulators to regulate gene expression. The study highlights CHD7 activity at insulators and underscores an unreported mechanism for promoting neuronal differentiation.

Cohesin as an essential disruptor of chromosome organization

Cohesin is a multi-subunit molecular machine that is able to create lateral chromatin loops within a linear chromosome fiber. Despite intense study, a consensus view of the functional significance of loop extrusion has remained elusive. This perspective proposes a rationale based on the need for continual disruption of spurious higher-order chromatin secondary structures. It is argued that cohesin-mediated chromosomal churn ensures broad accessibility to the diffusible factors on which genome function depends.

Bridging spatial and temporal scales of developmental gene regulation

The development of multicellular organisms relies on the precise coordination of molecular events across multiple spatial and temporal scales. Understanding how information flows from molecular interactions to cellular processes and tissue organization during development is crucial for explaining the remarkable reproducibility of complex organisms. This review explores how chromatin-encoded information is transduced from localized transcriptional events to global gene expression patterns, highlighting the challenge of bridging these scales. We discuss recent experimental findings and theoretical frameworks, emphasizing polymer physics as a tool for describing the relationship between chromatin structure and dynamics across scales. By integrating these perspectives, we aim to clarify how gene regulation is coordinated across levels of biological organization and suggest strategies for future experimental approaches.

Exploring the interplay between enhancer-promoter interactions and transcription

Enhancers in metazoan genomes are known to activate their target genes across both short and long genomic distances. Recent advances in chromosome conformation capture assays and single-cell imaging have shed light on the underlying chromatin contacts and dynamics. Yet the relationship between 3D physical enhancer-promoter (E-P) interactions and transcriptional activation remains unresolved. In this brief review, we discuss recent studies exploring this relationship across scales: from developmental stages to the minutes surrounding transcriptional activation and from the tissue level to single-allele subcellular dynamics. We discuss how seemingly contradictory observations might be reconciled and contribute to a refined causal relationship between E-P interactions and transcription, with mutual influences.

Bridging spatial and temporal scales of developmental gene regulation

The development of multicellular organisms relies on the precise coordination of molecular events across multiple spatial and temporal scales. Understanding how information flows from molecular interactions to cellular processes and tissue organization during development is crucial for explaining the remarkable reproducibility of complex organisms. This review explores how chromatin-encoded information is transduced from localized transcriptional events to global gene expression patterns, highlighting the challenge of bridging these scales. We discuss recent experimental findings and theoretical frameworks, emphasizing polymer physics as a tool for describing the relationship between chromatin structure and dynamics across scales. By integrating these perspectives, we aim to clarify how gene regulation is coordinated across levels of biological organization and suggest strategies for future experimental approaches.

Enhancer cooperativity can compensate for loss of activity over large genomic distances

Enhancers are short DNA sequences that activate their target promoter from a distance; however, increasing the genomic distance between the enhancer and the promoter decreases expression levels. Many genes are controlled by combinations of multiple enhancers, yet the interaction and cooperation of individual enhancer elements are not well understood. Here, we developed a synthetic platform in mouse embryonic stem cells that allows building complex regulatory landscapes from the bottom up. We tested the system by integrating individual enhancers at different distances and confirmed that the strength of an enhancer contributes to how strongly it is affected by increased genomic distance. Furthermore, synergy between two enhancer elements depends on the distance at which the two elements are integrated: introducing a weak enhancer between a strong enhancer and the promoter strongly increases reporter gene expression, allowing enhancers to activate from increased genomic distances.

Long-range regulation of transcription scales with genomic distance in a gene-specific manner

Although critical for tuning the timing and level of transcription, enhancer communication with distal promoters is not well understood. Here, we bypass the need for sequence-specific transcription factors (TFs) and recruit activators directly using a chimeric array of gRNA oligos to target dCas9 fused to the activator VP64-p65-Rta (CARGO-VPR). We show that this approach achieves effective activator recruitment to arbitrary genomic sites, even those inaccessible when targeted with a single guide. We utilize CARGO-VPR across the Prdm8-Fgf5 locus in mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs), where neither gene is expressed. Although activator recruitment to any tested region results in the transcriptional induction of at least one gene, the expression level strongly depends on the genomic distance between the promoter and activator recruitment site. However, the expression-distance relationship for each gene scales distinctly in a manner not attributable to differences in 3D contact frequency, promoter DNA sequence, or the presence of repressive chromatin marks at the locus.

Genome-wide absolute quantification of chromatin looping

3D genomics methods such as Hi-C and Micro-C have uncovered chromatin loops across the genome and linked these loops to gene regulation. However, these methods only measure 3D interaction probabilities on a relative scale. Here, we overcome this limitation by using live imaging data to calibrate Micro-C in mouse embryonic stem cells, thus obtaining absolute looping probabilities for 36,804 chromatin loops across the genome. We find that the looped state is generally rare, with a mean probability of 2.3% and a maximum of 26% across the quantified loops. On average, CTCF-CTCF loops are stronger than loops between cis-regulatory elements (3.2% vs. 1.1%). Our findings can be extended to human stem cells and differentiated cells under certain assumptions. Overall, we establish an approach for genome-wide absolute loop quantification and report that loops generally occur with low probabilities, generalizing recent live imaging results to the whole genome.

Dynamic Regulation OF The Chromatin Environment By Ash1L Modulates Human Neuronal Structure And Function

Precise regulation of the chromatin environment through post-translational histone modification modulates transcription and controls brain development. Not surprisingly, mutations in a large number of histone-modifying enzymes underlie complex brain disorders. In particular, the histone methyltransferase ASH1L modifies histone marks linked to transcriptional activation and has been implicated in multiple neuropsychiatric disorders. However, the mechanisms underlying the pathobiology of ASH1L-asociated disease remain underexplored. We generated human isogenic stem cells with a mutation in ASH1L's catalytic domain. We find that ASH1L dysfunction results in reduced neurite outgrowth, which correlates with alterations in the chromatin profile of activating and repressive histone marks, as well as the dysregulation of gene programs important for neuronal structure and function implicated in neuropsychiatric disease. We also identified a novel regulatory node implicating both the SP and Krüppel -like families of transcription factors and ASH1L relevant to human neuronal development. Finally, we rescue cellular defects linked to ASH1L dysfunction by leveraging two independent epigenetic mechanisms that promote transcriptional activation. In summary, we identified an ASH1L-driven epigenetic and transcriptional axis essential for human brain development and complex brain disorders that provide insights into future therapeutic strategies for ASH1L-related disorders.

Gene mobility elements mediate cell type specific genome organization and radial gene movement in vivo

Understanding the level of genome organization that governs gene regulation remains a challenge despite advancements in chromatin profiling techniques. Cell type specific chromatin architectures may be obscured by averaging heterogeneous cell populations. Here we took a reductionist perspective, starting with the relocation of the hunchback gene to the nuclear lamina in Drosophila neuroblasts. We previously found that this event terminates competence to produce early-born neurons and is mediated by an intronic 250 base-pair element, which we term gene mobility element (GME). Here we found over 800 putative GMEs globally that are chromatin accessible and are Polycomb (PcG) target sites. GMEs appear to be distinct from PcG response elements, however, which are largely chromatin inaccessible in neuroblasts. Performing in situ Hi-C of purified neuroblasts, we found that GMEs form megabase-scale chromatin interactions, spanning multiple topologically associated domain borders, preferentially contacting other GMEs. These interactions are cell type and stage-specific. Notably, GMEs undergo developmentally- timed mobilization to/from the neuroblast nuclear lamina, and domain swapping a GFP reporter transgene intron with a GME relocates the transgene to the nuclear lamina in embryos. We propose that GMEs constitute a genome organizational framework and mediate gene-to-lamina mobilization during progenitor competence state transitions in vivo .

Evolution and function of chromatin domains across the tree of life

The genome of all organisms is spatially organized to function efficiently. The advent of genome-wide chromatin conformation capture (Hi-C) methods has revolutionized our ability to probe the three-dimensional (3D) organization of genomes across diverse species. In this Review, we compare 3D chromatin folding from bacteria and archaea to that in mammals and plants, focusing on topology at the level of gene regulatory domains. In doing so, we consider systematic similarities and differences that hint at the origin and evolution of spatial chromatin folding and its relation to gene activity. We discuss the universality of spatial chromatin domains in all kingdoms, each encompassing one to several genes. We also highlight differences between organisms and suggest that similar features in Hi-C matrices do not necessarily reflect the same biological process or function. Furthermore, we discuss the evolution of domain boundaries and boundary-forming proteins, which indicates that structural maintenance of chromosome (SMC) proteins and the transcription machinery are the ancestral sculptors of the genome. Architectural proteins such as CTCF serve as clade-specific determinants of genome organization. Finally, studies in many non-model organisms show that, despite the ancient origin of 3D chromatin folding and its intricate link to gene activity, evolution tolerates substantial changes in genome organization.

Better together: how cooperativity influences transcriptional bursting

Transcriptional bursting refers to the stochastic transition of a promoter between transcriptionally active and inactive states. This dynamic process is highly regulated by the dynamics of transcription factor binding to DNA, their interactions with coactivators, and the 3D interactions between promoters, condensates, and enhancers. In this mini-review, we discuss recent insights into the kinetics of transcription factors and cofactors in both simple and complex regulatory environments to understand their impact on transcriptional bursting. We examine the novel concept of transcription factor exchange and relate it to different cooperativity models. Finally, we discuss recent live-cell imaging studies on the regulation of transcriptional bursting by enhancers and transcriptional condensates.

Single-molecule states link transcription factor binding to gene expression

The binding of multiple transcription factors (TFs) to genomic enhancers drives gene expression in mammalian cells1. However, the molecular details that link enhancer sequence to TF binding, promoter state and transcription levels remain unclear. Here we applied single-molecule footprinting2,3 to measure the simultaneous occupancy of TFs, nucleosomes and other regulatory proteins on engineered enhancer-promoter constructs with variable numbers of TF binding sites for both a synthetic TF and an endogenous TF involved in the type I interferon response. Although TF binding events on nucleosome-free DNA are independent, activation domains recruit cofactors that destabilize nucleosomes, driving observed TF binding cooperativity. Average TF occupancy linearly determines promoter activity, and we decompose TF strength into separable binding and activation terms. Finally, we develop thermodynamic and kinetic models that quantitatively predict both the enhancer binding microstates and gene expression dynamics. This work provides a template for the quantitative dissection of distinct contributors to gene expression, including TF activation domains, concentration, binding affinity, binding site configuration and recruitment of chromatin regulators.

The chromosome folding problem and how cells solve it

Every cell must solve the problem of how to fold its genome. We describe how the folded state of chromosomes is the result of the combined activity of multiple conserved mechanisms. Homotypic affinity-driven interactions lead to spatial partitioning of active and inactive loci. Molecular motors fold chromosomes through loop extrusion. Topological features such as supercoiling and entanglements contribute to chromosome folding and its dynamics, and tethering loci to sub-nuclear structures adds additional constraints. Dramatically diverse chromosome conformations observed throughout the cell cycle and across the tree of life can be explained through differential regulation and implementation of these basic mechanisms. We propose that the first functions of chromosome folding are to mediate genome replication, compaction, and segregation and that mechanisms of folding have subsequently been co-opted for other roles, including long-range gene regulation, in different conditions, cell types, and species.

Fluctuating Chromatin Facilitates Enhancer-Promoter Communication by Regulating Transcriptional Clustering Dynamics

Enhancers regulate gene expression by forming contacts with distant promoters. Phase-separated condensates or clusters formed by transcription factors (TFs) and cofactors are thought to facilitate these enhancer-promoter (E-P) interactions. Using polymer physics, we developed distinct coarse-grained chromatin models that produce similar ensemble-averaged Hi-C maps but with "stable" and "dynamic" characteristics. Our findings, consistent with recent experiments, reveal a multistep E-P communication process. The dynamic model facilitates E-P proximity by enhancing TF clustering and subsequently promotes direct E-P interactions by destabilizing the TF clusters through chain flexibility. Our study promotes physical understanding of the molecular mechanisms governing E-P communication in transcriptional regulation.

A Bioconductor/R Workflow for the Detection and Visualization of Differential Chromatin Loops

Background

Chromatin loops play a critical role in gene regulation by connecting regulatory loci and gene promoters. The identification of changes in chromatin looping between cell types or biological conditions is an important task for understanding gene regulation; however, the manipulation, statistical analysis, and visualization of data sets describing 3D chromatin structure is challenging due to the large and complex nature of the relevant data sets.

Methods

Here, we describe a workflow for identifying and visualizing differential chromatin loops from Hi-C data from two biological conditions using the 'mariner', 'DESeq2' and 'plotgardener' Bioconductor/R packages. The workflow assumes that Hi-C data has been processed into '.hic' or '.cool' files and that loops have been identified using an existing loop-calling algorithm.

Results

First, the 'mariner' package is used to merge redundant loop calls and extract interaction frequency counts. Next, 'DESeq2' is used to identify loops that exhibit differential contact frequencies between conditions. Finally, 'plotgardener' is used to visualize differential loops.

Conclusion

Chromatin interaction data is an important modality for understanding the mechanisms of transcriptional regulation. The workflow presented here outlines the use of 'mariner' as a tool to manipulate, extract, and aggregate chromatin interaction data, 'DESeq2' to perform differential analysis of these data across conditions, samples, and replicates, and 'plotgardener' to explore and visualize the results.

Regulatory landscape of enhancer-mediated transcriptional activation

Enhancers are noncoding regulatory elements that instruct spatial and temporal specificity of gene transcription in response to a variety of intrinsic and extrinsic signals during development. Although it has long been postulated that enhancers physically interact with target promoters through the formation of stable loops, recent studies have changed this static view: sequence-specific transcription factors (TFs) and coactivators are dynamically recruited to enhancers and assemble so-called transcription hubs. Dynamic assembly of transcription hubs appears to serve as a key scaffold to integrate regulatory information encoded by surrounding genome and biophysical properties of transcription machineries. In this review, we outline emerging new models of transcriptional regulation by enhancers and discuss future perspectives.

Cohesin organizes 3D DNA contacts surrounding active enhancers in C. elegans

In mammals, cohesin and CTCF organize the 3D genome into topologically associated domains (TADs) to regulate communication between cis-regulatory elements. Many organisms, including S. cerevisiae, C. elegans, and A. thaliana contain cohesin but lack CTCF. Here, we used C. elegans to investigate the function of cohesin in 3D genome organization in the absence of CTCF. Using Hi-C data, we observe cohesin-dependent features called "fountains", which are also reported in zebrafish and mice. These are population average reflections of DNA loops originating from distinct genomic regions and are ~20-40 kb in C. elegans. Hi-C analysis upon cohesin and WAPL depletion support the idea that cohesin is preferentially loaded at NIPBL occupied sites and loop extrudes in an effectively two-sided manner. ChIP-seq analyses show that cohesin translocation along the fountain trajectory depends on a fully intact complex and is extended upon WAPL-1 depletion. Hi-C contact patterns at individual fountains suggest that cohesin processivity is unequal on each side, possibly due to collision with cohesin loaded from surrounding sites. The putative cohesin loading sites are closest to active enhancers and fountain strength is associated with transcription. Compared to mammals, average processivity of C. elegans cohesin is ~10-fold shorter and NIPBL binding does not depend on cohesin. We propose that preferential loading and loop extrusion by cohesin is an evolutionarily conserved mechanism that regulates the 3D interactions of enhancers in animal genomes.

YY1-controlled regulatory connectivity and transcription are influenced by the cell cycle

Few transcription factors have been examined for their direct roles in physically connecting enhancers and promoters. Here acute degradation of Yin Yang 1 (YY1) in erythroid cells revealed its requirement for the maintenance of numerous enhancer-promoter loops, but not compartments or domains. Despite its reported ability to interact with cohesin, the formation of YY1-dependent enhancer-promoter loops does not involve stalling of cohesin-mediated loop extrusion. Integrating mitosis-to-G1-phase dynamics, we observed partial retention of YY1 on mitotic chromatin, predominantly at gene promoters, followed by rapid rebinding during mitotic exit, coinciding with enhancer-promoter loop establishment. YY1 degradation during the mitosis-to-G1-phase interval revealed a set of enhancer-promoter loops that require YY1 for establishment during G1-phase entry but not for maintenance in interphase, suggesting that cell cycle stage influences YY1's architectural function. Thus, as revealed here for YY1, chromatin architectural functions of transcription factors can vary in their interplay with CTCF and cohesin as well as by cell cycle stage.

Cooperative insulation of regulatory domains by CTCF-dependent physical insulation and promoter competition

The specificity of gene expression during development requires the insulation of regulatory domains to avoid inappropriate enhancer-gene interactions. In vertebrates, this insulator function is mostly attributed to clusters of CTCF sites located at topologically associating domain (TAD) boundaries. However, TAD boundaries allow some physical crosstalk across regulatory domains, which is at odds with the specific and precise expression of developmental genes. Here we show that developmental genes and nearby clusters of CTCF sites cooperatively foster the robust insulation of regulatory domains. By genetically dissecting a couple of representative loci in mouse embryonic stem cells, we show that CTCF sites prevent undesirable enhancer-gene contacts (i.e. physical insulation), while developmental genes preferentially contribute to regulatory insulation through non-structural mechanisms involving promoter competition rather than enhancer blocking. Overall, our work provides important insights into the insulation of regulatory domains, which in turn might help interpreting the pathological consequences of certain structural variants.

The method in the madness: Transcriptional control from stochastic action at the single-molecule scale

Cell states result from the ordered activation of gene expression by transcription factors. Transcription factors face opposing design constraints: they need to be dynamic to trigger rapid cell state transitions, but also stable enough to maintain terminal cell identities indefinitely. Recent progress in live-cell single-molecule microscopy has helped define the biophysical principles underlying this paradox. Beyond transcription factor activity, single-molecule experiments have revealed that at nearly every level of transcription regulation, control emerges from multiple short-lived stochastic interactions, rather than deterministic, stable interactions typical of other biochemical pathways. This architecture generates consistent outcomes that can be rapidly choreographed. Here, we highlight recent results that demonstrate how order in transcription regulation emerges from the apparent molecular-scale chaos and discuss remaining conceptual challenges.

Long range regulation of transcription scales with genomic distance in a gene specific manner

While critical for tuning the timing and level of transcription, enhancer communication with distal promoters is not well understood. Here we bypass the need for sequence-specific transcription factors and recruit activators directly using CARGO-VPR, an approach for targeting dCas9-VPR using a multiplexed array of RNA guides. We show that this approach achieves effective activator recruitment to arbitrary genomic sites, even those inaccessible by single dCas9. We utilize CARGO-VPR across the Prdm8-Fgf5 locus in mESCs, where neither gene is expressed. We demonstrate that while activator recruitment to any tested region results in transcriptional induction of at least one gene, the expression level strongly depends on the genomic distance between the promoter and activator recruitment site. However, the expression-distance relationship for each gene scales distinctly in a manner not attributable to differences in 3D contact frequency, promoter DNA sequence or presence of the repressive chromatin marks at the locus.

Connecting Chromatin Structures to Gene Regulation Using Dynamic Polymer Simulations

The transfer of regulatory information between distal loci on chromatin is thought to involve physical proximity, but key biophysical features of these contacts remain unclear. For instance, it is unknown how close and for how long two loci need to be in order to productively interact. The main challenge is that it is currently impossible to measure chromatin dynamics with high spatiotemporal resolution at scale. Polymer simulations provide an accessible and rigorous way to test biophysical models of chromatin regulation, yet there is a lack of simple and general methods for extracting the values of model parameters. Here we adapt the Nelder-Mead simplex optimization algorithm to select the best polymer model matching a given Hi-C dataset, using the MYC locus as an example. The model's biophysical parameters predict a compartmental rearrangement of the MYC locus in leukemia, which we validate with single-cell measurements. Leveraging trajectories predicted by the model, we find that loci with similar Hi-C contact frequencies can exhibit widely different contact dynamics. Interestingly, the frequency of productive interactions between loci exhibits a non-linear relationship with their Hi-C contact frequency when we enforce a specific capture radius and contact duration. These observations are consistent with recent experimental observations and suggest that the dynamic ensemble of chromatin configurations, rather than average contact matrices, is required to fully predict productive long-range chromatin interactions.

Enhancer selectivity in space and time: from enhancer-promoter interactions to promoter activation

The primary regulators of metazoan gene expression are enhancers, originally functionally defined as DNA sequences that can activate transcription at promoters in an orientation-independent and distance-independent manner. Despite being crucial for gene regulation in animals, what mechanisms underlie enhancer selectivity for promoters, and more fundamentally, how enhancers interact with promoters and activate transcription, remain poorly understood. In this Review, we first discuss current models of enhancer-promoter interactions in space and time and how enhancers affect transcription activation. Next, we discuss different mechanisms that mediate enhancer selectivity, including repression, biochemical compatibility and regulation of 3D genome structure. Through 3D polymer simulations, we illustrate how the ability of 3D genome folding mechanisms to mediate enhancer selectivity strongly varies for different enhancer-promoter interaction mechanisms. Finally, we discuss how recent technical advances may provide new insights into mechanisms of enhancer-promoter interactions and how technical biases in methods such as Hi-C and Micro-C and imaging techniques may affect their interpretation.

Multiscale Bayesian simulations reveal functional chromatin condensation of gene loci

Chromatin, the complex assembly of DNA and associated proteins, plays a pivotal role in orchestrating various genomic functions. To aid our understanding of the principles underlying chromatin organization, we introduce Hi-C metainference, a Bayesian approach that integrates Hi-C contact frequencies into multiscale prior models of chromatin. This approach combines both bottom-up (the physics-based prior) and top-down (the data-driven posterior) strategies to characterize the 3D organization of a target genomic locus. We first demonstrate the capability of this method to accurately reconstruct the structural ensemble and the dynamics of a system from contact information. We then apply the approach to investigate the Sox2, Pou5f1, and Nanog loci of mouse embryonic stem cells using a bottom-up chromatin model at 1 kb resolution. We observe that the studied loci are conformationally heterogeneous and organized as crumpled globules, favoring contacts between distant enhancers and promoters. Using nucleosome-resolution simulations, we then reveal how the Nanog gene is functionally organized across the multiple scales of chromatin. At the local level, we identify diverse tetranucleosome folding motifs with a characteristic distribution along the genome, predominantly open at cis-regulatory elements and compact in between. At the larger scale, we find that enhancer-promoter contacts are driven by the transient condensation of chromatin into compact domains stabilized by extensive internucleosome interactions. Overall, this work highlights the condensed, but dynamic nature of chromatin in vivo, contributing to a deeper understanding of gene structure-function relationships.

Biallelic non-productive enhancer-promoter interactions precede imprinted expression of Kcnk9 during mouse neural commitment

It is only partially understood how constitutive allelic methylation at imprinting control regions (ICRs) interacts with other regulation levels to drive timely parental allele-specific expression along large imprinted domains. The Peg13-Kcnk9 domain is an imprinted domain with important brain functions. To gain insights into its regulation during neural commitment, we performed an integrative analysis of its allele-specific epigenetic, transcriptomic, and cis-spatial organization using a mouse stem cell-based corticogenesis model that recapitulates the control of imprinted gene expression during neurodevelopment. We found that, despite an allelic higher-order chromatin structure associated with the paternally CTCF-bound Peg13 ICR, enhancer-Kcnk9 promoter contacts occurred on both alleles, although they were productive only on the maternal allele. This observation challenges the canonical model in which CTCF binding isolates the enhancer and its target gene on either side and suggests a more nuanced role for allelic CTCF binding at some ICRs.

Dissection of a CTCF topological boundary uncovers principles of enhancer-oncogene regulation

Enhancer-gene communication is dependent on topologically associating domains (TADs) and boundaries enforced by the CCCTC-binding factor (CTCF) insulator, but the underlying structures and mechanisms remain controversial. Here, we investigate a boundary that typically insulates fibroblast growth factor (FGF) oncogenes but is disrupted by DNA hypermethylation in gastrointestinal stromal tumors (GISTs). The boundary contains an array of CTCF sites that enforce adjacent TADs, one containing FGF genes and the other containing ANO1 and its putative enhancers, which are specifically active in GIST and its likely cell of origin. We show that coordinate disruption of four CTCF motifs in the boundary fuses the adjacent TADs, allows the ANO1 enhancer to contact FGF3, and causes its robust induction. High-resolution micro-C maps reveal specific contact between transcription initiation sites in the ANO1 enhancer and FGF3 promoter that quantitatively scales with FGF3 induction such that modest changes in contact frequency result in strong changes in expression, consistent with a causal relationship.

Increased enhancer-promoter interactions during developmental enhancer activation in mammals

Remote enhancers are thought to interact with their target promoters via physical proximity, yet the importance of this proximity for enhancer function remains unclear. Here we investigate the three-dimensional (3D) conformation of enhancers during mammalian development by generating high-resolution tissue-resolved contact maps for nearly a thousand enhancers with characterized in vivo activities in ten murine embryonic tissues. Sixty-one percent of developmental enhancers bypass their neighboring genes, which are often marked by promoter CpG methylation. The majority of enhancers display tissue-specific 3D conformations, and both enhancer-promoter and enhancer-enhancer interactions are moderately but consistently increased upon enhancer activation in vivo. Less than 14% of enhancer-promoter interactions form stably across tissues; however, these invariant interactions form in the absence of the enhancer and are likely mediated by adjacent CTCF binding. Our results highlight the general importance of enhancer-promoter physical proximity for developmental gene activation in mammals.

Hi-C, a chromatin 3D structure technique advancing the functional genomics of immune cells

The functional performance of immune cells relies on a complex transcriptional regulatory network. The three-dimensional structure of chromatin can affect chromatin status and gene expression patterns, and plays an important regulatory role in gene transcription. Currently available techniques for studying chromatin spatial structure include chromatin conformation capture techniques and their derivatives, chromatin accessibility sequencing techniques, and others. Additionally, the recently emerged deep learning technology can be utilized as a tool to enhance the analysis of data. In this review, we elucidate the definition and significance of the three-dimensional chromatin structure, summarize the technologies available for studying it, and describe the research progress on the chromatin spatial structure of dendritic cells, macrophages, T cells, B cells, and neutrophils.

Power-law behavior of transcriptional bursting regulated by enhancer-promoter communication

Revealing how transcriptional bursting kinetics are genomically encoded is challenging because genome structures are stochastic at the organization level and are suggestively linked to gene transcription. To address this challenge, we develop a generic theoretical framework that integrates chromatin dynamics, enhancer-promoter (E-P) communication, and gene-state switching to study transcriptional bursting. The theory predicts that power law can be a general rule to quantitatively describe bursting modulations by E-P spatial communication. Specifically, burst frequency and burst size are up-regulated by E-P communication strength, following power laws with positive exponents. Analysis of the scaling exponents further reveals that burst frequency is preferentially regulated. Bursting kinetics are down-regulated by E-P genomic distance with negative power-law exponents, and this negative modulation desensitizes at large distances. The mutual information between burst frequency (or burst size) and E-P spatial distance further reveals essential characteristics of the information transfer from E-P communication to transcriptional bursting kinetics. These findings, which are in agreement with experimental observations, not only reveal fundamental principles of E-P communication in transcriptional bursting but also are essential for understanding cellular decision-making.

Single-molecule chromatin configurations link transcription factor binding to expression in human cells

The binding of multiple transcription factors (TFs) to genomic enhancers activates gene expression in mammalian cells. However, the molecular details that link enhancer sequence to TF binding, promoter state, and gene expression levels remain opaque. We applied single-molecule footprinting (SMF) to measure the simultaneous occupancy of TFs, nucleosomes, and components of the transcription machinery on engineered enhancer/promoter constructs with variable numbers of TF binding sites for both a synthetic and an endogenous TF. We find that activation domains enhance a TF's capacity to compete with nucleosomes for binding to DNA in a BAF-dependent manner, TF binding on nucleosome-free DNA is consistent with independent binding between TFs, and average TF occupancy linearly contributes to promoter activation rates. We also decompose TF strength into separable binding and activation terms, which can be tuned and perturbed independently. Finally, we develop thermodynamic and kinetic models that quantitatively predict both the binding microstates observed at the enhancer and subsequent time-dependent gene expression. This work provides a template for quantitative dissection of distinct contributors to gene activation, including the activity of chromatin remodelers, TF activation domains, chromatin acetylation, TF concentration, TF binding affinity, and TF binding site configuration.

Boundary stacking interactions enable cross-TAD enhancer-promoter communication during limb development

Although promoters and their enhancers are frequently contained within a topologically associating domain (TAD), some developmentally important genes have their promoter and enhancers within different TADs. Hypotheses about molecular mechanisms enabling cross-TAD interactions remain to be assessed. To test these hypotheses, we used optical reconstruction of chromatin architecture to characterize the conformations of the Pitx1 locus on single chromosomes in developing mouse limbs. Our data support a model in which neighboring boundaries are stacked as a result of loop extrusion, bringing boundary-proximal cis-elements into contact. This stacking interaction also contributes to the appearance of architectural stripes in the population average maps. Through molecular dynamics simulations, we found that increasing boundary strengths facilitates the formation of the stacked boundary conformation, counter-intuitively facilitating border bypass. This work provides a revised view of the TAD borders' function, both facilitating and preventing cis-regulatory interactions, and introduces a framework to distinguish border-crossing from border-respecting enhancer-promoter pairs.

Leveraging Tissue-Specific Enhancer-Target Gene Regulatory Networks Identifies Enhancer Somatic Mutations That Functionally Impact Lung Cancer

Enhancers are noncoding regulatory DNA regions that modulate the transcription of target genes, often over large distances along with the genomic sequence. Enhancer alterations have been associated with various pathological conditions, including cancer. However, the identification and characterization of somatic mutations in noncoding regulatory regions with a functional effect on tumorigenesis and prognosis remain a major challenge. Here, we present a strategy for detecting and characterizing enhancer mutations in a genome-wide analysis of patient cohorts, across three lung cancer subtypes. Lung tissue-specific enhancers were defined by integrating experimental data and public epigenomic profiles, and the genome-wide enhancer-target gene regulatory network of lung cells was constructed by integrating chromatin three-dimensional architecture data. Lung cancers possessed a similar mutation burden at tissue-specific enhancers and exons but with differences in their mutation signatures. Functionally relevant alterations were prioritized on the basis of the pathway-level integration of the effect of a mutation and the frequency of mutations on individual enhancers. The genes enriched for mutated enhancers converged on the regulation of key biological processes and pathways relevant to tumor biology. Recurrent mutations in individual enhancers also affected the expression of target genes, with potential relevance for patient prognosis. Together, these findings show that noncoding regulatory mutations have a potential relevance for cancer pathogenesis and can be exploited for patient classification.

SIGNIFICANCE

Mapping enhancer-target gene regulatory interactions and analyzing enhancer mutations at the level of their target genes and pathways reveal convergence of recurrent enhancer mutations on biological processes involved in tumorigenesis and prognosis.

4D nucleome equation predicts gene expression controlled by long-range enhancer-promoter interaction

Recent experimental evidence strongly supports that three-dimensional (3D) long-range enhancer-promoter (E-P) interactions have important influences on gene-expression dynamics, but it is unclear how the interaction information is translated into gene expression over time (4D). To address this question, we developed a general theoretical framework (named as a 4D nucleome equation), which integrates E-P interactions on chromatin and biochemical reactions of gene transcription. With this equation, we first present the distribution of mRNA counts as a function of the E-P genomic distance and then reveal a power-law scaling of the expression level in this distance. Interestingly, we find that long-range E-P interactions can induce bimodal and trimodal mRNA distributions. The 4D nucleome equation also allows for model selection and parameter inference. When this equation is applied to the mouse embryonic stem cell smRNA-FISH data and the E-P genomic-distance data, the predicted E-P contact probability and mRNA distribution are in good agreement with experimental results. Further statistical inference indicates that the E-P interactions prefer to modulate the mRNA level by controlling promoter activation and transcription initiation rates. Our model and results provide quantitative insights into both spatiotemporal gene-expression determinants (i.e., long-range E-P interactions) and cellular fates during development.

Emerging insights into enhancer biology and function

Cell type-specific gene expression is coordinated by DNA-encoded enhancers and the transcription factors (TFs) that bind to them in a sequence-specific manner. As such, these enhancers and TFs are critical mediators of normal development and altered enhancer or TF function is associated with the development of diseases such as cancer. While initially defined by their ability to activate gene transcription in reporter assays, putative enhancer elements are now frequently defined by their unique chromatin features including DNase hypersensitivity and transposase accessibility, bidirectional enhancer RNA (eRNA) transcription, CpG hypomethylation, high H3K27ac and H3K4me1, sequence-specific transcription factor binding, and co-factor recruitment. Identification of these chromatin features through sequencing-based assays has revolutionized our ability to identify enhancer elements on a genome-wide scale, and genome-wide functional assays are now capitalizing on this information to greatly expand our understanding of how enhancers function to provide spatiotemporal coordination of gene expression programs. Here, we highlight recent technological advances that are providing new insights into the molecular mechanisms by which these critical cis-regulatory elements function in gene control. We pay particular attention to advances in our understanding of enhancer transcription, enhancer-promoter syntax, 3D organization and biomolecular condensates, transcription factor and co-factor dependencies, and the development of genome-wide functional enhancer screens.

High-resolution CTCF footprinting reveals impact of chromatin state on cohesin extrusion dynamics

DNA looping is vital for establishing many enhancer-promoter interactions. While CTCF is known to anchor many cohesin-mediated loops, the looped chromatin fiber appears to predominantly exist in a poorly characterized actively extruding state. To better characterize extruding chromatin loop structures, we used CTCF MNase HiChIP data to determine both CTCF binding at high resolution and 3D contact information. Here we present FactorFinder, a tool that identifies CTCF binding sites at near base-pair resolution. We leverage this substantial advance in resolution to determine that the fully extruded (CTCF-CTCF) state is rare genome-wide with locus-specific variation from ~1-10%. We further investigate the impact of chromatin state on loop extrusion dynamics, and find that active enhancers and RNA Pol II impede cohesin extrusion, facilitating an enrichment of enhancer-promoter contacts in the partially extruded loop state. We propose a model of topological regulation whereby the transient, partially extruded states play active roles in transcription.

What is an enhancer?

Tight control of the transcription process is essential for the correct spatial and temporal gene expression pattern during development and in homeostasis. Enhancers are at the core of correct transcriptional activation. The original definition of an enhancer is straightforward: a DNA sequence that activates transcription independent of orientation and direction. Dissection of numerous enhancer loci has shown that many enhancer-like elements might not conform to the original definition, suggesting that enhancers and enhancer-like elements might use multiple different mechanisms to contribute to transcriptional activation. Here, we review methodologies to identify enhancers and enhancer-like elements and discuss pitfalls and consequences for our understanding of transcriptional regulation.

SCENIC+: single-cell multiomic inference of enhancers and gene regulatory networks

Joint profiling of chromatin accessibility and gene expression in individual cells provides an opportunity to decipher enhancer-driven gene regulatory networks (GRNs). Here we present a method for the inference of enhancer-driven GRNs, called SCENIC+. SCENIC+ predicts genomic enhancers along with candidate upstream transcription factors (TFs) and links these enhancers to candidate target genes. To improve both recall and precision of TF identification, we curated and clustered a motif collection with more than 30,000 motifs. We benchmarked SCENIC+ on diverse datasets from different species, including human peripheral blood mononuclear cells, ENCODE cell lines, melanoma cell states and Drosophila retinal development. Next, we exploit SCENIC+ predictions to study conserved TFs, enhancers and GRNs between human and mouse cell types in the cerebral cortex. Finally, we use SCENIC+ to study the dynamics of gene regulation along differentiation trajectories and the effect of TF perturbations on cell state. SCENIC+ is available at scenicplus.readthedocs.io .

LAST-seq: single-cell RNA sequencing by direct amplification of single-stranded RNA without prior reverse transcription and second-strand synthesis

Existing single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) methods rely on reverse transcription (RT) and second-strand synthesis (SSS) to convert single-stranded RNA into double-stranded DNA prior to amplification, with the limited RT/SSS efficiency compromising RNA detectability. Here, we develop a new scRNA-seq method, Linearly Amplified Single-stranded-RNA-derived Transcriptome sequencing (LAST-seq), which directly amplifies the original single-stranded RNA molecules without prior RT/SSS. LAST-seq offers a high single-molecule capture efficiency and a low level of technical noise for single-cell transcriptome analyses. Using LAST-seq, we characterize transcriptional bursting kinetics in human cells, revealing a role of topologically associating domains in transcription regulation.

Fundamental insights into the correlation between chromosome configuration and transcription

Eukaryotic chromosomes exhibit a hierarchical organization that spans a spectrum of length scales, ranging from sub-regions known as loops, which typically comprise hundreds of base pairs, to much larger chromosome territories that can encompass a few mega base pairs. Chromosome conformation capture experiments that involve high-throughput sequencing methods combined with microscopy techniques have enabled a new understanding of inter- and intra-chromosomal interactions with unprecedented details. This information also provides mechanistic insights on the relationship between genome architecture and gene expression. In this article, we review the recent findings on three-dimensional interactions among chromosomes at the compartment, topologically associating domain, and loop levels and the impact of these interactions on the transcription process. We also discuss current understanding of various biophysical processes involved in multi-layer structural organization of chromosomes. Then, we discuss the relationships between gene expression and genome structure from perturbative genome-wide association studies. Furthermore, for a better understanding of how chromosome architecture and function are linked, we emphasize the role of epigenetic modifications in the regulation of gene expression. Such an understanding of the relationship between genome architecture and gene expression can provide a new perspective on the range of potential future discoveries and therapeutic research.

Organization of transcription and 3D genome as revealed by live-cell imaging

Higher-order genomic structures play a critical role in regulating gene expression by influencing the spatial proximity of promoters and enhancers. Live-cell imaging studies have demonstrated that three-dimensional genome structures undergo dynamic changes over time. Transcription is also dynamic, with genes frequently switching between active and inactive states. Recent observations suggest that the formation of condensates, composed of transcription-related factors, RNA, and RNA-binding proteins, around genes can regulate transcription. Advancements in technology have facilitated the visualization of the intricate spatiotemporal relationship between higher-order genomic structures, condensate formation, and transcriptional activity in living cells.

Dynamic network-guided CRISPRi screen identifies CTCF-loop-constrained nonlinear enhancer gene regulatory activity during cell state transitions

Comprehensive enhancer discovery is challenging because most enhancers, especially those contributing to complex diseases, have weak effects on gene expression. Our gene regulatory network modeling identified that nonlinear enhancer gene regulation during cell state transitions can be leveraged to improve the sensitivity of enhancer discovery. Using human embryonic stem cell definitive endoderm differentiation as a dynamic transition system, we conducted a mid-transition CRISPRi-based enhancer screen. We discovered a comprehensive set of enhancers for each of the core endoderm-specifying transcription factors. Many enhancers had strong effects mid-transition but weak effects post-transition, consistent with the nonlinear temporal responses to enhancer perturbation predicted by the modeling. Integrating three-dimensional genomic information, we were able to develop a CTCF-loop-constrained Interaction Activity model that can better predict functional enhancers compared to models that rely on Hi-C-based enhancer-promoter contact frequency. Our study provides generalizable strategies for sensitive and systematic enhancer discovery in both normal and pathological cell state transitions.

Ultra-long-range interactions between active regulatory elements

Contacts between enhancers and promoters are thought to relate to their ability to activate transcription. Investigating factors that contribute to such chromatin interactions is therefore important for understanding gene regulation. Here, we have determined contact frequencies between millions of pairs of cis-regulatory elements from chromosome conformation capture data sets and analyzed a collection of hundreds of DNA-binding factors for binding at regions of enriched contacts. This analysis revealed enriched contacts at sites bound by many factors associated with active transcription. We show that active regulatory elements, independent of cohesin and polycomb, interact with each other across distances of tens of megabases in vertebrate and invertebrate genomes and that interactions correlate and change with activity. However, these ultra-long-range interactions are not dependent on RNA polymerase II transcription or individual transcription cofactors. Using simulations, we show that a model of chromatin and multivalent binding factors can give rise to long-range interactions via bridging-induced clustering. We propose that long-range interactions between cis-regulatory elements are driven by at least three distinct processes: cohesin-mediated loop extrusion, polycomb contacts, and clustering of active regions.

Cell-type-specific prediction of 3D chromatin organization enables high-throughput in silico genetic screening

Investigating how chromatin organization determines cell-type-specific gene expression remains challenging. Experimental methods for measuring three-dimensional chromatin organization, such as Hi-C, are costly and have technical limitations, restricting their broad application particularly in high-throughput genetic perturbations. We present C.Origami, a multimodal deep neural network that performs de novo prediction of cell-type-specific chromatin organization using DNA sequence and two cell-type-specific genomic features-CTCF binding and chromatin accessibility. C.Origami enables in silico experiments to examine the impact of genetic changes on chromatin interactions. We further developed an in silico genetic screening approach to assess how individual DNA elements may contribute to chromatin organization and to identify putative cell-type-specific trans-acting regulators that collectively determine chromatin architecture. Applying this approach to leukemia cells and normal T cells, we demonstrate that cell-type-specific in silico genetic screening, enabled by C.Origami, can be used to systematically discover novel chromatin regulation circuits in both normal and disease-related biological systems.